A procedure for the delivery of a chemical ablative solution to the rat mammary ductal tree for image-guided preventive treatment of breast cancer is described. Mammary epithelial cells can be targeted with minimal collateral tissue damage through cannulation directly into the nipple opening and intraductal infusion of a 70% ethanol-based ablative solution.
There are still a limited number of primary interventions for prevention of breast cancer. For women at a high risk of developing breast cancer, the most effective intervention is prophylactic mastectomy. This is a drastic surgical procedure in which the mammary epithelial cells that can give rise to breast cancer are completely removed along with the surrounding tissue. The goal of this protocol is to demonstrate the feasibility of a minimally invasive intraductal procedure that could become a new primary intervention for breast cancer prevention. This local procedure would preferentially ablate mammary epithelial cells before they can become malignant. Intraductal methods to deliver solutions directly to these epithelial cells in rodent models of breast cancer have been developed at Michigan State University and elsewhere. The rat mammary gland consists of a single ductal tree that has a simpler and more linear architecture compared to the human breast. However, chemically induced rat models of breast cancer offer valuable tools for proof-of-concept studies of new preventive interventions and scalability from mouse models to humans. Here, a procedure for intraductal delivery of an ethanol-based ablative solution containing tantalum oxide nanoparticles as X-ray contrast agent and ethyl cellulose as gelling agent into the rat mammary ductal tree is described. Delivery of aqueous reagents (e.g., cytotoxic compounds, siRNAs, AdCre) by intraductal injection has been described previously in mouse and rat models. This protocol description emphasizes methodological changes and steps that pertain uniquely to delivering an ablative solution, formulation consideration to minimize local and systemic side effects of the ablative solution, and X-ray imaging for in vivo assessment of ductal tree filling. Fluoroscopy and micro-CT techniques enable to determine the success of ablative solution delivery and the extent of ductal tree filling thanks to compatibility with the tantalum-containing contrast agent.
For women in the USA1, breast cancer (BC) continues to be the most diagnosed cancer type and causes more deaths than any other cancer type except lung cancer. Projections for 2022 estimate that 51,400 women will be diagnosed with carcinoma in situ and 287,850 women will be diagnosed with invasive carcinoma, and that 43,600 women will die from BC1. Despite the prevalence and mortality associated with BC, there are few options available for primary prevention and translational research on novel interventions as primary prevention is not prioritized by federal agencies2. Prophylactic mastectomy is the most effective intervention for primary prevention. However, this procedure is only recommended for high-risk individuals because it is a major surgery with life-changing consequences3. This surgery involves complete removal of the mammary epithelial cells from which carcinogenesis develops as well as the normal surrounding tissue. Individuals are often dissuaded from using this procedure as their first option of primary intervention due to the negative impact of physical, psychological, and social stress. For these reasons, even some high-risk individuals opt to not undergo this procedure and choose instead watchful waiting or similar surveillance strategies3. In previous publication, delivery of 70% ethanol (EtOH) directly into the ductal tree of mouse models was effective at chemically ablating mammary epithelial cells with limited damage to adjacent normal tissue and at preventing breast tumor formation4. EtOH is used in multiple clinical applications as either an ablative agent for local treatment of some cancers or sclerosing agent for local treatment of arteriovenous swelling and malformations5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14. The low toxicity and safety profile of EtOH is well established, as in some procedures up to 50 mL of 95% EtOH can be administered per session5,10.
