In this manuscript, we describe a simple method of growth, purification, and titration of the oncolytic herpes simplex virus for preclinical use.
Oncolytic viruses (OVs), such as the oncolytic herpes simplex virus (oHSV), are a rapidly growing treatment strategy in the field of cancer immunotherapy. OVs, including oHSV, selectively replicate in and kill cancer cells (sparing healthy/normal cells) while inducing anti-tumor immunity. Because of these unique properties, oHSV-based treatment strategies are being increasingly used for the treatment of cancer, preclinically and clinically, including FDA-approved talimogene laherparevec (T-Vec). Growth, purification, and titration are three essential laboratory techniques for any OVs, including oHSVs, before they can be utilized for experimental studies. This paper describes a simple step-by-step method to amplify oHSV in Vero cells. As oHSVs multiply, they produce a cytopathic effect (CPE) in Vero cells. Once 90-100% of the infected cells show a CPE, they are gently harvested, treated with benzonase and magnesium chloride (MgCl2), filtered, and subjected to purification using the sucrose-gradient method. Following purification, the number of infectious oHSV (designated as plaque-forming units or PFUs) is determined by a "plaque assay" in Vero cells. The protocol described herein can be used to prepare high-titer oHSV stock for in vitro studies in cell culture and in vivo animal experiments.
Oncolytic viruses (OVs) are an emerging and unique form of cancer immunotherapy. OVs selectively replicate in and lyse tumor cells (sparing normal/healthy cells)1 while inducing anti-tumor immunity2. Oncolytic herpes simplex virus (oHSV) is one of the most extensively studied viruses among all OVs. It is furthest along in the clinic, with Talimogene laherparepvec (T-VEC) being the first and only OV to receive FDA approval in the USA for the treatment of advanced melanoma3. In addition to T-VEC, many other genetically engineered oHSVs are being tested preclinically and clinically in different cancer types3,4,5,6,7,8. The current advanced recombinant DNA biotechnology has further increased the feasibility of engineering new oHSVs coding for therapeutic transgene(s)3,5. An efficient system of oHSV propagation, purification, and titer determination is critical before any (newly developed) oHSV can be tested for in vitro and in vivo studies. This paper describes a simple step-by-step method of oHSV growth (in Vero cells), purification (by the sucrose-gradient method), and titration (by an oHSV plaque assay in Vero cells) (Figure 1). It can be easily adopted in any Biosafety Level 2 (BSL2) laboratory setting to achieve a high-quality viral stock for preclinical studies.
Vero, an African green monkey kidney cell line, is the most commonly used cell line for oHSV propagation9,10,11,12,13 as Vero cells have a defective antiviral interferon signaling pathway14. Other cell lines with inactivated stimulator of interferon genes (STING) signaling can also be used for oHSV growth12,13. This protocol utilizes Vero cells for oHSV growth and plaque assay. Following propagation, oHSV-infected cells are harvested, lysed, and subjected to purification, wherein lysed cells are first treated with benzonase nuclease to degrade host cell DNA, prevent nucleic acid-protein aggregation, and reduce the viscosity of the cell lysate. As proper activation of benzonase often requires Mg2+, 1-2 mM MgCl2 is used in this protocol15. The host cell debris from the benzonase-treated cell lysate is further eliminated by serial filtration before high-speed sucrose-gradient centrifugation. A viscous 25% sucrose solution cushion helps to ensure a slower rate of virus migration through the sucrose layer, leaving host cell-related components in the supernatant, thus improving purification and limiting virus loss in the pellet16. The purified oHSV is then titrated on Vero cells, and viral plaques are visualized by Giemsa staining17 or X-gal staining (for LacZ encoding oHSVs)18.
1) oHSV growth
NOTE: Ensure institutional biosafety committee approval before working with oHSV. This study was conducted under approved IBC Protocol no. 18007. Maintain BSL2 precautions: bleach all pipets, tips, tubes, and other materials that come into contact with the virus. Spray gloves with 70% isopropyl alcohol before hands leave the BSL2 cell culture hood. Always thoroughly wash hands with soap water after working with a virus.
2) oHSV purification
3. oHSV titration and plaque assay
A brief overview of the entire protocol is depicted in Figure 1, which represents the critical steps involved in the growth, purification, and titration of oHSV. CPE in Vero cells can be detected as early as 4 h post-HSV infection19. Figure 2 demonstrates CPE in Vero cells at three different time points following oHSV infection. The level of the CPE is increased over time. In this protocol, 90-100% CPE is usually observed within 48 h of low-MOI oHSV inoculation (which is the best time to harvest cells for purification). However, it can take up to 4 days depending on the oHSV MOI inoculated in step 1.2 and/or the oHSV's replication potential. Beyond this period, cells with CPE can be lysed, leading to the release of the virus in the supernatant. Thus, to obtain a high viral titer, it is critical to harvest CPE-affected cells when they are intact. Another important factor that contributes to the final virus titer is the number or size of the tissue culture flasks used for oHSV amplification. Figure 3 depicts the process of serial dilution (10-3 to 10-9) of a given virus stock (obtained in step 2.6.4) required for titer determination by the plaque assay. For oHSVs with lacZ expression, viral plaques can be visualized by X-gal staining (Figure 4). In this protocol, 20 T-150 cm2 tissue culture flasks were used, for which 1.3-1.6 mL of oHSV stock with a titer of 1 × 1010 pfu/mL can be expected.
