The objective is to fractionate and isolate bioactive small molecules, peptides from a complex plant extract, and proteins from pathogenic microbes by employing liquid-phase isoelectric focusing (IEF) method. Further, the separated molecules were identified and their bioactivity confirmed.
Natural products derived from plants and microbes are a rich source of bioactive molecules. Prior to their use, the active molecules from complex extracts must be purified for downstream applications. There are various chromatographic methods available for this purpose yet not all labs can afford high performance methods and isolation from complex biological samples can be difficult. Here we demonstrate that preparative liquid-phase isoelectric focusing (IEF) can separate molecules, including small molecules and peptides from complex plant extracts, based on their isoelectric points (pI). We have used the method for complex biological sample fractionation and characterization. As a proof of concept, we fractionated a Gymnema sylvestre plant extract, isolating a family of terpenoid saponin small molecules and a peptide. We also demonstrated effective microbial protein separation using the Candida albicans fungus as a model system.
The purification of biomolecules from complex biological samples is an essential and often difficult step in biological experiments1. Isoelectric focusing (IEF) is well-suited for high resolution separation of complex biomolecules where carrier ampholytes travel according to their charge and establish the pH gradient in an electric field3. The first commercial carrier ampholyte for IEF was developed by Olof Vesterberg in 1964 and patented4,5. Carrier ampholytes are aliphatic oligo-amino oligo-carboxylic acid molecules of varying length and branching6. Subsequently, Vesterberg and others improved the carrier ampholytes for their expanded use in separating biomolecules6,7.
Methods to separate biomolecules include agarose and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2-DE), isoelectric focusing, capillary electrophoresis, isotachophoresis and other chromatographic techniques (e.g., TLC, FPLC, HPLC)2. Liquid-phase IEF performed in an instrument called a “Rotofor” was invented by Milan Bier8. He pioneered the concept and design of this instrument and contributed extensively to the theory of electrophoretic migration. His team also developed a mathematical model of electrophoretic separation process for computer simulations9.
The liquid-phase IEF apparatus is a horizontally rotating cylindrical cell consisting of a nylon core divided into 20 porous compartments and a circulating water cooling ceramic rod. The porous chambers allow molecules to migrate through the aqueous phase between the electrodes and permit collection of purified samples under vacuum in fractions. This purification system can provide up to 1000-fold purification of a specific molecule in <4 hours. A valuable feature of this instrument is that it can be applied as a first step for purification from a complex mixture or as a final step to achieve purity10. If the molecule of interest is a protein, another advantage is that its native conformation will be maintained during the separation.
The use of liquid-phase IEF has been reported widely for proteins, enzymes and antibody purification6,10,11,12,13,14. Here we describe the use of this approach for separating and purifying small molecules and peptides from the medicinal plant Gymnema sylvestre. This protocol will help researchers concentrate and purify active small molecules from a plant extract for downstream applications at low cost. In addition, we also demonstrate that enrichment of proteins from a complex protein extract from Candida albicans fungus15 in this IEF-based system as a second example.
1. Setup and prerunning of standard liquid-phase IEF unit
2. Separation and purification of small molecules and peptides from Gymnema sylvestre extract
3. Separation and purification of proteins from C. albicans
4. Bioactivity of purified small molecules from plant extract Gymnema sylvestre
Separation and purification of small molecules and peptides from Gymnema sylvestre plant extract
Using the preparative liquid-phase IEF method, we fractionated medicinal plant extracts and cell surface proteins from a human pathogenic fungus, C. albicans. A schematic of these fractionation protocols is shown in Figure 1.
From 20 fractions of G. sylvestre extract obtained from liquid-phase IEF, the dark-colored molecules (terpenoid saponins) were found to migrate and be enriched at the anode end (pH 2-3) and the light-yellow clear fractions were observed at the cathode end (pH 8-9) (Figure 2). Aliquots (20 μL) from each fraction (1-20) were resolved on 15% SDS-PAGE after reducing and boiling the samples. A Coomassie blue-stained gel shows the diffused polypeptide band of about 5 kDa that is enriched in fractions 16-19 (Figure 3). It has been reported that the G. sylvestre plant contains a 35 amino acid gurmarin basic polypeptide with the predicted molecular weight of 4,209 Da20. Bacteria, plants and animals contain peptides; many of them are circular (knottins) and stable with wide range of biological activities such as insecticidal and antimicrobial properties21,22.
