The disproportionation reaction of a metastable Sn(I) chloride solution, obtained via the preparative co-condensation technique, is used for the synthesis of a metalloid tin cluster compound.
The number of well-characterized metalloid tin clusters, synthesized by applying the disproportionation of a metastable Sn(I) halide in the presence of a sterically demanding ligand, has increased in recent years. The metastable Sn(I) halide is synthesized at "outer space conditions" via the preparative co-condensation technique. Thereby, the subhalide is synthesized in an oven at high temperatures, around 1,300 °C, and at reduced pressure by the reaction of elemental tin with hydrogen halide gas (e.g., HCl). The subhalide (e.g., SnCl) is trapped within a matrix of an inert solvent, like toluene at -196 °C. Heating the solid matrix to -78 °C gives a metastable solution of the subhalide. The metastable subhalide solution is highly reactive but can be stored at -78 °C for several weeks. On heating the solution to room temperature, a disproportionation reaction occurs, leading to elemental tin and the corresponding dihalide. By applying bulky ligands like Si(SiMe3)3, the intermediate metalloid cluster compounds can be trapped before complete disproportionation to elemental tin. Hence, the reaction of a metastable Sn(I)Cl solution with Li-Si(SiMe3)3 gives [Sn10(Si(SiMe3)3)4]2– 1 as black crystals in high yield. 1 is formed via a complex reaction sequence including salt metathesis, disproportionation, and degradation of larger clusters. Further, 1 can be analyzed by various methods like NMR or single crystal X-ray structure analysis.
Due to recent progress in the field of nanotechnology, the nanoscale size range between molecules and the solid state became more and more important and is the focus of various research efforts1. Research with nanoscaled compounds is especially of interest for metals or semimetals, as drastic changes take place during the transformation from small molecular species (e.g., oxides, halides: non-conducting; e.g., AlCl3, AuCl3, GeO2, etc.) to metalloid clusters2 of the general formulae MnRm (n>m; M = metal such as Al, Au, Sn, etc.; R = ligand such as S-C6H4-COOH, N(SiMe3)2, etc.), to the final bulk elemental phase (metal: conducting; semimetal: semiconducting; e.g., elemental Al, Au, or Ge)3.
The synthesis of a definite molecular nanoscaled compound is challenging due to its metastable character. Many synthetic procedures give metal nanoparticles with a certain size distribution4, meaning a mixture of metalloid cluster compounds of different sizes. Consequently, to establish a basis for a structure-property relationship of nanoscaled materials, synthetic procedures must be developed to access definite nanoscaled molecular compounds. These definite molecular compounds (metalloid clusters in the case of metals5,6,7,8) will shed light on the complexity and the fundamental principles of deceptively simple chemistry, such as the dissolution and the formation of metals9.
One synthetic route to access metalloid clusters of various metals starts from the reduction of stable precursors that are reduced to form a metalloid cluster, mostly in low yield (e.g., metalloid group 14 clusters like Sn15(DippNSiMe3)6 (Dipp = 2,6-iPr2-C6H3)10, Pb10(Hyp)6 (Hyp = Si(SiMe3)3)11, or Ge5(CH(SiMe3)2)412). Additionally, an increasing number of metalloid clusters of coinage metals are synthesized via the reduction of precursors in the presence of a trapping ligand like [Ag44(p-MBA)30]4– (p-MBA = p-mercaptobenzoic acid)13 and Au102(p-MBA)4414. Beside the synthetic route of applying the reductive dehalogenation, Schnöckel et al. introduced a synthetic route to metalloid group 13 clusters by applying the disproportionation reaction of highly reactive metastable monohalides of the corresponding element (e.g., 3AlCl → 2Al + AlCl3).
The synthesis of the needed monohalides is thereby performed via a preparative co-condensation technique, where at high temperatures, gas-phase molecules of AlX and GaX (X = Cl, Br, I) are synthesized and afterwards trapped in a matrix of frozen solvents (Figure 1)15. This technique thus gives access to novel reagents, opening the way to novel areas of chemistry (e.g., starting from the metastable monohalides, metalloid clusters with diameters in the nanometer range like [Al77(N(SiMe3)2)20]2– or [Ga84(N(SiMe3)2)20]4– could be obtained)16,17.
