Here, we present a protocol to describe a minimally invasive technique for knee joint immobilization in a rat model. This reproducible protocol, basing on muscle-gap separation modus and the mini-incision skill, is suitable for studying the underlying molecular mechanism of acquired joint contracture.
Joint contracture, resulting from a prolonged joint immobilization, is a common complication in orthopedics. Currently, utilizing an internal fixation to restrict knee joint mobility is a widely accepted model to generate experimental contracture. However, implanting application will inevitably cause surgical trauma to the animals. Aiming to develop a less invasive approach, we combined a muscle-gap separation modus with a previously reported mini-incision skill during the surgical procedure: Two mini skin incisions were made on the lateral thigh and leg, followed by performing muscle-gap separation to expose the bone surface. The rat knee joint was gradually immobilized by a preconstructed internal fixation at approximately 135° knee flexion without interfering essential nerves or blood vessels. As expected, this simple technique permits rapid postoperative rehabilitation in animals. The correct position of the internal fixation was confirmed by an x-ray or micro-CT scanning analysis. The range of motion was significantly restricted in the immobilized knee joint than that observed in the contralateral knee joint demonstrating the effectiveness of this model. Besides, histological analysis revealed the development of fibrous deposition and adhesion in the posterior-superior knee joint capsule over time. Thus, this mini-invasive model may be suitable for mimicking the development of immobilized knee joint contracture.
Joint contractures are defined as a restriction in the passive range of motion (ROM) of a diarthrodial joint1,2. The current therapies aiming to prevent and treat joint contracture have achieved some success3,4. However, the underlying molecular mechanism of acquired joint contracture remains largely unknown5. The etiology of joint contractures in different social communities is highly diverse and includes genetic factors, posttraumatic states, chronic diseases, and prolonged immobility6. It is widely accepted that immobility is a critical issue in the development of acquired joint contracture7. People who suffer from major joint contracture may ultimately result in physical disability8. Thus, a stable and reproducible animal model is necessary for investigating the potential pathophysiological mechanisms of acquired joint contracture.
The currently built immobilization-induced knee joint contracture models are mostly achieved by utilizing non-invasive plaster casts, external fixations, and internal fixations. Watanabe et al. reported the possibility of the use of plaster cast immobilization on rat knee joints9. By wearing a special jacket, one side of the lower limb joint of the rat is immobilized by a cast. The rat knee joint can remain fully flexed without any surgical trauma10,11. However, both the hip and ankle joint movements are also affected by this form of immobilization, which may increase the degree of muscle atrophy in quadriceps femoris or gastrocnemius12. In addition, edema and congestion of the hind limbs must be avoided by replacing the cast at set time points, which may affect the continuity of immobility. Another accepted method for the establishment of a knee joint contracture model is using external surgical fixation. Nagai et al. combined Kirschner wire and steel wire into an external fixator, which immobilized the knee joint to approximately 140° of flexion13. In this method, a resin is used to cover the surface to prevent skin scratches. Although external fixation immobilization is robust and reliable14,15, percutaneous Kirschner wire pin tracks may increase the risk of infection16. In our own experience, using the external fixation technique may reduce the daily activity of rats due to an increase in the conditioned lick behavior.
Alternatively, Trudel et al. described a well-accepted model of joint contracture in the rat knee joint based on a surgical internal fixation17 (this method was modified from the one used by Evans and colleagues18). Notably, this method highlights the importance of utilizing a mini-incision technique to minimize the surgical wounds. The efficient development of joint contracture has been proved in this model19. However, the protocol on how to perform a minimal dissection to expose the bone surface is still unclear20. Also, the precise position where the screw is drilling is not fully understood. The implantation of the internal fixation through a subcutaneous or submuscular way is still controversial21. To solve these problems, we have modified this method by including an appropriate muscle-gap separation modus, which allows a mini-invasive exposure of the bone surface and the placement of the implantation through a submuscular channel. This protocol led to rapid postoperative rehabilitation in rats after surgery. Animals developed a limited joint range of motion after joint immobilization, which was consistent with morphological changes of capsular adhesion obtained from the histological analysis. We also describe an exact possible location of the drilled screws as confirmed by X-ray analysis or micro-CT analysis. Thus, this study aimed to describe in detail a minimal-invasive technique in a knee joint contracture model that was established by a muscle-gap separation modus combined with a mini-incision method. We believe that minimally invasive techniques can both reduce animal trauma and effectively mimic the pathological process of joint flexion contracture.
