Trans- and multi-generational effects of persistent chemicals are essential in judging their long-term consequences in the environment and on the human health. We provide novel detailed methods for studying trans- and multi-generational effects using free-living nematode Caenorhabditis elegans.
Information about toxicities of chemicals are essential in their application and waste management. For chemicals at low concentrations, the long-term effects are very important in judging their consequences in the environment and on human health. In demonstrating long-term influences, effects of chemicals over generations in recent studies provide new insight. Here, we describe protocols for studying effects of chemicals over multiple generations using free-living nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. Two aspects are presented: (1) trans-generational (TG) and (2) multi-generational effect studies, the latter of which is separated to multi-generational exposure (MGE) and multi-generational residual (MGR) effect studies. The TG effect study is robust with a simple purpose to determine whether chemical exposure to parents can result in any residual consequences on offspring. After the effects are measured on parents, sodium hypochlorite solutions are used to kill the parents and keep the offspring so as to facilitate effect measurement on the offspring. The TG effect study is used to determine whether the offspring are affected when their parent is exposed to the pollutants. The MGE and MGR effect study is systematical used to determine whether continuous generational exposure can result in adaptive responses in offspring over generations. Careful pick-up and transfer are used to distinguish generations to facilitate effect measurement on each generation. We also combined protocols to measure locomotion behavior, reproduction, lifespan, biochemical and gene expression changes. Some example experiments are also presented to illustrate the trans- and multi-generational effect studies.
The application and waste management of chemicals is highly dependent upon the information of their effects at certain concentrations. Notably, time is another essential element between effects and concentrations. That is to say, chemicals, especially those at low concentrations in the actual environments, need time to provoke measurable effects1. Therefore, researchers arrange different lengths of the exposure duration in animal experiments, and even cover the whole life cycle. For example, mice were exposed to nicotine for 30, 90 or 180 days to study its toxic effects 2. Yet, such exposure durations are still not enough to elucidate the long-term effects of pollutants (e.g., persistent organic pollutants [POPs]) that can last over generations of organisms in the environment. Therefore, studies on effects over generations are gaining more and more attention.
There are two main aspects in generational effect studies. The first one is the trans-generational (TG) effect study which can robustly test whether chemical exposure to parents can result in any consequences on the offspring3. The second one is a multi-generational effect study which is more systematic with considerations in both exposure and residual effects. On the one hand, the multi-generational exposure (MGE) effects are used to illustrate adaptive responses in the animals to the long-term challenging environments. On the other hand, the multi-generational residual (MGR) effects are used to demonstrate the long-term residual consequences after exposure, since maternal exposure is accompanied with embryo exposure to the first offspring and germ-line exposure to the second offspring which makes the third offspring as the first generation completely out of exposure4.
Although mammals (e.g., mice) are model organisms in toxicity studies especially in relation to human beings, their application in studying generational effects is quite time-consuming, expensive and ethically concerning 5. Accordingly, organisms including crustacean Daphnia magna6, insect Drosophila melanogaster7 and zebrafish Danio rerio8, provide alternative choices. Yet, these organisms either lack similarities to human beings, or require specific equipment in studies.
Caenorhabditis elegans is a small free-living nematode (approximately 1 mm in length) with a short life-cycle (approximately 84 h at 20 °C)9. This nematode shares many biological pathways conservative to human beings, and therefore it has been widely employed to illustrate effects of various stresses or toxicants10. Notably, 99.5% of the nematodes are hermaphrodites making this organisms extremely suitable in studying generational effects, e.g., TG effects of heavy metals and sulfonamides3,11, MGE effects of gold nanoparticles and heavy metals12 and temperature13, MGR effects of sulfonamide14, and both MGE and MGR effects of gamma irradiation15 and lindane4. Furthermore, comparable results were found between the effects of chemicals (e.g., zearalenone) on the development and reproduction of mice and C. elegans16,17, which would provide an advantage to extrapolate effects from this small animal to human beings.
Both TG and MG effect studies are time consuming and need careful design and performance. Notably, differences existed in life-stage choices, exposure conditions and generation separation methods in the aforementioned studies. Such differences hindered the direct comparison among the results and hampered further interpretation of the results. Therefore, it is imperative to establish uniform protocols to guide TG and MG effects studies, and also to provide a bigger picture to reveal similar patterns of various toxicants or pollutants in long-term consequences. The over goal of the present protocols will demonstrate clear operation processes in studying trans- and multi-generational effects with C. elegans. The protocols will benefit researchers that are interested in studying the long-term effects of toxicants or pollutants.
