Source: Tilde Andersson1, Rolf Lood1
1 Department of Clinical Sciences Lund, Division of Infection Medicine, Biomedical Center, Lund University, 221 00 Lund, Sweden
Viruses that infect prokaryotic organisms, called bacteriophages or simply phages, were identified in the early 20th century by Twort (1) and d'Hérelle (2) independently. Phages have since been widely recognized for their therapeutic value (3) and their influence on human (4), as well as global, ecosystems (5). Current concerns have fueled a renewed interest in the use of phages as an alternative to modern antibiotics in treatment of infectious disease (6). Essentially all phage research relies on the ability to purify and quantify viruses, also known as a viral titer. Initially described in 1952, this was the purpose of the plaque assay (7). Decades and multiple technological advancements later, the plaque assay remains one of the most reliable methods for determination of viral titer (8).
Bacteriophages subsist by injecting their genetic material into host cells, hijacking the machineries for production of new phage particles, and eventually causing the host to release numerous progeny virions through cell lysis. Because of their minute size, bacteriophages cannot be observed using solely light microscopy; therefore, scanning electron microscopy is required (Figure 1). Additionally, phages cannot be cultivated on nutritional agar plates like bacteria, as they need host cells to prey on.
Figure 1: The morphology of a bacteriophage, here exemplified by an E. coli phage, can be studied using scanning electron microscopy. Most bacteriophages belong to Caudovirales (tailed bacteriophages). This particular phage has a very short tail structure and an icosahedral head, placing it in the family of Podoviruses.
The plaque assay (Figure 2) is based on incorporation of host cells, preferentially in log-phase growth, into the medium. This creates a dense, turbid layer of bacteria able to sustain viral growth. An isolated phage can subsequently infect, replicate within, and lyse one cell. With each lysed cell, multiple adjacent ones become immediately infected. Several cycles in, a clear zone (a plaque) can be observed in the otherwise turbid plate (Figure 2B/Figure 3A), indicating the presence of what was initially a single bacteriophage particle. The number of plaque forming units per volume (i.e. PFU/mL) of a sample, can thus be determined from the number of plaques generated.
Figure 2: Testing for plaque forming units (PFU) is a common method for determining the number of bacteriophages in a sample. (A) The base of a sterile Petri dish is covered with an appropriate solid nutrient medium, followed by a mixture of soft media, susceptible host cells and a dilution of the original bacteriophage sample. Note that the phage-suspension could, in some cases, also be evenly spread-out across the surface of already solidified soft agar. (B) Growth of the host bacteria forms a lawn of cells in the top agar layer. Bacteriophage replication generates clear zones, or plaques, caused by host cell lysis.
Figure 3: Results from PFU-testing show multiple plaques generated by bacteriophages. Due to lysis of susceptible host cells, plaques can be seen as clearing zones in the bacterial lawn, either with (A) full clearance, or (B) partial re-growth caused by generation of resistant bacteria (or possibly by temperate phages in the lysogenic cycle).
Certain temperate phages can adopt what is referred to as a lysogenic lifecycle, in addition to the formerly described lytic growth. In lysogeny, the virus assumes a latent state through incorporation of its genetic material into the genome of the host cell (9), often conferring resistance to further phage infections. This is sometimes revealed through a slight clouding of the plaque (Figure 3B). It is worth noting however, that plaques can also appear blurred due to re-growth of bacteria that have evolved resistance to the phage independent of previous phage infections.
Viruses can attach, or adsorb, to only a limited range of host bacteria (10). Host ranges are further limited by intracellular anti-viral strategies such as the CRISPR-Cas system (11). The resistance/sensitivity towards specific phages displayed by bacterial subgroups has historically been used to categorize bacterial strains into different phage types (Figure 4). Although the effectiveness of this method has now been surpassed by novel sequencing techniques, phage typing can still provide valuable information about bacteria-phage interactions, for instance, facilitating the design of a phage cocktail for clinical usage.
Figure 4: Phage sensitivity of different bacterial strains. Soft agar plates with Cutibacterium acnes strain (A) AD27 and (B) AD35, were spotted with 21 different C. acnes bacteriophages. Only phage 11 were able to infect and kill AD27 while strain AD35 showed sensitivity towards all phages. This technique, termed phage typing, can be used to divide bacterial species and strains into different subgroups based on phage susceptibility.
