Natural Product Discovery with LC-MS/MS Diagnostic Fragmentation Filtering: Application for Microcystin Analysis

David  R. McMullin; Shawn Hoogstra; Kimberlynn  P. McDonald; Mark  W. Sumarah; Justin  B. Renaud

doi:10.3791/59712

JoVE Journal > Chemistry

Química

Natural Product Discovery with LC-MS/MS Diagnostic Fragmentation Filtering: Application for Microcystin Analysis

Published: May 31, 2019

doi:

10.3791/59712

David R. McMullin¹, Shawn Hoogstra², Kimberlynn P. McDonald¹, Mark W. Sumarah^1,2, Justin B. Renaud²

¹Department of Chemistry,Carleton University Ottawa, ²London Research and Development Center,Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada

Summary

Diagnostic fragmentation filtering, implemented into MZmine, is an elegant, post-acquisition approach to screen LC-MS/MS datasets for entire classes of both known and unknown natural products. This tool searches MS/MS spectra for product ions and/or neutral losses that the analyst has defined as being diagnostic for the entire class of compounds.

Abstract

Natural products are often biosynthesized as mixtures of structurally similar compounds, rather than a single compound. Due to their common structural features, many compounds within the same class undergo similar MS/MS fragmentation and have several identical product ions and/or neutral losses. The purpose of diagnostic fragmentation filtering (DFF) is to efficiently detect all compounds of a given class in a complex extract by screening non-targeted LC-MS/MS datasets for MS/MS spectra that contain class specific product ions and/or neutral losses. This method is based on a DFF module implemented within the open-source MZmine platform that requires sample extracts be analyzed by data-dependent acquisition on a high-resolution mass spectrometer such as quadrupole Orbitrap or quadrupole time-of-flight mass analyzers. The main limitation of this approach is the analyst must first define which product ions and/or neutral losses are specific for the targeted class of natural products. DFF allows for the subsequent discovery of all related natural products within a complex sample, including new compounds. In this work, we demonstrate the effectiveness of DFF by screening extracts of Microcystis aeruginosa, a prominent harmful algal bloom causing cyanobacteria, for the production of microcystins.

Introduction

Tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) is a widely used mass spectrometry method that involves isolating a precursor ion and inducing fragmentation via application of activation energy such as collision induced dissociation (CID)¹. The manner in which an ion fragments is intimately linked to its molecular structure. Natural products are often biosynthesized as mixtures of structurally similar compounds rather than as a single unique chemical². As such, structurally related compounds that are part of the same biosynthetic class often share key MS/MS fragmentation characteristics, including shared product ions and/or neutral losses. The ability to screen complex samples for compounds that possess class-specific product ions and/or neutral losses is a powerful strategy to detect entire classes of compounds, potentially leading to the discovery of new natural products³^,⁴^,⁵^,⁶. For decades, mass spectrometry methods such as neutral loss scanning and precursor ion scanning performed on low resolution instruments have allowed ions with the same neutral loss or product ions to be detected. However, the specific ions or transitions needed to be defined prior to performing the experiments. As high-resolution mass spectrometers have become more popular in research laboratories, complex samples are now commonly screened using non-targeted, data-dependent acquisition (DDA) methods. In contrast to traditional neutral loss and precursor ion scanning, structurally related compounds can be identified by post-acquisition analysis⁷. In this work, we demonstrate a strategy we have developed termed diagnostic fragmentation filtering (DFF)⁵^,⁶, a straight-forward and user-friendly approach to detect entire classes of compounds within complex matrices. This DFF module has been implemented into the open-source, MZmine 2 platform and available by downloading MZmine 2.38 or newer releases. DFF allows users to efficiently screen DDA datasets for MS/MS spectra which contain product ion(s) and/or neutral loss(es) that are diagnostic for entire classes of compounds. A limitation of DFF is characteristic product ions and/or neutral losses for a class of compounds must be defined by the analyst.

