This paper details the use of fixed-potential amperometric recordings using carbon fiber electrodes and enzymatic biosensor technology to measure the release of dopamine and glutamate with high temporal resolution during natural rewarding behavior in the female hamster.
The ability to measure neurotransmitter release on a rapid time scale allows patterns of neurotransmission to be linked to specific behaviors or manipulations; a powerful tool in elucidating underlying mechanisms and circuitry. While the technique of microdialysis has been used for decades to measure nearly any analyte of interest in the brain, this technique is limited in temporal resolution. Alternatively, fast scan cyclic voltammetry is both temporally precise and extremely sensitive; however, because this technically difficult method relies on the electroactivity of the analyte of interest, the possibility to detect nonelectroactive substances (e.g., the neurotransmitter glutamate) is eliminated. This paper details the use of a turn-key system that combines fixed-potential amperometry and enzymatic biosensing to measure both electroactive and nonelectroactive neurotransmitters with temporal precision. The pairing of these two powerful techniques allows for the measurement of both tonic and phasic neurotransmission with relative ease, and permits recording of multiple neurotransmitters simultaneously. The aim of this manuscript is to demonstrate the process of measuring dopamine and glutamate neurotransmission in vivo using a naturally rewarding behavior (i.e., sexual behavior) in female hamsters, with the ultimate goal of displaying the technical feasibility of this assay for examining other behaviors and experimental paradigms.
The ability to measure neurotransmitter release in awake behaving animals allows researchers to link specific behaviors with spatial and temporal patterns of neurotransmission-a powerful tool to investigate mechanisms and circuitry underlying both natural and operant behaviors in real-time. Historically, microdialysis has been employed to measure both electrically reactive and nonreactive substances in the extracellular milieu of the brain1. This technique uses a continuous flow of an aqueous solution of similar ionic composition to the extracellular fluid, through a microdialysis probe composed of a small shaft with a tip made of a semipermeable hollow fiber membrane2. After insertion of the probe, neurotransmitters or other analytes of interest can cross the semipermeable membrane by passive diffusion before being collected at intervals for subsequent analysis by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), an analytical chemistry technique commonly utilized to separate, identify, and quantify components in a heterogeneous mixture3.
Although microdialysis is a sensitive technique that can be used to measure virtually any analyte of interest, the temporal resolution is low, with maximum sampling rates on the order of minutes to tens of minutes1,2. The invention of fast scan cyclic voltammetry (FSCV), a technique that relies on the redox potential of electroactive species, can elucidate near instantaneous concentrations of the analyte of interest in the extracellular fluid. In brief (see Robinson et al.4 for an extensive review), an electrode is applied to raise and lower the voltage in a triangular wave fashion on a fast time scale4. When the voltage is in the correct range, the compound of interest is repeatedly oxidized and reduced. This oxidization and reduction results in a movement of electrons that creates a small alternating current. Scan rates take place on the sub-second scale with oxidization and reduction of compounds occurring in microseconds. By subtracting the background current created by the probe from the resulting current, one can generate a voltage vs. current plot unique to each compound. Since the time scale of the voltage oscillations is known, these data can be used to calculate a plot of the current as a function of time. Thus, the relative concentrations of the compound may be determined as long as the number of electrons transferred in each oxidation and reduction reaction is known4.
This chemical specificity and high temporal resolution make FSCV a powerful technique for detecting changing chemical concentrations in vivo. However, despite these manifold advantages, this technique requires extensive technical expertise and expensive equipment and setup. Further, nonelectroactive neurotransmitters (e.g., glutamate) cannot be measured using this technique. Fortunately, technological advancements in the field of electrochemistry5, as well as commercialization of these inventions, has introduced a relatively simple approach to measure non-electroactive neurotransmitters in awake behaving animals without compromising temporal precision-a technique known as enzymatic biosensor technology. This technique uses enzymatic conversion of the nonelectroactive neurotransmitter of interest into two substrates, one of which is electroactive hydrogen peroxide that is detected as an amperometric oxidation current generated by an applied potential5. Commercially available biosensor probes (see Figure 1) selectively measure analytes of interest by competitively reducing the contribution of endogenous interferents. In the case of glutamate, the contribution of the common interferent ascorbic acid (AA) is competitively reduced to the measured current by co-localizing AA oxidase onto the active enzymatic surface of the sensor, converting AA to non-electroactive dihydroascorbate and water. In addition, a negatively charged Nafion polymer layer present under the enzyme layer excludes endogenous anionic compounds.
