This protocol introduces a simple two-step method for differentiating corneal limbal epithelial stem cells from human pluripotent stem cells under xeno- and feeder cell-free culture conditions. The cell culture methods presented here enable cost-efficient, large-scale production of clinical quality cells applicable to corneal cell therapy use.
Corneal limbal epithelial stem cells (LESCs) are responsible for continuously renewing the corneal epithelium, and thus maintaining corneal homeostasis and visual clarity. Human pluripotent stem cell (hPSC)-derived LESCs provide a promising cell source for corneal cell replacement therapy. Undefined, xenogeneic culture and differentiation conditions cause variation in research results and impede the clinical translation of hPSC-derived therapeutics. This protocol provides a reproducible and efficient method for hPSC-LESC differentiation under xeno- and feeder cell-free conditions. Firstly, monolayer culture of undifferentiated hPSC on recombinant laminin-521 (LN-521) and defined hPSC medium serves as a foundation for robust production of high-quality starting material for differentiations. Secondly, a rapid and simple hPSC-LESC differentiation method yields LESC populations in only 24 days. This method includes a four-day surface ectodermal induction in suspension with small molecules, followed by adherent culture phase on LN-521/collagen IV combination matrix in defined corneal epithelial differentiation medium. Cryostoring and extended differentiation further purifies the cell population and enables banking of the cells in large quantities for cell therapy products. The resulting high-quality hPSC-LESCs provide a potential novel treatment strategy for corneal surface reconstruction to treat limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD).
The transparent cornea at the ocular surface allows light to enter the retina and provides the majority of the eye's refractive power. The outermost layer, the stratified corneal epithelium, is continuously regenerated by limbal epithelial stem cells (LESCs). The LESCs reside in the basal layer of the limbal niches at the corneoscleral junction1,2. LESCs lack specific and unique markers, so their identification requires a more extensive analysis of a set of putative markers. Epithelial transcription factor p63, and especially N-terminally truncated transcript of the alpha isoform of p63 (ΔNp63α), has been proposed as a relevant positive LESC marker3,4. Asymmetric division of LESCs allows them to self-renew, but also produce progeny that migrate centripetally and anteriorly. As the cells progress toward the corneal surface they gradually lose their stemness and finally terminally differentiate to superficial squamous cells that are continuously lost from the corneal surface.
Damage to any of the corneal layers can lead to severe visual impairment, and corneal defects are thus one of the leading causes of vision loss worldwide. In limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD), the limbus is destroyed by disease or trauma which leads to conjunctivalization and opacification of the corneal surface and subsequent loss of vision5,6. Cell replacement therapy using autologous or allogeneic limbal grafts offers a treatment strategy for patients with LSCD4,7,8,9. However, harvesting autologous grafts bears a risk of complications to the healthy eye, and donor tissue is in short supply. Human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs), specifically human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) and human induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPSCs), can serve as an unlimited source of clinically relevant cell types, including corneal epithelial cells. Therefore, hPSC-derived LESCs (hPSC-LESCs) represent an attractive new cell source for ocular cell replacement therapy.
Traditionally, both the undifferentiated hPSC culture methods and their differentiation protocols to LESCs have relied on the use of undefined feeder cells, animal sera, conditioned media, or amniotic membranes10,11,12,13,14,15. Recently, efforts toward safer cell therapy products have prompted the search for more standardized and xeno-free culture and differentiation protocols. As a result, several defined and xeno-free methods for long-term culture of undifferentiated hPSCs are now commercially available16,17,18. As a continuum, directed differentiation protocols relying on molecular cues to guide hPSCs to corneal epithelial fate have been recently introduced19,20,21,22,23. Yet many of these protocols used either undefined, feeder based hPSCs as starting material, or complex, xenogeneic growth factor cocktails for differentiation.
