Techniques are described to immunostain phospho-epitopes in whole zebrafish embryos and then conduct two-color fluorescent confocal localization in cellular structures as small as primary cilia. The techniques for fixing and imaging can define the location and kinetics of the appearance or activation of specific proteins.
The rapid proliferation of cells, the tissue-specific expression of genes and the emergence of signaling networks characterize early embryonic development of all vertebrates. The kinetics and location of signals – even within single cells – in the developing embryo complements the identification of important developmental genes. Immunostaining techniques are described that have been shown to define the kinetics of intracellular and whole animal signals in structures as small as primary cilia. The techniques for fixing, imaging and processing images using a laser-scanning confocal compound microscope can be completed in as few as 36 hr.
Zebrafish (Danio rerio) is a desirable organism for investigators who seek to conduct studies in a vertebrate species that is affordable and relevant to human disease. Genetic knockouts or knockdowns must be confirmed by the loss of the actual protein product. Such confirmation of protein loss can be achieved using the techniques described here. Clues into signaling pathways can also be deciphered by using antibodies that are reactive with proteins that have been post-translationally modified by phosphorylation. Preserving and optimizing the phosphorylated state of an epitope is therefore critical to this determination and is accomplished by this protocol.
This study describes techniques to fix embryos during the first 72 hr of development and co-localize a variety of relevant epitopes with cilia in the Kupffer's Vesicle (KV), the kidney and the inner ear. These techniques are straightforward, do not require dissection and can be completed in a relatively short period of time. Projecting confocal image stacks into a single image is a useful means of presenting these data.
The techniques described here are the outcome of studies that have sought to define downstream targets of Ca2+ signals during events that occur during early development, including fertilization, gastrulation, somitogenesis and trunk, eye, brain and organ formation.1-3 The original discoveries of embryonic Ca2+ signaling were dependent on the use of natural and engineered Ca2+ indicators, such as aequorin4 and fura-2.5 Even with current technology, the detection of transient elevations of Ca2+ requires cumbersome analytical tools and does not reveal the targets of such Ca2+ signals.
This laboratory investigates Ca2+ signals that act through the Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent (multifunctional) protein kinase known as CaMK-II, an enzyme that is enriched in the central nervous system and originally identified as a regulator of long-term potentiation.6 CaMK-II is not brain-specific, is widely expressed and highly conserved throughout the entire lifespan and bodies of species throughout the animal kingdom, including invertebrates.7,8 CaMK-II has the unique capability of sustaining its own activity even after Ca2+ levels have diminished due to its ability to autophosphorylate at Thr287. In this autophosphorylated state, CaMK-II remains active in a Ca2+/CaM-independent manner, until dephosphorylated.6 Thus, the localization of phosphorylated CaMK-II (Thr287) can identify cells in which natural, relevant Ca2+ elevations have occurred.
An antibody against autophosphorylated (P-Thr287) mammalian CaMK-II has been well-characterized and was initially used to localize activated CaMK-II in brain tissue.9 Zebrafish (Danio rerio) have seven CaMK-II genes10,11 whose protein products contain a sequence of MHRQE[pT287]VECLK in this region.10,11 This sequence is very similar to the phosphopeptide antigen used to create this rabbit polyclonal antibody (MHRQE[pT]VDCLK; Upstate/Millipore) and therefore it was not a complete surprise that this antibody cross-reacted with zebrafish CaMK-II. This laboratory showed that this antibody reacts with zebrafish CaMK-II in proportion to autophosphorylation and Ca2+/CaM-independent activity.12 Additional pan-specific CaMK-II antibodies have also been shown to cross-react with zebrafish CaMK-II.13
This antibody has been used to demonstrate that zebrafish CaMK-II is preferentially activated in cells on one side of the zebrafish Kupffer’s Vesicle (KV), the ciliated organ necessary for establishment of left/right asymmetry.12 This antibody was used to demonstrate that CaMK-II is transiently activated in four adjacent cells on the left side of the KV during the exact same developmental phase that organ positioning is determined.12 In addition to the Kupffer’s Vesicle (KV), autophosphorylated (P-T287) was also located in specific intracellular sites in other ciliated tissues including the kidney, neuromasts, and inner ear.12,13 In the zebrafish kidney, P-T287-CaMK-II is enriched along the apical border of ciliated ductal cells and within cloacal cilia where it influences their assembly.13 Finally, in the developing inner ear, P-T287-CaMK-II is intensely concentrated at the base of cilia and influences cell differentiation through the Delta-Notch signal pathway.14 In summary, the detection of activated CaMK-II has pinpointed sites of intracellular Ca2+ release and illuminated potential new signaling pathways.
