Here, we present a protocol to efficiently generate human trophoblastic cells from human pluripotent stem cells using bone morphogenic protein 4 and inhibitors of the Activin/Nodal pathways. This method is suitable for the efficient differentiation of human pluripotent stem cells and can generate large quantities of cells for genetic manipulation.
The placenta is the first organ to develop during embryogenesis and is required for the survival of the developing embryo. The placenta is comprised of various trophoblastic cells that differentiate from the extra-embryonic trophectoderm cells of the preimplantation blastocyst. As such, our understanding of the early differentiation events of the human placenta is limited because of ethical and legal restrictions on the isolation and manipulation of human embryogenesis. Human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs) are a robust model system for investigating human development and can also be differentiated in vitro into trophoblastic cells that express markers of the various trophoblast cell types. Here, we present a detailed protocol for differentiating hPSCs into trophoblastic cells using bone morphogenic protein 4 and inhibitors of the Activin/Nodal signaling pathways. This protocol generates various trophoblast cell types that can be transfected with siRNAs for investigating loss-of-function phenotypes or can be infected with pathogens. Additionally, hPSCs can be genetically modified and then differentiated into trophoblast progenitors for gain-of-function analyses. This in vitro differentiation method for generating human trophoblasts starting from hPSCs overcomes the ethical and legal restrictions of working with early human embryos, and this system can be used for a variety of applications, including drug discovery and stem cell research.
The placenta is required for the growth and survival of the fetus during pregnancy and facilitates the exchange of gases, nutrients, waste products, and hormones between maternal and fetal circulation. The first organ formed during mammalian embryogenesis is the placenta, which begins developing 6-7 days post-conception in humans and 3.5-4.5 days in mice1,2,3,4. Trophoblastic cells are the most important cells of the placenta, and these cells represent one of the earliest lineage differentiation events of the mammalian embryo. They arise from the outer extra-embryonic trophectoderm cells of the preimplantation blastocyst. Our knowledge of the early stages of placental development is limited by ethical and logistical restrictions on modeling early human development.
During embryonic implantation, trophoblasts invade the maternal epithelium and differentiate into specialized progenitor cells5. Cytotrophoblasts (CTBs) are mononucleated, undifferentiated progenitors that fuse and differentiate into syncytiotrophoblasts (SYNs) and extravillous invasive trophoblasts (EVTs), which anchor the placenta to the uterus. SYNs are multinucleated, terminally differentiated cells that synthesize hormones necessary for sustaining pregnancy. The early differentiation events that generate EVTs and SYNs are essential for placental formation, as impairments in trophoblastic cells result in miscarriage, pre-eclampsia, and intrauterine growth restriction1. The types of human trophoblast cell lines that have been developed include immortalized CTBs and choriocarcinomas, which produce placental hormones and display invasive properties6. Primary trophoblastic cells from human first-trimester placentas can be isolated, but the cells quickly differentiate and stop proliferating in vitro. Importantly, transformed and primary cell lines have different gene expression profiles, indicating that tumorigenic and immortalized trophoblast cell lines may not accurately represent primary trophoblasts7. Additionally, these lines are unlikely to resemble placental trophoblast stem cell progenitors because they are derived from later-stage first through third trimesters.
There is a need for a robust in vitro culture system of early-stage human trophoblasts in order to study the early events of placental formation and function. Human embryonic stem cells (hESCs), which share properties with the inner cell mass of the preimplantation embryo, are frequently used to model early human development, including the formation of the early placenta. Both human induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPSCs) and hESCs can be differentiated into trophoblasts in vitro using Bone Morphogenic Protein 4 (BMP4)8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15. This conversion of pluripotent cells to trophoblastic cells using BMP4 is specific for human cells and is widely used to study the development of the early human placenta because it does not require access to early human embryos9,16. Recently, it was discovered that the addition of the inhibitors A83-01 (A) and PD173074 (P), which block the SMAD2/3 and MEK1/2 signaling pathways, increases the efficiency of hPSC differentiation into trophectoderm-like progenitors, mainly SYNs and EVTs, without the extensive generation of mesoderm, endoderm, or ectoderm cells9,17. Using these medium conditions, hESCs differentiated for 12 days have similar gene expression profiles as trophectoderm cells isolated from human blastocyst-stage embryos and secrete various placental-specific growth hormones, supporting the validity of this in vitro model system9,11. Here, we present a detailed protocol for the in vitro differentiation of hPSCs into human trophoblast progenitors using BMP4/A/P culture medium. These conditions produce abundant numbers of cells for a wide variety of applications, including RNA sequencing, gene disruption using siRNAs, pathogen infections, and genetic modification using lipofection-mediated transfection.
