Pneumothorax is a common emergency and critical disease in newborn infants that needs rapid, clear diagnosis and timely treatment. Diagnosis and treatment based on chest X-rays are associated with delayed management and radiation damage. Lung ultrasound (US) provides useful guidance for rapid, accurate diagnosis and the precise thoracentesis of pneumothorax.
Pneumothorax (PTX) represents accumulation of the air in the pleural space. A large or tension pneumothorax can collapse the lung and cause hemodynamic compromise, a life-threatening disorder. Traditionally, neonatal pneumothorax diagnosis has been based on clinical images, auscultation, transillumination, and chest X-ray findings. This approach may potentially lead to a delay in both diagnosis and treatment. The use of lung US in diagnosis of PTX together with US-guided thoracentesis results in earlier and more precise management. The recommendations presented in this publication are aimed at improving the application of lung US in guiding neonatal PTX diagnosis and management.
Pneumothorax (PTX) is defined as the presence of air within the pleural space. It is a well-recognized medical emergency condition with high mortality rates, especially in neonates with associated risk factors1,2,3. The incidence of PTX is reported to be 1–2% in term infants and 6% in premature infants with respiratory distress2,3. In addition, lung US (LUS) performed on asymptomatic term infants show that the incidence of mild PTX in these patients can be as high as 10%2,3. Risk factors associated with increased incidence of PTX include meconium aspiration syndrome (MAS), respiratory distress syndrome (RDS), and persistent pulmonary hypertension of the newborn (PPHN)4,5,6,7. A 1 min Apgar score ≤ 7 was associated with a 2.67x increased risk of PTX (95% CI 1.14–6.25)8. Increasing peak inspiratory pressure (PIP) during conventional mechanical ventilation has been shown to be a risk factor for PTX, and a PIP increase of 1 cm H2O increases the odds of PTX by 1.46 (95% CI 1.02–2.07)8. The incidence of PTX in infants with a <2,500 g birth weight (BW) increases almost 10x compared to those with a BW ≥ 2500 g8. Notably, PTX is associated with increased mortality, with an odds ratio of 5.27 (95% CI = 1.96–14.17)7. Apiliogullari et al. reported that aggregate mortality was as high as 30% in PTX patients while survivors also had an increased rate of bronchopulmonary dysplasia (4.28x vs. controls)9. Therefore, early and accurate diagnosis followed by adequate treatment is imperative3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14. Lately, less expensive US imaging systems have become readily available, and non-ionizing, fast, and repeatable LUS represents an ideal tool for the diagnosis of neonatal PTX.
PTX is traditionally diagnosed by clinical imaging, auscultation, transillumination, and chest X-ray findings. In some cases of non-tension PTX, watchful waiting is warranted. However, large PTX or tension PTX requires prompt evacuation of the air in the pleural space by thoracentesis. Obtaining a chest X-ray image can be time-consuming and prolong the diagnosis of tension PTX. For these reasons, in many neonatal intensive care units (NICUs), LUS is replacing chest X-rays in diagnosing PTX due to its superior sensitivity and specificity15-17. Moreover, LUS has been shown to be more accurate than chest X-rays even for small, non-tension PTX18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27. LUS signs of PTX were first studied and described in adult critical patients. Patients with suspected PTX were scanned with LUS and computed tomography (CT). LUS signs characteristic of PTX were abolition of lung sliding in the B-mode (corresponding to the stratosphere sign in the M-mode), presence of A-lines, and the lung point. In the same study, abolition of lung sliding alone has a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 78% for PTX. Absent lung sliding together with the presence of A-lines had a sensitivity of 95% and a specificity of 94% while lung point alone had sensitivity of 79% and a specificity of 100%18.
Similarly, the usefulness of LUS to diagnose PTX has been described in infants19,20,21,22,23,24. CT could not be used as the benchmark in neonatal patients, thus LUS was compared with chest X-ray and clinical exam findings. Most of the studies included infants with sudden deterioration of their respiratory status, where LUS was performed before or after chest X-ray. The diagnostic accuracy showed a sensitivity of 100%, specificity of 100%, positive predictive value of 100%, and negative predictive value of 100%16,17,18,19. In cases characterized by large PTX, lung point was absent, which consequently decreased the sensitivity of this sign to 75–95%21,22. The average time to perform the diagnostic tests in these studies was 5.3 ± 5.6 min for LUS versus 19 ± 11.7 min for a chest X-ray19. As expected, LUS showed better diagnostic accuracy than chest transilumination19. Keeping in mind that in infants with tension PTX the needle is blindly placed in the second intercostal space at the midclavicular line, it is not surprising to see treatment failure and/or complications6. On the other hand, PTX thoracentesis performed under LUS guidance has shown promising results in infants28,29.
