Optically transparent zebrafish embryos are widely used to study and visualize in real time the interactions between pathogenic microorganisms and the innate immune cells. Micro-injection of Mycobacterium abscessus, combined with fluorescence imaging, is used to scrutinize essential pathogenic features such as cord formation in zebrafish embryos.
Zebrafish (Danio rerio) embryos are increasingly used as an infection model to study the function of the vertebrate innate immune system in host-pathogen interactions. The ease of obtaining large numbers of embryos, their accessibility due to external development, their optical transparency as well as the availability of a wide panoply of genetic/immunological tools and transgenic reporter line collections, contribute to the versatility of this model. In this respect, the present manuscript describes the use of zebrafish as an in vivo model system to investigate the chronology of Mycobacterium abscessus infection. This human pathogen can exist either as smooth (S) or rough (R) variants, depending on cell wall composition, and their respective virulence can be imaged and compared in zebrafish embryos and larvae. Micro-injection of either S or R fluorescent variants directly in the blood circulation via the caudal vein, leads to chronic or acute/lethal infections, respectively. This biological system allows high resolution visualization and analysis of the role of mycobacterial cording in promoting abscess formation. In addition, the use of fluorescent bacteria along with transgenic zebrafish lines harbouring fluorescent macrophages produces a unique opportunity for multi-color imaging of the host-pathogen interactions. This article describes detailed protocols for the preparation of homogenous M. abscessus inoculum and for intravenous injection of zebrafish embryos for subsequent fluorescence imaging of the interaction with macrophages. These techniques open the avenue to future investigations involving mutants defective in cord formation and are dedicated to understand how this impacts on M. abscessus pathogenicity in a whole vertebrate.
Mycobacterium abscessus is an emerging pathogen that causes a wide spectrum of clinical syndromes in humans. These include cutaneous infections as well as severe chronic pulmonary infections, mostly encountered in immunocompromised and in cystic fibrosis patients1,2,3,4. M. abscessus is also regarded as a major rapidly-growing mycobacterial species responsible for nosocomial and iatrogenic infections in humans. Moreover, several recent reports highlighted the possibility that M. abscessus could cross the blood-brain barrier and induce important lesions in the central nervous system (CNS)5,6. Despite being a rapid grower, M. abscessus exhibits also several pathogenic features that are related to those of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, including the capacity to remain silent for years within granulomatous structures and to generate caseous lesions in the lungs7. More alarming is the low sensitivity of M. abscessus to antibiotics, rendering these infections extremely difficult to treat leading to a significant therapeutic failure rate8,9. The important threat of this species is mainly its intrinsic resistance to antibiotics, which is of major concern in public health institutions10 and a contraindication to lung transplantation11.
M. abscessus displays smooth (S) or rough (R) colony morphotypes that lead to different clinical outcomes. In contrast to the S strain, R bacteria have a tendency to grow end to end, leading to a rope or cord-like structure12,13. Several independent studies based on either cellular or animal models revealed the hyper-virulence phenotype of the R morphotype14,15. From epidemiological studies, the most severe cases of M. abscessus pulmonary infections appear to be associated with R variants16 which are the only variant that has been seen to persist for years in an infected host3. The morphotype difference relies on the presence (in S) or loss (in R) of surface-associated glycopeptidolipids (GPL)12. However, due to the inherent limitations of the currently available cellular/animal models used to study M. abscessus infection, our knowledge regarding the pathophysiological events of the R or S variants remains obscure. Infection of immuno-competent mice via intravenous or aerosol routes leads to transient colonization, impeding the use of mice to study persistent infections and for in vivo drug susceptibility testing17. Therefore, developing animal models amenable to the manipulation of the host response is a major challenge. In this context, non-mammalian models of infection have been developed recently, including Drosophila melanogaster18 that offers several advantages such as cost, speed and ethical acceptability over the mouse model. The zebrafish (Danio rerio) model of infection has also been explored to visualize, by non-invasive imaging, the progression and chronology of M. abscessus infection in a live animal19. Importantly, a proof of concept was also established to demonstrate its suitability for in vivo antibiotic assessments against M. abscessus17,20.
