We present a protocol for probing ultrafast vibrational coherences in polyatomic radical cations that result in molecular dissociation.
We present a pump-probe method for preparing vibrational coherences in polyatomic radical cations and probing their ultrafast dynamics. By shifting the wavelength of the strong-field ionizing pump pulse from the commonly used 800 nm into the near-infrared (1200-1600 nm), the contribution of adiabatic electron tunneling to the ionization process increases relative to multiphoton absorption. Adiabatic ionization results in predominant population of the ground electronic state of the ion upon electron removal, which effectively prepares a coherent vibrational state ("wave packet") amenable to subsequent excitation. In our experiments, the coherent vibrational dynamics are probed with a weak-field 800 nm pulse and the time-dependent yields of dissociation products measured in a time-of-flight mass spectrometer. We present the measurements on the molecule dimethyl methylphosphonate (DMMP) to illustrate how using 1500 nm pulses for excitation enhances the amplitude of coherent oscillations in ion yields by a factor of 10 as compared to 800 nm pulses. This protocol may be implemented in existing pump-probe setups through the incorporation of an optical parametric amplifier (OPA) for wavelength conversion.
Since the invention of the laser in 1960's, the goal of selectively breaking chemical bonds in molecules has been a longstanding dream of chemists and physicists. The ability to tune both laser frequency and intensity was believed to enable direct cleavage of a target bond through selective energy absorbance at the associated vibrational frequency1,2,3,4. However, early experiments found that intramolecular vibrational redistribution of the absorbed energy throughout the molecule often resulted in non-selective cleavage of the weakest bond4,5. It was not until the development of femtosecond pulsed lasers and the pump-probe technique6 in the late 1980's that direct manipulation of coherent vibrational states, or "wave packets", enabled successful control over bond cleavage and other objectives6,7,8. Pump-probe measurements, wherein the "pump" pulse prepares an excited state or ion that is subsequently excited by a time-delayed "probe" pulse, remain one of the most widely used techniques for studying ultrafast processes in molecules9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20.
A significant limitation to studying the ultrafast dissociation dynamics of polyatomic radical cations using pump-probe excitation coupled to mass spectrometric detection arises from nonselective fragmentation of the target molecule by the ionizing pump pulse at the Ti:Sapphire wavelength of 800 nm21,22,23. This excess fragmentation results from nonadiabatic multiphoton ionization and can be mitigated by shifting the excitation wavelength into the near-infrared (e.g., 1200-1500 nm)22,23,24,25. At these longer wavelengths, the contribution of adiabatic electron tunneling increases relative to multiphoton excitation in the ionization process22,23. Adiabatic tunneling imparts little excess energy to the molecule and forms predominantly "cold" ground state molecular ions19,22,23. Our previous work has demonstrated that the use of near-infrared excitation significantly improves the preparation of coherent vibrational excitations, or "wave packets", in polyatomic radical cations as compared to 800 nm excitation19,20. This work will illustrate the difference between strong-field ionization dominated by multiphoton and tunneling contributions with pump-probe measurements taken on the chemical warfare agent simulant dimethyl methylphosphonate (DMMP) using 1500 nm and 800 nm pump wavelengths.
In our pump-probe experiments, a pair of ultrashort laser pulses is time-delayed, recombined, and focused into a time-of-flight mass spectrometer, as shown in our setup in Figure 1. These experiments require a Ti:Sapphire regenerative amplifier producing >2 mJ, 800 nm, 30 fs pulses. The amplifier output is split on a 90:10 (%R:%T) beam splitter, where most of the energy is used to pump an optical parametric amplifier (OPA) for generation of 1200 – 1600 nm, 100 – 300 µJ, 20 – 30 fs pulses. The diameter of the IR pump beam is expanded to 22 mm and the diameter of the 800 nm probe beam down-collimated to 5.5 mm and cored using an iris. These collimations result in the pump beam focusing to a significantly smaller beam waist (9 µm) than the probe beam (30 µm), thereby ensuring that all ions formed during the ionizing pump pulse are excited by the time-delayed probe pulse. This configuration is used because the goal of our experiments is to probe the dynamics of the parent molecular ion, which may be formed even at lower intensities near the edges of the focused beam. We note that if the dynamics of more highly-excited ionic species are of interest, then the probe beam diameter should be made smaller than that of the pump.