The synthetic route via the disproportionation reaction is thus the most productive, leading to clusters with diameters in the nanometer range. However, this synthetic route is only possible if a metastable subhalide is at hand that disproportionates at low temperatures (normally far below 0 °C). Again, in the case of group 14, monohalides are needed, as the subvalent dihalides MX2 (M = Ge, Sn, Pb) are too stable and disproportionate at temperatures well above 100 °C. The synthesis of metastable group 14 monohalide solutions is possible via the preparative co-condensation technique. However, group 14 monohalides are obtained at much higher temperatures with respect to the group 13 monohalides, which are readily available as gas phase species at 1,000 °C. Hence, SnBr is obtained in maximum yield at 1,250 °C18, whereas GeBr19, as well as SiCl220, are obtained at even higher temperatures, up to 1,600 °C. The monohalides are "trapped" via a preparative co-condensation technique (Figure 1), leading to metastable monohalide solutions. Starting from these metastable solutions, we were recently able to synthesize a variety of novel metalloid group 14 cluster compounds of germanium and tin, namely [Li(thf)2]3[Ge14(Hyp)5] (Hyp = Si(SiMe)3)21, Sn10(Hyp)622, and {[Li([12]crown-4)2]}2 [Sn10(Hyp)4]23. Here, we present the synthesis of a metastable Sn(I)Cl solution within a homemade co-condensation apparatus and describe its reactivity with LiHyp to give the metalloid cluster [Sn10(Hyp)4]2– 1 in high yield.
CAUTION! Please consult all relevant material safety data sheets (MSDS) before use. Several of the chemicals used in these syntheses are acutely toxic, pyrophoric, and carcinogenic. Nanomaterials may have additional hazards compared to their bulk counterpart. Please use all appropriate safety practices when performing a reaction, including the use of engineering controls (fume hood and glovebox) and personal protective equipment (safety glasses, gloves, lab coat, full length pants, and closed-toe shoes). Portions of the following procedures involve standard air-free Schlenk techniques. The co-condensation apparatus applied contains a 20 kW high-frequency generator. People with a cardiac pacemaker can have strictly no admittance. Gaseous HCl is highly corrosive. Store in a well-ventilated place or in a fume hood. Liquid nitrogen and dry ice are extremely cold substances; special gloves must be used to prevent frostbite.
1. Preliminary Work
2. Set up the Co-condensation Apparatus
3. Co-condensation Reaction
4. Synthesis of Sn10(Hyp)42–
The principle of the matrix isolation technique in conjugation with the preparative co-condensation technique is shown (Figure 1), as well as the setup of the co-condensation apparatus (Figure 2) and the graphite reactor (Figure 3). Figures 4 and 5 show photos of the assembly of the co-condensation apparatus. In Figure 6, the gas supply components with the mass flow controller are shown. Figure 7 shows the main apparatus shortly before the steel vessel is fixed to the main flange to close the co-condensation apparatus. The principle of the synthetic route to the metalloid cluster compound 1 by applying the disproportionation reaction of the metastable subhalide SnCl is shown in Figure 8. In Figure 9 (a)-(c), the NMR spectra of dissolved crystals of Li2(tmeda)4Sn10Hyp4 are shown (a: 1H-, b: 13C, and c: 29Si-NMR) and (d) shows the molecular structure of 1 as determined by X-ray crystallographic analysis.
Figure 1. Principle of the preparative co-condensation technique. Left: Within a reactor, a molecule is synthesized at a high temperature and is condensed together with an inert solvent on a cold surface (middle) forming the matrix (right). The solvent is used in large excess so that the MX molecules are completely separated in the solid matrix. Heating of the matrix above the melting temperature of the solvent gives a metastable solution of MX at a low temperature that can be used for further applications (M = Al, Ga, Si, Ge, Sn; X = Cl, Br, I). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2. 3D-Model of the co-condensation apparatus without the gas-supplying part. To show the interior setup inside the apparatus (graphite reactor, induction coil, copper cooling shield, etc.), the apparatus is sliced on the left side.
Figure 3. Graphite reactor. (a) General setup of the graphite reactor with the stack of reaction chambers. (b) Example of a reaction chamber, which should be filled with the metal (in the present case, elemental tin) prior to use. (c) Photo of the necessary pieces of the graphite reactor. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4. Mounted graphite reactor. Photo of the graphite reactor mounted inside the induction coil, together with the top copper sheet.
Figure 5. Mounted reaction chamber. Photo of the copper cooling shield during assembly, together with the solvent vapor diffuser placed below the copper cooling shield.
Figure 6. Gas supply part. Photo of the assembled gas supply components. The HCl glass vessel is attached to the steel cannula at the bottom of the picture and is not shown. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 7. Open apparatus. Photo of the co-condensation apparatus during assembly shortly before the steel vessel is fixed. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 8. Formation of a metalloid tin cluster applying the disproportionation reaction. General scheme for the synthesis of a metalloid tin cluster applying the disproportionation reaction of a metastable Sn(I)halide. At the bottom, the subsequent degradation of the primarily formed, bigger metalloid clusters into smaller basic units (yellow spheres) is shown. This second step thereby yields even smaller units (bottom right), with an open ligand shell as the final product (X = halide, here Cl; L = bulky ligand, here Si(SiMe3)3).