1. Culture E. coli OP50
2. Culture C. elegans
NOTE: Culture C. elegans using as per steps 2.1 to 2.11 based upon standard methods18.
3. Prepare synchronized eggs and L3 larvae of C. elegans
4. Use C. elegans for trans-generational effect study
5. Use C. elegans for multi-generational exposure (MGE) effect study
6. Use C. elegans for multi-generational residual (MGR) effect study
7. Measure indicators
Examples for MGE (F0 to F3) effects on reproduction and lifespan with 3 groups (one control and two exposure treatments). | |||
Day | NGM agar number for MGE study | Explanation | |
Lifespan | Reproduction | ||
0 | 30 (F0 exposure) | 10 replicates for each group, marked as F0-1-1-0 to F0-3-10-0, with the last digit to show the survival days. | |
1 | 30 (F0 survive 1 d) | F0-1-1-0 to F0-3-10-0 should be changed to F0-1-1-1 to F0-3-10-1. | |
2 | 30 (F0 survive 2 d) | F0-1-1-1 to F0-3-10-1 should be changed to F0-1-1-2 to F0-3-10-2. | |
No need to transfer F0 nematodes until 3 d. | |||
3 | 30 (F0 survive 3 d, cleared after nematodes transfer and collection) | After 3 d, F0 nematodes are mature and 36 new NGM agars (with 2 nematodes on each agar) are used to observe their survival and reproduction. | |
36 (F0-1-1-3 to F0-3-12-3) | Preliminary experiments should be performed to arrange the number of F0 nematodes, assuring at least 200 offspring for succeeding multi-generational operations. | ||
Notably, if MGR effects are studied, the F0 nematodes should be transferred onto clear NGM agars without chemical exposure, and it should be noted as T1 start. | |||
Most of the F0 nematodes are collected to measure chemical and genetic indices and the 30 agars in F0 are cleared. | |||
4 | 36 (F0-1-1-4 to F0-3-12-4) | 36 (F1-1-1-1 to F1-3-12-1) | Measurement on lifespan and reproduction requires transfer every day. |
Parent nematodes on F0-1-1-3 to F0-3-12-3 are picked onto new NGM agars marked as F0-1-1-4 to F0-3-12-4. | |||
The remaining offspring nematodes (i.e., F1 in MGE, or T1 in MGR) in F0-1-1-3 to F0-3-12-3 agars have grown for 1 d, and the markers are changed to F1-1-1-1 to F1-3-12-1. These agars are also used to monitor the lifespan of F1 with daily transfer. | |||
5 | 36 (F0-1-1-5 to F0-3-12-5) | 36 (F1-1-1-2 to F1-3-12-2) | Nematodes on F1-1-1-1 to F1-3-12-1 agars have grown for 2 d and become easily observable and the nematodes are counted, and the markers are changed to F1-1-1-2 to F1-3-12-2. |
36 (F0-1-1-4 to F0-3-12-4) | The offspring nematodes in F0-1-1-4 to F0-3-12-4 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
6 | 36 (F0-1-1-6 to F0-3-12-6) | 36 (F0-1-1-4 to F0-3-12-4, cleared after counted) | Nematodes on F1-1-1-2 to F1-3-12-2 agars have grown for 3 d and the markers are changed to F1-1-1-3 to F1-3-12-3. Notably, the F1 nematodes start to reproduce F2 on this day, F1 nematodes should be transferred onto new NGM agars making F2-1-1-0 to F1-3-12-0. For MGR studies, T2 start today. |
36 (F1-1-1-3 to F1-3-12-3) | 36 (F0-1-1-5 to F0-3-12-5) | This can be delayed by chemical exposure, and therefore flexible changes should be performed in each experiment to ensure enough nematodes for subsequent generations. | |
36 (F2-1-1-0 to F1-3-12-0) | The offspring nematodes on F0-1-1-4 to F0-3-12-4 agars have grown for 2 d, and the agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | ||
The offspring nematodes on F0-1-1-5 to F0-3-12-5 agars have grown for 1 d. | |||
7 | 36 (F0-1-1-7 to F0-3-12-7) | 36 (F0-1-1-5 to F0-3-12-5, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes on F0-1-1-5 to F0-3-12-5 agars have grown for 2 d, and the agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. |
36 (F1-1-1-4 to F1-3-12-4) | 36 (F0-1-1-6 to F0-3-12-6) | The overall nematode number in F1-1-1-1 to F1-3-12-1 agars, F0-1-1-4 to F0-3-12-4 agars and F0-1-1-5 to F0-3-12-5 are used to calculate the initial reproduction of F0. | |
36 (F2-1-1-1 to F2-3-12-1) | The offspring nematodes on F0-1-1-6 to F0-3-12-6 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
The F2 nematodes on F2-1-1-0 to F1-3-12-0 have grown for 1 d and their markers are changed into F2-1-1-1 to F2-3-12-1. | |||
8 | 36 (F0-1-1-8 to F0-3-12-8) | 36 (F0-1-1-6 to F0-3-12-6, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes on F0-1-1-6 to F0-3-12-6 agars have grown for 2 d, and the agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. |
36 (F1-1-1-5 to F1-3-12-5) | 36 (F0-1-1-7 to F0-3-12-7) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-7 to F0-3-12-7 agars have grown for 1 d. | |
36 (F2-1-1-2 to F2-3-12-2) | 36 (F1-1-1-4 to F1-3-12-4) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-4 to F1-3-12-4 agars have grown for 1 d. | |
