DNA curtain, a high-throughput single-molecule imaging technique, provides a platform for real-time visualization of diverse protein-DNA interactions. The present protocol utilizes the DNA curtain technique to investigate the biological role and molecular mechanism of Abo1, a Schizosaccharomyces pombe bromodomain-containing AAA+ ATPase.
Chromatin is a higher-order structure that packages eukaryotic DNA. Chromatin undergoes dynamic alterations according to the cell cycle phase and in response to environmental stimuli. These changes are essential for genomic integrity, epigenetic regulation, and DNA metabolic reactions such as replication, transcription, and repair. Chromatin assembly is crucial for chromatin dynamics and is catalyzed by histone chaperones. Despite extensive studies, the mechanisms by which histone chaperones enable chromatin assembly remains elusive. Moreover, the global features of nucleosomes organized by histone chaperones are poorly understood. To address these problems, this work describes a unique single-molecule imaging technique named DNA curtain, which facilitates the investigation of the molecular details of nucleosome assembly by histone chaperones. DNA curtain is a hybrid technique that combines lipid fluidity, microfluidics, and total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy (TIRFM) to provide a universal platform for real-time imaging of diverse protein-DNA interactions.Using DNA curtain, the histone chaperone function of Abo1, the Schizosaccharomyces pombe bromodomain-containing AAA+ ATPase, is investigated, and the molecular mechanism underlying histone assembly of Abo1 is revealed. DNA curtain provides a unique approach for studying chromatin dynamics.
Eukaryotic DNA is packaged into a higher-order structure known as chromatin1,2. Nucleosome is the fundamental unit of chromatin, which consists of approximately 147 bp DNA wrapped around the octameric core histones3,4. Chromatin plays a critical role in eukaryotic cells; for example, the compact structure protects DNA from endogenous factors and exogenous threats5. Chromatin structure changes dynamically according to the cell cycle phase and environmental stimuli, and these changes control protein access during DNA transactions such as replication, transcription, and repair6. Chromatin dynamics are also important for genomic stability and epigenetic information.
Chromatin is dynamically regulated by various factors, including histone tail modifications and chromatin organizers such as chromatin remodelers, polycomb group proteins, and histone chaperones7. Histone chaperones coordinate the assembly and disassembly of nucleosomes via deposition or detachment of core histones8,9. Defects in histone chaperones induce genome instability and cause developmental disorders and cancer9,10. Various histone chaperones do not need chemical energy consumption like ATP hydrolysis to assemble or disassemble nucleosomes9,11,12,13. Recently, researchers reported that bromodomain-containing AAA+ (ATPase associated with diverse cellular activities) ATPases play a role in chromatin dynamics as histone chaperones14,15,16,17. Human ATAD2 (ATPase family AAA domain-containing protein 2) promotes chromatin accessibility to enhance gene expression18. As a transcriptional co-regulator, ATAD2 regulates the chromatin of oncogenic transcriptional factors14, and the overexpression of ATAD2 is related to poor prognosis in many types of cancer19. Yta7, the Saccharomyces cerevisiae (S. cerevisiae) homolog of ATAD2, decreases nucleosome density in chromatin15. In contrast, Abo1, the Schizosaccharomyces pombe (S. pombe) homolog of ATAD2, increases nucleosome density16. Using a unique single-molecule imaging technique, DNA curtain, whether Abo1 contributes to nucleosome assembly or disassembly is addressed17,20.
Traditionally, the biochemical properties of biomolecules have been examined by bulk experiments such as the electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA) or co-immunoprecipitation (co-IP), in which a large number of molecules are probed, and their average properties are characterized21,22. In bulk experiments, molecular sub-states are veiled by the ensemble-average effect, and probing biomolecular interactions is restricted. In contrast, single-molecule techniques circumvent the limitations of bulk experiments and enable the detailed characterization of biomolecular interactions. In particular, single-molecule imaging techniques have been widely used to study DNA-protein and protein-protein interactions23. One such technique is DNA curtain, a unique single-molecule imaging technique based on microfluidics and total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy (TIRFM)24,25. In a DNA curtain, hundreds of individual DNA molecules are anchored to the lipid bilayer, which permits the two-dimensional motion of DNA molecules due to lipid fluidity. When hydrodynamic flow is applied, DNA molecules move along the flow on the bilayer and get stuck at a diffusion barrier, where they are aligned and stretched. While DNA is stained with intercalating agents, fluorescently labeled proteins are injected, and TIRFM is used to visualize protein-DNA interactions in real-time at a single-molecule level23. The DNA curtain platform facilitates the observation of protein movements such as diffusion, translocation, and collision26,27,28. Moreover, DNA curtain can be used for protein mapping on DNA with defined positions, orientations, and topologies or applied to the study of phase separation of protein and nucleic acids29,30,31.
