Targeting brain-resident cells for direct lineage-reprogramming offers new perspectives for brain repair. Here we describe a protocol of how to prepare cultures enriched for brain-resident pericytes from the adult human cerebral cortex and convert these into induced neurons by retrovirus-mediated expression of the transcription factors Sox2 and Ascl1.
Direct lineage-reprogramming of non-neuronal cells into induced neurons (iNs) may provide insights into the molecular mechanisms underlying neurogenesis and enable new strategies for in vitro modeling or repairing the diseased brain. Identifying brain-resident non-neuronal cell types amenable to direct conversion into iNs might allow for launching such an approach in situ, i.e. within the damaged brain tissue. Here we describe a protocol developed in the attempt of identifying cells derived from the adult human brain that fulfill this premise. This protocol involves: (1) the culturing of human cells from the cerebral cortex obtained from adult human brain biopsies; (2) the in vitro expansion (approximately requiring 2-4 weeks) and characterization of the culture by immunocytochemistry and flow cytometry; (3) the enrichment by fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) using anti-PDGF receptor-β and anti-CD146 antibodies; (4) the retrovirus-mediated transduction with the neurogenic transcription factors sox2 and ascl1; (5) and finally the characterization of the resultant pericyte-derived induced neurons (PdiNs) by immunocytochemistry (14 days to 8 weeks following retroviral transduction). At this stage, iNs can be probed for their electrical properties by patch-clamp recording. This protocol provides a highly reproducible procedure for the in vitro lineage conversion of brain-resident pericytes into functional human iNs.
As opposed to reprogramming of somatic cells into induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs), which in turn are endowed with a plethora of differentiation potentials, direct reprogramming aims for straight conversion of one specific cell type into another. With respect to their application in the context of disease modeling and potential cell-based therapies, both reprogramming approaches have specific advantages and disadvantages. Reprogramming into iPSCs (i) provides a virtually infinite source of cells; (ii) allows for genetic engineering; (iii) endows with a nearly unlimited differentiation potential. However, major disadvantages of iPSCs entail the risk of tumorigenicity of the undifferentiated cells (teratoma formation in vivo) and the need for ex vivo cultivation and subsequent transplantation if these cells are to be used for cell-based therapies. Conversely, direct lineage-reprogramming is restricted by the lower yield of the desired cells which correlates directly with the number of the targeted cells of the starting population, but possesses the advantage that lineage-reprogrammed cells appear to exhibit no tumorigenic risk upon transplantation1,2; furthermore, direct reprogramming can even be achieved in situ, i.e. within the organ where these cells would be required, thus avoiding the need of transplantation.
With this in mind, our lab has pursued the possibility of lineage-reprogramming brain-resident cells into iNs as a novel approach towards cell-based therapies of neurodegenerative diseases. Brain-resident cells that may be potentially considered as cellular targets for lineage-reprogramming comprise different types of macroglia (astrocytes, NG2 cells and oligodendrocytes), microglia, and microvessel-associated cells (endothelial cells and pericytes). We have extensively studied the in vitro reprogramming potential of astroglia of the cerebral cortex of early postnatal mice3-5. In search of similarly suitable cell sources for direct lineage-reprogramming in the adult human brain, we encountered a cell population that can be successfully reprogrammed into iNs and exhibit hallmarks of pericytes. Here we describe a protocol of how to harvest these cells from adult human brain biopsies, to expand and enrich these cells in vitro, and finally successfully reprogram a substantial fraction of these in vitro expanded cells (in the range of 25-30%) into iNs. Reprogramming can be achieved by simultaneous retrovirus-mediated co-expression of two transcription factors, sox2 and ascl1. These PdiNs were found to acquire the ability of repetitive action potential firing and to serve as synaptic targets for other neurons indicating their capability of integrating into neural networks. Our protocol provides a straightforward procedure for the isolation and lineage conversion of adult human brain pericytes into iNs.
1. Isolation and Culturing of Adult Human Brain Cells
Experiments involving human tissue should be performed in accordance with all relevant governmental and institutional regulations regarding the use of human material for research purposes. The present protocol was developed in accordance with the approval by the ethical committee of the Medical Faculty of the LMU Munich and written informed consent from all patients.
This protocol of preparing cultures of the human adult cerebral cortex has been established using specimen of patients of both sexes suffering from temporal lobe epilepsy or other deep-seated non-traumatic, non-malignant lesions. The tissue obtained from the surgical room comprised exclusively the access channel to the brain lesion and therefore is considered healthy. The age range of the patients was 19-70 years.
