We present three simple in vitro assays-the long-distance migration assay, the co-culture migration assay, and chemo-attraction assay-that collectively evaluate the functions of human stem cell derived periventricular endothelial cells and their interaction with GABAergic interneurons.
Role of brain vasculature in nervous system development and etiology of brain disorders is increasingly gaining attention. Our recent studies have identified a special population of vascular cells, the periventricular endothelial cells, that play a critical role in the migration and distribution of forebrain GABAergic interneurons during embryonic development. This, coupled with their cell-autonomous functions, alludes to novel roles of periventricular endothelial cells in the pathology of neuropsychiatric disorders like schizophrenia, epilepsy, and autism. Here, we have described three different in vitro assays that collectively evaluate the functions of periventricular endothelial cells and their interaction with GABAergic interneurons. Use of these assays, particularly in a human context, will allow us to identify the link between periventricular endothelial cells and brain disorders. These assays are simple, low cost, and reproducible, and can be easily adapted to any adherent cell type.
Endothelial cells form the lining of blood vessels and mediate important functions that include maintenance of vessel wall permeability, regulation of blood flow, platelet aggregation, and formation of new blood vessels. In the brain, endothelial cells form part of a critical blood-brain-barrier that tightly controls exchange of materials between the brain and the bloodstream1. Our studies in the past decade have identified novel neurogenic roles of brain endothelial cells that have significant implications for brain development and behavior2,3,4,5. We have shown that the mouse embryonic forebrain is vascularized by two distinct subtypes of vessels, the pial vessels and the periventricular vessels, that differ in anatomy, origin, and developmental profile2. Endothelial cells lining these two vessel subtypes show distinct differences in their gene expression profiles. While pial endothelial cells mostly express genes related to inflammation and immune response, periventricular endothelial cells are uniquely enriched in expression of genes commonly associated with neurogenesis, neuronal migration, chemotaxis, and axon guidance3. Periventricular endothelial cells also house a novel GABA signaling pathway that is distinct from the traditional neuronal GABA signaling pathway5. Concomitant with its gene expression, periventricular endothelial cells were found to regulate migration and distribution of GABAergic interneurons in the developing neocortex. During embryonic development, periventricular endothelial cells undergo long-distance migration along a ventral-dorsal gradient to establish the periventricular vascular network2,3. This migratory route is mirrored a day later by interneurons. Migrating interneurons physically interact with the pre-formed periventricular vascular network and use it as a guiderail to reach their final destination in the neocortex. In addition to acting as a physical substrate, periventricular endothelial cells serve as the source of navigational cues for migrating neurons. Periventricular endothelial cell-secreted GABA guides interneuron migration and regulates their final distribution patterns4. Defects in interneuron migration and distribution are associated with neuropsychiatric disorders such as autism, epilepsy, schizophrenia and depression6,7,8,9,10. Therefore, study of periventricular endothelial cell functions and their influence on interneuron migration in human context becomes critical for addressing the pathogenesis of these disorders.
We have generated human periventricular-like endothelial cells from human embryonic stem cells in our laboratory11, using induced pluripotent stem cell (iPSC) technology12,13. To validate whether human periventricular endothelial cells faithfully mimic mouse periventricular endothelial cells, and to quantitatively assess their influence on interneuron migration, we developed three in vitro assays: a long-distance migration assay, a co-culture migration assay, and a chemo-attraction assay. Here we describe protocols for these assays in detail. All three assays are based on the usage of silicone culture inserts to create a small rectangular patch of cells (of fixed dimensions) surrounded by cell-free space. Migration distance is evaluated by measuring the distance between the final positions of cells from the border of the rectangular patch that has been outlined on day 0. In the long-distance migration assay, human periventricular endothelial cells are seeded as a patch in the center of a 35 mm dish, and the distances traveled by the cells over a long range of time are calculated. In the co-culture migration assay, human periventricular endothelial cells are co-seeded with human interneurons as one patch in a 35 mm dish. This setup allows examination of the effect of direct physical interactions of these two cell types on the rate of migration of interneurons. The chemo-attraction assay measures the migration of interneurons in response to chemo-attractive cues secreted by human periventricular endothelial cells. Interneurons are seeded as a rectangular patch, with human periventricular endothelial cells and control non-periventricular endothelial cells seeded as similar sized patches on either side. Each of the cell patches are separated by a cell-free gap of 500 µm. Response of interneurons is assessed by quantifying the number of cells that have migrated towards periventricular endothelial cells compared to control non-periventricular endothelial cells.
