This protocol describes how measuring bite force and head withdrawal threshold can capture pain behavior in Complete Freund’s Adjuvant (CFA)-induced inflammatory temporomandibular joint (TMJ) pain.
Temporomandibular joint (TMJ) pain and osteoarthritis (OA) are common and debilitating disorders that impair patients’ quality of life. The mechanisms driving diseases-related pain are poorly understood, and current treatments fail to provide effective and long-term therapeutic effects. Additionally, pain assessment in research, particularly orofacial pain, poses several challenges that complicate studies in both clinical and basic science settings. Therefore, we have established an inflammatory TMJ pain mouse model via intra-articular injection of CFA (Complete Freund’s Adjuvant) and evaluated pain behaviors by bite force measurement and the von Frey filament test. Mice with CFA injection exhibited orofacial pain behaviors compared to PBS injection, including reduced bite force and head withdrawal threshold in the von Frey filament test. These methods are relatively easy to execute to have reproducible results and can be potentially extended to pain studies for other disease models related to TMJ disorders. Together, bite force, and the von Frey filament tests are reliable in measuring orofacial pain, as demonstrated in CFA injection-induced painful TMJOA mouse models.
Temporomandibular disorders (TMD) refer to pain and dysfunction of musculoskeletal and neuromuscular structures affecting the temporomandibular joints (TMJ), masticatory muscles, and associated structures. The TMJ is the most frequently used synovial joint in daily life. About 80% of TMD patients show signs and symptoms of TMJ diseases, which can significantly impact their quality of life1,2,3. In addition, TMJ osteoarthritis (TMJOA) is an important subtype of TMD and is defined as a progressive degenerative joint disease. Patients with TMJOA often present with joint pain. Painful TMJ is one of the primary reasons for patients to seek treatment4,5. However, there is an unmet medical need for more effective treatments to alleviate painful TMJOA. Understanding painful TMJOA is crucial for developing disease-modifying OA drugs (DMOADs).
Since obtaining clinical samples from patients with TMJOA pain is difficult, animal models have become essential tools for studying TMJOA pathologies6,7. Integrating the assessment of pain behavior can provide valuable insights into its underlying mechanisms and potential new therapeutic interventions. Pain measurement in animal models is challenging due to the subjective nature of pain perception and expression in non-human subjects6,8. Relatively few studies have used pain behavioral assays in TMJ compared to non-craniofacial joints. Therefore, it is important to define methods for assessing pain behavior to reliably capture the pain experience in animal models of TMJOA.
In this article, we have illustrated two distinct methods designed to evaluate pain in mouse models of TMJOA: bite force measurement and the von Frey filament test. Jaw and muscle coordination is essential for masticatory function, and pain associated with TMJ and muscle function can reduce bite force in TMD patients3,9. Thus, pain-related behavior secondary to masticatory function can be assessed using bite force measurement, which effectively reflects TMJ function related to joint pain. Additionally, the von Frey filament test measures the head withdrawal threshold to assess mechanical sensitivity. In this method, von Frey filaments with increasing force are applied to the skin of mice until a withdrawal response is observed. The force that triggers the head withdrawal response is recorded as the head withdrawal threshold. This technique is widely used for assessing mechanical allodynia, indicating peripheral nociceptor sensitization associated with orofacial pain8,10,11.
Although previous studies have used these methods to measure pain behavior, none have provided detailed protocols for direct implementation or combined these methods to assess TMJ pain induced by intra-articular injection of CFA12,13,14,15. Therefore, these methods are developed and validated to demonstrate their sensitivity and reproducibility in measuring the severity and progression of pain. These two complementary approaches provide cross-validation for pain behavior assessment. Importantly, the pain behavioral outcomes from these techniques can correlate with the histological and pathological features in painful TMJOA mice14,16. Additionally, measuring bite force provides valuable data for evaluating jaw function, while the von Frey test measures mechanical nociception8. Therefore, these protocols can be applied to assess pain behavior in various orofacial pain conditions, including odontogenic pain, TMJ pain, muscle pain, and neuropathic pain.
All animal procedures were approved by the University of Southern California Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC). Eight weeks of C57BL/6 female mice with body weight between 19-20 g were used in this study. The mice were housed in standard cages under environmental conditions with regulated humidity and 12-h light/dark cycles. The reagents and equipment used are listed in the Table of Materials.
