Here we present a protocol to quantify brain injury, locomotor deficits and neuroinflammation following bleeding in the brain in zebrafish larvae, in the context of human intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH).
Despite being the most severe subtype of stroke with high global mortality, there is no specific treatment for patients with intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH). Modelling ICH pre-clinically has proven difficult, and current rodent models poorly recapitulate the spontaneous nature of human ICH. Therefore, there is an urgent requirement for alternative pre-clinical methodologies for study of disease mechanisms in ICH and for potential drug discovery.
The use of zebrafish represents an increasingly popular approach for translational research, primarily due to a number of advantages they possess over mammalian models of disease, including prolific reproduction rates and larval transparency allowing for live imaging. Other groups have established that zebrafish larvae can exhibit spontaneous ICH following genetic or chemical disruption of cerebrovascular development. The aim of this methodology is to utilize such models to study the pathological consequences of brain hemorrhage, in the context of pre-clinical ICH research. By using live imaging and motility assays, brain damage, neuroinflammation and locomotor function following ICH can be assessed and quantified.
This study shows that key pathological consequences of brain hemorrhage in humans are conserved in zebrafish larvae highlighting the model organism as a valuable in vivo system for pre-clinical investigation of ICH. The aim of this methodology is to enable the pre-clinical stroke community to employ the zebrafish larval model as an alternative complementary model system to rodents.
Intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH) is the most severe sub-type of stroke associated with spontaneous cerebral vessel rupture and bleeding into the parenchyma leading to brain damage, physical disability and often death1. Despite the high mortality and morbidity rate associated with ICH2, understanding of the underpinning etiology and post-hemorrhage pathology is still lacking. As such, there are no specific treatments to prevent ICH or improve patient outcomes. Most of our understanding of disease biology has come from pre-clinical rodent models of ICH3, however studies to-date in these models have failed to translate any successful therapeutic to the clinic4,5. This failure may be due in part, to some limitations of these preclinical models, including the inability to easily recapitulate the spontaneous nature of human disease and the requirement for invasive surgery to generate the models in mammals6. Additionally, rodents pose practical problems with regards to observing the rapid onset of cellular responses to ICH in intact tissue. Given the lack of translation from rodent models, developing alternative models of spontaneous ICH is imperative if we are to overcome these practical problems and help identify novel drug targets.
The molecular mechanisms of vascular development are well conserved amongst vertebrates including zebrafish (Danio rerio)7. As such, the adoption of this model organism is becoming an ever more useful mechanistic strategy for studying cerebrovascular disease8. A number of zebrafish models have been generated which recapitulate phenotypes associated with stroke-related conditions9,10,11,12. The use of zebrafish larvae to investigate disease pathogenesis offers both practical and scientific advantages over mammalian models8. This includes high reproduction rates, rapid development and larval transparency that allows for intravital imaging without the invasive constraints associated with rodents. Coupling these advantages with the wide range of transgenic reporter lines available within the zebrafish research community amounts to a powerful in vivo approach for studying disease biology, not yet utilized for studying the pathological consequences of ICH.
The injury response to blood in the brain is biphasic13; the primary insult causes neuronal death and cell necrosis, which then initiates a secondary wave of damage that is induced by innate immune activation. The second phase of brain injury, in particular the neuroinflammatory component, is considered a realistic target for future drug treatment13. Spontaneous and cerebral-specific hemorrhages have been described in zebrafish larvae previously14,15,16,17,18,19. Two such models are the use of atorvastatin (ATV) at 24 h post-fertilization (hpf) to inhibit the HMGCR pathway and cholesterol biosynthesis14, and a bubblehead (bbh) mutant which express a hypomorphic mutation in the arhgef7 gene, βpix, and subsequently inhibits actin remodeling for tight endovascular junctions18. These models exhibit spontaneous cerebral-specific blood vessel rupture at the onset of circulation (~33 hpf). Recently, we have characterized these models further to reveal that key aspects of the brain injury response is conserved between humans and zebrafish larvae20. This study demonstrates the methodology required to obtain and visualize spontaneous brain hemorrhages in zebrafish larvae and how to quantify brain injury, and locomotor and neuroinflammatory phenotypes that relate to the human condition. These data and techniques support the use of this model species as a valuable complementary system for pre-clinical ICH research.
Zebrafish were raised and maintained at The University of Manchester Biological Services Unit under standard conditions as previously described21. Adult zebrafish husbandry was approved by the University of Manchester Animal Welfare and Ethical Review Board. All experiments were performed in accordance with U.K. Home Office regulations (PPL:P132EB6D7).
NOTE: Transgenic lines used in this study include macrophage-specific lineage mpeg1:mCherry (constructed in-house as previously described22), neutrophil-specific mpo:GFP23,erythroid-specific gata1:dsRed24 and ubiq:secAnnexinV-mVenus, a reporter for cell death (re-derived in house25)on wild-type, nacre (mitfaw2/w2) and mutant (bbhm292) backgrounds. Figure 1 shows the experimental timeline.
