This article describes a simple method to fabricate vertically aligned carbon nanotube arrays by CVD and to subsequently tune their wetting properties by exposing them to vacuum annealing or dry oxidation treatment.
In this article, we describe a simple method to reversibly tune the wetting properties of vertically aligned carbon nanotube (CNT) arrays. Here, CNT arrays are defined as densely packed multi-walled carbon nanotubes oriented perpendicular to the growth substrate as a result of a growth process by the standard thermal chemical vapor deposition (CVD) technique.1,2 These CNT arrays are then exposed to vacuum annealing treatment to make them more hydrophobic or to dry oxidation treatment to render them more hydrophilic. The hydrophobic CNT arrays can be turned hydrophilic by exposing them to dry oxidation treatment, while the hydrophilic CNT arrays can be turned hydrophobic by exposing them to vacuum annealing treatment. Using a combination of both treatments, CNT arrays can be repeatedly switched between hydrophilic and hydrophobic.2 Therefore, such combination show a very high potential in many industrial and consumer applications, including drug delivery system and high power density supercapacitors.3-5
The key to vary the wettability of CNT arrays is to control the surface concentration of oxygen adsorbates. Basically oxygen adsorbates can be introduced by exposing the CNT arrays to any oxidation treatment. Here we use dry oxidation treatments, such as oxygen plasma and UV/ozone, to functionalize the surface of CNT with oxygenated functional groups. These oxygenated functional groups allow hydrogen bond between the surface of CNT and water molecules to form, rendering the CNT hydrophilic. To turn them hydrophobic, adsorbed oxygen must be removed from the surface of CNT. Here we employ vacuum annealing treatment to induce oxygen desorption process. CNT arrays with extremely low surface concentration of oxygen adsorbates exhibit a superhydrophobic behavior.
The introduction of synthetic materials with tunable wetting properties has enabled many applications including self-cleaning surfaces and hydrodynamic drag reduction devices.6,7 Many reported studies show that to successfully tune the wetting properties of a material, one have to be able to vary its surface chemistry and topographic surface roughness.8-11 Among many other available synthetic materials, nanostructured materials have attracted most of the attention due to their inherent multi-scaled surface roughness and their surfaces can be readily functionalized by common methods. Several examples of these nanostructured materials include ZnO,12,13 SiO2,12,14 ITO,12 and carbon nanotubes (CNT).15-17 We believe that the ability to reversibly tune the wetting properties of CNT has its own virtue since they are considered as one of the most promising materials for future applications.
CNT can be turned hydrophilic by functionalizing their surfaces with oxygenated functional groups, introduced during an oxidation treatment. To date, the most common method to introduce oxygen adsorbates to the CNT is the well-known wet oxidation techniques, involving the use of strong acids and oxidizing agents such as nitric acid and hydrogen peroxide.18-20 These wet oxidation techniques are difficult to be scaled up to industrial level because of safety and environmental issues and the considerable amount of time to complete the oxidation process. In addition, a critical point drying method may need to be employed to minimize the effect of capillary forces that may destroy the microscopic structure and overall alignment of the CNT array during the drying process. Dry oxidation treatments, such as UV/ozone and oxygen plasma treatments, offer a safer, faster, and more controlled oxidation process compared to the aforementioned wet oxidation treatments.
CNT can be made hydrophobic by removing the attached oxygenated functional groups from their surfaces. Thus far, complicated processes are always involved in producing highly hydrophobic CNT arrays. Typically, these arrays have to be coated with non-wetting chemicals, such as PTFE, ZnO, and fluoroalkylsilane,15,21,22 or be pacified by fluorine or hydrocarbon plasma treatment, such as CF4 and CH4.16,23 Although the abovementioned treatments are not too difficult to be scaled up to industrial level, they are not reversible. Once the CNT are exposed to these treatments, they can no longer be rendered hydrophilic by using common oxidation methods.
The methods presented herein show that the wettability of CNT arrays can be tuned straightforwardly and conveniently via a combination of dry oxidation and vacuum annealing treatments (Figure 1). Oxygen adsorption and desorption processes induced by these treatments are highly reversible because of their non-destructive nature and the absence of other impurities. Hence, these treatments allow CNT arrays to be repeatedly switched between hydrophilic and hydrophobic. Further, these treatments are very practical, economical, and can be easily scaled up since they can be performed using any commercial vacuum oven and UV/ozone or oxygen plasma cleaner.
Note that the vertically aligned CNT arrays used here are grown by the standard thermal chemical vapor deposition (CVD) technique. These arrays are typically grown on catalyst coated silicon wafer substrates in a quartz tube furnace under a flow of carbon containing precursor gasses at an elevated temperature. The average length of the arrays can be varied from a few micrometers to a millimeter long by changing the growth time.
