This protocol details the methodology for quantifying locomotor behavior and sleep in the Mexican cavefish. Previous analyses are extended to measure these behaviors in socially-housed fish. This system can be widely applied to study sleep and activity in other fish species.
Across phyla, sleep is characterized by highly conserved behavioral characteristics that include elevated arousal threshold, rebound following sleep deprivation, and consolidated periods of behavioral immobility. The Mexican cavefish, Astyanax mexicanus (A. mexicanus), is a model for studying trait evolution in response to environmental perturbation. A. mexicanus exist as in eyed surface-dwelling forms and multiple blind cave-dwelling populations that have robust morphological and behavioral differences. Sleep loss has occurred in multiple, independently-evolved cavefish populations. This protocol describes a methodology for quantifying sleep and locomotor activity in A. mexicanus cave and surface fish. A cost-effective video monitoring system allows for behavioral imaging of individually-housed larval or adult fish for periods of a week or longer. The system can be applied to fish aged 4 days post fertilization through adulthood. The approach can also be adapted for measuring the effects of social interactions on sleep by recording multiple fish in a single arena. Following behavioral recordings, data is analyzed using automated tracking software and sleep analysis is processed using customized scripts that quantify multiple sleep variables including duration, bout length, and bout number. This system can be applied to measure sleep, circadian behavior, and locomotor activity in almost any fish species including zebrafish and sticklebacks.
Sleep is highly conserved throughout the animal kingdom at the physiological, functional, and behavioral levels1,2,3. While sleep in mammalian laboratory animals is typically assessed using electroencephalograms, electrophysiological recordings are less practical in small genetically amenable model systems and thus sleep is typically measured based on behavior3,4. Behavioral characteristics associated with sleep are highly conserved throughout the animal kingdom and include increased arousal threshold, reversibility with stimulation, and prolonged behavioral quiescence5. These measures can be used to characterize sleep in animals ranging from the nematode worm, C. elegans, through humans6.
The use of behavioral quiescence to characterize sleep requires automated tracking software. With tracking software, periods of activity and immobility are determined over a number of days, and long periods of inactivity are classified as sleep7,8. In recent years, multiple tracking systems have been developed for acquiring activity data among a diversity of small genetically-amenable model systems; including worms, fruit flies and fish9,10,11. These programs are accompanied by software that allows for automated tracking of animal behavior, including both open source freeware and commercially available software7,12,13,14. These systems differ in their flexibility and allow for efficient screening and characterization of sleep phenotypes in numerous genetically amendable models.
Genetic investigation of sleep in the zebrafish, Danio rerio, has led to the identification of numerous genes and neural circuits that regulate sleep15,16. While this has provided a powerful system for investigating the neural basis of sleep in a vertebrate laboratory animal, much less is known about how sleep evolves and how natural variation contributes to sleep regulation. The Mexican cavefish, Astyanax mexicanus (A. mexicanus), have evolved dramatic differences in sleep, locomotor activity and circadian rhythms17,18. These fish exist as eyed surface fish that inhabit the rivers of Mexico and Southern Texas and at least 29 cave populations around the Sierra Del Abra region of Northeast Mexico19,20,21. Remarkably, many behavioral differences, including sleep loss, appear to have emerged independently in multiple cavefish populations14,22. Therefore, cavefish provide a model for investigating the convergent evolution of sleep, circadian, and social behaviors.
This protocol describes a system for measuring sleep and locomotor behavior in A. mexicanus larvae and adults. A custom-built infrared-based recording system allows for video recording of animals under light and dark conditions. Commercially available software can be used to measure activity and custom macros are used to quantify several aspects of inactivity and determine periods of sleep. This protocol also describes experimental modifications for tracking the activity of multiple animals within a tank, providing the ability to examine interactions between sleep and social behaviors. These systems can be applied to measure sleep, circadian behavior, and locomotor activity in additional fish species including zebrafish and sticklebacks.
NOTE: Set up systems for behavioral tracking in larvae and adults.
1. Constructing a Sleep System for Larvae
NOTE: The monitoring system for tracking larval through juvenile fish aged 4 days post fertilization (dpf) through 30 dpf A. mexicanus requires multiple pieces of equipment including infrared (IR) lighting, acrylic IR light diffusers, automated light controls (timers), computers, cameras, and secondary materials such as wiring and power controllers (Figure 1A). The following instructions will inform how to build a system to accurately track locomotor behavior to study sleep and circadian rhythms in larval A. mexicanus.
2. Sleep System for Adults
3. Recording Locomotor Activity
NOTE: All behavioral recordings are made using a standard laptop computer or desktop with a backup battery source. Due to the large file size of a 24 h recording (60-100 GB), save all recordings on external hard drives.