This same biosensor experimental setup can measure electroactive neurotransmitters as in FSCV, but instead it employs a fixed-potential recording6. In contrast to the oscillating voltage applied in FSCV, in a fixed-potential recording the voltage is kept at the redox potential for the analyte of interest. Although it is less chemically selective than FSCV as multiple neurotransmitters may have the same redox potential, in brain areas that overwhelmingly skew towards one neurotransmitter, the turn-key nature of this approach outweighs the lack of chemical specificity.
The ability to measure both electroactive and nonelectroactive neurotransmitter release in near real-time and link it to specific behavioral events provides an opportunity to examine converging neurotransmitter release. This manuscript details the use of this system to interrogate both dopamine and glutamate neurotransmission in response to natural reward in awake behaving hamsters. The aim of this paper is to detail the process of measuring this neurotransmitter release during sexual behavior in female hamsters, with the goal of demonstrating its feasibility for examining other behaviors and experimental paradigms.
Hamsters are an ideal model for use in electrochemical recordings
Historically, rat and mice models have been employed in the study of sexual behavior. These rodent species engage in a dynamic copulatory sequence, involving numerous female solicitation behaviors that include hopping, darting, and ear wiggling to entice the male to chase and ultimately mount the female7. The mounting by the male (with or without vaginal penetration) lasts only a few seconds, during which the female engages in her sexual behavior posture (termed lordosis) also only for a few seconds before resuming active solicitation behaviors. This pattern of behavior, composed of high levels of activity interspersed with brief periods of immobility, is problematic for measuring neurotransmission in behaving animals. First, there can be movement artifacts in the amperometric recordings that are unrelated to neural activity. Second, the locomotion is associated with the release of particular neurotransmitters in certain brain regions. For example, dopamine release has been coupled to locomotor activity in the dorsal and ventral striatum8,9, a finding that formed the basis for microdialysis measurements of dopamine following psychostimulant administration10. Because the female-typical solicitation behaviors in most rodents involve high levels of locomotor activity, and are represented by the bulk of a 10 minute sexual behavior test, this makes it difficult to ascribe changes in neurotransmission to the explicit components of sexual behavior that collectively last only minutes.
To analyze the neurochemical profile of female sexual behavior, this lab sought out a species in which there is minimal locomotor activity accompanying sexual behavior. The copulatory sequence in Syrian hamsters (Mesocricetus auratus) is ideal for neurochemical recordings due to the lack of solicitation behaviors typically seen in rats and mice11. As a consequence, female hamsters will enter and maintain the lordosis posture for upwards of 9 minutes out of a 10 minute testing session12. With the lack of extraneous locomotor movements by the female, in vivo electrochemical recordings that can be associated with components of sexual interactions with the male can be obtained.
Copulatory bouts in hamsters
After the introduction of a male stimulus animal into the testing chamber, the male will initially engage in anogenital investigation (AI) of the female before mounting her (Figure 2A). In order for the male to mount, the female must assume a receptive sexual posture known as lordosis, in which she arches her back and deflects her tail so that the mounting male can gain penile access to her vagina. The male will mount the female, clasping her hindquarters with both paws (Figure 2B), and begin thrusting in an attempt to gain penile intromission (Figure 2C). The male will mount the female (without insertion) as well as intromit a number of times before eventually achieving ejaculation. This sequence of mounts and intromissions leading to ejaculation is termed a "copulatory bout". Males will have several copulatory bouts within a single session.
All procedures described here were approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC) of The University of Minnesota, and are in accordance with The Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals13.
