This paper describes a method to create wounds in the epithelium of a live Clytia hemisphaerica medusa and image wound healing at a high resolution in vivo. Additionally, a technique to introduce dyes and drugs to perturb signaling processes in the epithelial cells and extracellular matrix during wound healing is presented.
All animal organs, from the skin to eyes to intestines, are covered with sheets of epithelial cells that allow them to maintain homeostasis while protecting them from infection. Therefore, it is not surprising that the ability to repair epithelial wounds is critical to all metazoans. Epithelial wound healing in vertebrates involves overlapping processes, including inflammatory responses, vascularization, and re-epithelialization. Regulation of these processes involves complex interactions between epithelial cells, neighboring cells, and the extracellular matrix (ECM); the ECM contains structural proteins, regulatory proteins, and active small molecules. This complexity, together with the fact that most animals have opaque tissues and inaccessible ECMs, makes wound healing difficult to study in live animals. Much work on epithelial wound healing is therefore performed in tissue culture systems, with a single epithelial cell-type plated as a monolayer on an artificial matrix. Clytia hemisphaerica (Clytia) provides a unique and exciting complement to these studies, allowing epithelial wound healing to be studied in an intact animal with an authentic ECM. The ectodermal epithelium of Clytia is a single layer of large squamous epithelial cells, allowing high-resolution imaging using differential interfering contrast (DIC) microscopy in living animals. The absence of migratory fibroblasts, vasculature, or inflammatory responses makes it possible to dissect the critical events in re-epithelialization in vivo. The healing of various types of wounds can be analyzed, including single-cell microwounds, small and large epithelial wounds, and wounds that damage the basement membrane. Lamellipodia formation, purse string contraction, cell stretching, and collective cell migration can all be observed in this system. Furthermore, pharmacological agents can be introduced via the ECM to modify cell:ECM interactions and cellular processes in vivo. This work shows methods for creating wounds in live Clytia, capturing movies of healing, and probing healing mechanisms by microinjecting reagents into the ECM.
Sheets of epithelial cells cover the external surface of all metazoans, line internal organs, and divide the animal body into discrete compartments. The epithelium also separates the inner body from the external environment and protects it from damage and infection. Hence, the advent of epithelial layers was an essential part of the evolution of multicellular animals, and epithelial layers are seen in all animals from vertebrates to the most basal metazoans1. The epithelium of some organs is a single monolayer, such as in the lung air sacs, blood vessels, and gut2, as well as in the epidermis of invertebrates such as planaria and cnidarians3. In other tissues, such as the skin4 and cornea5 of vertebrates, the epithelium is stratified, meaning there are multiple epithelial cell layers2. In all cases, the most basal epithelial layer is affixed to the basement membrane, a protein sheet that forms a specialized region of the extracellular matrix (ECM)6,7,8.
Breaches in the epithelium must be rapidly repaired to recreate a continuous epithelial sheet. Damage to the epithelium occurs during natural processes, such as the shedding of epithelial cells in the gut,9,10 and as the result of inflammation or physical trauma. When a single epithelial cell is damaged, it must either repair itself or be eliminated to allow the surrounding cells to attach to each other and close the hole11,12. In wounds larger than the size of a single cell, epithelial cells must move to reach each other and repair the sheet13. This may be achieved by cell spreading if the gaps are small or may require the migration of epithelial cells from the margins of a wound to close the wound gap; this latter process is called re-epithelialization14,15. In embryonic tissues, epithelial cells spread and migrate to close wounds or are pulled across the gap by the contraction of actomyosin cables that form between the cells at the wound margin, in a mechanism resembling a purse string16. In many adult tissues, re-epithelialization involves the migration of coherent cell sheets, where cells maintain their junctions with neighboring cells14,17,18. In other tissues, cell:cell connections are dismantled and epithelial cells behave more like mesenchymal cells, moving in a coordinated but independent manner into the wound region during re-epithelialization14,19,20,21.
Epithelial cell movements are regulated by complex interactions between the migrating cells and between the cells and the ECM. While there is a tremendous amount of experimental literature addressing mechanisms of wound-activation of epithelial cells and subsequent migration, much still remains to be discovered. For example, the initial signal that activates epithelial cells to migrate in response to a wound has not been definitively identified22, nor is it completely understood how actin is redeployed to create lamellipodia on the side of epithelial cells closest to the wound22,23,24,25,26,27. Collective cell migration requires information from cells at the wound to be shared with cells distal to the wound, and the communication pathway is still unclear28. Cell:cell junctions and cell:ECM attachments must be disassembled and reformed as cells in the sheet rearrange themselves, but regulation of this process is poorly understood14,29. Making progress on these and other related questions is not only important as a fundamental biological problem but also because of the clinical significance of correct wound healing. Diseases that compromise the ability of epithelial cells to migrate correctly result in chronic wounds; an example is the genetic disease epidermolysis bullosa, where genes involved in the attachment of the epithelial cells to the ECM are mutated, resulting in fragile skin that peels and blisters. Re-epithelialization is also compromised in naturally aging tissues30,31. A better understanding is therefore essential for developing interventions to improve wound healing outcomes.
