Here we describe a method to visualize the oncogenic bacterial organelle known as the Cag Type IV Secretion System (Cag-T4SS). We find that the Cag-T4SS is differentially produced on the surface of H. pylori in response to varying conditions of iron availability.
Helicobacter pylori is a helical-shaped, gram negative bacterium that colonizes the human gastric niche of half of the human population1,2. H. pylori is the primary cause of gastric cancer, the second leading cause of cancer-related deaths worldwide3. One virulence factor that has been associated with increased risk of gastric disease is the Cag-pathogenicity island, a 40-kb region within the chromosome of H. pylori that encodes a type IV secretion system and the cognate effector molecule, CagA4,5. The Cag-T4SS is responsible for translocating CagA and peptidoglycan into host epithelial cells5,6. The activity of the Cag-T4SS results in numerous changes in host cell biology including upregulation of cytokine expression, activation of proinflammatory pathways, cytoskeletal remodeling, and induction of oncogenic cell-signaling networks5-8. The Cag-T4SS is a macromolecular machine comprised of sub-assembly components spanning the inner and outer membrane and extending outward from the cell into the extracellular space. The extracellular portion of the Cag-T4SS is referred to as the “pilus”5. Numerous studies have demonstrated that the Cag-T4SS pili are formed at the host-pathogen interface9,10. However, the environmental features that regulate the biogenesis of this important organelle remain largely obscure. Recently, we reported that conditions of low iron availability increased the Cag-T4SS activity and pilus biogenesis. Here we present an optimized protocol to grow H. pylori in varying conditions of iron availability prior to co-culture with human gastric epithelial cells. Further, we present the comprehensive protocol for visualization of the hyper-piliated phenotype exhibited in iron restricted conditions by high resolution scanning electron microscopy analyses.
H. pylori infection is a significant risk factor for gastric cancer1. However, disease outcomes vary and depend on numerous factors such as host genetics, genetic diversity of H. pylori strains, and environmental elements such as host diet11. Previous reports have established that a correlation exists between H. pylori infection, iron deficiency (as measured by decreased blood ferritin and hemoglobin concentrations), and increased proinflammatory cytokine production, including IL-8 secretion, which ultimately leads to increased gastric disease progression12. Acute H. pylori infection is also associated with hypochlorhydria which impairs the host’s ability to absorb nutrient iron, and ultimately leads to changes in iron homeostasis13. These clinical findings suggest that iron availability within the gastic niche could be an important factor in disease outcome. In fact, animal models of H. pylori infection have demonstrated that low dietary iron consumption exacerbates gastric disease14. The reduced iron levels in these animals necessitate that H. pylori induce an iron-acquisition response in order to obtain the iron needed for bacterial replication. H. pylori has the capacity to perturb iron trafficking within host cells to facilitate bacterial replication in a CagA-dependent fashion15. Interestingly, the cag-pathogenicity island has been shown to be regulated by the iron-responsive transcription factor Fur16,17. Furthermore, Cag+ strains are associated with increased inflammation and gastric diseases such as cancer1. These findings support a model whereby H. pylori alters Cag-T4SS expression in an effort to obtain iron from host cells that reside in an iron deplete environment resulting in exacerbated disease outcomes.
Two factors that increase inflammation and morbidity are Cag expression and low dietary iron intake. These facts support the hypothesis that reduced iron availability increases the production of Cag-T4SS pili at the host pathogen interface resulting in worse gastric disease11-14. The goal of the method provided in this manuscript is to establish the role of the micronutrient iron in the regulation of the Cag-T4SS pilus biogenesis. In previous work, we utilized two approaches to observe an iron-dependent increase in Cag-T4SS expression. First, output strains from animals maintained on high and low iron diets were analyzed and revealed that low-iron diet output strains produced more Cag-T4SS pili than high-iron diet strains14. Second, growing the H. pylori 7.13 strain in vitro in iron replete conditions resulted in reduced pili formation while cells grown in the presence of an iron chelator produced significantly more pili.