36 (F2-1-1-1 to F2-3-12-1, changed to F2-1-1-2 to F2-3-12-2 after counted) | The F2 nematodes on F2-1-1-1 to F2-3-12-1 have grown for 2 d, the nematodes are counted and their markers are changed into F2-1-1-2 to F2-3-12-2. | ||
9 | 36 (F0-1-1-9 to F0-3-12-9) | 36 (F0-1-1-7 to F0-3-12-7, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-7 to F0-3-12-7 agars have grown for 2 d, and the agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. |
36 (F1-1-1-6 to F1-3-12-6) | 36 (F1-1-1-4 to F1-3-12-4, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-4 to F1-3-12-4 agars have grown for 2 d, and the agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F2-1-1-3 to F2-3-12-3) | 36 (F0-1-1-8 to F0-3-12-8) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-8 to F0-3-12-8 agars have grown for 1 d. | |
36 (F3-1-1-0 to F3-3-12-0) | 36 (F1-1-1-5 to F1-3-12-5) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-5 to F1-3-12-5 agars have grown for 1 d. | |
The F2 nematodes on F2-1-1-2 to F2-3-12-2 have grown for 3 days and their markers are changed to F2-1-1-3 to F2-3-12-3. The F2 nematodes start to reproduce today and they are transferred to 36 new NGM agars are needed and marked as F3-1-1-0 to F3-3-12-0. For MGR studies, T3 start today. | |||
10 | 36 (F0-1-1-10 to F0-3-12-10) | 36 (F0-1-1-8 to F0-3-12-8, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-8 to F0-3-12-8 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. |
36 (F1-1-1-7 to F1-3-12-7) | 36 (F1-1-1-5 to F1-3-12-5, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-5 to F1-3-12-5 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F2-1-1-4 to F2-3-12-4) | 36 (F0-1-1-9 to F0-3-12-9) | The overall nematode number in F2-1-1-1 to F2-3-12-1, F1-1-1-4 to F1-3-12-4 agars and F1-1-1-5 to F1-3-12-5 are used to calculate the initial reproduction of F1. | |
36 (F3-1-1-1 to F3-3-12-1) | 36 (F1-1-1-6 to F1-3-12-6) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-9 to F0-3-12-9 agars have grown for 1 d. | |
The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-6 to F1-3-12-6 agars have grown for 1 d. | |||
The offspring nematode on F3-1-1-0 to F3-3-12-0 agars have grown for 1 d and the markers are changed into F3-1-1-1 to F3-3-12-1. | |||
Notably, the reproduction of F0 nematodes will significantly decrease after the first several days. Therefore, the nematode transfer is not strictly required to be daily after D10 and can be performed every 2 days. Yet, the survival still requires daily observation. | |||
The same rule also applies in F1 (T1, T1’), F2 (T2, T2’) and F3 (T3, T3’). | |||
11 | 36 (F0-1-1-11 to F0-3-12-11) | 36 (F0-1-1-9 to F0-3-12-9, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-9 to F0-3-12-9 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. |
36 (F1-1-1-8 to F1-3-12-8) | 36 (F1-1-1-6 to F1-3-12-6, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-6 to F1-3-12-6 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F2-1-1-5 to F2-3-12-5) | 36 (F0-1-1-10 to F0-3-12-10) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-10 to F0-3-12-10 agars have grown for 1 d. | |
36 (F3-1-1-2 to F3-3-12-2) | 36 (F1-1-1-7 to F1-3-12-7) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-7 to F1-3-12-7 agars have grown for 1 d. | |
36 (F2-1-1-4 to F2-3-12-4) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-4 to F2-3-12-4 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
36 (F3-1-1-1 to F3-3-12-1, changed to F3-1-1-2 to F3-3-12-2 after counting) | The nematodes on F3-1-1-1 to F3-3-12-1 agars have grown for 2 d, the nematodes are counted and the markers are changed into F3-1-1-2 to F3-3-12-2. | ||
12 | 36 (F0-1-1-12 to F0-3-12-12) | 36 (F0-1-1-10 to F0-3-12-10, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-10 to F0-3-12-10 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. |
36 (F1-1-1-9 to F1-3-12-9) | 36 (F1-1-1-7 to F1-3-12-7, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-7 to F1-3-12-7 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F2-1-1-6 to F2-3-12-6) | 36 (F2-1-1-4 to F2-3-12-4, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-4 to F2-3-12-4 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F3-1-1-3 to F3-3-12-3) | 36 (F0-1-1-11 to F0-3-12-11) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-11 to F0-3-12-11 agars have grown for 1 d. | |
36 (F4-1-1-0 to F4-3-12-0) | 36 (F1-1-1-8 to F1-3-12-8) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-8 to F1-3-12-8 agars have grown for 1 d. | |
36 (F2-1-1-5 to F2-3-12-5) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-5 to F2-3-12-5 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
The nematodes on F3-1-1-2 to F3-3-12-2 agars have grown for 3 d and the markers are changed into F3-1-1-3 to F3-3-12-3. The F3 nematodes start to reproduce today and they are transferred to 36 new NGM agars are needed and marked as F4-1-1-0 to F4-3-12-0. For MGR studies, the offspring of F3 (i.e., T1’) start today. | |||