Figure 1: A schematic presentation of major steps involved in oHSV growth, purification, and the plaque assay. Abbreviations: oHSV = oncolytic herpes simplex virus; CPE = cytopathic effect; VB = Virus Buffer; HBSS = Hank's Balanced Salt Solution; PBS = phosphate-buffered saline. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Cytopathic effect in Vero cells after oHSV infection. Vero cells were inoculated with oHSV coding for mCherry (shown in red fluorescence) at an MOI of 0.01 and imaged (10x magnification) at 36, 48, and 72 h post-virus infection. CPE is identified by rounding of the oHSV-infected cells (indicated by black arrows). Scale bars = 200 μm. Abbreviation: oHSV = oncolytic herpes simplex virus. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: A serial dilution of an oHSV stock for plaque assays. See also step 3.3 of the protocol. Abbreviation: oHSV = oncolytic herpes simplex virus. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: A representative image of X-gal-stained plaques at 72 h post-oHSV infection. Undiluted (upper well) and diluted (1:10; lower well) oHSV-infected cell culture supernatants added to Vero cells (70-80% confluent), followed by X-gal staining protocol described in section 3.8.5 (excluding counter-staining with Neutral Red). Representative images of an X-gal-stained virus plaque (from left panel) is presented in the middle (4x; scale bars = 1000 μm) and right (10x; scale bars = 200 μm) panels. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Solution Composition | |
Preparation of virus buffer | Quantity |
1 M Sodium chloride | 15 mL |
1 M Tris-hydrochloride | 3 mL |
Purified water | 132 mL |
adjust pH to 6.8 | |
Preparation of X-gal solution (~6.5 mL for one 6-well plate) | |
250 mM potassium ferricyanide | 130 µL |
250 mM potassium ferrocyanide | 130 µL |
1 M Magnesium chloride | 13 µL |
X-gal pre-dissolved (20 mg/mL) in dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) | 162.5 µL |
PBS | 6064.5 µL |
Preparation of Neutral Red solution for one 6-well plate | |
Neutral Red solution | 100 µL |
Methanol | 1 mL |
Purified water | 7 mL |
Table 1: Solution composition.
The protocol starts with the growth of oHSV in low-passage Vero cells. The confluency of the Vero cell monolayer should be ~80% at the time of virus inoculation as overgrown cells can develop tight fibrous structures that can reduce oHSV entry into Vero cells20. Once 90-100% CPE is observed, the culture supernatant is removed, cells are harvested, resuspended in VB/supernatant (see step 1.4.6), snap-frozen, and stored at -80 °C for later purification. Blaho and colleagues employed a slightly different method of harvesting and storage of infected Vero cells. For instance, the flasks containing the cells and culture media (supplemented with 1% bovine serum albumin and PBS with potassium) are initially stored at -80 °C for at least 15 min, followed by a slow warming up of the flasks at room temperature. The cells are then harvested, mixed with sterile milk, and stored at -80 °C until purification20. In this case, sterile milk acts as a stabilizer, and it was demonstrated that the titer of a virus stock is dramatically higher when it is stored in sterile milk/medium than in medium alone20. However, in another study, a direct comparison between different stabilizers (including sterile milk) used for the storage of several herpesviruses at -80 °C did not show any significant impact on the final virus titers21. Here, the cell pellet was re-suspended in VB constituted with Tris-buffer saline (pH 6.8) and 10% glycerol as a storage stabilizer, which usually gives a high virus titer (as outlined in step 3.10) for experimental studies.
It is critical to remove all cellular- and media-related components from the re-suspended pellet to obtain a high-quality virus stock. The removal of non-viral particles is crucial to avoid potential immune reactions during in vivo experiments. Several methods of virus purification have been described including centrifugation22, different gradient methods23, filtration24, and affinity chromatography25. Although this protocol is based on high-speed centrifugation using a sucrose-gradient method, a variety of other gradient methods have been used by others, such as iodixanol11,26, Percoll27, and Ficoll-Nycodenz23. These gradient methods separate the virus by density and require isolation of the band from the gradient, instead of the sucrose cushion where the virus is pelleted. The sucrose-gradient method offers a gentle approach to separate viral particles because it minimizes the risk of disrupting viral envelope proteins while retaining viral infectivity. Despite these advantages, the high osmolarity of the concentrated sucrose solution might dehydrate the viral particles; therefore, the iodixanol gradient method was developed to overcome this drawback. However, the iodixanol gradient method requires ultracentrifuge and collection of the virion band. Other factors that need to be considered during oHSV purification are speed and time of centrifugation and choice of the virus buffer used for long-term storage. This protocol has the limitation that the purity of oHSV is not confirmed; however, a high number of functional virus particles were found in a given purified oHSV stock by titration on Vero cells (see section 3).