1. Animals and Cannulation Surgery
2. Biosensor and Carbon Fiber Testing
3. Sacrifice and Perfusion
4. Behavioral Coding
5. Example Data Analysis
Note: The use of fixed-potential carbon fiber and enzymatic recordings for dopamine and glutamate, respectively, allows for the ability to measure both tonic and phasic patterns of electrochemical release. This lab uses a free, commercial acquisition system and software to record and convert recorded signals from analog to digital (bias 0.600 V, sampling rate = 1 Hz).
Using the electrochemical and behavioral coding methodology described above, this lab has begun to characterize both tonic and phasic fluctuations in both dopamine and glutamate during in vivo recordings of sexual behavior. Due to the temporally-precise manner of this methodology, we can more accurately characterize neurotransmission during sexual behavior; as well as ascribe specific changes in release patterns to corresponding tonic changes during mating bouts, and corresponding transient fluctuations during the female's receipt of individual copulatory behaviors (e.g., intromission, ejaculation) from the mounting male.
Specifically, we used this methodology to focus on measuring the release patterns of dopamine and glutamate in the NAc of separate animals. The NAc is a critical region involved in reward processing22 and has been described as an integral region in the reward aspects of sexual behavior23.
We observed that during sexual behavior, females demonstrate a tonic increase in dopaminergic levels in the NAc core during mating bouts (Figure 5). While these tonic changes are shown for all mating bouts, the methodology described above can measure tonic changes between each mating bout, and thus increase the temporal identification of overall changes to tonic levels of neurotransmitter release throughout the entire session. Further, this described methodology can pinpoint phasic changes and temporally map the behaviors likely associated with these phasic neurotransmitter fluctuations. Specifically, these preliminary results suggest that during mating bouts, dopaminergic transients in the NAc arise during vaginal insertion (intromission) by the male (Figure 6). Furthermore, this association with intromission is specific, with negligible dopaminergic responses to other copulatory behaviors, such as the AI.
A similar pattern has been observed in other animals with regard to glutamate release, with rapid transients that correspond to individual intromissions in the dorsal NAc core during a copulatory bout (Figure 7). This pattern is region specific, with no discernable signal occurring in the NAc shell or medial caudate of other animals.
Figure 1: Enzymatic Biosensor Technology.
Standard fabrication of commercially available enzymatic biosensor probes that detect neurotransmitters via enzyme-mediated processing (left image). In the case of glutamatergic sensors, glutamate oxidase is employed in the enzymatic layer (right image) to convert the nonelectroactive neurotransmitter to electroactive hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) that is detected by oxidation at the platinum-iridium (Pt-Ir) electrode. Ascorbic acid (AA), a common interferent that is oxidized at the same potential, is excluded via an addition of AA oxidase at the enzymatic layer that converts the interferent to nonelectroactive water. Other negative electroactive interferents present in the brain are excluded via a passive selective membrane. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Components of a Hamster Mating Bout.
In hamsters, a mating bout consists of a sequence of copulatory behaviors, during which the female remains in the immobile lordosis posture while the male anogenitally investigates (A), mounts (B), and achieves intromission (C). Note an intromission is behaviorally distinguishable from mounting as the male pulls his upper limbs towards his body, thrusts his pelvis forward, and curls his tail upwards, indicating penetration. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Skull Cap Construction.
Guide cannulae, bone screws, and dental acrylic are used in the construction of a skull cap to allow insertion of carbon fiber or enzymatic probe (see15 for stepwise details). This figure depicts a single cannula implant over the right NAc for an enzymatic sensor (no implanted reference electrode) and plastic head mount for sensor stability. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Glutamate Biosensor Calibration.
The sensitivity of each biosensor to glutamate is tested in vitro before experimental recording by 10 µm additions of glutamate (green) at 37 °C (since enzymatic activity is influenced by temperature). Each sensor is confirmed to be non-responsive to ascorbic acid (AA; red) or dopamine (DA; blue). This calibration allows for the conversion of changes in the amperometric signal seen during experimental recording to changes in the glutamate concentration. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: Tonic Increases in Dopamine During a Mating Bout.
