A protocol for the analysis of gels formed from the optoelectronic conjugated polymer poly(3-hexylthiophene-2,5-diyl) (P3HT) using small and ultra-small angle neutron scattering in both the presence and absence of illumination is presented.
We demonstrate a protocol to effectively monitor the gelation process of a high concentration solution of conjugated polymer both in the presence and absence of white light exposure. By instituting a controlled temperature ramp, the gelation of these materials can be precisely monitored as they proceed through this structural evolution, which effectively mirrors the conditions experienced during the solution deposition phase of organic electronic device fabrication. Using small angle neutron scattering (SANS) and ultra-small angle neutron scattering (USANS) along with appropriate fitting protocols we quantify the evolution of select structural parameters throughout this process. Thorough analysis indicates that continued light exposure throughout the gelation process significantly alters the structure of the ultimately formed gel. Specifically, the aggregation process of poly(3-hexylthiophene-2,5-diyl) (P3HT) nano-scale aggregates is negatively affected by the presence of illumination, ultimately resulting in the retardation of growth in conjugated polymer microstructures and the formation of smaller scale macro-aggregate clusters.
Conjugated polymers promise functional materials that can be utilized in a broad range of devices, such as organic light emitting diodes, organic semiconductors, chemical sensors, and organic photovoltaics.1,2,3,4,5,6 A crucial aspect of the performance in these devices is the ordering and packing of the conjugated polymer in the solid state in the active layer.7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14 This morphology is largely pre-determined by both the conformation of the polymer chain in solution as well as the structures that evolve as these solutions are cast unto a substrate and the solvent is removed. By studying the structures present throughout a typical sol-gel transition of a model optoelectronic polymer in a suitable solvent, these systems can be effectively modeled and a quantitative glimpse into the self-assembly that occurs during material deposition can be obtained.15,16,17,18,19,20
Specifically, we examine the conjugated polymer benchmark P3HT in the solvent deuterated ortho-dichlorobenzene (ODCB), a polymer-solvent system which has seen extensive use due to its suitability for a variety of organic electronic device fabrication techniques.23,24,25 In this given solvent environment, P3HT chains begin to aggregate upon an appropriate environmental stimuli, such as temperature decrease or loss of solvent quality. The exact mechanism for this assembly process is under investigation, with one of the leading proposed pathways believed to be a gradual process where individual P3HT molecules π-stack to form lamellar nano-aggregates known as nanofibrils, which then themselves agglomerate to form larger micron scale macro-aggregates.24 Understanding these pathways and the resultant structures formed is key to properly predicting and influencing the formation of optimal device active layer morphologies.
Towards this ultimate goal of more precisely directing the formation of these active layer architectures, there exists a need to develop additional experimental and industrial methods to non-destructively alter conjugated polymer morphology in-situ. One relatively new methodology centers around the use of light exposure as an inexpensive means for altering polymer chain morphology, with both computational and experimental results pointing towards its feasibility.25,26,27 Recent work by our laboratory has indicated the existence of a light induced alteration of the conjugated polymer-solvent interaction in a dilute solution, leading to a notable change in polymer chain size upon illumination.30,31 Here, we present a protocol to continue this work by effectively monitoring the effects of exposing a much more concentrated conjugated polymer solution to direct light throughout a gelation process that is directed by a thermostat-controlled temperature ramp. We employ neutron scattering as it allows robust analysis of structural parameters of the polymer-solvent sol-gel system on length scales from angstroms to microns, an ability not possible through other more common rheological or spectroscopic instrumental methods.16,17,30,31 Thus, by comparing the properly analyzed small and ultra-small angle neutron data for the assembly of gels formed under illumination to identical data collected in complete darkness, structural differences brought on by illumination-driven effects can be comprehensively identified and quantified.
All handling of chemicals should be carried out with proper personal protective equipment and within a safety hood. All samples exposed to ionizing radiation should be handled under the supervision of the facilities radioactive control technicians. This protocol was performed by individuals who had completed appropriate radiation safety training.
1. Preparation of P3HT in d-ODCB Solutions
2. Neutron Scattering Experiments
3. Data Reduction and Analysis
Through SANS and USANS experiments, the gelation process of P3HT in d-ODCB was effectively monitored from the dispersed solution state at 70 °C to a fully gelled state at 20 °C. These experiments were conducted in both complete darkness and under white light illumination. Figure 1 displays some example SANS reduced data curves from these experiments, with an example curve fit shown in Figure 2. From this data, the structural changes occurring as temperature decreases have been effectively captured, denoted by a clear increase in absolute intensity as temperature falls. Additionally, for each given temperature there is a clear discrepancy between the scattering data of the samples studied in the dark and those studied in the light as the data plots do not overlap. This indicates that light exposure significantly affects the aggregation process. Figure 3 displays values for a variety of structural parameters extracted using the combined fit model from the SANS data and provides structural information on both the nanofibril aggregates and the free chains still in solution. The nanofibril surface area describes the surface area of the face of the cylindrical nano-scale P3HT aggregates and the ECM scale factor gives a qualitative description of the amount of P3HT present in the aggregate phase, while the free chain Rg and Porod exponent describe the size and form factor of the P3HT chains not yet gelled in the solution. Significant differences in these parameters at each given temperature and between light and dark samples at a given temperature indicate that the experiment and fitting process have captured the effect of light exposure on this gelation process. Since they employ a substantially lower Q range, USANS experiments allow the characterization of larger length scales consistent with P3HT macro aggregates, and by mirroring the same approach used in the SANS experiments, the effect of temperature and light upon the size of these aggregates is effectively quantified. Figure 4 shows USANS data plotted alongside the SANS data for a single temperature, and Figure 5 displays the Rg data acquired through fitting USANS data with a power law model. This Rg value grows with decreasing temperature as gelation progresses and individual P3HT nanofibrils themselves aggregate to form large scale microstructures. And as with the SANS data, there exists clear difference between the light and dark data, specifically showing smaller Rg values with light exposure.