These discoveries were completely dependent on developing a sensitive and accurate method to localize activated (P-T287-autophosphorylated) CaMK-II. The methods to fix and immunostain the zebrafish KV, kidney and inner ear are described. The limitations of this technique are also described. These techniques should be useful to any investigator who seeks to obtain high-resolution images in two fluorescent channels of not just phospho-epitopes, but any epitope, during early vertebrate development.
The zebrafish procedures in this protocol have been approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC) at Virginia Commonwealth University.
1. Preparation of Reagents
2. Embryo Fixation
3. Immunostaining Whole Embryos
4. Confocal Imaging and Processing
Optimal Conditions for Visualizing Phospho-epitopes
Methods describing the immunolocalization of protein epitopes in zebrafish embryos have been relatively sparse compared to those for localizing mRNAs via in situ hybridization. Fixatives used in localizing protein epitopes in ciliated cells of zebrafish embryos have included 4% PFA/PBS and Dent's fixative, which is a mixture of methanol and DMSO.19 Localization of RNA by whole mount in situ hybridization (WISH) is typically achieved using PFA followed by storage in 100% methanol.20,21 Our studies revealed that the WISH fixative combination, when limiting the time in methanol to between two and seven days, was vastly superior to any other fixative for immunolocalization with the P-CaMK-II antibody. The signal achieved with this PFA/methanol combination was also significantly greater than when Dent's fixative, 4% PFA/PBS or methanol were used alone, depending on the developmental time and location within the embryo.
When optimizing the technique described here and for each fixative and developmental time used, a control sample was prepared in which all steps were followed, except that the primary antibody was omitted. Such control samples lacked a fluorescent signal when imaged under the same conditions described above. This control is recommended for other investigators replicating this approach with any antibody.
The PFA/methanol fixative combination yielded the strongest P-CaMK-II signal and was also compatible with immunostaining for acetylated tubulin, which is a standard marker for cilia. Developmentally, the first ciliated organ that emerges and has been imaged in these studies is the Kupffer's vesicle (KV). The KV is located at the posterior end of the notochord as shown at the 12-somite (15 hpf) stage (Figure 1). The KV is a transient organ and is responsible for left-right asymmetry. It emerges at the 2-somite stage (12 hpf) and disappears around the 18-somite stage. Beating primary cilia generate a circular flow of fluid, which leads to an elevation of Ca2+ in the ciliated cells lining the KV and the activation of CaMK-II in discrete locations (Figure 1). P-CaMK-II reactivity appears and disappears on one side of the KV as long as cilia are beating.12 At this early stage, total embryonic CaMK-II levels are still only half the level as at 24 hpf and one tenth of the level at 3 days of development.11 Perhaps because total CaMK-II expression is relatively low at 15 hpf, any improvement in the immunostaining technique at this stage is especially important.
Between 24 and 72 hpf of development, P-CaMK-II appears on the apical surface of ciliated cells lining specific regions of the pronephric ducts (Figures 2,3). The immunoreactivity of total CaMK-II along the entire pronephric duct and throughout adjacent somites (Figure 2) demonstrates that only a subset of embryonic CaMK-II is activated (P-CaMK-II).
Fixation Conditions are Compatible with Preserving GFP Fluorescence
These fixation techniques are also compatible with retaining green fluorescent protein (GFP) fluorescence without enhancement (Figure 3). In the GFP-tagged CaMK-II construct that is used in this figure, GFP retains sufficient fluorescence though PFA/methanol fixation and subsequent immunostaining. In a high magnification view of cells lining the pronephric duct (Figure 3), the mosaic expression of GFP-CaMK-II can be viewed in cells that have also been immunostained for P-CaMK-II.
The zebrafish embryonic ear is another tissue in which the elevation of Ca2+, acting through CaMK-II, influences its development.14 Zebrafish ears normally appear at around one day of development. At this time, CaMK-II is intensely activated at the base of the kinocilia and at lower levels along the kinocilium (Figure 4). This set of images shows that this fixation and immunolocalization technique can detect staining within cilia, a structure whose cross-section is less than 1 μm. These cilia retain their structure throughout this fixation and immunostaining process.