The pump and probe pulses propagate collinearly and are focused into the extraction region of a Wiley-McLaren time-of-flight mass spectrometer (TOF-MS)26 (Figure 2). Molecular samples placed in a vial are attached to the inlet and opened to the vacuum. This setup requires that the molecule under investigation have a nonzero vapor pressure; for molecules with low vapor pressure, the vial may be heated. The flow of gaseous sample into the chamber is controlled by two variable leak valves. The sample enters the chamber through a 1/16" stainless steel tube approximately 1 cm away from the laser focus (Figure 2) in order to deliver a locally high concentration of target molecule in the extraction region27. The extraction plate has a 0.5 mm slit oriented orthogonal to the laser propagation and ion paths. Because the Rayleigh range of the pump beam is approximately 2 mm, this slit serves as a filter, allowing only ions generated from the central focal volume where the intensity is highest to pass through the extraction plate28. The ions enter a 1 m field-free drift tube to reach the Z-gap micro channel plate (MCP) detector29, where they are detected and recorded with a 1 GHz digital oscilloscope at the 1 kHz repetition rate of typical commercial Ti:Sapphire lasers.
NOTE: All commercially acquired instruments and parts such as the laser, vacuum pumps, chamber, time-of-flight tube and microchannel plate detector were installed and operated according to the manufacturer’s instructions or user’s manual. Laser safety goggles designed for the operating laser intensities and wavelengths should be worn.
1. Construction of TOF-MS26
2. Construction of Optical Pump and Probe Paths
Note: A diagram of the pump and the probe optical paths is given in Figure 1.
3. Preliminary Measurements
Note: All data in our experiments were acquired using codes written in-house with commercial instrument control software (Table of Materials). All instrument driver software was obtained from the respective manufacturer.
4. Pump-probe Measurements
Results obtained for the molecule DMMP21 are presented. Figure 3 shows the DMMP mass spectra taken at zero time-delay with the peak intensities of the 1500 nm pump and 800 nm probe pulses being 8 x 1013 and 8 x 1012 W cm-2, respectively. For reference, the mass spectrum taken with only the pump pulse is also shown. The spectra are averaged over 10,000 laser shots (total acquisition time 12 s). The increase in ion signals marked with * is apparent when the spatial overlap between pump and probe beams is optimized (green spectrum). There is little perceptible difference between the poorly-overlapped and pump-only spectra. These results illustrate how to determine optimal spatial overlap of the pump and probe beams (step 3.3) using the ion signals directly.
Figure 4 shows mass spectral data obtained from one pump-probe scan (1000 laser shots/time step; 5 fs time steps; 1250 fs scan length), with the flight time on the abscissa and pump-probe delay on the ordinate. Total data acquisition time was approximately 16 min. The raw data illustrates how changes in ion signals with the pump-probe delay in these experiments can be visualized without additional data workup.
Figure 5 shows time-resolved DMMP+ signals from one pump-probe scan (1000 laser shots/time step; 5 fs time steps; 2200 fs scan length; total acquisition time 16 min) with optimized (green) and poor (red) spatial overlap of pump and probe beams. These results illustrate the importance of optimizing the pump-probe spatial overlap (step 3.3) to acquire high-quality transient ion signals in the processed data.
Figure 6 shows DMMP+ and the fragment PO2C2H4+ transient ion signals taken using 800 nm and 1500 nm pump wavelengths (Figure 6a and b, respectively). Signals were averaged over 10 scans (1000 laser shots/time step; 5 fs time steps; 1250 fs scan length); total acquisition time was approximately 3 h for each measurement. Figure 6c shows the fast Fourier transform (FFT) of the DMMP+ ion signals taken with 800 nm and 1500 nm pumps. The peak at 750 nm visible for the 1500 nm pump illustrates the frequency resolution under the scan settings used. The frequency resolution obtainable with FFT may be improved by increasing the scan length. These results illustrate how the pump wavelength determines the observable ion dynamics.