We have continued to investigate the iron-dependent regulation of Cag-T4SS pili phenotype and offer the following optimized protocol and representative results performed with an additional Helicobacter pylori strain, PMSS1. The rationale behind the development of this technique was to correlate increased Cag-T4SS activity in conditions of iron-limitation with increased Cag-T4SS pilus formation. The broader implication and use of this technique will provide optimized culture conditions that result in elevated production of the Cag-T4SS pili. This assay will be useful to researchers seeking to determine the composition and architecture of the Cag-T4SS by enriching for this important bacterial surface feature. The sample preparation and visualization by field-emission gun electron microscopy has numerous advantages over alternative techniques such as light-microscopy methods to visualize the Cag-T4SS and will be appropriate to investigators interested in studying the regulation of this organelle10.
1. H. pylori Growth in Various Conditions of Iron Availability and Co-culture with Human Gastric Epithelial Cells
2. SEM Sample Preparation to Visualize H. pylori Cag-T4SS Pili
3. Imaging Parameters for High Resolution SEM Analyses
4. Statistical Analyses to Evaluate Pili Quantifications
5. Optional: Evaluation of IL-8 Secretion to Correlate with Pilus Production
In this report, we have demonstrated that conditions of varying iron availability have the capacity to modulate H. pylori Cag-T4SS pilus biogenesis at the host pathogen interface. When cultured in medium alone, H. pylori forms an average of 3 pili/cell. When H. pylori is grown in iron deplete conditions (using the synthetic chelator dipyridyl) that are sub-inhibitory to bacterial growth (Figure 1), the bacteria produce numerous Cag-T4SS pili (~7 pili/cell) when co-cultured with human gastric cells (Figure 2). Conversely, when an exogenous source of nutrient iron is present, the formation of Cag-T4SS pili is repressed (less than 1 pilus/cell in FE sample, less than 1 pilus/cell in FE+DIP sample) (Figure 2). Quantification of the pili at the host-pathogen interface reveals that in conditions of iron restriction, H. pylori exhibits an 2-fold increase in Cag-T4SS pili (p<0.0001) and the percent piliated cells increases by 11% (p<0.05) compared to cells grown in medium alone (Figure 3). Interestingly, the activity of the Cag-T4SS, as measured by host IL-8 secretion, is enhanced 107% under conditions of iron restriction and repressed 49% under conditions of excess iron availability compared to medium alone (p=0.03, and p<0.001, respectively) a result that supports the SEM data. However, pili dimensions remain consistent among all conditions of iron availability (Figure 4). Furthermore, iron availability does not change the biogenesis of pili on the surface of a cagE mutant, nor does it change this isogenic derivative’s ability to induce an IL-8 response from host cells, supporting the hypothesis that the structures demonstrated are, in fact, Cag-T4SS and not an additional unrelated surface feature.
Figure 1: Bacterial viability determined in various conditions of iron availability. H. pylori was cultured in modified brucella broth alone (Medium Alone), or supplemented with 100 µM FeCl3 (FE), 200 µM dipyridyl (DIP), or 200 µM dipyridyl plus 250 µM FeCl3 (FE+DIP). Bacteria were diluted serially and plated onto bacteriological medium prior to incubation for 2 days at 37 °C in the presence of 5% CO2. Colonies were counted and colony forming units/mL (Cfu/ml) were calculated. Bars indicate mean of three independent experiments +/- SEM. Treatment with DIP, FE, or FE+DIP does not significantly alter bacterial viability.
Figure 2: High resolution scanning electron microscopy analyses of H. pylori Cag-T4SS pili. Bacteria were grown in A) medium alone, B) medium supplemented with 100 µM FeCl3, C) medium supplemented with 200 µM dipyridyl, or D) medium supplemented with 200 µM dipyridyl plus 250 µM FeCl3 prior to co-culture with AGS human gastric cells. Arrows indicate Cag-T4SS pili formed at the host-pathogen interface. Samples were analyzed by high-resolution scanning electron microscopy to evaluate Cag-T4SS biogenesis. Conditions of low iron availability increase the prevalence of Cag-T4SS pilus formation, while conditions of excess available nutrient iron repress Cag-T4SS pilus formation.