oHSV forms plaques on Vero cells (Figure 4). The viral plaques can be identified by Giemsa staining, which is an easy and convenient method. Giemsa stains Vero cells, leaving the viral plaques transparent or empty that can be easily visualized (naked eye) and counted using a dissecting microscope. While overlaying the media with agarose or methylcellulose is commonly used during plaque formation (in step 3.7) to prevent the spread of the virus and secondary infections and plaque tails28, the use of human IgG to neutralize oHSV in the culture supernatant is easier and more convenient. For oHSVs expressing lacZ, plaques can be visualized by X-gal staining (Figure 4), while fluorescent microscopy is used for fluorescent protein (i.e., green fluorescent protein)-expressing oHSVs18. Additional assays to detect oHSV-infected cells include immuno-histochemical or -fluorescence with oHSV-specific antibodies29 or laser-based scanning of near-infrared fluorophore-conjugated oHSV-specific antibodies30.
There are critical measures that must be followed to achieve a good virus stock such as maintaining sterility to prevent microbial (bacteria, yeast, or mold) contamination and healthy Vero cells. As the envelope of oHSV is extremely thermosensitive20, the oHSV stock should be handled in a cryoprotectant such as 10% glycerol. Overall, this protocol can be easily employed and practiced in a laboratory setting, but may not be useful for large-scale virus production.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
Research in the Saha lab was supported in part by funds from the DOD (W81XWH-20-1-0702) and Dodge Jones Foundation-Abilene. Samuel D. Rabkin and Melissa R.M. Humphrey were partially supported by NIH (R01 CA160762).
1.7 mL centrifuge tubes | Sigma | CLS3620 | |
15 mL polypropylene centrifuge tubes | Falcon | 352097 | |
5 mL polypropylene tubes | Falcon | 352063 | |
50 mL polypropylene centrifuge tubes | Falcon | 352098 | |
6-well cell culture plates | Falcon | 353046 | |
Benzonase Nuclease | Sigma | E8263-25KU | |
Cell scraper | Fisher Scientific | 179693 | |
Dimethyl sulfoxide | Sigma | D2650-100ML | |
Dulbecco’s Modified Eagle Medium | Corning | MT-10-013-CV | |
Dulbecco’s Phosphate Buffered Saline | Corning | MT-21-031-CV | |
Fetal Bovine Serum | Hyclone | SH3007003 | |
Giemsa Stain | Sigma | G3032 | |
Glutaraldehyde | Fisher Scientific | 50-262-23 | |
Glycerol | Sigma | G5516 | |
Hank's Balanced Salt Solution (HBSS) | Corning | MT-21-021-CV | |
High-Glucose Dulbecco’s Phosphate-buffered Saline | Sigma | D4031 | |
Human immune globulin | Gamastan | NDC 13533-335-12 | |
Magnesium chloride | Fisher Chemical | M33-500 | |
Media Sterilization filter, 250 mL | Nalgene, Fisher Scientific | 09-740-25E | |
Media Sterilization filter, 500 mL | Nalgene, Fisher Scientific | 09-740-25C | |
Neutral Red solution | Sigma | N4638 | |
Paraformaldehyde | Fisher scientific | 15710S | |
Plate rocker | Fisher | 88861043 | |
Potassium Ferricyanide | Sigma | P8131 | |
Potassium Ferrocyanide | Sigma | P9387 | |
Sodium chloride | Fisher Chemical | S271-3 | |
Sorvall ST 16R Centrifuge | ThermoFisher Scientific | 75004381 | |
Sorvall ST 21R Centrifuge | ThermoFisher Scientific | 75002446 | |
Sterile Microcentrifuge Tubes with Screw Caps | Fisher Scientific | 02-681-371 | |
Sucrose | Fisher Scientific | BP220-1 | |
Syringe Filter, 0.45 PVDF | MilliporeSigma | SLHV033RS | |
Syringe Filter, 0.8 MCE | MilliporeSigma | SLAA033SS | |
Syringe filter, 5 µm PVDF | MilliporeSigma | SLSV025LS | |
T150 culture flask | Falcon | 355001 | |
Tris-HCl | MP Biomedicals LLC | 816116 | |
Ultrasonic water bath | Branson | CPX-952-116R | |
X-gal | Corning | 46-101-RF |