Figure 1: Optical pump-probe setup. The pump and probe beam paths are shown as yellow and red beams, respectively. Schematic diagrams of optical paths and guidance into the TOF-MS are shown. Abbreviations are as follows. BS: beam splitter (90:10, %R:%T). OPA: optical parametric amplifier. WP: λ/2 wave plate. P: polarizer cube. ND: neutral density. DC: dichroic. TMP: turbomolecular pump. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Schematic diagram of the laser-sample interaction region. Pump and probe beams are focused between the repeller (V1) and extractor (V2) plates. The polarization of both beams is aligned along the TOF axis. The voltages of the repeller plate (V1 = +4190 V), extractor plate (V2 = +3910 V), ground plate (V3 = 0 V), and MCP detector bias (V4 = -3000 V) are set in the TOF power supply. The 0.5 mm slit on the extractor plate is oriented perpendicular to both the laser and ion paths to ensure the collection of ions only from the most intense region of the laser focus28. The sample inlet tube is placed between the plates V1 and V227. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Mass spectra of DMMP. The sample molecule is DMMP and the spectra are taken at zero time-delay with good overlap (green) and poor spatial overlap (red). For reference, the spectrum taken with only the pump pulse (blue) is shown. Peaks marked with * denote ion signals that are enhanced when the spatial overlap is optimized. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Raw pump-probe scan data. Mass spectral data recorded in the oscilloscope during one pump-probe scan at delays from -150 fs to +1100 fs. Flight time is labeled on the abscissa and pump-probe delay on the ordinate. The DMMP parent molecular ion and four fragment ion signals are labeled. Integration ranges for each ion signal are indicated by brackets. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: Pump-probe scan data with good and poor spatial overlap. The integrated signals of DMMP parent molecular ion obtained from a single scan taken with good overlap (green) and poor overlap (red) are plotted as a function of pump-probe delay. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6: Effect of pump wavelength. Normalized DMMP+ (red) and PO2CH4+ (blue) ion signals as a function of pump-probe delay obtained for experiments using pump wavelengths of 800 nm (a) and 1500 nm (b). The FFT of each DMMP+ ion signal is shown in panel (c). This figure has been adapted from reference 19 with permission from the PCCP Owner Societies. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
This protocol enables us to resolve ultrafast vibrational dynamics in polyatomic radical cations through selective preparation of the ions in the ground electronic state. While the standard strong-field ionization procedure using 800 nm can prepare vibrational coherences in ground-electronic state radical cations of first-row diatomics10,11,12,13 and CO214,15, the population of multiple ionic excited states in polyatomic ions using 800 nm significantly limits the resolvable dynamics17,19. In DMMP (Figure 6), the amplitude of 45-fs coherent oscillations in the parent molecular ion yield is larger by a factor of ~10 when 1500 nm is used for ionization (red curve, Figure 6b) as compared to 800 nm (red curve, Figure 6a). Furthermore, large-amplitude oscillations in the fragment ion PO2CH4+ are visible with a 1500 nm pump (blue curve, Figure 6b), but completely absent for 800 nm pump (blue curve, Figure 6a). Furthermore, FFT of the DMMP+ ion signals (Figure 6c) shows a peak at 750 cm-1 resolvable to ~40 cm-1 when the pump wavelength is 1500 nm, while no peak is visible when the pump wavelength is 800 nm. These results illustrate the efficacy of strong-field adiabatic ionization for preparing radical cations in the ground electronic state with well-defined vibrational coherences.
A critical step in the protocol is to optimize the spatial overlap between pump and probe beams using the ion signals directly for feedback (step 3.3). The differences in the ion signals acquired using good and poor overlap are illustrated in Figure 3 and Figure 5. While the fragmentation patterns will be different for each molecule, a reliable indicator of good spatial overlap is the enhancement of small-mass fragments in the mass spectrum, as seen in the peaks marked with a star in the green spectrum in Figure 3 (good overlap) as compared to the red spectrum (poor overlap). The consequences of performing pump-probe scans (step 4.2) with good and poor spatial overlap are illustrated in Figure 5. When the overlap is good (green trace), six well-defined oscillations in the DMMP+ yield are visible, with a relative depletion at 2000 fs delay of 12% from the yield at negative delay. When the overlap is poor (red trace), only two or three oscillations in DMMP+ yield are visible and the relative depletion of the ion signal at 2000 fs delay is only 5% of the yield at negative delay. These results demonstrate the importance of operating with optimized spatial overlap in order to accurately record the ion dynamics.
