Time-resolved single-molecule protein-induced fluorescence enhancement is a useful fluorescence spectroscopic proximity sensor sensitive to local structural changes in proteins. Here we show it can be used to uncover stable local conformations in α-Synuclein, which is otherwise known as globularly unstructured and unstable when measured using the longer range FRET ruler.
Using spectroscopic rulers to track multiple conformations of single biomolecules and their dynamics have revolutionized the understanding of structural dynamics and its contributions to biology. While the FRET-based ruler reports on inter-dye distances in the 3-10 nm range, other spectroscopic techniques, such as protein-induced fluorescence enhancement (PIFE), report on the proximity between a dye and a protein surface in the shorter 0-3 nm range. Regardless of the method of choice, its use in measuring freely-diffusing biomolecules one at a time retrieves histograms of the experimental parameter yielding separate centrally-distributed sub-populations of biomolecules, where each sub-population represents either a single conformation that stayed unchanged within milliseconds, or multiple conformations that interconvert much faster than milliseconds, and hence an averaged-out sub-population. In single-molecule FRET, where the reported parameter in histograms is the inter-dye FRET efficiency, an intrinsically disordered protein, such as the α-Synuclein monomer in buffer, was previously reported as exhibiting a single averaged-out sub-population of multiple conformations interconverting rapidly. While these past findings depend on the 3-10 nm range of the FRET-based ruler, we sought to put this protein to the test using single-molecule PIFE, where we track the fluorescence lifetime of site-specific sCy3-labeled α-Synuclein proteins one at a time. Interestingly, using this shorter range spectroscopic proximity sensor, sCy3-labeled α-Synuclein exhibits several lifetime sub-populations with distinctly different mean lifetimes that interconvert in 10-100 ms. These results show that while α-Synuclein might be disordered globally, it nonetheless attains stable local structures. In summary, in this work we highlight the advantage of using different spectroscopic proximity sensors that track local or global structural changes one biomolecule at a time.
Over the past two decades, single-molecule fluorescence-based methods have become a powerful tool for measuring biomolecules1,2, probing how different biomolecular parameters distribute as well as how they dynamically interconvert between different sub-populations of these parameters at sub-millisecond resolution3,4,5. The parameters in these techniques include the energy transfer efficiency in FRET measurements 6,7, fluorescence anisotropy8,9, fluorescence quantum yields and lifetimes10,11, as a function of different fluorescence quenching12 or enhancement13 mechanisms. One of these mechanisms, better known as protein-induced fluorescence enhancement (PIFE)14 introduces the enhancement of fluorescence quantum yield and lifetime as a function of steric obstruction to the free isomerization of the fluorophore when in excited-state, caused by protein surfaces in the vicinity of the dye14,15,16,17,18,19. Both FRET and PIFE are considered spectroscopic rulers or proximity sensors since their measured parameter is directly linked to a spatial measure within the labeled biomolecule under measurement. While the FRET efficiency is related to the distance between a pair of dyes within a range of 3-10 nm20, PIFE tracks increases in fluorescence quantum yields or lifetimes related to the distance between the dye and a surface of a nearby protein in the range of 0-3 nm19.
Single-molecule FRET has been widely used for providing structural insights into many different protein systems, including intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs)21, such as α-Synuclein (α-Syn)22. α-Syn can form ordered structures following binding to different biomolecules and under different conditions23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30. However, when unbound, the α-Syn monomer is characterized by high conformational heterogeneity with rapidly interconverting conformations31,32.