13 | 36 (F0-1-1-13 to F0-3-12-13) | 36 (F0-1-1-11 to F0-3-12-11, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-11 to F0-3-12-11 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. |
36 (F1-1-1-10 to F1-3-12-10) | 36 (F1-1-1-8 to F1-3-12-8, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-8 to F1-3-12-8 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F2-1-1-7 to F2-3-12-9) | 36 (F2-1-1-5 to F2-3-12-5, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-5 to F2-3-12-5 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F3-1-1-4 to F3-3-12-4) | 36 (F0-1-1-12 to F0-3-12-12) | The overall nematode number in F3-1-1-1 to F3-3-12-1, F2-1-1-4 to F2-3-12-4 agars and F2-1-1-5 to F2-3-12-5 are used to calculate the initial reproduction of F2. | |
36 (F4-1-1-1 to F4-3-12-1) | 36 (F1-1-1-9 to F1-3-12-9) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-12 to F0-3-12-12 agars have grown for 1 d. | |
36 (F2-1-1-6 to F2-3-12-6) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-9 to F1-3-12-9 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-6 to F2-3-12-6 agars have grown for 1 d. | |||
The offspring nematodes of F3 on F4-1-1-0 to F4-3-12-0 have grown for 1 d, and markers are changed into F4-1-1-1 to F4-3-12-1. | |||
14 | 36 (F0-1-1-14 to F0-3-12-14) | 36 (F0-1-1-12 to F0-3-12-12, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-12 to F0-3-12-12 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. |
36 (F1-1-1-11 to F1-3-12-11) | 36 (F1-1-1-9 to F1-3-12-9, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-9 to F1-3-12-9 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F2-1-1-8 to F2-3-12-8) | 36 (F2-1-1-6 to F2-3-12-6, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-6 to F2-3-12-6 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F3-1-1-5 to F3-3-12-5) | 36 (F4-1-1-1 to F4-3-12-1, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F4-1-1-1 to F4-3-12-1 have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. For MGR studies, T1’ nematodes have grown for 2 d, and will start to reproduce T2’ on the next day (D15), and T2’ will start to reproduce T3’ on D18. The lifespan of wild type C. elegans is exampled as 15 days. Then, the ending of T3’ lifespan will be on D33. | |
36 (F0-1-1-13 to F0-3-12-13) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-13 to F0-3-12-13 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
36 (F1-1-1-10 to F1-3-12-10) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-10 to F1-3-12-10 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
36 (F2-1-1-7 to F2-3-12-7) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-7 to F2-3-12-7 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
36 (F3-1-1-4 to F3-3-12-4) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-4 to F2-3-12-4 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
15 | 36 (F0-1-1-15 to F0-3-12-15) | 36 (F0-1-1-13 to F0-3-12-13, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-13 to F0-3-12-13 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. |
36 (F1-1-1-12 to F1-3-12-12) | 36 (F1-1-1-10 to F1-3-12-10, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-10 to F1-3-12-10 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F2-1-1-9 to F2-3-12-9) | 36 (F2-1-1-7 to F2-3-12-7, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-7 to F2-3-12-7 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F3-1-1-6 to F3-3-12-6) | 36 (F3-1-1-4 to F3-3-12-4, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-4 to F3-3-12-4 agars have grown for 2d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F0-1-1-14 to F0-3-12-14) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-14 to F0-3-12-14 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
36 (F1-1-1-11 to F1-3-12-11) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-11 to F1-3-12-11 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
36 (F2-1-1-8 to F2-3-12-8) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-8 to F2-3-12-8 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
36 (F3-1-1-5 to F3-3-12-5) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-5 to F2-3-12-5 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
16 | 36 (F0-1-1-15 to F0-3-12-15, over) | 36 (F0-1-1-14 to F0-3-12-14, cleared after counted) | The lifespan of wild type C. elegans is exampled as 15 days. Therefore, F0 should have all died before Day 16 since the exposure. |
