Here, we present a reproducible in vitro electroporation protocol for genetic manipulation of primary cerebellar granule cell precursors (GCPs) that is cost-effective, efficient, and viable. Moreover, this protocol also demonstrates a straightforward method for the molecular study of primary cilium-dependent Hedgehog signaling pathways in primary GCP cells.
The primary cilium is a critical signaling organelle found on nearly every cell that transduces Hedgehog (Hh) signaling stimuli from the cell surface. In the granule cell precursor (GCP), the primary cilium acts as a pivotal signaling center that orchestrates precursor cell proliferation by modulating the Hh signaling pathway. The investigation of primary cilium-dependent Hh signaling machinery is facilitated by in vitro genetic manipulation of the pathway components to visualize their dynamic localization to the primary cilium. However, transfection of transgenes in the primary cultures of GCPs using the currently known electroporation methods is generally costly and often results in low cell viability and undesirable transfection efficiency. This paper introduces an efficient, cost-effective, and simple electroporation protocol that demonstrates a high transfection efficiency of ~80-90% and optimal cell viability. This is a simple, reproducible, and efficient genetic modification method that is applicable to the study of the primary cilium-dependent Hedgehog signaling pathway in primary GCP cultures.
Cerebellar GCPs are widely used to study the machinery of the Hh signaling pathway in neuronal progenitor cell-types owing to their high abundance and high sensitivity to the Hh signaling pathway in vivo1,2,3,4. In GCPs, the primary cilium acts as a pivotal Hh signal transduction hub5 that orchestrates the proliferation of the precursor cells6,7,8. In vitro visualization of Hh signaling components on the primary cilium is often challenging due to their low endogenous basal levels. Hence, transgene modification of protein expression levels and fluorophore tagging of the gene of interest are useful approaches to study the pathway at molecular resolution. However, genetic manipulation of GCP primary cultures using liposome-based transfection approaches often result in low transfection efficiency, hindering further molecular investigations9. Electroporation increases the efficiency but commonly requires exorbitant vendor-specific and cell type-restricted electroporation reagents10.
This paper introduces a high-efficiency and cost-effective electroporation method to manipulate the Hh signaling pathway components in GCP primary cultures. Using this modified electroporation protocol, a green fluorescent protein (GFP)-tagged Smoothened transgene (pEGFP-Smo) was efficiently delivered to GCPs and achieved high cell survival and transfection rates (80-90%). Furthermore, as evidenced by the immunocytochemical staining, the transfected GCPs showed high sensitivity to Smoothened agonist-induced activation of the Hh signaling pathway by trafficking EGFP-Smo to the primary cilia. This protocol shall be directly applicable and beneficial for experiments that involve in vitro genetic modification of cell types that are difficult to transfect, such as human and rodent primary cell cultures, as well as human induced pluripotent stem cells.
All animal-related procedures were carried out in compliance with animal handling guidelines and the protocol approved by the Department of Health, Hong Kong. Animal experiment licenses following Animal (Control of Experiments) Ordinance (Cap. 340) were obtained from the Department of Health, Hong Kong Government. The animal work was carried out in compliance with the animal safety ethics approved by HKBU Research Office and Laboratory Safety Committee. Refer to the Table of Materials for details about all materials used in this protocol.
1. Preexperiment preparation
2. Experimental day 0
3. DIV 2: Visualization of primary cilia and investigation of the Hh signaling pathway
Using the Opti-MEM (see the Table of Materials) as the universal reagent, this proposed electroporation methodology could achieve consistently high electroporation efficiency at ~80-90% (Figure 1). The electroporation efficiency of the Smo-EGFP vector was determined at DIV 2 post electroporation by quantification of the percentage of green fluorescence-positive cells in all paired box protein-6 (Pax6)-expressing GCP cells. The electroporation efficiency of DMSO- and SAG-treated groups appeared comparable (Figure 1 and Table 2).