2. In vitro Expansion and Characterization of Adult Human Brain Cells
3. Enrichment for Pericyte-derived Cells by Fluorescence Activated Cell Sorting
4. Retroviral Transduction of Pericyte-derived Cells and Reprogramming into Induced Neurons
Note: Refer to local biosafety guidelines when handling retroviral particles. In Germany the use of the retroviruses employed here require biosafety level 2. For production of retroviral particles refer to protocol6. For retroviral constructs used for reprogramming, refer to Karow et al. (2012). Retroviruses were pseudotyped with VSV-G (vesicular stomatitis virus-glycoprotein)5. For production please refer to Gavrilescu et al6.
5. Characterization of Induced Neurons by Immunocytochemistry
The first outcome of this protocol after successfully establishing a culture from a specimen of human adult cerebral cortex consists in the identification of the cellular composition of the culture. Immunocytochemistry for cell type specific proteins reveals a considerable degree of heterogeneity between cultures derived from specimen of different patients (Figure 1A). As quantified by flow cytometry there is always a substantial fraction of cells that express PDGFRβ (on average ~75%, ranging from 30 to up to 99%); other markers of pericytes such as CD146, NG2 and CD13 are typically expressed in a lower range (Figure 1B). Likewise SMA is expressed in a minor subpopulation of the cultured cells, as determined by immunocytochemistry (Figure 1A). At passage 0 (P0), there are usually <10% of CD34-positive endothelial cells, and their number declines below detection with further passaging. Likewise, astrocytes comprise only a negligible contamination at earlier passages. Furthermore, there are typically no cells that stain for neural stem cell, neuronal, or oligodendrocyte markers. Immunocytochemical and flow cytometry data are fully corroborated by quantitative RT-PCR7. In sum, the largest fraction within the culture expresses proteins and mRNAs characteristic of pericytes. A further enrichment for pericyte-derived cells can be achieved by FACS at this stage. This is particularly relevant when the purity of the culture is at the lower end of the spectrum as reflected by the level of PDGFRβ expression. Thus, we have utilized an antibody against PDGFRβ (CD140b) alone or in combination with an anti-CD146 antibody, while excluding any CD34-positive contaminants, to FAC-sort specifically pericytes (Figure 1C).
Transducing these cultures with control viruses encoding a reporter gene only, does not alter their marker expression profile (assessed 3-4 weeks following transduction), indicating that these cells remain in the pericyte lineage. Likewise, retrovirus-mediated expression of Sox2 alone does not result in any overt changes in morphology nor induces bIII-tubulin expression suggesting that Sox2 alone is not sufficient to induce a fate conversion. In contrast, a low percentage (approximately 10%) of the cells transduced with an ascl1-encoding retrovirus alone exhibit βIII-tubulin expression, however without acquiring a neuronal morphology. Strikingly, nearly 50% of all sox2- and ascl1-cotransduced cells show βIII-tubulin expression and even more importantly, a third of these double-transduced cells (visualized by their double reporter expression) also display neuronal processes (Figure 2). Along with the acquisition of neuronal features, expression of PDGFRβ is down-regulated7. With further maturation in culture, sox2- and ascl1-coexpressing cells also become immunoreactive for the more mature neuronal markers MAP2 (staining dendritic processes) and NeuN (staining predominantly neuronal cell bodies). As discussed below these changes in marker expression also correlate with the acquisition of electrophysiological hallmarks of neurons. In sum, these data provide evidence for the direct fate conversion of pericyte-derived cells into iNs, referred to as PdiNs. These PdiNs possess the competence to establish functional postsynaptic compartments as revealed in coculture experiments with neurons of the embryonic mouse cerebral cortex. This competence can be demonstrated electrophysiologically in the appearance of synaptic inputs (see discussion below) as well as the decoration of dendritic processes of PdiNs with presynaptic terminals derived from co-cultured neurons (characterized by clusters of vesicular neurotransmitter transporters, e.g. vGluT1 immunoreactivity). These data further indicate the ability of PdiNs to integrate into neuronal circuits.