4. Analysis of Locomotor Activity in Individually Housed Fish Using Automated tracking Software
5. Tracking Socially Housed Fish
6. Extraction of Sleep Data from Locomotor Activity
NOTE: The behavioral definition of sleep in both larval and adult A. mexicanus is 1 min or more of quiescence. This definition was determined using arousal threshold experiments, where a greater sensory stimulus is required to initiate a behavioral response in a sleeping state (>60 s) compared to waking14,17. To account for small movements and drifting common to fish species, there are velocity thresholds applied to segregate real movement from noise or drift. These thresholds are computationally-derived by comparing correlations between distance and sleep duration to find the highest R-squared values; thereby determining the most accurate velocity for movement and sleep. For larval fish, the upper and lower limits are both 12 mm/s as there is little to no drift. For adult fish the lower limit is 2 cm/s with an upper limit of 4 cm/s to account for drift.
Larvae ages 4-30 dpf can be reliably recorded in the custom-build closed system described in Figure 1. The system includes both IR and visible lighting to allow for recordings under light and dark conditions, under various visible light conditions (Figure 1A). The videos are then analyzed using tracking software (Figure 1B,C) and post-processed using a custom sleep macro (See Supplemental Download). Larval fish from three independent cavefish populations display a significant reduction in sleep compared to surface fish (Figure 1D) and 20 dpf, and this sleep loss is consistent across developmental stages. The age of fish analyzed for sleep is often dependent on the experimental manipulation. For example, A. mexicanus do not consume food at 4 days, so experiments examining interactions between sleep and feeding would typically occur in older larvae25. Conversely, morpholinos are only effective in early fry (typically younger than 4 dpf) so this age is used to asses sleep24,26,27.
A. mexicanus can live for up to 30 years in the laboratory, but experiments using adults are typically performed in fish aged 6 months to 3 years. Fish can be recorded in a variety of tank sizes depending on the experiment and IR lighting allows for recordings during light and dark periods (Figure 2A). Individual arenas are labeled in tracking to allow for tracking of fish, and post-processing using a custom macro provides a readout of sleep (Figure 2B,C). Sleep is significantly reduced in Pachón, Molino, and Tinaja cavefish, compared to surface fish (Figure 2D). In addition, this system allows for recording multiple fish in a single arena (typically 10 gallon tanks), allowing for analysis of how social interactions affect sleep (Figure 2E,F). Social housing robustly reduces sleep in surface fish, without affecting sleep in Pachón cavefish (Figure 2G). The lack of effect in cavefish is likely due to a basement effect, where cavefish sleep little, particularly in the larger arenas used to examine social behavior.
Figure 1: Recording sleep behavior in larval and juvenile A. mexicanus. (A) Schematic of larval sleep behavior setup: Larva are placed on a platform within a light-controlled tube. Infrared and white lighting systems sit below the fish at the bottom of the tube. An IR-pass camera sits at the top of the tube and is connected to a laptop on which the video is recorded. All powered systems (lighting and laptop) are plugged in to backup power. (B) Arena settings in tracking software. Individual larvae are kept in wells in a tissue culture plate, and arenas (cyan) are made for each animal. (C) Locomotor traces of fish locomotor behavior after acquiring the data in tracking software. Red traces represent 10 s of activity in 20-day old fish. (D) Resulting sleep data from tracking software. Juvenile cavefish converge upon reduced sleep behavior compared to surface fish morphs (One-way ANOVA F(3, 116) = 76.12; Dunnett post-hoc analysis was applied to compare each cavefish population with surface fish, P < 0.001). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Adult A. mexicanus system for sleep and circadian behavior. (A) Diagram of sleep-recording system: Fish are held in tanks on a rack opposite of tracking cameras. An infrared lighting system is placed behind the fish tanks, while IR-pass cameras are attached to a laptop for recording behavior. All powered systems are plugged in to a backup battery system in case of power fluctuations. (B) Arena setup in tracking software. Individual fish are marked by creating separate arenas (cyan) to track locomotor behavior. (C) Representative locomotor tracks (red lines) of individual fish after acquiring a behavioral recording on tracking software. Traces represent 20 s of activity. (D) Total sleep duration over 24 h is significantly reduced in three distinct populations of cavefish compared to surface fish (One-way ANOVA F(3, 106) = 52.66; Dunnett post-hoc tests were applied between surface fish and each cave population, P < 0.001). (E) A single tank containing multiple fish in which one arena (orange) is made to track social interactions and sleep. (F) Locomotor traces of multiple fish after data acquisition in tracking software (each line color represents an individual fish). (G) Representative data of surface and Pachón cavefish in social sleep tracking. Surface fish significantly reduce sleep in 10 L tanks compared to 2 L arenas; Surface fish sleep is further reduced when fish are socially housed. Cavefish sleep is not significantly altered in any condition (Two-way ANOVA F(2,46) = 4.545; post hoc analysis was performed within each population to test the effect of the tank size and social state on total sleep 10 L single, P = 0.013; 10 L Social, P = 0.0003). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
This protocol describes a custom system for quantifying sleep and locomotor activity in larval and adult cavefish. Cavefish have emerged as a leading model for studying the evolution of sleep that can be used to investigate the genetic and neural basis of sleep regulation1. The critical steps in this protocol include optimization of lighting and video quality in order to assure accurate tracking that is necessary to quantify sleep. The system for acquisition and analysis described here are fully functional, as are many other systems, both commercial and custom-built, to quantify locomotion and behavior28,29,30. The previous assay examining sleep in single fish can be extended to allow for analysis of group-housed fish. A significant consideration when trouble-shooting or designing assays is the confounds social behavior may have on the sleep of an individual. For example, aggression is common in Astyanax, and aggression levels differ between surface fish and cavefish31. Optimizing the number of fish, size of the arena, and sex ratio, in order to minimize aggression will allow for reproducible measurements of sleep regulation.
