Quick and accurate chemical assays to screen for specific inhibitors are an important tool in the drug development arsenal. Here, we present a scalable acetyl-click chemistry assay to measure the inhibition of HAT1 acetylation activity.
HAT1, also known as Histone acetyltransferase 1, plays a crucial role in chromatin synthesis by stabilizing and acetylating nascent H4 before nucleosome assembly. It is required for tumor growth in various systems, making it a potential target for cancer treatment. To facilitate the identification of compounds that can inhibit HAT1 enzymatic activity, we have devised an acetyl-click assay for rapid screening. In this simple assay, we employ recombinant HAT1/Rbap46, which is purified from activated human cells. The method utilizes the acetyl-CoA analog 4-pentynoyl-CoA (4P) in a click-chemistry approach. This involves the enzymatic transfer of an alkyne handle through a HAT1-dependent acylation reaction to a biotinylated H4 N-terminal peptide. The captured peptide is then immobilized on neutravidin plates, followed by click-chemistry functionalization with biotin-azide. Subsequently, streptavidin-peroxidase recruitment is employed to oxidize amplex red, resulting in a quantitative fluorescent output. By introducing chemical inhibitors during the acylation reaction, we can quantify enzymatic inhibition based on a reduction of the fluorescence signal. Importantly, this reaction is scalable, allowing for high throughput screening of potential inhibitors for HAT1 enzymatic activity.
Among the numerous eukaryotic acetyltransferases, HAT1 was the initial histone acetyltransferase to be isolated1,2,3. Subsequent investigations have firmly established its pivotal role in chromatin replication, particularly in the synthesis of new nucleosomes during S-phase4. Our research endeavors led to the recognition that HAT1 is highly stimulated by epidermal growth factor (EGF) treatment in mammary cells5. Furthermore, it has come to light that HAT1 is required for rapid cell proliferation and tumor formation in vivo6,7,8,9. Data indicate that HAT1 is critical in coordinating anabolic and epigenetic processes for cell division, driving tumor growth.
HAT1 di-acetylates the amino-terminal tail of histone H4 on lysines 5 and 12 in complex with the chaperone protein Rbap46, which binds the histone and presents the amino-terminus to HAT1. Histone tetramers or disomes10, together with HAT1/Rbap46 and other histone chaperones11, are then imported to the nucleus. Histones are then released to be deposited at the replication fork, or other sites to support gene activation or repression. The function of the HAT1 di-acetylation mark on histone H4 is not fully understood. It is likely quickly removed within a span of 15-30 min by the action of histone deacetylases12,13,14,15 after H4 is inserted into chromatin. Thus, the HAT1 di-acetylation mark is not propagated in chromatin and may not serve a true epigenetic role, although a role in the recruitment of chromatin-modifying enzymes to nascent chromatin has been postulated12. Also, HAT1 does not directly acetylate chromatin; its activity is restricted to soluble histones.
The development of small-molecule histone acetyltransferase inhibitors has been hampered by nonspecific and low-throughput assays, often resulting in the generation of biologically reactive compounds16,17. The gold-standard assay to measure acetyltransferase activities requires the use of 3H-acetyl-coA, which limits throughput and requires radiation. Nonetheless, recently, specific and highly potent small molecule acetyltransferase inhibitors targeting CBP/p30018 and KAT6A/B19,20 have been described and confirmed through the use of 3H-acetyl-CoA. Moving forward, improved assays to achieve better throughput and avoid laboratory hazards are being devised.
Recent advances in acetylation monitoring21 have used click chemistry to enable enzymatic reaction monitoring. There are a variety of click-enabled precursors that are accessible by simple synthetic routes or available for purchase that can be incorporated into enzyme reactions. These reactions are typically carried out in recombinant systems, although cell-based assays are also feasible22. The advantage of click-enabled co-factors and substrates is that screening can directly measure enzyme activity without the need for coupled read-out systems that are often perturbed by screening compounds and require additional handling steps. This allows for inhibitor treatments only during the enzymatic step, whereas all downstream functionalization and detection steps are carried out after extensive washing to remove compounds, thus limiting the potential for assay interference to occur. These advantages make the design of click-enabled assays preferable to coupled assays that commonly rely on the detection of free coenzyme A.