For example, each of the more than 60 different fumonisin mycotoxins identified⁸^,⁹ possess a tricarballylic side chain, that generates a m/z 157.0142 (C₆H₅O₅^–) product ion upon fragmentation of the [M-H]^– ion⁴. Therefore, all putative fumonisins in a sample can be detected using DFF by screening all MS/MS spectra within a DDA dataset that contain the prominent m/z 157.0142 product ion. Similarly, sulfated compounds can be detected by screening DDA datasets for MS/MS spectra that contain a diagnostic neutral loss of 79.9574 Da (SO₃)³. This approach has also been successfully applied for detecting new cyclic peptides⁵ and natural products that contain tryptophan or phenylalanine residues⁶.

To demonstrate the effectiveness of DFF and its ease of use within the MZmine platform¹⁰, we have applied this approach to the analysis of microcystins (MCs); a class of over 240 structurally related toxins produced by freshwater cyanobacteria¹¹^,¹²^,¹³.

The most commonly reported cyanotoxins are MCs, with the MC-LR (leucine [L]/arginine [R]) congener most frequently studied (Figure 1). MCs are monocyclic non-ribosomal heptapeptides, biosynthesized by multiple cyanobacteria genera including Microcystis, Anabaena, Nostoc, and Planktothrix¹²^,¹³. MCs are composed of five common residues and two variable positions occupied by L-amino acids. Nearly all MCs possess a characteristic β-amino acid 3-amino-9-methoxy-2,6,8-trimethyl-10-phenyldeca-4,6-dienoic acid (Adda) residue at position 5¹¹. The MS/MS fragmentation pathways of MCs are well described¹⁴^,¹⁵; the Adda residue is responsible for the prominent MS/MS product ion, m/z 135.0803⁺ (C₉H₁₁O⁺) as well as other product ions including m/z 163.1114⁺ (C₁₁H₁₅O⁺) (Figure 2). Non-targeted DDA datasets of Microcystis aeruginosa cellular extracts can be screened for all microcystins present using these diagnostic ions, granted that the microcystins have an Adda residue.

Protocol

1. Preparation of non-targeted liquid chromatography (LC)-MS/MS datasets

NOTE: DFF can be performed using any high-resolution mass spectrometer and analytical method optimized for a target class of analytes. MC optimized LC-MS/MS conditions on Orbitrap mass spectrometer are listed in the Table of Materials.

Downloading MZmine 2 (http://mzmine.github.io/)
NOTE: Example data CPCC300.raw can be found at https://drive.google.com/open?id=1HHbLdvxCMycSasyNXPRqIe5pkaSqQoS0.
1. Under the Raw data methods drop down menu, select the Raw data import option.
2. Choose the data file(s) to be analyzed. Single or multiple files may be imported.
(Optional) If vendor data format is not supported by MZmine, use Proteowizard¹⁶ to generate centroided .mzml data files.
1. Choose the Peak Picking filter to apply vendor-supplied centroiding algorithm.

2. Diagnostic fragmentation filtering of imported DDA files

Using the cursor, select and highlight the data file(s) in the Raw data files column of the main MZmine screen.
Under the Visualization drop down menu, select the Diagnostic fragmentation filtering option.
In the DFF dialogue box that appears (Figure 3), input the following options:
1. Retention time – use Auto range or define the range of retention times in minutes when the targeted class of analytes will elute.
2. Precursor m/z – use Auto range or define the m/z range of the targeted class of analytes, including the possibility for multiple charged compounds when appropriate.
3. m/z tolerance – Input the achievable MS/MS mass accuracy of the MSinstrument; 0.01 m/z or 3.0 ppm is appropriate for an Orbitrap platform. If only diagnostic product ions will be investigated, input 0.0 into the Diagnostic neutral loss value (Da) option. Conversely, if only diagnostic neutral losses will be investigated, input 0.0 into the Diagnostic product ions (m/z) option.
4. Diagnostic product ions (m/z) – Input the class specific product ion(s) m/z. Separate multiple product ions with a comma.
  NOTE: Inputting multiple product ions will visualize spectra that contain all listed product ions.
5. Diagnostic neutral loss value (Da) – Input the class specific neutral loss(es). Separate multiple neutral losses with a comma.
  NOTE: Inputting multiple neutral losses will visualize spectra that contain all listed neutral losses. Inputting both diagnostic product ions and neutrals losses will visualize spectra that satisfy all the criteria.
6. Minimum diagnostic ion intensity (% base peak) – As a % of the base peak of the MS/MS spectra, define the minimum intensity for diagnostic product ions and/or neutral losses to be considered.
7. Peaklist output file – Select a path and filename to output the results.
8. Click the OK button to start the DFF analysis. A DFF plot will appear upon successfully completing the above steps
  NOTE: Two .csv data files will be generated. {Peaklist output file}.csv contains the precursor m/z, scan numbers, and retention times of the scans. This can be used in existing MZmine modules including Raw data methods > Peak detection > Targeted peak detection to generate extracted ion chromatograms of precursors that met the defined DFF criteria. {Peaklist output file}_data.csv contains the precursor m/z, product ion m/z and retention times to allow generation of DFF plots outside of MZmine.