Complete removal of mammary epithelial cells from which BC develops is the most crucial component of both prophylactic mastectomy and local delivery of an ablative solution.Therefore, confirmation of complete ductal tree filling is necessary to guarantee that the ablative solution has come in direct contact with all the mammary epithelial cells. Delivering a solution within the ductal tree(s) and its visualization by image-guided fluoroscopy or ductography are possible through clinical procedures that already exist15,16,17. Thus, it will be feasible to readily implement and evaluate this procedure in clinical trials. A key step in establishing the efficacy and translational feasibility of intraductal (ID) ablation as a new intervention for primary prevention will be to demonstrate the feasibility of this X-ray visualization approach in animal models of increasing size and complexity of their ductal tree architecture4,18,19. A protocol that scales up this ablative procedure from mouse20 to rat models is described here. While mouse and rat ductal trees have a similar linear structure and branching pattern, the rat ductal tree is proportionally larger and is surrounded by a much denser stroma. We have implemented a method in the laboratory to successfully inject every mammary gland in a rat over a series of weekly sessions with an ablative solution containing a contrast agent. Session spacing is necessary to ensure the animals have minimal side effects of EtOH (Figure 1 and Figure 2). The procedure involves injection of the ablative solution directly into the nipple opening of an isoflurane-anesthetized rat with a 33 G needle. Some key improvements of the procedure include the use of extended anti-inflammatory treatment, injection of higher volumes per ductal tree than suggested21, and gastight syringes for liquid and gases. The duration of treatment with 5 mg/kg of carprofen (an NSAID) from 48 h before to 1 week after ID injections is comparable to the anti-inflammatory protocol used for the sclerosing therapy of venous malformation in the clinic. The treatment is performed on patients under systemic anesthesia followed by 2 days of anti-inflammatory medications such as NSAIDs. The anti-inflammatory treatment may be extended for a few more days to reduce local inflammation and any potential pain13. As in mice20, intraperitoneal injection of a 5% sucrose solution mitigates the short-term effect of alcohol intoxication in rats. Rats can be injected with up to 1 mL of 70% EtOH (up to 4 ducts; 0.2 g/dL of EtOH content in blood) in a single session when administered with this sucrose solution; animals fully recover within 4 h after ID injections. We perform sequential sessions to allow enough recovery time when injecting more than 4 glands and/or higher EtOH concentrations. Alcohol intoxication in women will be much less likely as ID injection of all ductal trees in both breasts, assuming 16 main ducts16,17and 2 mL per duct22,23, with 70% EtOH would result in less than 0.1 g/dL of EtOH content in blood and may cause mild impairment.
X-ray imaging enables the determination of how successful intraductal delivery is in each individual gland and whether the entire ductal tree is filled (Figure 1, Figure 2, Figure 3). Real-time fluoroscopy imaging in preparation for micro-CT scan and/or 3D reconstruction of DICOM file data can be used to assess the extent of solution delivery into the ductal tree and any leakage into the stroma. Use of fluoroscopy can help to limit the overall radiation dose imposed on the animal. The fluoroscopy technique approximates more closely to the intended clinical application for image-guidance of this ablative treatment. Comparison of FDA-approved iodine-containing Isovue to tantalum oxide (TaOx) nanoparticles has been performed in order to further refine the utility of the ablative solution4,19. It has been found that TaOx is a superior micro-CT contrast agent than Isovue for visualization of the initial filling of the ductal tree in mice4,19. Here, we demonstrate that TaOx is a suitable contrast agent to visualize the initial filling of the rat ductal tree (Figure 2 and Figure 3). Both in translational research and clinical practice applications, the gelling agent ethyl cellulose (EC) has been added to the EtOH solution to minimize diffusion from the intended targeted regions13,14,24,25,26,27,28,29. Studies have shown that addition of up to 1.5% EC to EtOH-containing ablative solutions is compatible with TaOx-based imaging (Figure 3). These as well as further refinements to the ablative solution may assist in ready translation of this image-guided procedure to the clinic.
All the experiments that are described were conducted under protocols approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee at Michigan State University.
1. Extended anti-inflammatory treatment
2. Preoperative preparation
NOTE: Ensure that the animal preparation step precedes the ID injection procedure by 2-3 days.
3. Intraductal injection
4. Micro-CT imaging
5. Image analysis
Each of the 12 mammary glands of a female rat contains a single ductal tree that opens at the nipple orifice. Despite the differences in size between the mouse and the rat, the developmental timing of the mammary glands and the time that these animals reach adulthood is very similar30,31. A brief description of the key stages of mammary gland development in rats as representative of both rodent species is provided. Terminal end buds (TEBs) are the highly proliferative structures at the tips of the elongating ductal tree that direct ductal branching30,31. The peak of proliferation and density of the TEBs occurs at 3-4 weeks of age during the elongating phase of the ductal tree in pubertal development30. By 9-10 weeks of age, there are few TEBs remaining as the ductal tree has grown to occupy the entire length of the fat pad30. After that, growth and expansion of the ductal tree is proportional to that of the fat pad and of the animal32. Terminal ductal lobular units (TDLUs) in the human breast carry out a similar role to the TEBs in rodents. TDLUs are the main source for initiation of carcinogenesis and progression to BC33,34. We can inject up to 300 µL of 70% EtOH solution to fill the entire ductal tree of the thoracic and abdominal mammary glands of the 9-week-old Sprague-Dawley rat (Figure 1, Figure 2, Figure 3). Unlike mice20, the nipples of the cervical and inguinal glands of the Sprague-Dawley rats are typically suitable for injection in more than 80% of animals, and up to 100 μL of 70% EtOH solution is required to fill the entire ductal tree (Figure 2). We routinely inject up to 10 mammary glands with the ablative solution under study. A typical experimental design consists of two independent weekly ID injection sessions, in which five alternating glands are infused with the ablative solution containing X-ray contrast agent and/or EC as the gelling agent (Figure 2). For TaOx-containing (50-200 mM) ablative solution, fluoroscopy and/or micro-CT scanning is performed after the end of each session to determine and record the individual success of infusing each ductal tree with partial or full amount of infused solution (Figure 2). Immediate and longitudinal imaging after injection enables assessment of how changes in formulation, especially concentration of EC gelling agent, affects and limits outward diffusion of the ablative solution as a function of the injected volume (Figure 3). This imaging analysis provides information to understand the optimal parameters to achieve maximal ablation with minimal collateral tissue damage.
