Fluorescence in-situ hybridization (FISH) is often required in combination with histopathology and molecular diagnostics for selection of therapy in personalized medicine. A novel non-cross-linking, formalin-free tissue fixative that allows high quality morphologic, molecular and FISH analyses from the same specimen by addition of a post-fixation step before FISH is presented.
Morphologic assessment of formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissue samples has been the gold standard for cancer diagnostics for decades due to its excellent preservation of morphology. Personalized medicine increasingly provides individually adapted and targeted therapies for characterized individual diseases enabled by combined morphological and molecular analytical technologies and diagnostics. Performance of morphologic and molecular assays from the same FFPE specimen is challenging because of the negative impact of formalin due to chemical modification and cross-linking of nucleic acids and proteins. A non-cross-linking, formalin-free tissue fixative has been recently developed to fulfil both requirements, i.e., to preserve morphology like FFPE and biomolecules like cryo-preservation. Since FISH is often required in combination with histopathology and molecular diagnostics, we tested the applicability of FISH protocols on tissues treated with this new fixative. We found that formalin post-fixation of histological sections of non-cross-linking, formalin-free and paraffin-embedded (NCFPE) breast cancer tissue generated equivalent results to those with FFPE tissue in human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2) FISH analysis. This protocol describes how a FISH assay originally developed and validated for FFPE tissue can be used for NCFPE tissues by a simple post-fixation step of histological sections.
Personalized medicine increasingly relies on multi-parameter tests involving morphological and molecular tissue analyses. Formalin fixation of tissues as the gold standard provides excellent morphologic quality1,2. However, formalin-induced chemical modification and cross-linking of proteins and nucleic acids3,4,5 negatively interferes with molecular analysis6. These molecular modifications limit the quality of nucleic acids and proteins and may result in gene sequence artefacts7 or reduced sensitivity of polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based assays8. Although major efforts were taken to optimize molecular tests for FFPE tissue, cryo-preservation of tissues is in general superior to formalin fixation, making it necessary to split tissue samples for different preservation procedures. To avoid the need for cryo-preservation for molecular analyses, a non-cross-linking, formalin-free fixative, PAXgene Tissue was developed. This commercially available system consists of a fixation and a stabilization solution containing different alcohols, acetic acid and a soluble organic compound. Proper preservation of nucleic acids, (phospo)proteins and morphology was shown in several studies6,9,10,11,12,13.
One particular application in cancer diagnostics is FISH detecting a comprehensive range of chromosomal alterations, such as translocations, submicroscopic deletions and amplifications 14. For example, twenty percent of invasive breast cancer tumors show amplification of the human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2) gene15,16,17, which is associated with poor prognosis18,19. Determination of the HER2 overexpression and amplification status in breast cancer by FISH is needed to select patients for anti-HER2-directed therapy and is a companion diagnostic listed by the Federal Drug Association (FDA) (http://www.fda.gov/MedicalDevices/ProductsandMedicalProcedures/InVitroDiagnostics/ucm301431.htm)17. In order to allow a broad application of FISH-based companion diagnostics in health care, assays were developed and approved for FFPE tissues.
In a previous study, we showed that NCFPE tissues cannot be used for FISH assays which have been approved for FFPE tissue. However, tests of time series of different post fixation procedures of NCFPE tissues with 4 % buffered formaldehyde showed that post fixation times of 18 h or longer of NCFPE tissue sections achieved equivalent results to those with FFPE tissues14.
In this study, we provide a detailed protocol and demonstrate the impact of non-cross-linking, formalin-free tissue fixation and 24 h 4 % buffered formaldehyde post-fixation on sections used for HER2 FISH and RNA quality from the same primary tissue specimen.
Figure 1: Diagram showing the steps for fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) and RNA analysis of formalin fixed paraffin embedded (FFPE) and non-cross-linking, formalin-free fixed paraffin embedded (NCFPE) tissues. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of the Medical University of Graz (reference number 20-066), Austria. Tissue samples were obtained from two cases of surgically resected primary invasive breast cancers after the patients had given written informed consent.
1. Tissue fixation
NOTE: Tissue fixation is performed either with standard buffered formalin solution (SBFS), defined as 10 % formalin solution containing a mass fraction of 3.7 % (corresponding to a volume fraction of 4 %) formaldehyde buffered to pH 6.8 to pH 7.2 according to CEN/TS 16827-1:2015 or the non-cross-linking, formalin-free tissue fixation system (also referred to as the alternate fixation solution below) consisting of a fixative and a stabilizer solution at room temperature (RT).
2. Tissue processing and embedding
3. Tissue sectioning and slide preparation for FISH
NOTE: FFPE sections are directly used for FISH, while slides with NCFPE sections are post-fixed in SBFS for 24 h before FISH procedure.
4. Post-fixation of NCFPE specimens
5. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH)
NOTE: Here FISH is performed using the commercially available HER2/CEN17 dual color probe Kit according to the manufacturer's instructions. Do not allow the tissue sections to dry during the hybridization and washing steps. Do not allow the DNA probe and 4', 6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI) DNA counterstain solutions to be exposed to light for a longer period. Perform these steps in the dark using lightproof containers. Depending on the age and the fixation step of the sample material, increase or decrease the denaturing and wash temperatures to obtain better hybridization results.