These assays provide robust assessment of human periventricular endothelial cell functions and their influence on interneuron migration. The novel setup of long-distance assay and co-culture migration assay provides cell-free space in the range of centimeters (~1-1.5 cm) to allow detection of long-distance migration. A summary of the features of our assays compared to other popular assays is presented in Table 1. Collectively, the assays described here will serve as a platform for assessing "diseased" periventricular endothelial cells and interneurons generated from iPSCs of brain disorders like schizophrenia, autism or epilepsy. These assays can also be used to determine how different conditions (e.g. inhibitors, ligands, RNAi) affect cell migration. Finally, these assays can be optimized for other cell types to measure long-distance migration, chemo-attraction or cell-cell mediated migration.
1. Culture and Storage of Human Periventricular Endothelial Cells
2. Preparation of Human Periventricular Endothelial Cells for Assay
3. Preparation of Human GABAergic Interneurons for Assay
NOTE: Human induced pluripotent stem cell (iPSC)-derived GABAergic interneurons and the neuronal medium were commercially purchased (see Table of Materials). The neurons are generated by differentiating a human fibroblast-derived iPSC line following a protocol developed by the manufacturer. The cells were thawed and cultured according to manufacturer's protocol.
4. Preparation of Control Human Endothelial Cells for Assay
NOTE: Control human iPSC-derived endothelial cells and endothelial cell medium were commercially purchased (Table of Materials). These endothelial cells are generated by differentiating a human fibroblast-derived iPSC line to endothelial fate following a protocol developed by the manufacturer. The cells were thawed and cultured on Fibronectin substrate according to manufacturer's protocol. Fibronectin-coated plates were prepared following manufacturer's protocol.
5. Preparation of One-well Culture Inserts
6. Long-distance Migration Assay
7. Co-culture Migration Assay
8. Chemo-attraction Assay
9. Imaging and Data Analysis
The steps to set up a one-well culture insert inside a 35 mm dish are shown in Figure 1. Long-distance migration assay and co-culture migration assay used a one-well insert to seed the desired number of cells in the center of a poly-L-ornithine/laminin coated 35 mm dish. On day 0, cells were present as a rectangular patch (Figure 2A,C). In day 0 images, the day 0 line could be easily identified by the sharp edge of the cell layer (white dotted line in Figure 2C). By 48 h, cells had migrated out into the cell-free space (Figure 2B,D). In post-day 0 images, the black border drawn around the insert (at the back of the dish) could be clearly observed as a black gap. The edge of the gap was assigned as the day 0 line (white dotted line in Figure 2D). As mentioned in Step 9.2, only those cells which fell in the area adjacent to the right and left long-edges of the cell layer (yellow area in Figure 2B) were considered for data analysis. The distance travelled by a cell was measured by calculating the distance between the cell (white arrow in Figure 2D) and the day 0 line. Immunocytochemical staining with anti-active Caspase 3 antibody, a marker of apoptosis, showed no apoptotic signal in the seeded cells (Figure 2E). In the co-culture migration assay, when interneurons were co-seeded with human periventricular endothelial cells, neurons travelled farther distances compared to when interneurons were seeded alone or when co-seeded with control endothelial cells (Figure 2F). Also, for the same distance range, a higher number of interneurons migrated out when co-seeded with periventricular endothelial cells in comparison to interneurons in the other two groups. This shows that, like mouse periventricular endothelial cells, human periventricular endothelial cells promote human interneuron migration.
In the chemo-attraction assay, using three-well culture inserts, human interneurons were seeded as a small rectangular patch in a 35 mm poly-L-ornithine/laminin coated culture dish. Periventricular endothelial cells and control non-periventricular endothelial cells were seeded as patches on either side of the neuronal patch, with the gap between each patch being 500 µm (Figure 3A). The number of interneurons that migrated towards periventricular endothelial cells versus control endothelial cells was quantified after 36 h. A significantly higher number of interneurons migrated towards periventricular endothelial cells compared to control endothelial cells (Figure 3B,C), confirming that GABAergic interneurons respond selectively to chemo-attractive cues secreted by human periventricular endothelial cells.
