Here, we describe the use of the single-molecule imaging method, DNA Curtains, to study the biophysical mechanism of EWS-FLI1 condensates assembling on DNA.
The fusion genes resulting from chromosomal translocation have been found in many solid tumors or leukemia. EWS-FLI1, which belongs to the FUS/EWS/TAF15 (FET) family of fusion oncoproteins, is one of the most frequently involved fusion genes in Ewing sarcoma. These FET family fusion proteins typically harbor a low-complexity domain (LCD) of FET protein at their N-terminus and a DNA-binding domain (DBD) at their C-terminus. EWS-FLI1 has been confirmed to form biomolecular condensates at its target binding loci due to LCD-LCD and LCD-DBD interactions, and these condensates can recruit RNA polymerase II to enhance gene transcription. However, how these condensates are assembled at their binding sites remains unclear. Recently, a single-molecule biophysics method-DNA Curtains-was applied to visualize these assembling processes of EWS-FLI1 condensates. Here, the detailed experimental protocol and data analysis approaches are discussed for the application of DNA Curtains in studying the biomolecular condensates assembling on target DNA.
Transcriptional regulation is a crucial step for precise gene expression in living cells. Many factors, such as chromosomal modification, transcription factors (TFs), and non-coding RNAs, participate in this complicated process1,2,3. Among these factors, TFs contribute to the specificity of transcriptional regulation by recognizing and binding to specific DNA sequences known as promoters or enhancers and subsequently recruiting other functional proteins to activate or repress transcription4,5,6,7. How these TFs manage to search for their target sites in the human genome and interact with DNA coated with histones and non-histone DNA-binding proteins has perplexed scientists for decades. In the past few years, several classical models for the target search mechanism of TFs have been built to describe how they "slide," "hop," "jump," or "intersegment transfer" along the DNA chain8,9,10,11. These models are focused on the searching behavior on the DNA of one single TF molecule. However, recent studies show that some TFs undergo liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) either alone in the nucleus or with the Mediator complex12. The observed droplets of TFs are associated with the promoter or enhancer regions, highlighting the role of biomolecular condensate formation in transcription and the three-dimensional genome13,14,15. These biomolecular condensates are linked to membrane-lacking compartments in vivo and in vitro. They are formed via LLPS, in which modular biomacromolecules and intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs) of proteins are two main driving forces of multivalent interactions16. Thus, TFs not only search DNA but also function synergistically within these condensates4,17,18. To date, the biophysical property of these transcription condensates on DNA remains unclear.
Therefore, this study aimed to apply a single-molecule method-DNA Curtains-to directly image the formation and dynamics of the transcription condensates formed by TFs on DNA in vitro. DNA Curtains, a high-throughput in vitro imaging platform to study the interaction between proteins and DNA, has been applied in DNA repair19,20,21, target search22, and LLPS17,23,24. The flowcell of DNA Curtains is coated with biotinylated lipid bilayers to passivate the surface and allow the biomolecules to diffuse on the surface. The nanofabricated zig-zag patterns limit the movement of DNA. Biotinylated Lambda DNA substrates can align along the barrier edges and be stretched by the oriented buffer flow. The same starting and ending sequences of all the molecules allow the tracking of the protein on DNA and describe the position distribution of the binding events25,26. Moreover, the combination of DNA Curtains with total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy (TIRFM) helps minimize the background noise and detect signals at a single-molecule level. Thus, DNA Curtains could be a promising method to investigate the dynamics of transcription condensate formation on DNA motifs. This paper describes the example of an FUS/EWS/TAF15 (FET) family fusion oncoprotein, EWS-FLI1, generated by chromosomal translocation. Lambda DNA containing 25× GGAA-the binding sequence of EWS-FLI127– was used as the DNA substrate in the DNA Curtains experiments to observe how EWS-FLI1 molecules undergo LLPS on DNA. This manuscript discusses the experimental protocol and data analysis methods in detail.
1. Preparation of the lipid bilayer master mix
2. Preparation of liposome solution
3. Sequence cloning and biotinylation of Lambda DNA
4. Nanofabricated zig-zag barriers
5. Purification of EWS-FLI1 protein
NOTE: The observation of 500 nM EWS-FLI1 on Lambda DNA with 25× GGAA motifs serves as a good example for the application of DNA Curtains to condensate formation. EWS-FLI1 is a fusion protein combining the N-terminal of EWSR1 (1-265) and the C-terminal of FLI1 (220-453). An mCherry tag was fused to the N-terminal of the EWS-FLI1 fusion protein for visualization.
