This protocol presents a fluorescence imaging method that uses a class of pH-sensitive lipid fluorophores to monitor lipid membrane trafficking during cell exocytosis and the endocytosis cycle.
Exo-/endocytosis is a common process mediating the exchange of biomolecules between cells and their environment and among different cells. Specialized cells use this process to execute vital body functions such as insulin secretion from β cells and neurotransmitter release from chemical synapses. Owing to its physiological significance, exo-/endocytosis has been one of the most studied topics in cell biology. Many tools have been developed to study this process at the gene and protein level, because of which much is known about the protein machinery participating in this process. However, very few methods have been developed to measure membrane lipid turnover, which is the physical basis of exo-/endocytosis.
This paper introduces a class of new fluorescent lipid analogs exhibiting pH-dependent fluorescence and demonstrates their use to trace lipid recycling between the plasma membrane and the secretory vesicles. Aided by simple pH manipulations, those analogs also allow the quantification of lipid distribution across the surface and the intracellular membrane compartments, as well as the measurement of lipid turnover rate during exo-/endocytosis. These novel lipid reporters will be of great interest to various biological research fields such as cell biology and neuroscience.
The lipid bilayer is one of the most common biomolecule assemblies and is indispensable for all cells. Outside cells, it forms the plasma membrane interfacing cells and their environment; inside cells, it compartmentalizes various organelles specialized for designated functionalities. Rather dynamic than still, lipid membranes constantly experience fusion and fission, which mediates biomaterial transport, organelle reform, morphology change, and cellular communication. Undoubtedly, the lipid membrane is the physical foundation for almost all cellular processes, and its dysfunction plays a crucial role in various disorders ranging from cancer1 to Alzheimer's disease2. Although lipid molecules are far less diverse than proteins, membrane research so far has mainly been protein-centric. For example, a lot more is known about protein machinery than about lipids in exocytosis3,4,5. Moreover, the organization, distribution, dynamics, and homeostasis of lipids across surface and intracellular membranes largely remain unexplored in comparison to membrane proteins6.
This is not surprising as modern molecular biology techniques, such as mutagenesis, provide a methodological advantage for studying proteins rather than lipids. For example, transgenic tagging of pH-sensitive green fluorescent protein (a.k.a., pHluorin) to vesicular proteins facilitates the quantitative measurement of the amount and rate of vesicular protein turnover during exo-/endocytosis7,8,9. However, it is almost impossible to genetically modify membrane lipids in vivo. Moreover, qualitative and even quantitative manipulations of protein amounts and distributions are much more feasible than those of lipids10. Nevertheless, native and synthetic fluorescent lipids have been isolated and developed to simulate endogenous membrane lipids in vitro and in vivo11. One group of widely used fluorescent lipids are styryl dyes, e.g., FM1-43, which exhibit membrane-enhanced fluorescence and are a powerful tool in studying synaptic vesicle (SV) release in neurons12. Lately, environment-sensitive lipid dyes have been invented and widely used as a new class of reporters to study various cell membrane properties, including membrane potential11, phase order13, and secretion14.
A new class of lipid mimetics whose fluorescence is both pH-sensitive (e.g., pHluorin) and membrane-sensitive (e.g., FM1-43) was developed to directly measure the lipid distribution in the plasma membrane and endosomes/lysosomes and the lipid traffic during exo-/endocytosis. The well-known solvatochromic fluorophores exhibiting push-pull characteristics due to intramolecular charge transfer were selected for this purpose. Among existing solvatochromic fluorophores, the 1,8-naphthalimide (ND) scaffold is relatively easy to modify, versatile for tagging, and is unique in photo-physics15 and has therefore been used in DNA intercalators, organic light-emitting diodes, and biomolecule sensors16,17,18.
Attaching an electron-donating group to the C4 position of the ND scaffold generates a push-pull structure, which leads to an increased dipole moment by redistributing the electron density in the excited state19,20. Such an intramolecular charge transfer produces large quantum yields and Stokes shifts, resulting in bright and stable fluorescence21. This group has recently developed a series of solvatochromic lipid analogs based on the ND scaffold and obtained them with good synthetic yields20.