Figure 1. Heterogeneous expression of pericyte markers in cultures derived from the adult human cerebral cortex. A) Fluorescent micrographs illustrating the heterogeneous expression of pericyte markers (PDGFRb, SMA, CD146) as revealed by immunocytochemistry. Scale bar = 50 µm. B) The histogram summarizes the relative numbers of cells positive for the pericyte markers PDGFRβ (CD140b), CD13, and CD146 as determined by flow cytometry of different patient-derived cultures. CD34 is a marker for endothelial cells. C) FACS dot plots depicting isotype control- and CD146/ CD140b-stained human cells for sorting of the double-positive pericytes (highlighted by the red box) for subsequent reprogramming. Note the high rate of PDGFRβ expression and the heterogeneity with regard to CD146 expression in this particular culture.
Figure 2. Reprogramming of adult human pericyte-derived cells into iNs. Top: Experimental set-up. Below: Fluorescent micrographs depicting cells transduced with retrovirus encoding sox2-IRES-GFP and ascl1-IRES-DsRed. Note that only double transduced cells (arrowheads) express bIII-tubulin (right panel) and exhibit neuronal morphology.
cell division [%] | cell death [%] | bIII-tubulin+ [%] | |
untransduced | 36 | 3 | 0 |
Sox2 | 46 | 7 | 0 |
Ascl1 | 26 | 33 | 7 |
Sox2-Ascl1 | 3 | 36 | 25 |
Table 1. Behavior of pericyte-derived cells undergoing conversion into PdiNs as assessed by continuous live imaging. Note that Sox2- and Ascl1 co-expressing cells exit cell cycle. Moreover, note the high rate of cell death following Ascl1 or Sox2 and Ascl1- coexpression. Taking into account these distinct cellular events, approximately 25% of all co-transduced cells become iNs.
The present protocol describes the in vitro expansion and enrichment of pericyte-derived cells following isolation from the adult human cerebral cortex and the subsequent conversion into iNs by retrovirus-mediated expression of the neurogenic transcription factors Sox2 and Ascl1. Such protocol provides an experimental in vitro system to study the lineage-conversion of brain-resident cells into neurons and potentially also glia, with the goal in mind to ultimately translate this direct conversion approach into the in vivo setting of the adult brain.
Technical Considerations
In our study we utilized human brain tissue from patients aged between 19 and 70 years, from both sexes. We did not notice a overt difference in reprogramming efficiency depending on gender or age7. It is nevertheless recommended to document this information as more subtle differences may nonetheless be observed that escaped our attention.
It is further recommended to commence processing as early as possible following transfer of the tissue sample to the lab. There will be necessarily some unknowns for how long the tissue has remained in the surgical room prior to transfer to the experimentalist. We estimate that in our study7 the time between removal from the patient’s brain to the start of the culturing procedure ranged between 2-6 hr, with the samples being kept all time on ice. No overt difference in the ease of subsequent processing nor any adverse outcome were noticed within this time window.
A critical assessment for any protocol concerns its simplicity, reproducibility, and efficiency. The present protocol is straightforward in that during a first phase cells are expanded in an inexpensive medium which can be easily obtained, followed by a second phase of cell reprogramming using only two transcription factors and culturing in a defined medium.
Regarding reproducibility, we observed that the quality of the retrovirus preparation is of utmost importance, with low titer virus preparations used at dilutions to match the number of infectious particles of high titer viruses often resulting in failure of reprogramming. In fact we noted that the same pericyte culture in which reprogramming had failed previously could be successfully converted into iNs when using high titer viruses.
Regarding efficiency of conversion, we have assessed the number of βIII-tubulin-positive cells derived from sox2- and ascl1-cotransduced cells using continuous live imaging. Live imaging allows for assessing the number of cells that undergo cell division or cell death during the conversion process, while such information is lacking when the number of generated iNs is determined only at the end point of the experiment. In fact using time-lapse video microscopy (for the procedure refer to Ortega et al.8) it was observed that untransduced and single factor-transduced cells continue proliferating, while sox2- and ascl1-cotransduced cells rapidly exit the cell cycle. Moreover, a significant fraction of the latter population undergoes cell death. While retrovirus toxicity cannot be formally excluded from the data obtained in our study7, the fact that increased cell death was observed only when ascl1 was expressed (alone or in combination with sox2), we interpret this as evidence for a catastrophic conflict of cell fates. Taking these two events into account, we estimate that 25% of all sox2- and ascl1-cotransduced cells convert into bIII-tubulin positive iNs (Table 1).
