Surgery is the gold standard for accessible arteriovenious malformations (AVMs), and pre-operative embolization can simplify this procedure. We describe our approach for staged endovascular embolization and open resection of AVMs, and provide a representative clinical example highlighting the advantages of a comprehensively trained neurovascular surgeon leading a multi-disciplinary clinical team.
Arteriovenious malformations (AVMs) are associated with significant morbidity and mortality, and have a rupture risk of ~3% per year. Treatment of AVMs must be tailored specifically to the lesion, with surgical resection being the gold standard for small, accessible lesions. Pre-operative embolization of AVMs can reduce nidal blood flow and remove high-risk AVM features such as intranidal or venous aneurysms, thereby simplifying a challenging neurosurgical procedure. Herein, we describe our approach for the staged endovascular embolization and open resection of AVMs, and highlight the advantages of having a comprehensively trained neurovascular surgeon leading a multi-disciplinary clinical team. This includes planning the craniotomy and resection to immediately follow the final embolization stage, thereby using a single session of anesthesia for aggressive embolization, and rapid resection. Finally, we provide a representative case of a 22-year-old female with an unruptured right frontal AVM diagnosed during a seizure workup, who was successfully treated via staged embolizations followed by open surgical resection.
Cerebral arteriovenous malformations (AVMs), abnormal connections between arteries and veins without intervening normal capillary beds, present unique neurosurgical challenges. Classified based on size, presence of deep draining veins, and involvement of eloquent cortex,1 the risk of hemorrhage for previously unruptured AVMs ranges from 0.9 to 8% per year,2 with an annual average rupture risk of ~3%.3 Hemorrhages from AVMs are associated with a nearly 10% mortality rate and significant morbidity, with up to 34% of patients having moderate to severe disabilities.4 Previously ruptured AVMs have increased annual hemorrhage rates,2 but a relatively low immediate risk of re-rupture. Unless mass effect from a hematoma demands acute intervention, treatment is often performed on an elective basis after weighing the expected natural history of a lesion versus its treatment-associated risks.5,6
Surgical resection is the treatment of choice for small accessible AVMs as it immediately and definitively eliminates future hemorrhage risk. However, the high flow rate of AVMs, as well as the increased risk of AVM-associated aneurysms,4,7 makes surgical resection amongst the most challenging of all neurosurgical cases. Pre-operative embolization of AVMs to reduce blood flow and remove high-risk AVM features can significantly reduce the technical challenges of resection.
Comprehensively trained vascular neurosurgeons are uniquely positioned to definitively treat AVMs by performing both the pre-operative angiogram and endovascular embolization, as well as the open surgical resection. Herein, we describe the protocol for management of surgically accessible cerebral AVMs (as defined by established grading scales1,8 as well as surgeon and multidisciplinary conference evaluations) at our institution.
All procedures described below are performed as standard of care for patients with cerebral AVMs, after obtaining informed consent as per institutional guidelines.
1. Initial patient evaluation and imaging
NOTE: Patients with unruptured AVMs often present after the malformation is discovered on imaging for headache or seizure workup. Patients with ruptured AVMs often present with acute onset of headache, nausea, vomiting, weakness, numbness, and/or vision changes.
2. Six-vessel angiography
3. AVM embolization
NOTE: If the AVM is amenable to endovascular and subsequent surgical treatment (as defined by established grading scales1,8 as well as surgeon and multidisciplinary conference evaluations), the initial embolization may be performed in a delayed fashion or in the same session as the diagnostic angiography. Embolizations are often staged to decrease rupture and stroke risk from rapidly altered flow dynamics.
4. AVM resection
5. Long term follow up
A 22-year-old previously healthy female presented with new onset seizures. Non-contrast head CT was negative for acute hemorrhage, but revealed an incompletely characterized right frontal lesion. MRI demonstrated an approximately 2.9 x 2.4 cm Spetzler-Martin Grade 3 AVM within the right superior frontal gyrus (Figure 1), with large draining cortical veins going to the superior sagittal sinus, and an arterial supply via large branches off the right middle cerebral artery. The patient underwent multiple staged endovascular embolizations, culminating in an embolization of a right anterior cerebral artery pedicle (Figure 2). At the completion of these staged embolizations there was residual supply to the nidus via distal right middle and anterior cerebral artery branches (Figure 3), and indirect supply from the left external carotid artery via distal superior temporal artery branches that anastomosed to the middle meningeal artery via transosseous collaterals.