NOTE: For the differentiation of either hESCs or hiPSCs into trophoblast progenitors, hPSCs grown on mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) are transitioned to feeder-free conditions for two passages before initiating differentiation with BMP4/A/P. This process eliminates the MEF contamination of differentiated cells. Here, we present a protocol for hESC differentiation, and the same protocol can be applied to hiPSCs.
1. Culture and Recovery of hESCs on Irradiated Mouse Embryonic Fibroblasts (MEFs) (Preparations)
2. Transition of hESCs from MEFs to Feeder-free Conditions on Extracellular Matrix-coated Plates
3. Differentiation of hESCs Using BMP4/A/P
4. Transfection of Trophoblastic Cells with siRNAs or Plasmid DNA
5. Pathogen Infection of Trophoblastic Cells: Sendai Viral Infection
Overview of In Vitro Differentiation of hPSCs
This in vitro differentiation protocol begins with undifferentiated hESCs grown on MEFs that are transitioned to feeder-free conditions for one passage (Figure 1A). While we described the differentiation of hESCs in this protocol, we used this protocol to successfully differentiate hiPSCs into trophoblastic cells. The transition to extracellular matrix removes the majority of the irradiated MEFs, which are undesirable for analyses that require pure populations of human trophoblastic cells. Undifferentiated hPSCs are grown on extracellular matrix and cultured with CM containing B-FGF until the colonies are ready for passaging (approximately one week). This maintains the pluripotent state prior to inducing BMP4/A/P-mediated differentiation. The colonies are disrupted into clumps of ~50-100 cells using dispase and passaged a second time onto an extracellular matrix-coated plate. The day after passaging, the adherent cells are ready to induce differentiation, and the medium is switched to contain BMP4/A/P lacking B-FGF. The differentiated cells proliferate for approximately 2 weeks, during which time the cells can be collected for RNA isolation or used for transfection experiments. Morphological changes appear 1-2 days after differentiation has been initiated, and results from one representative experiment are shown in Figure 1B. Notice that cells on differentiation days 1-2 are larger in size than the cells from day 0 (Figure 1B). The differentiated cell colony grows rapidly, and this change is noticeable every day. As differentiation proceeds, the cells divide and expand out from the center of the colony, growing in an outward direction (days 3-5; Figure 1B). The outer portion of the colony contains larger cells compared to the cells at the center of the colony. The differentiating cells become darker and flatter than pluripotent stem cells cultured on extracellular matrix; the changes in cell brightness are more apparent when viewing the cells with an upright microscope used for routine cell culture. The individual colonies merge together by differentiation day 5 (Figure 1B), with cells growing on top of each other. After differentiation day 4-5, cells containing multiple nuclei are present (not shown) (Figure 1B).
BMP4/A/P Induces the Differentiation and Expression of Trophoblast Markers
We examined gene expression changes during the first three days of BMP4/A/P differentiation using quantitative RT-PCR (qRT-PCR). RNA was isolated at differentiation days 1, 2, and 3 and converted to cDNA. The disappearance of pluripotent stem cells can be assessed both by morphology, visually using a microscope, and by qRT-PCR, using primers for pluripotency genes. The relative expression levels of NANOG, a marker of pluripotent stem cells, is reduced by ~75% after one day of differentiation when cells are cultured with BMP4, and levels are reduced by ~90% in the presence of BMP4/A/P (Figure 2). By differentiation day 2, the levels of NANOG are very low for cells cultured in BMP4 alone or in BMP4/A/P compared to those in hESC CM medium (containing B-FGF). This is an expected result, because we do not observe undifferentiated cells after two days of differentiation (Figure 1B), which are brighter and smaller in size compared to differentiated cells. The efficiency of BMP4-mediated differentiation to trophoblastic cells can be directly assessed by qRT-PCR using primers specific for two trophoblast markers: KRT7 and CDX2. Both of these genes are not expressed in human pluripotent stem cells, and their expression increases after 2-3 days of BMP4 treatment (Figure 2). Using the conditions described here, KRT7 transcript levels increase on differentiation day 1 in BMP4/A/P medium and remain constant for the first 3 days of differentiation (Figure 2). KRT7 expression when using BMP4 alone has a delayed increase by day 2, in agreement with previous observations that Activin/Nodal inhibitors increase the differentiation rate of hESCs9. Another way to assess the efficiency of using these inhibitors is to determine the steady-state abundance of CDX2 and KRT7 transcripts in cells treated with BMP4 alone. CDX2 levels are similar for differentiation days 1-3 when using either BMP4 alone or BMP4 together with Activin/Nodal inhibitors. However, KRT7 transcripts are more abundant after one day of differentiation in the presence of these inhibitors, which suggests a more rapid differentiation (Figure 2). CDX2 expression typically peaks at differentiation day 2 for both conditions and decreases after day 3 (Figure 2). Undifferentiated hESCs do not express either KRT7 or CDX2 (Figure 2), as expected. In conclusion, BMP4/A/P conditions rapidly differentiate hESCs, and placental marker expression can be detected as early as differentiation day 3.