Epithelial cell migration in wound healing has been studied using both in vitro approaches and model organisms. The majority of studies of wound healing and mechanisms of cell migration have been carried out in tissue culture, where monolayers of a single epithelial cell type are grown on a substrate that substitutes for the ECM. Cell monolayers are either scratched or grown with stencils to create gaps of specific shapes and sizes and then observed32,33,34. The in vitro model allows an ideal visualization of cell behavior, as well as the opportunity to change qualities of the substrate, to expose cells to drugs and abiotic and biotic factors, and to transfect cells with constructs that express or suppress various genes of interest. However, this reductionist approach may fail to capture some of the important parameters involved in epithelial cell behavior in an in vivo context, including communication between various cell types and signaling events that occur in the ECM11. In vivo models provide the authentic context of a wound, with multiple cell types, overlapping signaling pathways, and a complex ECM35. One such model for wound healing studies is the mouse19, in which recent advances have allowed researchers to observe epidermal cells during healing of full thickness wounds in live animals36. The mouse and other in vivo systems present challenges to study re-epithelialization, however. First, the great advantage of observing cell behavior in a natural context is balanced by the complexity of the temporally overlapping events that occur during vertebrate wound healing, including blood clotting, recruitment of immune cells and inflammation, recruitment of fibroblasts, and cell de-differentiation, re-vascularization, and remodeling of the ECM. Further, opaque tissues make imaging difficult. The Drosophila larva and Zebrafish epidermis systems37,38 have overcome some of these difficulties because of their relative simplicity39.
Our lab recently introduced a new model for studying epithelial wound healing: the medusa (jellyfish) form of the hydrozoan cnidarian Clytia hemisphaerica (Clytia)40. Clytia is an emerging model organism with a fully sequenced and annotated genome41, single cell RNAseq transcriptome42, and protocols in place for genome modification (mutagenesis and transgenesis)43,44,45. Cnidarians are one of the oldest extant lineages to have epithelial layers, so understanding cnidarian wound healing provides insights into the ancestral pathways that ensured epithelial integrity. For those pathways that have been conserved throughout the tree of life, Clytia offers an exciting new system to study epithelial cell dynamics and the functional regulation of wound healing in vivo.
The epithelium covering the upper surface of the Clytia medusa (exumbrella) is a monolayer of transparent, squamous epithelial cells that are approximately 50 µm wide by 1-2 µm thick (Figure 1). They are attached to an ECM called the mesoglea — the "jelly" of the jellyfish. The mesoglea is compositionally similar to the ECM found in other animals46,47,48 including vertebrates, has a basement membrane40, and is completely transparent. The epithelial layer in the Clytia medusa can be easily scratched or wounded (see below). The simplicity and transparency of the epithelium and ECM allows high resolution imaging of the cells and their movements during healing. Recently, Kamran et al. characterized the healing of small wounds in the Clytia epithelium in detail40. It was demonstrated that healing in Clytia occurs through lamellipodia-based cell-crawling, cell spreading, and collective cell migration, as well as purse string closure that is more typical of embryonic systems (although seen previously in adult animal structures such as the cornea49). Clytia wound healing is extremely fast, as has been seen in other systems that lack an inflammatory response40,50. Healing in the Clytia exumbrella is completely dependent on movements of the existing epithelial cells — no cells proliferate or migrate through the ECM to the wound site (Supplemental Movie 1). All of these findings suggest that Clytia is a useful model system to study epithelial wound healing. Indeed, the ease of imaging epithelial cells in Clytia during wound healing led to the discovery that epithelial cell lamellipodia extend and spread over areas of exposed ECM as long as there is an intact basement membrane; if the basement membrane is damaged, epithelial healing switches to a purse string mechanism40. This was the first demonstration of a mechanism underlying the decision to close by lamellipodia-based crawling versus purse string closure, highlighting the importance of specific cell:ECM interactions in healing and of observing cells in their natural context.
