Transmitochondrial cybrids are hybrid cells obtained by fusing mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)-depleted cells (rho0 cells) with cytoplasts (enucleated cells) derived from patients affected by mitochondrial disorders. They allow the determination of the nuclear or mitochondrial origin of the disease, evaluation of biochemical activity, and confirmation of the pathogenetic role of mtDNA-related variants.
Deficiency of the mitochondrial respiratory chain complexes that carry out oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) is the biochemical marker of human mitochondrial disorders. From a genetic point of view, the OXPHOS represents a unique example because it results from the complementation of two distinct genetic systems: nuclear DNA (nDNA) and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA). Therefore, OXPHOS defects can be due to mutations affecting nuclear and mitochondrial encoded genes.
The groundbreaking work by King and Attardi, published in 1989, showed that human cell lines depleted of mtDNA (named rho0) could be repopulated by exogenous mitochondria to obtain the so-called "transmitochondrial cybrids." Thanks to these cybrids containing mitochondria derived from patients with mitochondrial disorders (MDs) and nuclei from rho0 cells, it is possible to verify whether a defect is mtDNA- or nDNA-related. These cybrids are also a powerful tool to validate the pathogenicity of a mutation and study its impact at a biochemical level. This paper presents a detailed protocol describing cybrid generation, selection, and characterization.
Mitochondrial disorders (MDs) are a group of multisystem syndromes caused by an impairment in mitochondrial functions due to mutations in either nuclear (nDNA) or mitochondrial (mtDNA) DNA1. They are among the most common inherited metabolic diseases, with a prevalence of 1:5,000. mtDNA-associated diseases follow the rules of mitochondrial genetics: maternal inheritance, heteroplasmy and threshold effect, and mitotic segregation2. Human mtDNA is a double-stranded DNA circle of 16.6 kb, which contains a short control region with sequences needed for replication and transcription, 13 protein-coding genes (all subunits of the respiratory chain), 22 tRNA, and 2 rRNA genes3.
In healthy individuals, there is one single mtDNA genotype (homoplasmy), whereas more than one genotype coexists (heteroplasmy) in pathological conditions. Deleterious heteroplasmic mutations must overcome a critical threshold to disrupt OXPHOS and cause diseases that can affect any organ at any age4. The dual genetics of OXPHOS dictates inheritance: autosomal recessive or dominant and X-linked for nDNA mutations, maternal for mtDNA mutations, plus sporadic cases both for nDNA and mtDNA.
At the beginning of the mitochondrial medicine era, a landmark experiment by King and Attardi5 established the basis to understand the origin of a mutation responsible for an MD by creating hybrid cells containing nuclei from tumor cell lines in which mtDNA was entirely depleted (rho0 cells) and mitochondria from patients with MDs. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) techniques were not available at that time, and it was not easy to determine whether a mutation was present in the nuclear or mitochondrial genome. The method, described in 1989, was then used by several researchers working in the field of mitochondrial medicine6,7,8,9; a detailed protocol has been recently published10, but no video has been made yet. Why should such a protocol be relevant nowadays when NGS could precisely and rapidly identify where a mutation is located? The answer is that cybrid generation is still the state-of-the-art protocol to understand the pathogenic role of any novel mtDNA mutation, correlate the percentage of heteroplasmy with the severity of the disease, and perform a biochemical investigation in a homogeneous nuclear system in which the contribution of the autochthonous nuclear background of the patient is absent11,12,13.
This protocol describes how to obtain cytoplasts from confluent, patient-derived fibroblasts grown in 35 mm Petri dishes. Centrifugation of the dishes in the presence of cytochalasin B allows the isolation of enucleated cytoplasts, which are then fused with rho0 cells in the presence of polyethylene glycol (PEG). The resulting cybrids are then cultivated in selective medium until clones arise. The representative results section shows an example of molecular characterization of the resulting cybrids to prove that the mtDNA is identical to that of the donor patients' fibroblasts and that the nDNA is identical to the nuclear DNA of the tumoral rho0 cell line.
