Through a double treatment with colchicine, a plant-derived toxin that kills dividing cells, nerve-free Hydra vulgaris can be generated. These Hydra cannot feed or egest on their own. This paper describes an improved method for long-term maintenance of nerve free Hydra vulgaris in the laboratory.
The interstitial cell lineage of Hydra includes multipotent stem cells, and their derivatives: gland cells, nematocytes, germ cells, and nerve cells. The interstitial cells can be eliminated through two consecutive treatments with colchicine, a plant-derived toxin that kills dividing cells, thus erasing the potential for renewal of the differentiated cells that are derived from the interstitial stem cells. This allows for the generation of Hydra that lack nerve cells. A nerve-free polyp cannot open its mouth to feed, egest, or regulate osmotic pressure. Such animals, however, can survive and be cultured indefinitely in the laboratory if regularly force-fed and burped. The lack of nerve cells allows for studies of the role of the nervous system in regulating animal behavior and regeneration. Previously published protocols for nerve-free Hydra maintenance involve outdated techniques such as mouth-pipetting with hand-pulled micropipette tips to feed and clean the Hydra. Here, an improved protocol for maintenance of nerve-free Hydra is introduced. Fine-tipped forceps are used to force open the mouth and insert freshly killed Artemia. Following force-feeding, the body cavity of the animal is flushed with fresh medium using a syringe and hypodermic needle to remove undigested material, referred to here as “burping”. This new method of force-feeding and burping nerve-free Hydra through the use of forceps and syringes eliminates the need for mouth-pipetting using hand-pulled micropipette tips. It thus makes the process safer and significantly more time efficient. To ensure that the nerve cells in the hypostome have been eliminated, immunohistochemistry using anti-tyrosine-tubulin is conducted.
The nervous system of Hydra consists of a nerve net, with neurons associated with both epithelial tissue layers1. The nerve net is denser in the hypostome and peduncle and less dense in the body column2. The nerve cells originate from interstitial stem cells, which are multipotent stem cells that give rise to secretory cells, nematocytes, germ cells, and neurons1. It is possible to eliminate the interstitial cells of Hydra vulgaris through treatment with colchicine3,4, a plant-derived toxin that kills dividing cells. Although colchicine has been found to inhibit microtubule polymerization in other organisms, a previous study has shown that microtubules are present in Hydra throughout the entire treatment, suggesting that colchicine does not act this way in Hydra3. Another study suggests that colchicine does not bind efficiently to tubulin in some organisms, including Tetrahymena pyriformis, Zea mays, Chlamydomonas, and Schizosaccharomyces pombe, which may explain this difference5. The colchicine treatment induces phagocytosis of the interstitial cells by the endodermal epithelial cells3 and thus allows for the creation of animals that are lacking nerve cells, gland cells, and nematocytes. It is unclear why the interstitial cells are particularly susceptible to colchicine treatment. Given that both post-mitotic interstitial cells and the interstitial stem cell lineage are damaged and phagocytosed, Campbell concluded that colchicine was not directly affecting mitotic activity3. Notably, the colchicine treatment works well in Hydra vulgaris, but has been shown to not work as well in other species, such as Hydra oligactis6. A modified treatment with colchicine and hydroxyurea can be used to produce nerve-free Hydra viridis7. Nerve-free Hydra (also sometimes referred to as "epithelial Hydra"8) are therefore a useful tool for studying the roles of these specialized cell types from the interstitial cell lineage in tissue homeostasis and regeneration.
Hydra may be the only known example of an animal capable of living without a nervous system. Nerve-free Hydra serve as a particularly useful model for dissecting the role of the nerve net in regulating Hydra regeneration, homeostasis, and behavior. For example, the introduction of interstitial cells into nerve-free Hydra via grafting allowed for the characterization of nerve cell differentiation as highly region-specific9. Furthermore, because nerve-free Hydra can regenerate, they enable the investigation of alternative, nervous system-independent regeneration pathways. One such example is apical neurogenesis and head formation, which has been shown to depend on cnox-2 function in the nervous system in wildtype Hydra, but appears to be dispensable in nerve-free Hydra, suggesting that there may be an alternative head regeneration process10.
Nerve-free Hydra have also been used to study epithelial cell expression and regulation of neurogenic and neurotransmission genes after the loss of neurogenesis11. Nerve-free Hydra do not exhibit spontaneous contraction bursts12, indicating that these bursts are regulated by the nervous system. Nerve-free Hydra do, however, contract in response to pinching the body column with forceps, suggesting that contraction in response to mechanical stimuli is mediated by coupling through gap junctions in epithelial cells, while spontaneous contractile behavior is mediated by coupling through gap junctions in nerve cells13.
