To assess the pulmonary diffusion and vasculature responses to exercise, we describe the multiple-inspired oxygen diffusion capacity technique to determine capillary blood volume and membrane diffusing capacity, as well as agitated saline contrast echocardiography to assess the recruitment of intrapulmonary arteriovenous anastomoses.
Exercise is a stress to the pulmonary vasculature. With incremental exercise, the pulmonary diffusing capacity (DLCO) must increase to meet the increased oxygen demand; otherwise, a diffusion limitation may occur. The increase in DLCO with exercise is due to increased capillary blood volume (Vc) and membrane diffusing capacity (Dm). Vc and Dm increase secondary to the recruitment and distension of pulmonary capillaries, increasing the surface area for gas exchange and decreasing pulmonary vascular resistance, thereby attenuating the increase in pulmonary arterial pressure. At the same time, the recruitment of intrapulmonary arteriovenous anastomoses (IPAVA) during exercise may contribute to gas exchange impairment and/or prevent large increases in pulmonary artery pressure.
We describe two techniques to evaluate pulmonary diffusion and circulation at rest and during exercise. The first technique uses multiple-fraction of inspired oxygen (FIO2) DLCO breath holds to determine Vc and Dm at rest and during exercise. Additionally, echocardiography with intravenous agitated saline contrast is used to assess IPAVAs recruitment.
Representative data showed that the DLCO, Vc, and Dm increased with exercise intensity. Echocardiographic data showed no IPAVA recruitment at rest, while contrast bubbles were seen in the left ventricle with exercise, suggesting exercise-induced IPAVA recruitment.
The evaluation of pulmonary capillary blood volume, membrane diffusing capacity, and IPAVA recruitment using echocardiographic methods is useful to characterize the ability of the lung vasculature to adapt to the stress of exercise in health as well as in diseased groups, such as those with pulmonary arterial hypertension and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.
During exercise, cardiac output can increase up to six-fold above resting values1. Given that the lungs are the only organ to receive 100% of the cardiac output, exercise presents a considerable stress to the pulmonary system. With incremental exercise, pulmonary diffusing capacity (DLCO) must increase to meet the increased oxygen demand2. From rest to peak exercise, DLCO can increase to up to 150% of resting values without reaching an upper limit with respect to cardiac output3,4,5. The increase in diffusing capacity occurs as a result of increases in membrane diffusing capacity (Dm) and capillary blood volume (Vc), secondary to the recruitment and distension of pulmonary capillaries6.
Roughton and Forster (1957) developed a technique to partition Dm and Vc7 by modulating the fraction of inspired oxygen (FIO2) during a standard diffusion capacity for carbon monoxide test (DLCO). Oxygen and carbon monoxide (CO) competitively bind to heme sites on hemoglobin, such that increasing FIO2 will decrease the DLCO8,9. By modulating the FIO2 during a standard DLCO maneuver, this relationship can be exploited to measure Vc and Dm7. We have recently adapted this technique to be used during exercise5. Similar to previous work, we have found that DLCO continuously increases up to peak exercise secondarily to increases in both Vc and Dm5. Interestingly, we have found that in endurance-trained athletes who have a greater oxygen consumption and thus a greater need for diffusing capacity, there is an increase in the DLCO at peak exercise, secondary to an increased Dm, and not Vc, suggesting a potential adaptation in the pulmonary membrane of the athlete5.
The increases in Vc and Dm during exercise are accomplished by an increase in pulmonary artery pressure, which results in the recruitment and distension of pulmonary capillaries previously hypo-perfused at rest4,10. This results in an increase in the cross-sectional area of the pulmonary capillary network, thereby decreasing pulmonary vascular resistance and attenuating the increase in pulmonary artery pressure.
Studies using agitated saline contrast echocardiography have shown evidence of intrapulmonary arteriovenous anastomoses (IPAVA) recruitment during exercise11,12,13,14. The significance of IPAVA recruitment is not yet clear, and while some studies suggest that they may contribute to gas exchange impairment12,14 and may serve to unload the right ventricle11,12, the topic remains controversial15,16. Further, while the exact mechanism of IPAVA recruitment is not known, we have found that increasing cardiac output, as well as exogenous dopamine, causes IPAVA recruitment at rest17. An acutely-increasing pulmonary artery pressure18 or dopamine blockade does not appear to significantly affect IPAVA recruitment during exercise11. There is speculation that these larger-diameter IPAVA vessels may help to protect the pulmonary capillaries from the large increases in pulmonary artery pressure by reducing pulmonary vascular resistance12,17,19,20,21.
When combined with the evaluation of Vc and Dm, agitated saline contrast echocardiography is a valuable tool to examine the adaptation of the pulmonary circulation to the stress of exercise22,23.