Biological activity of separated gymnemic acids
The G. sylvestre plant also contains gymnemic acids (terpenoid saponins) as major constituents16,23,24. As expected, these small molecules in fraction 1 and the next few fractions were not detected by SDS-PAGE and Coomassie staining (Figure 3) since they are non-proteinaceous. However, these small molecules can be separated by TLC and detected under UV light (Figure 4A, lane F1). Fraction 10 did not contain a detectable amount of these small molecules on TLC suggesting most of the organic small molecules were enriched in fractions 1-3. Gymnemic acids (GAs) molecules were shown to inhibit C. albicans yeast-to-hypha transition16,25. We assayed all 20 fractions collected in this study for their inhibitory activity against C. albicans yeast-to-hypha conversion and hyphal growth16. The results are shown in Figure 4B,4C. The highest activity is observed in fraction 1, which agrees with the TLC results where several spots can be seen. Isomers of gymnemic acids exist and all have similar biological activities10. These isomers were separated in fraction 1-3 and show inhibition of C. albicans hyphal growth (Figure 4A,4C, fraction 1). The degree of hyphal inhibition was gradually decreased as it goes from 1 to 10. Little or no activity was obtained in fractions 10 and above.
Separation of cell surface proteins from pathogenic fungus, C. albicans
Results from liquid-phase IEF fractionation of C. albicans cell surface proteins are shown in Figure 5. These cell surface proteins play important roles in C. albicans adhesion and pathogenesis26. Several enriched proteins (arrows) in different fractions were observed. This may allow identification of their immunological reactions with Candida infected human serum and/or their identification by mass spectrometry. Similarly, proteins from other cellular fractions (e.g., cytoplasm and cell wall) can be fractionated using this IEF method. The liquid-phase IEF-based purification will allow identification of low abundance proteins from complex biological samples, when coupled with mass spectrometry analysis.
Figure 1: Flow chart showing the experimental workflow. Stepwise liquid-phase IEF fractionation procedures and subsequent downstream assays are depicted. Samples include Gymnema sylvestre leaf extract (sample 1) and Candida albicans non-glucan attached yeast proteins (sample 2). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Liquid-phase IEF apparatus setup and fractionation of G. sylvestre plant extract. (A) During the run, (B) during fraction collection, (C) after fraction collection, and (D) liquid-phase IEF apparatus parts, 1) ion exchange membranes, 2) focusing chamber and membrane core, 3) electrode assembly (negative), 4) electrode assembly (positive). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: SDS-PAGE separations of the IEF focused plant extract fractions. L- ladder, PC- Positive control (peptide), 0 – input sample, 1-20 separated fractions. SDS-PAGE (15% resolving gel) was stained by Coomassie blue dye to visualize the resolved peptides (~5 kDa) from fractions 1-20. Fractions 1-3 contain small molecules (fraction 1 has darker color indicating enriched compounds) which cannot be stained/detected by Coomassie blue dye. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Analysis of IEF fractionated small molecules by TLC and determination of bioactivity against C. albicans. (A) Shows TLC analysis of small molecules from fraction #1 and #10. Activated silica gel plate was used to spot ~5 µL of samples and ran with toluene: chloroform: methanol solvent (5:8:3 ratio) until the solvent front reached the margin. TLC separated compounds were detected under an epifluorescence UV light (310 nm). (B) Shows the % inhibition of C. albicans yeast-to-hypha conversion by different fractions. (C) Demonstrates the cell morphology of C. albicans under hypha inducing conditions. Fraction #1 shows maximum (98%) inhibition of yeast-to-hypha conversion. Other fractions and controls show no inhibition of C. albicans hyphal growth after 12 hours of incubation at 37 °C. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: SDS-PAGE analysis of C. albicans cell surface proteins (non-glucan attached). L- ladder, 0 – input sample, 1-18 fractions collected after IEF in a standard liquid-phase IEF cell using a narrow range (pH 5-8) ampholyte. The image shows SDS-PAGE (12.5%) resolved proteins after staining with Coomassie blue dye. Several proteins were enriched in certain fractions (arrows). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Small molecules from natural product sources (e.g., plants) include complex secondary metabolites that are highly diverse in chemical structure. They are believed to be involved in plant defense mechanisms. In addition, polypeptides are also present in plant tissues22. These natural product small molecules are rich sources of test molecules for drug discovery and development. However, the difficult and tedious methods required for their isolation and purification limit their use for therapeutic applications. The liquid-phase IEF approach used in this report highlights the ability to separate these small molecules and polypeptides without compromising their bioactivities.