The zebrafish have been widely used during the last two decades to study the interactions between various pathogens and the host immune system21. The increasing success of this alternative vertebrate model relies on major and unique opportunities that motivated and validated its use for a better understanding of numerous viral and bacterial infections19,22,23,24,25,26,27,28,29. As opposed to most other animal models, zebrafish embryos are optically transparent, allowing non-invasive fluorescence imaging30. This has led to study M. abscessus infected zebrafish embryos with unprecedented details, culminating with the description of extracellular cording, that represent an example of bacterial morphological plasticity. Cording represents a new mechanism of subversion of the immune system and a key mechanism promoting pathogenesis of acute M. abscessus infection19.
This report describes new tools and methods using the zebrafish embryo to decipher the pathophysiological traits of M. abscessus infection and to study the intimate interactions between the bacilli and the innate immune system. First, a detailed microinjection protocol that includes processing of the bacterial inoculum, embryo preparation, and infection per se, is presented. Methods specifically adapted to assess M. abscessus virulence by measuring various parameters, such as host survival and bacterial burden, are presented. Special focus is given on how to monitor, at a spatiotemporal level, the fate and progression of the infection and the host immune response to M. abscessus using video microscopy. Moreover, to investigate the contribution and role of macrophages during M. abscessus infection, methods to generate macrophages-depleted embryos (using either genetically- or chemically-based approaches) are described. Finally, protocols to visualize the specific interactions with macrophages or neutrophils using either fixed or living embryos are documented.
The aim of this report is to stimulate further studies to shed new light into M. abscessus virulence mechanisms and particularly the role of cording in the establishment of an acute and uncontrolled infection process.
Zebrafish experimental procedures must comply with the relevant institutional and governmental regulations. For the present study, zebrafish experiments were done at the University Montpellier, according to European Union guidelines for handling of laboratory animals (http://ec.europa.eu/environment/chemicals/lab_animals/home_en.htm) and approved under the reference CEEA-LR-13007.
1. Preparation of Reagents and Microinjection Equipment
Figure 1. Positioning chambers for zebrafish injections. (A) U-shaped channels for eggs (left panel) and V-shaped channels for embryos (right panel). Zebrafish eggs/embryos are laid in the channels and aligned along the same axis. (B) Viewing chambers for microscopic observation. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
2. Preparation and Storage of the M. abscessus Inoculum
Figure 2. Preparation of dispersed M. abscessus inocula. Ziehl-Neelsen staining of R or S variants grown on broth medium prior to any treatment (upper panels) or after treatment (lower panels) to reduce the size and number of mycobacterial aggregates (successive steps of syringing, sonication and decantation). Bacteria were observed using a microscope with 100 X APO oil 1.4 NA objective). Scale bars: 20 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
3. Preparing Zebrafish Embryos
4. Micro-injection Procedure
NOTE: The micro-injection procedure for M. abscessus is similar to the one described previously for M. marinum injections32. To assess the chronology of M. abscessus infection (survival, bacterial loads, kinetic and characteristics of infection), injections in the caudal vein of 30 hpf embryos are preferred. To visualize the recruitment of immune cell, injections are done in localized sites such as is in tail muscles in 48 hpf embryo.
5. Generation of Macrophage-Depleted Embryos
NOTE: Selective depletion of macrophages from tissues is used to investigate their contribution and role during infection. To visualize the proper depletion of macrophages, it is recommended to use a transgenic line with fluorescent macrophages, where mCherry is specifically expressed under the control of the macrophage specific mpeg1 promoter19.