Transfections of siRNAs and Plasmid DNA and Viral Infections Using In Vitro-derived Trophoblastic Cells
In vitro derived human trophoblastic cells can be transfected with siRNAs to disrupt the gene expression of either coding or noncoding RNAs. We initiated the differentiation of hESCs using BMP4/A/P, performed two rounds of siRNA transfections (using 75 pmol of siRNAs) on differentiation days 1 and 2, and collected the cells for RNA isolation. Quantitative RT-PCR is an effective method to determine the knockdown efficiency for either coding or noncoding genes. Using two siRNAs complementary to different regions of the long, noncoding RNA lncRHOXF119, we obtained 80% knockdown of lncRHOXF1 transcripts (Figure 3A). Next, we transfected one siRNA (25 pmol) for the protein-coding gene hnRNP U, also on differentiation days 1 and 2. We observed an 80% reduction in hnRNP U transcripts following two consecutive transfections. In vitro differentiated trophoblast progenitor cells can also be used to investigate innate immune responses. We performed infections of differentiation day 2 cells using Sendai virus at an MOI of 1 and collected the cells after 8 hr of viral incubation. Using qRT-PCR, we detected abundant viral protein transcripts (Sev-NP) in infected cells (Figure 3B), indicative of active viral propagation in trophoblastic cells. Importantly, infected cells (using MOI = 1) do not change in appearance and are viable (data not shown). In vitro derived trophoblastic cells can also be transfected with plasmid DNA. We performed transfections using a GFP plasmid and introduced this construct into BMP4/A/P-treated cells on differentiation day 1 and day 3 and imaged for GFP the following day (Figure 4). We typically obtained 30-50% transfection efficiency at 24 hr post-transfection. In conclusion, in vitro derived trophoblastic cells can be utilized for gain- and loss-of-function experiments.
Figure 1: In vitro differentiation of human pluripotent stem cells to early trophoblastic cells using BMP4/A/P. (A) Schematic of BMP4 differentiation of hPSCs to trophoblastic cells using BMP4/A/P. (B) Representative bright-field images of HUES9 cells during d0, d2, and d6 of BMP4/A/P differentiation. Scale bar = 50 μM. The arrowheads denote single-cell hESCs that are not differentiated. The arrows highlight morphological features during differentiation. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: BMP4/A/P differentiation quickly downregulates the pluripotency marker NANOG and upregulates trophoblast genes CDX2 and KRT7. qRT-PCR analysis for NANOG (pluripotency marker), CDX2, and KRT7 (trophoblast markers). The values are averages from triplicate measures. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Gene disruption and viral infection using in vitro differentiated human trophoblastic cells. (A) qRT-PCR analysis of hESCs (HUES9) differentiated and then transfected with siRNAs specific to the long, noncoding RNA lncRHOXF1 (left) or the protein-coding gene hnRNP U (right) for two consecutive days. The knockdown efficiency (KD) is typically 70-80%, and the results from one transfection experiment are shown. (B) qRT-PCR analysis of the Sendai viral protein transcript of differentiation day 2 trophoblastic cells infected with Sendai virus (MOI = 1) for 8 hr. The error bars denote the SEM. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Introduction of plasmid DNA into in vitro differentiated human trophoblastic cells. Transfection of GFP plasmid DNA into differentiation day 1 and day 3 trophectoderm progenitor cells, visualized the following day. Scale bar = 50 μM. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
We presented the basic steps for differentiating hESCs into trophoblast progenitors. This protocol has recently been optimized to rapidly differentiate hESCs with the addition of Activin/Nodal signaling inhibitors, increasing the differentiation to trophoblastic cells and avoiding the generation of mesoderm progenitors, which are typically observed with BMP4 treatment alone. The BMP4 model system allows for the examination of the earliest stages of human trophoblast lineage specification and expansion. In addition, this BMP4 model system is also useful for investigating the differentiation of trophoblastic cells to specific sub-lineages, which is not possible using choriocarcinoma cell lines and extravillous trophoblast cell lines. In vitro derived trophoblastic cells can also be used for loss-of-function experiments using siRNAs19. Additionally, hESCs or hiPSCs can be genetically modified for the inducible expression of transgenes19 or for the insertion of reporter genes at endogenous loci20, and these cells can be differentiated into trophoblastic cells using the conditions described here.