3. Example use of DFF for microcystin analysis

Sample preparation
1. Sterilize 250 mL Erlenmeyer flasks containing 30 mL of sterile MA media¹⁷ or other cyanobacteria growth media (BG-11) fitted with a foam stopper.
2. Inoculate sterilized growth media with a cyanobacteria culture to approximately 5 × 10⁵ cells mL^-1 under aseptic conditions. Monitor cell density with a hemocytometer. In this example, grow M. aeruginosa strain CPCC300 photoautotrophically at 27 °C, illuminated with cool white fluorescent light (30 µE m^-2 s^-1) using a 12 h light: 12 h dark regime. Swirl the cells once per day.
3. Separate the cells from the culture medium after 26 days by vacuum filtration using 47 mm diameter GF/C glass microfiber filter papers.
4. Add 3 mL of 80% methanol _(aq) to harvested cells in 14 mL test tube(s).
5. Vortex and subsequently sonicate the test tube(s) containing cyanobacteria cells for 30 s each. Store the test tube(s) at -20 °C for 1 h. Return the test tube to room temperature and allow the sample(s) to thaw for 15 min.
6. Repeat step 3.1.5 two additional times to effectively lyse the cells.
7. Filter the resulting cyanobacteria cell extract(s) through a 0.22 μm PTFE syringe filter(s).
8. Dry extract(s) with an evaporator at a temperature of 30 °C using a gentle stream of nitrogen gas. Store the extract dry at -20 °C until LC-MS/MS analysis.
9. Reconstitute the dried residue with 500 µL of 90% methanol _(aq)and vortex for 30 s in an amber HPLC vial prior to analysis.
Analyze the cyanobacteria extract using a DDA acquisition method on a high-resolution mass spectrometer.
NOTE: The optimized LC-MS conditions for MC analysis used here are listed in Table of Materials.
Prepare the DDA datafile(s) and import into MZmine following steps 1.1 and 1.2.
Select the datafiles and start the DFF modules following steps 2.1-2.2.
For MC analysis, use the following settings within the DFF module (Figure 3).
1. Retention time – Input the range of 2.00 para 6.00 min.
2. Precursor m/z – Input m/z range of 430.00 para 1200.00.
3. m/z tolerance – Apply m/z tolerance of 0.01 m/z or 3.0 ppm.
4. Diagnostic product ions (m/z) – Input m/z of 135.0803, 163.1114 as the diagnostic product ions
5. Diagnostic neutral loss value (Da) – Input 0.0 to define that no diagnostic neutral losses are being used.
6. Minimum diagnostic ion intensity (% base peak) – Use 15.00 as the minimum intensity threshold
7. Peaklist output file – Define the output file as putative_MCs.csv.
Click the OK button to start the DFF analysis. A DFF plot (Figure 4) will appear upon successfully completing the above steps