Nerve-free Hydra do not open their mouths when presented with food or reduced glutathione3, suggesting that sensory neurons are necessary to detect the presence of food and signal the mouth to open. In addition, the nerve net seems to play a role in sensing osmotic pressure, because nerve-free animals are unable to autonomously regulate their internal hydrostatic pressure through mouth opening, causing their characteristic balloon-like appearance3,4 (Figure 1B). Regulation of hydrostatic pressure in nerve-free Hydra by frequent manual deflation led to a loss of some abnormal morphology in the hypostome and body column. However, chronic deflation led to interference with growth, elongation, budding, and tissue organization8.
Although nerve-free Hydra are unable to feed and egest on their own, it is possible to maintain them indefinitely in the laboratory by manually force-feeding and burping each animal. Previous publications have described methods of force-feeding and burping nerve-free Hydra, however these protocols involved the use of micropipette tips that must be hand pulled carefully to the appropriate size as well as use of a mouthpiece connected to the pipette by tubing14. Here, a simpler, safer, and more time-efficient method of feeding and burping is described.
In addition, previous studies involved checking for the absence of nerve cells through dissociation of fixed animals into individual cells and examination of cell morphology3,4,15. Here, immunohistochemistry with a monoclonal antibody against the tyrosinated carboxyl-terminus of alpha-tubulin was used as a complimentary method to maceration to check for the depletion of neurons in the hypostome13,16. Previous studies have shown that neurons in the peduncle can also be visualized using this antibody13, however these neurons as well as those in the body column are more difficult to make out. While immunohistochemistry is sufficient to confirm the absence of nerve cells in the hypostome and does not require expertise on cell type morphology, it cannot be used to check for the absence of the interstitial stem cells and the other derivatives of these cells. Dissociation and cell morphology studies are more rigorous and can give a quantitative account of the numbers of each cell type remaining following each stage of the treatment.
1. Double Colchicine Treatment
2. Force-Feeding
3. Burping
4. Quality Control Via Immunohistochemistry
NOTE: The following protocol is adapted from protocols by Shenk, M. A, et al.18, and Böttger, A19. All steps are done at room temperature (RT) unless otherwise noted. A nutator can be used for the incubation steps and may improve staining quality. However, if the Hydra get tangled up with one another, all steps can also be performed without.
Immediately following the initial 8 h colchicine treatment, all Hydra survive. Some of these Hydra will have only tentacle stubs remaining (Figure 3A), while others will have completely lost their tentacles (Figure 3B). Over the following 1 or 2 days, the tentacles will continue to shrink until all Hydra have lost their tentacles. About 1 week following the treatment, the Hydra will show signs of tentacle regrowth, with small stub like tentacles (Figure 3C) before they fully regenerate their tentacles (Figure 3D). Of the original Hydra, around 50-60% eventually regenerate their tentacles between 1-2 weeks after the treatment.
Following the second treatment, the recovery of the animals is similar to that after the first treatment. Thus, around 10% of the original number of animals that went into both treatments recover and grow to a size suitable for experimentation (Figure 1B). These Hydra have tentacles that appear thinner than those of untreated animals, have tissue which is more transparent, and will appear bloated due to the inability to open their mouths in order to relieve osmotic pressure (Figure 1A, 1B). Any animals that are not fed can survive for a few weeks, however, unfed animals will shrink in size and become increasingly difficult to feed.
Hydra that do recover following the second treatment can be maintained indefinitely. These animals are able to bud, thus sustaining and growing the population. Additionally, the population may be grown by cutting these animals and allowing them to regenerate4.
Immunohistochemistry confirms the loss of neurons in the hypostome following the second colchicine treatment. The dense nerve net in the hypostome can be visualized using an anti-tyrosine-tubulin antibody13,16 and shows distinct fibers radiating outward from the mouth and obvious cell bodies (Figure 4A). These fibers are absent in nerve-free Hydra that have been produced by double-treatment with colchicine (Figure 4B). Furthermore, co-staining with DAPI reveals a reduced number of cell nuclei in the nerve-free Hydra compared to the untreated controls due to the loss of cells of the interstitial cell lineage as a result of the colchicine treatments (Figure 4A, 4B).
Figure 1. Comparison of Nerve-free and Untreated Hydra.
(A) Untreated Hydra. (B) Nerve-free Hydra 22 days following the second colchicine treatment. Note the swollen body column and the thin tentacles in the nerve-free animal. Scale bars are 500 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2. Examples of Deformed Hydra.
(A) Two Hydra that have fused together following the first treatment. (B) An oddly shaped Hydra. (C) A Hydra that has deflated after having its mouth opened. Scale bars are 400 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3. Representative Images of Hydra Following the First 8 h Colchicine Treatment.
(A) A Hydra with stubby tentacles immediately after treatment. (B) A Hydra that has completely lost its tentacles immediately after treatment. (C) A Hydra that is beginning to regrow its tentacles 8 days following the treatment. (D) A Hydra that has completely regrown its tentacles 13 days following the treatment. Scale bars are 400 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4. Loss of Nerve Cells in the Hypostome can be Confirmed by Immunohistochemistry.