An additional example of two-color counterstaining in the inner ear at a later time of development was achieved by staining with both Alexa488 phalloidin and anti-acetylated tubulin followed by an Alexa568 tagged secondary antibody (Figure 5). It is noteworthy that the PFA/methanol fixation method preserves both F-actin and tubulin, which is not true of all fixatives. This example is shown as a merged color image for the entire ear and then for sub-regions.14
A final representative example of two-color counterstaining was achieved with a strain of fish that produced embryos with membrane-targeted GFP (Figure 6). Membrane targeted GFP is not attached to any other protein and is lost when extracted with methanol, therefore this image was obtained from fish that were fixed with PFA alone. This result suggests that methanol treatment extracts membranes, so it is not recommended for proteins that may be exclusively membrane bound. The P-CaMK-II signal in this figure is diminished relative to that achieved if methanol were also used, but this demonstrates that at this stage and location (kidney) of the developing embryo, the signal is strong enough to be detected without methanol treatment. That is not true at the KV stage; i.e., methanol is required to visualize P-CaMK-II immunostaining. This example is only shown as a merged image where the kidney's pronephric duct is adjacent to trunk muscle.
In summary, the PFA/methanol fixation method described here is compatible with the preservation of GFP and with staining for F-actin, acetylated tubulin, total CaMK-II and P-CaMK-II.
Figure 1. P-CaMK-II Counterstained for Acetylated Tubulin (cilia) in Zebrafish KV. Views of a single live 12 somite stage (12 ss) embryo reveals the posterior location of the KV by the arrowhead (lateral view, A) and the circle within the box (ventral view, B). Embryos at this stage were fixed using PFA/methanol. Embryos were immunostained for acetylated tubulin followed by an Alexa488-labelled secondary antibody (green channel). Next, the rabbit polyclonal antibody against P-CaMK-II was followed by an Alexa568-labelled secondary antibody (red channel). Two-channel fluorescent image projections were acquired as described at progressively higher magnifications (C,D). Scale bar = 10 μm. This figure is modified from a previous publication.12 Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2. P-CaMK-II Counterstained for Total CaMK-II along Zebrafish Kidney. A single dechorionated embryo at 30 hpf was fixed using PFA/methanol. Embryos were then stained for total CaMK-II followed by the Alexa488 labeled secondary antibody (green). Next, the P-CaMK-II primary antibody was followed by the Alexa568 labeled secondary antibody (red). Staining reveals an enrichment of activated CaMK-II (in red) along the apical surface of cells that line the ducts of the pronephric zebrafish kidney whereas total CaMK-II is enriched at the somite boundaries of adjacent muscle tissue and throughout sarcomeres. Scale bar = 50 μm. These images were acquired at a lower magnification than is described in the text in order to visualize the entire kidney. This figure is modified from a previous publication.13 Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3. P-CaMK-II Counter Imaged for GFP in Zebrafish Kidney Cells. This 30 hpf embryo was injected with a cDNA encoding a dominant negative GFP-CaMK-II.13 Such injections typically show mosaic expression. The embryo was fixed using PFA/methanol and then immunostained for P-CaMK-II using an Alexa568 labeled secondary antibody. Imaging reveals that GFP persists through PFA/methanol fixation, rehydration, blocking and immunostaining. Scale bar = 10 μm. This figure is modified from a previous publication.13 Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4. P-CaMK-II Counterstained with Acetylated Tubulin in Zebrafish Inner Ear. This 30 hpf embryo was fixed using PFA/methanol. The anti-acetylated tubulin antibody was followed in order by the Alexa488-labeled secondary antibody, the P-CaMK-II antibody and the Alexa568 labeled secondary antibody. Staining reveals that P-CaMK-II is present along inner ear cilia and co-localizes with acetylated tubulin. Scale bar = 5 μm. This figure is modified from a previous publication.14 Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5. Actin and Acetylated Tubulin in Zebrafish Inner Ear. A three day old (72 hpf) zebrafish embryo was fixed and immunostained for acetylated tubulin using Alexa568-labeled secondary antibodies, followed by actin visualization using Alexa488 phalloidin. Cilia as well as axonal innervation of the ear is revealed by acetylated tubulin (in red) and F-actin structures include muscle fibers (in green). Two ciliated sensory regions of the zebrafish ear are shown in more detail: the anterior macula (am) and posterior crista (pc). Scale bar = 10 μm. This figure is modified from a previous publication.14 Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6. P-CaMK-II Counter Imaged for Membrane GFP in Zebrafish Kidney. This single merged image in which the β-actin:CAAX-GFP embryo (30 hpf) was fixed and stained for P-CaMK-II followed by the Alexa568 labeled secondary antibody. Staining reveals an enrichment of activated CaMK-II (in red) along the apical surface of cells that line the ducts of the pronephric zebrafish kidney. These kidney ductal cells are nestled just underneath muscle tissue and both are marked by the expression of membrane targeted GFP (in green). Scale bar = 50 μm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
The PFA/methanol method was developed in this laboratory with the primary objective of optimizing the immunolocalization of the phospho-T287-CaMK-II epitope during zebrafish development. This method successfully localized P-CaMK-II during the formation of several ciliated organs including the zebrafish KV,12 inner ear14 and kidney.13 Particularly at the KV stage, this technique was necessary. The success of this method is likely due to a combination of a) minimization of autofluorescence, b) preservation of the phospho-CaMK-II epitope and c) enhanced accessibility of the epitope to antibodies.