This protocol follows the guidelines of the human research ethics board at the University of Alberta and conforms to the standards set by the latest revision of the Declaration of Helsinki.
1. Graded Exercise Test (VO2peak)
2. Multiple Fraction of Inspired Oxygen (FIO2 ) Diffusing Capacity (DLCO ) Method7
3. Calculating Pulmonary Capillary Blood Volume and Membrane Diffusing Capacity
Figure 2: Representative Graph of 1/DLCO versus 1/θCO at Peak Exercise. The relationship between 1/DLCO and 1/θCO is plotted for three breath holds at the various FIO2 (21%, 40%, and 60%). The calculation of Vc and Dm are derived from the regression equation for the relationship above. The inverse of the slope (1/0.00796) of the line gives the value for Vc (125.5 mL), and the inverse of the y-intercept (1/0.00869) gives the value for Dm (115.0 mL·min-1·mmHg-1). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
4. Intrapulmonary Arteriovenous Anastomosis Recruitment
Figure 3: Agitated Saline Contrast Setup. An IV catheter is placed in the antecubital space and is connected to a three-way stopcock via a 6-in extension. Two 10 mL syringes are attached to the stopcock to create the contrast solution, which contains 10 mL of saline and 0.5 mL of room air. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Representative Images for IPAVA Scoring. The scale is 5 cm (solid white line). (A) Pre contrast injection. (B) IPAVA score = 0. (C) IPAVA score = 1. (D) IPAVA score = 3. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
The effect of increasing exercise intensity on oxygen consumption, diffusing capacity, pulmonary capillary blood volume, membrane diffusing capacity, and IPAVA score is shown in Table 1. VO2, DLCO, Vc, and Dm increase in response to increasing power output.
Figure 2 shows a representative calculation of Vc and Dm using the multiple FIO2-DLCO technique during exercise. DLCO decreases with increasing FIO2, and this relationship is exploited to partition Vc and Dm. Calculating the inverse of the slope of 1/DLCO versus 1/θCO results in the Vc, and the inverse of the y-intercept yields the value for the Dm. As expected, both the Vc and Dm increase during exercise compared to resting values.
The results show that these techniques can be used to assess the pulmonary vasculature response during exercise. The multiple-FIO2 DLCO and agitated saline contrast echocardiography method provides investigators with more insight into the contributions of pulmonary capillary and membrane recruitment to the overall diffusion capacity and could supplement traditional pulmonary function testing in the clinical setting. Failure to increase Vc or Dm during exercise would lead to a diffusion limitation and hypoxemia. For example, a low DLCO secondary to a low Vc would indicate changes to the pulmonary capillaries; similarly, a decreased Dm would indicate changes to the pulmonary membrane.
Figure 4 shows representative tracings of four-chamber contrast echocardiographs. With increasing exercise intensity, the IPAVA score increases from 0 (i.e., no evidence of IPAVAs) at rest to 3 at the highest exercise intensity (Table 1). Previous work has shown that exercise increases the IPAVA score11,12,14, but there is no consensus as to how these IPAVAs are recruited. There is evidence that IPAVAs can be recruited pharmacologically at rest with dopamine17,28, as well as by increasing cardiac output with dobutamine17,28 and epinephrine28. Inotropes such as dopamine and epinephrine are of particular interest, as they increase endogenously during exercise29. Furthermore, there is some evidence that IPAVA recruitment may be important to exercise hemodynamics, in that the absence of IPAVAs appears to result in greater pulmonary artery pressure, decreased cardiac output, and decreased peak power output12. Thus, this technique may be used in studies examining individuals with pulmonary artery hypertension.
Figure 1: Multiple FIO2 DLCO Setup. (A) Setup overview. (B) Compressed-gas cylinders containing 21%, 40%, and 60% O2 with 0.3% CO, 0.3% methane, and balance nitrogen, as well as a supplemental oxygen compressed-gas cylinder. (C) Three-way valve selector for the three FIO2 DLCO tanks. (D) Valve switch for three-way valves in the series for the selection of FIO2 for pre-breathing. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Table 1: Representative Data for One Subject at Rest and During Exercise at 30, 50, 70, and 90% of the VO2peak. VO2, volume of oxygen consumption relative to body mass; DLCO, diffusing capacity for carbon monoxide; Vc, pulmonary capillary blood volume; Dm, membrane diffusing capacity; IPAVA score, scoring of contrast appearance in the left ventricle after five cardiac cycles. Data modified from Tedjasaputra et al. 2016.
This method enables the evaluation of the pulmonary diffusing capacity and intrapulmonary arteriovenous anastomosis recruitment during exercise.
Critical steps within the protocol
Although the DLCO breath hold is relatively simple at rest, breath holding during exercise presents a unique challenge to the subject, as it is counter-intuitive, and subjects have a high drive to breathe during exercise. Thus, a good-quality determination of Vc and Dm relies on the rapport and clear communication between the tester and the subject. The tester's technical ability can be quantified with the variability of the alveolar volume (± 5% of previous trials) and a breath-hold time (BHT) of 6.0 ± 0.3 s.