A limitation of the technique, as described, is a lack of reliability following individual fish throughout the assay. Automated animal tracking will often switch animals when they come into close contact. This can be addressed by careful optimization of thresholds, or by manually correcting any switches. In addition, the system described is not a flow-through system, and therefore, water quality can become an issue after recordings lasting more than a few days. Other flow through systems have been described in zebrafish13 and these could be readily applied to the sty of Mexican cavefish.
The methodology described is significant because of its broad applicability to measure behavior in diverse fish species. Sleep has yet to be characterized in almost any marine or fresh water fish including Sticklebacks, Cichlids, and swordtails32,33,34. The versatility of this system to measure sleep in A. mexicanus and other fish models may address diverse questions about the evolution and genetic underpinnings of sleep. The hardware associated with this system is highly cost-effective, making it highly accessible and providing potential for high throughput analysis of pharmacological and ecotoxilogical analysis of sleep and locomotor activity.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported by NIGMS award GM127872 ACK, NINDS award 105072 to ERD and ACK, and NSF award 1656574 to ACK.
12V power adaptor | Environmental Lights | 24 Watt 12 VDC Power Supply | |
Acrylic dividers (adults) | TAP Plastic | Order sheets in sizes as needed | |
Adult infrared light power source | Environmnental Lights 24 Watt 12 VDC Power Supply | ||
Battery pack | CyberPower | CP850PFCLCD | |
Camera lens (adult) | Navitar Zoom 7000 | Zoom 7000 | |
Camera lens (larval) | Fujian 35mm f/1.7 | B01CHX7668 | Purchase on Amazon |
Camera lens adapter | d | 1524219 | |
Camera mount | CowboyStudio Super Clamp | B002LV7X1K | Purchase on Amazon |
Fish tank | Deep Blue Professional | ADB11006 | |
Heat sink (adult) | M-D Building products | SKU: 61085 | Cut to fit |
Heat sink (larval) | M-D Building products | SKU: 57000 | Cut to fit |
Infrared lights (adults) | Environmental Lights Infrared 850 nm 5050 LED strip | irrf850-5050-60-reel | Cut to fit |
Infrared lights (larval) | LED World | B00MO9H7H4 | Purchase on Amazon |
IR-diffusing acrylic | TAP Plastic | Order sheets in sizes as needed | |
Laptop/computer | N/A | N/A | Any laptop will work. |
LED light | Chanzon 10 High Power Led Chip 3W White (6000K-6500K/600mA-700mA/DC 3V-3.4V/3 Watt) | B06XKTRSP7 | Use with Chanzon 25pcs 1W 3W 5W LED Heat Sink (2 pin Black) Aluminum Base Plate Panel |
light timer | Century 24 Hour Plug-in Mechanical Timer Grounded | ||
Plastic wall mount for IR | Everbilt Plastic pegboard | Model # 17961 | |
Power cable | BNTECHGO 22 Gauge Silicone Wire | B01K4RPE0Y | |
Power source | Rapid LED | MOONLIGHT DRIVER (350MA) | |
Tissue culture plates | Fisherbrand | 12-well (FB012928) 24-well (FB012929) | |
Tripod Ball head | Demon DB-44 | B00TQ54CZO | Purchase on Amazon |
USB Hardrive | Seagate 3TB backup | STDT3000100 | |
USB Webcam | Microsoft LifeCam | Q2F-00014 | Purchase on Amazon |
Wall mount for camera | LDR Industries 1/2" Steel pipe | 307 12X36 | Mounted on wall with Flange and 90 degree pipe elbow. Could also use a tripod to hold camera. |