A primary limitation of this approach is the time of storage in methanol. While immunoreactivity of P-CaMK-II is maximal after two days in methanol at -20°C, the reactivity of this epitope is lost after one week of storage in methanol. It is not clear whether at this time the phosphate group is hydrolyzed or further denaturation occurs that decreases immunoreactivity. Methanol/EGTA at -20 °C is a traditionally rapid fixative for preserving tubulin-rich structures during the development of early embryos.22 However, methanol alone is not desirable for preserving morphology or even structures such as the actin cytoskeleton and must be preceded by PFA.
Additional advantages of this approach are that it also preserves other epitopes such as F-actin and acetylated tubulin and does not eliminate the native fluorescence of GFP. Other fixatives, such as Dent's fixative, are superior for other epitopes13 and remain compatible with P-CaMK-II staining, although P-CaMK-II staining is weaker in Dent's fixative than PFA/methanol. Since phospho-proteins are prevalent in signaling pathways that are active during early development, Dent's fixative and PFA/methanol are recommended as two fixatives for other phospho-epitopes in zebrafish embryos. In developing applications with this technique for other proteins and their antibodies, it has been helpful to have antibodies that are also reactive on immunoblots and to have cloned and overexpressed proteins with which antibodies can be validated.12
It is worth the effort to optimize techniques for immunolocalization because it a) can verify gene suppression at the protein level and b) enables the development of models of action. In this laboratory, the results of these assays have allowed the formulation of models through which CaMK-II functions. For example, its location in the KV is transient and asymmetric, like the role of this organ. In the kidney, its location on the apical side of pronephric ductal cells suggests roles that respond to signals from the duct. Finally, the activation of this enzyme in specific intense puncta at the base of ear kinocilia suggests a localized Ca2+ signal. The methods described here should also be useful to any investigator who seeks to obtain high-resolution images of any embryonic cell type in two fluorescent channels.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported by the National Science Foundation grant IOS-0817658.
1-phenyl-2-thiourea (PTU) | Sigma | P-7629 | 0.12% Stock solution. Dilute 1:40 in system water |
Alexa488 anti-mouse IgG | Life Technologies | A11001 | Goat polyclonal, use at 1:500 |
Alexa488 anti-rabbit IgG | Life Technologies | A11008 | Goat polyclonal, use at 1:500 |
Alexa488 phalloidin | Life Technologies | A12379 | Preferentially binds to F-actin |
Alexa568 anti-mouse IgG | Life Technologies | A11004 | Goat polyclonal, use at 1:500 |
Alexa568 anti-rabbit IgG | Life Technologies | A11011 | Goat polyclonal, use at 1:500 |
anti-acetylated a-tubulin | Sigma | T7451 | Mouse monoclonal, use at 1:500 |
anti-phospho-T287 CaMK-II | EMD Millipore | 06-881 | Rabbit polyclonal, use at 1:20 |
anti-total CaMK-II | BD Biosciences | 611292 | Mouse monoclonal, use at 1:20 |
Ethanol | Fisher | S96857 | Lab grade, 95% denatured |
Forceps | Fine Science Tools | 11252-20 | Dumont #5 |
Glass coverslips | VWR | 16004-330 | #1 thickness |
Glass microscope slides | Fisher | 12-550-15 | Standard glass slides |
Methanol | Fisher | A411 | Store in freezer |
Microcentrifuge tubes | VWR | 20170-038 | capped tubes, not sterile |
Normal goat serum | Life Technologies | 16210-064 | Aliquot 1ml tubes, store in freezer |
Paraformaldehyde | Sigma | P-6148 | Reagent grade, crystalline |
Phosphate buffered saline (PBS) | Quality Biological | 119-069-131 | 10X stock solution or made in lab |
Triton X-100 | Sigma | BP-151 | 10% solution in water, store at room temp |
Tween-20 | Life Technologies | 85113 | 10% solution in water, store at room temp |
Compound microscope | Nikon | E-600 | Mount on vibration-free table |
C1 Plus two-laser scanning confocal | Nikon | C1 Plus | Run by EZ-C1 program, but upgrades use "Elements" |