1. Set-up
2. Protocol
3. Data Analysis and Results
Bacteriophages, also called phages, are viruses that specifically infect bacteria and we can confirm their presence and quantify them using a tool called the plaque assay. Bacteriophages infect their susceptible hosts by first attaching to the bacterial cell wall and injecting their genetic material. Then, they hijack the cell's biosynthetic machinery to replicate their DNA and produce numerous progeny phage particles, which they then release by lysing and killing the host cell.
This lytic activity is the basis of a widely used phage enumerating technique known as the plaque assay or double agar layer assay. Here, a bacteriophage mix is first prepared in a molten nutrient broth containing low concentration agar. All bacteria used in the mix should be alive and actively dividing in the log phase of their growth, which will ensure that a large percentage of the bacteria are viable and able to form a dense lawn around the plaques. Next, this molten bacterial-phage agar mix is spread over a more solid, concentrated agar nutrient medium which is already solidified on a Petri dish. On incubation at room temperature, the low concentration agar-phage-bacteria broth also solidifies to form a soft agar overlay.
Here, the bacterial cells can derive additional nutrients from the bottom layer and should rapidly multiply to produce a confluent lawn of bacteria. However, as phage particles are also present in the soft layer, these will infect and replicate their genetic material within the bacteria, culminating in cell lysis, which releases multiple progeny. These phage progeny then infect the neighboring cells, as the semi-solid state of the bacteria-phage layer restricts their movement to more distantly located host cells. This cycle of infection and lysis continues over multiple rounds, killing a large number of bacteria in a localized area. The effect of the neighboring cells being destroyed, is to produce a single circular clear zone, called a plaque, which can be seen by the naked eye, effectively amplifying the bacteria lytic activity of the phage and enabling their enumeration.
The number of plaques on a Petri dish are referred to as Plaque-Forming Units, or PFUs, and, providing the initial bacteriophage concentration was sufficiently dilute, should directly correspond to the number of infective phage particles in the original sample. This technique can also be used for characterization of plaque morphology, to aid in identification of phage types, or to isolate phage mutants. In this lab, you will learn how to perform the plaque assay for enumerating phages, using the T7 phage of E. coli as an example.
First, identify a suitable medium for the culturing of the host bacterial cells and the bacteriophage. Here lysogeny broth, or LB medium, was used to culture E. coli and the T7 phage. Next, take three clean glass bottles and label them with media, name, and then the first as LB-Broth, the second as LB-Bottom Agar, and the third as LB-Top Agar. Now, weigh out four grams of pre-formulated LB powder in three sets and then transfer one set of weighed dried media into each bottle. Add 200 milliliters of water to the first bottle. Mix the contents using a magnetic stir bar.
Then, using a pH meter and constant stirring, bring the final pH to 7.4 through the addition of sodium hydroxide or hydrochloric acid. Repeat the water addition and pH adjustment for the other two remaining bottles, as well. Now, weigh out three grams of agar powder and add it to the second bottle to make a 1.5 % bottom agar. Finally, weigh 1. 2 grams of agar and add it to the third bottle to make the .6 % LB top agar. The broth condition in bottle one does not need an agar addition. Cap the bottle semi-tightly and then, sterilize the media by autoclaving at 121 degrees Celsius for 20 minutes. Once complete, remove the media bottles from the autoclave and immediately twist the bottle caps to close them fully to prevent contamination. Keep the LB-Broth and LB-Top Agar media on the bench for later use. Place the LB-Bottom Agar to cool in a water bath that is preset to approximately 45 degrees Celsius.
When the LB-Bottom agar reaches approximately 45 degrees Celsius, transfer it to the work bench. Next, sterilize the workspace using 70 % ethenol. Next, add 450 microliters of sterile one molar calcium chloride to the molten bottom agar to make a final concentration of 2.25 millimolar. Gently swirl the bottle to mix. Then, set out seven clean Petri dishes. Label each dish on the bottom with the media name and preparation date. Then, pour 15 milliliters of the bottom agar into each of the seven Petri dishes. Allow the plates to set for a few hours or overnight at room temperature. Once set, the culture plates can be stored at four degrees Celsius for several days if needed, upside down to minimize condensation. Transfer the Petri dishes from the four degrees Celsius refrigerator to a 37 degrees Celsius incubator one hour before the assay.