The neonatal Lung Ultrasound Training Base of China, Chinese College of Critical Ultrasound, as well as the World Interactive Network Focused On Critical Ultrasound China branch have organized this international expert panel that reviewed the latest literature related to neonatal PTX diagnosis and treatment aimed at the improvement in the application of LUS-based diagnosis and treatment of PTX.
Patients and timing of the examination
The LUS exam can be used on any neonate in respiratory distress. It is indicated in the following situations: 1) Suspicion of PTX in neonates with sudden deterioration of respiratory status; 2) Before and after thoracentesis.
Lung ultrasonography terminology used in PTX diagnosis
Frequently used ultrasound terms in diagnosis of PTX include: A-line, B-line, confluent B-lines, compact B-lines, alveolar-interstitial syndrome, pleural line, lung sliding, lung pulse, sandy beach sign, and stratosphere sign. The exact definitions of the terms used have been described in detail previously30,31,32,33,34.
This work was approved by the Research Ethics Committee of Beijing Chaoyang District Maternal and Child Healthcare Hospital & Beijing Chaoyang District Bureau of Science, Technology and Information. The study protocol follows the guidelines of the hospital's human research ethics committee.
1. Ultrasound Exam Preparation
2. Place the Infant in a Suitable Position
3. Partitioning the Lungs
4. Procedure for LUS Imaging
5. Identifying the Presence of PTX
6. Identifying the Degree of PTX
7. LUS-guided Thoracentesis
The main purpose of these guidelines is to direct users on how to perform US-guided thoracentesis to treat PTX. Neonatal normal lung appears as a bamboo sign on B-mode US (Figure 1A) and as a seashore sign (Figure 1B) on M-mode US. Lung sliding is clearly evident under real-time US (see Video 1 for lung sliding)31,32,33,34.
PTX is diagnosed based on the following LUS imaging characteristics: 1) Disappearance of lung sliding. This is the most important sign in the US diagnosis of PTX; 2) Absence of B-lines; 3) Presence of the pleural line and A-lines; 4) On M-mode imaging a normal sandy beach sign is replaced by the stratosphere sign, which is highly specific for PTX; 5) Presence of the lung point in mild to moderate PTX. This sign may not be evident if PTX is large30,31,32,33,34. The PTX diagnostic flowchart is presented in Figure 234.
Identifying the degree of PTX
The severity of PTX can be identified by the several characteristics. 1) Mild PTX: LUS signs of PTX exist in the anterior chest areas only when an infant is in a supine position. The area where lung sliding disappears is approximately <50% of the whole lung field or the spared areas exist. Lung point is easily identifiable due to the normally expanded lung. The presence of a spared area generally suggests mild PTX; 2) Moderate PTX: LUS signs of PTX are evident in the anterior and lateral chest areas when the infant is in a supine position. The area where lung sliding disappears is >50% of the whole lung field. Identifying the transitional lung point area may be challenging; 3) Severe PTX: LUS signs of PTX exist in the anterior, lateral, and posterior lung areas. Lung sliding is absent in all lung areas. There is no identifiable lung point.
Thoracentesis under lung US guidance
The infant can be placed in the supine, prone, or side position. Slight elevation of the upper body helps obtain more complete air evacuation. If severe PTX is present, the thoracentesis must be performed immediately (Figure 3, Video 2). Place the patient in a prone position (Figure 4A), side position (Figure 4B), or supine position. In the case of tension PTX, continuous air drainage with a chest tube can be used with the infant in a supine position (Figure 4C). In moderate PTX, if thoracentesis is indicated, the site of needle insertion can be anywhere in the field where lung sliding is absent (Figure 5, Video 3). Mild PTX (Figure 6, Figure 7, Video 4, Video 5, Video 6) generally does not require thoracentesis. However, if the primary pulmonary disease of the infant is more severe and the infant presents with clinical deterioration, then thoracentesis may be indicated (Figure 8, Video 7).