Figure 1: Preparation of the culture insert. (A) A two-well culture insert. (B) A one-well insert fixed in the center of a 35 mm dish. (C) The outline of the rectangular patch as observed after removing the insert. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Schema and representative result of migration assay. (A) Schema of cell layer (red rectangle) on day 0. (B) Schema of cells migrating out into the cell-free space. Red dots indicate migrating cells. The yellow region marks the area that is imaged for data acquisition. The dotted box in A and B corresponds to the area shown in panels C and D. (C,D) Representative fluorescent images of anti-β-Tubulin antibody labeled interneurons on day 0 (C) and day 2 (D) of the migration assay. The white dotted line marks day 0. The yellow line in D indicates the distance travelled by a cell (marked by white arrow) in 48 h. (E) Neurons (on day 0) are co-labeled with anti-β-Tubulin antibodies (red) and anti-active Caspase 3 antibodies (green), which mark apoptotic cells. Nuclei are stained with DAPI (blue). Apoptotic cells were not detected in seeded cells. (F) Graph from day 5 of the co-culture assay, where the number of interneurons that have migrated is plotted against distance travelled. In comparison to interneurons that were seeded alone or co-seeded with control endothelial cells, interneurons co-seeded with periventricular endothelial cells migrated out in higher numbers, and also travelled farther distance. Data represents mean ± S.D (n = 5; **p<0.01, ***p< 0.001, Student's t test). Scale bars = 100 µm. IN = interneurons; PV EC = periventricular endothelial cells. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Chemo-attraction assay. (A) Schema of the chemo-attraction assay. Using a three-well culture insert, interneurons (IN) were seeded in the middle (green dotted rectangle), while periventricular endothelial cells (PV ECs; orange dotted rectangle) and control endothelial cells (ECs; yellow dotted rectangle) were seeded on either side. (B) Images of β-Tubulin labeled interneurons showing robust migration towards periventricular endothelial cells but not towards control endothelial cells. (C) Quantification of the chemo-attractive response of interneurons. A significantly higher number of neurons migrated towards periventricular endothelial cells than towards control endothelial cells. Data represents mean ± S.D (n = 5; *p < 0.05, Student's t test). Scale bars = 100 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
A | Advantages | Limitations |
Boyden chamber assay16,17 | · Technically non-demanding · Suitable for adherent and non-adherent cells · Can be modified to study effect of paracrine signaling or chemo-attractants on cell migration |
· Endpoint assay. Not suitable for real-time imaging. · Not suitable for study of effect of direct cell-cell interaction on migration |
Scratch assay18 | · Endpoint or kinetic · Technically non-demanding |
· Assays migration length of a few hundred micrometers. Not suitable for study of long-distance migration in the range of 1-2 cm. · Not suitable for suspension cells · Variations in scratch area |
Long-distance migration assay | · End point or kinetic · Allows study of long-distance migration between 1.5 to 2 cm · Technically non-demanding |
· Not suitable for suspension cells |
Co-culture migration assay | · End point or kinetic · Allows study of the effect of direct cell-cell contact on migration · Allows migration length of up to 1.5 to 2 cm · Technically non-demanding |
· Not suitable for suspension cells |
B | Advantages | Limitations |
Boyden chamber assay | · Technically non-demanding · Suitable for adherent and non-adherent cells |
· Endpoint assay. Not suitable for live imaging. · Steep concentration gradient |
Under-agarose assay19 | · Technically non-demanding · Two or more chemo-attractive signals can be assayed in one set up |
· Not suitable for adherent cells. Restricted mostly to blood cells. · Difficult visualization of cells in agarose |
Capillary chamber migration assay20,21 | · Endpoint or kinetic · Suitable for adherent or suspension cells |
· Needs special chambers |
Microfluidic device22 | · Generates controllable and stable concentration gradient · Allows single-cell level resolution |
· Needs sophisticated devices and tools · Technically demanding and steep learning curve · Complex imaging and data analysis |
Chemo-attraction assay | · End point or kinetic · Gradual concentration gradient · Suitable for real-time or fluorescent imaging · Technically non-demanding |
· Not suitable for suspension cells |
Table 1: Comparison of assay methods. (A) Comparison of common in vitro migration assays with the long-distance migration assay and co-culture assay. (B) Comparison of common chemotaxis assays with the chemo-attraction assay.
Here, we described three in vitro assays that together provide quantitative assessment of human periventricular endothelial cell-specific properties. These assays will be valuable in gaining mechanistic insights into the interaction of human periventricular endothelial cells with human interneurons. Experiments using ligands, inhibitors, or cells with gene-specific knockdown or overexpression will identify or validate molecular players that mediate endothelial cell-guided interneuron migration or long-distance migratory properties of periventricular endothelial cells. These assays can also be modified to perform live-cell time-lapse migration studies. Furthermore, there is evidence for interaction of endothelial cells with cells other than interneurons. Studies from our group and others have alluded to the influence of periventricular endothelial cells on patterning of projection neurons and proliferation of neural precursor cells5,14,15. It would be of interest to test these possible interactions using our assay settings. Finally, these assays will serve as a platform for assessment of diseased periventricular endothelial cells. Our work has established novel autonomous links between the periventricular vascular network and the origin of neuropsychiatric disorders like schizophrenia, epilepsy, autism, and major depression3,5. These assays will be invaluable in identifying potential defects in long distance migration, chemo-attraction, or juxtracrine signaling of diseased-periventricular endothelial cells in these neuropsychiatric disorder conditions.