The day before the assay is to be preformed, the E. coli should be cultured. Here, 10 microliters of E. coli culture was inoculated into 10 milliliters of LB-Broth. Place the bacteria to grow overnight in a shaking incubator set to 37 degrees Celsius at 160 RPM. Then, on the day of the assay, remove the bacterial culture from the incubator. Seed a fresh 10 milliliters of fresh LB broth with 0.5 milliliters of the overnight culture. Place these cells to grow into a shaking incubator set to 37 degrees Celsius at 160 RPM. Next, use a spectrophotometer to check when this culture reaches log phase growth, indicated by an optical density of 0.5 to 0.7. Once the OD reaches this level, stop the incubation by transferring the cell culture to the bench. They are now ready to be used for phage overlay assay.
Phage titers can vary exponentially across different phage types and samples. So in order to count them effectively, they should be diluted to generate a wide range of phage concentrations. On the day of the assay, generate a series of phage dilutions ranging from one tenth to one millionth concentrations, following a 10-fold dilution technique. To obtain statistically significant and accurate data, perform the serial dilution in triplicate.
Next, melt the solidified LB-top agar using a microwave. Then, place it in a water bath that is preset at 45 degrees Celsius for one hour. After one hour, collect the Petri dishes containing the bottom agar layer from the incubator. Label the plates with phage concentration and assay date. Then, set out seven clean test tubes. Label each test tube with the serial phage dilution number and designate one as control.
When the LB-top agar reaches 45 degrees Celsius, transfer it to the working bench. Now, add 450 microliters of one molar calcium chloride to the 200 milliliter agar to make a final concentration of 2.25 millimolar. Gently swirl the bottle to mix. Next, add 35 milliliters of LB-top agar and four milliliters of bacterial suspension to a sterile conical tube. Gently swirl to evenly distribute the cells but avoid shaking to prevent foaming.
Now, aliquot five milliliters of this bacteria- top agar mix to each of the seven test tubes. Then, transfer 100 microliters of the serially diluted bacteriophage samples and control media, which should be simply media with no bacteriophage, to the respectfully labeled test tubes. Swirl the mixture gently to ensure proper mixing. Gently transfer five milliliters of bacteriophage mix onto the respective Petri plate. Evenly spread the mix throughout the whole surface by gently swirling the Petri plate.
Once all of the Petri plates are layered with the mix, allow solidification of the top layer by incubating at room temperature for 15 minutes. After completion of these steps, repeat the process for the second and then the third sets of the Petri dishes using the remaining two sets of phage dilutions. Seal each dish with parafilm and incubate at room temperature for 15 minutes. Place the culture plate upside down at a suitable temperature for 24 hours or until plaques develop. Here, plates were placed in a 37 degrees Celsius incubator for one day, a stimulating growth condition for E. coli and the T7 phage.
Plaques will appear after one to five days of incubation, depending on the bacterial species, incubation conditions, and the choice of medium. Here, plaques were visible after one day of incubation at 37 degrees Celsius. Begin by checking the plates marked control and ensure that no plaques were formed in these plates, as this would indicate viral contamination. To determine the phage titer in the original sample, start with the plates containing the most diluted phage sample first and count the plaques without removing the lids, marking them to indicate which ones have already been counted. Repeat the counting for each plate in every set. Some plates might have too many or too few plaques to be counted. Consider 10 to 150 as an ideal plaque count.
Next, generate a table listing the plaque number values for the different dilutions and replicates. Then, calculate the mean plaque number values for the dilution plates that contained the ideal number of plaque counts. In this example, these were the average number of plaques formed in the 10 to the minus three and 10 to the minus four dilution plates. Now, adjust for phage dilution factor by dividing the obtained mean plaque values by the respective phage dilution factors. Here, the average number of plaques formed to the 10 to the minus three and 10 to the minus four dilution plates, were divided by their respective dilution factors to obtain the number of plaque forming units, or PFUs, in 100 microliters of phage mixture. To convert the value to PFU per milliliter, multiply the generated values by 10, as only 100 microliters of phage dilution mix was used during the bacteriophage overlay preparation step, producing an additional dilution factor of 10. Finally, calculate the average of the values obtained from the different dilution plates. This will give the average number of PFUs per milliliter. The number of PFUs corresponds to the number of infective phage particles in the original sample.
Despite multiple technological advances, plaque assays remain the gold standard for determination of viral titer (as PFU) and essential for isolation of pure bacteriophage populations. Susceptible host cells are cultivated in the top coat of a two layered agar-plate, forming a homogenous bed enabling viral replication. The initial event where an isolated bacteriophage in lytic lifecycle infects a cell, replicates within it, and eventually lyses it, is too small to observe. However, the virions released will infect adjacent cells, subsequently giving rise to a clearing zone, or plaque, denoting the presence of a single PFU.