Figure 1: Graphic of experimental timeline to characterize brain injury, locomotor and neuroinflammatory outcomes. ICH, intracerebral hemorrhage; bbh, bubblehead. Figure has been reproduced from Crilly et al.20 with permission under a Creative Commons license. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
1. Day 0: Egg production and collection
2. Day 1: Atorvastatin treatment at 24 hpf
3. Day 2: Separating ICH- and ICH+ populations at 50 hpf
Figure 2: ICH+ brain hemorrhage phenotypes. Examples of larval ICH phenotypes maintained on a transgenic gata1:DsRed reporter nacre background observed with a brightfield stereomicroscope (top panels) and fluorescence (bottom panel) at ~48 h post-fertilization. No hemorrhages were observed in ICH-larvae (left panels). A distinct accumulation of red blood cells in the forebrain and hindbrain (arrows) were observed in ICH+ larvae (right panels). Scale bars represent 250 µm. Figure has been reproduced from Crilly et al.20 with permission under a Creative Commons license. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
4. Day 3: Cell death and leukocyte analysis at 72 hpf
5. Day 3: Selecting larvae for motility assay at 72 hpf
6. Day 3-5: Assaying locomotion at 72, 96 and 120 hpf
Assessment of brain cell death using transgenic ubiq:secAnnexinV-mVenus results in clear definitive clusters of dying cells in ICH+ larvae in both ATV and bbh models that are absent in all ICH- larvae (Figure 3). Clusters recede before 96 hpf. Through image analysis, bleeding is associated with a significant two-fold increase in total intensity of fluorescence signal in the brain, indicating marked cell death.
A neuroinflammatory response is identified in ICH+ larvae by significantly increased numbers of mpeg1 positive macrophage cells in the brain. The number of total mpo positive neutrophil cells also increased however this did not reach statistical significance (Figure 4). The morphology of the mpeg1 positive macrophages can also be seen to change in ICH+ larvae as the cells adopt an active, rounded, amoeboid shape. These activated rounded cells can also be monitored over time to show an increased phagocytic response of the ubiq:secAnnexinV-mVenus expressing dying cells in ICH+ larvae (Figure 5). mpeg1 positive macrophages exhibiting ramified processes were categorized as inactive.
Brain hemorrhage is associated with a significant decrease in motility at 72 and 96 hpf in comparison to ICH- sibling controls in both bbh and ATV models (Figure 6). Motility at 120 hpf recovers to near baseline levels. There are often differences in baseline motility between egg clutches and strains and so comparison should be made to ICH- controls every time.
Figure 3: Intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH) in zebrafish larvae results in a quantifiable brain injury. (A) Representative images of the brain injury phenotype in ICH+ larvae (right panels), in comparison to ICH- siblings (left panels), at 72 hpf. Brightfield images (bottom panels, scale bar = 250 µm) demonstrate the presence of brain bleeds (arrows) in ICH+ larvae. Fluorescent microscopy was performed to visualize cell death in the ubiq:secAnnexinV-mVenus reporter line (top panels, scale bar = 100 µm). Clusters of dying cells were observed in peri-hematomal regions. Images were cropped to brain-only regions and analyzed for total green fluorescence intensity in round particles larger than 30 pixels in diameter (white line) using the macro in Supplementary File 1. (B) Quantification of fluorescence signal in the brains of untreated, ICH- and ICH+ larvae obtained through the ATV model (n = 12 per group; 3 independent replicates) at 72 hpf. Significant differences were observed when comparing ICH+ with untreated (**p = 0.004) and with ICH- (*p = 0.03) siblings. (C) Quantification of fluorescence signal as a read out for annexinV binding in the brains of ICH- and ICH+ larvae obtained through the bubblehead (bbh) model (n = 12 per group; 2 independent replicates) at 72 hpf. Graphs show SD from the mean. A significant difference in mVenus fluorescence was observed between ICH+ and ICH- age-matched siblings (**p = 0.002). Figure has been reproduced from Crilly et al.20 with permission under a Creative Commons license. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH) initiates an innate cellular immune response in the zebrafish larval brain. Numbers of leukocytes quantified within the brain regions previously described for mpo:GFP;mpeg1:dsRed double transgenic larvae (n = 8 per group; 2 independent replicates) at 72 hpf reveals a significant increase in macrophages (*p = 0.01), but not neutrophils (p = 0.5), in response to ICH. Figure has been reproduced from Crilly et al.20 with permission under a Creative Commons license. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: Activated macrophage cells show a phagocytic response to the brain lesion. (A) Representative time-lapse stills20 showing a ramified patrolling macrophage migrating towards an annexinV positive cell (i – vi). Stills are obtained from a series of images taken of the whole brain using a 20x objective. Scale bar represents 50 µm. The macrophage acquired an amoeboid morphology (v) before phagocytosing the annexinV-positive cell (vi, vii). After phagocytosis the macrophage resumes a ramified morphology and migrates away and the annexinV-positive cell can no longer be seen (viii). Ramified macrophage (#), annexinV positive cell (arrow), amoeboid macrophage (*) are indicated. (B) Representative images of mpeg1-positive cells in the ICH- and ICH+ larval brain exhibiting amoeboid and ramified morphologies. Scale bars represent 50 µm. (C) An increased proportion of amoeboid (phagocytic) and decreased proportion of ramified (inactive) macrophages was observed in ICH+ brains in comparison to ICH- siblings. Figure has been reproduced from Crilly et al.20 with permission under a Creative Commons license. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6: ICH-induced brain injury results in a quantifiable locomotor deficit in zebrafish larvae. (A) Representative examples of the swimming tracks in ICH- and ICH+ bbh larvae at 72, 96 and 120 hpf. (B) ICH+ larvae exhibited a significant decrease in the cumulative time spent mobile during the 10 min recording period at both 72 and 96 hpf. Significance was lost at the 120 hpf time point potentially alluding to recovery from brain injury (n = 24 larvae per group; 3 independent replicates; ****p = 0.00006; **p = 0.003; ns: p = 0.08). (C) Quantification of cumulative time spent moving in untreated and ATV-treated ICH- and ICH+ larvae at 120 hpf. ICH+ larvae exhibited a significant decrease in the cumulative time spent mobile during the 10 min recording period. Three technical replicates (n = 24 larvae per group) were used to calculate SD from the mean (***p = 0.00004, **p = 0.0003). Figure has been reproduced from Crilly et al.20 with permission under a Creative Commons license. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Supplementary File 1. Please click here to download this file.