6. Bacterial Burden Quantification
7. Imaging M. abscessus- infected Embryos
Although various anatomical sites can be injected32, caudal vein injections are often used to generate systemic infection for subsequent analyses including survival experiments, bacterial burden determination, phagocytosis activity or cord formation. Injections in the tail muscles are used to assess the recruitment of macrophages at the site of injection (Figure 3A). To investigate and compare the virulence of R and S variants of M. abscessus, fluorescent bacterial suspensions are injected in the caudal vein of 30 hpf embryos (Figure 3A)19. In contrast to the S variant, the R morphotype induces a more robust and lethal infection in zebrafish embryos (Figure 3B), characterized by the rapid development of bacterial abscesses within the Central Nervous System (CNS) (Figure 3C). Systemic injections with both the R and S variants lead to CNS infections and difference in the pathology and virulence phenotypes can be quantified either by fluorescence microscopy observation (Figure 3C), by enumerating the CFU per fish (Figure 3D) or by determining the FPC of acquired images (Figure 3E). Importantly, CFU and FPC determination are correlated and point out to larger bacterial loads for the R strain than the S strain at 3 and 5 dpi. Overall, these results strongly support zebrafish as a relevant and non-invasive model of infection to study the chronology of the infection process.
Perhaps one of the most spectacular features was revealed by video-microscopy that allows visualizing serpentine cords within the CNS of embryos infected with the R variant (Figure 4). Thanks to the optical transparency of the embryos, the kinetic of R-cord formation could be monitored and imaged in a non-invasive manner, illustrating the high propensity of the R variant to replicate extracellularly. This uncontrolled replication rate, combined with cellular/tissue destruction rapidly leads to the development of abscesses and ultimately larval death.
Macrophages are known to play an important role during mycobacterial infection and particularly by driving the granuloma formation35. Two complementary strategies can be used to study M. abscessus growth/virulence in macrophage-depleted embryos: the lipo-clodronate- and morpholino-based procedures (Figure 5A). Infection of macrophage-depleted embryos with the R variant leads to a massive increase in the bacterial loads and cord production as revealed by video-microscopy (Figure 5B), leading to extremely rapid death (100% dead embryos at 3 dpi; Figure 5C). This clearly indicates that macrophages are required to control M. abscessus infection.
To further investigate the role of macrophages during infection, specific transgenic embryos harboring red fluorescent macrophages (mpeg1:mCherry) can be used19. Injection of M. abscessus expressing Wasabi into the tail muscle or in the caudal vein induces a marked recruitment of myeloid cells, mainly macrophages, at the site of infection. This recruitment leads to efficient phagocytosis of individual bacteria (Figure 6A-6B). Despite the presence of macrophages, confocal microscopy reveals the appearance of large bacterial cords that macrophages cannot phagocytize (Figure 6C). Taken together, these findings highlight a new mechanism of immune evasion based on the role of cording in preventing mycobacterial phagocytosis.
Figure 3. M. abscessus infection in zebrafish embryos. (A) (Top panel) Intravenous infection performed by injecting fluorescent M. abscessus (shown in white) in the caudal vein (arrow 1), posterior to the urogenital opening, in 30 hpf embryos. (Lower panel) Intramuscular infection performed by injecting fluorescent mycobacteria (shown in white) in the tail muscle over a somite (arrow 2), in 48 hpf embryos. (B-E) 30 hpf embryos intravenously infected with tdTomato-M. abscessus (R and S variants). (B) Survival curves of embryos infected with ≈ 300 CFU either R or S variants or PBS injected controls (n=20). Representative results from three independent experiments are shown. (C) Spatiotemporal visualization of either the R or the S variant expressing tdTomato (white) at various times points post-infection performed by fluorescence live imaging. For each strain, a representative fluorescence and transmission overlay of whole infected embryos is shown. The same embryos were imaged at 3 and 5 dpi. (D-E) Bacterial loads within embryos infected with either R or S variants (≈ 200 CFU) determined by CFU counting (D) or FPC measurements (E). (D) CFU from lysate of individual embryos at various time points post-infection determined by plating onto Middlebrook 7H10OADC supplemented with BBL MGIT PANTA. Results are expressed as mean log ± SD (horizontal bars) CFU per embryo from three independent experiments (n=5). (E) FPC measurements from individual living embryos at various time points post-infection based on particle analysis using ImageJ. Results are expressed as mean log ± SD (horizontal bars) FPC per embryo from three independent experiments (n=5). All images were obtained with an epifluorescence microscope equipped with a digital color camera. