In this article, we present a protocol to detect microtubule-loaded oligodendrocytes in a model of tubulinopathy through a simple, innovative second harmonic generation microscopy approach.
The satisfactory visualization of cytoskeletal components in the brain is challenging. The ubiquitous distribution of the networks of microtubules, microfilaments, and intermediate filaments in all the neural tissues, together with the variability in the outcomes of fluorescent protein fusion strategies and their limited applicability to dynamic studies of antibodies and drugs as chromophore vehicles, make classical optical approaches not as effective as for other proteins. When tubulin needs to be studied, the label-free generation of second harmonics is a very suitable option due to the non-centrosymmetric organization of the molecule. This technique, when conjugated to microscopy, can qualitatively describe the volumetric distribution of parallel bundles of microtubules in biological samples, with the additional advantage of working with fresh tissues that are unfixed and unpermeabilized. This work describes how to image tubulin with a commercial second harmonic generation microscopy setup to highlight microtubules in the tubulin-enriched structures of the oligodendrocytes, as in hypomyelination with atrophy of the basal ganglia and cerebellum (H-ABC) tubulinopathy, a recently described myelin disorder.
The optical imaging of cytoskeletal structures in tissues and organ preparations is not an easy task. Cytoskeletal filaments are ubiquitous, so if generic staining is performed, for example, against alpha-tubulin or beta-actin or potentially keratin in an epithelial sample, the signal will likely be distributed rather homogeneously all over the sample. To restrict the staining to a more meaningful subset of cellular components, one can either use transgenic mice with targeted expression1 or plan to use isoform-specific antibodies. While very few of the latter are on the market (and very few exist at all2,3,4), a transgenic animal model might be available. However, it needs to be acquired by the lab and properly housed, with all the expenses involved in the process. Certain antibodies or chemicals, for example, fluorophore-conjugated drugs like phalloidin or paclitaxel, may be partially or fully incompatible with use in living cells or tissues, thus limiting their applicability to only studies of fixed samples.
In the case of tubulin, an additional aspect has to be taken into consideration, which is the sensitivity of the polymer to fixation. Conventional chemical fixation with formaldehyde is known for not being adequate for optimally preserving the integrity of microtubules5. Additionally, a recent report confirms that formaldehyde crosslinking induces subtle changes in the ultrastructure of the microtubule, similar to what happens with the binding of some drugs or physiological molecules such as GTP6.
The direct visualization of microtubules in unstained, unfixed samples is, therefore, often desirable. To achieve this, one technical solution is second harmonic generation (SHG) microscopy7, which is based on the ability of bundles of parallel microtubules to act as harmonophores and to emit frequency-doubled light when properly illuminated with an intense, pulsed infrared laser. Although a stronger and more stable second harmonic signal can be generated from collagen and myosin, which are the only other two biological materials known to be capable of frequency-doubling, the signal from tubulin has been used so far mostly to study mitotic spindle rearrangements8,9,10 and axonal microtubule morphology11,12,13.
In this work, we introduce a novel use of SHG microscopy as a diagnostic tool to distinguish central nervous system (CNS) tissues affected by tubulin beta 4 A (TUBB4A) tubulinopathy from their healthy counterparts14. Some of the mutations occurring in this predominantly neural isoform of tubulin, like those causing hypomyelination and atrophy of the basal ganglia and cerebellum (H-ABC), induce microtubule overfilling in the oligodendrocytes15,16; the cytoskeletal alterations, in turn, are associated with downstream effects like dysmyelination, with profound impairment of the motor and sensory pathways16,17,18,19. The taiep murine model used in this work displays abnormal microtubule content in the oligodendrocytes and recapitulates most of the sensory-motor symptoms of H-ABC patients17. The protocol explains how to image structures as the corpus callosum and the cerebellum, which are usually highly myelinated and which are severely affected in human patients as well as in the taiep rat19, to highlight the differences in SH signals between healthy and mutant tissues.
