Here, we describe a general protocol and design that could be applied to identify trace amounts and minor constituents in the complex natural product formulations (matrixes) in Tibetan medicine.
Tibetan medicines are complex and contain numerous unknown compounds, making in-depth research on their molecular structures crucial. Liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (LC-ESI-TOF-MS) is commonly used to extract Tibetan medicine; however, many unpredictable unknown compounds remain after using the spectrum database. The present article developed a universal method for identifying components in Tibetan medicine using ion trap mass spectrometry (IT-MS). The method includes standardized and programmed protocols for sample preparation, MS setting, LC prerun, method establishment, MS acquisition, multiple-stage MS operation, and manual data analysis. Two representative compounds in the Tibetan medicine Abelmoschus manihot seeds were identified using multiple-stage fragmentation, with a detailed analysis of typical compound structures. In addition, the article discusses aspects such as ion mode selection, mobile phase adjustment, scanning range optimization, collision energy control, collision mode switchover, fragmentation factors, and limitations of the method. The developed standardized analysis method is universal and can be applied to unknown compounds in Tibetan medicine.
The qualitative analysis of trace components in traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) has become a crucial topic in research. Due to the high numbers of compounds in TCM, it is difficult to isolate them for nuclear magnetic resonance spectrometer (NMR) or X-ray diffractometer (XRD) analysis, making mass spectrometry (MS)-based methods that only require low sample volumes increasingly popular. Additionally, liquid chromatography (LC) coupled with MS has been widely used in TCM research in recent years for the improved separation of complex samples and qualitative analysis of chemical compounds1. One common method is liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (LC-ESI-TOF-MS), which is widely used in qualitative research on Tibetan medicine2. With this method, complex components are enriched and separated in an LC column, and the mass-to-charge ratio (m/z) of the adduct ions is observed using an MS detector. Searching tandem MS (MS/MS or MS2) databases is currently the fastest approach for confident compound annotations in small molecule analysis using quadrupole time-of-flight (Q-TOF) MS and Orbitrap MS3. However, the poor quality of databases and the presence of various isomers hinder the identification of unknown compounds. In addition, the information provided by the MS/MS database is limited4,5,6,7. It is significant to investigate the chemical compounds in each TCM using a general protocol that can be widely applied to other TCM.
IT-MS captures a wide range of ions by applying different radio frequency (RF) voltages to the ring electrodes8. IT-MS can perform time-series multiple-stage MS scans in diverse chronological orders, providing ingredient multiple-stage MS (MSn) fragmentation, where n is the number of product ion stages9. Linear IT-MS is considered the best for structure identification as it can be used for sequential MSn experiments10. Targeted ions can be isolated and accumulated in linear IT-MS1. The MSn (n ≥ 3) in IT-MS provides more fragment information than MS/MS in Q-TOF-MS. Since IT-MS cannot lock the target ion and its fragment ions, it is a powerful tool for the structure elucidation of unknown compounds, including isomers1. MSn technology has been widely applied to the structural analysis of unknown proteins, peptides, and polysaccharides11,12. The abundance level of fragment ions in MSn provides more molecular fragment information on targeted compounds in complex samples than MS/MS in Q-TOF-MS. Hence, applying MSn technology to structural identification in TCM is essential.
Tibetan medicine is a significant component of TCM13, and these medicines are primarily derived from animals, plants, and minerals found in the plateau area14. The Tibetan medicine Abelmoschus manihot seeds (AMS) is the seed of Abelmoschus manihot (linn.) medicus. AMS is a traditional herbal medicine used to treat conditions such as atopic dermatitis, rheumatism, and leprosy. It contains chalcone, which possesses antibacterial, antifungal, anticancer, antioxidative, and anti-inflammatory effects15. In the present study, MSn procedures were improved, and a detailed method was developed to identify compound structures in the Tibetan medicine AMS using IT-MS and MSn. Certain MS parameters, including the ion mode, scanning range, and collision mode, were optimized to overcome problems in identifying trace compounds. This study aims to promote the standardized structure identification of trace compounds in TCM.