Bacteriophages, also called phages, are viruses that specifically infect bacteria and we can confirm their presence and quantify them using a tool called the plaque assay. Bacteriophages infect their susceptible hosts by first attaching to the bacterial cell wall and injecting their genetic material. Then, they hijack the cell’s biosynthetic machinery to replicate their DNA and produce numerous progeny phage particles, which they then release by lysing and killing the host cell.
This lytic activity is the basis of a widely used phage enumerating technique known as the plaque assay or double agar layer assay. Here, a bacteriophage mix is first prepared in a molten nutrient broth containing low concentration agar. All bacteria used in the mix should be alive and actively dividing in the log phase of their growth, which will ensure that a large percentage of the bacteria are viable and able to form a dense lawn around the plaques. Next, this molten bacterial-phage agar mix is spread over a more solid, concentrated agar nutrient medium which is already solidified on a Petri dish. On incubation at room temperature, the low concentration agar-phage-bacteria broth also solidifies to form a soft agar overlay.
Here, the bacterial cells can derive additional nutrients from the bottom layer and should rapidly multiply to produce a confluent lawn of bacteria. However, as phage particles are also present in the soft layer, these will infect and replicate their genetic material within the bacteria, culminating in cell lysis, which releases multiple progeny. These phage progeny then infect the neighboring cells, as the semi-solid state of the bacteria-phage layer restricts their movement to more distantly located host cells. This cycle of infection and lysis continues over multiple rounds, killing a large number of bacteria in a localized area. The effect of the neighboring cells being destroyed, is to produce a single circular clear zone, called a plaque, which can be seen by the naked eye, effectively amplifying the bacteria lytic activity of the phage and enabling their enumeration.
The number of plaques on a Petri dish are referred to as Plaque-Forming Units, or PFUs, and, providing the initial bacteriophage concentration was sufficiently dilute, should directly correspond to the number of infective phage particles in the original sample. This technique can also be used for characterization of plaque morphology, to aid in identification of phage types, or to isolate phage mutants. In this lab, you will learn how to perform the plaque assay for enumerating phages, using the T7 phage of E. coli as an example.
First, identify a suitable medium for the culturing of the host bacterial cells and the bacteriophage. Here lysogeny broth, or LB medium, was used to culture E. coli and the T7 phage. Next, take three clean glass bottles and label them with media, name, and then the first as LB-Broth, the second as LB-Bottom Agar, and the third as LB-Top Agar. Now, weigh out four grams of pre-formulated LB powder in three sets and then transfer one set of weighed dried media into each bottle. Add 200 milliliters of water to the first bottle. Mix the contents using a magnetic stir bar.
Then, using a pH meter and constant stirring, bring the final pH to 7.4 through the addition of sodium hydroxide or hydrochloric acid. Repeat the water addition and pH adjustment for the other two remaining bottles, as well. Now, weigh out three grams of agar powder and add it to the second bottle to make a 1.5 % bottom agar. Finally, weigh 1. 2 grams of agar and add it to the third bottle to make the .6 % LB top agar. The broth condition in bottle one does not need an agar addition. Cap the bottle semi-tightly and then, sterilize the media by autoclaving at 121 degrees Celsius for 20 minutes. Once complete, remove the media bottles from the autoclave and immediately twist the bottle caps to close them fully to prevent contamination. Keep the LB-Broth and LB-Top Agar media on the bench for later use. Place the LB-Bottom Agar to cool in a water bath that is preset to approximately 45 degrees Celsius.
When the LB-Bottom agar reaches approximately 45 degrees Celsius, transfer it to the work bench. Next, sterilize the workspace using 70 % ethenol. Next, add 450 microliters of sterile one molar calcium chloride to the molten bottom agar to make a final concentration of 2.25 millimolar. Gently swirl the bottle to mix. Then, set out seven clean Petri dishes. Label each dish on the bottom with the media name and preparation date. Then, pour 15 milliliters of the bottom agar into each of the seven Petri dishes. Allow the plates to set for a few hours or overnight at room temperature. Once set, the culture plates can be stored at four degrees Celsius for several days if needed, upside down to minimize condensation. Transfer the Petri dishes from the four degrees Celsius refrigerator to a 37 degrees Celsius incubator one hour before the assay.