A. Stylized example of premating bout lordosis signal vs. mating bout lordosis signal. To measure tonic dopamine release, the amperometric responses to dopamine levels during lordosis before a mating bout (MB) were compared to those during a MB. Gray boxes indicate lordosis before a MB. Blue boxes indicate lordosis during a MB. B. Representative quantification from one animal comparing the mean voltage between preMB lordosis and MB lordosis. Error bars indicate standard error of the mean (SEM), and asterisk indicates significant difference (p-value < 0.05). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6: Representative Dopamine Trace.
Phasic release of dopamine is time-locked to intromissions from the male in the dorsal NAc core. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 7: Representative Glutamate Trace.
Glutamate transients correspond to individual intromissions from the male in the dorsal NAc core during an extended sexual experience. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Although relatively straightforward, some issues can arise when employing this technique. First, the stereotaxic placement of the probes must be precise: unlike microdialysis that samples a wider radius of the extracellular milieu surrounding the probe, this technique only allows the measurement of a neurotransmitter that comes into direct contact with the probe. Second, in the case of the carbon fiber recording, due to the small width of fiber, breakage can occur, and the probe must be inserted with deliberate care. In the case of glutamatergic biosensors, enzymatic degradation can occur if the probe is not used within the guaranteed time-frame of 3-weeks. Fortunately, all of these issues are addressable, and can be eliminated with proper care and attention to detail.
A potentially problematic caveat arises in the specificity of fixed-potential carbon fiber recordings. Because the applied potential for dopamine coincides with other monoamines, such as norepinephrine, if the recordings are made in areas that release both neurotransmitters, than this lack of chemical specificity may limit the interpretation of the results. In the NAc this does not pose a major problem, with dopamine being the primary catecholamine transmitter24. Because roughly 98% of the cells in NAc are medium spiny neurons that respond to dopaminergic neurotransmission24, the signal is biased towards detection of dopamine and facilitates the use of this more turn-key approach.
Another benefit of this enzymatic biosensor and fixed-potential carbon fiber recording system is that dual-probe recordings can be performed, so that both electroactive and nonelectroactive neurotransmitters such as dopamine and glutamate can be measured in the same animal concurrently. Although the data presented here come from recordings in separate animals, these techniques can be employed concurrently such that one can evaluate the convergence of neurotransmission in multiple brain regions or in the same region bilaterally. Combination of recordings within the same animal, or comparison of recordings across animals as shown here, are both powerful tools in elucidating mechanisms behind network connections and signaling.
In sum, this paper demonstrates the powerful techniques of enzymatic biosensing and fixed- potential recording to measure multiple electroactive and nonelectroactive neurotransmitters utilizing a single experimental setup. Although the data presented here come from individual neurotransmitter recordings across multiple animals, this system provides the capability to record from up to 4 sensors in one animal concurrently15. The sample results presented collectively provide insight into rapid neurotransmission in the female hamster resulting from specific patterns of copulatory stimulation from the male. Further, these experiments demonstrate time-locked responses of dopaminergic and glutamatergic transients in the NAc core of the female to intromission from the male, suggesting that this release may be responsible for encoding distinct rewarding properties of sexual behavior. Our goal is to continue utilizing the mating pattern in female Syrian hamsters to develop a more comprehensive picture of the relation of in vivo dopamine and glutamate release and the underlying circuitry to individual components of copulatory stimuli from the male. We believe that the capability to characterize the patterns of these neurotransmitters is not only beneficial from a basic science perspective23, but also in elucidating potential therapeutic approaches for pathological forms of reward behavior such as drug addiction25.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
The authors would like to thank undergraduate Daniel Korus for his help running the Matlab code and undergraduate Alex Boettcher for his assistance in running the behavioral experiments. This project is supported by NSF IOS 1256799 to R.L.M., and by the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health under Award Number T32DA007234.