1. Sample preparation
2. MS setting
3. LC prerun, method establishment, and MS acquisition
4. Operating multiple-stage mass spectrometry
5. Manual MSn data analysis
Cellobiose was used as a model to verify the feasibility of MSn in positive ion mode. As shown in Figure 2A, the ESI-MS (positive ion mode) of cellobiose [C12H22O11]+ produced the protonated molecule [M+H]+ at m/z 365. The product ion scan (CID-MS/MS) of [M+H]+ at m/z 365 resulted in the second fragment ion at m/z 305 (Figure 2B), which was further analyzed using MS3 and MS4 analyses (Figure 2C,D). MS3 analysis resulted in the third fragment ion at m/z 254, and the MS4 analysis resulted in the fourth fragment ion at m/z 185. The MS/MS analysis (Figure 2E) revealed that the lost fragment ion at m/z 60 indicated a sequence of ion fragmentation at m/z 365, namely ring-opening hydrolysis (marked in blue), C-C bond cleavage (marked in red), and dehydration (marked in green). Similarly, the MS3 analysis revealed that the lost fragment ion at m/z 60 indicated the C-C bond cleavage (marked in red) of an ion at m/z 305. The MS4 analysis showed that the lost fragment ion at m/z 60 implied hydrolysis (marked in blue) and dehydration (marked in green), resulting in the cleavage of the ion with m/z 245 into an ion with m/z 185. The step fracture in the MSn analysis indicated that this method was feasible for investigating the structure of carbohydrates.
The preliminary qualitative analysis of AMS using LC-Q-TOF-MS revealed the presence of numerous unknown compounds. One of these, an ion at m/z 617, was selected for MSn analysis in negative mode. The product ion scan (CID-MS/MS) of the [M-H]− at m/z 617 in AMS produced a second fragment ion at m/z 571. The MS3 analysis of this fragment ion produced a third fragment ion at m/z 525, and the MS4 analysis produced fourth fragment ions at m/z 345 and 273 (Figure 3A–D). The MS3 of m/z 571 afforded a fragment ion at m/z 525 by the loss of the CH2OH portion as methanol (−32 Da) and the OH portion (−18 Da) as water. These MS4 results were used for the manual identification of the "core" structure of the compound, and its original structure was determined by comparing the m/z values of the ion and its fragment ions. The molecular structure of the compound at m/z 617 and its cleavage paths in MSn are shown in Figure 3E. Another unknown compound at m/z 365 was analyzed in positive mode using MSn. The product ion scan (CID-MS/MS) of the [M+H]+ ion at m/z 365 in AMS produced second fragment ions at m/z 299, m/z 329, and m/z 347. The MS3 analysis of these fragment ions produced a third fragment ion at m/z 231 (Figure 4A–C). The molecular structure and cleavage mechanism of the compound at m/z 365 are shown in Figure 4E.
Figure 1: Identifying unknown compound structures in Tibetan medicine using IT-MS and multiple-stage mass spectrometry analysis. (A) The mobile phase forliquid chromatography. (B) The liquid chromatography pump. (C) The sample room. (D) The ion source for MS. (E) The internal structure of the ion trap module in MS. (F) The MS4 spectrum. (G) The molecular structure information from the MS4 results. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Multiple-stage fragmentation of cellobiose via IT-MS in positive ion mode. (A) Original mass spectrum of cellobiose. (B) Fragment ions in the MS/MS spectrum. (C) Fragment ions in the MS3 spectrum. (D) Fragment ions in the MS4 spectrum. (E) The cleavage mechanism and molecular structure of cellobiose. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Multiple-stage fragmentation and structural analysis of the unknown AMS compound ion at m/z 617 via IT-MS in negative ion mode. (A) Partial mass spectrum of AMS. (B) Fragment ions in the MS/MS spectrum. (C) Fragment ions in the MS3 spectrum. (D) Fragment ions in the MS4 spectrum. (E) The cleavage mechanism and molecular structure of the AMS compound ion at m/z 617. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Multiple-stage fragmentation structural analysis of the unknown AMS compound ion at m/z 365 via IT-MS in positive ion mode. (A) Partial mass spectrum of AMS. (B) Fragment ions in the MS/MS spectrum. (C) Fragment ions in the MS3 spectrum. (D) The cleavage mechanism and molecular structure of the AMS compound ion at m/z 365. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
IT-MS and its MSn technology offer a new approach to identifying the structure of trace TCM compounds. Unlike Q-TOF-MS, which could not deeply identify the fragment ions, IT-MS with MSn technology excels due to its ability to isolate and accumulate ions. This article outlines a method for identifying trace compounds in Tibetan medicine using the IT-MS and MSn technique. The method utilizes the n value in MSn to determine the amount of fragment ion information provided. The crucial steps in this method include selecting the appropriate scan range and adjusting the CE value, which lead to the identification of valuable fragments.