Figure 9. Characterization of [Li(tmeda)2]2Sn10Hyp4. The respective NMR spectra for crystals of [Li(tmeda)2]2Sn10Hyp4 (solvent: THF-d8): (a) 1H-NMR spectra; (b) 13C-NMR spectra; (c) 29Si-NMR spectra. In (d), the molecular structure of [Sn10Hyp4] 1 is shown. Thermal ellipsoids are shown at 25% probability, and the CH3 groups are shown transparent for clarity. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
By applying the preparative co-condensation technique (Figure 1)25, novel materials based on molecules like SnBr are obtained. Due to the high flexibility in temperature, pressure, metal, and reactive gas, a large variety of metastable solutions of high reactive species can be synthesized. For example, subhalides of silicon and germanium are already obtained in this way. However, finding the right conditions to obtain a metastable solution for further synthesis is not trivial, and the solutions usually must be handled at very low temperatures (e.g., -78 °C). Additionally, the synthesis needs a co-condensation apparatus that is not standard equipment for a chemical laboratory. However, after solving this primary aspect, novel materials are available that might open new doors of chemical syntheses based on metastable solutions of somehow unattainable or even esoteric molecules. Nevertheless, these metastable solutions were up to now the best starting compounds for the synthesis of metalloid group 14 clusters, especially for Ge and Sn6,7. Thus, the intrinsic reactivity of the disproportionation reaction (4 MX → 3M + MX4; M = Ge, Sn) is combined with a salt metathesis reaction by reacting the solutions with an organolithium compound like LiHyp or LiN(SiMe3)2.
The reaction path starting from a binary halide like SnCl and ending with a metalloid cluster like [Sn10Hyp4]2– 1, as exemplified in Figure 8, is very complex, and finding the right reaction conditions for a successful synthesis might not be possible. However, although such a complex reaction system is present, the reaction of SnCl with LiHyp, as described above, gives the metalloid cluster [Sn10Hyp4]2– 1 with a high yield of 60%. This behavior might be explained by a second degradation step of the primarily formed mixture of metalloid tin clusters (Figure 8). Luckily, the ratio of SnCl and SnCl2 of the metastable solution plays only a minor role during the synthesis of [Sn10Hyp4]2– 1. Hence, applying different solutions with different tin:halide ratios, we found that 1 can be isolated in good yield within a tin:halide ratio of 1:1.05 to 1:1.35. Due to the robust reaction, as well as the high yield of isolated compounds, the metalloid cluster [Sn10Hyp4]2– 1 is an ideal compound for further reactions26,27. The major drawback of the high reactivity of the metalloid cluster [Sn10Hyp4]2– 1 is that it is not stable in solution at room temperature, so the subsequent reactions have to be performed at -78 °C, restricting certain reagents.
1 is isolated in the form of single crystals; thus, its molecular structure can be experimentally determined by single crystal X-ray structural analysis. This first insight into the structural behavior of nanoscaled metalloid tin clusters on an atomic scale is a good basis to establish a structure-property relationship in the field of tin nanoparticles or group 14 nanoparticles in general. We have demonstrated a convenient synthesis of the metalloid tin cluster [Sn10Hyp4]2– 1 using a metastable Sn(I) chloride solution synthesized via a co-condensation technique. The synthesis applies the disproportionation reaction, which is an intrinsic ability of the metastable monohalide solutions.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
We are grateful to the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) for financial support, and we thank Dr. Daniel Werner for helpful discussions.
Tin 99.999% | ABCR | AB122397 | |
HydrogenchlorideN28 99.8% | Air Liquide | P0820S10R0A001 | Toxic |
Toluene anhydrous 99.8% | Sigma Aldrich | 244511 | |
Tri-n-butylphosphine >93.5% | Sigma Aldrich | 90827 | Toxic |
TMEDA, >99.5% | Sigma Aldrich | 411019 | |
12-crown-4 | Sigma Aldrich | 194905 | Toxic |
THF anhydrous, >99.9% | Sigma Aldrich | 401757 | |
Sodium, 99.95% | Sigma Aldrich | 262715 | |
Benzophenone, >99% | Sigma Aldrich | 427551 | |
Differential pressure manometer | MKS | MKS Baratron 223B | |
Mass flow controller | Bronckhorst | Low Δp flow mass flow controller | |
High frequency generator | Trumpf Hüttinger | TruHeat MF 5020 | |
NMR spectrometer | Bruker | Bruker DRX-250 | |
Glovebox | GS Systemtechnik | ||
Argon 5.0 | Westfalen | ||
Nitrogen 4.8 | Westfalen | ||
Graphite | SGL | ||
Quartz glass tube | Gebr. Rettberg GmbH | ||
Steel transferring cannula | Rohre Ketterer | ||
Balance | Kern | Kern PFB200-3 | |
Oil diffusion pump | Balzers | Balzers Diff900 | |
Rotary vane pump | Balzers | Balzers QK100L4D | |
Pyrometer | Sensotherm | 6285 | |
Schlenk tubes with glassy stopcocks | Gebr. Rettberg GmbH | J.-Young-type valve with glassy stopcock |