Below, protocols are described for creating and imaging single-cell microwounds, small wounds that close primarily by cell spreading, and large wounds that require collective cell migration to close. Furthermore, a protocol is described for the introduction of small molecules into the ECM and epithelial cells, allowing experimental perturbations of putative regulatory pathways of wound healing.
1. Animal culture
2. Wounding
Figure 1: Intact and wounded exumbrella epithelial layer in Clytia medusa. (A) Cartoon graphic of the Clytia medusa body. (A') Intact medusa exumbrella epithelium viewed from above. (B) Cartoon of single-cell microwounds (red jagged shapes) with epithelial cells in blue. (B') Single cell microwounds. (C) Cartoon of a small epithelial wound (red jagged shape). (C') Small epithelial wound. (D) Cartoon of a large epithelial wound (red jagged shape). (D') Large epithelial wound. Images were all obtained using DIC microscopy. Scale bars in (A'–C'): 50 µm. Scale bar in (D'): 100 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Multiple size wounds and a damaged basement membrane. A typical small exumbrella epithelial wound is shown, with labels indicating lamellipodia that form from marginal cells. In addition, microwounds within and between epithelial cells are seen. Note the small basement membrane tear in the upper portion of the wound. Movie 4 shows healing of this wound. Scale bar: 50 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
3. Imaging epithelial wound healing
Figure 3: Creating a small wound in the exumbrellar epithelium. (A) Gentle scratching of the exumbrella with a 200 µL pipette tip to create a small epithelial wound. (B) Placing the coverslip is sometimes sufficient to create small epithelial wounds. (C) Medusa mounted on a depression slide. (D) Small epithelial wound image without DIC optics and (E) with DIC optics. Scale bars: 50 µm Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
4. Analysis
Figure 4: Analysis of wound area in small epithelial wounds. (A) Example of a small epithelial wound healing over 10 min. (B) Example of a different epithelial wound healing over 21 min. The purple outlines in A,B are comparable to the measurements of wound areas using the lasso tool in FIJI/ImageJ. (C) Normalized reduction of the wound area over time in A. (D) Normalized reduction of the wound area over time in B. (E) Average reduction of the wound area over time for 14 small wounds. n = 14. Error bars centered around mean ± SEM. Scale bars: 50 µm Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
5. Mesogleal injections
Figure 5: Injection setup for introducing dyes or drugs to the ECM. (A) Injection setup. (B) Close-up of the injection setup showing microinjection needle orientation (approximately 45° angle relative to the animal in the dish). (C) Close-up of the silicone injection dish with the medusa in a small amount of ASW for injection. (D) A microinjection needle loaded with Fast Green FCF entering the mesoglea of the medusa through the subumbrella. (E) Post-injection of Fast Green FCF in a mounted medusa. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Following the protocols above, single-cell microwounds, small wounds, and large wounds were imaged. Registered stacks of image files were saved as .avi files.
In Movie 1, microwounds can be seen to close between and within cells (Figure 1 and Figure 2). Small lamellipodia are observed during closure, followed by contraction and healing. Debris is excluded and released into the water. Healing is completed in a minute or less.
In Movie 2 and 3, small wounds of different shapes heal through the formation of lamellipodia, extension of lamellipodial contacts, and spreading of cells at the wound margin, as previously described40 (Figure 1 and Figure 2). Cells in tiers behind the marginal cells do not participate in healing of wounds of this size nor is there collective cell migration. Rapid and progressive closure of epithelial gaps is followed by tissue contraction along the newly formed wound seam40. The normalized rate of healing of these two wounds, expressed as a percentage of the original area over time, is shown (Figure 4C,D). While there is some variability in the dynamics of wound closure, averaging the percent area closure over time for 14 wounds of various shapes ranging from 0.02-0.125 mm2 allows the establishment of an average curve for wound healing in untreated animals (Figure 4E).
Damage to the basement membrane can be clearly seen when it occurs (Figure 2). In Movie 4, cells at the margin of a small wound in which there is basement membrane damage spread around the damaged area, and gap closure is completed with a purse string contraction.
If the tissue is dehydrated or too damaged to repair, cell movements can stop, or the entire sheet of cells can burst (Movie 5 and Movie 6). This usually happens after long periods of imaging (45 minutes or longer). If cell bursting occurs early in imaging, the sample is discarded.
As shown in Movie 7, large wounds heal in several stages. First, the edge of the wound becomes smooth and regular due to contractions at the margin, as previously reported57. Then, lamellipodia are seen to form from the cells at the wound margin, with lamellipodia moving forward to maximize contact with adjacent lamellipodia. Tracking of the nuclei in cells at the wound margin and several tiers behind the marginal cells shows that large gaps close by collective cell migration40. Cells never detach but move together as a sheet.