NOTE: The use of human fibroblasts may require ethical approval. Fibroblasts used in this study were derived from MD patients and stored in the Institutional biobank in compliance with ethical requirements. Informed consent was provided for the use of the cells. Perform all cell culture procedures under a sterile laminar flow cabinet at room temperature (RT, 22-25 °C). Use sterile-filtered solutions suitable for cell culture and sterile equipment. Grow all cell lines in a humidified incubator at 37 °C with 5% CO2. Mycoplasma tests should be conducted weekly to ensure mycoplasma-free cultures. 143BTK– rho0 cells can be generated as previously described5.
1. Culture of cells
2. Enucleation of fibroblasts
3. Fusion of the enucleated fibroblasts with rho 0 cells
4. Cybrid selection and expansion
Generating cybrids requires 3 days of laboratory work plus a selection period (~2 weeks) and additional 1-2 weeks for the growth of clones. The critical steps are the quality of cytoplasts and the selection period. The morphology of cybrids resembles that of the rho0 donor cells. Assignment of the correct mtDNA and nDNA in the cybrids is mandatory to confirm the identity of the cells. An example is given in Figure 2. In this case, we generated cybrids starting from fibroblasts derived from a patient carrying the heteroplasmic m.3243A>G, one of the most common mtDNA mutations associated with mitochondrial myopathy, encephalopathy, lactic acidosis, and stroke-like episodes (MELAS). Analysis of VNTR showed that cybrid nDNA is identical to that of the rho0 cells (Figure 2A), confirming the replacement of the patient's nDNA with the 143B genome. RFLP and/or sequencing analyses can be used to assess the presence of the mtDNA mutation and the heteroplasmy percentage (Figure 2B,C).
Figure 1: Schematic diagram of the cybrid generation protocol. Patient-derived fibroblasts are treated with cytochalasin B and centrifuged to obtain cytoplasts (enucleated cells). Cytoplasmic fusion of cytoplasts and mtDNA-depleted cells (143BTk– rho0) allows the generation of cybrids that can be isolated after selection in the appropriate medium. Picking up and amplification of single clones yields different heteroplasmy percentages, which in theory can vary from 100% wild-type to 100% mutated. Abbreviation: mtDNA = mitochondrial DNA. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Molecular characterization of cybrids. (A) Analysis of Apo-B microsatellites shows that the nDNA extracted from the generated cybrids is identical to the nuclear DNA of the rho0 cell line. (B) HaeIII restriction maps of the PCR product spanning the MELAS-associated m.3243A>G, used to quantify the amount of WT) and Mut mtDNA species. (C) Representative results of RFLP analysis showing m.3243A>G heteroplasmy levels in different cybrid clones (c1, c2, c3). Abbreviations: M = marker; bp = base pairs; WT = wild-type; Mut = mutant; RFLP = restriction fragment length polymorphism; MELAS = mitochondrial myopathy, encephalopathy, lactic acidosis, and stroke-like episodes. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Media Composition | |
Complete culture medium | Final conc. |
DMEM High Glucose (w/o L-Glutamine W/Sodium Pyruvate) | [1:1] |
FetalClone III (Bovine Serum Product) | 10% |
Sodium Pyruvate 100 mM | 1 mM |
Penicillin-Streptomycin (solution 100x) | 1% |
L-Glutamine 200 mM (100x) | 2 mM |
Supplemented culture medium | Final conc. |
DMEM High Glucose (w/o L-Glutamine W/Sodium Pyruvate) | [1:1] |
FetalClone III (Bovine Serum Product) | 10% |
Sodium Pyruvate 100 mM | 1 mM |
Penicillin-Streptomycin (solution 100x) | 1% |
L-Glutamine 200 mM (100x) | 4 mM |
Uridine | 50 µg/mL |
Enucleation medium | Final conc. |
DMEM High Glucose (w/o L-Glutamine W/Sodium Pyruvate) | [1:1] |
FetalClone III (Bovine Serum Product) | 5% |
Sodium Pyruvate 100 mM | 1 mM |
Penicillin-Streptomycin (solution 100x) | 1% |
L-Glutamine 200 mM (100x) | 2 mM |
Cytochalasin B from Drechslera dematioidea | 10 µg/mL |
Fusion medium | Final conc. |
DMEM High Glucose (w/o L-Glutamine W/Sodium Pyruvate) | [1:1] |
FetalClone III (Bovine Serum Product) | 5% |
Sodium Pyruvate 100 mM | 1 mM |
Penicillin-Streptomycin (solution 100x) | 1% |
L-Glutamine 200 mM (100x) | 2 mM |
Selection medium | Final conc. |
DMEM High Glucose (w/o L-Glutamine W/Sodium Pyruvate) | [1:1] |
Dialyzed FBS | 5% |
Sodium Pyruvate 100 mM | 1 mM |
Penicillin-Streptomycin (solution 100x) | 1% |
L-Glutamine 200 mM (100x) | 2 mM |
5-Bromo-2'-Deoxyuridine | 100 µg/mL |
Table 1: Details of media used for cybrid generation.