In this work, the DNA curtain technique is used to provide evidence for the function of chaperones through direct visualization of specific proteins. Moreover, because DNA curtain is a high-throughput platform, it facilitates an extent of data collection sufficient for statistical reliability. Here, it is described how to conduct the DNA curtain assay in detail to investigate the molecular role of S. pombe bromodomain-containing AAA+ ATPase Abo1.
1. Preparation of the flow cell
2. Connecting flow cell to the microfluidic system and loading it onto the microscope
3. Histone assembly by Abo1 using DNA curtain
4. Data analysis
This work describes the procedure for flow cell preparation for the DNA curtain assay (Figure 1A). The DNA curtain assay facilitated the study of histone H3-H4 dimer assembly on DNA by Abo1. First, DNA curtain formation was checked by staining DNA molecules with YOYO-1, an intercalating dye. Green lines were shown in parallel arrays, indicating that YOYO-1 intercalated into DNA molecules, which were well-aligned and stretched at a diffusion barrier under hydrodynamic flow (Figure 2A). To exclude the possibility of YOYO-1 hindering the interaction of DNA and histone proteins, YOYO-1 was removed from DNA with a high salt buffer before adding histone proteins. When Cy5-H3-H4 dimers were injected into the DNA curtain in the absence of Abo1, Cy5-H3-H4 did not bind to DNA, indicating a lack of spontaneous binding of H3-H4 dimers to DNA (Figure 2B). When Cy5-H3-H4 was injected with Abo1, red fluorescent puncta were seen on DNA molecules, suggesting that Abo1 loads H3-H4 dimers onto DNA (Figure 2C). The buffer flow was transiently switched off to ensure that Cy5-H3-H4 dimers did not bind to the slide surface while binding to DNA. When the flow was turned off, fluorescently labeled proteins bound to DNA disappeared because DNA molecules recoiled out of the evanescent field. In contrast, proteins adsorbed to the surface remained the same. The fluorescent signals disappeared in the absence of flow and reappeared when the flow was resumed, suggesting that H3-H4 dimers bind to DNA (Figure 2C). The binding of H3-H4 dimers to DNA was also confirmed by the kymograph, in which the fluorescence signals disappeared whenever the flow was turned off (Figure 2D). Because Abo1 is an AAA+ ATPase, the effect of ATP hydrolysis on histone loading activity of Abo1 was examined16. Few fluorescent puncta appeared in the DNA curtain either in the absence of nucleotide (Apo) or in the presence of ADP (Figure 2E), indicating that H3-H4 dimers rarely bind to DNA either in the Apo state or in the presence of ADP. Figure 2F displays quantitative analyses of Figure 2B,C, and Figure 2E, showing that the number of H3-H4 dimers bound to DNA increases in the presence of ATP. The results suggest that ATP hydrolysis is essential for H3-H4 loading onto DNA by Abo1 (Figure 2E,F).
Next, it was tested whether Abo1 preferentially loads histones to the Widom 601 sequence, which has a ten-times higher binding affinity to histones than random sequences in vitro, even though nucleosomes have no specificity for the Widom 601 sequence in vivo36,37,38,39,40. The DNA curtain was formed with lambda DNA that contains Widom 601 repeats at one end or internally (Figure 3A,B). The binding landscape of H3-H4 dimers on each DNA construct was obtained (Figure 3C,D). The binding location of Cy5-H3-H4 was estimated from the center position of 2D Gaussian fitting for each fluorescent punctum17,41. If the H3-H4 loading activity of Abo1 depends on the DNA sequence, then the binding distribution would be skewed toward the Widom 601 sequence. Figure 3C,D displays the binding distribution histograms of H3-H4 dimers by Abo1 on lambda DNA containing Widom 601 repeats at the end (ten repeats) and internally (five repeats), respectively. There was no preferential binding to the multiple Widom 601 repeats, and the binding distribution was random, suggesting that Abo1 does not have any preference for the Widom 601 sequence but instead loads H3-H4 onto DNA in a sequence-independent manner (Figure 3C,D).