These assays are simple, reproducible, and low cost, and they can be modified to measure cell migration and effects of co-culture or chemo-attractive cues on migration in various cell types, except for non-adherent cells. There are some critical steps that need to be followed to obtain accurate and reproducible results. First, it is critical to optimize seeding cell number for each assay. The number of cells to be seeded in a single compartment should depend on cell type, desired level of confluency, and assay-specific factors like co-culture ratio. Second, it is necessary to optimize the cell culture medium for each assay. In the co-culture migration assay and the chemo-attraction assay, where more than one cell type is seeded in a single dish, the assay medium should be conducive to all cell types. In pilot experiments, we examined the effect of co-culture medium on viability (using trypan blue exclusion method) and morphology (using immunocytochemistry) of each cell type. We cultured human GABAergic neurons with co-culture medium for one week and observed no significant difference in viability and morphology of neurons in co-culture medium compared to neurons cultured in neuronal medium. In a similar fashion, periventricular endothelial cells and control endothelial cells, cultured in co-culture medium for two passages, did not show any significant variation in cell survival and morphology. Third, since rate of migration varies among different cell types, it is important to determine the time frame for each assay for the cell type(s) being studied. Fourth, it is critical to handle the culture inserts carefully. Inserts should be fixed firmly on the dish by gently pressing with a fingertip. The dish should be turned upside down to verify that the insert is not moving. Care should also be taken while removing the insert so as not to disturb the cell layer. Finally, it is recommended to increase sample size to reduce experimental variability.
In conclusion, these assays will significantly expand our understanding of human periventricular endothelial cell biology and its role on brain development in normal and diseased conditions.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported by awards from the National Institute of Mental Health (R01MH110438) and National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke (R01NS100808) to AV.
Accutase dissociation solution | Millipore Sigma | SCR005 | Cell dissociation solution (for periventricular endothelial cells, step 1.4) |
Anti-human β-Tubulin antibody | Biolegend | 802001 | |
Anti-human CD31 antibody | Millipore Sigma | CBL468 | |
Anti- MAP2 antibody | Neuromics | CH22103 | |
Anti-active Caspase 3 antibody | Millipore Sigma | AB3623 | |
Control human endothelial cells | Cellular Dynamics | R1022 | |
Control endothelial Cells Medium Supplement | Cellular Dynamics | M1019 | |
Cryogenic vials | Fisher Scientific | 03-337-7Y | |
DMEMF/12 medium | Thermofisher Scientific | 11320033 | |
DMSO | Sigma-Aldrich | D2650 | |
E6 medium | Thermofisher Scientific | A1516401 | |
FGF2 | Thermofisher Scientific | PHG0261 | |
Fibronectin | Thermofisher Scientific | 33016-015 | |
Freezing Container | Thermofisher Scientific | 5100 | |
GABA | Sigma-Aldrich | A2129 | |
Hemacytometer | Sigma-Aldrich | Z359629 | |
Human GABAergic neurons | Cellular Dynamics | R1013 | |
Human GABAergic neurons base medium | Cellular Dynamics | M1010 | |
Human GABAergic neuron Neural supplement | Cellular Dynamics | M1032 | |
Laminin | Sigma | L2020 | |
Matrigel | Corning | 356230 | Basement membrane matrix |
Mounting Medium | Vector laboratories | H-1200 | |
poly-L-ornithin | Sigma | p4957 | |
PBS | Thermofisher Scientific | 14190 | |
Trypan blue | Thermofisher Scientific | 15250061 | |
TrypLE | Thermofisher Scientific | 12563011 | Cell dissociation solution (for GABAergic interneurons and endothelial cells, sections 3 and 4) |
VEGF-A | Peprotech | 100-20 | |
VascuLife VEGF Medium Complete Kit | Lifeline Cell Technologies | LL-0003 | Component of control human endothelial cell medium |
2-well silicone culture-Insert | ibidi | 80209 | |
3-well silicone culture-Insert | ibidi | 80369 | |
35 mm dish | Corning | 430165 | |
15-ml conical tube | Fisher Scientific | 07-200-886 | |
4% PFA solution | Fisher Scientific | AAJ19943K2 | |
6-well tissue culture plate | Fisher Scientific | 14-832-11 | |
Inverted phase contrast microscope | Zeiss | Zeiss Axiovert 40C | |
Fluorescent microscope | Olympus | FSX-100 |