Dual DNA ruler assay is developed to determine the mRNA position during ribosome translocation, which relies on the dissociation forces of the formed DNA-mRNA duplexes. With single-nucleotide resolution and capability of reaching both ends of mRNA, it can provide mechanistic insights for ribosome translocation and probe other nucleic acid displacements.
The ribosome translocation refers to the ribosomal movement on the mRNA by exactly three nucleotides (nt), which is the central step in protein synthesis. To investigate its mechanism, there are two essential technical requirements. First is single-nt resolution that can resolve normal translocation from frameshifting, during which the ribosome moves by other than 3 nt. The second is the capability to probe both the entrance and exit sides of mRNA in order to elucidate the whole picture of translocation. We report the dual DNA ruler assay that is based on the critical dissociation forces of DNA-mRNA duplexes, obtained by force-induced remnant magnetization spectroscopy (FIRMS). With 2-4 pN force resolution, the dual ruler assay is sufficient to distinguish different translocation steps. By implementing a long linker on the probing DNAs, they can reach the mRNA on the opposite side of the ribosome, so that the mRNA position can be determined for both sides. Therefore, the dual ruler assay is uniquely suited to investigate the ribosome translocation, and nucleic acid motion in general. We show representative results which indicated a looped mRNA conformation and resolved normal translocation from frameshifting.
Biomolecular displacement is a fundamental parameter in studying the mechanism of the related biological functions. One particular example is the ribosome translocation1,2, during which the ribosome moves by exactly three nucleotides (nt) on the messenger RNA (mRNA) normally, and by one, two, or other numbers of nt except three in the case of frameshifting. Therefore, a molecular ruler system single-nt resolution is required to distinguish the different step sizes. A greater challenge is to probe the ribosome movement on both the entrance and exit sides. In other words, only with a dual ruler system will we be able to reveal whether the mRNA is smoothly threaded through the ribosome, or there are intermediate steps in which the two sides have different step sizes leading to a kinked or looped mRNA conformation inside the ribosome.
Several methods have been developed to address the first challenge of resolving different steps on the exit side of the ribosome (the 3' end of the mRNA). The dual luciferase assay resolves the different reading frames by measuring the ratios of the resulting different proteins3,4. It is only applicable for the 3' end of the mRNA and thus insufficient to provide a complete picture of translocation. Mass spectrometry can analyze the different peptide fragments as the consequence of the corresponding code rearrangements5. But it cannot pinpoint to how many nt the ribosome moves on the mRNA. The toe-printing assay is another common method that uses a reverse transcriptase primed at the 3'-distal end to transcribe the mRNA toward the ribosome6. However, it is not applicable for the 5' end of mRNA that is entering the ribosome. Other techniques, including single molecule approaches and fluorescence methods7, are difficult to achieve single-nt resolution.
We have developed the dual DNA ruler assay that can uniquely determine both the entrance and exit positions of the uncovered mRNA in ribosome-mRNA complexes. The ruler DNAs are DNA oligomers that form duplexes of certain numbers of basepairs (bp) with the mRNA uncovered by the ribosome, regardless of which end of the mRNA. The bp numbers then precisely reveal the ribosome position on the mRNA during translocation. The bp numbers of the duplexes are determined by their critical dissociation forces obtained from force-induced remnant magnetization spectroscopy (FIRMS)8. With 2-3 pN force uncertainty, the critical forces are sufficient to offer single-nt resolution. By implementing a linker molecule on the DNA rulers, the sterically hindered side of the mRNA by the ribosome can be probed. Different ribosomal displacements can thus be accurately resolved. We have successfully revealed a unique looped conformation of mRNA trapped by antibiotics during translocation9, and resolved different reading frames that coexisted on a slippery mRNA sequence10. This article describes the details of the dual ruler assay, which include preparation of the ribosome complexes, surface functionalization of the glass slides, immobilization of the ribosome complexes and their hybridization with magnetically labeled DNA ruler molecules, magnetic detection, and force spectrum analysis by FIRMS.