All procedures described were done in compliance with the laws and codes approved in the seventh title of the Regulation of the General Health Law Regarding Health Research of the Mexican Government (NOM-062-ZOO-1999) and in accordance with the recommendations of the National Institutes of Health Guide for the Care and Use of Experimental Animals and were approved by the institutional committee of bioethics in research of the Universidad de Guanajuato and Benemérita Universidad Autónoma de Puebla.
1. Microscope settings
2. Microscope preliminary controls
NOTE: Perform the preliminary microscope controls once, unless the setup is modified.
3. Tissue extraction
NOTE: Always use clean tools to perform the surgical procedures.
4. Vibratome sectioning
5. Transfer to the microscope
6. Imaging
7. Processing of the cerebellum
The images obtained with this methodology have an intrinsic low background level due to the very limited number of harmonophores present in biological tissues, which is one of the significant advantages of the method.
When the fibers of the corpus callosum are imaged, fiber-like short structures and rounded elements can be consistently found in the taiep brain (Figure 3B), while the corpus callosum of the control brain shows a much more heterogeneous and isotropic signal throughout the brain region (Figure 3A). The origin of the differential signal lies specifically in the second harmonic generation phenomenon, since adding the narrow bandpass filter only decreases the non-specific signal intensity from the control images (Figure 3C–D) while selectively removing this low, diffuse signal from around the soma-like and the short, elongated structures in the taiep images, which always generate intense SH light (Figure 3E–F).
The other structure analyzed, the cerebellar white matter, gives comparable results. Specifically, while in control tissue there is an almost complete absence of SH signal (Figure 4B), and the Purkinje cells are barely visible when using the short-pass filter, the elongated and rounded structures persist in the SH image from the taiep tissue (Figure 4D).
Figure 1: Microscope and sectioning. (A) Schematic of the microscope used, with relevant components highlighted. Arrows: 1 = NDD port where the SP485 is located close to the detector; 2 = removable frames where the BP405 is placed; 3 = position under the objective where the half-wave plate (HWP) is placed for control experiments. The inset shows the frame where the HWP could be inserted. (B) Top view of the vibratome buffer tray with the glued brain ready to be fine-sectioned. (C) The original (top) and modified (bottom) Pasteur pipette used to transfer the sections. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Preliminary controls. (A) The SHG signal emitted by corn starch grains shows a predominant orientation that coincides with the oscillation direction of the laser (horizontal in this case). (B) After inserting a half-wave plate with its fast axis oriented at 45° with respect to the horizontal, the signal is rotated by 90°. (C) Merging of the signal before and after the half-wave plate insertion. (D) The signal below 485 nm emitted from the corn starch grains. (E) The SHG signal from the starch grains detected at 405/10 nm. (F) Graph showing a comparison of the two signals corresponding to the line-scans shown in the zoomed inserts of D and E. The SHG filter used causes negligible signal loss. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: SHG images from taiep and WT corpus callosum. Representative examples of (A) WT and (B) taiep signals obtained from the corpus callosum. (C) SP485 filtered image from an WT corpus callosum. (D) BP405 filtered image from the same sample as in C. (E) SP485 filtered image from a taiep corpus callosum. (F) BP405 filtered image of the same sample as in E. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: SHG images from taiep and WT cerebellums. Representative examples of (A–B) WT and (C–D) taiep signals obtained from cerebellar folia. (A) An SP485 filtered image from a WT folium; only some Purkinje cells are visible. (B) A BP405 filtered image from the same sample as in A. (C) An SP485 filtered image from a taiep folium. (D) A BP405 filtered image of the same sample as in C. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Supplementary Figure 1: Examples of artifacts. (A) Artifact due to drying of the sample. (B) Artifact due to excessive exposure. Scale bars: 30 µm. Please click here to download this File.
Supplementary File 1: Köhler alignment.The file presents the steps for performing the Köhler alignment. Please click here to download this File.
Supplementary File 2: ZEN software steps for SHG image acquisition. Please click here to download this File.
