We describe a modified small-scale extraction and colorimetric assays of lactate and pyruvate in the nematode C. elegans. When utilizing commercial assay kits, the technical development of their sensitivity and accuracy is important. Protein precipitation in extraction is the most critical step for the quantitative determination of intracellular metabolites.
Lactate and pyruvate are key intermediates of intracellular energy metabolic pathways. Monitoring the lactate/pyruvate ratio in cells helps to determine whether there is an imbalance in age-related energy metabolism between mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation and aerobic glycolysis. Here, we show the utilization of commercial colorimetric assay kits for lactate and pyruvate in the model organism C. elegans. Recently, the sensitivity and accuracy of the colorimetric/fluorimetric assay kits have been improved greatly by the research and development conducted by reagent manufacturers. The improved reagents have enabled the use of small-scale assays with a 96-well plate in C. elegans. In general, a fluorimetric assay is superior in sensitivity to a colorimetric assay; however, the colorimetric approach is more suitable for the use in common laboratories. Another important issue in these assays for quantitative determination is protein precipitation of homogenized C. elegans samples. In our protein precipitation method, common precipitants (e.g., trichloroacetic acid, perchloric acid and metaphosphoric acid) are used for sample preparation. A protein-free assay sample is prepared by directly adding cold precipitant (final concentration of 5%) during homogenization.
Lactate and pyruvate concentrations are widely regarded as intermediates of energy metabolism, and are related to the states of glycolysis, tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle, and electron transport chain in the cells of aerobic organisms. A series of reactions in glycolysis oxidize glucose to pyruvate, which lies at a metabolic crossroads and can be converted to carbohydrates through gluconeogenesis, to fatty acids and energy metabolism through acetyl-CoA, and to the amino acid alanine. The TCA cycle occurs under the presence of sufficient dissolved oxygen and is fundamental for the conversion of glucose to energy. Especially, the alteration of secondary metabolism is an interesting phenomenon in which glycolysis is used predominantly for energy production and aerobic mitochondrial respiration, which involves the TCA cycle and electron transport chain, is downregulated in mammalian cancer cells1,2. We showed recently that the lactate levels and the consequent lactate/pyruvate (L/P) ratio decreased during aging in the model organism Caenorhabditis elegans (C. elegans). Likewise, we found that the mammalian tumor suppressor p53 ortholog CEP-1 in C. elegans has an important role in the age-related alterations of energy metabolism through the activation of its transcriptional targets3.
In biological assays, such as the measurement of lactate and pyruvate concentrations in cells, the sensitivity, accuracy, sample size, and incubation time of colorimetric/fluorimetric assay kits have been improved dramatically. Owing to technological innovations, we are now able to analyze various metabolites and intermediate metabolites without the large-scale culture of C. elegans, which is difficult given its small size. In general, the sensitivity of a colorimetric assay is an order of magnitude smaller than that of a fluorimetric assay; however, the colorimetric approach is more suitable in the setting of common laboratories. Furthermore, an extraction technique containing homogenization and protein precipitation is crucial for the quantitative determination of lactate and pyruvate concentrations in C. elegans cells because this nematode is enclosed in an exoskeleton called the cuticle, unlike mammalian cultured cell lines4,5. Here, we describe a protocol to analyze lactate and pyruvate concentrations using commercial colorimetric assay kits including tips for sample extraction from C. elegans.
1. Synchronized Culture of C. elegans
2. Extraction of Cellular Fraction from C. elegans
3. Lactate Assay Using a Colorimetric Assay Kit
4. Pyruvate Assay Using a Colorimetric Assay Kit
5. Protein Assay for Normalization with Protein Content
Using the colorimetric assays for the quantitative determination of lactate and pyruvate concentrations, we showed the accuracy of these assays compared with previous reports in C. elegans7,8. Here, the process of protein precipitation during sample extraction was the most crucial step to generate accurate values. For protein precipitation, common precipitants (e.g., TCA, PCA, or metaphosphoric acid) can be used to prepare the test samples (Figure 1). In C. elegans, however, it was necessary to perform protein precipitation during homogenization of the worms (Table 1). In addition to accuracy, these assays were sufficiently sensitive to measure lactate and pyruvate concentrations in small-scale samples and were able to detect them in a short period of time (the reactive incubation time of both assays is at least 30 min) (Figure 2-3). Actually, we presented the data in a recent report3. Thus, we could detect age-related metabolic alterations indicating that cellular lactate levels and the consequent L/P ratio decreased during aging, and we also showed different energy metabolism in a cep-1 mutant3.
