The study describes a cost-effective method for the identification of the source of fecal/urine contamination or contamination by nitrates in water using qPCR for the specific quantification of human/porcine/bovine DNA viruses, adenoviruses and polyomaviruses, proposed as MST tools.
Microbial contamination of the environment represents a significant health risk. Classical bacterial fecal indicators have shown to have significant limitations, viruses are more resistant to many inactivation processes and standard fecal indicators do not inform on the source of contamination. The development of cost-effective methods for the concentration of viruses from water and molecular assays facilitates the applicability of viruses as indicators of fecal contamination and as microbial source tracking (MST) tools. Adenoviruses and polyomaviruses are DNA viruses infecting specific vertebrate species including humans and are persistently excreted in feces and/or urine in all geographical areas studied. In previous studies, we suggested the quantification of human adenoviruses (HAdV) and JC polyomaviruses (JCPyV) by quantitative PCR (qPCR) as an index of human fecal contamination. Recently, we have developed qPCR assays for the specific quantification of porcine adenoviruses (PAdV) and bovine polyomaviruses (BPyV) as animal fecal markers of contamination with sensitivities of 1-10 genome copies per test tube. In this study, we present the procedure to be followed to identify the source of contamination in water samples using these tools. As example of representative results, analysis of viruses in ground water presenting high levels of nitrates is shown.
Detection of viruses in low or moderately polluted waters requires the concentration of the viruses from at least several liters of water into a much smaller volume, a procedure that usually includes two concentration steps in series. This somewhat cumbersome procedure and the variability observed in viral recoveries significantly hamper the simultaneous processing of a large number of water samples.
In order to eliminate the bottleneck caused by the two-step procedures we have applied a one-step protocol developed in previous studies and applicable to a diversity of water matrices. The procedure includes: acidification of ten-liter water samples, flocculation by skimmed milk, gravity sedimentation of the flocculated materials, collection of the precipitate and centrifugation, resuspension of the precipitate in 10 ml phosphate buffer. The viral concentrate is used for the extraction of viral nucleic acids and the specific adenoviruses and polyomaviruses of interest are quantified by qPCR. High number of samples may be simultaneously analyzed using this low-cost concentration method.
The procedure has been applied to the analysis of bathing waters, seawater and river water and in this study, we present results analyzing groundwater samples. This high-throughput quantitative method is reliable, straightforward, and cost-effective.
1. Concentration of the viral particles present in water samples
2. Nucleic acid extraction
3. Quantitative PCR of human adenoviruses (HAdV), JC polyomaviruses (JCPyV), porcine adenoviruses (PAdV) and bovine polyomaviruses (BPyV)
Following the procedure described, human and animal viruses have been detected and quantified in bathing waters, seawater and river water2,3. As a representative example, ground water samples from areas presenting high levels of nitrates were evaluated to define the sources of the contamination. Ten-liter water samples were collected from 4 different wells in rural areas of a Northeast region in Spain. Five replicates were collected in each well being one replicate seeded with human adenovirus 2 used as process control. Samples were processed according to the protocol represented in Figure 1. The four replicates analyzed in one of the four sites studied showed positive results for PAdV (mean value 7.74×102 GC/L) which would be related to the presence of pig slurries in the areas surrounding the sampling site and would support fecal porcine contamination as the source of nitrates in groundwater (Table 2).
4. Representative Results:
Figure 1. Procedure for the detection and quantification of viruses in water.
Table 1. Concentration of primers and probes for qPCR assays.
Table 2. Detection and quantification of animal and human adenoviruses and polyomaviruses in ground water samples.
n number of replicates analyzed
% percentage of positive replicates
(-) non detected
The procedure described would fulfill the conditions for a fitting method for routine environmental and public health laboratories: reproducible, reliable, straightforward and cost-effective. The protocol is simple; however it must be followed carefully. Low conductivity in the samples without adding the requested concentration of artificial seawater salts would dramatically reduce the recovery of viruses as would be the case if the stirring time for flocculation is significantly reduced (less than 5 hours for example).
Currently applied MST tools are generally based on molecular techniques. Studies developed by different groups have shown that out of the currently used parameters (i.e. bacterial genes) none is as specific as needed. Thus the use of a combination of these parameters has been suggested as the best approximation for an efficient tracking of the origin of fecal contamination in water bodies8,11.
In recent years, the study of the selected DNA viruses that produce in many cases persistent infections in absence of clinical symptoms, has emerged as a method for source-tracking fecal contamination in the environment. Quantitative PCR techniques and the concentration method proposed provide reliable values of the concentration of these viruses and very valuable data for the development of risk-assessment studies and remediation actions. These techniques are also highly sensitive and specific, which is an absolute requirement for tracking the source of contamination. Also, they will be a very useful tool for the generation of larger data bases for the quantitative characterization of the excretion and dissemination of the specific viruses proposed as microbial source-tracking tools in diverse geographical areas.
The procedure described allows the analysis of multiple samples simultaneously in about 48 hours without intensive labor requirements. The availability of an efficient low-cost concentration method support the applicability of HAdV and JCPyV, and PAdV and BPyV in water as cost-effective assays for quantitative microbial source-tracking studies and identification of the origin of contaminants in ground water.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was partially supported by the Spanish Government “Ministerio de Educación y Ciencia” (project AGL2008-05275-C01/ALI), by the European Union Research Framework 7 funded projects VIROBATHE (Contract No. 513648), VIROCLIME (Contract No. 243923) and by the Catalan Agency of Water, Agència Catalana de l’Aigua (ACA), Departament de Control i Millora dels Ecosistemes Aquàtics. During the developed study Marta Rusiñol was a fellow of the Catalan Government “AGAUR” (FI-DGR).
Name of the reagent | Company | Catalogue number | Comments |
High speed centrifuge (8,000xg) | Berckman Coulter | Avanti J-20XP | |
pH-meter, thermometer and conductimeter | Afora | LPPC3003 | |
Plastic tubes 100-200 cm length | Deltalab | 350059 | |
Sterile graduated disposable pipettes | Labclinics | PN10E1 | |
Sterile plastic tubes of 1.5 and 10-15 mL (Eppendorf, Falcons, etc.) | Afora | KA298/00 | |
Centrifuge pots (500 mL) | Fisher Scientific | SE5753512 | |
Magnetic stirrers and magnets (one per sample) | Fisher Scientific | 10510 | |
Glass or plastic containers having flat bottoms to allow the use of magnetic stirrers | Deltalab | 191642 | |
A peristaltic pump for removing the supernatant (or a water-jet vacuum pump) | Watson-Marlow | 323E/D | |
Timer to switch-off the stirring after 8-10 hours | Deltalab | 900400 | |
Hydrochloric acid (1N and 0.1N) | Panreac | 141020.1611 | |
Sodium hydroxide (1N) | Panreac | 131687.1211 | |
Artificial seawater sea salts | Sigma | S9883 | |
Skimmed milk (SM) | Difco | 232100 | |
Phosphate buffer pH 7,5 | 1:2 v/v of sterile Na2HPO4 0,2M and NaH2PO4 0,2M at pH 7.5 | ||
Thiosulphate | Panreac | 121879.1209 | Make a 10% solution in water |
QIAamp Viral RNA Mini Kit | Qiagen | 52904 | |
96-well optical reaction plate (500 units) | Applied Biosystems | 43426659 | |
Optical adhesive covers (100 units) | Applied Biosystems | 4311971 | |
TaqMan Environmental PCR Master Mix 2x | Applied Biosystems | 4396838 |