Representative Results

The DFF plot generated following the analysis of M. aeruginosa CPCC300 is shown in Figure 4. The x-axis of this plot is the m/z of the precursor ions that satisfied the defined DFF criteria while the y-axis shows the m/z of all product ions within the MCs MS/MS spectra. For this analysis, the criteria for MC detection included precursor ions within the m/z range of 440-1200, retention times between 2.00–6.00 min. Most importantly, these MS/MS spectra contain both m/z 135.0803 and 163.1114 (± 3 ppm) above the defined 15% basepeak intensity threshold. Under these conditions, a total of 4116 MS/MS spectra were acquired during the LC-MS/MS DDA analysis. Of those, 26 spectra satisfied the DFF criteria were detected in the M. aeruginosa CPCC300 extract. However, multiple MS/MS spectra can be acquired on the same compound, particularly for higher intensity ions. In this extract, only 18 unique precursor m/z were found. The smallest ion (m/z 497.2746, [M+2H]²⁺) is the doubly charged complement of the [M+H]⁺ precursor m/z 993.5389, which was also detected by DFF. Based on previously published studies on this M. aeruginosa strain¹⁸, the major MCs detected can be confidently assigned as MC-LR and [D-Asp³]MC-LR. Investigating the mass spectra of the remaining putative MCs revealed that two were ¹³C isotopes of other detected MCs (m/z 993.5389, 1025.5343) and another was an adduct of and MC of m/z 993.5389. Of the 12 remaining putative MCs, four corresponded to the masses of known MCs, and eight were previously unreported compounds (Supplementary File. Table S1).

Figure 1: Chemical structure of MC-LR. The Adda residue is common in a large proportion of known MCs and produces diagnostic product ions at m/z 135.0803 and 163.1114. Other MC variants that contain a dimethyl-Adda and acetyldemethyl-Adda residue at position 5 are known and would not produce the same product ions. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.

Figure 2: MS/MS spectra of MC-LR. MS/MS spectra acquired on a Orbitrap mass spectrometer showing the prominent product ion at m/z 135.0803 derived from the Adda residue. An additional product ion at m/z 163.1114 is also derived from the Adda residue and increases the selectivity of the DFF analysis. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.

Figure 3: DFF dialogue box within MZmine. The product ions and/or neutral losses that are diagnostic for the targeted class of compounds are inputted. Retention time and precursor ion filters can be used to increase selectivity of the analysis. The minimum diagnostic ion intensity refers the threshold intensity of the diagnostic product ions and neutral losses that must be achieved in order for the spectra to satisfy the DFF criteria. Lowering this value may result in false positive hits. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.

Figure 4: DFF plot for MC analysis of M. aeruginosa cellular extract. DFF analysis of the M. aeruginosa CPCC300 extract found 26 spectra that met the defined DFF criteria, comprising 18 unique m/z values. Right clicking the plot allows the user to “Zoom Out” the domain and/or range axes. A doubly charged precursor ion was detected at m/z 497.2746 and corresponded to an unknown MC at [M+H]⁺ 993.5389. The two known MCs produced by strain CPCC300 are [D-Asp³]MC-LR and MC-LR ¹⁸. In total, eight putative MCs did not correspond to the m/z of known MCs, four MCs corresponded to the m/z of multiple congeners and three were found to be isotopes/adducts of other MCs (Supplementary File. Table S1). The DFF plot shown here was generated manually in Excel from the “putative_MCs_data.csv” that was automatically made upon executing the DFF module. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.

Supplementary File. Optimized conditions for LC-MS/MS analysis of M. aeruginosa extracts. Please click here to download this file.

Discussion

DFF is a straight-forward and rapid strategy for detecting entire classes of compounds, especially relevant for natural product compound discovery. The most important aspect of DFF is defining the specific MS/MS fragmentation criteria for the targeted class of compounds. In this representative example, DFF was used to detect all Adda residue containing MCs present in an M. aeruginosa cellular extract. Although the vast majority of MCs contain an Adda residue, other residues at this position have been known, notably demethyl- and acetyldemethyl-Adda variants¹⁹. Any MCs with these residues would not be detected using the defined criteria. However, as DFF is a post-acquisition approach, additional diagnostic fragments can easily be investigated on the same dataset using the simple step-by-step protocol outlined here. This also allows the analyst to detect compounds with hypothetical modifications that would alter the diagnostic product ions and/or neutral loss.

Adducts and in-source fragments may also meet DFF criteria and be incorrectly interpreted as unique analytes. False positives may arise when other compounds present in the extract exhibit the same product ions and/or neutral losses. In both cases, this can be alleviated by using additional product ions and neutral losses that increase method selectivity.

