Here we present a protocol for studying the rate of programmed cell death initiation by continuously imaging inoculated leaves following cell death induction.
Hypersensitive response (HR)-conferred resistance is an effective defense response that can be determined by the N resistance genes. HR is manifested as the formation of cell death zones on inoculated leaves. Here, a protocol for studying the rate of cell death initiation by imaging inoculated leaves in the time between the cell death initiation and the cell death appearance using a digital microscope is presented. The digital microscope enables a continuous imaging process in desired intervals, which allows an accurate determination of cell death initiation rate up to minutes exactly, as opposed to hours in traditional methods. Imaging with the digital microscope is also independent of light and can therefore be used during day and night without disturbing the circadian rhythm of the plant. Different pathosystems resulting in programmed cell death development could be studied using this protocol with minor modifications. Overall, the protocol thus allows simple, accurate, and inexpensive identification of cell death initiation rate.
Potato is one of the world's most widely grown food crops, fourth place behind rice, wheat, and corn. However, potato production can be severely affected by potato virus Y (PVY), which is currently considered its most important virus pathogen1,2. In potato plants cv. Rywal, several strains of PVY (including PVY strain N-Wilga) trigger hypersensitive response (HR)-conferred resistance, where the pathogen's restriction to the infection site manifests as necrotic lesions on inoculated leaves3. In this pathosystem, HR is mediated by Ny-1 resistance gene, which is temperature-dependent, as plants grown at lower temperatures efficiently develop necrotic lesions, whereas in plants grown constitutively at elevated (28 °C) temperature, abortion of resistance is demonstrated as lack of lesion formation and systemic virus spread3,4. When the plants are transferred to a lower temperature (22 °C), cell death is initiated, which can be exploited to follow the rate of cell death initiation by imaging inoculated leaves in the time between the cell death initiation and the cell death appearance.
This protocol demonstrates a simple method for the determination of cell death initiation rate using a digital microscope. By imaging the inoculated leaves after transferring the plant from 28 °C to 22 °C, a digital microscope enables continuous observation of the leaf in desired intervals. Unlike the use of other methods (for example, confocal microscopy or observation of lesion formation with the naked eye), this allows determination of the exact time of lesion formation and therefore, the cell death initiation rate up to minutes exactly, as opposed to hours in aforementioned methods5,6. Digital microscope use is also independent of light and can therefore be used during day and night. This protocol can also be used to identify components involved in cell death initiation or to determine the effects of different components on cell death initiation rate if used plants are transgenic and have altered levels of components of interest.
NOTE: Sections 1 and 2 describe a modified protocol for plant material preparation based on the methods outlined by Lukan et al.7. Specifically, some modifications to controlled environmental conditions and inoculum preparation were made.
1. Growing potato plants
2. Inoculum preparation and potato inoculation
3. Plant preparation and using the digital microscope for recording lesion development
This study demonstrates a step-by-step protocol for studying cell death initiation through lesion occurrence on potato cv. Rywal, with a digital microscope. This enables determining the exact time of programmed cell death initiation.
Plants that have developed roots were put in soil 2 weeks after potato cv. Rywal micropropagation (Figure 1A,B). After 3-4 weeks of growth under described conditions, plants with at least 3-4 fully developed leaves with visible leaflets that looked healthy, with no signs of abscission, were used for further analysis (Figure 1C). Using a digital microscope as described in this protocol, we observed the same area on the inoculated leaf at 15-min-intervals and determined the lesion occurrence and expansion in time (Figure 3). The lesion occurred at 15 h 30 min (Figure 3).
Figure 1: Plant preparation for analysis with a digital microscope. (A) A plastic box with MS 30 medium and potato cv. Rywal plant explants containing nodes. (B) Potato cv. Rywal plant in soil (2 weeks after micropropagation). (C) Potato cv. Rywal plant, ready for inoculation (4 weeks after being put in soil), having at least three fully developed leaves. (D) Second inoculated leaf (arrow) of potato cv. Rywal plant positioned and immobilized (arrow) with tape. (E) Plant positioned under the digital microscope with the arrow pointing to the dial used for focusing. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Digital software setting for recording lesion development. (A) Software interface – circled with red are options for the button for (1) camera settings, (2) image capture settings, and (3) saving images. (B) Window with camera settings, which opens with a click on (1) in panel A. Brightness, Contrast, Saturation, Sharpness, and Gamma should be properly adjusted. (C) Window with image capture settings, which opens with a click on (2) denoted in panel A. (D) Window with image saving settings, which opens with a click on (3) denoted in panel A. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Lesion formation on the inoculated leaf observed under the digital microscope. Images of the central part of PVY-inoculated potato leaf at 23.6x magnification as seen under the digital microscope, taken at intervals of 5 min. Inoculated plants were put at 28 °C for 3 days, and on the third day, the observation with a digital microscope at 22 °C started at 7:00. (A) At 21:02, the lesion is not yet visible, (B) 90 min later, at 22:32, the lesion is visible. (C) The lesion expansion was observed at 01:02 and (D) 07:32 the next morning. Experiment was repeated two times, and the lesions occurred 8 h 15 min, and 12 h after cell death initiation, respectively. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
The demonstrated protocol allows the user to accurately determine the cell death initiation rate by continuously imaging inoculated leaves in the time between the cell death initiation and the cell death appearance using a digital microscope. Even though there are numerous ways of monitoring lesion and plant disease occurrence12,13,14,15, this protocol presents the advantage of light-independent measuring without disturbing the plant's circadian rhythm, as the light is switched off between measurements.