1. Carbon Nanotube (CNT) Array Growth
2. Oxygen Adsorption Induced by UV/Ozone Treatment
3. Oxygen Adsorption Induced by Oxygen Plasma Treatment
4. Oxygen Desorption Induced by Vacuum Annealing Treatment
5. Wetting Properties Characterization
The CVD method described above results in densely packed vertically aligned multi-walled CNT arrays with a typical diameter, number of wall, and inter-nanotube spacing of about 12 – 20 nm, 8 – 16 walls, and 40 – 100 nm respectively. The average length of the arrays can be varied from a few micrometers long (Figure 6a) to a millimeter long (Figure 6b) by changing the growth time from 5 min to 1 hr respectively. Typically the vertical alignment is good at larger length scale and some entanglements present at smaller length scale.1
After being exposed to UV/ozone or oxygen plasma treatment, the CNT arrays become hydrophilic and they can be wetted by water. A prolonged exposure to these treatments turns the CNT arrays superhydrophilic, indicated by their extremely low static contact angle of less than 30 °. Since these superhydrophilic CNT arrays can be wetted very easily by water, they show their original black color whenever they are being completely submerged in water (Figure 7).
After being exposed to vacuum annealing treatment, the CNT arrays become hydrophobic and they cannot be easily wetted by water. A prolonged exposure to this treatment turns the CNT arrays superhydrophobic, indicated by their extremely high static contact angle of more than 150 °. Since these superhydrophobic CNT arrays repel water very strongly, they appear reflective whenever they are being completely submerged in water due to the presence of thin air films on their surfaces (Figure 7).
A simple oxidation-time-independent relation can be observed from a plot of oxygen-to-carbon atomic ratio (O/C ratio) of the CNT arrays to their static contact angle. The O/C ratio, corresponds to the degree of oxidation of the CNT array, can be calculated from the O 1s and C 1s peaks obtained by x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). The O/C ratio decreases as the static contact angle of the array increases, where the O/C ratio of superhydrophilic CNT arrays is higher than 15% and that of superhydrophobic CNT arrays is lower than 8% (Figure 8a). Notice that the O/C ratio of superhydrophobic CNT arrays is not zero, suggesting that a small amount of oxygen cannot be easily removed by vacuum annealing treatment.
Deconvolution of the high resolution XPS spectra at the binding energy of 283-293 eV shows four distinct peaks, with one primary peak associated with the presence of sp2 C-C 1s bonds (~284.9 eV) and three secondary peaks associated with the presence of hydroxyl C-OH (~285.4 eV), carbonyl C=O (~287.4 eV), and carboxyl -COOH (~289.7 eV) functional groups.20,25 As the CNT arrays undergo a dry oxidation treatment, they become more hydrophilic, and all peaks associated with C-OH, C=O and -COOH groups become more pronounced (Figure 8b). At a longer exposure time, the surface concentration of C=O groups decreases slightly while that of C-OH and -COOH groups continues to increase (Figure 8c). On the other hand, the amount of C-OH, C=O and -COOH groups decreases after the vacuum annealing treatment (Figure 8d). The existence of these peaks suggests that the vacuum annealing treatment does not completely remove oxygen adsorbates from the CNT arrays, even though these arrays are found to be superhydrophobic.
Figure 1. Wetting properties of CNT arrays can be varied via a combination of UV/ozone or oxygen plasma treatment and vacuum annealing treatment. Oxygen adsorption occurs during the UV/ozone or oxygen plasma treatment while oxygen desorption occurs during vacuum annealing treatment. CNT arrays become more hydrophilic after being exposed to UV/ozone or oxygen plasma treatment and more hydrophobic after being exposed to vacuum annealing treatment. Click here to view larger figure.
Figure 2. A 1 inch diameter quartz tube furnace, equipped with digital mass flow and pressure controllers, for CNT array growth.
Figure 3. A commercial UV/ozone cleaner used to render CNT arrays hydrophilic by functionalizing them with oxygenated functional groups.
Figure 4. A commercial oxygen plasma cleaner used to render CNT arrays hydrophilic by functionalizing them with oxygenated functional groups.
Figure 5. A commercial vacuum oven used for introducing oxygen desorption process on the CNT array so that they become more hydrophobic.
Figure 6. Low magnification SEM images of CNT array with an average length of 15 μm (a) and 985 μm (b).
Figure 7. An image of two CNT arrays with opposite wetting properties fully submerged in water. The highly hydrophilic UV/ozone treated CNT array (§) shows its original black color while the superhydrophobic vacuum annealed CNT array (‡) appears reflective due to the presence of a thin air film on its surface.
Figure 8. A plot of oxygen to carbon atomic ratio (O/C ratio) of CNT arrays as a function of static contact angle for water, with shaded region indicates the superhydrophobic regime (a). The O/C ratio can is calculated from the O 1s and C 1s peaks obtained by XPS. Deconvolution of high resolution XPS spectra of the C 1s peak of a mildly hydrophilic CNT array (b), a highly hydrophilic CNT array (c), and a superhydrophobic CNT array (d).
We consider UV/ozone treatment as the most convenient oxidation technique because it can be performed in air at a standard room temperature and pressure for up to several hours, depending on the length of the CNT array and the power of the UV radiation. UV radiation, generated by a high intensity mercury vapor lamp at 185 nm and 254 nm, breaks the molecular bonds on the outer wall of CNT allowing ozone, converted simultaneously from air by UV radiation, to oxidize their surface.26,27 The oxidation process stops once the CNT surfaces are fully functionalized, preventing the CNT to be completely oxidized into CO and CO2 molecules.