Figure 1: Neonatal Normal LUS. (A) B-mode US: Pleural line and A-lines are smooth, regular, and straight hyperechoic lines, parallel and equidistant from each other. A-lines gradually diminish and finally disappear off the screen. (B) M-mode US: Above the pleural line are linear hyperechoic lines that correspond to the non-moving skin, and subcutaneous and muscle tissue. Below the pleural line is the normal lung tissue that moves with each respiration, leaving a grainy image. These M-mode findings create a seashore sign. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: The PTX diagnostic flowchart program. This flowchart program shows that B-mode US is the most important method to diagnose PTX, while M-mode US is helpful to confirm the diagnosis. This figure is reproduced from Liu et al.34. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Severe PTX. B-mode US (upper part): The pleural line and the A-lines are present, apparently normal LUS. M-mode US (lower part) shows a stratosphere sign as the lung below the pleural line is displaced by PTX. The absence of lung movement under the pleural line cancels out the normal grainy image. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Body position. (A) Infant in prone position. (B) Infant in side position. An angiocatheter is used to evacuate the air from the pleural location. It is connected to a 20 mL syringe. (C) Chest tube under continuous suction. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: Lung point in moderate PTX. B-mode US: Lung point with an area of disappeared lung sliding that is >50% of the whole field, suggesting moderate PTX. Evacuation of air is usually needed with this degree of PTX. The needle puncture site can be selected anywhere in the lung field without lung sliding. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6: Lung point in mild PTX. B-mode US: Lung point with an area of disappeared lung sliding that is <50% of the whole lung field suggests moderate PTX. Evacuation of air is rarely needed with this degree of PTX. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 7: Spared area in mild PTX. The pleural line and A-lines exist in the middle field of the lung while the significant B-lines exist in the upper and lower field of the lung. This kind of lung US sign in known as a spared area. You can find two lung points in this condition. The presence of a spared area generally suggests mild PTX (please also see Video 6). Air evacuation is usually not needed with this degree of PTX. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 8: Spared area in mild PTX. A male patient with a gestational age of 41 weeks and birth weight of 3,200 g. The patient was admitted to the NICU because of dyspnea 20 min after birth. LUS showed that spared areas existed in the left anterior chest only. B-mode LUS (Figure 8) and real-time US (Video 7) suggest the presence of mild PTX in the left chest together with pneumonia. Although the infant had only mild PTX, it was accompanied by severe dyspnea not alleviated with mechanical ventilation. Thus, the pleural puncture was performed. The infant's status significantly improved upon drainage of 15 mL of air from the left chest. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Video 1: Neonatal Normal LUS. Positive lung sliding under real-time US appears as shimmering of the pleural line. Please click here to download this video.
Video 2: Severe PTX. Absence of lung sliding under real-time US. Please click here to download this video.
Video 3: Lung point in moderate PTX. Under real-time US the lung point presents as an alternate point of lung sliding emergence and disappearance. Please click here to download this video.
Video 4: Lung point in mild PTX. Under real-time US the lung point presents as an alternate point of lung sliding emergence and disappearance. Please click here to download this video.
Video 5: Spared area in mild PTX. Under real-time US, two alternating points of lung sliding emergence and disappearance, indicating two lung points and a spared lung field area. Please click here to download this video.
Video 6: Spared area in mild PTX. A spared area is present in the left anterior chest on real-time LUS. Please click here to download this video.
Video 7: Spared area in mild PTX. On real-time US in the middle field of the lung the lung sliding disappeared, but the pleural line and A-lines are there. In the upper and lower fields of the lung, lung sliding as well as significant B-lines exist. That is the spared area, suggesting mild PTX in the left chest. Please click here to download this video.
LUS for the diagnosis of neonatal PTX is a manageable and timely diagnostic modality17,19,20,21,22,23,30,35,36,37,38. Recent animal studies found that the LUS diagnosis of PTX is very accurate and reliable39,40. In one of these studies LUS and chest X-rays findings of PTX were compared to CT scans as a point of reference and confirmed that LUS is superior to chest X-rays in diagnosis of small PTXs40. In newborn infants with PTX, LUS sensitivity and specificity are also higher than that of chest X-rays17,19-23,37,38, and recent meta-analysis further established that the sensitivity of LUS in diagnosing PTX is nearly 50% higher than the chest X-ray sensitivity41,42.