The purpose of this protocol is to provide a robust, optimized, xeno-and feeder-free hPSC culture method and subsequent differentiation to corneal LESCs. Monolayer culture of pluripotent hPSCs on laminin-521 (LN-521) matrix in defined, albumin-free hPSC medium (specifically Essential 8 Flex) allows rapid production of homogeneous starting material for differentiations. Thereafter a simple, two-step differentiation strategy guides hPSCs toward surface ectodermal fate in suspension, followed by adherent differentiation to LESCs. A cell population where > 65% express ΔNp63α is obtained within 24 days. The xeno- and feeder-free protocol has been tested with several hPSC lines (both hESCs and hiPSCs), without any requirement for cell line specific optimization. The protocols for weekend-free maintenance, passaging, cryostoring and hPSC-LESC phenotyping described here enable production of large batches of high-quality LESCs for clinical or research purposes.
University of Tampere has the approval of the National Authority for Medicolegal affairs Finland (Dnro 1426/32/300/05) to conduct research on human embryos. The institute also has supportive statements of the Ethical Committee of the Pirkanmaa Hospital District to derive, culture, and differentiate hESC lines (Skottman/R05116) and to use hiPSC lines in ophthalmic research (Skottman/R14023). No new cell lines were derived for this study.
NOTE: The protocol described is based on specific, commercially available hPSC and corneal epithelium differentiation media. Please refer to the Table of Materials for manufacturer/supplier information and catalog numbers.
1. Establishing Xeno- and Feeder-free hPSC Culture
2. Directed Differentiation and Cryopreservation of hPSC-derived LESCs
3. Phenotyping of hPSC-derived LESCs
From hPSCs to hPSC-LESCs
The entire process from inducing differentiation of FF hPSCs to cryostoring hPSC-LESCs takes around 3.5 weeks. Schematic overview of the differentiation method highlighting its key steps is presented in Figure 1A. Figure 1B shows typical morphologies of cell populations in different phases of the protocol. The data presented are obtained with Regea08/017 hESC line and UTA.04607.WT hiPSC line, both derived and characterized at the University of Tampere, Finland, as described previously26,27,28.
On LN-521 in hPSC medium, the undifferentiated, high quality FF hPSCs first form distinct colonies with sharp edges, which merge to homogeneous monolayers upon confluence (Figure 1B, first image). Several individually derived and genetically distinct hESC and hiPSC lines were successfully adapted and cultured with this system. The FF hPSC populations multiply approximately 3-fold within each passage, providing robust means to generate xeno-and feeder-free starting material for differentiations25. The 24 h induction in EB medium typically produces a suspension of tight, regular EBs of varying sizes (Figure 1B, second image). During the surface ectodermal induction in suspension (day 2–4), the EB morphology should not change dramatically. Colonial outgrowth appears soon after the EBs are plated onto col IV/LN-521 combination matrix in differentiation medium (Figure 1B, third and fourth images), and within 21–25 days of differentiation the cells form confluent homogeneous layers with polygonal morphology typical to epithelial cells (Figure 1B, fifth image). The cells may then be cryostored for later use. Viability and morphology are well preserved after thawing the hPSC-LESCs (Figure 1B, last image).
Typically, 3 x 106 FF hPSCs plated to a single 6-well plate yield enough EBs to be plated for adherent culture in 2–3 cell culture dishes (100 mm). From each 100 mm dish, 1 to 1.5 x 106 cells may be harvested for cryobanking by day 22–25 of differentiation. On average, each undifferentiated FF hPSC generates 0.7 cells by day 25 (Figure 2).
Validation of hPSC-derived LESCs
In the absence of specific LESC marker proteins, the correct cell phenotype is confirmed with a set of markers that demonstrate the decrease in expression of the pluripotency associated proteins and increased expression of acknowledged LESC markers. At day 24 of differentiation, the vast majority of the hPSC-derived LESCs express Paired box protein PAX6 (PAX6), the key regulator of eye development, as well as p63α, the widely recognized LESC marker. The truncated p63-isoform ΔNp63 is co-expressed in most of the p63α-positive cells, confirming the most cornea-specific ΔNp63α-positive cell phenotype. Basal epithelial markers and putative LESC markers cytokeratin (CK)-15 and CK-14 are expressed in part, whereas pluripotent stem cell marker OCT3/4 and mature corneal epithelial marker CK-12 are undetectable at this point. This indicates differentiation of FF hPSCs toward the unipotent limbal epithelial progenitors, but not yet terminal differentiation into mature corneal epithelial cells. (Figure 3A) The hPSC-LESCs successfully retain their phenotype after recovery from cryostorage (Data comparable to Figure 3A).
