Here, we present a protocol to prepare and visualize secondary structures (e.g., fibers, toroidal architectures, and nano-spheres) derived from helical polycarbodiimides. The morphology characterized by both atomic force microscopy (AFM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was shown to depend on molecular structure, concentration, and the solvent of choice.
A facile method for the preparation of polycarbodiimide-based secondary structures (e.g., nano-rings, "craters," fibers, looped fibers, fibrous networks, ribbons, worm-like aggregates, toroidal structures, and spherical particles) is described. These aggregates are morphologically influenced by extensive hydrophobic side chain-side chain interactions of the singular polycarbodiimide strands, as inferred by atomic force microscopy (AFM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) techniques. Polycarbodiimide-g-polystyrene copolymers (PS-PCDs) were prepared by a combination of synthetic methods, including coordination-insertion polymerization, copper(I)-catalyzed azide alkyne cycloaddition (CuAAC) "click" chemistry, and atom transfer radical polymerization (ATRP). PS-PCDs were found to form specific toroidal architectures at low concentrations in CHCl3. To determine the influence of a more polar solvent medium (i.e., THF and THF/EtOH) on polymer aggregation behavior, a number of representative PS-PCD composites have been tested to show discrete concentration-dependent spherical particles. These fundamental studies are of practical interest to the development of experimental procedures for desirable architectures by directed self-assembly in thin film. These architectures may be exploited as drug carriers, whereas other morphological findings represent certain interest in the area of novel functional materials.
The helix is a ubiquitous chiral motif observed in nature. Complex biological systems and their components, such as proteins, polypeptides, and DNA, all utilize the helical structure as a means of performing complex tasks for applications like information storage, tissue molecular transportation support, and localized chemical transformations.
Helical polymeric macromolecules1 have been a target for the design of functional materials and composites possessing interesting properties, which enabled their practical use in many areas2,3,4,5. So far, numerous helical scaffolds6,7,8,9, as well as their secondary structure motifs, have been successfully exploited to achieve promising results, both in the field of physical engineering10,11,12 and in biological applications13,14. Current studies represent a logical extension of our earlier efforts to synthesize optically active alkyne polycarbodiimides bearing one or two modifiable alkyne moieties per repeat unit15,16,17.
Recently, we reported22 the homo- and co-polymerization of carbodiimide monomers leading to chiral helical macromolecules — a family of (R)- and (S)-polycarbodiimides with modifiable pendant groups that offer further functionalization through a CuAAC "click" protocol. Br-terminated polycarbodiimides obtained from their respective ethynyl precursors were shown to act as ATRP macroinitiators in graft-polymerization with styrene23.
The specific aim of this manuscript is to provide a practical guide for morphological characterizations (AFM measurements and SEM inspection) of the secondary structures formed from PS-PCDs synthesized from their corresponding ethynyl precursors by using a well-known click protocol21. In particular, experimental details, such as the solvent of choice, the temperature, the deposition method, the substrate chosen for deposition, and the polymer structure, were shown to be highly important to obtain specific morphologies (e.g., fibers, including right- and left-handed helical senses; nano-spheres; and nano-rings). They may also be of use for the development of materials with tunable properties based on polycarbodiimides with precisely controlled chiral architecture.
NOTE: All reactions were performed in a glove box (or fume hood, when noted) using standard scintillation vials.
1. Synthesis of the (R)- and (S)-series of Ethynylpolycarbodiimides
2. Synthesis of the (R)- and (S)-series of Triazole Polycarbodiimides under a "Click" Protocol
3. Synthesis of the (R)- and (S)-series of Polycarbodiimide-g-polystyrene Copolymers
4. Thin-film Preparation for Tapping Mode Atomic Force Microscopy (TMAFM) Measurements
Figure 1 (upper panel) illustrates BINOL (R)- or (S)-titanium (IV) catalyst-mediated coordination-insertion polymerization leading to the (R)- and (S)-series of ethynylpolycarbodiimides with an altering ratio of the repeat units (i.e., aryl- and alkyne aryl). Monomers and catalysts were obtained as described elsewhere18. Both (R)- and (S)-family alkyne random copolymers were selected for "click"-coupling with N-(3-azidopropyl)-2-bromo-2-methylpropane amide22. The lower panel shows the synthesis of the triazole polycarbodiimides used as macroinitiators in the ATRP reaction to produce polycarbodiimide-g-polystyrenes (PS-PCDs)22,23.
Figure 2 illustrates a model of the polycarbodiimide backbone, depicted as a pink spiral spinning around the yellow axis. Brown and green substituents form a "secondary" helical motif with respect to the pink amidine main chain. Macromolecules can self-assemble in a thin film to form a great variety of complex supramolecular architectures, such as fibers, looped fibers, superhelices, fibrous networks, ribbons, worm-like aggregates, toroidal structures, and craters. A molecular model of the triazole macroinitiator is given in Figure 3 (35-mer segment of a polymer chain with terminal Br atoms represented in red).