36 (F1-1-1-13 to F1-3-12-13) | 36 (F1-1-1-11 to F1-3-12-11, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-14 to F0-3-12-14 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F2-1-1-10 to F2-3-12-10) | 36 (F2-1-1-8 to F2-3-12-8, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-11 to F1-3-12-11 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F3-1-1-7 to F3-3-12-7) | 36 (F3-1-1-5 to F3-3-12-5, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-8 to F2-3-12-8 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F0-1-1-15 to F0-3-12-15) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-5 to F3-3-12-5 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | ||
36 (F1-1-1-12 to F1-3-12-12) | The overall nematode number in F4-1-1-1 to F4-3-12-1, F3-1-1-4 to F3-3-12-4 agars and F3-1-1-5 to F3-3-12-5 are used to calculate the initial reproduction of F3. | ||
36 (F2-1-1-9 to F2-3-12-9) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-15 to F0-3-12-15 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
36 (F3-1-1-6 to F3-3-12-6) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-12 to F1-3-12-12 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-9 to F2-3-12-9 agars have grown for 1 d. | |||
The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-6 to F2-3-12-6 agars have grown for 1 d. | |||
17 | 36 (F1-1-1-14 to F1-3-12-14) | 36 (F0-1-1-15 to F0-3-12-15, cleared after counted, over) | The offspring nematodes of F0 on F0-1-1-15 to F0-3-12-15 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. There will be no more F0 offspring. |
36 (F2-1-1-11 to F2-3-12-11) | 36 (F1-1-1-12 to F1-3-12-12, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-12 to F1-3-12-12 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F3-1-1-8 to F3-3-12-8) | 36 (F2-1-1-9 to F2-3-12-9, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-9 to F2-3-12-9 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F3-1-1-6 to F3-3-12-6, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-6 to F3-3-12-6 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | ||
36 (F1-1-1-13 to F1-3-12-13) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-13 to F1-3-12-13 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
36 (F2-1-1-10 to F2-3-12-10) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-10 to F2-3-12-10 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
36 (F3-1-1-7 to F3-3-12-7) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-7 to F2-3-12-7 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
18 | 36 (F1-1-1-15 to F1-3-12-15) | 36 (F1-1-1-13 to F1-3-12-13, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-13 to F1-3-12-13 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. |
36 (F2-1-1-12 to F2-3-12-12) | 36 (F2-1-1-10 to F2-3-12-10, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-10 to F2-3-12-10 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F3-1-1-9 to F3-3-12-9) | 36 (F3-1-1-7 to F3-3-12-7, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-7 to F3-3-12-7 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F1-1-1-14 to F1-3-12-14) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-14 to F1-3-12-14 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
36 (F2-1-1-11 to F2-3-12-11) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-11 to F2-3-12-11 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
36 (F3-1-1-8 to F3-3-12-8) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-8 to F2-3-12-8 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
In MGR studies, T2’ will start to reproduce T3’ today. The lifespan of wild type C. elegans is exampled as 15 days. Then, the ending of T3’ lifespan will be on D33. | |||
19 | 36 (F1-1-1-15 to F1-3-12-15, over) | 36 (F1-1-1-14 to F1-3-12-14, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-14 to F1-3-12-14 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. |
36 (F2-1-1-13 to F2-3-12-13) | 36 (F2-1-1-11 to F2-3-12-11, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-11 to F2-3-12-11 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F3-1-1-10 to F3-3-12-10) | 36 (F3-1-1-8 to F3-3-12-8, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-8 to F3-3-12-8 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F1-1-1-15 to F1-3-12-15) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-15 to F1-3-12-15 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
36 (F2-1-1-12 to F2-3-12-12) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-12 to F2-3-12-12 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
36 (F3-1-1-9 to F3-3-12-9) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-9 to F2-3-12-9 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
20 | 36 (F2-1-1-14 to F2-3-12-14) | 36 (F1-1-1-15 to F1-3-12-15, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F1 on F1-1-1-14 to F1-3-12-14 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. There will no more F1 offspring. |