Identification of the degree of PTX is very important for thoracentesis. However, absolutely accurate quantification of PTX volume by LUS is not easy. Finding the lung point effectively distinguishes the normal lung from the lung being separated from the chest wall by the presence of PTX. Similarly, LUS cannot ascertain the depth of air collection. Some studies have shown that semi-quantification of PTX volume is only reliable for small PTX43. Therefore, the comprehensive analysis of vital signs, physical exams, and LUS images are essential before making a decision as to whether or not to perform an invasive procedure such as thoracentesis or thoracostomy44,45. A study also showed certain variations among pediatric surgeons in the management of spontaneous PTX. The use of CT, timing of operation, and length of observation for air leak before performing surgery have not been adequately standardized44. Recent systemic reviews showed no significant difference between thoracentesis and chest tube placement with regards to safety and rates of immediate success. However, thoracentesis is associated with decreased pain and duration of hospital stay compared to chest tube thoracotomy6. Traditionally, thoracentesis is performed in the 2nd intercostal space at the midclavicular line or 4–5th intercostal space at the midaxillary line with the needle pointed toward the opposite shoulder with a repeat chest X-ray after the procedure. This technique may have several disadvantages. It may delay evacuation of the air because the needle may not always be located right above the PTX, rendering the evacuation incomplete. Evacuation drainage may be prolonged due to incomplete evacuation and the need to change the patient's body position. Also, repeated chest X-ray exposure is always needed. Finally, if the needle is not pointed in the right direction, major blood vessels can be pierced. LUS not only facilitates the needle aspiration by decreasing the risk of complications, but it also offers real-time observation of postprocedural PTX resolution and lung reexpansion46. In summary, compared to the traditional thoracentesis procedure there are several benefits of LUS-guided thoracentesis. These include 1) Convenience: There are no limitations to the infant's body position; 2) Accurate and real-time procedure performance: The procedure can be performed immediately after the LUS diagnosis, precisely aimed at the PTX with simultaneous follow-up of lung reexpansion; 3) Decreased risks of complications: LUS can guide the needle just above the rib, avoiding the blood vessels and allowing the operator to visualize the needle as it enters the pleural space; 4) Pain reduction: Shortening the procedural time as well as accurate needle insertion may alleviate the infant's pain47.
Critical steps within the protocol are to diagnose PTX and perform thoracentesis proficiently and accurately. The operator must be skilled in neonatal LUS examination as well as in the neonatal thoracentesis technique. Studies have shown that learning essential LUS skills requires short training programs with a relatively small number of supervised scans ranging between 20–80 LUS exams34,35. Several published guidelines should assist in developing and maintaining those skills30,31,32,33,34.
Limitations to LUS-guided thoracentesis are: 1) Difficulty to accurately quantify the exact PTX volume; 2) Operator-dependent procedure; 3) Less experienced examiners may mistake PTX for diseases that are similar to it, such as bullae and some congenital pulmonary airway malformations48,49.
For comprehensive neonatal LUS guidelines, including PTX diagnosis, one can also reference previous publications30,31,32,33,34. The diagnosis of PTX using LUS is relatively easy when guiding principles are followed. Formal LUS training allows trainees to quickly acquire these skills50. Thoracentesis remains a high-risk procedure, particularly in very low birth weight infants. US-guided thoracentesis offers several potential improvements over conventional landmark PTX management. Further, multicenter studies should aim to quantify the extent of this improvement. A detailed description of US-guided thoracentesis allows for a more standardized approach that should guide both clinical practice and research.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
We acknowledge all the experts and authors that participated in writing and editing the manuscript.
This work was supported by the Social Development Projects, Beijing Chaoyang District Bureau of Science, Technology and Information (CYSF1922 & CYSF1820) and the Clinical Research Special Fund of Wu Jieping Medical Foundation (320.6750.15072 & 320.6750.16092).
We acknowledge the Neonatal Lung Ultrasound Training Base of China, Chinese College of Critical Ultrasound, as well as World Interactive Network Focused On Critical Ultrasound China branch for organizing this work.
We acknowledge the all the staff that worked for the Department of Neonatology and the NICU, Beijing Chaoyang District Maternal and Child Healthcare Hospital, especially the nursing staff who assisted this work, particularly during the process of the video recording.
Disinfection wipe | Nantong Sirui Company Ltd. | YZB0016-2013 | Benzalkonium Bromide Patches |
Ultrasound gel | Tianjin Xiyuansi Company | TM20160195 | Aquasonic 100 ultrasound transmission gel |
Ultrasound machine | GE Healthcare | H44792LW | Ultrasound machine,Voluson S10 BT16,Probe ML6-15 & 9L |
Ultrasound machine | GE Healthcare | H48701UZ | Ultrasound machine,Voluson E10 BT18 OLED,Probe ML6-15 & 9L |