Figures 4 and 5 show the representative AFM images of alkyne PCDs, confirming the formation of fiber-like morphologies and their respective diameter sizes (e.g., Figure 5: ~76 nm (panel b), 38-60 nm (panel c), 30-40 nm (panel e), and ~12-20 nm (panel f)). In general, diluting stock solutions resulted in diminishing the size of the aggregated morphologies formed (e.g., "thick," fiber-like networks at relatively high concentrations tend to transform into thin, separated fibers upon dilution).
Also shown are the morphologies formed from polycarbodiimide-g-polystyrenes spin-coated from CHCl3 stock (Figure 6). Unlike alkyne polycarbodiimide aggregation behaviors in CHCl3, examining PS-PCDs revealed both crater-like assemblies and nano-size toroidal architectures as predominant motifs. The reproducible formation of those morphologies is thought to be driven by concentration changes.
Figures 7 and 8 both illustrate representative AFM images of polycarbodiimide-g-polystyrenes indicative of the formation of discrete nano-spheres when applying a THF or binary THF/EtOH (25%, v) solvent system for sample deposition with concentration-dependent particle sizes. Figure 8 shows the assembly of the individual macromolecules into spherical nano-particles of ~84 nm in size matching up closely SEM-measured morphologies (~100 nm, panel e). Remarkably, the greater micron-size aggregates shown in panels a-d may be comprised of individual nano-particles agglomerated together.
Figure 1. Synthesis of alkyne polycarbodiimides and their "grafting from" transformation to PS-PCDs. (R)- and (S)-series of ethynylpolycarbodiimides were generated by altering the ratio of carbodiimide precursors (i.e., N-phenyl-N'-hexylcarbodiimide monomer (Ph) and N-(3-ethynylphenyl)-N'-hexylcarbodiimide (ET)), with repeat unit compositions varying in the range: 0:100 (100-Ph), 15:85 (15-ET-85-Ph), 30:70 (30-ET-70-Ph), 50:50 (50-ET-50-Ph), 70:30 (70-ET-30-Ph), 85:15 (85-ET-15-Ph), and 100:0 (100-ET). The "click" protocol was used to synthesize their triazole derivatives, which were further employed as Br-terminated macroinitiators for the ATRP reaction with styrene (either 50 or 100 eq.) to form polycarbodiimide-g-polystyrenes. Reprinted with permission22. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2. Schematic representation of polycarbodiimides self-assembling into fibrillar motifs. The panels show the representative helical macromolecule and self-assembly of individual macromolecules to form bundled structures identifiable by AFM analysis. Reprinted with permission22. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3. Molecular model of triazole polycarbodiimide. The triazole polycarbodiimide structure displays the helical motif introduced by specific orientations of Br-terminated side chains. Atom color codes: carbon (green), nitrogen (blue), oxygen (red), and bromine (red). Please click here to view this video. (Right-click to download.)
Figure 4. Evidence for alkyne polycarbodiimide fiber formation by AFM. Fibrous aggregates appeared to be a common trend for all alkyne composites. Representative AFM micrographs are taken for (S)-85-ET-15-Ph-PCD (panels a-c) and (S)-100-ET-PCD (panels d−f) polymers deposited from CHCl3. Reprinted with permission22. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5. Controlling the size/thickness of fibers through concentration change. Fibrous aggregates are generated from (S)-100-ET-PCD at different concentrations: 5.0 mg/mL (panel a); 2.5 mg/mL (panel b); 1.25 mg/mL (panel c); 0.625 mg/mL (panel d); 0.313 mg/mL (panel e); and 0.156 mg/mL (panel f), deposited from CHCl3. Scan size = 5.0 x 5.0 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6. Developing PS-PCD nano-ring patterns in the thin film. Representative concentration series for (R)-30-TRZ-70-Ph-STYR(1:100)-PCD polymer: 10.0 mg/mL (panel a); 5.0 mg/mL (panel b); 2.5 mg/mL (panel c); 1.25 mg/mL (panel d); 0.625 mg/mL (panel e); 0.313 mg/mL (panel f); and 0.156 mg/mL (panels g and h). Scan size = 5.0 x 5.0 µm. Reprinted with permission23. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 7. Polycarbodiimide-g-polystyrene nano-particles assembled in the thin film. Representative height and phase diagrams for (S)-50-TRZ-50-Ph-STYR(1:50)-PCD polymer in different solvents: THF (panels a, b) and THF/EtOH binary system (panels c, d). Importantly, appending PS-segments to the polycarbodiimide backbone has a noticeable effect on the self-assembling properties; thus, macromolecules tend to aggregate into "craters" and nano-rings rather than fibers, a predominant motif found for all alkyne PCDs. Reprinted with permission23. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 8. Schematic representation of polycarbodiimide-g-polystyrene nano-spheres as evidenced by SEM-analysis. Individual nano-particles (panel e) and large aggregates (panels a-d) assembled from (S)-70-TRZ-30-Ph-STYR(1:100)-PCD and (R)-50-TRZ-50-Ph-STYR(1:100)-PCD polymers, respectively. Proposed self-assembly model for the individual polycarbodiimide-g-polystyrene macromolecules with rigid polycarbodiimide backbones (green-yellow) dispersed in the environment and formed by polystyrene lateral chains (light blue). Reprinted with permission23. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
In summary, the spin-coating deposition method represents a convenient way to reproducibly generate multiple-type morphologies, including fiber-like aggregates, ribbons, worm-like structures, fibrillar networks, looped fibers, toroids, and superhelices, from either alkyne polycarbodiimides or from their respective PS-derivatives (i.e., polycarbodiimide-g-polystyrenes). Thus, coordination-insertion polymerization, along with further functionalization using a "click" reaction followed by ATRP, provides a unique opportunity to rapidly obtain a series of statistical polycarbodiimides with the R– and S-configuration of backbones in a nearly quantitative yield.