The conformations of α-Syn have been studied previously using various different techniques that help in identifying conformational dynamics of such highly heterogeneous and dynamic protein systems33,34,35,36,37,38,39. Interestingly, single-molecule FRET (smFRET) measurements of α-Syn in buffer reported a single FRET population39,40 that is an outcome of time-averaging of conformations dynamically interconverting at times much faster than the typical diffusion time of α-Syn through the confocal spot (times as fast as few microseconds and even faster than that, relative to typical millisecond diffusion times)40,41. However, using a FRET spectroscopic ruler with the 3-10 nm distance sensitivity sometimes reports only on overall structural changes in a small protein such as α-Syn. Single-molecule measurements utilizing spectroscopic proximity sensors with shorter distance sensitivities have the potential to report on dynamics of local structures. Herein we perform single-molecule PIFE measurements of α-Syn and identify different sub-populations of fluorescence lifetimes mapping to different local structures with transitions between them as slow as 100 ms. This work summarizes time-resolved smPIFE measurements of freely-diffusing α-Syn molecules one at a time, in buffer and when bound to SDS-based membranes as a short-range single-molecule spectroscopic proximity sensor.
1. Plasmid transformation
2. Protein preparation
3. Measurements
4. smPIFE burst analysis
As an IDP, when it is not bound to another biomolecule, α-Syn exhibits structural dynamics between multiple conformations, with transitions at few microseconds40 and even at hundreds of nanoseconds41. When α-Syn crosses the confocal spot, it may undergo thousands of transitions between conformations. Indeed, this was the case when smFRET was used39,40. Here we perform smPIFE measurements in order to probe the local conformational dynamics of α-Syn.
The measurement records fluorescence photons emitted from a sulfo-Cy3 (sCy3) dye, attached to the thiol group of cysteine in the α-Syn A56C mutant. The sCy3 fluorophore can undergo isomerization when in excited state. However, sCy3 emits a photon when it de-excites from its trans isomer. Therefore, if nothing sterically obstructs the sCy3 excited-state isomerization, it will emit few photons on average, but will exhibit a low fluorescence quantum yield and short fluorescence lifetime. However, if the excited-state isomerization of sCy3 is obstructed by, for example, the surface of a nearby protein, the rate of isomerization will decrease, which in turn will lead to more de-excitations from the trans isomer, and hence more photons, a higher fluorescence quantum yield and longer fluorescence lifetimes. This is better known as the PIFE effect.
Using smPIFE we measured the mean fluorescence lifetime of sCy3 labeling α-Syn at residue 56 one α-Syn at a time, where the sCy3 dye senses the protein environment around residue 56. The protein was measured at a concentration of 25 pM, in which it is mainly found as a monomer. The results of the smPIFE measurements are shown as histograms of mean fluorescence lifetimes of single α-Syn molecules (Figure 1). The mean fluorescence lifetimes can be grouped into two major sub-populations (Figure 1A). The first sub-population exhibits short fluorescence lifetimes, with a characteristic fluorescence lifetime of 1.6 ns, representing α-Syn conformational states with no or few protein surfaces found in the vicinity of residue 56. The second sub-population exhibits longer fluorescence lifetimes, with a characteristic fluorescence lifetime of 3.5 ns, representing α-Syn conformational states with more protein surfaces found in the vicinity of residue 56.
It is known that in the presence of ~5-10 mM SDS, the N-terminal and NAC segments of almost all of the α-Syn molecules in solution adopt a helical hairpin structure upon binding to SDS vesicles40. Since residue 56 is located within the NAC segment, fluorescence from sCy3 labeling residue 56 is expected to sense a rather uniform microenvironment, since the majority of almost all α-Syn molecules should acquire the vesicle-bound helical hairpin structure. Therefore, we performed similar smPIFE measurements but in the presence of 5 mM SDS as a control, expecting to identify a single population of fluorescence lifetimes. Indeed, these measurements result in a single population of fluorescence lifetimes with a characteristic fluorescence lifetime of 3.1 ns (Figure 1B). The ~3 ns characteristic fluorescence lifetime points to a local structure in the vicinity of residue 56, that does not exist in the ~1.5 ns lifetime sub-population of α-Syn in solution, emphasizing the structuring α-Syn undergoes when the helical hairpin is formed and the binding to the SDS vesicle surface has occurred. Interestingly, that single population has a shorter characteristic fluorescence lifetime relative to the ~3.5 ns lifetime sub-population of α-Syn in solution.