SHG microscopy is part of a group of non-linear optics techniques, which include two-photon excitation microscopy, third harmonic generation microscopy, and coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering microscopy, that have contributed to expanding the range of applications of conventional optical microscopy to the life sciences20.
Specifically, the major strength and weakness of SHG microscopy relate to the same condition: the signal generator is non-centrosymmetric21. Such a specific architectural condition is often found in the realm of inorganic and organic crystals but is rare among biological objects. Together with collagen and muscular myosin, microtubules are able to generate a second harmonic signal22, which can be detected with a microscope if enough summation occurs in the bundles of parallel polymers. Inside the cells, tubulin associates to form parallel bundles in the cores of axons (a cell type-specific location), in mitotic spindles (a temporal-specific distribution), and, as presented in this work, in the trademark microtubule association of a recently described tubulinopathy-hypomyelination with atrophy of the basal ganglia and cerebellum, or H-ABC (which represents the first reported pathological distribution of this kind)14,16,23.
This sensory-motor syndrome is still an orphan disease, as many neurologists are not yet familiar with all the symptoms and/or cannot afford the genetic screening of suspected patients to confirm the diagnosis, which very likely causes underdiagnosis, at least in some populations. On top of that, not much is known about the pathology at the molecular and cellular level, so the techniques that could help shed light on the specific mechanisms of this degenerative process are very valuable, also at a basic level.
Therefore, two uses of SHG microscopy concerning this myelin disorder are proposed. In the long term, SHG microscopy could be integrated into diagnostic approaches for biopsy screening or direct intracranial analysis, but the greatest impact could be associated with trying to decipher the molecular basis of the disease.
There are many advantages of SHG microscopy over other microscopy techniques. Indeed, SHG microscopy does not require the fixation of the tissue, which is a particularly delicate step of sample preparation in the case of microtubules, and does not require staining of any kind. The greatest advantage is related to the physical phenomenon involved. On one hand, due to the virtually absent background, it provides high contrast despite the weak signals generated, and on the other hand, since the light intensities needed for frequency-doubling are very high and these intensities are met only in a very restricted volume of the sample, the technique provides intrinsic optical sectioning, thus allowing 3D reconstructions.
The major limitations of this microscopy technique are related to the cost of the equipment. A good confocal microscope, together with a pulsed infrared (IR) laser, is necessary for this application, and although a two-photon excitation system is available in many neuroscience labs, which can be easily modified into an SHG setup, the difference in cost compared to a conventional epifluorescence setup is still significant. Additionally, as a diffraction-limited technique, its resolution is affected by the use of IR light for illumination.
As with many pioneering applications, the setups used for the early experiments on SHG microscopy applied to the life sciences were totally customized optical setups built as open systems11,24,25, giving the experimenters the possibility to optimize every single component. Since, in life science labs, it is more common to have access to a commercial setup, we wanted to test whether one of these systems is sensitive enough to detect the weak signal emitted by tissular microtubules bundles, which are known to not be as strong harmonophores as collagen. The LSM710 NLO system by Zeiss consists of an inverted confocal microscope with modules for non-descanned detection in transmission and "epi" mode and with a Coherent Chameleon tunable IR laser. Due to the coherent nature of the SHG phenomenon, it is crucial to select the transmission path to maximize the collection of frequency-doubled light from the sample, and, therefore, the detection was performed through the 0.55 NA condenser by integration. An LCI Plan-Neofluar 25X/0.8 NA immersion objective was used to illuminate the sample from the bottom and approximate the condenser NA. With the conditions described in this paper, we could reliably detect a signal from the tissue bearing the TUBB4A mutation, and this signal was always absent in the controls.
In the reported protocol, two steps required adjustments to achieve the best imaging conditions: the thickness of the tissue section and the opening of the condenser diaphragm. The sections should be as thin as possible to prevent excessive absorbance, scattering, and loss of SH photons, especially since the goal is to image in transmission due to the coherent nature of the physical phenomenon. In our case, the limiting factor was the consistency of the taiep tissue, which hindered sectioning in homogeneously thick sections below 160-180 µm. With the conventional Köhler alignment, the condenser diaphragm is usually shut to about 60% of its area to generate contrast in the transmitted light image; conversely, for this application, the aim is to collect as many photons as possible, hence the total opening of the diaphragm.