Spectroscopic characterization shows that among those products, ND6 possesses the best fluorescence properties (Figure 1)20. First, it has well-separated excitation and emission peaks (i.e., ~400 nm and ~520 nm, respectively, in Figure 2A,B) compared to popular fluorophores such as fluorescein isothiocyanate, rhodamine, or GFP, making it spectrally separatable from them and thus useful for multicolor imaging. Second, ND6 fluorescence exhibits a more than eight-fold increase in its fluorescence in the presence of micelles (Figure 2C), suggesting a strong membrane-dependency. Prior live-cell fluorescence imaging studies with different types of cells showed excellent membrane staining by ND620. Third, when the solution's pH is decreased from 7.5 (commonly found in extracellular or cytosolic environments) to 5.5 (commonly found in endosomes and lysosomes), ND6 shows an approximately two-fold increase in fluorescence (Figure 2D), showing its pH-sensitivity. Moreover, molecular dynamics simulation indicates that ND6 readily integrates into the lipid bilayer with its ND scaffold facing out of the membrane and piperazine residue showing strong interactions with phospholipid head groups (Figure 3). Altogether, these features make ND6 an ideal fluorescent lipid analog to visualize and measure membrane lipid turnover during exo-/endocytosis.
This paper presents a method to study the turnover rate and dynamics of SV lipids using cultured mouse hippocampal neurons. By stimulating neurons with high K+ Tyrode's solutions, SVs and the plasma membrane were loaded with ND6 (Figure 4A,B). Subsequently, neurons were re-stimulated with different stimuli followed by NH4Cl-containing and pH 5.5 Tyrode's solutions (Figure 4D). This protocol facilitates the quantitative measurement of the assembled exocytosis and endocytosis rates under different circumstances (Figure 4C).
The following protocol includes (1) a simplified procedure for establishing mouse hippocampal and cortical cultures based on a well-established protocol22, (2) a brief introduction to an epifluorescence microscope setup for live neurons, (3) a detailed description of loading and imaging ND6 in mouse neurons, (4) a discussion about the quantification of membrane trafficking by ND6 signal. All procedures follow the biosafety and IACUC guidelines at the Florida Atlantic University. The synthesis of ND6 has been described previously20.
1. Preparation of mouse hippocampal and cortical cultures
NOTE: If not specified otherwise, all steps must be performed in a biosafety level 2 laminar flow hood. Sterilize all tools and materials.
2. Microscope setup for live-cell fluorescence imaging
NOTE: An exemplary imaging setup (Figure 5) includes at least an inverted fluorescence microscope (see the Table of Materials), fluorescence light source with automatic shutter, fluorescence filter sets (e.g., for imaging ND6, use 405/10 BP for excitation, 495 LP for dichroic, and 510/20 BP for emission), and a high-sensitivity camera (Table of Materials), all of which are controlled by image acquisition software (Table of Materials).
3. Loading and imaging ND6 in neuronal cultures
4. Quantification of membrane trafficking by a change in ND6 fluorescence
SVs are specialized for neurotransmitter release via evoked exo-/endocytosis27. SVs have highly acidic lumen (i.e., pH 5.5), which is ideal for ND6. We used high K+ stimulation to evoke SV exo-/endocytosis in order to allow ND6 to access SV. Expectedly, bright green fluorescent puncta along neuronal processes showed up after loading (Figure 9A). The line profile shown in Figure 4B demonstrated a strong overlap between ND6 (green curve) and FM4-64 puncta (red curve). The strong correlation between ND6 and FM4-64 fluorescence intensities also suggest a SV-staining of ND6 (Figure 9B).
An electric stimulation and a high K+ stimulation were used to evoke the release of the readily releasable pool (RRP, i.e., SVs with high release probability) and the reserve pool SVs (i.e., SVs with low release probability), respectively. There were decreases in ND6 fluorescence in response to both stimuli (Figure 4C and Figure 4E), which suggests that ND6 resides in the SV membrane and that the SV lumen is neutralized (reported by ND6 signal decrease) during the SV release.