After 24 days of differentiation, ΔNp63 was expressed in 66.2% (n=33, SD 9.3%) of Regea08/017 hESC-LESCs, and in 65.7% (n=10, SD 4.1%) UTA.04607.WT hiPSC-LESCs (quantified from cytospin samples, Figure 3B). After recovery from cryostorage, 82.2% (n=10, SD 5.7%) of hESC-LESCs and 90.5% (n=10, SD=3.7%) of hiPSC-LESCs expressed ΔNp63 (quantified from well plates on day 26–28, Figure 3B).
The p63α expression was further confirmed with flow cytometry analysis for Regea08/017 hESC-LESCs. At day 25 of differentiation, 62% of the freshly differentiated hPSC-LESCs were positive for p63α. Two days after recovery from cryostorage (day 28 in total), 81% of the cells were p63α-positive (Figure 3C).
Figure 1: Schematic illustration of the hPSC-LESC differentiation protocol (A) and typical cell morphologies observed in different phases of the process (B). EBs are formed from a single cell suspension of high-quality, undifferentiated hPSCs during the first 24 h. Three-day small molecule induction toward surface ectoderm in suspension is followed by adherent differentiation phase. By day 24 of differentiation, the majority of the cells show typical LESC-like morphology. Representative images shown for Regea08/017 hESC line before and during differentiation. Black scale bar = 200 µm, valid for all images in the panel. Abbreviations: Blebb.: blebbistatin, SB: SB-505124 small molecule inhibitor, bFGF: basic fibroblast growth factor, BMP-4: bone morphogenetic protein 4, LN-521: human recombinant laminin 521, col IV: human placental collagen type IV, hPSC: human pluripotent stem cell, EB: embryoid body, LESC: limbal epithelial stem cells. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Expected cell yield. Boxplots showing the number of cells obtained for cryostoring on day 22-25 of differentiation, divided by number of undifferentiated hPSCs plated for EB formation step on day 0. On average 0.72 (SD 0.4) cells were produced from each pluripotent Regea08/017 hESC, while 0.78 (SD 0.67) cells were produced from each UTA.04607.WT hiPSC. n: number of differentiation experiments. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3. Expected phenotype of hPSC-derived LESCs. Immunofluorescence antibody labeling (A) showing uniform expression of eye development regulator PAX6 and acknowledged LESC markers p63α and its ΔNp63 isoform, as well as two other suggested LESC markers – CK15 and 14. Pluripotency marker OCT3/4 and mature corneal epithelial marker CK-12 are negative. Representative IF images shown for Regea08/017 hESC-LESCs at day 24 of differentiation. Scale bars = 100 µm. (B) ΔNp63 cell counting from freshly differentiated and cryostored hPSC-LESCs demonstrates that the cells do not only retain, but show increased ΔNp63 expression after cryostorage. Cell counting results show >65% of the freshly differentiated hPSC-LESCs stained positive for ΔNp63 before the cryobanking procedure, and >80% after successful recovery. n = number of separate differentiation experiments (minimum of 600 cells counted per sample and >1600 cells per time point) (C) Flow cytometry analysis showing 62% of the freshly differentiated hPSC-LESCs and 81% of the thawed cells positive for p63α, confirming the cell counting results for line Regea08/017. * in B-C indicate thawed cells. Red histogram for positive sample and black for negative (unstained) sample. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Antibody | Host | Dilution |
Primary antibodies for IF | ||
PAX6 | rabbit | 1:200 |
p63α | mouse | 1:200 |
ΔNp63α | rabbit | 1:200 |
CK-15 | mouse | 1:200 |
CK-14 | mouse | 1:200 |
CK-12 | goat | 1:200 |
OCT3/4 | goat | 1:200 |
Secondary antibodies for IF | ||
Alexa Fluor 568 anti-goat Ig | donkey | 1:800 |
Alexa Fluor 568 anti-mouse Ig | donkey | 1:800 |
Alexa Fluor 488 anti-rabbit Ig | donkey | 1:800 |
Alexa Fluor 488 anti-mouse Ig | donkey | 1:800 |
Table 1: Recommended primary and secondary antibodies used for immunofluorescence (IF) labeling of hPSC-derived LESCs. See Table of Materials for manufacturers.