Figure 3: Quantification of pili/cell and percent piliated cells cultured in various conditions of iron availability. Bacteria were grown in modified brucella broth alone (Medium Alone), or medium supplemented with 100 µM FeCl3 (FE), 200 µM dipyridyl (DIP), or 200 µM dipyridyl plus 250 µM FeCl3 (FE+DIP) prior to co-culture with human gastric epithelial cells. Samples were analyzed by high-resolution scanning electron microscopy and pili were enumerated using ImageJ software. A) Scatterplot of pili per cell (*p<0.0001 compared to medium alone) and B) Bar graph depicting percent of piliated cells (*p<0.05 compared to medium alone) derived from 60-112 cells per culture condition derived from 3 separate biological experiments.
Figure 4: Pilus dimensions measured from cells cultured in various conditions of iron availability. Bacteria were grown in modified brucella broth alone (Medium Alone), or medium supplemented with 100 µM FeCl3 (FE), 200 µM dipyridyl (DIP), or 200 µM dipyridyl plus 250 µM FeCl3 (FE+DIP) prior to co-culture with human gastric epithelial cells. Samples were analyzed by high-resolution scanning electron microscopy and pili dimensions were measured using ImageJ software. A) Pilus width is an average of 13.1+/- 2.4 nm among all conditions. B) Pilus length is an average of 75.8 +/- 16.0 nm among all conditions. No significant difference in pilus dimensions are seen in the various conditions of iron availability.
Supplemental Figure 1: High resolution scanning electron microscopy analyses of H. pylori cagE mutant in various conditions of iron availability. Bacteria were grown in A) medium supplemented with 100 µM FeCl3, B) medium supplemented with 200 µM dipyridyl (DIP) or C) medium supplemented with 200 µM dipyridyl (DIP) plus 250 µM FeCl3 prior to co-culture with AGS human gastric cells. Samples were analyzed by high-resolution scanning electron microscopy to evaluate Cag-T4SS biogenesis. Conditions of low or high iron do not modulate any Cag-independent pilus biogenesis, supporting the hypothesis that the structures visualized in Figure 2 are Cag-T4SS pili.
Supplemental Figure 2: ELISA analysis of host IL-8 secretion in response to bacteria grown in varying conditions of iron availability. Wild-type (white bars) or cagE mutant (grey bars) bacteria were grown in modified brucella broth alone (Medium Alone), or medium supplemented with 100 µM FeCl3 (FE), 200 µM dipyridyl (DIP), or 200 µM dipyridyl plus 250 uM FeCl3 (FE+DIP) prior to co-culture with human gastric epithelial cells. Iron restriction results in increased IL-8, a host response that is dependent upon Cag-T4SS activity. Bars indicate mean +/- SEM, derived from 3 separate biological experiments. (*p<0.05 compared to PMSS1 grown in medium alone).
Iron is an essential micronutrient for most forms of life, including bacterial pathogens. In an effort to restrict the viability of invading microorganisms, vertebrate hosts sequester nutrient iron in a process known as “nutritional immunity”18. In response to this, bacterial pathogens have evolved to use iron as a global signaling molecule to sense their surroundings and regulate the elaboration of virulence features such as iron acquisition systems, toxins, and toxin secretion machinery19,20.
H. pylori requires micronutrients such as iron, zinc, and magnesium to grow22 and can use alternate iron sources such as heme, hemoglobin, transferrin, and lactoferrin23. H. pylori, like most successful pathogens, has evolved a wide repertoire of virulence factors to help it scavenge nutrient iron from the host21. One virulence factor, CagA, the effector molecule of the Cag-T4SS, is implicated in rerouting transferrin from the basolateral side of polarized cells to the apical surface where it can be readily used by the bacterial cells as a nutrient iron source and promote replication15. Thus, it seems an intuitive evolutionary strategy to promote the secretion of CagA in conditions of low iron availability.
The H. pylori Cag-T4SS is an important bacterial organelle, due to the proinflammatory host cell responses it elicits. The effects of the Cag-T4SS have been well studied in both co-cultures and animal models of infection. However, studies of the macromolecular structure and composition of this toxin secretion system have been hindered by the lack of high-resolution imaging protocols. Our previously published reports studying the Cag-T4SS have reported an average of four Cag-T4SS pili per bacterial cell by high-resolution electron microscopy analyses24. Our improved method provides a robust imaging technique to visualize the Cag-T4SS by using a culture technique that promotes the production of this feature on the surface of the bacterial cell. Utilization of culture techniques in conjunction with high-resolution field-emission gun scanning electron microscope is critical for this imaging protocol. Two-fold enrichment of the Cag-T4SS surface feature is a significant increase for investigators interested in performing immunohistochemical analyses such as immunofluorescence or immunoprecipitation techniques to further characterize the subcellular location or composition of the Cag-T4SS. Once the high-resolution electron microscopy imaging of the Cag-T4SS has been mastered, it is also possible to develop other applications, such as immunogold-labeling, to determine the location of bacterial proteins with respect to the Cag-T4SS pilus25.