6. Preparation of a DNA Curtains flowcell
7. Imaging of EWS-FLI1 condensation formation on DNA Curtains
8. Intensity analysis for mCherry-EWS-FLI1
The schematic of DNA Curtains is shown in Figure 1A, Figure 1B, and Figure 1D. The cloned target sequence containing 25 uninterrupted repeats of GGAA is found in the NORB1 promoter in Ewing sarcoma. This target sequence is crucial for EWS-FLI1 recruitment28. EWS-FLI1 molecules were visualized by detecting the mCherry-labeled EWS-FLI1 signals obtained with a 561 nm laser (Figure 1C and Figure 1E). After a DNA Curtains experiment was set up, the in vitro formation of biomolecular condensates of EWS-FLI1 at the 25× GGAA sites of the DNA substrate could be directly visualized (Figure 1B–E). The specificity of the mCherry-EWS-FLI1 used in DNA Curtains was confirmed by an electrophoretic mobility shift assay using a DNA template containing 25× GGAA and without GGAA separately (Figure 2A). Additionally, the concentration of EWS-FLI1 was titrated from 20 nM to 500 nM, and the intensity of the puncta at the 25× GGAA sites was determined. Compared with the intensity of mCherry-FLI1DBD, the intensity of EWS-FLI1 increased dramatically, whereas the change in the intensity of FLI1DBD was negligible when the proteins were saturated to cover the 25× GGAA sites. Therefore, these results strongly suggest that EWS-FLI1 formed condensates on DNA (Figure 2B–E).
Figure 1: EWS-FLI1 condensate formation on Lambda DNA containing 25× GGAA motifs. (A) Schematic of DNA Curtains. (B and D) Two strategies for detecting EWS-FLI1 condensates (500 nM) assembling on Lambda DNA: (B) Keep washing for 10 min;(D)incubate for 10 min. (C and E) Representative wide-field total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy image of DNA Curtains: (C) Detection strategy in B; (E) Detection strategy in D. C (ii) and E (ii) DNA is zoomed in to show the distinct puncta formed on a single DNA substrate. DNA substrates are Lambda DNA with 25× GGAA motifs. Numbers "1, 2, 3, 4" represent different positions of puncta on one Lambda DNA, and "3" is where the 25× GGAA microsatellite sequence was cloned. Scale bars = 4.9 µm (C, E (i)) and 0.7 µm (C, E (ii)). This figure has been modified from 24. Abbreviation: dsDNA = double-stranded DNA. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Binding events of the detached domain of mCherry-EWS-FLI1 on 25× GGAA repeats. (A) (i) mCherry-EWS-FLI1. (ii) Electrophoretic mobility shift assay of mCherry-EWS-FLI1: 306-bp dsDNA labeled with 5' Quasar670 was incubated with mCherry-EWS-FLI1 at different concentrations under room temperature for 30 min in reaction buffer containing 40 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.5), 150 mM KCl, 2 mM MgCl2, 1 mM DTT, and 0.2 mg/mL bovine serum albumin. The samples were loaded and run on 1.3% agarose gel for 25 min, 120 V. (B–D) Wide-field total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy images of 25× GGAA with DNA Curtains after incubation with 500 nM mCherry (B), 500 nM mCherry-EWSLCD (C), or 500 nM mCherry-FLI1DBD (D). (E) Intensity distribution of EWSFLI1 (cyan) and FLI1DBD (black) signals at the target site (25× GGAA) region vs. protein concentration. This figure has been modified from 24. Abbreviations: LCD = low-complexity domain; DBD = DNA-binding domain. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
As single-molecule approaches are extremely sensitive to the contents of the reaction system, extra effort must be invested to ensure good quality of all the materials and solutions during the DNA Curtains experiments, especially the lipids prepared in sections 1 and 2 and the buffers used in section 5. Reagents of higher purity must be used to prepare buffers, and buffers must be freshly prepared for the single-molecule assay
When 500 nM mCherry-labeled EWS-FLI1 was flushed into the chamber, several magenta puncta appeared on Lambda DNA containing the 25× GGAA sequences. Notice that there was a consecutive non-specific distribution of magenta signals throughout the entire DNA even after 10 min of washing with blank buffer (Figure 1B,C). Interestingly, EWS-FLI1 molecules were rearranged on DNA during the 10 min incubation without the buffer flow and gathered into several puncta (Figure 1D,E). One of these puncta was formed at the cloned 25× GGAA site, while all others were formed in the regions containing a high density of consecutive GGAA motifs. This phenomenon strongly suggests that the no-flow incubation procedure allows EWS-FLI1 molecules to search the loci and assemble on DNA faster.