Figure 1: Preparation of flow cell. (A) Schematics of flow cell assembly and DNA curtain system. The microfluidic chamber can be formed between a fused-silica slide and a glass coverslip stuck together with double-sided tape. Under the hydrodynamic flow in the chamber, a large amount of lambda DNA molecules are aligned at a diffusion barrier (a nano-trench here) because of the fluidity of the lipid bilayer and stretched like a curtain. In the enlarged view of the diffusion barrier, the nano-trench has saw-tooth patterns with 1.5 µm pitch, 350 nm width, and 1.4 µm depth. (B) Photograph of the microfluidic system consisting of a syringe pump, a shut-off valve, and a 6-way sample injection valve with a sample loop. (C) Pictures of slide holder components (left), the assembly of holders and flow cell (middle), and the fully assembled flow cell mounted on a custom-made TIRF microscope (right). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Visualization of histone loading by Abo1 using single-molecule DNA curtain. (A) Image of DNA curtain, where DNA molecules stained with YOYO-1 (green) are well-aligned at a diffusion barrier. (B) Images of Cy5-H3-H4 (red) without Abo1. (C) Images of Cy5-H3-H4 (red) loaded by Abo1 in the presence (top) and absence (bottom) of buffer flow. (D) Kymograph extracted from a single DNA molecule from (C). When the flow is transiently turned off, the Cy5 fluorescence signals disappear, indicating that Cy5-H3-H4 binds to DNA but not to the slide surface. (E) Image of Cy5-H3-H4 loaded by Abo1 without nucleotide (Apo) (top). Image of Cy5-H3-H4 loaded by Abo1 in the presence of ADP (bottom). (F) Quantification of Cy5-H3-H4 loaded by Abo1 according to nucleotides. Error bars depicts the standard deviation in triplicate. Each experiment involved the analysis of 100-200 molecules. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Sequence-independent loading of H3-H4 by Abo1. (A) One end of the lambda DNA is anchored to biotinylated lipid via streptavidin, and the other end contains ten repeats of the Widom 601 sequence (top). The other lambda DNA contains five repeats of the Widom 601 sequence inside lambda DNA (bottom). (B) Schematic of DNA curtain assay with lambda DNA containing Widom 601 repeats. (C,D) Binding distribution histograms of Cy5-H3-H4 on lambda DNA containing Widom 601 repeats at the end (C) and internally (D). There is no sequence specificity for DNA when H3-H4 is assembled by Abo1. Error bars are obtained by bootstrapping42 with a 70% confidence interval. Total events are 312 and 252 for (C) and (D), respectively. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
As a single-molecule imaging technique, DNA curtain has been used extensively to probe DNA metabolic reactions43. DNA curtain is a hybrid system that concatenates lipid fluidity, microfluidics, and TIRFM. Unlike other single-molecule techniques, DNA curtain enables high-throughput real-time visualization of protein-DNA interactions. Therefore, the DNA curtain technique is suitable for probing the mechanism behind molecular interactions, including sequence-specific association, protein movement along with DNA, and protein-protein collision on DNA17,20,26. Additionally, the high-throughput nature of the DNA curtain enables the collection of enough data to ensure statistical reliability. DNA curtain facilitates the investigation of the bio-physicochemical properties of proteins, including kinetic parameters, diffusion coefficient, speed, and processivity17,26,27,30. Importantly, DNA curtain can be used to determine the binding landscape of nucleosome deposition, which indicates the intrinsic sequence preference of nucleosomes30.
Several points need to be considered to obtain high-quality data from the DNA curtain assay. First, the lipid bilayer must be appropriately formed on the slide surface. The fluidity of the lipid bilayer allows DNA molecules to move on the slide and be aligned at a diffusion barrier in the presence of hydrodynamic flow. The lipid bilayer also passivates the surface of the microfluidic chamber to prevent nonspecific adsorption of proteins to the surface. Because the passivation by the lipid bilayer is not complete, fluorescently labeled proteins are adsorbed nonspecifically to the surface, leading to incorrect interpretation of the results. However, the surface-stuck proteins can be distinguished from DNA-bound ones by turning the transient flow on and off because DNA-bound proteins disappear when the flow stops. Second, photobleaching of fluorophores needs to be suppressed. Many single-molecule fluorescence imaging methods adopt an oxygen scavenging system to reduce photobleaching. Several oxygen scavenging systems have been developed, the most popular of which is gloxy. Gloxy, consisting of glucose oxidase and catalase, enzymatically reduces molecular oxygens in solution but lowers the pH44,45,46. Low pH is not compatible with physiological conditions and reduces lipid fluidity. To delay the decrease in pH, (1) the imaging buffer needs to be prepared with degassed deionized water, (2) the buffer must be immediately used, and (3) the buffer must be sealed and stored on ice until use.