In addition, immunostaining of the primary cilium marker, Arl13b, demonstrates that the ciliation rate of GCP at DIV 2 of culture was ~18% in both the vehicle- and SAG-treated groups (DMSO: 17.35% ± 0.59%; SAG: 18.24% ± 0.88%). The ciliation rate is illustrated as the percentage of Pax6-expressing GCPs bearing a primary cilium (Arl13b-positive) on the cell surface at DIV 2 post electroporation (Figure 2 and Table 3).
To decipher the primary cilium-dependent Hh signaling pathway, an agonist of Smo, SAG, was used to activate the Hh signaling pathway. Upon Hh pathway activation, the Smo receptor is enriched at the axoneme of the primary cilium14. Our results show significantly increased Smo-EGFP localization on the primary cilium axoneme of Pax6-expressing GCP cells at 24 h post SAG treatment (Figure 3, quantification data modified from previous work6), indicating a profound activation of the primary cilium-dependent Hh signaling pathway.
Figure 1: Electroporation setup and the electroporation efficiency of GCPs. (A) Electroporation setup. Right, black arrowhead denotes electroporation cuvette. (B, C) Representative images depict the electroporation efficiency of the Smo-EGFP vector determined by quantification of the percentage of GFP-positive cells in all Pax6-expressing GCP cells (Table 2). Representative images depict the green fluorescent signals on Pax6-expressing (violet) GCP cells on DIV 2 post electroporation after 24 h treatment with (B) DMSO and (C) SAG. Nuclei were labeled with DAPI (blue). Scale bars = 20 µm. Abbreviations: GCPs = granule cell precursors; GFP = green fluorescent protein; Pax6 = paired box protein-6; DIV = day in vitro; DMSO = dimethyl sulfoxide; SAG = Smoothened agonist; DAPI = 4',6-diamidino-2-phenylindole. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Percentage of ciliation on DIV 2 of GCP primary culture. (A, B) Representative images depict the percentage of ciliation on DIV 2 of GCP primary culture. Representative images depict the primary cilia (green) on Pax6-expressing (red) GCP cells on DIV 2 post electroporation after 24 h treatment with (A) DMSO and (B) SAG. Nuclei were labeled with DAPI (blue). The primary cilium (green) is denoted by white arrowheads. Scale bars = 20 µm. (C) Graph illustrates quantification data of 4 independent experiments. Statistical analysis, Unpaired Student's t-test. Error bars depict ±SEM. Abbreviations: GCP = granule cell precursor; Pax6 = paired box protein-6; DIV = day in vitro; DMSO = dimethyl sulfoxide; SAG = Smoothened agonist; DAPI = 4',6-diamidino-2-phenylindole; n.s. = Not significant; SEM = standard error of the mean; Arl13b = ADP ribosylation factor-like protein 13B. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Increased Smo localization on the primary cilium of Pax6-expressing GCP cells upon SAG treatment. (A) Representative images depict the Smo-EGFP localization (green) on the primary cilium (red, white square box) on Pax6-expressing (violet) GCP cells at DIV 2 post electroporation after 24 h treatment with DMSO and SAG. Nuclei were labeled with DAPI (blue). Scale bars = 5 µm. (B) Graph illustrates quantification data of 4 independent experiments. Statistical analysis, unpaired Student's t-test. *** P ≤ 0.001. Error bars depict ± SEM. Total n for DMSO group = 97, total n for SAG group = 130. Figure 3B was modified from 6. Abbreviations: GCP = granule cell precursor; Smo = Smoothened; Pax6 = paired box protein-6; DIV = day in vitro; DMSO = dimethyl sulfoxide; SAG = Smoothened agonist; DAPI = 4',6-diamidino-2-phenylindole; SEM = standard error of the mean; Arl13b = ADP ribosylation factor-like protein 13B. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Poring Pulse Setting | Transfer Pulse Setting | |||
Mouse Primary GCPs | Primary neurons | Mouse Primary GCPs | Primary neurons | |
Voltage | 275 V | 275 V | 20 V | 20 V |
Length | 1 ms | 0.5 ms | 50 ms | 50 ms |
Interval | 50 ms | 50 ms | 50 ms | 50 ms |
No. | 2 | 2 | 5 | 5 |
D rate | 10% | 10% | 40% | 40% |
Polarity | + | + | ± | ± |
Table 1: The electroporation parameters of mouse primary GCPs and primary neurons using Super Electroporator NEPA21 TYPE II. Abbreviation: GCP = granule cell precursor.