Figure 1: Schematics of the procedure for intraductal injection and image analysis in rats. The step-by-step procedure for intraductal injection and image analysis are highlighted. Please see video for more details. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Examples of nipple cannulation and delivery outcome of the ablative solution into multiple mammary glands. (A) Typical presentation of nipple shapes in the Sprague-Dawley rat strain. Nipple length correlates with likelihood of successful cannulation. Longer nipples are easier to cannulate than short nipples, whereas excessively short or vestigial nipples cannot be cannulated. Once cannulated, both long and short nipples can be infused with the solution and achieve similar success rates of delivery. Blue food dye in the injected solution may be used as in vivo evidence of ductal tree filling and delivery success (most apparent, dome formation, for an unsuccessful fat pad injection). Real-time fluoroscopy (B) and 3D micro-CT renditions generated after image acquisition (C) provide in vivo evidence of delivery success and more quantitative assessment of the solution reaching the TEBs. (B) Each abdominal mammary gland of the first pair (#4, #10) received ablative solution with 1% EC (orange outline) or without it (green outline) (C) Successful delivery (blue outline) of the ablative solution in the right cervical (#7), second pair of thoracic (#3, #9) and first pair of abdominal (#4, #10) mammary glands, and unsuccessful injection (dashed white outline) in the left thoracic (#1) gland. Scale bars correspond to 1 mm in the images at different magnification. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: 3D reconstruction and assessment of ablative solution filling and diffusion. 70% EtOH/100 mM TaOx nanoparticles with 1% EC (top) or without EC (bottom) were intraductally injected into the second abdominal mammary gland pair (#4 and #10) and immediately imaged by micro-CT. Each Sprague-Dawley rat received an increasing volume of either solution. Individual ductal trees were reconstructed using an image analysis software package (spline trace + propagate object + threshold rendition). With 1% EC, the solution can be seen reaching the terminal ends. As the delivered volume is increased, the number of TEBs filled is more apparent. Scale bar corresponds to 10 mm in all renditions. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Issue | Appearance | Solution | |||
Short nipple (Fig. 2) | Nipple has low profile – hard to grab | It is sometimes easier to hold the skin near the nipple and target the center of the nipple with the needle. The needle will likely dive under the skin. Pulling up slowly may reveal the nipple to be slightly over the tip of the needle and give room to grab and pull it the rest of the way onto the needle. Be very careful when diving below the skin about the angle of the needle. It is easy to inadvertently get a fat pad injection by stabbing at the wrong angle. | |||
Fat pad injection (Fig. 2) | Swollen around nipple and possibly in nipple itself – easiest to see if color is added to injection solution | If nipple is swelling with first few ul injected, remove needle, and attempt to insert again with more care taken of angle. Begin injection again and watch for further swelling. If swelling continues, abandon attempt. It is very rare to successfully inject a nipple that has started out as a fat pad injection. | |||
Wounds/scabbing | Open wound or scabbing near injection site of EtOH solution | Rats are more likely than mice to develop wounds or scabbing near the injection area. If wounds are found, apply triple antibiotic ointment to open wounds but leave scabbed wounds alone. Applying ointment to scabs can increase likelihood animal will bother the scab and remove it. Check every 1-2 days until healed depending on severity of wound. Carprofen should be given until healed even if beyond normal window. | |||
Inject alternating glands | N/A | Larger injection volumes in rats make it more likely to cause skin abrasions if injecting consecutive glands. For least likelihood of trauma to injection area, alternate glands injected within a single session (i.e. inject #1, 3, 4 and 6 rather than #1-4). Spacing between third (#3 and #9) and fourth (#4 and #10) gland pairs allows injection of both of these glands in one session. |
Table 1: Helpful tips and troubleshooting
As shown here, ID delivery of 70% EtOH preferentially ablates the mammary epithelial cells with limited collateral damage to the surrounding stroma and vasculature in mice4. Local ablation of the ductal tree is effective at preventing tumor formation in mouse models4. Here, we demonstrate that this ablative procedure can be scaled up to rats.