The day before the assay is to be preformed, the E. coli should be cultured. Here, 10 microliters of E. coli culture was inoculated into 10 milliliters of LB-Broth. Place the bacteria to grow overnight in a shaking incubator set to 37 degrees Celsius at 160 RPM. Then, on the day of the assay, remove the bacterial culture from the incubator. Seed a fresh 10 milliliters of fresh LB broth with 0.5 milliliters of the overnight culture. Place these cells to grow into a shaking incubator set to 37 degrees Celsius at 160 RPM. Next, use a spectrophotometer to check when this culture reaches log phase growth, indicated by an optical density of 0.5 to 0.7. Once the OD reaches this level, stop the incubation by transferring the cell culture to the bench. They are now ready to be used for phage overlay assay.
Phage titers can vary exponentially across different phage types and samples. So in order to count them effectively, they should be diluted to generate a wide range of phage concentrations. On the day of the assay, generate a series of phage dilutions ranging from one tenth to one millionth concentrations, following a 10-fold dilution technique. To obtain statistically significant and accurate data, perform the serial dilution in triplicate.
Next, melt the solidified LB-top agar using a microwave. Then, place it in a water bath that is preset at 45 degrees Celsius for one hour. After one hour, collect the Petri dishes containing the bottom agar layer from the incubator. Label the plates with phage concentration and assay date. Then, set out seven clean test tubes. Label each test tube with the serial phage dilution number and designate one as control.
When the LB-top agar reaches 45 degrees Celsius, transfer it to the working bench. Now, add 450 microliters of one molar calcium chloride to the 200 milliliter agar to make a final concentration of 2.25 millimolar. Gently swirl the bottle to mix. Next, add 35 milliliters of LB-top agar and four milliliters of bacterial suspension to a sterile conical tube. Gently swirl to evenly distribute the cells but avoid shaking to prevent foaming.
Now, aliquot five milliliters of this bacteria- top agar mix to each of the seven test tubes. Then, transfer 100 microliters of the serially diluted bacteriophage samples and control media, which should be simply media with no bacteriophage, to the respectfully labeled test tubes. Swirl the mixture gently to ensure proper mixing. Gently transfer five milliliters of bacteriophage mix onto the respective Petri plate. Evenly spread the mix throughout the whole surface by gently swirling the Petri plate.
Once all of the Petri plates are layered with the mix, allow solidification of the top layer by incubating at room temperature for 15 minutes. After completion of these steps, repeat the process for the second and then the third sets of the Petri dishes using the remaining two sets of phage dilutions. Seal each dish with parafilm and incubate at room temperature for 15 minutes. Place the culture plate upside down at a suitable temperature for 24 hours or until plaques develop. Here, plates were placed in a 37 degrees Celsius incubator for one day, a stimulating growth condition for E. coli and the T7 phage.
Plaques will appear after one to five days of incubation, depending on the bacterial species, incubation conditions, and the choice of medium. Here, plaques were visible after one day of incubation at 37 degrees Celsius. Begin by checking the plates marked control and ensure that no plaques were formed in these plates, as this would indicate viral contamination. To determine the phage titer in the original sample, start with the plates containing the most diluted phage sample first and count the plaques without removing the lids, marking them to indicate which ones have already been counted. Repeat the counting for each plate in every set. Some plates might have too many or too few plaques to be counted. Consider 10 to 150 as an ideal plaque count.
Next, generate a table listing the plaque number values for the different dilutions and replicates. Then, calculate the mean plaque number values for the dilution plates that contained the ideal number of plaque counts. In this example, these were the average number of plaques formed in the 10 to the minus three and 10 to the minus four dilution plates. Now, adjust for phage dilution factor by dividing the obtained mean plaque values by the respective phage dilution factors. Here, the average number of plaques formed to the 10 to the minus three and 10 to the minus four dilution plates, were divided by their respective dilution factors to obtain the number of plaque forming units, or PFUs, in 100 microliters of phage mixture. To convert the value to PFU per milliliter, multiply the generated values by 10, as only 100 microliters of phage dilution mix was used during the bacteriophage overlay preparation step, producing an additional dilution factor of 10. Finally, calculate the average of the values obtained from the different dilution plates. This will give the average number of PFUs per milliliter. The number of PFUs corresponds to the number of infective phage particles in the original sample.