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4. In vivo cording of the R variant. 30 hpf embryos infected intravenously with the R variant of M. abscessus and imaged at various time points post-infection to visualize the progression of cord formation. The red arrow is used as a fixed reference point in order to follow the spatiotemporal evolution of the cord. The DIC pictures of the part of the tail containing the growing serpentine cord are boxed (microscope equipped with a color camera). Scale bars: 100 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5. Depletion of macrophages leads to increased cord proliferation. (A) Embryos are depleted using the lipo-clodronate-based procedure or the morpholino-based procedure. (Top panel) Clodronate-encapsulated liposomes (lipo-clodronate) are injected intravenously in 24 hpf Tg(mpeg1:mCherry) embryos. Within the circulation, lipo-clodronate is rapidly engulfed by macrophages that undergo subsequent apoptosis. (Left-lower panel) Injection of the morpholino preparation to knock-down the expression of the pu.1 gene into fertilized Tg(mpeg1:mCherry) zebrafish eggs. (Right-down panel) The correct depletion of macrophages in embryos is checked by fluorescence microscopy. (B-C) 30 hpf macrophage-containing (+) or macrophage-depleted (-) embryos (following lipo-clodronate treatment) are infected with M. abscessus R expressing tdTomato (shown in white). (B) Live imaging at 2 dpi shows exacerbation of the infection within macrophage-depleted embryos and hyper-cording. (C) Survival curves of the macrophage-containing or macrophage-depleted embryos infected with ≈300 CFU M. abscessus R (n=20). Representative results from three independent experiments are shown. All images were acquired with a microscope connected to a color camera. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6. Behavior of macrophages in embryos infected either locally or systemically with M. abscessus. (A) 48 hpf Tg(mpeg1:mCherry) zebrafish embryos are infected intramuscularly with Wasabi-expressing M. abscessus R. Live imaging using a confocal microscope to visualize recruited macrophages phagocytizing individual mycobacteria (in minutes post-infection, mpi). Maximum intensity projection showing an intense recruitment of macrophages (red) to the injection site (confocal microscope with 40X APO water 0.8 NA objective). Scale bar: 20 µm. (B-C) 48 hpf Tg(mpeg1:mCherry) embryos intravenously infected with M. abscessus R expressing Wasabi were fixed and imaged by confocal microscopy (40X) at 4 hpi (B) and 3 dpi (C). (B) Maximum intensity projection of macrophage (red) or other myeloid cells, presumably neutrophils (arrows), containing isolated mycobacteria (green) close to the site of injection (confocal microscope with 63X APO oil 1.33 NA objective). Scale bar: 10 µm. (C) Maximum intensity projection showing one macrophage (red) unable to phagocytize a cord (green) (confocal microscope with 63X APO oil 1.33 NA objective). Scale bar: 5 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
The zebrafish has recently emerged as an excellent vertebrate model system for studying the dynamics of bacterial infection using wide field and confocal imaging in real-time36. The combination of dispersed mycobacterial suspensions (protocol 2.2) together with micro-injection methods (protocol 4) allows reproducible systemic infections, and subsequent monitoring and visualization of the progression of the infection with a special focus on the bacterial interactions with host macrophages. Virulence of M. abscessus in vivo can be investigated thanks to the use of wild-type golden zebrafish37. To study interactions between M. abscessus and host myeloid cells, several transgenic zebrafish lines can be used such as Tg(mpeg1:mCherry) to visualize macrophages19. Additional transgenic reporter lines such as the as Tg(mpx:GFP)38 or Tg(lyz:DsRed)39 with either green of red neutrophils, respectively, can also be used to address the specific role of these granulocytes in response to the infection.
M. abscessus, and particularly the R variant, exhibits a natural propensity to form massive bacterial aggregates19, thus preventing reproducible micro-injection. In addition, the fact that the R variant forms much larger clumps than the S variant also precludes the potential comparison of the virulence phenotypes for the two isogenic variants. The protocol described in section 2 allows obtaining homogenous and dispersed M. abscessus suspensions for micro-injection in embryos. This preparation can be applied to any other mycobacterial species or mutant strains displaying excessive aggregating properties. Since the sonication step can alter the outermost mycobacterial cell wall layer, care should be taken to assess the impact of this physical treatment on bacterial viability for each new strain.