36 (F3-1-1-11 to F3-3-12-11) | 36 (F2-1-1-12 to F2-3-12-12, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-12 to F2-3-12-12 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F3-1-1-9 to F3-3-12-9, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-9 to F3-3-12-9 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | ||
36 (F2-1-1-13 to F2-3-12-13) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-13 to F2-3-12-13 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
36 (F3-1-1-10 to F3-3-12-10) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-10 to F2-3-12-10 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
21 | 36 (F2-1-1-15 to F2-3-12-15) | 36 (F2-1-1-13 to F2-3-12-13, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-13 to F2-3-12-13 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. |
36 (F3-1-1-12 to F3-3-12-12) | 36 (F3-1-1-10 to F3-3-12-10, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-10 to F3-3-12-10 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F2-1-1-14 to F2-3-12-14) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-14 to F2-3-12-14 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
36 (F3-1-1-11 to F3-3-12-11) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-11 to F2-3-12-11 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
22 | 36 (F2-1-1-15 to F2-3-12-15, over) | 36 (F2-1-1-14 to F2-3-12-14, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-14 to F2-3-12-14 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. |
36 (F3-1-1-13 to F3-3-12-13) | 36 (F3-1-1-11 to F3-3-12-11, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-11 to F3-3-12-11 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
36 (F3-1-1-12 to F3-3-12-12) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-12 to F2-3-12-12 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
23 | 36 (F3-1-1-14 to F3-3-12-14) | 36 (F2-1-1-15 to F2-3-12-15, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F2 on F2-1-1-15 to F2-3-12-15 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. There will be no more F2 offspring. |
36 (F3-1-1-12 to F3-3-12-12, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-12 to F3-3-12-12 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | ||
36 (F3-1-1-13 to F3-3-12-13) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-13 to F2-3-12-13 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
24 | 36 (F3-1-1-15 to F3-3-12-15) | 36 (F3-1-1-13 to F3-3-12-13, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-13 to F3-3-12-13 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. |
36 (F3-1-1-14 to F3-3-12-14) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-14 to F2-3-12-14 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
25 | 36 (F3-1-1-15 to F3-3-12-15, over) | 36 (F3-1-1-14 to F3-3-12-14, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-14 to F3-3-12-14 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. |
36 (F3-1-1-15 to F3-3-12-15) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-15 to F2-3-12-15 agars have grown for 1 d. | ||
26 | 36 (F3-1-1-15 to F3-3-12-15, cleared after counted) | The offspring nematodes of F3 on F3-1-1-15 to F3-3-12-15 agars have grown for 2 d, and agars are cleared after the nematodes are counted. | |
Notably, in MGR studies, the first non-exposed offspring of F3 (i.e., T3’) would be born on D18. The lifespan of wild type C. elegans is exampled as 15 days. Then, the ending of T3’ lifespan will be on D33. | |||
Both MGE and MGR studies will cover more days when the nematode lifespan is longer. |
Table 1: List of markers and their definitions.
Here, we describe protocols for studying effects of chemicals over generations using C. elegans in trans-generational (TG), multi-generational exposure (MGE) and multi-generational residual (MGR) effect studies. Our own research results are presented as examples. One study presents the TG effects of heavy metals on locomotion behavior3. The other two studies present MGE and MGR effects of sulfomethoxazole and lindane on the reproduction and biochemical and genetic indices measurements4,14.
TG effects of heavy metals on locomotion behavior of C. elegans
The TG effects of cadmium (Cd), copper (Cu), lead (Pb) and zinc (Zn) on the body bending frequency (BBF) were studied in the nematode parent (F0) after maternal exposure and their progeny (T1)3. The effects of metals on BBF showed that the inhibitions in T1 were greater than in F0, demonstrating more severe toxicities of heavy metals on the locomotion behavior in the embryo-exposed offspring than in the directly exposed parent. The TG effects of heavy metals at environmentally realistic concentrations demonstrated that maternal exposure can multiply the hazards of heavy metal pollution in succeeding generations. See Figure 1.