The appearance of two distinct centrally distributed sub-populations of single-molecule bursts is a well-known signature of molecular heterogeneity. Since no mixture of separate labeled molecules is involved, both lifetime sub-populations represent two separate species of sCy3 labeling residue 56 in α-Syn (Figure 1A). Therefore, the results report dynamic heterogeneity. This is because the parameter reported in the histogram is calculated using all the photons in a burst throughout the few ms duration of the diffusing α-Syn inside the confocal volume. Therefore, sCy3-labeled α-Syn molecules crossed the confocal volume either when exhibiting a short or a long mean lifetime. The transitions between these species must occur slower than the characteristic diffusion times through the confocal spot, hence slower than a few milliseconds. In order to assess this dynamic behavior, we performed burst-recurrence analysis47. In short, since we seek to assess dynamics that occur at times longer than the duration of a single-molecule burst, we tested the possibility that a single α-Syn molecule exhibits a change in the sCy3 mean fluorescence lifetime between consecutive crossings of the confocal spot. To do so, we first distinguish between two types of consecutive bursts: i) consecutive bursts of different α-Syn molecules with burst separation times that distribute in seconds, and ii) consecutive bursts of the same α-Syn molecule that recurs in the confocal volume after a burst separation time, at times as slow as ~100 ms (Figure 2A). Following the two mean lifetime sub-populations, we chose to inspect pairs of consecutive bursts that are separated by at most 100 ms (Figure 2A), where the first out of the pair of bursts exhibited mean fluorescence lifetime within the short lifetime sub-population (0-2 ns) or within the long lifetime sub-population (>3.5 ns; Figure 2B, colored shades). The inspection tests which of the bursts of recurring bursts, represented by the second burst in the pair of consecutive bursts, exhibits mean fluorescence lifetime within the lifetime sub-population opposite to the one in the first burst. One can observe that a fraction of molecules that start as a burst in the short lifetime sub-population recur as a burst outside that range and even within the long lifetime subpopulation (Figure 2C), and that a fraction of molecules that start as a burst in the long lifetime sub-population recur as a burst outside that range and even within the short lifetime subpopulation (Figure 2D), all within 10-100 ms.
Figure 1: Mean fluorescence lifetime sub-populations of sCy3 labeling residue 56 in α-Syn A56C. mean fluorescence lifetime histograms of freely-diffusing sCy3-labeled α-Syn A56C (at 25 pM) in the absence (A) and presence (B) of 5 mM SDS. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: PIFE burst recurrence analysis shows individual molecules undergo transitions between different average lifetime values within 100 ms. From top to bottom: (A) the histogram of separation times between consecutive single-molecule bursts. The orange shade represents separation times between consecutive bursts of recurring molecules, where the first and second bursts arise from the same molecule. (B) The mean fluorescence lifetime histogram of all single-molecule bursts. The yellow and green shades represent the range of average lifetime values chosen to represent values within short and long mean lifetime sub-populations, respectively. (C) or (D). The mean fluorescence lifetime histograms of bursts that were separated from a previous burst by a time within the orange-shaded timescale (in A), and where the previous burst had an average lifetime within the range represented by the yellow or green shades, respectively. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Extensive biochemical and biophysical studies were performed to study the structural characteristics of α-Syn and its disordered nature33,34,35,36,37,38. Several works have already utilized freely-diffusing smFRET to investigate the intra-molecular dynamics of the α-Syn monomer free of binding. These works reported the high dynamic heterogeneity of α-Syn, which leads to averaging-out of multiple different structural species within the typical diffusion times through the confocal spot, leading to the appearance of a single FRET population39,40. However, one must remember that smFRET measurements report on changes in inter-dye distances occurring within 3-10 nm, a scale characterizing overall structural changes in a small protein such as α-Syn.