This IEF based method offers several advantages in separating biological molecules including concentration of purified proteins from a complex mixture, maintenance of native conformation during and after their focusing, and collection of samples as individual purified fractions without cross-contamination. When necessary, samples can be re-focused with a narrow pH range to purify protein isoforms. Since a miniature IEF focusing cell (~15 mL) is available, it can be used for smaller volumes of samples as well. The new finding from this report is that organic small molecules and peptides can be separated from a complex plant extract. Though it is difficult to agree that small molecules can be separated from natural product extracts by IEF, it is plausible for those compounds that are amphoteric. The gymnemic acids that were separated from the gurmarin peptide in the G. sylvestre extract appear to be amphoteric as they contain a carboxylic acid group or they behave so at least in the presence of the ampholyte used. Since glycosides are bioactive natural molecules similar to gymnemic acids, the IEF method can be used to separate them from complex natural sources. Similarly, peptides from natural products may also be isolated using this liquid-phase IEF approach.
Some of the limitations in this approach are that not all small molecules can be fractionated by the IEF method as they must be water-soluble and weakly amphoteric, at least. The extract used here was prepared by a 50% methanol extraction of dried plant material but is water-soluble. The use of the IEF method for solvent-soluble and amphoteric compounds remains to be seen as some of the organic solvents are incompatible with the liquid-phase IEF instrument components. The tendency of proteins to precipitate at their isoelectric points (pI) in low ionic strength solutions is well known. However, in a rotating IEF system, protein precipitation is reduced as the focused proteins remain in circulation at their pI point.
If one uses a high concentration of proteins in this IEF separation, precipitation may occur. To minimize protein precipitation and to improve protein focusing, urea can be used up to 3-5 M. Nonionic detergents such as CHAPS, digitonin and low concentration of detergents (0.1-1%) can also be used to reduce protein aggregation during IEF. However, urea and detergents need to be removed before analyzing the proteins for their activity and in some cases, these agents may affect protein functions. A few critical steps to consider during a liquid-phase IEF run include loading the IEF focusing cell without air bubbles, replacing the ion exchange membranes if they were damaged, and replacing the vent buttons after a certain number of repeated uses.
In conclusion, using the liquid-phase IEF method, we have shown the separation of bioactive gymnemic acids and gurmarin polypeptide from the G. sylvestre leaf extract. Further, liquid-phase IEF can be useful to enrich selective proteins from the complex crude extracts of pathogenic microbes.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
We are thankful for the funding sources from the Division of Biology and Johnson Cancer Research Center for BRIEF and IRA awards, respectively to GV. We also thank the K-INBRE postdoctoral award to RV. This work was supported in part by the Institutional Development Award (IDeA) from the National Institute of General Medical Sciences of the National Institutes of Health under grant number P20 GM103418. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institute of General Medical Sciences or the National Institutes of Health. We thank the anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments.
0.45 µm syringe filter | Fisher scientfic | 09-720-004 | |
2-Mercaptoethanol | Sigma | M3148 | |
Ammonium carbonate | Sigma-Aldrich | 207861-500 | |
Bio-Lyte 3/10 Ampholyte | Bio-Rad | 163-1113 | |
Bio-Lyte 5/8 Ampholyte | Bio-Rad | 163-1192 | |
Compact low temperature thermostat | Lauda -Brinkmann | RM 6T | Set water cooling to 4 oC and it can be run even at 0 oC as when it passes through the Rotofor cooling core, the circulating water temperature will be around 5 or more depending on the voltage. |
Coomassie Brilliant Blue R | Sigma-Aldrich | B7920 | |
Dialysis tubing (3,500 MWCO) | Spectrum Spectra/Por | 132112T | |
Gymnema plant leaf extract powder (>25% Gymnemic acids) | Suan Farma, NJ USA | ||
Incubator | Lab companion | SI 300R | |
Microscope | Leica | DM 6B | |
Mini protean electrophoresis | Bio-Rad | ||
pH meter | Mettler Toledo | S20 | Useful to determine the pH of the Rotofor (liquid-phase IEF) fractions |
Rotofor | Bio-Rad | 170-2972 | http://www.bio-rad.com/webroot/web/pdf/lsr/literature/M1702950E.pdf (Rotofor Instruction manual for assembling the unit) |
RPMI-1640 Medium | HyClone | DH30255.01 | |
Sealing tape | Bio-Rad | 170-2960 | Scotch tape may also be used. |
Sorvall legend micro 17 centrifuge | Thermo scientific | 75002432 | |
TPP tissue culture plate -96 well flat bottom | TPP | TP92696 |