A unique platform was developed to improve the DNA curtain system in which carved nano-trenches serve as diffusion barriers instead of chromium nano-patterns25. Since these nano-trenches are more robust under harsh cleaning conditions with strong solvents, they allow repeatable, clearer imaging. However, the DNA curtain technique has several limitations. Under continuous laser illumination, the fluorophores that label proteins are photobleached, making long-time measurements challenging. DNA curtain does not work at low pH (lower than ~6) because the lipid bilayer is not fluidic. In addition, the fluorescence background and nonspecific binding of proteins to the slide surface disturb single-molecule imaging when protein concentration is high. Another drawback of the DNA curtain is that the spatial resolution of the DNA curtain is ~1 kbp/pixel, so the movement of proteins at less than 1 kbp cannot be observed. In addition, DNA curtain continuously applies hydrodynamic force to proteins on DNA. But the force by flow is weak (less than 1 pN), and hence it is challenging that histones or nucleosomes move along DNA in the curtain. It was also reported that nucleosomes rarely slide along DNA without chromatin remodelers47. If histones or nucleosomes slide along DNA, most of them will stay at the end region of DNA in the curtain. However, we did not see the biased distribution. On the other hand, if histones or nucleosomes runoff from the DNA end, they would be depleted at the end of DNA. We did not observe this either.
This work demonstrates that the DNA curtain assay is a single-molecule imaging platform ideal for investigating chromatin dynamics. DNA curtain can be applied to study the process by which histone chaperones such as bromodomain-containing AAA+ ATPases assemble chromatin. The biological function of bromodomain-containing AAA+ ATPases is controversial. Lack of human ATAD2 or S. cerevisiae Yta7 downregulates gene expression via chromatin condensation18. In contrast, S. pombe Abo1 increases nucleosome density16. The single-molecule studies show that Abo1 catalyzes histone H3-H4 loading onto DNA. It is shown that the histone loading activity of Abo1 is dependent on ATP hydrolysis (Figure 2C,E,F). Moreover, the binding distribution of H3-H4 dimers shows that H3-H4 dimers are loaded onto DNA by Abo1 in a sequence-independent manner (Figure 3). In conclusion, the DNA curtain can be used to unravel the biological role of Abo1 as a histone chaperone in histone assembly. Using the DNA curtain technique, nucleosome formation by Abo1 and other histone chaperones such as CAF-1 and FACT will be studied in the future.
Based on this protocol, DNA curtain assay can be used to observe chromatin reorganization by remodeling complexes that translocate and rearrange nucleosomes.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
The authors appreciate the kind support for Abo1 and Cy5-H3-H4 by Professor Ji-Joon Song, Carol Cho, Ph.D., and Juwon Jang, Ph.D., in KAIST, South Korea. This work is supported by the National Research Foundation Grant (NRF-2020R1A2B5B01001792), intramural research fund (1.210115.01) of Ulsan National Institute of Science and Technology, and the Institute for Basic Science (IBS-R022-D1).
1 mL luer-lock syringe | BecktonDickinson | 301321 | |
1' x 3' fused-silca slide glass | G. Finkenbeiner | 1 inch x 3 inch rectangular and 1 mm thickness | |
10 mL luer-lock syringe | BecktonDickinson | 302149 | |
18:1 (Δ9-Cis) PC (DOPC) | Avanti | 850375 | This is a component of biotinylated lipid stock |
18:1 Biotinyl cap PE | Avanti | 870273 | This is a component of biotinylated lipid stock |
18:1 PEG2000 PE | Avanti | 880130 | This is a component of biotinylated lipid stock |
3 mL luer-lock syringe | BecktonDickinson | 302832 | |
6-way sample injection valve | IDEX | MX series II | |
950K PMMA | All-resist | 671.04 | |
Acetone | SAMCHUN | A1759 | |
Adenosine 5'-triphosphate disodium salt hydrate (ATP) | Sigma | A2383 | |
Aluminum (Al) | TASCO, South Korea | LT50AI414 | Diameter 4 inch, thickness 1/4 inch |
Amicon Ultra centrifugal filter, MWCO 10 kDa | Millipore | Z648027 | |