At the end of every trial, 50 mM NH4Cl was applied to deacidify SVs28 and pH 5.5 solution to brighten surface membrane ND6 (Figure 4D and Figure 4F). The differences in fluorescence allow us to determine ND6 in the surface membrane (~44%) and SV membrane (~56%). These number match the fractions of surface and SV membranes at the axon terminals29, suggesting that ND6 evenly distributes across membranes. Moreover, ND6 signals during two different stimuli and two pH manipulations allow us to estimate that the short electric burst mobilized about ~31% SVs and high K+ stimulation released ~70% of the remaining SVs. The rates of ND fluorescence decrease during the stimulations also match the time constant for the evoked SV exocytosis previously reported30.
ND6’s compact size leads to much less steric disturbance to cell membranes than previous tagging method14 and thus offers more accurate measurement of SV trafficking. Supporting that idea, a ten-time higher loading concentration showed no significant difference in FM4-64 destaining during stimulation (Figure 10). However, 1μM is still recommended given its moderate staining in astrocytes.
As SV exo-/endocytosis involves cholesterol (an abundant and vital lipid in the neuronal membranes), we have used ND6 imaging to ask how membrane cholesterol affects SV release and retrieval. A 1-mM for 90-min treatment of methyl-β-cyclodextrin (MβCD) can remove ~10% cholesterol from neuronal surface membrane31, mimicking aging-associated membrane cholesterol decrease. Under an exhaustive electric stimulation, the MβCD treatment significantly reduced SV release and retrieval measured by ND6 imaging (Figure 11A), which suggests that membrane cholesterol facilitates SV exo-/endocytosis32. We also evaluated cholesterol’s contribution to SV pool replenishment, which is crucial for the fidelity of neurotransmission33. Two electric stimulations with a 10-s interval was applied in the presence of Bafilomycin A1 (BafA1). BafA1 selectively inhibits v-ATPase that reacidifies SVs. By acutely blocking the reacidification of retrieved SVs, BafA1 prevents ND6 fluorescence recovery after stimulation (Figure 11B). The ND6 decrease during the second stimulus should only come from nascent SVs that replenish empty RRP. In comparison to the sham control, a significantly smaller ND6 response to the second stimulus was observed in the neurons pretreated with MβCD (i.e., smaller amplitude and faster decay of ND6 fluorescence reduction). This result supports the notion that cholesterol plays a pivotal role in recruiting new SVs to RRP.
Figure 1: General synthesis scheme for ND6 probe. This figure has been modified from Thomas et al.20. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Properties of ND6. (A and B) Solvatochromic properties of ND6. Absorbance spectra (A) and fluorescence spectra (B) in various solvents excited at 405 nm. (C) Comparison of fluorescence intensity of ND6 in water (red) and 1% octyl glucoside solution at 1 µM. (D) ND6 fluorescence as a function of pH in 1% OG solution is proportional to protonation state of piperazine head group (calculated pKa = 7.4). Inset shows calculated protonation state of ND6 piperazine moiety (predicted pKa = 8.83). The dashed line represents fitted values. This figure has been modified from Thomas et al.20. Abbreviations: DCM = dichloromethane; MeCN = acetonitrile; DMSO = dimethylsulfoxide; EtOH = ethyl alcohol; MeOH = methyl alcohol; Abs= absorbance; Em = emission; OG = octyl glucoside. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Snapshot from molecular dynamics simulation trajectory. Interaction of ND6 probe in POPC membrane (left panel). Piperazine head group interacts strongly with phosphate groups (right panel) through electrostatic interactions. The black arrow (right panel) points at the C-N bond between the naphthalimide ring and piperazine. Results show that the piperazine group moves only slightly with a preference for the dihedral angle (atoms showed) between 90 and 120 degrees while maintaining its chair conformation. This figure has been modified from Thomas et al.20. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: ND6 labels synaptic vesicles and reports their release and retrieval in the nerve terminals. (A) Sample images of FM4-64 (red), ND6 (green), and overlay (yellow). The neurites and soma of one neuron were line-profiled. The straightened line images (20-pixel width) are next to the corresponding images. Arrowheads point to synaptic boutons marked by FM4-64. Scale bars = 100 µm. (B) Line profiles of FM4-64 and ND6 fluorescence intensities exhibit significant resemblance. (C) Sample traces of ND6 fluorescence changes at synaptic boutons indicated by arrowheads in A in response to stimuli. (D) Sample traces of ND6 fluorescence changes in response to NH4Cl and pH 5.5 Tyrode's solutions. (E) The de-staining of FM4-64 is temporarily coupled to ND6 intensity changes. Data are plotted as mean ± S.E.M. (F) ND6 fluorescence intensity but not FM4-64 intensity was decreased and increased by the applications of 50 mM NH4Cl and pH 5.5 Tyrode's solutions, respectively. Data are plotted as mean ± S.E.M. This figure has been modified from Thomas et al.20. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: Imaging setup based on a Nikon-TiE inverted microscope. Annotated are four components required for live-cell fluorescence imaging. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6: Stimulation-imaging setup. Setup modified from a Warner Instruments RC-26 chamber and PH-1 heating platform for temperature control and solution exchange. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 7: Diagram of device configurations for image acquisition with synchronized stimulations and solution exchanges. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 8: Sample images demonstrating the key steps in image analysis. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 9: ND6 highlights synaptic vesicles clustered at presynaptic terminals. (A) Sample images FM4-64 (red) and ND6 (green) co-loading at high magnification. Scale bar = 30 µm. (B) Scatter plot of FM4-64 and ND6 mean fluorescence intensities at the same ROIs corresponding to synaptic boutons and linear regression fit. r = 0.8353; p = 1.7 × 10-8; fields of view N = 9; ROIs n = 450. The threshold for FM4-64 is 1,200 au (arbitrary unit) and 160 au for ND6. This figure has been modified from Thomas et al.20. Abbreviation: ROIs = regions of interest. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 10: ND6 does not intervene with SVs. (A) ND6-represented SV turnover (by electric stimulus) after 1 or 10 µM ND6 loading. (B) FM4-64-measured SV turnover (with the electric stimulus). This figure has been modified from Thomas et al.20. Abbreviation: SVs = synaptic vesicles. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 11: Cholesterol reduction impairs SV turnover. (A) ND6-represented SV turnover under 10 Hz, 120 s electric stimulus in control and MβCD-treated neurons. (B) Bafilomycin A1 prevents the reacidification of recycled SVs (i.e., no ND6 fluorescence recovery after stimulation-evoked decrease) and further elucidates MβCD's impact on SV replenishment. This figure has been modified from Thomas et al.20. Abbreviation: SV = synaptic vesicle; MβCD = methyl-β-cyclodextrin; BafA1 = Bafilomycin A1. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Lipid-based dyes, such as 1,1′-dioctadecyl-3,3,3′,3′-tetramethylindocarbocyanine (DiI) and 3,3′-Dioctadecyloxacarbocyanine perchlorate (DiO), have long been used to illustrate cell morphology and track cellular processes such as the axon projections of neurons. Styryl dyes, such as FM1-43, have been invented and used successfully for the study of exocytosis34. Due to their low membrane affinity, they selectively label endocytosed vesicles where they are trapped while dyes remaining on the plasma membrane are washed off by constant perfusion. As such, styryl dyes are not suitable for continuous monitoring of vesicle recycling.
The recent invention of pH-sensitive GFP (i.e., pHluorin) made it possible to repeatedly visualize vesicle recycling when tagged to a vesicular membrane protein such as VAMPII or Synaptophysin35. Following the same principle, tagging a pH-sensitive fluorophore to lipid molecules enables the tracking of lipid membrane recycling during cycles of exo-/endocytosis14. In this case, being a single entity of lipid, ND6 is easier to prepare, simpler to apply, more efficient to label lipid membranes, less disruptive to cells, more stable in staying in cell membranes, and thus more reliable for fluorescence imaging. Its membrane-dependency and inverse pH-sensitivity allow brighter staining of acidic organelles such as SVs and endosomes.
Moreover, it is also feasible to label such acidic organelles or presynaptic terminals in tissues such as hippocampal slices as unspecifically distributed ND6 is quenched by neutral pH in extracellular or cytosolic spaces. Additionally, its large Stokes shift makes ND6 ideal for multiphoton imaging of deep tissues. Therefore, ND6 and other pH-sensitive lipid-based fluorophores allow the real-time optical measurement of lipid and cell membrane trafficking between the plasma membrane and intracellular apparatus such as SVs and endosomes for multiple rounds of exo-/endocytosis. Given that synapses and SVs are vital to neurotransmission, ND6 is undoubtedly useful for studying synaptic physiology.