As co-transduction is absolutely required for successful reprogramming, one may consider employing a viral vector encoding both genes to optimize the amount of cells expressing both factors at the same time.
Recently, Ladewig et al. developed a protocol for the efficient conversion of fibroblasts into iNs obtaining a yield of 200% by using small molecule-based inhibition of glycogen synthase kinase-3β and SMAD signaling9. It will be interesting to determine whether these add-ons to our protocol improve the yield of PdiN production.
Another interesting outcome of the live imaging of the reprogramming process concerns the fact that the conversion of adult human pericytes into iNs occurs at a rather slow tempo compared to similar reprogramming protocols in cultures of different somatic cells of mouse origin4. This is consistent with the characteristic slow maturation of human neurons10.
While we have not systematically analyzed the impact of the oxygen tension on the yield of PdiN production, we noted that incubation in low oxygen conditions (5%) generally gave superior results compared to culturing the cells in normoxic conditions (21%). Recently, Davila et al. described a similar enhancing effect by reduced oxygen tension for the induction of iNs from human fibroblasts11.
Our protocol is based on the retroviral delivery of sox2 and ascl1 while other direct conversion protocols have employed inducible lentiviral vectors1,12,13. More recently we have also successfully applied doxycycline-inducible lentiviral constructs encoding sox2 and ascl1, indicating that a relatively short pulse (10 days) of Sox2 and Ascl1 expression is sufficient to cause pericyte-to-neuron conversion. The retroviruses used in our study7 were designed for reduced silencing5. Accordingly, we did not notice the appearance of neurons devoid of reporter gene expression. However, the possibility that the overall expression levels of both transgenes and reporter change over time cannot be excluded. Integration-free approaches (utilizing Sendai viruses) have been lately employed in case of the generation of induced neural progenitors14, but it is currently not known whether this or even virus-free reprogramming strategies can be successfully applied to convert human pericytes. Finally, whether pericytes derived from other tissues can undergo conversion into induced neural cell types remains to be tested.
Conceptual Considerations
A critical outcome of reprogramming of somatic cells into iNs concerns their functionality15. We have assessed the electrophysiological properties of PdiNs at different time points following the onset of the reprogramming process. At very early stages, i.e. 2 weeks following retroviral transduction, PdiNs exhibit barely signs of electrical excitability, despite βIII-tubulin expression at this stage. Thus, most of the electrophysiological analyses were conducted 4-8 weeks following transduction with sox2 and ascl1. As described in Karow et al., PdiNs are characterized by considerable immaturity as reflected by high input resistances and a low frequency of action potential firing. Further maturation can be promoted by co-culturing PdiNs with neurons derived from the mouse E14 cerebral cortex. Under these conditions, PdiNs exhibit higher action potential frequencies and increased sodium currents7. Moreover, coculturing reveals the competence of PdiNs to receive functional synaptic input from mouse neurons. In sum, PdiNs acquire functional neuronal properties which can be further enhanced upon coculturing with other neurons. However, it remains to be shown whether PdiNs can also establish functional presynaptic compartments. Further studies transplanting PdiNs into the brain are needed to reveal their potential to reach full maturity and functionality.
Using sox2 and ascl1 as reprogramming factors we noted that the resulting PdiNs acquire features of GABAergic neurons7. Interestingly, other groups have developed protocols to convert fibroblasts into iNs by using different transcription factor and/or microRNA combinations with the result that the developing iNs acquired distinct neurotransmitter specification such as a glutamatergic, dopaminergic, and cholinergic phenotype1,16-18. It remains to be tested whether the factor combinations used in fibroblasts induce the same transmitter identity in PdiNs. Moreover, recent work has expanded the conversion spectrum beyond neurogenesis to generate neural stem cells19,20 or glial, in particular oligodendrocytes21,22. If these reprogramming protocols elicit a similar outcome in adult human brain pericyte-derived cells, this would greatly widen the panorama of applications of this important brain-resident cell type.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
We are grateful to Dr. Magdalena Götz for her input during the development of this protocol. We thank Dr. Marius Wernig (Stanford University) for generously providing us with the sox2 coding sequence. We are also very grateful to Dr. Alexandra Lepier for virus production. This work was supported by grants of the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (BE 4182/2-2) and the BMBF (01GN1009A) to B.B., and the Bavarian State Ministry of Sciences, Research and the Arts to M.K. and B.B. C.S. received funding from the binational SYSTHER-INREMOS Virtual Institute (German and Slovenian Federal Ministries of Education and Research) and the DFG (SFB 824).