Ampicillin | Mbcell | MB-A4128 | Antibiotics |
AZ 300 MIF developer | Merck | 10454110521 | Used for removing aluminum |
Blade | DORCO | DN52 | 12 mm x 6 m |
Boron trichloride (BCl3) | UNIONGAS | Purity: >99.99% | |
Bovine serum albumin (BSA) | Sigma | A7030 | |
Catalase | Sigma | C40-1g | This is a component of 100x gloxy stock |
Chlorine (Cl2) | UNIONGAS | Purity: >99.99% | |
Clear double-sided tape | 3M | 313770 | |
D-(+)-glucose | Sigma | G7528 | |
DC sputter | Sorona | SRM-120 | Used for deposition aluminum on a slide |
Diamond-coated drill bit | Eurotool | DIB-211.00 | Used for making holes in a fusced silica slide |
DL-Dithiothreitol (DTT) | Sigma | D0632 | |
Dove-prism | Korea Electro-Optics Co. Ltd. | 1906-106 | Custom-made fused-silica dove prism with anti-reflection coating |
Drill | Dremel | Dremel 3000 | Used for making holes in a fusced silica slide |
Electron Bean Lithography | Nanobeam Ltd. | NB3 | |
Ethylene-diamine-tetraacetic acid (EDTA) | Sigma | EDS-1KG | |
Fingertight fittings | IDEX | F-300 | It is connected with "PFA Tubing Natural" to form luer-lock tubing |
Flangeless male nut | IDEX | P-235 | It is connected with "PFA Tubing Natural" to form luer-lock tubing |
Freeze Dryer, HyperCOOL | Labogene | HC3110 | Used for lyophilizing liquid proteins |
Glucose oxidase | Sigma | G2133-50KU | This is a component of 100x gloxy stock |
Guanidinium hydrochloride | Acros Organics | 364790025 | |
Hamilton syringe | Hamilton Company | 80065 | This syringe is used for sample injection |
Hellmanex III | Sigma | Z805939 | |
HiLoad 26/600 SuperdexTM 200 pg | Cytiva | 28-9893-36 | Used for FPLC (size exclusion) |
Hot plate stirrer | Corning | PC-420D | |
Hydrochloric acid | Sigma | H1759 | Used for Tris-HCl |
Index matching oil | ZEISS | 444970-9000-000 | |
Inductively coupled plasma-reactive ion etching | Top Technology Ltd. | FabStar | |
Isopropyl β-D-1-thiogalactopyranoside (IPTG) | Glentham Life Sciences | GC6586-100g | Used for induction of β-galactosidase activity |
Lambda phage DNA | NEB | N0311 | |
LB broth | BD difco | 244610 | Media for E.coli cell growth |
Luer adapter 10-32 | IDEX | P-659 | This connects luer-lock syringe and tubing |
Magnesium chloride hexahydrate | fisher bioreagents | BP214 | |
Methyl isobutyl ketone (MIBK) | KAYAKU ADVANCED MATERIALS | Used for developing solution | |
Microscope (Eclipse Ti2) | Nikon | Eclipse Ti2 | Inverted fluorescence microscope |
Microscope glass coverslip | MARIENFELD | 101142 | 22 x 50 mm (No. 1) |
Microscope slide | DURAN GROUP | DU.2355013 | Slide glass ground edge 45°, plain 26 x 76 mm |
Nanoport | IDEX | N-333-01 | |
Objective lens | Nikon | CFI Plan Apochromat VC 60XC WI | Immersion type: water, magnification: 60x, correction: 18, working distance: 0.29 (0.31-0.28) |
One Shot BL21 (DE3)pLysS Chemically Competent E. coli | Thermo Fisher Scientific | C6060-03 | Competent cell for overexpressing proteins |
Oxygen (O2) | NOBLEGAS, South Korea | Purity: >99.99% | |
PFA tubing natural | IDEX | 1512L | It is connected with "Fingertight Fittings" to form luer-lock tubing |
Phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride (PMSF) | Roche | 11359061001 | Protease inhibitor |
Sephacryl S-200 High Resolution | Cytiva | 17-0584-01 | Used for FPLC (size exclusion) |
Shut-off valve | IDEX | P-732 | |
Sodium acetate | Sigma | 791741 | |
Sodium chloride (NaCl) | Sigma | S3014 | |
Sodium hydroxide (NaOH) | Sigma | s5881 | |
Spectra/Por molecularporous membrane tubing, MWCO 6-8 kDa | Spectrum laboratories | 132660 | |
Streptavidin | Thermo Fisher Scientific | S888 | |
Sulfur tetralfluoride (SF4) | NOBLEGAS, South Korea | Purity: >99.99% | |
Syringe pump | KD Scientific | 78-8210 | |
Tetrafluoromethane (CF4) | NOBLEGAS, South Korea | Purity: >99.99% | |
TritonX-100 | Sigma | T9284 | |
Trizma base | Sigma | T1503 | Used for Tris-HCl |
TSKgel SP-5PW | TOSOH | 14715 | Used for FPLC (ion exchange) |
Union assembly | IDEX | P-760 | This connects tubings |
Urea | Sigma | U5378 | |
Vacuum oven | Jeio Tech | OV-11 | |
YOYO-1 | Thermo Fisher Scientific | Y3601 | This intercalation dye is diluted in DMSO |
β-mercaptoethanol (BME) | Sigma | M6250 |