We were curious as to what results we might find when using a different fluorescence-based sensor of spatial changes within a protein that is sensitive to local structural dynamics and that has been utilized also at the single-molecule level. smPIFE can track local spatial changes nearby sCy3 labeling a specific amino acid residue in the 0-3 nm range.
In this study, we utilized smPIFE to investigate the dynamics of local structures within α-Syn and more specifically local structure changes nearby the NAC residue 56. The results suggest that the region in the vicinity of residue 56 in α-Syn exhibits a few distinct structural sub-populations that are stable enough thermodynamically to interconvert in as slow as 100 ms, and perhaps even slower. These sub-populations are identified through the inspection of the mean fluorescence lifetimes of measured sCy3-labeled single α-Syn molecules. In these sub-populations, the longer the characteristic fluorescence lifetime of the sub-population is, the more nearby a protein surface obstructs the excited-state isomerization of sCy3, and hence the closer that protein surface is to that sCy3-labeled residue.
Like other IDPs, α-Syn has been reported to have interactions with other biomolecules, as well as self-association, where in many cases these binding events involve stabilization of a specific structure within the α-Syn subunit56,57,58,59. Some proteins acquire a specific structure upon binding, via an induced-fit mechanism. However other proteins spontaneously interconvert between several distinct conformations, and the binding event to a specific biomolecule merely stabilizes one of the preexisting conformations. For the latter case, one of the requirements is that the conformation to be stabilized will survive long enough to accommodate the initial binding. Therefore, the longer a structural region in a protein survives, the higher the binding efficiency will be. We suggest that the observed millisecond-stable sub-populations represent the existence of distinct species of local structure in the vicinity of residue 56. These point to different local structure species nearby the middle of the NAC and NTD segments. In a recent work, we report this and other sCy3-labeled residues in these segments also exhibit such sub-populations60. This result comes to show that the structural dynamics of the free α-Syn monomer can be best described as rapid (few microseconds at most40) overall protein dynamics, carrying local structural segments that stay stable for milliseconds. Other IDPs such as Tau and amyloid-β were known to share similar characteristics of carrying a local structured region48,49,50.
smPIFE has been mainly used for studying the interactions between separate biomolecules. Here, we employ smPIFE to investigate PIFE within segments of the same protein. It is important to mention that the majority of previous smPIFE experiments were performed by tracking relative changes in fluorescence intensities of single immobilized sCy3-labeled molecules13,14,15,16,17,18,19,51,52,53. While useful for immobilized molecules, this procedure is less informative when measuring freely-diffusing single-molecules. Hwang et al. have shown how to measure the PIFE effect also by tracking changes in fluorescence lifetimes, which report directly on the change in the excited-state isomerization dynamics of sCy319. Here we probe the PIFE effect of single diffusing α-Syn via the sCy3 mean fluorescence lifetimes, rather than tracking relative changes in fluorescence intensities. Doing so, we were able to acquire PIFE-related sub-populations despite the short residence time of each single α-Syn molecule in the confocal spot. In fact, the mean fluorescence lifetimes proved to be useful not only in defining PIFE-related sub-populations, but also in assessing slow PIFE-related dynamics using the burst recurrence analysis framework47. However, more work is required in developing procedures that will allow to properly assess faster PIFE dynamics. There are plenty of existing photon statistics tools, utilized to assess rapid FRET dynamics in freely diffusing smFRET experiments, which we intend to repurpose to be used in smPIFE54,55.
To summarize, in this work we used the relatively new combination of PIFE measurements of freely-diffusing single molecules to identify ms-stable sub-populations of local structures in α-Syn, which were not recovered by smFRET. We employed smPIFE measurements to study α-Syn as a model IDP and our results extend beyond past findings of α-Syn being globally disordered. The findings suggest α-Syn may carry ms-stable ordered local structures and we hypothesize these local structures may serve a role in binding recognition.