The patient then underwent a frontotemporal craniotomy by the same comprehensively trained neurovascular surgeon, wherein the medial draining veins were identified early and protected. All arterial feeders were identified, bipolared, and cut to achieve sequential devascularization prior to removal of the AVM nidus. Intra-operative and post-operative catheter angiogram (Figure 4) confirmed complete resection. One month post-operatively the patient was stable neurologically and being weaned from anti-seizure medications, with plans for delayed cerebrovascular imaging at one year.
Figure 1: Initial imaging of a Spetzler-Martin Grade 3 unruptured right frontal AVM.
a) Serial axial (i-iii) and b) coronal post-contrast T1-weighted MRI images demonstrating the AVM nidus and medial draining veins. c) Redemonstration of nidus and draining veins on axial T2 Flair MRI imaging. d) Serial AP (i-ii) and lateral (iii-iv) right internal carotid catheter angiogram runs re-demonstrating the AVM nidus and draining veins. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Catheter angiogram images from final AVM embolization.
a) Serial oblique views (i-ii) of microcatheter exploration of the distal right anterior cerebral artery (ACA) during establishment of embolization position in the right ACA pedicle exclusively supplying the AVM. (b) Oblique unsubtracted image demonstrating the Onyx cast within the AVM at the conclusion of the final embolization. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Catheter angiogram post final staged embolization demonstrating residual AVM nidal filling.
a) Serial oblique views of a right internal carotid injection (i-vi) following Onyx embolization of a right anterior cerebral artery pedicle via the left internal carotid and anterior communicating artery. b) Serial AP views of a left internal carotid injection following the above embolization (i-ii). Residual supply to the nidus is seen from distal right middle cerebral artery branches, and distal right anterior cerebral artery branches filling from both the left and right internal carotids. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Post-operative catheter angiogram demonstrating complete AVM resection.
Serial oblique views of a right internal carotid injection (i-v) on post-operative day 1 demonstrating complete AVM resection. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Here we demonstrate a comprehensive approach to cerebral AVMs via combined endovascular and open surgical management. Catheter angiography is the gold standard for imaging AVMs, and is critical to surgical evaluation and planning. Pre-operative embolizations can simplify surgical resection, but requires communication between the surgical and interventional teams to develop an optimal strategic approach. For example, the AVM arterial feeders most easily embolized may also be the most surgically accessible. If, however, they are embolized prior to development of a comprehensive treatment plan, leaving only deeper more difficult to access arterial feeders, surgery becomes more difficult without further embolization and exposes the patient to potentially avoidable procedures.
The main advantage of comprehensively trained neurovascular surgeons is that the same individual is performing all of the above procedures. No two AVMs are exactly alike, and this heterogeneity demands a flexible, individualized treatment approach based on lesion morphology, patient characteristics, and clinical presentation. The above protocol ensures not only that the optimal pre-operative embolization strategy is pursued, but also gives the surgeon an intricate understanding of the lesion before resection is attempted. Additionally, as the risk of venous outflow obstruction and rupture increases with progressive AVM embolizations, this combined approach allows for a planned craniotomy and resection to immediately follow a final aggressive embolization, all during a single anesthesia session.
Critical steps for complication avoidance within this protocol include: i) appropriate patient selection based on a given AVMs expected natural history versus treatment risks,5,6 ii) selective AVM embolization without compromise of the arterial supply of normal brain (to prevent iatrogenic strokes) or sacrifice of draining veins (to minimize treatment-associated hemorrhage risk), and iii) step-wise surgical resection to avoid massive hemorrhage or damage to surrounding parenchyma. Because the ultimate goal of this combined approach is a safe surgical resection, it is well suited for smaller, more superficial AVMs not involving eloquent cortex. For surgically inaccessible lesions, radiosurgery is often the treatment of choice as opposed to the embolization/surgical resection protocol described herein.
As evidenced by this multi-step protocol, the treatment of AVMs is complex, and requires cooperation across multiple teams. In addition to the neurovascular surgery team, critical contributions include neuroanesthesia to control intracranial pressure and ensure hemodynamic stability in case of AVM rupture, neuromonitoring to identify in real time neurologic changes and allow appropriate modification of the surgical or endovascular plan, and neurocritical care to help manage the intensive care unit (ICU) needs of these challenging patients. As such, management of AVMs is best undertaken at high-volume centers where this multi-disciplinary infrastructure is in place.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
The authors thank all the clinical teams contributing daily to the care of AVM patients at UCSD.