Modifications and troubleshooting
At the conclusion of a Vc/Dm measurement, the tester should quickly graph the three DLCO maneuvers to determine the best-fit line of the data points; the DLCO measured with 21% FIO2 should always be greater than that with 40%, which should be greater than that with 60%. If not, it is recommended to check if the valve switch corresponds to the correct testing gas. Similarly, check that the pre-breathing bags are filled with the correct FIO2 gas corresponding to the testing gas (Figure 1B-1D). Caution should be taken when testing a participant who is a smoker, as elevated COHb levels may underestimate DLco.
For the IPAVA recruitment assessment, the position of the subject is critical to ensure high-quality image acquisition. It is possible to replace the upright cycle ergometer with a recumbent cycle ergometer to minimize the movement of the subject. However, recumbent cycle exercise will elicit a different metabolic response for a given work rate, and thus the graded exercise test should be repeated on the recumbent cycle ergometer. Scanning of the upper chest may be uncomfortable to some women; in this case, a female sonographer is recommended. Finally, the recommended exercise protocol is designed for a young, healthy individual; accordingly, the exercise protocol can be modified for a different target population.
Limitations of the technique
The principal limitations of the multiple FIO2 DLCO technique are the skill of the tester and the ability of the subject to follow commands and to remain calm during the breath hold, as Valsalva or Müllerian maneuvers will affect the measurements. Secondly, the number of breath holds in one session should be limited to 12, due to an increase in CO backpressure, which may affect the Vc and Dm measurement5,30 and pose a health risk to the subject. Depending on the research design, it may be necessary to complete the testing across multiple sessions to allow for the clearance of CO and to limit participant fatigue. With good participant coaching and good technical ability, we have determined a satisfactory coefficient of variation between trials for DLco, Vc, and Dm to be 7%, 8%, and 15%, respectively.
The multiple FIO2 DLCO technique assumes that the alveolar O2 is the same as the capillary O2, and thus, caution should be exercised when interpreting the data in individuals with known gas exchange impairment.
Agitated saline contrast echocardiographic imaging is limited by the technical ability of the sonographer and the ability of the subject to minimize thoracic movement while exercising. It is also critical that the interpreter of the images be familiar with the scale for scoring IPAVA recruitment according to established procedures (Figure 4)27. The significance of a positive saline contrast echocardiography during exercise remains a topic of debate15,16, and there is some discussion that a positive agitated saline contrast in the left ventricle may be secondary to capillary distention, and not IPAVA recruitment. Ongoing work is attempting to resolve this issue.
Significance of the technique with respect to existing/alternative methods
By utilizing these physiological techniques, it is possible to assess the pulmonary vasculature during exercise in a variety of conditions, including in health, in disease, and in drug interventions. Although the quality relies with the ability of the tester, these skills are easily and quickly acquired with proper mentorship and training. The multiple FIO2 DLCO method is considered the "gold standard" in the measurement of Dm and Vc31. While these measures are not calculated clinically, the values could be used to determine the mechanisms for hypoxemia and exercise intolerance, to predict patient outcomes, and to further characterize diagnosis31,32. Likewise, the agitated saline echocardiography technique is the most widely-used method in determining the recruitment of IPAVAs.
Future applications or directions after mastering this technique
These techniques are applicable for use in a range of experimental conditions and interventions. We demonstrate these techniques during exercise, but they can easily be modified to measure pulmonary vascular responses during a drug infusion, such as dobutamine or dopamine, inotropes known to increase cardiac output17. Furthermore, it is possible to use these techniques in clinical populations, such as in those with heart failure34 or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), in which the DLCO is lower compared to age-matched control subjects35.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
Funding was provided by the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada and The Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada.
Metabolic Measurement System | SensorMedics Inc. | Encore 299 Vmax | |
Cycle Ergometer | Ergoline | Ergoselect II 1200 | |
60L Douglas Bags | Hans Rudolph | 6100 Series | |
Two-way T Valve | Hans Rudolph | 2700 Series | |
Hemoglobin Measurement System | HemoCue | Hb 201+ | |
22-gauge Intravenous Catheter | BD | Insyte-W | |
Ultrasound | Vivid Q | ECHOpac | |
Compressed gas 21% O2, 0.3% CO, 0.3% CH4, balance nitrogen | Praxair | ||
Compressed gas 40% O2, 0.3% CO, 0.3% CH4, balance nitrogen | Praxair | ||
Compressed gas 60% O2, 0.3% CO, 0.3% CH4, balance nitrogen | Praxair | ||
Nose-clip | Vacu-Med | snuffer #1008 |