Figure 1. Process for the extraction of cellular metabolites. (A) 1,500-3,000 worms were placed on an NGM agar plate (90-mm Petri dish). Extraction from worms on five plates was sufficient for the colorimetric assays. (B) Worms collected from the five plates of 3,000 and 1,500 worms per plate are indicated on the left and right side of panel, respectively. Both the wet volumes in each 15-mL tube are < 0.5 mL, which were sufficient for detection. (C) Protein precipitation using 10% TCA during homogenization of the worms. Adding the worms into ice-cold 10% TCA in a homogenizer has to be performed before the worms are homogenized. Otherwise, cellular lactate and pyruvate cannot be detected in test samples using a colorimetric assay kit (data are shown in Table 1). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2. Colorimetric pigmentation patterns of the lactate standards using a colorimetric assay kit. (A) Wells of the 96-well plate used in the colorimetric assay, and a dilution series of the L(+)-lactate standard. Increasing the lactate concentration resulted in a more intense pink color. BG indicates the background of a lactate probe against the dilution series. (B) Lactate standard curve for the colorimetric assay. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3. Colorimetric pigmentation patterns of the pyruvate standards using a colorimetric assay kit. (A) Wells of the 96-well plate using the colorimetric assay, and dilution series of pyruvate standard. Increasing of the pyruvate concentration resulted in increased light pink coloring. (B) Pyruvate standard curve for the colorimetric assay. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Test Samples | Lactate (mM) | Pyruvate (mM) |
Protein-precipitated samples during homogenization | 3.07 ± 0.94 | 0.22 ± 0.08 |
Protein-precipitated samples after homogenization | ND | ND |
Intact cytosolic fraction after homogenization and ultracentrifugation* | 1.12 | 0.06 |
Table 1. Effects of protein precipitation on different timings for the detection of cellular lactate and pyruvate in 5-day-old animals of wild-type N2. Data indicate means + standard deviation (SD) of at least three determinations. ND indicates not detected. *The extraction process was performed preliminarily using ultracentrifugation without protein precipitation.
When utilizing these colorimetric assay kits, the most critical step in sample extraction to detect cellular lactate and pyruvate accurately in C. elegans is the process of protein precipitation during homogenization (Figure 1). It is not strictly necessary to use a Teflon homogenizer, as other homogenizers (e.g., Dounce and tapered tissue grinders, or bead mills) are also suited to the small-scale extraction of worms. We did not detect cellular lactate and pyruvate in test samples that were extracted using a homogenizer before protein precipitation. Furthermore, both lactate and pyruvate levels decreased drastically in the cytosolic fraction separated using ultracentrifugation instead of protein precipitation (Table 1). These suggest that the sample extraction is crucial to detect the cellular metabolites in biochemical methodology using a nematode C. elegans. For protein precipitation, not only TCA but also several other precipitants (PCA or metaphosphoric acid) can be utilized to the biochemical methodology7,9. According to a previous report, the use of TCA resulted in the disappearance of approximately 12% of NADH in the enzymatic measurement of blood lactate and pyruvate. Therefore, the authors concluded that 5% metaphosphoric acid should be selected as the protein precipitant for both lactate and pyruvate when using enzymatic assays9. It suggests that TCA partially denatures proteins including many enzymes.However, we had no problems regarding the protein precipitants when using colorimetric assays to detect cellular lactate and pyruvate.
In this study, we used commercial colorimetric assay kits for the quantitative determination of lactate and pyruvate (Figure 2 and Figure 3). Their sensitivities and sample sizes were superior in comparison with previous assay kits7; therefore, we prepared the test samples using a smaller scale extraction and reported the differences in the cellular lactate and pyruvate concentrations in C. elegans3. We detected an age-related decrease in lactate and consequent L/P ratio in wild-type C. elegans and found that the p53/CEP-1 has an important role in the age-related alteration of energy metabolism through the activation of its transcriptional targets2,3. Thus, the analysis of energy metabolism in nematode C. elegans advantageously proceeds due to using the improved colorimetric assay kits, at least in part.
As shown in Figure 3B, lactate concentration below 2 mM tend to be indeed larger in this colorimetric assay (not the fluorometric assay). Therefore, the fluorometric assay may be suitable for a more accurate measurement of lactate. The capabilities of these assay kits support both colorimetric and fluorometric assays, so that the assay is selected in response to the appliance in laboratory of the user. It is still more expensive to use the present commercial colorimetric assay kits to determine quantitatively the concentration of cellular metabolites. However, trials can be adequately performed in smaller laboratories using common instruments and a spectrophotometric plate reader.
Hitherto, there are relatively few reports using conventional biochemical approaches in a model organism C. elegans, which typically need the large-scale culture of worms, compared with genetic studies5. However, the recent remarkable progress of biological assay systems (e.g., improvement of the sensitivity and stability of assay kits) makes studies using the nematode C. elegans, which is small and consists of fewer than 1,000 cells, more attractive and performed easily in the laboratory. Henceforth, effective metabolomic analysis using mass spectrometry (MS) and gas chromatography/mass spectrometry (GC/MS) can help to reduce certain problems, such as large-scale culture, analytical sensitivity, and specificity, and will help to elucidate the role of cellular metabolism in aging and human diseases including cancer10. Looking ahead, easier methodology, such as colorimetric assay kits, would be effective as a screening tool prior to more precise instrumental analyses.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was financially supported by a Special Research Grant from Daito Bunka University to Sumino Yanase.
Lactate Colorimetric/Fluorimetric Assay kit | BioVision | #K607-100 | colorimetric/fluorimetric 100 assays; Store at -20oC |
EnzyChrom Pyruvate Assay Kit |
BioAssay Systems |
#EPYR-100 | colorimetric/ fluorometric 100 assays; Store at -20oC |
BCA Protein Assay Kit | Thermo Scientific | #23225 | colorimetric assay; store at room temperature |
Trichloroacetic Acid | Wako Pure Chemical | #207-04955 | store at room temperature |
Teflon homogenizer | Iwaki/Pyrex | #358034 (Wheaton) | Instead of Iwaki/Pyrex, available by Wheaton |