After the inoculation, plants should grow at 28 °C for 3 days. Ny-1 resistance gene, which induces a hypersensitive response, is temperature-dependent, and in plants grown at higher temperatures, leads to abortion of resistance, which is manifested as lack of lesion formation and systemic virus spread3. After plants are transferred to 22 °C, cell death is initiated, so for accurate results, observation with a digital microscope should begin as soon as possible after this transfer. Another crucial step in the preparation of the plant for imaging is the immobilization of the leaf (Figure 1D), as the plant will continue to grow during imaging, which could move the observed leaf out of focus, or such set-up will not give desired results.
If the described protocol is used on transgenic plants with altered components of interest, hypothesized to be involved in cell death initiation, the protocol enables the user to determine if the decreased level of a studied component affects the rate of cell death initiation. By that, components involved in cell death initiation can be identified in pathosystems, where programmed cell death occurs, using this protocol. Other methods for identifying these components are, for example, transcriptomic analysis such as RNA-seq or various forms of microscopy, which can be expensive and time-consuming16. The method described in this protocol allows for easy and inexpensive identification of components involved in cell death initiation by observing differences in cell death initiation rates between transgenic and control plants. Optimally, in such a set-up, two digital cameras must be used, as a transgenic plant should be analyzed in parallel with a control plant within the same experiment.
In this protocol, PVY strain N-Wilga was used; however, other strains of this virus, for example, GFP-tagged PVY (PVY-N605(123)-GFP)7, could also be used. Moreover, other pathosystems, which result in programmed cell death development could be studied using this protocol with minor modification.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
We thank Barbara Jaklič for technical assistance. This research was financially supported by the Slovenian Research and Innovation Agency (research core funding no. P4-0165 and project Z4-3217: Deciphering redox-related signaling interconnectedness in potato resistance against viruses).
Alcohol burner | Mikro+Polo | SH-234002455 | For tweezers and scalpel sterilization |
Autoclave A-21 CAV | Kambi | N/A | |
Bacto Agar | Becton, Dickinson and Company | 214010 | |
Carborundum powder | VWR Chemicals | 22505297 | |
DinoCapture 2.0 | Dino-Lite | Version 2.0 | software for digital microscope |
Dino-Lite Edge AM7915MZTL digital microscope | AnMo Electronics Corporation | AM7915MZTL | |
Ethanol, 70% | Stella Tech | P94000 | For tweezers and scalpel sterilization |
Extraction bags | Bioreba | 420100 | |
Growth chamber FS-WI | Photon Systems Insturments | N/A | |
Hand homogenizer | Bioreba | 400010 | |
Hawita Special Substrate | HAWITA Gruppe | 2000000071701 | Ready to use substrate, made using peat (H4-H6 and H6-H8) |
Hydrochloric acid (HCl) | Merck | 109057 | |
Label tape | Sigma | L8144-5EA | |
Laptop computer with installed DinoCapture 2.0 | HP | Z2V77EA#BED | Computer needs to be transferable as experiment takes part in a growth chamber |
Murashige and Skoog medium | Duchefa Biochemie | M02220100 | |
Na2HPO4 | Emsure | 1065860500 | |
NaH2PO4 | Emsure | 1064700250 | |
Pasteur pipette 0.5 mL | Brand | 21500209 | |
pH-meter | Mettler Toledo | ML1601 | |
Plastic boxes | Cvetlice Dornig | VCG10.5 | Radius = 10.5 cm |
Plastic pots | Lab Associates | DIS40003 | Radius = 11.5 cm (top), Radius = 9.8 cm (bottom) |
Saccharose | Kemika d.d. | 1800408 | |
Sodium Diethyldithiocarbamate (DIECA) | Sigma-Aldeich | 228680 | Sodium diethyldithiocarbamate trihydrate, ACS reagent |
Sodium hydroxide (NaOH) | Merck | 106462 | |
Sterile surgical blades | Braun | 4511733633 | |
Tweezers | Braun | BD033R |