The expected result of this protocol is the successful and robust generation of LESCs from a single cell suspension of FF hPSC within approximately 3.5 weeks. As corneal epithelium develops from surface ectoderm29, the first step of the protocol aims at steering hPSCs towards this lineage. A short 24 h induction with transforming growth factor beta (TGF-β) antagonist SB-505124, and bFGF are used to induce ectodermal differentiation, followed by 48 h mesodermal BMP-4 cue to push the cells towards surface ectoderm. The following adherent differentiation step on col IV/LN-521 combination matrix together with chemically defined differentiation medium is used to further guide differentiation towards LESCs.
High quality of the starting material (the FF hPSCs) is critical for successful differentiation. Only FF hPSC cultures with near confluence and close to 100% of undifferentiated phenotype should be used. Regular hPSC karyotyping is recommended, as single cell passaging can predispose hPSCs to karyotypic abnormalities that lead to growth and differentiation advantages30. Prolonged exposure to trypsin can cause inadequate EB formation or hPSC death. The protocol was tested with five individually derived and genetically distinct hPSC lines, both hESC and hiPSC lines. There was no need for cell line specific modifications to the small molecule concentrations or induction times. However, during the initial optimization of the protocol, excessive cell death or appearance of cells with fibroblastic, neuronal or other morphology indicated differentiation to undesired lineages. In such case, the method might require fine-tuning. The culture vessel formats provide a starting point and can be upscaled from the recommended sizes.
The entire protocol from hPSC culture to LESC differentiation and cryopreservation is defined, allowing easy transition to Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP) for production of cell therapy products. As the commercial media and reagents undergo robust development, manufacture and quality control procedures, they provide a consistent, uniform quality platform for hPSC culture and differentiations.The defined conditions minimize batch-to-batch variation, which offers an advantage over existing hPSC-LESC differentiation protocols10,11,12,13,14,20,22,23. The fast and relatively simple protocol also provides an advantage over three-dimensional corneal organoids which are difficult to standardize across cell lines and laboratories, and require robust methods to purify desired cell types31,32. Additionally, the highly efficient protocol provides robust means to produce LESCs for research purposes, e.g. disease modeling, genetic engineering, drug screening, and toxicological testing. Moreover, the platform can be easily fine-tuned for differentiation of other ocular epithelial cell types such as retinal pigment epithelial cells (RPE cells)25.
Successful limbal cell replacement therapy requires only a few thousand p63-positive LESCs4, per eye, but quality assurance requires additional cell populations and therefore large scale production. Cryobanking allows preparation of readily available cell stocks for transplantation, as well as for quality and safety testing. Further, the hPSC-LESC purity improves after cryostoring, and further after passaging and prolonged culture25, as suggested by increased ΔNp63 expression.
In summary, this robust method generates ΔNp63α-positive cells from hPSCs within 3.5 weeks under xeno- and feeder cell-free culture conditions. The cell culture methods presented here enable production of high-quality LESCs applicable to ocular cell therapy use.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
The study was supported by the Academy of Finland (grant number 297886), the Human spare parts program of Tekes, the Finnish Funding Agency for Technology and Innovation, the Finnish Eye and Tissue Bank Foundation and the Finnish Cultural Foundation. The authors thank the biomedical laboratory technicians Outi Melin, Hanna Pekkanen, Emma Vikstedt, and Outi Heikkilä for excellent technical assistance and contribution to cell culture. Professor Katriina Aalto-Setälä is acknowledged for providing the hiPSC line used and BioMediTech Imaging Core facility for providing equipment for fluorescence imaging.