Given the modular design of these lipid analogs, it is feasible to conjugate ND to other lipids, such as phospholipids and sphingolipids, in various types of cell membranes or organelles. Moreover, the ND groups can be replaced with other environment-sensitive fluorophores to detect other environmental factors such as calcium or zinc concentration inside or outside cells or organelles. Furthermore, fluorophores with different emission spectra can be linked to membrane lipids to expand the palette of lipid reporters. For all those modifications, the linker between lipids and ND or other fluorescent groups can be adjusted to achieve better photo-properties and/or desired sensitivities.
This protocol describes the use of ND6 in visualizing SV turnover using live-cell imaging. Critical steps include loading, synchronized stimulations, and fluorescence quantification, all of which significantly affect the quality of the results. Moreover, the parameters/settings used in those steps can be modified according to the needs of the study. For example, the stimulation during the loading can be adjusted (shorter or longer duration) to allow the access of different pools of SVs (pools with high or low releasable probabilities, respectively). For live-cell fluorescence imaging, it is important to strike a balance between cell health and fluorescence intensity, which is particularly important here. This is because the excitation for ND6 is near-UV (i.e., 405 nm), which can cause more phototoxicity and dye breakdown than visible light. Thus, it is important to adjust the excitation power, exposure time, frame rate, and imaging duration to minimize photodamage and maximize the signal quality.
ND6 is a very interesting probe. Its large Stokes shift made it possible to be used it simultaneously with other membrane dyes such as FM4-6420. More importantly, it is a suitable donor candidate for fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) and can be excited by purple light, which will be much less likely to co-excite the FRET recipient. Lipid-mimicking dyes, such as ND6, make it possible to study the interactions between membrane proteins and lipids during exo-/endocytosis. The pH-dependent association and dissociation between membrane proteins and lipids will be magnified in the acidic lumen of SVs or endosomes, facilitating the exploration of the role of membrane lipids in receptor-mediated endocytosis and sorting. In summary, ND6 and its derivatives can significantly expand the toolbox for studying membrane lipids and their trafficking in live cells.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported by Florida Atlantic University Office of Undergraduate Research and Inquiry grant (M.J.S.), Florida Department of Health Ed and Ethel Moore Pilot Grant 20A17 (Q.Z.), Alzheimer's Association grant AARG-NTF-19-618710 (Q.Z.), and NIA R21 grant AG061656-01A1 (Q.Z.).
Digidata 1440A Data Acquistion System | Molecular Devices | Digidata 1440A | For synchronized stimulation and solution exchange |
Dual Channel Temperature Controller | Warner Instruments | TC-344B | For live-cell imaging |
Fetal Bovine Serum | OMEGA Scientific | FB-01 | For making H+20 solution used in dissection and tissue culture |
Hamamatsu Flash4.0 sCOMS camera | Hamamatsu Inc. | C13440-20CU | high-sensitivity camera |
Hank's Balanced Salt Solution | Sigma | H6648 | For making H+20 solution used in dissection and tissue culture |
Heated Platform | Warner Instruments | PH-1 | For live-cell imaging |
Matrigel | BD Biosciences | 354234 | For tissue culture |
Micro-G Vibration Isolation Table | TMC | 63-564 | For live-cell imaging |
Micro-manager | https://micro-manager.org/ | NA | For image acquisition control |
Multi-Line In-Line Solution Heater | Warner Instruments | SHM-6 | For live-cell imaging |
Neurobasal Plus Medium | THermoFisher Scientific | A3582901 | For tissue culture |
Nikon Ti-E Inverted Microscope | Nikon | Ti-E/B | For live-cell imaging |
ORCA-Flash4.0 Digital CMOS camera | Hamamatsu | C1340-20CU | For live-cell imaging |
Perfusion Chamber | Warner Instruments | RC-26G | For live-cell imaging |
Six-Channel Valve Control Perfusion System | Warner Instruments | VC-6 | For solution exchange |
Square Pulse Stimulator | Grass Instrument | SD9 | For electric field stimulation |