All procedures were carried out in accordance with the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals and were approved by The Third Affiliated Hospital of Sun Yat-sen University institutional animal care and use committee (permission number: 02-165-01). All the animal experiments were performed according to the ARRIVE guidelines.
1. Preoperative preparation
NOTE: Figure 1 shows the design of the surgical procedure.
2. Surgery
3. Postoperative management
4. Postoperative examination
We observed that rats received minimally invasive surgery can return to the regular diet just one day postoperatively. In particular, the surgical incision has scarred without exudate (Figure 5a). The swelling of the ankle and metacarpophalangeal joints in the operative hindlimb has almost wholly disappeared two days postoperatively (Figure 5b) when compared with the contralateral side (Figure 5c). None of the signs of early infection were found in the rats. Rats can stand and exercise regularly (Figure 5d). The surgical wounds had healed entirely on day twelve postoperatively (Figure 5).
Visually, the immobilized knee joint was contracted after four weeks of immobilization, while the mini-invasive surgery had no visible effect on the contralateral limb (Figure 6a). The X-ray image shows the correct placement of the steel screws in the femur or the tibia (Figure 6b), although it did not show the location of the plastic plate. We also employed a high-resolution micro-CT scanner to image the immobilized lower limb. The 3D reconstruction analysis demonstrated that the screws were drilled laterally (Figure 6c). The drilling position is approximate 8 mm below the lower edge of the greater trochanter at the proximal femur and just (approximate 4 mm) below the edge of the tibiofibular fusion at the distal tibia (Figure 6c).
We measured six rats at the end of two times (28 days and 56 days), respectively, to compare the arthrogenic ROM deficits on the immobilized knee joint and the contralateral side after myotomies of the transarticular muscles20. The contralateral knee joint (non-operative) serves as a control. After 28 days of immobilization, the average arthrogenic deficits in extension ROM was 29.4 ± 3.3° for the immobilized knee joint, significantly higher than that in control (4.8 ± 2.8°, P< 0.05). The arthrogenic deficits in ROM increased during immobilization in a time-dependent manner, demonstrated by the average arthrogenic deficits of 40.7 ± 4.3° for the immobilized knee joint, significantly greater than that in control, 11.2 ± 3.8° on the 56 days of immobilization (p < 0.05) (Figure 7).
Using Elastica-Masson-Staining, we analyzed the posterior-superior knee joint capsule at three-time points. On day one immobilization, no adhesion was observed in the joint space between the postero-superior joint capsule and the femur in the immobilized or the contralateral side knee joint (Figure 8a,d). However, we observed that there was fibro-adipose tissue deposited and adhesion had developed in the joint space after 28 days of immobilization (Figure 8e). The fibrous tissues even partially replaced this deposition after 56 days of immobilization (Figure 8f) while this type of adhesion was not observed in the contralateral side at different time points (Figure 8 a,b,c).