The introduction of dyes and pharmacological agents can be a powerful tool for dissecting biological mechanisms. Many substances are excluded from Clytia (not shown), likely because of the mucus layer that coats the surface of the animal. However, microinjection can be used to directly introduce molecules into the ECM, disrupting ECM structure or perturbing regulatory activities in the ECM. In addition, dyes and other molecules are able to enter epithelial cells from the basal side. For example, Figure 6 shows nuclear staining with Hoechst, membrane staining with FM1-43, and inhibition of lamellipodia formation by cytochalasin B after these reagents are microinjected into the ECM. The introduction of these molecules to the ECM and epithelial cells before wounding allows experiments that test the effect of pharmacological tools on the healing process.
Figure 6: Epithelial cells of the medusa after microinjection of dyes or pharmacological agents. (A) Epithelial cells shown in top panel 5 min after injection with 20 µM Hoechst (nuclei) and 50 µM FM1-43 (membranes).(B,C) Wound healing after injection with 1:1,000 DMSO control (B) or 100 µM Cytochalasin B (C). Wounds were made 15 min after injection. Images were taken 5 min post-wounding. The formation of lamellipodia is inhibited by cytochalasin B. The apparent "fibers" often seen between cells in the wound area are believed to be the result of tension stretching the basement membrane — they do not stain with phalloidin (not shown). Scale bars: 50 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Movie 1: Time-lapse movie of single cell microwound healing. Time elapsed: 20 s. Frame rate: 10 fps. Scale bar: 50 µm. Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 2: Time-lapse movie of a small epithelial wound healing. Time elapsed: 9 min 54 s. Frame rate: 10 fps. Scale bar: 50 µm. Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 3: Time-lapse movie of a small epithelial wound healing. This wound is larger and more irregularly shaped than the wound in Movie 2. Time elapsed: 20 min 54 s. Frame rate: 10 fps. Scale bar: 50 µm. Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 4: Time-lapse movie of a small wound and a microwound healing with a basement membrane tear. Lamellipodia spread around the basement membrane tear, although they can advance over the rest of the ECM. Once the region of the wound with the basement membrane damage is surrounded, a purse string contraction pulls cells over the region. Time elapsed: 19 min 4 s. Frame rate: 10 fps. Scale bar: 50 µm. Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 5: Cells dying in a small epithelial wound. Cell death is likely due to dehydration of the animal. Time elapsed: 4 min 24 s. Frame rate: 10 fps. Scale bar: 100 µm. Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 6: A small epithelial wound fails to complete healing. Time elapsed: 42 min 32 s. Frame rate: 10 fps. Scale bar: 50 µm. Please click here to download this Movie.
Movie 7: Large epithelial wound healing. Time elapsed: 25 min 29 s. Frame rate: 10 fps. Scale bar: 100 µm. Please click here to download this Movie.
Supplemental Figure 1: Clytia tank dimension schematics. 3D visualization of the custom-made Clytia tanks. (A) Front and back view. (B) Side view. The cut-out in the piece shown in green is covered with nylon mesh. Water enters the tank directly over the mesh, sweeps over the mesh and creates a circular current. Water exits the system through the hole in the end piece shown in blue.Please click here to download this File.
Supplemental Movie 1: Acellular extracellular matrix in Clytia. Z-stack of Clytia taken using confocal microscopy. The stack initially focuses on the exumbrella and then scans every 10 µm through the ECM to the plate endoderm and subumbrella. Images using DIC (left) and Hoechst nuclear staining (right) demonstrate the lack of cells in the ECM. Scale bar: 100 µm. Please click here to download this File.
Here, the methodology is presented for imaging wounds in vivo in Clytia, a relatively new invertebrate model organism40,43,58. There are several factors that make this system a unique and powerful research tool, distinct from other models used to study wound healing and re-epithelialization. First, the monolayer epithelium is attached to a transparent ECM, hence resembling in vitro tissue culture assays (Figure 1, Figure 2, Figure 3, Figure 4). As in in vitro assays, cells can be imaged at high resolution. However, unlike in tissue culture, there is an authentic cellular environment and ECM, so that wound healing can be viewed in the context of the complex signaling events that occur in a live injured animal. Second, Clytia lacks inflammatory responses, migratory fibroblasts, vasculature, and blood. This allows the re-epithelialization process to be studied in vivo in the absence of the overlapping events that occur in more complex adult animals during wound healing59. Third, the ECM is acellular (Supplemental Movie 1) and large, allowing easy access with a microinjection needle (Figure 5 and Figure 6). Using this approach, researchers can test the effect of pharmacological reagents that perturb ECM structure or signaling on wound healing in vivo. Reagents can also be introduced into epithelial cells, and their effects on in vivo wound healing can be assessed. Fourth, there are protocols that exist for creating mutants and transgenic animals in the Clytia system42,43,44,45. In vivo wound healing can therefore be observed in animals with increased/decreased expression of genes of interest.