One important consideration is the acceptance of click-enabled co-factors into the enzyme active site. Existing click-enabled co-factors may not be fully compatible with the active site optimized for the native co-factor. Structural information and modeling can be used to design amino acid substitutions to enlarge the active site to incorporate altered substrates23. This may enable screening with improved enzyme kinetics and lower substrate and enzyme levels. The drawback of this approach is that altered catalytic pockets may not identify inhibitors that interact strongly with the native enzyme. Ultimately, a combination of approaches is required to identify and validate potential enzyme inhibitors.
Here, we describe a method developed to purify and assay HAT1 enzyme activity using the click co-factor 4-pentynoyl-CoA24. This assay (Figure 1) uses the native enzyme sequence in complex with its required partner protein Rbap46, which has been shown to boost enzyme activity. Purification of the enzyme from human cells allows for enzyme activation in cellulo, which may preserve stimulating post-translational modifications important for full enzyme activity. Design and optimization of recombinant enzyme assays for high-throughput chemical screens have successfully been used to identify and characterize HAT1 small molecule inhibitors.
1. Method 1: Producing and purifying recombinant HAT1/Rbap46 complex
2. Method 2: HAT1 acetyl-click standard curve
3. Method 3: HAT1 acetyl-click assay
Standard curves in duplicate (16 wells) should be included on every plate to ensure proper assay performance. Standard curve data should be set up in table form, with a range of 100% to 0% according to the ratio of Pra-containing peptide to native H4 peptide in solution (Table 1). Amplex red signal will be the highest in 100% pra/0% native H4 peptide wells, and lowest in 0% pra/100% native H4 peptide wells. After fluorescence has been detected and wells are averaged, the resulting standards graph should fit a straight line (Figure 2), although saturation of signal at concentrations above 50% Pra can be observed. Improper mixing of Pra to H4 control peptides may result in little to no amplex red signal or nonlinear changes in amplex red signal between 0-50% Pra. Proper signal and curve results indicate that the click chemistry reaction has occurred, and the data can be analyzed accordingly.
It is important to always include triplicate control reactions: DMSO-treated reactions serve as negative controls, and H4K12CoA-treated reactions serve as positive controls for enzyme inhibition, respectively. These should be included on every plate to ensure robust assay performance and allow for Percent Inhibition calculations. Positive control wells that contain 1 µM of H4K12CoA should have a low amplex red signal, which is similar to the 0% Pra/100% H4 peptide wells. Negative control wells containing DMSO should have a signal that is similar to the fluorescent output of wells with 50% Pra/50% H4 peptide. Test compound wells will contain varying amplex signals. Average duplicate, or triplicate, wells to get a mean value of the signal with standard error.
Calculate enzyme inhibition with the formula above where D is the DMSO fluorescent output, X is the experimental output, and BG is the output from the H4 peptide without enzyme or the 0% well on the standard curve. Fluorescence output from the test compound reactions will be less than DMSO if the test compound inhibits enzyme activity and will result in positive inhibition percent values. The opposite effect will be seen in reactions where no enzyme inhibition has occurred. Example data of test compounds screened at two concentrations (1 µM and 10 µM) are depicted in Figure 3. Serial dilutions of the compounds can also be tested using this assay, where the IC50 of the compound can be found with non-linear curve fitting of the data (Figure 4).