anti-CD140b-PE | BD Biosciences | 558821 | use 1:100 |
anti-CD146-FITC | AbD Serotec | MCA2141FT | use 1:100 |
anti-CD13-FITC | AbD Serotec | MVA1270A488T | use 1:100 |
anti-CD34-APC | BD Biosciences | 560940 | use 1:100 |
anti-PDGFRβ | Cell Signaling | 3169S | use 1:200 |
anti-CD146 | Abcam | Ab75769 | use 1:400 |
anti-NG2 | Millipore | AB5320 | use 1:400 |
anti-SMA | Sigma-Aldrich | A2547 | use 1:400 |
anti-βIII-tubulin | Sigma-Aldrich | T8660 | use 1:400 |
anti-MAP2 | Sigma-Aldrich | M4403 | use 1:200 |
anti-GFAP | Sigma-Aldrich | G3893 | use 1:600 |
anti-GFP | Aves Labs | GFP 10-20 | use 1:1000 |
anti-RFP | Chromotek | 5F8 | use 1:500 |
anti-S100β | Sigma-Aldrich | S2532 | use 1:300 |
anti-NeuN | Millipore | MAB377 | use 1:200 |
anti-GABA | Sigma-Aldrich | A2052 | use 1:500 |
anti-Calretinin | Millipore | AB5054 | use 1:500 |
anti-vGluT1 | SYnaptic SYstems | 135511 | use 1:1000 |
Rat IgG1 isotype control FITC | AbD Serotec | 11-4301-81 | use 1:100 |
Rat IgG1 isotype control PE | AbD Serotec | 12-4301-81 | use 1:100 |
Rat IgG1 isotype control APC | AbD Serotec | 17-4301-81 | use 1:100 |
TrypLE | Invitrogen | 12605-010 | |
DMEM, high glucose, GlutaMAX | Invitrogen | 61965 | |
B27 serum-free supplement | Invitrogen | 17504044 | |
fetal calf serum | Invitrogen | 10106-169 | perform heat inactivation by incubation at 56 °C for 30 min |
Penicillin-Streptomycin | Invitrogen | 15140122 | |
HBSS (Hanks Balanced Salt Solution) | Invitrogen | 24020-091 | |
Dulbecco's PBS without CaCl2 and MgCl2 (D-PBS, 1×; Invitrogen, cat. no. 14190) | Invitrogen | 14190 | |
HEPES | Sigma-Aldrich | H3375 | |
Poly-D-lysine hydrobromide (PDL) | Sigma-Aldrich | P0899 | |
PFA (paraformaldehyde) | Sigma-Aldrich | P1648 | |
Bovine serum albumin | Sigma-Aldrich | A9418 | |
Triton X-100 | Sigma-Aldrich | T9284 | |
DAPI (4′,6-Diamidin-2-phenylindole) dilactate | Sigma-Aldrich | 042M4005 | |
Aqua-Poly/Mount | Polysciences | 18606-20 | |
Polypropylene round-bottom tubes | BD Biosciences | 352063 | |
Polystyrene round-bottom tubes with cell-strainer cap | BD Biosciences | 352235 | |
24-well plates | Orange Scientific | 5530305 | |
75 cm2 culture flasks | Greiner Bio-One | 658175 | |
25 cm2 culture flasks | Greiner Bio-One | 690175 | |
Disposable pipettes 10 ml | Sarstedt | ######### | |
Glass Pasteur pipettes (150 mm) | Fisherbrand | FB50251 | |
Glass coverslips 12 mm diameter | Menzel | CB00120RA1 | |
Surgical disposable scalpels | B. Braun | 5518083 | |
Tissue culture dishes | Greiner Bio-One | 633180 | |
Conical tubes 15ml | BD Biosciences | 352095 | |
Laminar flow hood | |||
Centrifuge and swing-out rotor with adapters for 15 ml and 50 ml tubes | Hettich Lab Technology | 1406 | |
Flow cytometry cell sorter: FACSAria l with FACSDiva software | BD Biosciences | ||
Humified cell culture incubator | Eppendorf Galaxy 170R | ||
Wather bath at 37 °C | |||
FACSFlow sheath fluid | BD Biosciences | 342003 | |
Epifluorescence microscope BX61 | Olympus | ||
Confocal microscope LSM710 | Zeiss |