6. Confocal imaging and scanning of FISH slides
7. Interpretation
NOTE: The HER2/CEN17 probe is a mixture of a red fluorochrome-labelled CEN17 probe specific for the alpha satellite centromeric region of chromosome 17 (D17Z1) and a green fluorochrome-labelled HER2 probe specific for the HER2 gene (probe location 17q12). Tumor specimens with a HER2:CEN17 ratio ≤2.0 per nucleus are scored as normal, whereas those with a HER2:CEN17 ratio ≥2.0 are scored as amplified17.
8. RNA Quality
FISH HER2 determination:
The HER2-FISH signal intensities from FFPE and NCFPE are similar (Figure 2). Both cases in most cells show a clear excess of the green signal (indicative of the amplified HER2 gene locus) as compared to the red signal (CEN17 reference gene). Therefore, the case shows an amplified HER2 gene, which means that this patient is expected to respond to trastuzumab, an anti-HER2 targeted therapy. The FFPE specimen served as positive control. The signals observed in non-neoplastic cells (both in FFPE and NCFPE) serve as internal reference and negative control for HER2 gene amplification. For every analysis series, at least one section with known gene amplification status should be used as positive control for the hybridization reaction.
RNA Quality:
Corresponding FFPE and NCFPE samples from two different cases show differences in RNA quality by employing real-time reverse transcription PCR. Results obtained show different amplification efficiencies for different amplicon lengths (i.e., 71 bp, 153 bp, 200 bp, 275 bp, 323 bp) of the GAPDH mRNA. All Ct (cycle threshold) values obtained from FFPE samples were higher than those from NCFPE. This difference demonstrates the lower PCR amplificability of mRNA isolated from FFPE tissues, suggesting a more pronounced chemical modification. Furthermore, the higher Ct values for long compared to short amplicons are an indicator for mRNA fragmentation. In comparison, the Ct value slopes of the different amplicon lengths shows more pronounced mRNA fragmentation in FFPE than NCFPE tissues (Figure 3).
Figure 2: Representative results of HER2 FISH for corresponding formalin fixed paraffin embedded (FFPE) and non-cross-linking, formalin-free fixed paraffin embedded (NCFPE) tissue sections. Corresponding samples from the same FFPE (A)and NCFPE (B) tissues are shown. In contrast to normal interphase cells (C), where two green (HER2) and two red (CEN17) signals are expected, cells with amplified HER2 gene locus represent multiple copies of green signals (HER2) (D). HER2 amplification status was identical in both FFPE and the post-fixed NCFPE sections (A, B). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Results of a real-time reverse transcription PCR assay used for RNA quality control. Y-Axis: Ct (cycle threshold) values of the GAPDH gene are shown for different amplicon lengths (71 bp, 153 bp, 200 bp, 275 bp, 323 bp) on the X-axis. mRNA was isolated from FFPE and NCFPE of two different breast cancer tissue samples processed in parallel and transcribed to cDNA for PCR. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
The results demonstrate two key findings. First, a simple 24 h SBFS post-fixation step of sections cut from NCFPE tissues is sufficient to obtain equivalent results to those with FFPE in FISH analyses using FISH assays approved for FFPE tissues (see also reference14). This protocol has the advantage of using FISH assays originally developed and approved for FFPE without the need for comprehensive revalidation (e.g., by optimizing the pre-hybridization conditions for non-cross-linked tissue). The FISH protocol can be used exactly as described in the manufacturer's instructions.
Minor modifications from the manufacturer´s instructions described in this protocol (e.g. tissue section diameter and incubation periods at the deparaffinization steps) result from previous adaptations, which is explicitly recommended by the manufacturer due to the use of different tissue types and fixation methods.
The post-fixation step is critical because it requires a chemical reaction time of 18-24 h, which extends the analysis time by one day but allows the same daily workflow as developed for FFPE tissues (Figure 1). SBFS is reported to penetrate tissue at an average rate of 1 mm per hour22 to 5 mm in 2 h depending on the tissue type23,24. The observation that only prolonged post-fixation periods of more than 18 h could change the properties of NCFPE to FFPE sections, indicates that not the penetration of the fixative but the chemical reaction time is critical for achieving the desired results1,14.
Second, the remaining NCFPE tissue that is not used for post-fixation can be used for further molecular analyses as the biomolecules are well preserved. This was demonstrated by real-time reverse transcription PCR (Figure 3). The assay is more sensitive and specific than the electropherogram-derived RIN value (RNA integrity number) with regard to RNA quality (i.e., chemical modification and fragmentation) for mRNA isolated from paraffin-embedded tissues8. Quality control was restricted in this study to real-time PCR since independent groups have shown that in addition to RNA, the quality of DNA and proteins isolated from NCFPE is better than that from FFPE tissues 8,9,13.