Alkyne polycarbodiimide formation (Figure 1) appears to be a critical step in polymer synthesis, since those macromolecules are important as substrates for the production of fiber-like aggregates; they also serve as precursors in the synthesis of polycarbodiimide-g-polystyrenes. Notably, alkyne compositions with a high n:m ratio tend to produce completely insoluble (or having very limited solubility in organic solvents) material during the course of Cu(I)-catalyzed "click" synthesis, possibly as a result of the cross-linking side reaction. Unlike the most common C6-residues, longer dodecyl alkyl chains (i.e., C12-) having increased conformational flexibility should be avoided from a practical point of view, since they often lead to the formation of complex dewetting patterns and "craters" rather than distinct individual fibers22.
Another important practical finding for both alkyne PCD and PS-PCD series is their ability to form secondary structures that are strongly influenced by solvent and concentration (i.e., control over the type and dimensions (or size) of aggregated morphologies), thus opening up possibilities for the structural design and preparation of novel functional materials based on rigid-rod polycarbodiimides. Specifically, toroidal aggregates can be successfully obtained from polycarbodiimide-g-polystyrenes when spin-coated from 0.156 mg/mL CHCl3 stock (Figure 6), whereas applying the more polar THF or THF/EtOH (25% by volume) solvent system to the grafted macromolecules induces the formation of spherical aggregates, as shown by the combination of AFM and SEM techniques (Figures 7 and 8). Despite the fact that there is no linear relationship between the concentration and diameter of the fibers/ribbons formed when spin-coated from CHCl3 on an Si wafer, it seemed that decreasing the concentration of stock solution allowed for control of the thickness of the fibrous morphologies for alkyne PCDs (Figure 5).
Limitations in the provided method arise from the technique itself used to generate nano-structures (i.e., motifs easily identifiable by AFM in thin film by tapping mode may or may not retain their structure in solution or in bulk; however, in certain cases, it is possible to corroborate AFM findings with SEM measurements). Another disadvantage of using the AFM technique is the low uniformity of thin-film patterns. Therefore, the end result is often predetermined by a delicate balance of the polymer structure, solvent of choice, deposition method, and substrate. The latter requires thorough and careful screening of multiple specimens in order to define the optimal conditions for each specific morphological motif.
A key advantage of the aforementioned AFM technique is that it offers a reliable and inexpensive way to produce and visualize specific morphologies (i.e., fibers, nano-rings, and spheres) assembled from statistical polycarbodiimide polymers with rigid backbones that are otherwise obtainable by more sophisticated methods, including the blending of chemically distinct polymers24, applying surfactants, or using relatively complex machinery like microcapillary devices25. Future applications of this method might include developing the electronic nose26, constructing spherical aggregates as carriers to deliver drug molecules27, and designing novel liquid crystalline materials28.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
We gratefully acknowledge the NSF-MRI grant (CHE-1126177) used to purchase the Bruker Advance III 500 NMR instrument.
styrene | Sigma-Aldrich | S4972-1L | reagent |
N,N,N′,N′′,N′′- Pentamethyldiethylenetriamine (PMDETA) | Sigma-Aldrich | 369497-250ML | reagent |
Copper(I) iodide | Sigma-Aldrich | 215554-5G | reagent |
Copper(I) chloride | Alfa-Aesar | 14644, 5G | reagent |
1,8-Diazabicyclo[5.4.0]undec-7-ene (DBU) | Sigma-Aldrich | 139009-100G | reagent |
N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) | Sigma-Aldrich | 227056-100mL | solvent |
Tetrahydrofuran (THF) | Acros-Organics | B0320346 | solvent |
Chloroform | Sigma-Aldrich | 372978-100mL | solvent |
Methanol | Fisher-Chemical | A411-20 | solvent |
20 mL glass scintillation vials | Cole-Palmer | UX-08918-03 | glassware |
1-Dram vials (15 x 45 mm) | Kimble-Chase | KIM-60965D-1 | glassware |
13 mm syringe filter with 0.45µm PTFE membrane | VWR International | 28145-493 | membrane filter |
Silicon wafer disks (25.4± .5 mm) | Wafer World, Inc | S076453 | AFM substrate |
Corning Stirrer/Hot Plate | Hot Plate | PC-420 | heating device |
single stage Unilab mBraun glove box | Unilab | 12-109 | glove box |
Nanoscope IV-Multimode Veeco AFM-machine | Veeco | 3100 Dimension V Atomic Probe Microscope | AFM-instrument |