ChloraPrep Sterilization Solution | BD, Franklin Lakes, NJ | 260815 | For skin sterilization |
Lidocaine Hcl 1% | ACE Surgical Supply, Inc, Brockton, MA | 001-1421 | For local anesthetic |
Micropuncture Groin Access Kit | Cook Medical, Bloomington, IN | G56202 | Used for femoral artery access |
0.035 Guidewire | Terumo Medical, Somerset, NJ | GR3506 | Used in conjunction with diagnostic catheters for cerebral angiography |
Cerebral Angiography Diagnostic Catheters | Terumo Medical, Somerset, NJ | CG416 | Used in conjunction with guidewire for cerebral angiography |
Omnipaque Contrast Agent | GE Healthcare, Chicago, IL | Q9965 | Contrast agent for cerebral vessel imaging |
Microcatheter and Microwire | Covidian, Plymouth, MN | 105-5091-150, 103-0608 | Used for distal arterial catheterization |
Onyx Liquid Embolic | Covidian, Plymouth, MN | 105-7100-060 | Used for AVM embolization |
Angio-Seal Vascular Closure Device | St. Jude Medical, St Paul, MN | 610130 | Used for femoral artery closure following angiography/intra-arterial embolization |
Midas Rex High Power Drill System | Medtronic, Minneapolis, MN | PM700 | Used for craniotomy |
Matchstick Drill Bit | Medtronic, Minneapolis, MN | 10MH30-MN | Used to create burr hole for craniotomy |
Tapered Drill Bit | Medtronic, Minneapolis, MN | F1/8TA15 | Used to complete craniotomy |
#11 and 15 Blade Surgical Scalpels | BD Bard-Parker, Franklin Lakes, NJ | 372615 | Used for groin incision for angiography and dural opening for external ventricular drain placement or AVM resection |
Metzenbaum Dissecting Scissors | Stoelting Co, Wood Dale, IL | 52134-01P | Used for dural opening |
Bone Elevator | Stoelting Co, Wood Dale, IL | 52169 | Used for separating dura from the inner skull |
Gerald Forceps | Stoelting Co, Wood Dale, IL | 52106-52 | Used for dural opening and manipulation |
Microsurgical Instruments | Accurate Surgical & Scientific Instruments Corporation, Westbury, NY | ASSI.BML1 | Used for AVM microsurgical resection |
Bipolar Forceps | Accurate Surgical & Scientific Instruments Corporation, Westbury, NY | ASSI.BPNS20423FP | Used for AVM microsurgical resection |
Electrosurgery Generator | Bovie Medical Products, Clearwater, FL | IDS-200 | Used for electrosurgical cutting/coagulation |
Small Aneurysm Clips | Codman Neuro, Raynham, MA | 20-1801 | Used for occlusion of arterial AVM feeders not amenable to coagulation |
Brain Retractors | Medicon, Tuttlingen, Germany | 22.00.06 | For brain retraction for deep AVM dissection/resection |
Variable Action Suction tip | Millennium Surgical, Narberth, PA | 6-8607 | For suction with AVM dissection/resection |
Fibrillar Absorbable Hemostatic Agent | Ethicon, Somerville, NJ | 63713-0019-61 | For hemostatis within surgical cavity |
4-0 Suture | Ethicon, Somerville, NJ | C554D | For dural closure |
2-0 Absorbable Suture | Ethicon, Somerville, NJ | J286G | For deep tissue closure |
3-0 Nylon Suture | Ethicon, Somerville, NJ | ET-663G | For skin closure |
Surgical Staples | Medline, Mundelein, IL | STAPLER35RB | For skin closure |
Bone Plating System | Biomet, Warsaw, IN | 15-7378-12 | For bone flap securement |
Operating Microscope | Leica Microsystems, Buffalo Grove, IL | M720 OH5 | Used for AVM microsurgical resection |
BrainLab Neuronavigation Imaging System | Brainlab, Inc, Chicago, IL | Brainlab Curve | Used for AVM microsurgical resection |
Lumbar External Drainage System | Codman Neuro, Raynham, MA | K964923 | Used for placement of lumbar drain for CSF drainage |
External Ventricular Drainage Catheter | Medtronic, Minneapolis, MN | Used for placement of ventricular catheter for CSF drainage | |
Disposable Raney Scalp Clips | A&E Medical Corporation, Farmingdale, NJ | 070-001 | Used for scalp hemostasis |