Although precursor ions may meet all of the DFF criteria defined by the analyst and represent compounds within the targeted class, their absolute identity will still be putative. Using the identification confidence levels, proposed by Schymanski (2014), MCs detected using this MS/MS approach have a ‘level 3’ identification confidence when unequivocal molecular formula of the precursor ion can be assigned by accurate mass and the isotope profile²⁰. In this example, eight putative MCs had masses that corresponded to multiple, isobaric MCs¹¹. Absolute identity would have been achieved by either comparison of retention time and MS/MS spectra with an authentic standard or confirmed by NMR and other spectroscopic methods after purification. Putative compounds that do not correspond to masses of any known members of the targeted class, such as the eight putative MCs detected here, represent tangible targets for discovering new natural products.

Declarações

The authors have nothing to disclose.

Acknowledgements

The authors thank Heather Roshon (Canadian Phycological Culture Centre, University of Waterloo for providing the cyanobacteria culture studied and Sawsan Abusharkh (Carleton University) for technical assistance.

Materials

Cyanobacteria
Microcystis aeruginosaCPCC300	CANADIAN PHYCOLOGICAL CULTURE CENTRE	CPCC300	https://uwaterloo.ca/canadian-phycological-culture-centre/
Software
Proteowizard (software)		software	http://proteowizard.sourceforge.net/
Mzmine 2		software	http://mzmine.github.io/
LC-MS
Q-Exactive Orbitrap	Thermo	–	Equipped with HESI ionization source
1290 UHPLC	Agilent		Equipped with binary pump, autosampler, column compartment
C18 column	Agilent	959757-902	Eclipse Plus C18 RRHD column (2.1 × 100 mm, 1.8 μm)
Solvents
Optima LC-MS grade Methanol	Fisher	A456-4
OptimaLC-MS grade Acetonitrile	Fisher	A955-4
OptimaLC-MS grade Water	Fisher	W6-4
LC-MS grade Formic Acid	Fisher	A11710X1-AMP
Vortex-Genie 2	Scientific Industries	SI-0236
Centrifuge Sorvall Micro 21	Thermo Scientific	75-772-436
Outro
Amber HPLC vials 2 mL/caps	Agilent	5182-0716/5182-0717
0.2-μm PTFE syringe filters	Pall Corp.	4521
Whatman 47mm GF/A glass microfiber filters	Sigma-Aldrich	WHA1820047
Media
MA media (pH 8.6) ( quantity / L)			Watanabe, M. F. & Oishi, S. Effects of environmental factors on toxicity of a cyanobacterium (Microcystis aeruginosa) under culture conditions. Applied and Environmental microbiology. 49 (5), 1342-1344 (1985).
Ca(NO₃)·4H₂O, 50 mg	Sigma-Aldrich	C2786
KNO₃, 100 mg	Sigma-Aldrich	P8291
NaNO₃, 50 mg	Sigma-Aldrich	S5022
Na₂SO₄, 40 mg	Sigma-Aldrich	S5640
MgCl_2·6H₂0, 50 mg	Sigma-Aldrich	M2393
Sodium glycerophosphate, 100 mg	Sigma-Aldrich	G9422
H₃BO₃, 20 mg	Sigma-Aldrich	B6768
Bicine, 500 mg	Sigma-Aldrich	RES1151B-B7
	P(IV) metal solution, 5 mL
Bring the following to 1 L with ddH₂O
NaEDTA·2HO	Sigma-Aldrich	E6635
FeCl₃ ·6H2O	Sigma-Aldrich	236489
MnCl₂·4H₂O	Baker	2540
ZnCl₂	Sigma-Aldrich	Z0152
CoCl₂·6H2O	Sigma-Aldrich	C8661
Na₂MoO₄·2H₂O	Baker	3764
Cyanobacteria BG-11 50X Freshwater Solution	Sigma-Aldrich	C3061-500mL