Figure 1: Small angle neutron scattering data for a 17 wt% sample of P3HT in d-ODCB through 70-20 °C temperature ramp. Data collected under white light illumination (open symbols) and in complete darkness (closed symbols). Error bars report instrumental error. Reproduced from reference 28 with permission. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Example fit using a combination model approach incorporating both the Elliptical Cylinder and Polymer Excluded Volume Model to 17 wt% P3HT SANS data collected at 34 °C in the presence of white light illumination. Reproduced from reference 28 with permission. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Select parameters obtained from the combined model fit for 17 wt% P3HT through a 70 – 20°C temperature ramp, with black traces indicating samples studied in the dark, and red traces indicating samples studied under illumination: (A): nanofibril surface area, (B): Elliptical Cylinder Model scale factor, (C): radius of gyration of free chains, and (D): Porod exponent of free chains. Error bars report fit-generated standard deviation error values. Reproduced from reference 28 with permission. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Small and ultra-small angle scattering data of 17 wt% P3HT at 24°C for both illuminated (gray) and dark (black) samples. Error bars report instrumental error. Reproduced from reference 28 with permission. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: Radius of gyration values obtained from 17 wt% P3HT USANS data fit with a Guinier-Porod power law model for both illuminated (red) and dark (black) samples. Error bars report fit-generated standard deviation error values. Reproduced from reference 28 with permission.
Figure 6: Illustration of the P3HT assembly process from free chains to final micron-scale aggregates. Reproduced from reference 28 with permission. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
First, looking at the SANS data as a function of temperature, the increase in the Elliptical Cylinder Model scale factor indicates a marked increase in the amount of P3HT present in the nanofibril phase, which isconsistent with the progression of the gelation process. Simultaneously, the decrease in free chain Rg paired with an increase in Porod exponent reveals that the deteriorating thermodynamic conditions associated with temperature decrease are causing a chain collapse in the P3HT chains still present in solution. These results, combined with the USANS data showing a marked increase in macroaggregate Rg upon temperature decrease, indicate that the scattering experiments have effectively captured and analyzed the progression of the structural self-assembly process central to the sol-gel transition, a process that is visualized in Figure 6. Analyzing the results of these experiments as a function of light exposure provides further information related to the effect of illumination on the gelation process and the ultimate aggregate structures formed. Comparison of all SANS parameters in Figure 2 reveals differences between the light and dark samples over a range of temperatures, as does the USANS data in Figure 3. Taken together, this information indicates that light exposure effectively hinders the P3HT aggregation process, resulting in less material aggregating in the nanofibril phase (indicated by the ECM scale factor results) and smaller micron scale aggregates (given by the USANS Rg values). Thus, this experiment has also emphasized the differences between conjugated polymer gelation conducted in the light versus the dark and underlined the importance of illumination conditions upon the device-relevant active layer morphologies which are formed.
When considering a similar experimental approach to the above method it is important to keep in mind the limitations inherent to the system. Neutron scattering is a powerful technique for analyzing angstrom to nanometer scale structures in polymer systems, however, length scales that lie above or below this range are better probed by other techniques. Additionally, if one of the components of the polymer system of interest are not easily deuterated, it can be difficult to achieve the level of contrast necessary for acceptable results. Also, given the limited amount of neutron beam time, experiments must be carefully planned with a relatively concentrated focus. It is also important to have an appropriate robust fitting model pre-determined before the experiments begin to narrow the scope of the analysis process and ensure proper modeling of the system.
Assuming that an experiment meets these conditions, these neutron scattering methods offer a unique tool to unobtrusively monitor the structural evolution of polymer systems over a range of length scales as a function of multiple environmental stimuli, such as temperature and light exposure. Harnessing these approaches could allow for the expansion of these methods to a huge variety of polymer-solvent systems to explore structural changes occurring due to changes in a variety of conditions including (but not limited to) polymer concentration, solvent quality, dopant addition, and thermal history.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
The authors gratefully acknowledge the National Science Foundation (DMR-1409034) for support of this project. We also acknowledge the support of the National Institute of Standards and Technology, U.S. Department of Commerce, in providing the USANS facilities used in this work, where these facilities are supported in part by the National Science Foundation under Agreement No. DMR-0944772. The SANS experiments of this research were completed at ORNL's High Flux Isotope Reactor, which was sponsored by the Scientific User Facilities Division, Office of Basic Energy Sciences, US Department of Energy.
M(106) poly(3-hexylthiophene-2,5-diyl) (P3HT) | Ossila | 104934-50-1 | Conjugated polymer |
deuterated 1,2 ortho-dichlorobenzene (ODCB) | Sigma Aldrich | AC321260050 | solvent |