Nembutal | Oak Pharmaceuticals Inc. | 76478-501-50 | Pentobarbital sodium injection, USP. This lab uses 8.5mg/100g body weight, injected intraperotineally. |
Loxicom analgesic | Norbrook Laboratories | 6451603670 | NSAID antinflammatory and analgesic used for post-operative pain control. Generic: meloxicam. |
Enroflox antibiotic | Norbrook Laboratories | 5552915411 | Fluoroquinolone antibiotic for post-operative infection prevention. Generic: Enrofloxacin. |
Beuthanasia-D | Merck Animal Health | 00061047305 | Pentobarbital Sodium, Phenytoin Sodium euthanasia agent. |
Bone screws | Pinnacle Technologies, Inc. | 8111-16 | 1/8" bone screw (Pkg. of 16) used to affix skull cap to skull. |
Dental acrylic (Bosworth Duz-All) | Bosworth | 166261C | Self curing dental acrylic is used in construction of a skull cap to affix cannula and head mount to skull. |
Hardware biosensor setup | Pinnacle Technologies, Inc. | 8400-K2 | Pinnacle offers complete hardware kits for new users of our tethered biosensor system for rats. Kits include a commutator, preamplifier, and data conditioning and acquisition system |
Base video computer package | Pinnacle Technologies, Inc. | 9000-K1 | The base computer package includes a preconfigured computer with ample hard disk storage, a high-definition monitor, a keyboard and mouse, an uninterruptible power supply, and all necessary cables. |
Video EQ700 EverFocus camera package | Pinnacle Technologies, Inc. | 9000-K10 | EQ700 night vision capable box camera with independent IR source was obtained as part of Pinnacle video computer package. Dome camera (9000-K9) and HD camera (9000-K11) options are also available. |
Sirenia Acquisition software | Pinnacle Technologies, Inc. | Free–available to download from pinnaclet.com | Sirenia Acquisition provides a single platform for recording data from any Pinnacle hardware system. The software features synchronization of all data streams, user-configurable settings, data consolidation, and multiple export options. In addition, the software includes basic review and analysis modules for biosensor recordings. Sirenia delivers free ll-in-one software that is ideal for data acquisition and review. |
Tethered rat in vitro calibration kit | Pinnacle Technologies, Inc. | 7000-K2-T-BAS | In order to relate the current changes measured by a biosensor to actual changes in analyte concentration, it is necessary to calibrate the biosensor prior to implantation into the animal. The process also confirms the integrity and selectivity of the sensors. Calibration kit includes 20 mL jacketed beaker (#7058), 1/2" by 1/8" magnetic stir bar (#7059), right angle clamp (#7056), 2 prong single-adjustment clamp (#7055), 4-channel calibration preamplifer (#7053), and calibration holder (#7051). |
Stir plate | Corning | 6795-410D | Corning digital Stirrer, 5" x 7", 120 VAC used to spin magnetic stirrer in jacketed beaker during in vitro calibration of glutamate biosensors. |
Water bath capable of closed loop circulation | PolyScience | 8006A11B | PolyScience 8006A11B 6L Standard Digital Heated Circulating Bath, 120VAC water bath was used with plastic tubing to heat jacketed beaker to physiological temperature. |
Carbon fiber sensor with BASi rat cannulae | Pinnacle Technology, Inc. | 7002-CFS | Carbon fiber electrode used for recording dopamine neurotransmission. |
Ag/AgCl reference electrode | Pinnacle Technology, Inc. | 7065 | Necessary for carbon fiber recordings. |
Glutamate biosensors | Pinnacle Technology, Inc. | 7001 | Enzymatic biosensor probe used for recording glutamatergic neurotransmission. |
BASi guide cannulae | Pinnacle Technologies, Inc. | 7030 | Guide cannulae implanted into brain region of interest to guide probe. |
BASi cannula plastic headpiece for rats | Pinnacle Technologies, Inc. | 7011 | Headmount stabilizes probe and attaches to potentiostat. |