This study shows that ICH in zebrafish larvae induces a brain injury response that recapitulates key aspects of the human condition that can be systematically assayed and quantified. Zebrafish offer a consistent and reproducible model of spontaneous ICH which will assist with future drug intervention studies focused on targeting blood-induced brain injury, rather than preventing vessel rupture17,28. Indeed, given the rapid nature of disease onset akin to the clinical situation, such an approach offers exciting prospects for successful translation in the future.
Some limitations are associated with the use of zebrafish larvae, such as the use of a developing system and taxonomic rank, however the practical and scientific advantages of this model must be considered to offer new insights into ICH. No surgery is required to initiate a haemorrhage or to monitor cellular processes over extended periods of time after injury. High fecundity of zebrafish pairings generate easily accessible and large sample sizes, and due to the fast development of the larvae the experimental timeline is significantly reduced compared to rodent studies29,30.
Currently these models are fit to use for elucidating the immediate pathological and immunological response to spontaneous ICH in the brain of live intact animals. Potentially, this model can be adapted for medium-high throughput drug screens for ICH therapies, whether preventative or recovery promoting. As such, the post-ICH pathologies presented in this study represent an alternative, complementary platform for pre-clinical ICH research.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
We would like to thank Dr David Spiller and the University of Manchester Systems Microscopy Core Facility for use of the equipment, Prof. Richard Baines for the use of DanioVision and Dr. Jack Rivers-Auty for statistical consultation. The bbh line was kindly shared by Nicole Munsie from Dr. Sarah Child's lab at the University of Calgary. We also thank Prof. Stephen Renshaw, Dr. Adam Hurlstone, Dr. Andrew Badrock and Dr. Helen Young for fish lines and equipment.
This study was supported by the NC3Rs (NC/N002598/1), Stroke Association (TSA LECT 2017/02), ERA-NET NEURON (MR/M501803/1) and The British Heart Foundation (FS/15/67/32038). We are also particularly thankful to The Natalie Kate Moss Trust and the University of Manchester Faculty of Biology, Medicine and Health for their continued financial support.
24 well plates | Sigma-Aldrich | CLS3527 | |
28 °C incubator | LMS | 210 | |
Atorvastatin | Sigma-Aldrich | PZ0001-5mg | |
Breeding boxes | Thoren Aquatics systems | 10011 | |
Daniovision observation chamber | Noldus | n/a | |
E3 medium 1x | 4% Instant Ocean, 500 µL methylene blue in 1 L dH2O | ||
EthoVision XT software | Noldus | version 11 | |
Heat block | Grant-Bio | PHMT-PSC18 | |
Instant ocean | Instant Ocean | SS15-10 | |
Lightsheet microscope | Zeiss | Z.1 | |
Lightsheet microscope mounting capillary | Zeiss | 402100-9320-000 | |
Low melt agarose | Promega | V2111 | |
Methylene Blue | Sigma-Aldrich | 319112-100ML | |
Microscope | Leica | MZ95 | dissection microscope |
Microscope | Leica | M165FC | fluorescent microscope |
MS222 | 4g tricaine powder, 500 mL of dH2O, 10 mL of 1 M Tris (pH 9). Adjust pH to ~7 | ||
P1000 pipette | Gilson | F144059M | |
P1000 pipette tips | Starlab | S1122-1830 | |
Pasteur pipettes | Starlab | E1414-0300 | |
Petri dishes | Corning | 101VR20 | |
Pipetboy | Integra Biosciences | PIPETBOY | |
Stripette 25ml | Corning | CLS3527 | |
Tricaine powder | Sigma-Aldrich | A5040-25G | |
Tris Base | Fisher BioReagents | BP152-1 | |
Ultra fine dissection forceps | Agar scientific | AGT502 | |
Zen software | Zeiss | version 2.3 |