This application of SHG microscopy is important as it provides the possibility for discerning tubulin-rich versus tubulin-normal tissue, with the tubulin-rich tissue emitting a detectable signal. It is also possible that other yet-to-be-described tubulinopathy mutations cause cytoskeletal disorders in other tissues26, which may also involve tubulin enrichment.
In terms of other possible applications, SHG microscopy could be expanded to the study of weaker signals, like those present in tubulin-normal tissue, in fine, dissociated axons, or in intracellular bundles with mixed polarity. To do so, setup modifications, such as the substitution of the air condenser with one with a higher numerical aperture and/or with immersion or the use of a more sensitive detector, could make an important difference.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported by Consejo Nacional de Ciencia y Tecnología (CONACYT) through the following grants: infraestructura 226450 to VP-CIO, infraestructura 255277 to V.P., and FORDECYT-PRONACES/194171/2020 to V.H. We acknowledge the support of Juvenal Hernández Guevara at CIO in the video-making.
405/10 nm BrightLine(R) single-band bandpass filter | Semrock | FF01-405/10-25 | 32 mm diameter, with housing ring |
Black Nylon, Polyurethane-Coated Fabric | Thorlabs | BK5 | 5' x 9' (1.5 m x 2.7 m) x 0.005" (0.12 mm) Thick |
Blades for vibratome | any commercial; e.g. Wilkinson Sword | Classic stainless steel double edge razor blades | |
Cell culture dishes, 35 mm | any commercial; e.g. Falcon | 351008 | |
Confocal microscope | Zeiss | LSM710NLO AxioObserver Z1 | Inverted microscope, objective used is LCI Plan-Neofluar 25x/0.8 NA |
Cooler | any commercial | Any insulated, polystyrene box could work, to mantain the sample at about 37 °C | |
Corn stach | e.g. Maizena | From the supermarket | |
Coverslips #1.5 | any commercial | Rectangular | |
Cyanoacrylate glue | e.g. Loctite | To glue the brain to the masking tape | |
Fine forceps | fine science tools | 11412-11 | To manipulate tissue sections by handling from the meninges |
Fine scissors | fine science tools | 14370-22 | To cut the skin |
Fine scissors curved tip | fine science tools | 14061-09 | To cut along the midline |
Formaldehyde 37% | Sigma-Aldrich | 252549 | To dilute 1:10 in PBS |
Friedman Rongeur | fine science tools | 16000-14 | To cut the bone |
Gel packs | any commercial | Prewarmed to 37 °C, to help mantaining the temperature inside the cooler | |
Glass Pasteur pipette, modified | any commercial | To transfer the tissue section | |
Hanks′ Balanced Salt solution (HBSS) | Gibco | 14025-076 | Could be prepared from powders |
Kelly hemostats | fine science tools | 13018-14 | To separate the bone |
Masking tape | any commercial | To protect th surface of the specimen plate | |
NDD module, type C | Zeiss | 000000-1410-101 | To detect the signal, reducing light loss. Housing the 000000-1935-163 filter set with the SP485 |
Offset bone nippers | fine science tools | 16101-10 | To cut the bone |
Phosphate buffered saline (PBS) | Gibco | 10010-031 | Could be prepared from powders or tabs |
Pulsed laser | Coherent | Chameleon Vision II | 680–1080 nm tunable laser |
Scalpel | any commercial | Straight blade with sharp point | |
Standard pattern forceps | fine science tools | 11000-18 | |
Vannas spring scissors | fine science tools | 15018-10 | To cut meninges that remain joined to both the slice obtained from vibratome cutting and the section glued to the specimen plate. |
Vibratome | any commercial; e.g. Leica | VT1200 |