The protocol described here has two limitations with regards to the molecules that may be easily studied. First, the effusive molecular beam inlet to the TOF-MS requires that the target molecules have a sufficiently high vapor pressure to go into the gas phase. Molecules with a lower vapor pressure, such as 4-nitrotoluene, may be gently heated to produce a sufficiently high pressure in the chamber to obtain satisfactory ion signals20. Second, many polyatomic molecules have low-lying ionic excited states that may be populated through resonant absorption during the pump pulse, even under adiabatic ionization conditions. For instance, acetophenone exhibits an ionic resonance at 1370 nm24,25, which results in significantly decreased amplitudes in coherent oscillations in ion yields using this protocol17. Thus, the excitation wavelength for the pump must be chosen carefully to ensure a sufficiently high parent ion signal when only the pump is applied. For maximum flexibility, the use of a commercial OPA with the wavelength range of 1150-2500 nm is recommended.
This protocol has potential applications for chemical warfare agent and explosive detection, as illustrated in our studies on DMMP19 and nitrotoluenes20. In addition to studies of coherent dynamics in radical cations, the use of near-infrared wavelengths for ionization has been used in pump-probe experiments to study ultrafast dynamics on neutral excited states in aminobenzonitriles35, where the use of 1300-2100 nm ionizing probe pulses improved the resolution of ultrafast coherent oscillations in the ion yields. Thus, strong-field adiabatic ionization techniques may facilitate the study of a wide range of ultrafast dynamical processes in both neutrals and ions of polyatomic molecules.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported by the U.S. Army Research Office through Contract W911NF-18-1-0051.
Mass spectrometer components | |||
TOF lens stack and flight tube assembly | Jordan TOF Products, Inc. | C-677 | |
18 mm Z-gap detector assembly | Jordan TOF Products, Inc. | C-701Z | |
TOF high voltage power supply | Jordan TOF Products, Inc. | D-603 | |
Vacuum system components | |||
Rotary vane backing pump | Edwards Vacuum LLC | RV12 | |
Turbomolecular pumps (2) | Edwards Vacuum LLC | EXT255H | |
Turbomolecular pump controllers (2) | Edwards Vacuum LLC | EXC300 | |
Pressure gauge | Edwards Vacuum LLC | AIGX-S-DN40CF | |
Chiller for water cooling | Neslab | CFT-25 | |
Femtosecond laser system | |||
Ti:Sapphire regenerative amplifier | Coherent, Inc. | Astrella | oscillator and amplifier in a single integrated system |
Optical Parametric Amplifer (OPA) | Light Conversion | TOPAS Prime | |
Motion control | |||
Motorized linear translation stage 1" travel | Thorlabs | Z825B | |
controller for linear translation stage | Thorlabs | KDC 101 | |
USB controller hub and power supply | Thorlabs | KCH 601 | |
Manual linear translation stage 1" travel | Thorlabs | PT1 | |
Detectors | |||
Pyroelectric laser energy meter | Coherent, Inc. | 1168337 | |
Thermal laser power meter | Coherent, Inc. | 5356E16R | |
Si-biased detector 200-1100 nm | Thorlabs | DET10A | |
Compact USB CMOS Camera | Thorlabs | DCC1545M | |
USB spectrometer | Ocean Optics | HR4000 | |
1 GHz digital oscilloscope | LeCroy | WaveRunner 610Zi | |
Optics | |||
Type 1 BBO crystal | Crylight Photonics | BBO007 | aperture and thickness may be customized |
Achromatic half wave plate, 1100-2000 nm | Thorlabs | AHWP05M-1600 | |
Wollaston prism polarizer | Thorlabs | WPM10 | |
Hollow retro-reflector | PLX, Inc. | OW-20-1C | |
Variable neutral density filter | Thorlabs | NDC-100C-2 | |
Longpass dichroic mirror 2" diameter | Thorlabs | DMLP950L | |
Software | |||
Digital Camera image software | Thorlabs | ThorCam | |
Instrument communication interface | National Instruments | NI-MAX | |
Graphical development environment for measurement programs | National Instruments | LabVIEW | |
Data processing software | Mathworks | MATLAB |