1. Preparation of the ribosome complexes
2. Preparation of biotin-coated glass slides
3. Sample preparation prior to magnetic and force measurements
4. Magnetic and force measurements
Figure 1 shows the detection scheme and photographs of the major components. Magnetic detection is achieved by an atomic magnetometer using the scanning scheme (Figure 1A)13. The sample is placed on a rod mounted on a linear motor. The motor transports the sample to the atomic sensor inside a magnetic shield, then back to the original site for unloading. The atomic magnetometer detects the magnetic signal during the sample scan and produced a signal trace, with the maximum signal when the sample is the closest to the sensor. Figure 1B shows the photo of the overall instrument. Figures 1C,D show the photos of the magnetization station and the centrifuge used for force application, respectively.
Principle of the dual DNA ruler assay is shown in Figure 2. The ribosome complex is immobilized on the surface via the 5' end of the mRNA. Two DNA rulers are designed to probe the exact position of the ribosome, one for each side of the mRNA. The current immobilization scheme makes the 3' side easily accessible for the probing DNA rulers. Therefore, DNA oligomers conjugated with magnetic beads can form duplexes with the uncovered mRNA. The 5' side, however, is sterically hindered by the ribosome and the surface. A linker molecule is thus needed for the DNA to reach the uncovered mRNA on this side. By varying the linker length, we have determined that when the linker is longer than 50 T, we can detect a strong magnetic signal which indicates successful formation of DNA-mRNA duplexes (Figure 2B). The correlation of dissociation force to duplex length is achieved by varying the number of nt on the DNA that are complementary to the mRNA. Figures 2C,D show the correlation for the 3'- and 5'- sides, respectively. Because the force difference between duplexes of consecutive lengths is typically 12-20 pN and the force resolution is typically 2-4 pN, we routinely achieve single-nt resolution for the length of DNA-mRNA duplexes based upon their dissociation forces.
Figure 3 presents the results of normal translocation in the absence and presence of various antibiotics. The translocation is from MF-Pre to MF-Post (Figure 3A). The inset indicates that MF-Pre carries vacant tRNAfMet and MF-tRNAPhe at the P- and A-sites, respectively. MF-Post carries tRNAfMet and MF-tRNAPhe at the E- and P-sites, respectively, with a vacant A-site. Figure 3B shows that without antibiotics, the ribosome moves by 3 nt on both sides (moving toward the 3'-end). This is because of the following reasons: (i) The DNA-mRNA duplexes at the 5' side exhibit 12 bp and 15 bp binding forces in MF-Pre and MF-Post, respectively. (ii) Duplexes at the 3' end exhibit a reversed change from 15 to 12 bp (Figure 3C). However, when both fusidic acid and neomycin are present, the force spectra show that the ribosome moves only by 1 nt at the 5' side but 2 nt at the 3' side (Figure 3D,E). This result indicates that the ribosome translocated via a stepwise mechanism, resulting a looped mRNA conformation that has an extra nt inside the ribosome, which has not been experimentally revealed before. This is consistent with reported theoretical simulation14. Alternatively, the ribosome may be stretched to cover 28 nt of mRNA, instead of the usual 27 nt15. After washing away the antibiotics, normal translocation occurs, as evidenced by 3 nt movements from both the 5ʹ and 3ʹ sides (purple trace in Figure 3D, E). The looped conformation does not form when only fusidic acid is used. The force spectra are consistent with the ribosome movement of 3 nt at both sides, similar to the situation for normal translocation (Figure 3F,G). The dual ruler assay also reveals that viomycin completely inhibited translocation, as shown by 0 nt movement on both sides (Figure 3H,I).
We have also investigated whether this looped conformation can form on "-1" frameshifting motifs. Here, the translocation from MFNF-Pre and MFNF-Post complexes takes place on the 'U6A' motif, which has been found to be part of the '-1' frameshifting motif in HIV16. Figures 4A,B show that in the MFNF-Post, the DNA-mRNA duplex is shortened by either 2 or 3 nt at the 3'-end; the duplex length increases by either 2 or 3 nt at the 5ʹ-ends. The results suggest the coexistence of both normal translocation and "-1" frameshifting, with the former correlating with the 3-nt movement and the latter correlating with the 2-nt movement. The dual ruler assay is able to clearly resolve the two populations. With both neomycin and fusidic acid, we observe that the ribosome moves by 2 nt at the 3'-end but only 1 nt at the 5ʹ-end, respectively (Figure 4C,D). Therefore, the looped mRNA conformation also takes place on the slippery sequence. When only fusidic acid is present for the MFNF-Pre (Figure 4E,F), the result is the same as that for MFNF-Post in panels A and B (blue traces), indicating that fusidic acid alone is not sufficient to pause translocation or frameshift. Therefore, it confirms that both fusidic acid and neomycin are required for the unequal displacements for the two sides of mRNA.