There are several critical steps in this technique. First, as shown in Figure 3, it is necessary to use a microscope that is correctly configured for DIC microscopy as the flat, transparent epithelial cells are nearly invisible with standard light microscopy. It is also important to develop the skill to wound animals gently so that the epithelium is damaged without gouging the ECM. A similarly gentle touch is necessary for microinjecting materials into the ECM, as extensive damage to the animal during injection might compromise a subsequent analysis of wound healing. While there is a learning curve to these techniques, even beginner students have mastered them quickly in the Malamy lab. Indeed, these protocols have been used to demonstrate cell migration in undergraduate lab courses at The University of Chicago.
For optimal imaging, it is important that the animal does not move and the chosen wound area does not drift out of the field of view. If animals are pulsing, treatment with Tricaine as described is very effective. For drifting, it is often necessary to manually reposition the sample. These movements can be eliminated from the final movie using the registration function in FIJI/ImageJ.
A limitation with this system is that it is not possible to create identical wounds, as wounds vary in both shape and size using the methods described here. Therefore, it can be difficult to quantitate the exact rate of wound closure or cell migration. Positional markers such as carbon grains stick to the exposed ECM in a wounded animal and can be used to measure the rate of collective cell migration in large wounds (not shown). For small wound closure analysis, even with variable wound size and shape, there is a limited range of rates of closure among wounds of this size (Figure 4). It is therefore possible to quantitatively detect the effects of promotive or repressive pharmacological reagents.
While this work describes the characterization of wound healing using only DIC microscopy, the same approaches can be used to image healing using fluorescence or confocal microscopy. To aid in this, protocols are in place to generate transgenic animals in which various cellular and extracellular proteins are fluorescently labeled. Concurrent imaging with DIC and fluorescence, combined with perturbation of wound healing using pharmacological agents or mutant lines, will be a powerful approach to understanding mechanisms that underlie the wound healing process in the epithelium.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
E.E.L.L. is supported by a grant from the National Science Foundation PRFB 2011010. We would like to thank Tsuyoshi Momose and Evelyn Houliston for helping us establish our Clytia colonies, Jean-Baptiste Reynier for collection of the microwound healing images, Harry Kyriazes for construction of the pseudo-kreisel tanks, and Elizabeth Baldo for maintaining the Clytia habitat. Figure 1B was created with BioRender.com.
20500 ACE EKE Microscope Fiber Optic Light Source | Kramer Scientific Corporation | ||
AxioCam 506 mono | ZEISS | 426557-0000-000-MA285 | |
Capillary tubes | World Precision Instruments | TW1004 | |
Cytochalasin B | Abcam | ab143482 | |
Depression slides | Amscope | BS-C12 | |
DMR with DIC options and fluorescence halogen lamp | Leica | ||
Ethyl 3-aminobenzoate methanesulfonate | Sigma Aldrich | E10521-10G | |
Fast Green FCF | Thermo Scientific | A16520-06 | |
FM1-43 | Biotium | 70022 | Excitation/Emission: 480/598 nm |
Hoechst 33342 | Thermo Scientific | 62249 | Excitation/Emission: 361/497 nm |
imageJ | NIH | ||
Microloader tips (0.5-10 μL /2-20 μL) | Eppendorf | 930001007 | |
Micromanipulator | World Precision Instruments | 3301R / M3301L | |
Microscope Cover Glass (22X40-1.5) | Fisherbrand | 12-544-BP | |
Petri Dish (60 mm x 15 mm) | Fisherbrand | FB085713A | |
PicoNozzle v2 | World Precision Instruments | 5430-ALL | |
Pipette puller | Sutter Instrument Co | P-97 | |
Pneumatic PicoPump | World Precision Instruments | PV820 | |
Polycarbonate vacuum, desiccator | Bel-art | F42025-0000 | |
Prism 9 | GraphPad | ||
STEMI Sv11 Dissection scope | ZEISS | STEMI SV11 | |
SYLGARD 184 | Dow Silicones | 1024001 | |
Transfer pipettes | Fisherbrand | 13-711-7M | |
Z-Hab mini system | Pentair | ||
ZEN Microscopy software | Zeiss |