Figure 1: The effects of cadmium (Cd), copper (Cu), lead (Pb) and zinc (Zn) on the body bending frequency of the nematode parent (F0, blank) after prenatal exposure and their progeny (T1, shaded). Error bar = standard error; * = significantly different from the control, p < 0.05; # = significantly different from the lower concentration, p < 0.05; + implies significantly different effects in F1 than in F0, p < 0.05. This figure has been modified from Yu et al.3 with permission. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
MGR effects of sulfamethoxazole (SMX) on the nematode lifespan and reproduction
The MGR effects of sulfamethoxazole (SMX) on the nematode lifespan and reproduction14 were studied on the gestating parent (F0), embryo-exposed offspring (T1), germline-exposed offspring (T2), the first non-exposed offspring (T3) and the three following generations (T4-T6). Results showed that the reproduction (a total brood size as 49% of the control) were significantly affected in germline exposure (T2), and the toxicities persisted in non-exposed generations from T3 to T6 generations (Figure 2). Our findings raised new concerns regarding the long-term influences of antibiotics themselves besides their effects on antibiotic resistance.
Figure 2: Brood size (in (A), expressed in percentage of control) and initial reproduction (in (B)) of C. elegans in the exposed parent and its offspring (F0, T1 to T6, from left to right at each concentration). Error bar = standard error; a = significantly different from the control by ANOVA (p < 0.05); b = significantly different from the control and from the earlier generation at the same concentration (p < 0.05); c = significantly different from the control and from the lower concentration in the same generation (p < 0.05); d = significantly different from the control and from the earlier generation at the same concentration and the lower concentration in the same generation (p < 0.05); e = significantly different from the earlier generation at the same concentration and the lower concentration in the same generation (p < 0.05); f = significantly different from the earlier generation at the same concentration (p < 0.05). This figure has been modified from Yu et al.14 with permission.
MGE and MGR effects of lindane on the nematode biochemical and genetic indices
The MGE and MGR effects of lindane (a persistent organic pollutant [POP]) were studied on key biochemicals in the lipid metabolisms and genetic expression changes in the related insulin-like pathway4. Results showed that lindane showed obesogenic effects with disturbances in the insulin signal regulation (Figure 3). Moreover, the changes between sgk-1 (F0, F3, T1' and T3') and akt-1 (T1 and T3) signaling indicated that nematodes from different exposure generations showed different response strategies for tolerance and avoidance.
Figure 3: Changes of expression levels of key genes in insulin-like signal pathway in nematodes with different exposure experiences. →: positive regulation; : negative regulation; ↑: expression up-regulation; ↓: expression down-regulation. This figure has been modified from Chen at al.4 with permission. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
In order to successfully conduct the described protocol, the following suggestions should be taken into consideration. Perform the overall experimental operations in a sterile environment. Improper operation may result in contamination of the E. coli strains, e.g., fungi and mites may hinder the normal growth of C. elegans and therefore affect the experimental results. In the section describing cultivating C. elegans, observe the growth scale of C. elegans on the NGM agars by naked eyes or microscopes. When the scale of C. elegans on the agar exceeds 75% in area, or the culture time exceeds one week, perform a new round of inoculation to avoid over-growth or population decline of C. elegans. Before the process of the synchronization, use a microscope to observe the growth of C. elegans, and continue the process when nematode eggs are widely distributed on the agar. In addition, if solvents (e.g., dimethyl sulfoxide [DMSO]) are used, their concentrations in the stock solutions should be lower than 1% to ensure that their final concentrations do not exceed 0.5% (v/v) to avoid the adverse effects of the solvents themselves. In TG effect studies, the duration of exposure over 24 h is necessary to ensure that the exposure time covers the embryo formation of the next generation, and the duration should be within 96 h to facilitate the subsequent generation separation. Use small amounts of nematodes (usually within 20) for measuring the lifespan and reproduction. On the other hand, use large amounts of nematodes (usually more than 500) for measuring biochemical and genetic regulation indices. Hence, in order to ensure sufficient number of samples, perform preliminary experiments to roughly estimate how many offspring the mature F0 nematodes can reproduce within the first 24 h since they start reproduction. Then determine the number of F0 nematodes required to ensure there are at least 200 offspring for the proceeding multi-generational studies.