Figure 1: Instruments for the FIRMS-based dual DNA ruler assay. (A) Schematic of the magnetic detection. 1: sample and its mount; 2: motor; 3: atomic sensor and magnetic shield. (B) Photo of the atomic magnetometer and sample handling system. The numbers indicate the actual corresponding components shown in the schematic. Note the magnetic shield is inside the cardboard box for improved thermal stability. (C) Magnetization station. (D) Centrifuge used for force application. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Dual ruler assay with single-nt resolution for studying ribosome translocation. (A) Schematic of the dual ruler assay, in which two DNA rulers are designed to respectively probe the 5ʹ- and 3ʹ- ends. The red line indicates the polyT linker. (B) Optimization of the linker length for Ruler-In. (C) FIRMS results to determine the dissociation forces of the duplexes between Ruler-Ins and mRNA. (D) Dissociation forces of the duplexes between Ruler-Outs and mRNA. The error bar is defined as the ratio between the instrument noise and the overall magnetic signal decrease (B0), with typical value of ±3-5%. Figure has been reproduced with permission9. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Probing translocation steps under the influence of various antibiotics. (A) Probing scheme for the MF-Pre and MF-Post complexes. Inset indicates the schematic ribosomes in Pre and Post, which correspond to the solid and dash-lined ovals, respectively. (B, C) FIRMS results with no antibiotics. (D, E) Results with both fusidic acid and neomycin. (F, G) Results with fusidic acid only. (H, I) Results with viomycin only. Left panels: using Ruler-In to probe the 5' side; right panels: using Ruler-Out to probe the 3' side. The error bars are calculated the same way as those in the previous figure. Figure has been reproduced with permission9. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: FIRMS results of using dual rulers to probe frameshifting. (A, B) MFNF-Pre and MFNF-Post without antibiotics. (C, D) Results with both fusidic acid and neomycin. (E, F) Results with only fusidic acid. Left panels: using Ruler-In to probe the 5ʹ side; right panels: using Ruler-Out to probe the 3ʹ side. The error bars are calculated the same way as those in the previous figure. Figure has been reproduced with permission9. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
In our dual ruler assay, the magnetic beads play two essential roles. First, they serve as the force transducers because the centrifugal force is proportional to their buoyant mass. Second, the beads are signal carriers detected by an atomic magnetometer, which is currently the most accurate magnetic sensor. Combining mechanical manipulation and magnetic detection, the FIRMS technique is able to resolve a large number of molecular interactions based on their critical dissociation forces, which is the basis of the DNA rulers. The dual ruler assay is uniquely suited to probe both sides of mRNA during translocation. Because it is a physical approach that only relies on the formation of the duplexes, it is not limited by the mRNA sides or other biological constrains. This is an advantage compared to other techniques that are based on biochemical reactions. We have shown that by using a long linker molecule, the rulers can reach the targeted binding site to determine the mRNA position. Specifically, for the ribosome, the linker length is 50 T, which corresponds to 17 nm in length. This length is very close to the size of the ribosome17. The concentrations of the antibiotics are typical values from the literature. It is also possible to use our method to reveal the onset values for their functions.
There are two critical aspects for the dual ruler assay. One is the delicate functionalized surface for molecular immobilization and subsequent biological reactions. Every loading and washing step should be performed with minimum disturbance to the surface, so that the molecules immobilized on the surface will remain intact. For the DNA-mRNA hybridization process, sufficient time is necessary to ensure the completion of the process. It is also advised to use TAM10 buffer with extra 1 M NaCl to maintain a homeostatic system. The other critical aspect is the magnetization of the beads. Since excessive beads are used, there are plenty of free beads not immobilized on the surface. Therefore, when magnetizing the sample, the coated surface should approach and leave the magnet vertically. Any minor swing of the sample can possibly cause scratching damage on the surface.
Our dual DNA ruler assay is currently the only method that can objectively probe both the entrance and exit sides of mRNA in the ribosome complexes with single-nt resolution. Novel mechanistic information regarding ribosome translocation has been obtained. The method is generally applicable for molecular displacement of nucleic acids, which is widely encountered in molecular biology.