Referências

Mayer, P. M., Poon, C. The mechanisms of collisional activation of ions in mass spectrometry. Mass Spectrometry Reviews. 28 (4), 608-639 (2009).
Fisch, K. M. Biosynthesis of natural products by microbial iterative hybrid PKS–NRPS. RSC Advances. 3 (40), 18228-18247 (2013).
Kelman, M. J., et al. Identification of six new Alternaria sulfoconjugated metabolites by high-resolution neutral loss filtering. Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry. 29 (19), 1805-1810 (2015).
Renaud, J. B., Kelman, M. J., Qi, T. F., Seifert, K. A., Sumarah, M. W. Product ion filtering with rapid polarity switching for the detection of all fumonisins and AAL-toxins. Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry. 29 (22), 2131-2139 (2015).
Renaud, J. B., Kelman, M. J., McMullin, D. R., Yeung, K. K. -. C., Sumarah, M. W. Application of C8 liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry for the analysis of enniatins and bassianolides. Journal of Chromatography A. 1508, 65-72 (2017).
Walsh, J. P., et al. Diagnostic Fragmentation Filtering for the Discovery of New Chaetoglobosins and Cytochalasins. Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry. , (2018).
Wang, M., et al. Sharing and community curation of mass spectrometry data with Global Natural Products Social Molecular Networking. Nature biotechnology. 34 (8), 828 (2016).
Bartók, T., Szécsi, &. #. 1. 9. 3. ;., Szekeres, A., Mesterházy, &. #. 1. 9. 3. ;., Bartók, M. Detection of new fumonisin mycotoxins and fumonisin-like compounds by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography/electrospray ionization ion trap mass spectrometry. Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry: An International Journal Devoted to the Rapid Dissemination of Up-to-the-Minute Research in Mass Spectrometry. 20 (16), 2447-2462 (2006).
Bartók, T., et al. Detection and characterization of twenty-eight isomers of fumonisin B1 (FB1) mycotoxin in a solid rice culture infected with Fusarium verticillioides by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography/electrospray ionization time-of-flight and ion trap mass spectrometry. Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry. 24 (1), 35-42 (2010).
Pluskal, T., Castillo, S., Villar-Briones, A., Orešič, M. MZmine 2: modular framework for processing, visualizing, and analyzing mass spectrometry-based molecular profile data. BMC bioinformatics. 11 (1), 395 (2010).
Spoof, L., Catherine, A. Appendix 3: tables of microcystins and nodularins. Handbook of cyanobacterial monitoring and cyanotoxin analysis. , 526-537 (2016).
Pick, F. R. Blooming algae: a Canadian perspective on the rise of toxic cyanobacteria. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences. 73 (7), 1149-1158 (2016).
Carmichael, W. W., Boyer, G. L. Health impacts from cyanobacteria harmful algae blooms: Implications for the North American Great Lakes. Harmful algae. 54, 194-212 (2016).
Mayumi, T., et al. Structural characterization of microcystins by LC/MS/MS under ion trap conditions. The Journal of antibiotics. 59 (11), 710 (2006).
Frias, H. V., et al. Use of electrospray tandem mass spectrometry for identification of microcystins during a cyanobacterial bloom event. Biochemical and biophysical research communications. 344 (3), 741-746 (2006).
Kessner, D., Chambers, M., Burke, R., Agus, D., Mallick, P. ProteoWizard: open source software for rapid proteomics tools development. Bioinformatics. 24 (21), 2534-2536 (2008).
Watanabe, M. F., Oishi, S. Effects of environmental factors on toxicity of a cyanobacterium (Microcystis aeruginosa) under culture conditions. Applied and Environmental microbiology. 49 (5), 1342-1344 (1985).
Hollingdale, C., et al. Feasibility study on production of a matrix reference material for cyanobacterial toxins. Analytical and bioanalytical chemistry. 407 (18), 5353-5363 (2015).
Yuan, M., Namikoshi, M., Otsuki, A., Sivonen, K. Effect of amino acid side-chain on fragmentation of cyclic peptide ions: differences of electrospray ionization/collision-induced decomposition mass spectra of toxic heptapeptide microcystins containing ADMAdda instead of Adda. European Mass Spectrometry. 4 (4), 287-298 (1998).
Schymanski, E., et al. Identifying small molecules via high resolution mass spectrometry: communicating confidence. Environmental science & technology. 48 (4), 2097 (2014).

Play Video

PDF

DOI

DOWNLOAD MATERIALS LIST

Citar este artigo

McMullin, D. R., Hoogstra, S., McDonald, K. P., Sumarah, M. W., Renaud, J. B. Natural Product Discovery with LC-MS/MS Diagnostic Fragmentation Filtering: Application for Microcystin Analysis. J. Vis. Exp. (147), e59712, doi:10.3791/59712 (2019).