One limitation of our technique is the fact that the investigator is still restricted to using a co-culture system for visualization of the Cag-T4SS. In a single field, only a subset of H. pylori under normal culture conditions form these structures (about 50-70 percent, see Figure 3 panel B). So numerous cells in a field will be non-piliated. It is unknown why these subpopulations exist in the same location, but these cells are always accounted within both the quantifications of pili/cell and percent of cells with pili on the surface. Because the Cag-T4SS is only observed at the host-bacterial interface, the primary and secondary fixation steps within the SEM sample preparation are critical for the preservation of both proteinaceous structures and the membranes of the eukaryotic and prokaryotic cells. However, over-fixation can occur if fixation steps are carried out longer than outlined, or if the solutions are not freshly prepared. If over-fixation occurs, samples will have a stony appearance when viewed under SEM and the Cag-T4SS will be masked by this. To troubleshoot, repeat the SEM sample preparation using less concentrated fixatives and/or less time incubated in the presence of the fixative.
The co-culture system also renders biochemical characterization (such as mass spectrometry analyses) cumbersome due to the contamination of large quantities of host proteins. However, understanding the molecular mechanisms that regulate the production of this bacterial secretion system could ultimately lead to new techniques that will trigger Cag-T4SS pilus formation in the absence of host cells. This would greatly improve the isolation and purification techniques for biochemical assays.
In conclusion, we report that conditions of restricted iron availability result in increased production of H. pylori Cag-T4SS that can be visualized by high resolution scanning electron microscopy techniques. We also report the iron-dependent repression of this surface feature at the host-pathogen interface. This assay may be optimized and utilized for numerous bacterial pathogens that form iron-regulated toxin-secretions and is broadly applicable to a variety of host-microbe interactions.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This research was supported by the Department of Veterans Affairs Career Development Award 1IK2BX001701 and the CTSA award UL1TR000445 from the National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences. Its contents are solely the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily represent official views of the National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences or the National Institutes of Health. Scanning electron microscopy experiments were performed in part through the use of the VUMC Cell Imaging Shared Resource, supported by NIH grants CA68485, DK20593, DK58404, DK59637 and EY08126.
Name of Material/ Equipment | Company | Catalog Number | |
Modified brucella broth | |||
Peptone from casein (10g/L) | Sigma | 70172 | |
Peptic digest of animal tissue (10g/L) | Sigma | 70174 | |
Yeast extract (2g/L) | Sigma | 92144 | |
Dextrose (1g/L) | Sigma | D9434 | |
Sodium chloride (5g/L) | Thermo Fisher | S271-10 | |
Cholesterol (250X) (4mL/L) | Life Technologies | 12531018 | |
Ferric chloride (100 or 250 uM) | Sigma | 157740-100G | |
Dipyridyl (200 uM) | Sigma | D216305-100G | |
Modified RPMI | |||
RPMI+HEPES (1X) | Life Technologies | 22400-121 | |
Fetal bovine serum (100 mL/L) | Life Technologies | 10438-026 | |
Electron Microscopy Preparation | |||
Paraformaldehyde (2.0% aqueous) | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 15713 | |
Gluteraldehyde (2.5% aqueous) | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 16220 | |
Sodium cacodylate (0.05 M) | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 12300 | |
Osmium tetroxide (0.1% aqueous) | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 19150 | |
Ethanol (absolute) | Sigma | E7023 | |
Colloidal silver paint | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 12630 | |
SEM sample stubs | Electron Microscopy Sciences | 75220 | |
Coverslips | Thermo Fisher | 08-774-383 | |
IL-8 Secretion Evaluation | |||
Quantikine IL-8 ELISA kit | R&D Systems | D8000C |