1. CFA intra-articular injection to induce TMJOA
2. Measurement of bite force
3. Measurement of head withdrawal threshold
Inflammatory-induced TMJOA pain is induced by injecting CFA into the TMJ. As the left and right TMJ must coordinate during jaw movement, CFA is injected into both the left and right joints to assess TMJ pain. The sham group will receive injections of PBS as controls. Mean ± SEM and Student's t-test are used to statistically analyze the differences in pain behavior between the CFA and sham groups.
Measurements of bite force and head withdrawal threshold are used to examine whether mice experience TMJ pain. CFA-treated mice exhibited significant reductions in both their bite force levels and head withdrawal thresholds on day 1 following CFA injection compared to their baseline levels, with gradual increases observed at later time points. In contrast, the control group injected with PBS showed no significant changes in bite force or responses to von Frey filament tests compared to their baseline training (Figure 4A–D). These results suggest that mice receiving CFA injections experienced TMJ pain with mechanical allodynia and impaired masticatory function.
Figure 1: TMJ intra-articular injection in mouse model. (A) The mouse was anesthetized with isofluorane using a nosecone. The yellow line indicated the imaginary line from eye level to ear canal. (B) Anatomical landmark for injection. The black dash line indicates the zygomatic arch, which can be palpated from the skin. The depressed area for the injection site was indicated with a red mark. (C) The condylar head of TMJ can be seen when removing the masseter muscle. (D,E) Fast green dye was injected to indicate the condylar head of TMJ. Scale bar: 1 mm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Recording of bite force measurement. (A,B) Bite force machine and the computer for recording bite force. (C) The amplitude of the bite force recording during bite force measurement. (D–F) Parameters in the program for recording bite force. (D'–F') Enlargements of each parameter section. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Electronic Von Frey analgesiometer. (A,B) Von Frey filament instruments. (C) The screen that shows up when the machine is turned on. (D) Set the machine to zero to start recording. (E) The amount of force applied by von Frey to trigger head withdrawal response. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Pain behavior assessment in CFA-induced inflammatory TMJOA compared to PBS control group. (A,B) Bite force measurement and the percentage change of bite force values compared to baseline. (C,D) Measurement of head withdrawal threshold by von Frey filament test and the percentage change of head withdrawal threshold compared to baseline. Values represent mean ± SEM, Student's t-test. *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001, ****p < 0.0001. n = 6 mice for PBS group, n = 8 mice for CFA group. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Supplementary File 1: Bite force measurement and analysis. Column A indicates the time point of each bite event, while Column B records the amplitude or value of the bite force. This table presents data organized by the maximum absolute value of the bite force. Please click here to download this File.
An inflammatory-induced TMJOA in mice serves as an animal model to investigate pain mechanisms in TMJOA since the intra-articular CFA injection can induce pain and inflammation, resulting in synovitis, bone loss, and cartilage remodeling. These conditions resemble the pathology observed in humans to a certain degree and contribute to the main characteristics of TMJOA, such as joint pain and inflammation in patients13,18. Painful symptoms associated with TMJOA are the major reason for patients to seek medical help. Being able to detect the presence and severity of pain in animal models provides opportunities to investigate pain pathogenesis and potential new treatments. This report described the method for assessing TMJ pain behavior through measurements of bite force and head withdrawal threshold. TMJ is one of the key structures involved in all jaw movement, including mouth opening-closing, biting, and chewing. Additionally, the dominant clinical manifestation of TMD is pain associated with chewing or mastication. TMD patients with TMJ pain typically have reduced bite force compared to healthy individuals9,19. Consistent with clinical studies, intra-articular injection of CFA in mouse models can lead to a significant decrease in bite force that could be considered equivalent to symptoms related to TMJ pain and dysfunction in humans11.
The clinical diagnosis of TMJ pain involves palpating the TMJ and recording the severity of pain based on the patient's report. This procedure is similar to the von Frey filament test, which measures the lowest threshold force leading to head withdrawal behavior. Head withdrawal indicates pain response and hyperalgesia state of the orofacial region20. A reduced head withdrawal threshold may indicate joint tenderness and a lower pressure pain threshold in patients with TMJ pain18,19,21. Consequently, the von Frey filament test is useful for assessing the pressure pain threshold for TMD. In the CFA-induced TMJOA mouse model, measuring bite force and head withdrawal threshold has been validated as a reliable method for evaluating pain behavior22.