For future development and applications, we have shown that using acoustic radiation force to replace the centrifugal force will further improve the force resolution, reaching sub-nt regime18. We are also investigating multiplexed detection using atomic magnetometers to improve the detection efficiency. With these improvements, we expect our method detailed in this work will find broad applications in biological research.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work is supported by the US National Institutes of Health (R01GM111452, Y.W., S.X.). Y. W. acknowledges support from the Welch Foundation (E-1721).
Styrene Strip | City of Industry | MS-861 | |
Glass slides | Evaporated Coatings | 60.0 × 4.0 × 0.3 mm3 | |
Acetic acid | Millipore Sigma | A6283-500ML | |
3-Aminopropyltriethoxysilane | UCT specialties | 21400088 | |
mPEG-SVA | Laysan Bio | 154-82 | |
Biotin-PEG-SVA | Laysan Bio | 152-84 | |
Sodium bicarbonate | Millipore Sigma | S5761-500G | |
Epoxy glue | Devcon | 31345 | |
Streptavidin | ThermoFisher | 434301 | |
Fusidic Acid | Millipore Sigma | F0756-1G | |
Neomycin Sulfate | Millipore Sigma | 1458009 | |
Viomycin Sulfate | Millipore Sigma | 1715000 | |
Hygromycin | invitrogen | 10687-010 | |
Tris-HCl | Millipore Sigma | T5941-100G | |
Magnesium acetate | Millipore Sigma | M5661-50G | |
Ammonium chloride | Millipore Sigma | A9434-500G | |
Potassium chloride | Millipore Sigma | P9333-500G | |
EDTA | GIBCO | 774750 | |
2-mercaptoethanol | Millipore Sigma | M6250-500ML | |
Tween20 | Millipore Sigma | P1379-250ML | |
GTP | Millipore Sigma | G8877-100MG | |
PEP | Millipore Sigma | P7127-100MG | |
Pyruvate Kinase | Millipore Sigma | P1506-5KU | |
Sucrose | Millipore Sigma | S7903-5KG | |
Dynabeads M-280 Streptavidin | ThermoFisher | 11205D | |
mRNA Oligo | Integrated DNA Technologies | 133899727 | 5′-Bio- CAA CUG UUA AUU AAA UUA AAU UAA AAA GGA AAU AAAA AUG UUU AAU UUU UUA GGG CGC AAU CUA CUG CUG AAC UC-3′ |
DNA Oligo | Integrated DNA Technologies | 157468630 | 3ʹ- TAA TTT AAT TTA ATT TTT CGA AAU AT50/TEGBio/-5ʹ |
DNA Oligo | Integrated DNA Technologies | 164845370 | 3ʹ-AAT TTA ATT TTT CCT TTA AAA AT50/TEGBio/-5’ |
DNA Oligo | Integrated DNA Technologies | 157468628 | 3ʹ-AAA ATC CCG CGT TAG AAC UGG GG/TEGBio/-5’ |
DNA Oligo | Integrated DNA Technologies | 163472705 | 3ʹ-CCG CGT TAG ATG ACG AGA ACG GG/TEGBio/-5’ |
DNA Oligo | Integrated DNA Technologies | 138678130 | 3ʹ-AGA TGA CGA CTT CTC GGG/TEGBio/-5’ |
DNA Oligo | Integrated DNA Technologies | 138678131 | 3ʹ-T AGA TGA CGA CTT CTC GGG/TEGBio/-5’ |
DNA Oligo | Integrated DNA Technologies | 138678132 | 3ʹ-TT AGA TGA CGA CTT CTC GGG/TEGBio/-5ʹ |
DNA Oligo | Integrated DNA Technologies | 138678133 | 3ʹ-GTT AGA TGA CGA CTT CTC GGG/TEGBio/-5’ |
Centrifuge | Eppendorf | 5427R | |
Micro Ultracentrifuge | Hitachi | CS150FNX | |
Vortex mixer | VWR | VM-3000 | |
Lock-in Amplifier | Stanford Research Systems | SR530 | |
Lock-in Amplifier | Stanford Research Systems | SR830 | |
Laser | Newport | TLB-6918-D | |
Function generator | Stanford Research Systems | DS345 | |
Photo detectors | Thorlabs | DET36A |