Critical Steps within the Protocol
It is imperative to omit B-FGF (FGF2) from the CM differentiation medium to obtain trophoblastic progenitor cells from hESCs. The presence of B-FGF together with BMP4 in the culture medium enhances the expression of mesoderm and endoderm progenitors16. The inclusion of B-FGF in trophoblast differentiation medium is believed to explain why a recent study found that BMP4-mediated differentiation generates mesoderm and endoderm cells instead of trophoblasts21. It is well-established that B-FGF together with Activin A and BMP4 promotes endoderm and mesoderm differentiation in a dose-dependent fashion22,23. In the mouse, the development of the epiblast, trophectoderm, and primitive endoderm lineages are dependent on FGF signaling pathways24. In differentiating hESCs, B-FGF-induced signaling is required for mesoderm formation when BMP4 is used to induce differentiation21,25. In contrast, the inhibition of both FGF and the Activin/Nodal signaling pathways, together with BMP4, favors SYN formation in hESC-derived trophoblast progenitors and prevents the formation of mesoderm and primitive endoderm progenitors26.
Limitations of the Technique
The most typical problem with this protocol of hPSC differentiation to trophoblast progenitors is associated with starting with a predominantly undifferentiated population of hESCs or hiPSCs on MEFs. Because hPSCs accumulate differentiated cells at both the inner and outer edges of the colonies, it is important to monitor the amount of differentiation daily and to remove differentiated colonies (or portions of colonies). The presence of differentiated cells can complicate the differentiation process, particularly when the cells are transferred to the extracellular matrix. The differentiated cells will quickly proliferate on the extracellular matrix in the presence of CM, and these cells will rapidly take over the culture and out-compete the hPSCs. Therefore, it is ideal to begin with healthy, undifferentiated colonies of hPSCs grown on MEFs before transferring the cells to the extracellular matrix.
Significance of the Technique with Respect to Existing/Alternative Methods
When using this differentiation protocol, the resulting trophoblast progenitors are a heterogenous mixture of cell types. Trophoblasts are comprised of villous cytotrophoblasts, syncytiotrophoblasts (SYNs), and extravillous cytotrophoblasts (EVTs)27. Villous cytotrophoblasts are the progenitors that generate EVTs and SYNs. BMP4-differentiated hPSCs will generate a mixture of villous cytotrophoblasts, SYNs, and EVTs9,15, which have been defined by the gene or protein expression of placental-specific markers. The distinct differentiation pathways can be distinguished by the secretion of HLA-G (characteristic of EVTs) or human chorionic gonadotropin (from SYNs)28,29. Recently, it has been shown that the inhibition of Activin/Nodal signaling favors EVT differentiation from hESCs, and the removal of this inhibition favors differentiation to SYN17. Indeed, an earlier publication found that using BMP4 alone to differentiate hESCs generates mostly SYN cells26. The data using BMP4/A/P and conditioned medium (lacking B-FGF) indicate that there are both EVT and SYN cells present by differentiation day 5. If pure EVT or SYN populations are desired, additional purification using cell surface markers, such as HLA-G conjugated to beads for the isolation of EVTs, is possible29. In conclusion, the culture method described here is an efficient way to generate significant amounts of trophoblastic cells from hPSCs that can be used for a variety of applications. Because this protocol generates both SYNs and EVTs, it is a suitable model system for examining the early human placenta. These cells can be used for a variety of applications, including drug discovery and genetic engineering.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported by a Pennsylvania Health Research Formula Fund.
DMEM/F12 | Invitrogen | 11330-057 | |
Knock Out Serum Replacement | Invitrogen | 10828-028 | This is referred to as "serum replacement" in this protocol. |
NEAA | Invitrogen | 11140-050 | |
FBS | Invitrogen | 16000-044 | |
L-Glutamine | Invitrogen | 10828-028 | |
Penicillin/Streptomycin | Invitrogen | 15140-155 | |
2-Mercaptoethanol | Sigma | M-7522 | |
B-FGF | Millipore | GF-003 | |
DMEM | Invitrogen | 11965-118 | |
Dispase | Invitrogen | 17105-041 | |
Collagenase Type IV | Invitrogen | 17104-019 | |
Rock inhibitor Y27632 | Calbiochem | 688000 | |
Irradiated CF1 MEFs | GlobalStem | 6001G | MEFs can be generated from embryonic day 13.5 embyos and irradiated. |
0.22 um syringe filter | Millipore | SLGS033SS | |
Heracell 150i low oxygen incubator | Heracell/VWR | 89187-192 | Any tissue culture incubator with capacity to regulate oxygen concentrations is sufficient. |
BMP4 | R&D Systems | 314-BP-01M | |
A 83-01 | R&D Systems | 2939/10 | |
PD173074 | R&D Systems | 3044/10 | |
RNAiMax | Invitrogen | 13778150 | |
Trizol | ThermoFisher | 15596026 | Trizol is used to isolate total RNA. |
X-tremeGENE 9 | Roche | 6365779001 | |
Matrigel | Corning | 356231 | This is referred to as "extracellular matrix" in this protocol. |