Figure 1: Graphical illustration of a lateral view of the knee joint immobilized with an internal fixation at 135° of flexion. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Design the polypropylene plastic plate into an internal fixation. (a-b) A polypropylene plastic plate was cleaved from the syringe. The dotted lines represent the approximate plate range. The plate has the following dimensions: length, 25 mm; width, 10 mm; thickness, 1 mm. (c) Photograph of the hand-held electric drill. (d) Drills with the 0.9 mm and 1.0 mm diameter at each end of the plate. The specification of the screw is 1.4 x 8 mm and 1.2 x 6 mm respectively. (e) The final form of a preconstructed internal fixation. (f) The surgical instruments. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Macrographs of surgical exposure the middle femur and the distal tibia using the mini-invasive technique. (a) A black line indicates the skin incision between the vastus lateralis (upper marked area) and biceps femoris (lower marked area). The dotted lines represent the approximate muscle range. (b) The surgical incision between the muscles is illustrated. The incision is away from the sciatic nerve. The black line represents the orientation of the sciatic nerve. (c) The exposure of the femoral midshaft by muscle-gap separation with the vastus lateralis and capput vertebralis indicated. (d-e) The exposure of the tibia is shown in relation to the fibularis longus. (f) The drill hole in the femoral shaft is illustrated with the vastus lateralis, and capput vertebralis indicated. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Implantation of internal fixation. (a) The hole made in the tibia is illustrated with the fibularis longus, and the flexor digitorum profundis indicated. (b-c) The plastic plate screwed into the drill hole is illustrated in relation to the caput vertebralis (b) and the fibularis longus (c). (d-e) Wound closure using vicryl suture. The dotted line (e) represents the approximate plastic plate range. (f) Postoperative overall view of the mini-incision. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: Observation of surgical incision healing. (a) The surgical incision has scarred two days postoperatively. (b-c) The swelling of the ankle and metacarpophalangeal joints in the postsurgical limb (b) has almost completely disappeared two days postoperatively. Arrowheads indicate the ankle joints. (d) A rat can stand normally. (e-f) The wound has completely healed twelve days postoperatively. Black arrows indicate surgical healing incision. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6: Evaluation of knee joint immobilization. (a) The macroscopic image illustrates a contraction of the left knee joint after four weeks of immobilization. (b) Overall x-ray image shows the placement of the screws. (c) Microcomputed tomography analysis of the immobilized knee joint. The white arrows represent the fixed screws. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 7: Analysis of arthrogenic deficits in joint extension range of motion (ROM). Data are presented as mean ± SEM (n = 6 per group). The arthrogenic deficits in extension ROM of the immobilized knee joints are significantly higher than that of the contralateral, nonoperative side (serve as a control group). Limitation in ROM represents joint immobilization induced a typical knee flexion contracture. Statistical analysis: The Equality of Variances was performed using Levene's Test, ROM differences between the contralateral and immobilized groups were compared at two-time point (28 and 56 days) by two tails Student’s t test. Significance difference was determined by *P < 0.05 from the control. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 8: Histological changes in the posterior-superior knee joint capsule analyzed by Elastica-Masson-Staining at different time points. Representative images of the posterior-superior joint capsule in the contralateral knee joint (non-operative, upper panels), and the immobilized knee joint (operative, lower panels) on day 1, 28, and 56 during joint immobilization. After a day of immobilization, synovium was thick, and no adhesion was observed in the joint space between the postero-superior joint capsule and the femur (indicated by asterisks in a left row). After 28 days of immobilization, there was fibro-adipose tissue deposited in the joint space and adhesion had developed between postero-superior joint capsule and the femur (indicated by arrowhead). On days 56 of immobilization, the deposits still existed, and there was fibrous tissue increasingly appeared (indicated by arrow). The black border in the bottom left corner represents the magnified image of the joint space between the postero-superior joint capsule and the femur. F: femur; T: tibia; M: meniscus, the posterior horn; JS: joint space. Scale bar = 50 μm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
This study aimed to elucidate a step-by-step knee joint immobilization method using a mini-invasive technique that permits rapid postoperative rehabilitation in animals after surgery. Conventionally, the muscle-gap separation approach is thought to be a minimally invasive technique in orthopedic surgery. As expected, we found that rats can return to a normal diet and activities just one day postoperatively, which was consistent with the previous study. Moreover, no artery or nerve injury occurred after the surgery, evidence that the muscle-gap separation modus ensured an adequate and safe bone exposure method. Although the invasive surgical effects can be reduced by using plaster casts, the possibility of edema occurrence in the hind limbs may affect the continuity of immobility. In this study, the ankle or toe swelling caused by surgical procedures disappeared entirely after two days postoperatively. These results highlight a reliable and stable joint immobilization model created by a mini-invasive technique aligned with the principle of rapid recovery. Clinically, the flexion contracture that is caused by immobilization is closer to a non-inflammatory course6. Edema can lead to the release of inflammatory mediators4. Therefore, using plaster casts to induced joint contracture cannot indeed be harmless. In the present study, two separate small incisions (of 1-1.5 cm) were performed on the femoral and tibial sides, respectively. The incision lengths were similar to the size of the incision that is required for K-wire drilling. Therefore, the mini-invasive effect of this method is more conducive to reducing trauma to that of external fixation. Besides, a previous randomized controlled trial demonstrated a possible correlation between the application of external fixation (percutaneously) and the increased risk of infection in the limb16. Considering there no rats had an early infection sign in the research, we assumed that the muscle gap separation technique is the key to this model because it can reduce bleeding and unnecessary cutting. Also, the internal fixator was trimmed down from the syringe, it is low cost and most importantly, non-toxic to animals. Although both the lateral and medial surgical approaches can establish an effective rat model of knee flexion contracture28, this small-invasive technique, however, may only be implemented using the lateral approach rather than using the medial approach.