This is the next step in the path to translation of this ablative procedure as an alternative intervention to prophylactic mastectomy for primary prevention of breast cancer in high-risk individuals. Addition of TaOx nanoparticles as an X-ray contrast agent to the ablative solution allows to assess effectiveness of the solution at preventing tumor formation, as it can be determined whether the procedure was successful or not at completely filling the ductal tree. Using fluoroscopy to visualize the injected mammary gland mirrors what will likely be done in the clinic to guide this ID procedure. Image guidance of how much the solution has filled the ductal tree and when to stop infusion will be a key aspect of the clinical implementation to ensure maximal filling of each ductal tree. Troubleshootings and helpful tips are listed in Table 1. Effectiveness of this ablative procedure requires that the infused solution makes direct contact with all the epithelial cells to maximize the rate of cell killing. Spare epithelial cells within one or more trees could eventually serve as a source for BC development. The other groups reported ID delivery of viral particles (e.g., components of Cre/LoxP and/or Cas9/CRISPR systems), hormones and hormone antagonists (e.g., prolactin, fulvestrant), chemotherapeutic agents (e.g., cisplatin), siRNAs and/or antibodies or other targeting agents in mice4,19,21,35,36,37,38,39,40,41,42,43,44,45, rats21,33,46,47,48 and/or rabbits18,49,50,51,52,53. Successful cannulation of up to eight ductal trees per human breast for local delivery of chemotherapy has been reported in independent clinical studies47,54,55. Image guidance for infusion of these other solutions aimed at tumor prevention or geared toward local treatment would similarly maximize their effectiveness.
The scalability and refinement of this procedure from mouse to rat ductal tree is demonstrated here. TaOx nanoparticle in the murine4,19 and rat (unpublished data) ductal tree provide high-resolution imaging that surpasses the FDA-approved iodine-containing X-ray contrast agents. Similarly, we are unaware of other ductal tree imaging approaches in mice40,41 or other animal models18 that can provide comparable resolution to TaOx. Relevant for clinical translation is the fact that the gelling effect of EC in this intermediate size rat models is an enabling formulation refinement to minimize collateral tissue damage. As we continue to assess this ablative ID procedure for its ability to prevent BC, we will be able to determine, more precisely, from which glands BC develops through the added information provided by imaging after ID delivery in chemically induced and other rat models of BC. These data will determine the safety of this procedure and pinpoint any concerns or shortcomings of whether partial or unsuccessful treated ductal trees might be more prone to develop BC in a high-risk woman.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported, in part, by the National Cancer Institute R21 CA226579 and R01 CA258314 grants to LFS and by the National Institute of Biomedical Imaging and Bioengineering R01 EB029418 grant to EMS. We are grateful to the MSU Institute for Quantitative (IQ) Health Science and Engineering Imaging Core facility for use of their imaging systems and technical expertise. We thank Dr. Danielle Ferguson for reviewing contents of the video and the figures for adherence to animal welfare guidelines.
AnalyzeDirect v12.0 | Caliper | n/a | For micro-CT image processing |
Carprieve, Carprofen 50 mg/mL | Allivet | 50647 | For anti-inflammatory treatment |
Ethyl cellulose | Acros Organics | 9004-57-3 | For intraductal injection |
Evans blue | Sigma | E2129-50G | For injection visualization |
Hot water bath | Toolots | Yidu_HH-S2 | For preparing carprofen cups |
MediGel Sucralose Cups | ClearH2O | 74-02-5022 | For delivery of carprofen |
Model 1750 TTL, PTFE Luer Lock Syringe, 500μL | Hamilton | 81220 | For intraductal injection |
Photoshop 2021 | Adobe | n/a | For image processing |
Quantum GX2 microCT Imaging System | Perkin Elmer | CLS149276 | For micro-CT image acquisition |
Metal Hub Needle, 33 gauge, custom (30° bevel angle, 0.4 in, point style 4) | Hamilton | 7747-01 | For intraductal injection |
Stereo Microscope SZM Series | AmScope | SM-4TPZ-144 | For intraductal injection |
Sterile blue food dye | McCormick | 930641 | For injection visualization |
Sterile phosphate buffered saline (PBS) | ThermoFisher | 14190250 | For solution preparation |
Stickers | DOT Scientific | DOTSCI-C50 | For preparing carprofen cups |
Sucrose | Calbiochem | 8550-5KG | For intraductal injection |
Syringes | Fisher | 14-826-79 | For preparing carprofen cups |
Vortex | VWR | 10153-834 | For preparing carprofen cups |
Warming pump/pad(s) | Braintree Scientific | HTP-1500 120V; AP-R 26E | For intraductal injection/preoperative preparation |