Electroporation efficiency | Exp. 1 (n = 486) | Exp. 2 (n = 1314) | Exp. 3 (n = 704) | Exp. 4 (n = 476) | Average |
DMSO-treated group | 90.57% ± 10.12% | 96.62% ± 3.09% | 98.89% ± 0.97% | 90.72% ± 11.31% | 94.02% ± 1.36% |
SAG-treated group | 91.8% ± 8.69% | 79.97% ± 2.77% | 89.35% ± 5.67% | 88.59% ± 13.54% | 87.42% ± 1.71% |
Average Electroporation efficiency | 91.31% ± 7.99% | 88.27% ± 10.81% | 94.12% ± 6.36% | 89.65% ± 11.21% | 90.84% ± 0.84% |
Table 2: Electroporation efficiency of Smo-EGFP vectordeterminedbyquantification of thepercentage of GFP-positive cells in all Pax6-expressing GCP cells. Data of four independent experiments (Exp.) are shown. (Total n = 2980). Abbreviations: Smo = Smoothened; GFP = green fluorescent protein; GCP = granule cell precursor; Pax6 = paired box protein-6.
Exp. 1 | Exp. 2 | Exp. 3 | Exp. 4 | average | |
Ciliation rate – DMSO | 18.88% ± 3.61% | 19.58% ± 7.42% | 16.60% ± 1.48% | 14.35% ± 7.99% | 17.35% ± 0.59% |
Ciliation rate – SAG | 13.93% ± 3.39% | 17.30% ± 2.15% | 22.19% ± 10.35% | 19.56% ± 1.15% | 18.24% ± 0.88% |
Table 3: The percentage of ciliation on DIV 2 of GCP primary culture. Data of four independent experiments (Exp.) are shown. (Total n for DMSO group = 1169, Total n for SAG group = 816). Abbreviations: GCP = granule cell precursor; DIV = day in vitro; DMSO = dimethyl sulfoxide; SAG = Smoothened agonist.
Transfection of transgenes in primary GCP culture by electroporation method is typically associated with low cell viability and poor transfection efficiency9,10. This paper introduces a cost-effective and reproducible electroporation protocol that has demonstrated high efficiency and viability. In addition, we also demonstrate a straightforward method of studying the primary cilium-dependent Hh signaling pathway in primary GCP cells.
Other common electroporation methods often require costly cell-type-specific electroporation reagents that must be purchased from specific manufacturers. The method described here is deemed favorable as it uses a common and economical electroporation reagent for different cell types. Moreover, these data showed that the electroporation efficiency reached ~80-90%, which is highly efficient compared to other electroporation and transfection methods9,10.
To maintain higher cell viability, there are a few critical steps that one should take into consideration. The cerebellum dissection and dissociation procedures should be completed within the shortest possible time window of 1-2 h. Another critical step is to avoid bubble formation in the plasmid-cell electroporation mixture before pulses during electroporation. After pulses, prewarmed culture medium should be added immediately into the cuvettes and the cells seeded as quickly as possible. The cells must be undisturbed in the first 3 h post cell seeding. The aforementioned precautions will enhance cell viability up to approximately 70-80% on the second day of culture.