(A) The hypostome of an untreated Hydra and (B) hypostome of a nerve-free Hydra approximately 2 weeks following the second colchicine treatment, labeled with (i) anti-tyrosine-tubulin antibody and (ii) DAPI. (iii) shows the overlay. The * indicates the location of the mouth. Maximum z projections were made from spinning disk confocal fluorescence z stacks taken with exposures of 500 ms (GFP) and 15 ms (DAPI). Brightness and contrast were adjusted to improve visibility. Scale bars are 20 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Hydra interstitial cells can be eliminated through a double colchicine treatment3,4. In the days following the first treatment, it is critical to prevent contact between individual Hydra to avoid fusion of Hydra pieces into deformed Hydra. Also, animals that can eat unassisted following the first treatment must be removed as the second colchicine treatment may not be sufficient to eliminate the remaining interstitial cells from such animals. To maximize the survival rate of nerve-free Hydra after the second colchicine treatment, the animals should be fed as many Artemia as possible following recovery from the first treatment, with 1 – 2 days between feedings to recover and grow. Each colchicine treatment causes the Hydra to diminish significantly in size as cells are egested, so the larger the Hydra are prior to each treatment, the better the chances that the Hydra will recover to a size that can be fed and maintained.
Due to the low survival rate of Hydra after each treatment, it may be desirable to start with many Hydra. However, caution must be taken with starting treatment on too many Hydra at once. This will make feeding following the first treatment difficult and extremely time-consuming. Animals fed well after the first treatment recover to larger sizes and therefore have a higher survival rate after the second treatment. Thus, it may be more productive to start with fewer and focus on feeding better. Generally, starting with 50 – 100 animals is manageable for 1 – 2 people. It is also best to begin with the largest Hydra possible, as these will better survive the two treatments.
The method of force-feeding and burping Hydra that are lacking nerve cells described here is safer, simpler, and more time-efficient than methods described in the past3,4,14. The use of commercially available forceps and syringes eliminate the need for hand pulled micropipette tips, which are time consuming and difficult to make. The use of these tools also avoids the need to mouth-pipette. Force-feeding using forceps may be difficult at first but given enough time and practice, it becomes quite easy and efficient. One should first practice force-feeding and burping normal Hydra to get a feel for how much force to use with the tools and how to manipulate Hydra. Various forceps and needle sizes were tested to find the optimal tools for force-feeding and burping.
The use of antibody staining as described here is only adequate to check for the absence of nerve cells in the hypostome. To ensure that all interstitial cells have been eliminated, animals may be macerated and the types of cells present can be examined15.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
The authors thank Dr. Dick Campbell (UC Irvine) for discussions about the original protocol for generating and maintaining nerve-free animals, Ms. Rui Wang for help with adapting the syringe and needle technique, and Ms. Danielle Hagstrom and Dr. Rob Steele (UC Irvine) for comments on the manuscript. This work was supported by the RCSA and NSF grant CMMI-1463572.
Colchicine | Acros Organics | 227120010 | |
1 ml Syringe | BD | 301025 | |
Brine Shrimp Eggs | Brine Shrimp Direct | N/A | Can be purchased locally |
Brine Shrimp Hatchery Dish | Brine Shrimp Direct | N/A | |
60 mm x 15 mm Petri Dish | Celltreat | 229663 | |
30 G x 3/4" Hypodermic Needle | Covidien | 1188830340 | A 27G needle may also be used |
2 x Fine-tip Tweezers | Dumont | 0109-5-PO | |
Rifampicin | EMD Millipore | 557303 | |
Goat anti-mouse lgG, Pab (HRP Conjugate) | Enzo | ADI-SAB-100-J | |
Bovine Serum Albumin (BSA) | Fisher | BP9703-100 | |
Scalpel | Fisher | 08-920A | |
Fetal Bovine Serum (FBS) | Gibco | 10437028 | |
DAPI (4',6-Diamidino-2-Phenylindole, Dihydrochloride) | Invitrogen | D1306 | |
PBS Tablets | MP Bio | 2810305 | |
Monoclonal Anti-Tubulin, Tyrosine | Sigma | T9028 | |
Dimethyl Sulfoxide (DMSO) | Sigma | D2650 | |
Hydrogen Peroxide | Sigma | 216763 | |
Paraformaldehyde (PFA) | Sigma | P6148 | |
Triton X – 100 | Sigma | T9284 | |
Tween 20 | Sigma | P1379 | |
Urethane | Sigma | U2500 | |
Air Pump | Tetra | 77846-00 | |
Glass Pasteur Pipette | VWR | 53283-916 | Length of the pipet does not matter |
15 ml Tube | VWR | 89039-670 | |
P320 Sandpaper | 3M | IBGABBV00397 | Can be purchased at local home improvement store |