The protocol presented follows, where applicable (e.g., SBFS recipe, fixation conditions, RNA quality control, validation), the requirements of the CEN technical specifications for pre-analytical procedures for in-vitro diagnostics (IVD), which have been recently released by the European Committee of Standardization (CEN) (e.g. CEN/TS 16827-1:2015 for RNA-Isolation from FFPE tissues which refers to the ISO 15189 standard).
The method is limited to this specific fixative. Although the good preservation of biomolecules and morphology using the non-cross-linking, formalin-free fixative has been presented in several studies, it is mainly used in research but not in routine medical applications. One reason is that replacing the gold standard SBFS fixation by another fixative would require a variety of validation studies as not all protocols optimized for FFPE material can be used for materials fixed with non-cross-linking fixatives. Other tissue fixation methods were not tested for this FISH protocol.
The simple post-fixation step described in this manuscript has the advantage of using IVD approved assays both for FFPE and NCFPE tissues.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
We thank the team of the laboratory for molecular pathology at the Institute of Pathology of the Medical University Graz for their expertise and support. Furthermore, we thank Iris Kufferath and Daniela Pabst for technical assistance, Bernadette Rieger and Sylvia Eidenhammer for processing the HER2 cases as well as Kinga Szurian (pathologist) and Tamas Regényi (3DHISTEC). We thank Penelope Kungl for proofreading the manuscript. This work has been financially supported by the Christian Doppler Research Fund, the Austrian Federal Ministry of Science, Research and Economy and the National Foundation for Research, Technology and Development.
SAV LP GmbH, Flintsbach a. I., Germany | www.sav-lp.de | FN-200L-4-1 | Tissue fixative |
Simport Plastic Ltd., Beloeil, Canada | www.simport.com | M-498 | Safekeeping device providing labelling, fixation and paraffin embedding for tissue samples. |
Qiagen GmbH, Hilden Germany | www.qiagen.com | 765112 | For collection, fixation, and stabilization of tissue samples: 10 Prefilled Reagent Containers, containing PAXgene Tissue FIX and PAXgene Tissue STABILIZER. |
ThermoFisher Scientific | www.thermofisher.com | 813150 | Processing of biological specimens from chemical fixation to paraffin infiltration |
Merck Millipore, Munich, Germany | www.analytics-shop.com/de/hersteller/millipore.html | MC1009834000 | Dehydration of tissue samples |
VWR Chemicals, Darmstadt, Germany | https://at.vwr.com | 10293EP | Dehydration of tissue samples |
ACM Herba Chemosan Apotheker AG, Vienna, Austria | www.herba-chemosan.at | 2549662 32 | Paraffin used in a tissue processing device |
Leica Mikrosysteme Handels GmbH, Vienna, Austria | www.LeicaBiosystems.com | 39602004 | Paraffin embedding medium |
Sanova Diagnostik, Vienna, Austria | www.sanova.at | 5229 | Paraffin embedding instrument for tissues for histology |
Histocom Medizintechnik Vertriebs GmbH, Wiener Neudorf, Austria | www.histocom.info | M 910010 | This device is used for especially sophisticated paraffin sectioning techniques in biology and medicine. Only skilled or specially trained personnel must operate the microtome, i.e. clamping the specimen, trimming, sectioning and taking off the sections from the instrument. |
Dako Denmark A/S, Glostrup, Denmark | www.chem.agilent.com | K802021-2 | Coated glass slides, intended for mounting formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue sections. |
Qiagen GmbH, Hilden Germany | www.qiagen.com | 73504 | For purification of total RNA from formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue sections |
Qiagen GmbH, Hilden Germany | www.qiagen.com | 765134 | For purification of total RNA from PAXgene-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue sections |
ZytoVision GmbH, Bremerhaven, Germany | www.zytovision.com | Z-2015-200 | For the detection of ERBB2 (a.k.a HER2) gene amplification frequently observed in solid malignant neoplasms e.g. breast cancer samples. |
3DHISTEC, Budapest, Hungary | www.3dhistech.com | Digital device for scanning tissue slides equipped with a 40x/1.2 NA objective, Quad band filters (DAPI/FITC/TRITC/Cy5) filters and a 5.5Mpx, 16 bit, cooled scientific CMOS (Complementary Metal Oxide Semiconductor) camera. | |
ThermoFisher Scientific | www.thermofisher.com | 4368814 | The High Capacity cDNA Reverse Transcription Kit contains all components necessary for the quantitative conversion of up to 2 µg of total RNA to single-stranded cDNA in a single 20 µL reaction. |
ThermoFisher Scientific | www.thermofisher.com | 4367659 | PCR Master Mix containing polymerase, nucleotides and SYBR Green for PCR and quanitification of amplicons. |
ThermoFisher Scientific, Wilmington, DE | www.thermofisher.com | Ser. Nr. F239 | Spectrophotometer for nucleic acid quantification. |
QuantStudio 7 Flex Real-time PCR System | www.thermofisher.com | 4485701 | PCR machine, |
Vysis/Abbott Laboratories. Abbott Park, Illinois, U.S.A | www.molecular.abbott/us/en/products/instrumentation/thermobrite#order | e.g. (ThermoBrite) 07J91-020 | Temperature controlled slide processing system for in-situ denaturation/hybridization procedures. |