Thus far, smPIFE was used as means to study interactions of sCy3-labeled nucleic acids with their unlabeled protein counterparts51. By that, smPIFE was utilized as a powerful tool to sense biomolecular interactions, and hence the natural next step in that direction would be to use it in order to sense protein-protein interactions and their dynamics, one complex at a time.
The power of using a short-range proximity sensor such as smPIFE can assist in identifying stable local structuring within other protein systems considered disordered and structurally unstable. However, the power of using a single-molecule fluorescence-based short proximity sensor does not stop there. There are many biomolecular systems that exhibit short-scale conformational dynamics to facilitate their function, such as many ion channels. We believe smPIFE can serve as a tool complementary to single-molecule FRET, in such cases where the dynamic range of the proximity changes within the protein system does not match the dynamic range of distances FRET can detect and resolve. In summary, we promote the use of smPIFE as a proximity-sensor complementary to single-molecule FRET measurements, in order to cover a wider scale of biomolecular proximities, and perhaps observe clear millisecond-averaged sub-populations of the measured parameters reporting on stable structures that are either local or overall.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
The pT-t7 plasmid encoding A56C α-Syn mutant was given to us as a present from Dr. Asaf Grupi, Dr. Dan Amir and Dr. Elisha Haas. This paper was supported by the National Institutes of Health (NIH, grant R01 GM130942 to E.L. as a subaward), the Israel Science Foundation (grant 3565/20 within the KillCorona – Curbing Coronavirus Research Program), the Milner Fund and the Hebrew University of Jerusalem (startup funds).
Amicon Ultra-15 Centrifugal Filter Units | Merc | C7715 | cutoff: 100 kDa |
ammonium sulfate | Sigma-Aldrich | A4418 | |
BSA | Sigma-Aldrich | A9647 | |
cysteamine | Sigma-Aldrich | 30070 | |
dialysis bags – MEGA GeBaFlex-tube | Gene Bio-Application | MEGA320 | |
dithiothreitol (DTT) | Sigma-Aldrich | 43815 | |
ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) | Sigma-Aldrich | E5134 | |
Fast SeeBand staining solution | Gene Bio-Application | SB050 | |
Glycine | Sigma-Aldrich | 50046 | |
D-Glucose | Sigma-Aldrich | G7021 | |
HEPES | Sigma-Aldrich | 54457 | |
HiTrap Desalting 5 mL | Sigma-Aldrich | GE17-1408 | |
6-hydroxy-2,5,7,8-tetramethylchroman-2-carboxylic acid (TROLOX) | Sigma-Aldrich | 238813 | |
isopropyl β-d-1-thiogalactopyranoside (IPTG) | Sigma-Aldrich | I5502 | |
LB broth | Sigma-Aldrich | L3152 | |
Magnesium chloride | Sigma-Aldrich | 63068 | |
MonoQ column | Sigma-Aldrich | 54807 | |
protein LoBind tube | Sigma-Aldrich | EP0030108094 | 0.5 mL |
Rinse a µ-slide 18 | Ibidi | 81816 | |
SDS | Sigma-Aldrich | 75746 | |
Sodium acetate | Sigma-Aldrich | S2889 | |
Sodium hydroxide | Sigma-Aldrich | S8045 | |
Sodium phosphate monobasic monohydrate | Sigma-Aldrich | 71507 | |
Sterile Cell spreaders, Drigalski spatulas | mini-plast | 815-004-05-001 | |
streptomycin sulfate | Sigma-Aldrich | S9137 | |
sulfo-Cy3 maleimide | abcam | ab146493 | |
Tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine hydrochloride (TCEP) | Sigma-Aldrich | 75259 | |
Tris-HCl | Sigma-Aldrich | 93363 | |
Tryptone | Sigma-Aldrich | T7293 | |
Yeast Extract | Sigma-Aldrich | Y1625 |