One notable limitation of studying the primary cilium in the primary culture platform is that the rate of ciliation in cultured cells is generally lower than that observed in vivo. Previous data 6 showed that the in vivo rate of ciliation on GCP at both E15.5 and P15 was approximately 60-80%. In contrast, the in vitro rate of ciliation in primary GCP culture was ~20%6. Nonetheless, this is a general phenomenon that is discernible across most (if not all) cell types when comparing the rate of ciliation between in vitro and in vivo studies.
Notably, this method is also applicable to other primary cultures such as neural progenitor cells and cortical and hippocampal neuron culture, which is achievable by modifying the electroporation parameter, i.e., poring pulse voltage, length, and number of pulses. To extend the application of this protocol to a broader field of study, the recommended electroporation parameters for primary neurons are provided in Table 1. In addition, the universal electroporation reagent, i.e., Opti-MEM used in this protocol also helps avoid additional tedious optimization effort compared to other electroporation protocols that require optimization with respect to reagent compatibility. This optimized, cost-effective electroporation protocol for the investigation of the primary cilium and Hh signaling in primary GCP cultures could be used as the reference procedure for other primary cilium-related studies using primary cultures.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This study was supported by HKBU Seed Fund and Tier-2 Start-up Grant (RG-SGT2/18-19/SCI/009), Research Grant Council-Collaborative Research Fund (CRF-C2103-20GF) to C.H.H. Hor.
GCP Culture | |||
B27 supplement | Life Technologies LTD | 17504044 | |
Cell strainer, 70 µm | Corning | 352350 | |
DNase I from bovine pancreas | Roche | 11284932001 | |
Earle’s Balanced Salt Solution | Gibco, Life Technologies | 14155063 | |
FBS, qualified | Thermo Scientific | SH30028.02 | |
GlutamMAXTM-I ,100x | Gibco, Life Technologies | 35050061 | L-glutamine substitute |
L-cysteine | Sigma Aldrich | C7352 | |
Matrigel | BD Biosciences | 354277 | Basement membrane matrix |
Neurobasal | Gibco, Life Technologies | 21103049 | |
Papain,suspension | Worthington Biochemical Corporation | LS003126 | |
Poly-D-lysine Hydrobromide | Sigma Aldrich | P6407 | |
SAG | Cayman Chemical | 11914-1 | Smoothened agonist |
IF staining | |||
Bovine Serum Albumin | Sigma Aldrich | A7906 | |
Paraformaldehyde | Sigma Aldrich | P6148 | |
Triton X-100 | Sigma Aldrich | X100 | |
Primary antibody mix | |||
Anti-GFP-goat ab | Rockland | 600-101-215 | Dilution Factor: 1 : 1000 |
Anti-Arl13b mouse monoclonal ab | NeuroMab | 75-287 | Dilution Factor: 1 : 1000 |
Anti-Pax6 rabbit polyclonal ab | Covance | PRB-278P | Dilution Factor: 1 : 1000 |
Secondary antibody mix | |||
Alexa Fluor 488 donkey anti-goat IgG | Invitrogen | A-11055 | Dilution Factor: 1 : 1000 |
Alexa Fluor 555 donkey anti-mouse IgG | Invitrogen | A-31570 | Dilution Factor: 1 : 1000 |
Alexa Fluor 647 donkey anti-rabbit IgG | Invitrogen | A-31573 | Dilution Factor: 1 : 1000 |
DAPI | Thermo Scientific | 62247 | Dilution Factor: 1 : 1000 |
Electroporation | |||
CU 500 cuvette chamber | Nepagene | CU500 | |
EPA Electroporation cuvette (2 mm gap) | Nepagene | EC-002 | |
Opti-MEM | Life Technologies LTD | 31985070 | reduced-serum medium for transfection |
pEGFP-mSmo | Addgene | 25395 | |
Super Electroporator NEPA21 TYPE II In Vitro and In Vivo Electroporation | Nepagene | NEPA21 | electroporator |