Figure 1: HAT1 acetylation/acylation click chemistry schematic. The HAT1 Acetylation click reaction occurs with purified HAT1 and Rbap46 protein in a solution with biotinylated histone H4 peptide, 4-pentynoyl-CoA, and test compounds. After reactions are completed, the solution is bound to a neutravidin-coated plate, and click chemistry with copper sulfate and biotin-azide is completed. The final addition of streptavidin-HRP and amplex red results in red fluorescent output. Comparison of amplex red fluorescence intensities determines HAT1 acetylation activity. This figure has been modified with permission from Gaddameedi et al.24. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Example standard curve. After averaging the standard curve values for each pair, graph the means ± SEM against the positive control Pra peptide percentages. The resulting curve should resemble the shown curve and fit a linear line. This assay has a limit of detection (LOD) of 1.8% ± 0.89% and a limit of quantitation (LOQ) of 5.4% ± 3.1%24. The standard curve may saturate for Pra percentages >50%. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Testing new compounds in triplicate. Acetyl-click assay was used to assess the inhibitory activity of newly synthesized compounds. Compounds were diluted to 10 µM and 1 µM for testing in triplicate, with median indicated. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Serial dilution of test compounds in HAT1 acetyl click assay. Compounds were diluted from 100 µM to 0.01 µM and tested in duplicate. The resulting dose curves show that compounds A and C inhibit HAT1 activity by nearly 100% for several dilutions. Data were then used to calculate IC50 of compounds to be used in further experiments. Data are mean ± SEM of duplicate experiments. R2 values for nonlinear fits are 0.84, 0.78, and 0.94 for compounds A, B, and C, respectively. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
% Positive Control | Positive Control Peptide [2.5 rxns] “pra” diluted to 0.1 mg/mL in DMSO (alkyne-containing) | H4 Peptide [2.5 rxns] diluted to 0.1 mg/mL in DMSO |
100 | 2.5 µL | - |
75 | 1.875 µL | 0.625 µL |
50 | 1.25 µL | 1.25 µL |
25 | 0.625 µL | 1.875 µL |
10 | 1 µL | 9 µL |
5 | 1.25 µL (of 1:10) | 1.25 µL |
1 | 1 µL (of 1:10) | 9 µL |
0 | - | 2.5 µL |
Total | 8.5 µL | 25.5 µL |
Table 1: Dilution of Pra control peptide to H4 peptide. Ratios of positive control "Pra" peptide to H4 peptide that are used to create a standard curve. After Pra stock is initially resuspended at 4 mg/mL in DMSO, it must be diluted 1:40 in DMSO to a final concentration of 0.1 mg/mL. Biotinylated H4 peptide must also be diluted to 0.1 mg/mL (34.8 µM) in DMSO. Then, each peptide should be mixed together in the shown proportions. Each standard will be added in duplicate to the 96-well plate. Fluorescence output values should be averaged together to create the standard curve.
In the past decade, click chemistry became prominent20, enabling the precise design of interacting chemical structures. Within this context, various bioorthogonal covalent connections21 have emerged as promising options for forming complexes in their natural environment. Click chemistry employs pairs of functional groups that exhibit rapid and selective reactions, commonly known as "click reactions." These reactions occur efficiently in environmentally friendly, gentle aqueous conditions. Here, we present the development of a platform designed for identifying and characterizing HAT1 acetyltransferase activity24. This platform utilizes a high-throughput, peptide-based enzymatic assay enabled by click chemistry.
One of the key advantages of this assay is that it relies on the human HAT1/Rbap46 enzyme complex obtained from human cell purification rather than a bacterial source. Moreover, this method directly measures enzymatic activity on the peptide substrate, eliminating the need for coupled reactions that might be susceptible to nonspecific inhibition. While antibody-based methods are available for assessing enzyme activity21, the acetyl-click assay offers distinct advantages by avoiding biological variability and antibody-related costs. Furthermore, we have successfully validated its high-throughput capabilities in 96-well plates, making it feasible to conduct extensive chemical screens. The click chemistry approach can likely be adapted for use with other acetyltransferases as well. For example, recombinant acetyltransferases could be incubated with other histone peptides that mimic their natural substrates in combination with 4-pentynoyl-CoA to induce peptide acylation. Then the subsequent assay steps for peptide binding, functionalization, and amplex red oxidation could be quickly adapted. Care should be taken to design appropriate positive and negative controls for standard curves to allow for assay quantitation.
Certain limitations of the assay should be kept in mind. First, although this protocol has been optimized for HAT1, not all acetyltransferases may accept pentynoyl-CoA as an acetyl-CoA mimetic. Thus, the development of additional acyl-donor molecules could be considered26, or mutagenesis of the catalytic pocket may be required to allow acceptance of click-compatible co-factors27,28. Second, as affinity for click-enabled co-factors may differ from the natural co-factor, it is recommended to use secondary follow-up assays to confirm results, for example, antibody-based detection (see step 3.12). Finally, additional confirmatory enzymatic, biophysical, and cellular assays should be performed to confirm results. Small molecule binding to protein complexes can be confirmed by instruments that measure surface plasmon resonance, for example29.