As compared with earlier reports of TG studies with C. elegans, the present experimental protocol was more considerate of the choice of life stage. In C. elegans, sperms are formed at L4 stage to fertilize the later-formed oocytes23. Accordingly, the exposure covering the spermiogenesis and oocytogenesis period will provide a particular window to study the TG effects on the offspring. The age-synchronized eggs are used for multi-generational effect studies to ensure that the exposure covers the overall period from the beginning of each life cycle. Compared with earlier multi-generational studies, the present experimental protocol facilitated the measurement of effects over multiple generations instead of only 1-2 generations. Moreover, the present protocol considered both MGE and MGR effects, which is more systematic than earlier studies that only measured MGE or MGR effects.
Notably, there are still some issues to be considered in the present experimental protocol. The present protocol employs wild-type C. elegans whose generation time is around 60 h and lifespan is 20 days. This makes the overall duration of the experiment fairly long (e.g., MGE effects study on lifespan over 3 generations requires at least 30 days). In order to shorten the time, researchers can choose mutant C. elegans, such as the short-lived mutant nematodes. Another issue is the killing treatment on the bacteria, the live status of which is necessary to keep nematodes healthy 24. Also, the UV killing process might introduce changes in the chemicals25. Therefore, other treatments on the bacteria should be considered, and careful monitoring on the chemical changes during the preparation or exposure process may be necessary, especially for unstable compounds. At the same time, there are limitations in studying the sex differences in toxic effects because most of the fact that C. elegans is hermaphrodite. Further improvements to investigate the sex contribution in the TG, MGE or MGR effects are needed. In summary, we anticipate that the proposed protocol will be great significance for using C. elegans to study TG, MGE and MGR effects of toxicants.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
agar powder | OXOID, Thermo Fisher Scientific, UK | 9002-18-0 | |
79nnHT Fast Real-Time PCR System | Applied Biosystems | ||
96-well sterile microplate | Costar,Corning,America | ||
Autoclave sterilizer | Tomy, Tomy Digital Biology, Japan | ||
Biosafety cabinet | LongYue, Shanghai longyue instrument equipment co. Ltd, China | ||
calcium chloride | Sinopharm chemical reagent company Ltd, China | 10043-52-4 | |
centrifuge 5417R | Eppendorf, Ai Bende (Shanghai) International Trade Co., Ltd, Germany | ||
Centrifuge tubes | Axygen, Aixjin biotechnology (Hangzhou) co. Ltd, America | ||
cholesterol | Sinopharm chemical reagent company Ltd, China | 57-88-5 | |
Dimethyl sulfoxide | VETEC, Sigmar aldrich (Shanghai) trading co. Ltd, America | 67-68-5 | |
disodium hydrogen phosphate | Sinopharm chemical reagent company Ltd, China | 7558-79-4 | |
ethanol | Sinopharm chemical reagent company Ltd, China | 64-17-5 | |
Filter | Thermo, Thermo Fisher Scientific, America | ||
incubator | YiHeng17, Shanghai yiheng scientific instrument co. Ltd, China | ||
inoculating loop | |||
K2HPO4•3H2O | Sinopharm chemical reagent company Ltd, China | 16788-57-1 | |
kraft paper | |||
Mcroplate Reader | Boitek, Boten apparatus co. Ltd, America | ||
MgSO4•7H2O | Sinopharm chemical reagent company Ltd, China | 10034-99-8 | |
Microscopes XTL-BM-9TD | BM, Shanghai BM optical instruments manufacturing co. Ltd, China | ||
Petri dishes | |||
Pipette | Eppendorf, Ai Bende (Shanghai) International Trade Co., Ltd, Germany | ||
Potassium chloride | Sinopharm chemical reagent company Ltd, China | 7447-40-7 | |
potassium dihydrogen phosphate | Sinopharm chemical reagent company Ltd, China | 7778-77-0 | |
Qiagen RNeasy kits | Qiagen Inc., Valencia, CA, United States | ||
QuantiTect SYBR Green RT-PCR kits | Qiagen Inc., Valencia, CA, United States | ||
RevertAid First Strand cDNA Synthesis Kit | Thermo Scientific, Wilmington, DE, United States | ||
sodium chloride | Sinopharm chemical reagent company Ltd, China | 7647-14-5 | |
sodium hydroxide | Sinopharm chemical reagent company Ltd, China | 1310-73-2 | |
sodium hypochlorite solution | Aladdin, Shanghai Aladdin biochemical technology co. Ltd, China | 7681-52-9 | |
tryptone | OXOID, Thermo Fisher Scientific, UK | 73049-73-7 | |
yeast extract | OXOID, Thermo Fisher Scientific, UK | 119-44-8 |