The mtDNA has a very high mutation rate compared to nDNA because of the lack of protective histones and its location close to the respiratory chain, which exposes the molecule to damaging oxidative effects not efficiently counteracted by the repair systems16. The first pathogenic mtDNA mutations were identified in 198817,18, and since then, a large number of mutations have been described. NGS technology is a relevant approach to screen the entire mitochondrial genome and easily identify variants14. However, assessing the pathogenic role of a never-described mtDNA mutation can be challenging and still relies on "old-fashioned" methods such as the generation of cybrid cells described in this protocol11,12,13. The cybrid generation described here recapitulates the original methods described by King and Attardi5. However, other protocols contain minor modifications mainly related to systems for cell enucleation10. In other instances, enucleation is unnecessary, for example, when the patient-derived biological material consists of platelets, which do not contain a nucleus19.
Transmitochondrial cybrids possess several important features, making them a relevant research tool even when high-throughput molecular technologies can profile DNA and RNA at the single-cell level. In pioneering works, cybrids were used to establish or confirm the genetic origin of disorders clinically and biochemically defined as mitochondrial disorders6,7,8,9,20. Indeed, the system exclusively allows the study of the contribution of the mtDNA mutation without the influence of the nuclear genes of the proband and in a homogeneous nuclear background of the rho0 cells.
In addition, a quantitative genotype-to-phenotype correlation can be performed, thanks to the isolation of different cybrid clones carrying different percentages of the mutations. The different clones were selected using Selection Medium (Table 1) supplemented with dialyzed FBS and not containing uridine and pyruvate, allowing the growth of rho0 cells fused with cytoplasts only. Thus, rho0 cells that had not fused or had fused with intact fibroblasts (bi- or polynucleated cells), as well as any residual non-enucleated intact fibroblasts, are eliminated. Indeed, rho0 cells are completely depleted of mtDNA by long-term exposure to low concentrations of ethidium bromide, a potent inhibitor of the mitochondrial gamma-polymerase21.
Lacking a functional respiratory chain, rho0 cells rely exclusively on glycolysis for their energy requirements and become pyruvate-dependent. Additionally, rho0 cells have become auxotrophic for pyrimidines (uridine is a pyrimidine precursor) because of the deficiency of the dihydroorotate dehydrogenase, an enzyme functioning within mitochondria and involved in the pyrimidine biosynthesis. While rho0 cells are derived from human osteosarcoma 143B thymidine kinase-deficient (TK–) cells, fibroblasts, cytoplasts, and polynucleated hybrids are TK+. Therefore, TK+ cells are removed due to exposure to 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine. In fact, this uridine analog is recognized by TK catalyzing the phosphorylation of deoxythymidine, which is then used in DNA biosynthesis. This process results in lethal mutations causing cell death. Another advantage of cybrids is the possibility to freeze and/or reuse them for long culture times without alterations. Moreover, like tumor cells, their high growth rate reduces the experimental study duration.