In general, the MSn analysis of saccharides is best performed in positive ion mode16, while phenolic acids and alkaloids are best analyzed in negative ion mode. The response of the compound in the ESI source can be improved by adjusting the mobile phase with additives such as formic acid, acetic acid, and ammonium acetate17. An atmospheric-pressure chemical ionization source can be considered for compounds with weak polarity. Choosing an appropriate scan range can increase the intensity of the fragment ions, which is beneficial for the next stage of MSn because of the inevitable energy decay in each MSn. The m/z of the fragment ion should be located in the central region of the scanning range to obtain the best corresponding intensity. If an ion has double or multiple charges, fragment ions with higher m/z values can be obtained by decreasing the charge number during fragmentation. In this case, the end m/z of the scanning range should be set to be larger. The CID mode is suitable for most compounds in MSn analysis18. If the intensity of the fragment ion is insufficient, the CE value can be increased by 5% at a time. When there are multiple, complex fragment ions in MSn, a lower CE value is needed to control the ion dissociation. The pulsed-Q collision-induced dissociation mode, which is suitable for small molecules, provides more detailed information about low-molecular weight fragment ions than CID mode19. The electron transfer dissociation (ETD) model is dominant in peptide fracture and protein identification but is rarely used to identify the TCM components20. The ETD mode can be used to investigate unknown compounds containing disulfide bonds21.
Although the MSn method has many advantages for structural identification compared to other MS techniques, there are still some limitations. First, none of the collision modes are suitable for all TCM compounds. A reasonable choice of collision mode and manual adjustment of the collision energy can improve the fragment ions. In addition, with the MSn method, it is difficult to distinguish the position of functional groups in large molecules with complex isomers. Identifying the functional group sites is a challenging task that requires experienced researchers. Manual post-analysis and long MSn data processing time are also significant barriers that discourage researchers from utilizing this technology. Q-TOF-MS is popular among researchers due to its high measurement accuracy, resolution, and ease of use with databases. However, IT-MS is a good solution for unidentified ions and trace ions due to its ability to isolate and accumulate ions and perform multiple stages of analysis. The integration of Q-TOF and IT-MS could provide a optimal solution for the full qualitative analysis of TCM samples. MSn technology is widely used in fields such as food, environmental science, and medicine, and its popularity and use in various fields are expected to increase with the improvement of IT-MS instrumentation.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was funded by the Xinglin Talent Program of Chengdu University of TCM (No. 030058191), the Nature Science Foundation of Sichuan (2022NSFSC1470), and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (82204765).
Acetonitrile | Thermo Scientific | CAS 75-05-8 | LC-MS grade |
Formic Acid | Knowles | CAS 64-18-6 | HPLC grade |
Linear ion trap mass spectrometer | Thermo Scientific | LTQ XL | |
liquid chromatograph | Thermo Scientific | U3000 | |
LTQ Tune | Thermo Scientific | version 2.8.0 | MS control software |
Methanol | Thermo Scientific | CAS 67-56-1 | LC-MS grade |
Pure water | Thermo Scientific | CAS 7732-18-5 | LC-MS grade |
Xcalibur | Thermo Scientific | version 2.0 | LC-IT-MS operational software |