Most behavioral outcomes are somewhat subjective. Like many other behavioral assays, variation is always a concern when measuring orofacial pain. To achieve the goal of reliable, reproducible, and sensitive measurements of TMJ pain, it is important to note the limitations and potential solutions in our experimental design, execution, and result interpretation. One caveat is that reduced bite force could be caused by TMJ dysfunction that is not necessary from joint pain. For example, muscles play a crucial role in TMJ movement and biting. Reduced bite force could be due to muscle dysfunction rather than joint pain. However, radiographic and histological findings can be used to differentiate CFA-induced TMJ pain from muscle pain. TMJ pain from CFA injection will subsequently lead to cartilage and bone loss, whereas CFA-induced muscle pain is less likely to cause bone loss16.
It should be noted that this study used electronic von Frey to measure the head withdrawal threshold on a continual scale, which can minimize the number of force applications and thus prevent injury to the facial skin in the test area23. It has been reported that there are notable differences in the withdrawal threshold values obtained from manual and electronic von Frey. Typically, the withdrawal threshold measured with electronic von Frey tends to be higher than that measured with manual von Frey8,10. The plastic tip of our electronic von Frey is not sharp to avoid facial skin injury, which could lead to different values from manual von Frey filaments. In addition, the "g" unit in the electronic von Frey test is not an actual force but an arbitrary unit set by the machine. Additionally, to minimize the skin pain, the hair was removed from the injection site before starting baseline training. This approach should reduce the confounding factors of skin pain and sensitivity and prevent potential infection contamination. Meanwhile, PBS was also injected in the sham group under the same procedure to maximally exclude the confounding effects from skin pain and to ensure the measurement is from joint pain. Although intra-articular injection of CFA is specific to the TMJ area, CFA-induced tissue inflammation is likely not limited to the joint itself, which potentially contributes to some pain response, including reduced bite force and decreased head withdrawal threshold. Overall, we acknowledge that we cannot completely exclude the secondary effect of TMJ inflammation-derived skin or muscle pain, which might contribute to the overall outcome.
The values of bite force and head withdrawal threshold obtained from each instrument could be different since they have different units, parameters, and protocols that are specifically set up for individual assays. Although female mice were used in this study, males can also be used to study painful TMJOA. However, there is sexual dimorphism in the basal nociceptive thresholds of rodents. Males and females exhibited various pain experiences, which can be characterized by distinct physiological and behavioral responses to painful stimuli24,25,26. Additionally, male mice tend to have a higher head withdrawal threshold and bite force than females. Age and body weight also affect bite force values11,16,27. A previous study reported that there was a positive correlation between bite force and body weight during the initial two weeks of observation11. Bite force values for female C57BL/6 mice at 8 weeks old at baseline in this study ranged from 4.5-5.5 N (Figure 4A). After CFA injection, the reduction in bite force to 2-3 N in the early phase is consistent with the previous studies involving the induction of TMJOA using the MIA inflammatory substance6. However, using the percentage change in bite force can serve as a means to validate the consistency of findings with other previous studies since each laboratory might have different instruments and protocols, resulting in different values27,28.
To reduce variation in pain behavior measurement, the critical step is to validate and ensure consistency in training the mice at baseline. Variation can arise from differences in sex, body weight, and age, all of which can affect bite force and head withdrawal threshold measurements. For example, 8-week-old female mice typically weigh around 19-20 g; relative bite force values usually fall within the range of 4.5-5.5 N based on data from baseline training. Therefore, mice with average bite force values outside baseline training ranges should be excluded from the experiment. Similarly, the head withdrawal threshold during baseline training ranges between 22-35 g. Mice with a head withdrawal threshold outside this range should be excluded from the experiment. Overall, it is important to establish the benchmark of bite force and head withdrawal threshold during animal training before the formal behavioral tests.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
We thank the Chen laboratory colleagues for stimulating discussions. We appreciate the support from Thach-Vu Ho for helping with mouse images. This study was supported by grant R01DE033511 (J.C.) from the National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research (NIDCR).
Bite force transducer | Nanjing Shen-yuan-sheng Intelligent Technology Co | NBIT-YFM-1-100 | 0–100 N, a bite force transducer connected to the NB IT RSD-V2.6.3 program (NST2000 data collector) from Nanjing Shen-yuan-sheng Intelligent Technology Co., PR. China |
Complete Freund's Adjuvant (CFA) | Chondrex Inc | 7023 | CFA 5mg/mL |
Isofluorane | Fluoriso | MWI501017 | |
NBIT RSD-V2.6.3 program | Nanjing Shen-yuan-sheng Intelligent Technology Co | ||
Polyethylene tube | Scientific Commodities Inc | NC0923369 | PE Tubing 0.38 x 1.09 mm 100 Ft |
Von Frey analgesiometer | Bioseb | BIO-EVF4 | Electric Von Frey |
.