Material/Reagent | |||
1x DPBS containing Ca2+ and Mg2+ | Gibco | #14040-091 | |
1x DPBS without Ca2+ and Mg2+ | Lonza | #17-512F/12 | |
100 mm cell culture dish | Corning CellBIND | #3296 | Culture vessel format for adherent hPSC-LESC differentiation |
12-well plate | Corning CellBIND | #3336 | Culture vessel format for IF samples |
24-well plate | Corning CellBIND | #3337 | Culture vessel format for IF samples |
2-mercaptoethanol | Gibco | #31350-010 | |
6-well plate, Ultra-Low attachment | Corning Costar | #3471 | Culture vessel format for induction in suspension culture |
Alexa Fluor 488 anti-mouse Ig | ThermoFisher Scientific | #A-21202 | Secondary antibody for IF |
Alexa Fluor 488 anti-rabbit Ig | ThermoFisher Scientific | #A-21206 | Secondary antibody for IF |
Alexa Fluor 568 anti-goat Ig | ThermoFisher Scientific | #A-11057 | Secondary antibody for IF |
Alexa Fluor 568 anti-mouse Ig | ThermoFisher Scientific | #A-10037 | Secondary antibody for IF |
Basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF, human) | PeproTech Inc. | #AF-100-18B | Animal-Free Recombinant Human FGF-basic (154 a.a.) |
BD Cytofix/Cytoperm Fixation/Permeabilization Solution | BD Biosciences | #554722 | Fixation and permeabilization solution for flow cytometry |
BD Perm/Wash Buffer | BD Biosciences | #554723 | Washing buffer for flow cytometry |
Blebbistatin | Sigma-Aldrich | #B0560 | |
Bone morphogenetic protein 4 (BMP-4) | PeproTech Inc. | #120-05A | |
Bovine serum albumin (BSA) | Sigma-Aldrich | #A8022-100G | |
Cytokeratin 12 antibody | Santa Cruz Biotechnology | #SC-17099 | Primary antibody for IF |
Cytokeratin 14 antibody | R&D Systems | #MAB3164 | Primary antibody for IF |
Cytokeratin 15 antibody | ThermoFisher Scientific | #MS-1068-P | Primary antibody for IF |
CnT-30 | CELLnTEC Advanced Cell Systems AG | #Cnt-30 | Culture medium for adherent hPSC-LESC differentiation |
Collagen type IV (human) | Sigma-Aldrich | #C5533 | Human placental collagen type IV |
CoolCell LX Freezing Container | Sigma-Aldrich | #BCS-405 | |
CryoPure tubes | Sarsted | #72.380 | 1.6 ml cryotube for hPSC-LESC cryopreservation |
Defined Trypsin Inhibitor | Gibco | #R-007-100 | |
Essential 8 Flex Medium Kit | Thermo Fisher Scientific | #A2858501 | |
GlutaMAX | Gibco | #35050061 | |
Laminin 521 | Biolamina | #Ln521 | Human recombinant laminin 521 |
ΔNp63α antibody | BioCare Medical | #4892 | Primary antibody for IF |
OCT3/4 antibody | R&D Systems | #AF1759 | Primary antibody for IF |
p63α antibody | Cell Signaling Technology | #ACI3066A | Primary antibody for IF |
p63-α (D2K8X) XP Rabbit mAb (PE Conjugate) | Cell Signaling Technology | #56687 | p63-α PE-conjugated antibody for flow cytometry |
PAX6 antibody | Sigma-Aldrich | #HPA030775 | Primary antibody for IF |
Penicillin/Streptomycin | Lonza | #17-602E | |
Paraformaldehyde (PFA) | Sigma-Aldrich | #158127 | Cell fixative for IF |
ProLong Gold Antifade Mountant with DAPI | Thermo Fisher Scientific | #P36931 | DAPI mountant for hard mounting for IF |
PSC Cryopreservation Kit | Thermo Fisher Scientific | #A2644601 | |
TrypLE Select Enzyme | Gibco | #12563-011 | |
KnockOut Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium | Gibco | #10829018 | |
KnockOut SR XenoFree CTS | Gibco | #10828028 | |
MEM non-essential amino acids | Gibco | #11140050 | |
SB-505124 | Sigma-Aldrich | #S4696 | |
Triton X-100 | Sigma-Aldrich | #T8787 | Permeabilization agent for IF |
VectaShield | Vector Laboratories | #H-1200 | DAPI mountant for liquid mounting for IF |
Name | Company | Catalog Number | Comments |
Equipment | |||
Cytocentrifuge, e.g. CellSpin II | Tharmac | ||
Flow cytometer, e.g. BD Accuri C6 | BD Biosciences | ||
Fluorescence microscope, e.g.Olympus IX 51 | Olympus |