Several control experiments must be performed to clarify how these condensates formed on DNA Curtains. We purified mCherry, mCherry-EWSLCD, and mCherry-FLI1DBD and followed the same procedure to inject these proteins into the chamber. Neither mCherry (Figure 2B) nor mCherry-EWSLCD (Figure 2C) left any signals on DNA, indicating that the FLI1DBD of EWS-FLI1 was necessary for the interaction with DNA. To confirm that phase separation occurred in DNA Curtains at such low protein concentrations, the concentration of mCherry-EWS-FLI1 was titrated from 25 nM to 500 nM, and the intensity of each puncta on one DNA molecule was determined at the clone site (Figure 2E). A comparison with the intensity of fusion TF FLI1DBD labeled with mCherry revealed that although the puncta intensities of EWS-FLI1 and FLI1-DBD were similar at low protein concentrations, the intensity of EWS-FLI1 increased dramatically while that of FLI1DBD remained low even when the concentration reached 500 nM. These results suggest that EWS-FLI1 molecules bind to the 25× GGAA sequence and assemble into a condensate on it through LCD interactions. A single FLI1DBD can bind 2x GGAA motifs, and higher-order oligomers bind to highly repetitive low-affinity sequences27. The mCherry-FLI1DBD signal on the 25× GGAA sequence was from a protein cluster rather than an individual protein molecule. Although mCherry-FLI1DBD could bind the 25× GGAA sites, it failed to assemble as a condensate on DNA, confirming that the LCD-LCD interaction was necessary for phase separation (Figure 2D,E).
Single-molecule methods enable researchers to study the dynamics inside transcription factor condensates. The DNA Curtains method has some advantages compared with other single-molecule methods such as single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (smFRET)29, super-resolution imaging30, and optical tweezer31,32. First, the DNA Curtains method allows for the reconstitution of the transcription machinery on long genomic DNA in vitro and the real-time observation of transcription condensate formation with high-throughput data acquisition. Second, aligned DNA molecules allow the mapping of the position of condensates on each DNA strand. Thus, the preferred DNA sequences for puncta formation can be easily determined.
Moreover, long-term acquisition is feasible with DNA Curtains, allowing for the measurement of the on-rate (kon) and off-rate (koff) of one punctum. Nevertheless, DNA Curtains has some inherent technical defects, necessitating the evidence from different methods to be collectively examined. On the one hand, the resolution of DNA Curtains can only reach 0.18 µm or ~1,000-bp because the long Lambda DNA template has a restriction with respect to the diffraction limit, which can hinder the differentiation of two neighboring fluorescence signals. On the other hand, the flow is used to extend double-strand DNA (dsDNA), and the force applied on the biomolecule may influence the diffusion property of the proteins binding to the DNA. Double-tethered DNA Curtains can anchor both ends of dsDNA and record the movement of proteins without flow, which is a noteworthy solution33. To summarize, deepening our understanding of the dynamic assembly of biomolecular condensates on DNA in real-time will shed light on not only the biophysical mechanism of LLPS but also on the basic biology of LLPS-related cellular processes, such as gene transcription regulation24.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported by NSFC Grants No. 31670762 (Z.Q.).
488 nm diodepumped solid-state laser | Coherent | OBIS488LS | |
561 nm diodepumped solid-state laser | Coherent | OBIS561LS | |
Agar | Rhawn | R003215-50g | |
biotinylated DOPE | Avanti | 870273P | |
Bovine Serum Albumin | Sigma | A7030 | |
Chloroform | Amresco | 1595C027 | |
Coating Electra 92 | Allresist GmbH | AR-PC 5090.02 | The conductive protective coating |
Deoxyribonuclease I bovine | Sigma | D5139-2MG | |
DOPC | Avanti | 850375P | |
DTT | Sigma | D9779 | |
Glass coverslip | Fisher Scientific | 12-544-7 | |
Hellmanex III | Sigma | Z805939-1EA | |
KCl | Sigma | 60130 | |
Lambda DNA | NEB | N3013S | |
Lambda Packing Extracts | Epicentre | MP5120 | |
MgCl2 | Sigma | M2670 | |
NaCl | Sigma | s3014 | |
Nanoport | Idex | N-333-01 | |
NheI-HF | NEB | R3131S | |
Nikon Inverted Microscope | Nikon | Eclipse Ti | |
NZCYM Broth | Sigma | N3643-250G | |
PEG-2000 DOPE | Avanti | 880130P-1G | |
PEG-8000 | Amresco | 25322-68-3 | |
PMMA 200K, ETHYL LACTATE 4% | Allresist GmbH | AR-P 649.04 | |
PMMA 950K, ANISOLE 2% | Allresist GmbH | AR-P 672.02 | |
Prime 95B Scientific CMOS camera | PHOTOMETRICS | Prime95B | |
proteinase K | NEB | P8107S | |
Silica glass slide | G.Finkenbeiner | ||
Six-way injection valve | Idex | MXP9900-000 | |
Streptavidin | Thermo | S888 | Diluted with ddH2O |
Syringe pump | Harvard Apparatus | Pump11 Elite | |
T4 DNA Ligase | NEB | M0202S | |
Tris base | Sigma | T6066 | |
XhoI | NEB | R0146V | |
YOYO-1 Iodide (491/509) | Invitrogen | Y3601 | Diluted with DMSO |