To our best knowledge, the precise screw drilling position at the proximal femur or distal tibia is not fully understood. Choosing to drill a hole in the middle section of the tibia may affect the blood supply in the tibia. The results obtained from the micro-CT analysis indicated that the proper drilling position is approximate 8 mm below the lower edge of the greater trochanter and approximate 4 mm below the edge of the tibiofibular fusion. The proper drilling position can help avoid effects on the joint component or blood supply. However, the implantation of the internal fixation through a subcutaneous or submuscular way is still controversial. Interestingly, performing the muscle-gap separation technique is convenient for placing the implantation through a submuscular channel to a certain extent.
The results from the joint angle measurement were consistent with the histological analysis, demonstrating that knee joint contracture was successfully induced in the immobilized hindlimb. The average arthrogenic deficits in extension ROM was 29.4 ± 3.3°, 40.7 ± 4.3° on the immobilized knee joint at the end of 28 days and 56 days of immobilization, respectively, which were significantly higher than that in control (P < 0.05). We also found that typical adhesion had developed between in the joint space between the postero-superior joint capsule and the femur in the immobilized side knee joint (Figure 8e,f), which indicates that using the mini-invasive technique will not interfere with the occurrence of joint contracture. Taken together, the research indicates that this mini-invasive model produces stable results and is effective in inducing acquired joint flexion contracture.
This mini-invasive model still has some limitations. First, the tibia side screw will inevitably irritate the nearby tendons, including the fibularis longus. Second, drilling into the cortical bone may cause fractures. Third, there is still a chance of fixation failure. We believe that the use of 3D-built individualized splints is a possible option for building a non-invasive knee joint contracture model in the future29.
In conclusion, the present study describes a mini-invasive knee joint contracture model that is based on a combination of the muscle gap separation modus and the mini-incision method. Given that internal surgical fixations can produce a well-accepted model of joint contracture, this mini-invasive technique may be useful in the study of immobilization-induced knee flexion contracture.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported by grants from National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 81772368), Natural Science Foundation of Guangdong Province (No. 2017A030313496), and Guangdong Provincial Science and Technology Plan Project (No. 2016A020215225; No. 2017B090912007). The authors thank Dr. Fei Zhang, M.D. from the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, The Eighth Affiliated Hospital of Sun Yat-sen University for his technical assistance during modification.
Anerdian | Shanghai Likang Ltd. | 310173 | antibacterial |
Buprenorphine | Shanghai Shyndec Pharmaceutical Ltd. | / | analgesia |
Carprofen | MCE | HY-B1227 | analgesia |
Cross screwdriver | STANLEY | PH0*125mm | tighten the screws |
Electric drill | WEGO | 185 | drill hole(with stainless steel drill 0.9mm;1.0mm) |
Microsurgical instruments | RWD | / | Orthopaedic surgical instruments for animals |
Neomycin | Sigma | N6386 | antibacterial |
Sodium pentobarbital | Sigma | P3761 | anaesthetize |
Stainless Steel screws | WEGO | m1.4*8; m1.2*6 | screw(part of internal fixation) |
Syringe | WEGO | 3151474 | use for plastic plate(part of internal fixation) |
μ-CT | ALOKA | Latheta LCT-200 | in vivo CT scan |