There are a few critical steps to highlight to ensure the assay runs smoothly and the corresponding results are accurate. The exponential growth of 293f cells should be evident prior to and after DNA transfection to achieve good protein expression. Plasmids that yield high protein expression in transient transfection systems should be employed, for example, the pHEK-293 plasmid used here. HAT1 enzyme is activated by forskolin in this protocol, but similar results have been achieved with orthovanadate, suggesting post-translational modifications are necessary for HAT1 activity. We have observed that purified HAT1/Rbap46 enzyme preparations are relatively stable and can survive freeze/thaw cycles without loss of enzyme activity. However, we recommend freezing enzyme aliquots in small amounts. We do not typically use enzymes after more than one freeze/thaw cycle.
During the acetyl-click assay, it is important to always include triplicate control reactions: DMSO-treated reactions serve as negative controls, and H4K12CoA-treated reactions serve as positive controls for enzyme inhibition, respectively. DMSO-treated enzyme reaction fluorescence values should fall on the linear standard curve between 25 and 50 % positive Pra peptide to avoid signal saturation. This may require carefully titrating the amount of HAT1/Rbap46 enzyme in control reactions prior to drug testing. For example, the HAT1/Rbap46 enzyme can be diluted 1:1, 1:5, 1:10, 1:25, 1:50, 1:75, and 1:100 in EB, then used in acetyl-click reactions to determine the amount of enzyme required to generate signal between 25%-50% of Pra peptide. We have found that 100 nM enzyme is typically sufficient but should be determined empirically for each new preparation of enzyme. The purpose of mixing streptavidin-HRP with streptavidin is to decrease the amplex oxidation signal. The dilution of streptavidin can be adjusted to the output signal as needed. If a rapid signal is generated, it may be necessary to read the plate before 30 min to avoid signal saturation. During initial assay optimization, we suggest reading at 5 min, 15 min, and 30 min. Serial reads can be performed without influencing signal. If the assay is well calibrated the amplex red signals generated between 5 min and 30 min should scale linearly.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
We thank George Zheng for providing H4K12CoA. We thank members of the Gruber Lab for helpful discussions and feedback. We thank support from the NIH/NCI (1K08CA245024), CPRIT (RR200090, RP210041), and the V Foundation (V2022-022).
4P CoA | Cayman Chemical | 10547 | Click chemistry co-factor |
Amplex Red | Fisher Sci | A12222 | Fluorescence substrate |
Biotin-PEG-Azide | Alfa Aesar | J64996MC | Click chemistry |
Copper Sulfate | Sigma-aldrich | 7758-98-7 | Click chemistry |
DMSO | Fisher Scientific | 67-68-5 | diluent |
DTT | Acros Organics | 03-12-3483 | reducting agent |
Forskolin | VWR | 102987-310 | Protein expression |
Freestyle 293 Expression Medium | Thermo Fisher | 12338018 | Media |
Freestyle 293-F cells | Thermo Fisher | R790-07 | Protein expression |
H4-peptide/1-23-GGK-biotin | Anaspec | AS65097 | peptide substrate |
HEPES | Sigma-aldrich | 7365-45-9 | EB buffer |
Hydrogen peroxide 30% solution | Sigma-aldrich | Z00183-99-0 | initiator |
M2 FLAG antibody slurry | Millipore-Sigma | A2220 | Protein purification |
Macrosep 10K Filter (Pall Lab) | VWR | 89131-980 | Protein purification |
Neutravidin Plate | Thermo Sci | 15127 | BSA-pre-blocked |
NP40 (IGEPAL) | MP Biomedical | 198596 | 20x buffer |
pHEK-293 plasmid | Takara Bio | 3390 | Protein expression |
Phosphate Buffered Saline 10x | Alfa Aesar | Z00082-33-6 | wash buffer |
Pra peptide | Genscript | Custom synthesis | biotinylated |
Sodium Ascorbate | Sigma-aldrich | 134-03-2 | Click chemistry |
Sodium chloride | Sigma-aldrich | 7647-14-5 | EB buffer |
Sodium phosphate | VWR International | 7558-80-7 | buffer |
Streptavidin | EMD Millipore | 189730 | competitor |
Streptavidin-HRP | Cell Signaling | 3999S | enzyme |
THPTA ligand | Fisher Sci | 1010-500 | Click chemistry |
Tris base | Sigma-aldrich | 77-86-1 | 20x buffer |
Triton-X 100 | VWR International | 9002-93-1 | EB buffer |
Tween-20 | Sigma-aldrich | 9005-64-5 | Wash buffer |
Urea | Sigma-Aldrich | 57-13-6 | quencher |