Determination of bacterial burdens routinely relies on CFU counting after plating lysed embryos on selective agar medium at various time points post-infection, as described in protocol 6.1. This procedure includes several limitations: since animals are euthanized, each embryo (or group of embryos) can be used for the determination of a single time point. In addition, this method remains inaccurate due to a large proportion of bacteria that are killed and/or lost during lysis, subsequent serial dilutions, or mainly by clumping. Counting the CFU is also a laborious task. As an alternative, the protocol 6.2 describes an efficient method to quantify the M. abscessus burden that includes limited handling steps, based on the analysis of fluorescent images of infected embryos with pixel quantification, as developed originally for M. marinum40,41. This FPC method based on particle analysis, shows a good correlation with the CFU countings. Similarly, by combining microscopy and fluorescence quantification, relative changes in innate immune cell numbers per embryo can be quantified by image analysis using adequate transgenic lines.
Zebrafish embryos can be used to evaluate the role of immune cell during infection and macrophage depletion was found to adversely affect host survival in response to M. abscessus infection. Specific macrophage depletion can be efficiently generated using the lipo-clodronate-based procedure (protocol 5.1) or the morpholino-based procedure (protocol 5.2). Nevertheless, since the presence of macrophages is crucial for the establishment and the maintenance of the vascular system and for correct embryonic development, it is recommended to ablate macrophage production at 24 hpf using lipo-clodronate.
The zebrafish embryo appears as a unique model to study M. abscessus infections and the role of extracellular cording as an immune system subversion strategy. If determinants controlling cording in M. abscessus can be identified, they could lead to the development of innovative therapeutic options. Linking the use of zebrafish together with innovative high throughput technologies42 also opens the field to drug discovery and new pharmacological approaches against this drug-resistant pathogen.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
The authors are grateful to K. Kissa for helpful discussions and for providing lipo-clodronate and L. Ramakrishnan for the generous gift of pTEC27 and pTEC15 that allow expression of tdTomato and Wasabi, respectively. This work forms part of the projects of the French National Research Agency (ZebraFlam ANR-10-MIDI-009 and DIMYVIR ANR-13-BSV3-007-01) and the European Community’s Seventh Framework Program (FP7-PEOPLE-2011-ITN) under grant agreement no. PITN-GA-2011-289209 for the Marie-Curie Initial Training Network FishForPharma. We wish also to thank the Association Gregory Lemarchal and Vaincre La Mucoviscidose (RF20130500835) for funding C.M. Dupont.
BBL MGIT PANTA | BD Biosciences | 245114 | |
Bovine Serum Albumin | Euromedex | 04-100-811-E | |
Catalase from Bovine Liver | Sigma-Aldrich | C40 | |
Difco Middlebrook 7H10 Agar | BD Biosciences | 262710 | |
Difco Middlebrook 7H9 Broth | BD Biosciences | 271310 | |
Ethyl 3-aminobenzoate methanesulfonate salt (Tricaine) | Sigma-Aldrich | A5040 | |
Oleic Acid | Sigma-Aldrich | O1008 | |
Paraformaldehyde | Delta Microscopie | 15710 | |
Phenol Red | Sigma-Aldrich | 319244 | |
Tween 80 | Sigma-Aldrich | P4780 | |
Agar | Gibco Life Technologie | 30391-023 | |
Low melting agarose | Sigma-Aldrich | ||
Instant Ocean Sea Salts | Aquarium Systems Inc | ||
Borosilicate glass capillaries | Sutter instrument Inc | BF100-78-10 | 1mm O.D. X 0.78 mm I.D. |
Micropipette puller device | Sutter Instrument Inc | Flamming/Brown Micropipette Puller p-87 | |
Microinjector | Tritech Research | Digital microINJECTOR, MINJ-D | |
Tweezers | Sciences Tools inc | Dumont # M5S | |
Microloader Tips | Eppendorf |