The molecular prerequisite to make this system useful and reliable is to verify the correct genetic contribution of the nuclear and mitochondrial DNA and the mtDNA amount in the repopulated cybrids. Nowadays, this can be easily performed by using NGS techniques allowing the analysis of the entire mtDNA molecule to define haplogroups and continuously verifying the presence of any other unwanted pathogenic variants in addition to the variant under investigation. In the case of heteroplasmic conditions, the isolation of clones with different mutation loads, ranging ideally from 0% to 100%, can be used to correlate the mutation percentage with the severity of the mitochondrial impairment.
Possible pitfalls hidden in these cybrid generation procedures are linked to the tumor origin of the rho0 cells used as nuclear donors. These cells are aneuploid, and it is not clear how this could eventually affect mitochondrial functions and the translation and assembly of the different respiratory chain subunits encoded by the nuclear and mitochondrial DNA, respectively. Generally, it would be advisable to generate cybrids using rho0 cells of different origins and verify that the clones obtained display comparable phenotypes. Still another limitation is that tumor cells are mainly glycolytic while mitochondrial disorders rely massively on OXPHOS. Therefore, the impact of a glycolytic nucleus (rho0 cells) on the consequences of an mtDNA mutation must be carefully established.
Despite the above limitations, the generation of cybrids has revolutionized the mitochondrial medicine field and is still used to establish the pathogenic role of novel mtDNA mutations. Moreover, cybrid technology is used to investigate the mitochondrial contribution to different diseases, ranging from common neurodegenerative disorders such as Parkinson's, Alzheimer's, and Huntington's disease22,23,24,25,26, to cancer and anticancer treatment27,28.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This study was carried out in the Center for the Study of Mitochondrial Pediatric Diseases (http://www.mitopedia.org), funded by the Mariani Foundation. VT is a member of the European Reference Network for Rare Neuromuscular Diseases (ERN EURO-NMD).
5-Bromo-2'-Deoxyuridine | Sigma-Aldrich (Merck) | B5002-500MG | |
6 well Plates | Corning | 3516 | |
96 well Plates | Corning | 3596 | |
Blood and Cell Culture DNA extraction kit | QIAGEN | 13323 | |
Centrifuge | Beckman Coulter | Avanti J-25 | 7,200 rcf, 37 °C |
Centrifuge bottles, 250 mL | Beckman Coulter | 356011 | |
Cytochalasin B from Drechslera dematioidea | Sigma-Aldrich (Merck) | C2743-200UL | |
Dialyzed FBS | Gibco | 26400-036 100mL | |
DMEM High Glucose (w/o L-Glutamine W/Sodium Pyruvate) | EuroClone | ECB7501L | |
Dulbecco's Phosphate Buffered Saline – PBS (w/o Calcium w/o Magnesium) | EuroClone | ECB4004L | |
Ethanol Absolute Anhydrous | Carlo Erba | 414601 | |
FetalClone III (Bovine Serum Product) | Cytiva – HyClone Laboratories | SH30109.03 | |
Glass pasteur pipettes | VWR | M4150NO250SP4 | |
Inverted Research Microscope For Live Cell Microscopy | Nikon | ECLIPSE TE200 | |
JA-14 Fixed-Angle Aluminum Rotor | Beckman Coulter | 339247 | |
Laboratory autoclave Vapormatic 770 | Labotech | 29960014 | |
L-Glutamine 200 mM (100x) | EuroClone | ECB 3000D | |
Minimum Essential Medium MEM | Euroclone | ECB2071L | |
MycoAlert Mycoplasma Detection Kit | Lonza | LT07-318 | |
PEG (Polyethylene glicol solution) | Sigma-Aldrich (Merck) | P7181-5X5ML | |
Penicillin-Streptomycin (solution 100x) | EuroClone | ECB3001D | |
Primo TC Dishes 100 mm | EuroClone | ET2100 | |
Primo TC Dishes 35 mm | EuroClone | ET2035 | |
Sodium Pyruvate 100 mM | EuroClone | ECM0542D | |
Stereomicroscope | Nikon | SMZ1000 | |
Trypsin 2.5% in HBSS | EuroClone | ECB3051D | |
Uridine | Sigma-Aldrich (Merck) | U3003-5G |