In contrast, oxygen plasma treatment has to be performed in a special chamber at a reduced pressure and a constant oxygen flow rate. Typically, oxygen plasma is generated remotely under 50 Watts of RF power and delivered at a constant flow rate of 150 SCCM and a chamber pressure of 500 mTorr for several minutes. Although oxygen plasma treatment allows a much faster oxidation process, care has to be taken because it is very capable of completely oxidizing the CNT into CO and CO2 molecules. .
UV/ozone and oxygen plasma treatments have been successfully employed to functionalize the surface of CNT with oxygenated functional groups.26-31 However, none of these published methods have been previously performed on CNT arrays. Although the oxidation method described herein is similar to these published methods, it is optimized for CNT arrays, not CNT powders. This current method utilizes low UV lamp irradiation power and plasma generator power to keep the oxygen adsorption rate low. Such low oxygen adsorption rate is essential to ensure that the functionalization process occurs uniformly across the CNT array sample without damaging them. Therefore, the oxidation time for CNT arrays is typically longer than that for CNT powders.
Vacuum annealing treatment is employed to induce oxygen desorption process without using any harsh reducing agents. Vacuum annealing treatment performed at a mild vacuum of about 2.5 Torr and a moderate temperature of about 250 °C for several hours is found to be sufficient to deoxidize CNT arrays.
The surface hydrophilicity of UV/ozone and oxygen plasma treated CNT arrays is found to be stable in air at standard room temperature for more than 2 months. On the other hand, the surface hydrophobicity of vacuum annealed CNT arrays is found to be stable in air at standard room temperature for only 3 weeks. These vacuum annealed CNT arrays are gradually losing their hydrophobicity until they become mildly hydrophilic. However, the superhydrophobic CNT arrays produced by vacuum annealing treatment are found to remain superhydrophobic for more than 2 months storage in air at standard room temperature.
Here we have shown that the wettability of CNT arrays can be tuned via a combination of dry oxidation and vacuum annealing treatments. However, these treatments have one main limitation. Both dry oxidation and vacuum annealing treatments perform poorly on low quality CNT arrays. In general, low quality CNT arrays are defined as ones with a high amount of metal contaminants or amorphous carbon coatings. The oxide layers on the metal contaminants inhibit further oxygen adsorption, rendering the oxidation process to functionalize CNT without damaging their structure unfeasible. In addition, these oxide layers are inherently hydrophilic and can only be removed by an exposure to a reducing agent, not by vacuum annealing treatment. Similarly, lack of dangling bonds on amorphous carbon coatings makes them naturally hydrophilic, such that they cannot be turned hydrophobic just by vacuum annealing treatment. Therefore, these low quality CNT arrays are extremely difficult to be turned hydrophobic by vacuum annealing treatment.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported by The Charyk Foundation and The Fletcher Jones Foundation under grant number 9900600. The authors gratefully acknowledge the Kavli Nanoscience Institute at the California Institute of Technology for use of the nanofabrication instruments, the Molecular Materials Research Center of the Beckman Institute at the California Institute of Technology for use of the XPS and contact angle goniometer, and the Division of Geological and Planetary Sciences of the California Institute of Technology for use of SEM.
Material Name | Company | Catalogue Number | Comments (optional) |
Lindberg Blue M Mini-Mite tube furnace | Thermo Scientific | TF55030A | 1″ tube furnace for CNT array growth |
Electronic mass flow controllers | MKS | PFC-50 πMFC | Max flow rate of 1000 sccm |
Electronic pressure controller | MKS | PC-90 πPC | Max pressure of 1000 Torr |
1″ quartz tube | MTI Corp. | >EQ-QZTube-25GE-610 | 1″ D x 24″ L |
Hydrogen gas | Airgas | HY UHP200 | CNT array growth precursor gas, 99.999% purity |
Ethylene gas | Matheson | G2250101 | CNT array growth precursor gas, 99.999% purity |
Argon gas | Airgas | AR UHP200 | CNT array growth precursor gas, 99.999% purity |
Silicon wafer | El-Cat | 2449 | With 300 nm polished thermal oxide layer |
Iron pellets | Kurt J Lesker | EVMFE35EXEA | 99.95% purity |
Aluminum oxide pellets | Kurt J Lesker | EVMALO-1220B | 99.99% purity |
E-beam evaporator | CHA Industries | CHA Mark 40 | For buffer and catalyst layer deposition |
UV/ozone cleaner | BioForce Nanosciences | ProCleaner Plus | For oxidizing CNT array |
Oxygen plasma cleaner | PVA TePla | M4L | For oxidizing CNT array |
Vacuum oven | VWR | 97027-664 | For deoxidizing CNT array |
SEM | Zeiss | 1550 VP | For CNT array growth characterization |
XPS | Surface Science | M-Probe | For surface chemistry characterization |
Contact angle goniometer | ramé-hart | Model 190 | For wetting properties characterization |