Localizing gene expression to specific cell types can be challenging due to the lack of specific antibodies. Here we describe a protocol for simultaneous triple detection of gene expression by combining double fluorescence RNA in situ hybridization with immunostaining.
Detection of gene expression in different types of brain cells e.g., neurons, astrocytes, oligodendrocytes, oligodendrocyte precursors and microglia, can be hampered by the lack of specific primary or secondary antibodies for immunostaining. Here we describe a protocol to detect the expression of three different genes in the same brain section using double fluorescence in situ hybridization with two gene-specific probes followed by immunostaining with an antibody of high specificity directed against the protein encoded by a third gene. The Aspartoacyclase (ASPA) gene, mutations of which can lead to a rare human white matter disease – Canavan disease – is thought to be expressed in oligodendrocytes and microglia but not in astrocytes and neurons. However, the precise expression pattern of ASPA in the brain has yet to be established. This protocol has allowed us to determine that ASPA is expressed in a subset of mature oligodendrocytes and it can be generally applied to a wide range of gene expression pattern studies.
Glial cells, which are the most abundant cells in the central nervous system (CNS), comprise oligodendrocytes (the myelinating cells of CNS), oligodendrocytes precursors (OPs, also known as "NG2 cells"), astrocytes and microglia. There is growing interest in the functions of glial cells and their potential roles in neurological diseases1. For example, Canavan disease (CD) is a hereditary neurodegenerative disorder starting early in infancy with spongiform leukodystrophy and a progressive loss of neurons, leading to death usually before 10 years of age2,3. Mutations in the Aspartoacyclase (ASPA) gene that lead to drastically reduced ASPA activity4 in CD have been identified. ASPA is an enzyme catalysing the deacetylation of N-acetylaspartate (NAA), a molecule highly concentrated in the brain, generating acetate and aspartate 5-7. Many CD patients show higher levels of NAA due to lack of ASPA activity. Some studies speculate that NAA-derived acetate could be a major source of fatty acids/lipids in the brain during development and CD may result from decreased myelin synthesis during development caused by the failure of NAA to be broken down3,5,6.
ASPA is predominantly found in the kidney, liver and white matter of the brain, and given the important role of ASPA in CD, the cellular expression of this enzyme in the brain has been studied by several labs. By looking at ASPA enzymatic activity in the brain, earlier studies found that the increase in ASPA activity during brain development parallels the time course of myelination 8-10. At the cellular level, assays for enzymatic activity as well as in situ hybridization (ISH) and immunohistochemistry (IHC) analyses suggest that ASPA is mainly expressed in oligodendrocytes in the brain but not in neurons or astrocytes11-16. A few studies found that ASPA might also be expressed in microglia in the CNS12,14. So far data on ASPA expression in OPs are limited. According to a recent study where transcriptomes of different cell types in the mouse cerebral cortex including neurons, astrocytes, OPs, newly formed oligodendrocytes, myelinating oligodendrocytes, microglia, endothelial cells, and pericytes were analysed by RNA sequencing17, ASPA is exclusively expressed in oligodendrocytes, in particular in myelinating oligodendrocytes (http://web.stanford.edu/group/barres_lab/brain_rnaseq.html). Despite these studies on ASPA expression pattern in the brain, a number of uncertainties remain.
Different techniques can be used to study gene expression patterns. IHC is a commonly used method for detecting the functional product (i.e., protein) of a gene expression in tissue sections. Despite its great utility, this technique has limitations as its application and specificity are subject to the availability and specificity of the antibody needed. By comparison, ISH has the advantage of being able to reveal the expression of any gene at the mRNA level. However, it can be technically challenging to use several probes at the same time in order to localize a gene expression to specific cell types. In this article, we describe a protocol combining double fluorescence RNA in situ hybridization with fluorescence immunolabelling of a protein. We have used this set of techniques to examine the expression pattern of Aspa in mouse brain. This method allows the precise study of gene expression using confocal microscopy.
Ethics Statement:
Mouse husbandry and handling are in accordance with UK Home Office regulations and UCL ethics committee guidelines, complying with the Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986 of the United Kingdom and its Amendment Regulations 2012.
NOTE: All solutions should be made with diethyl pyrocarbonate (DEPC)- treated water to destroy any residual RNase. For DEPC treatment, add DEPC (1 ml per litre), shake vigorously until all the DEPC globules have disappeared then autoclave to degrade the DEPC.
1. RNA Probe Synthesis
2. Perfusion, Fixation and Tissue Collection
3. Cryosectioning
4. Hybridization
5. Visualization of the FITC Probe
6. Visualization of the DIG Probe
7. Immunohistochemistry
8. Mounting
This article describes a method for a double fluorescence ISH followed by immunolabelling in mouse brain sections. A brief description of this protocol is shown in Figure 1. The first step was to synthesize probes specific to Aspa and Mbp (myelin basic protein). To check that the probes had been synthesized, a small aliquot of each reaction was run on an agarose gel. The faint linear template and a large amount of the RNA probe can be seen (Figure 2). Double fluorescence ISH forAspa and Mbp, followed by Olig2 immunolabelling and Hoechst nuclear staining, was performed on mouse brain sections. We scanned the brain sections in a confocal microscope and stitched the images together to reveal the distribution of gene expression signals in the brain. Aspa expression in Mbp-positive (Mbp+) cells was observed throughout the brain (Figure 3). We also examined Aspa expression in different brain structures using a higher magnification. Aspa expression in oligodendrocytes in the cortex and corpus callosum are shown in Figure 4. The co-localization of Mbp, Olig2, and Aspa indicates that Aspa is expressed in a subset of mature oligodendrocytes in the cortex and the corpus callosum (Figure 4). These results demonstrate that this protocol can simultaneously detect the expression of three different genes in brain sections.
Figure 1. Protocol for Double Fluorescence In Situ Hybridization Followed by Immunostaining. This protocol runs over 5 days and detects the expression of three genes. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2. Examination of Aspa RNA Probe on Agarose Gel. The linear template and a large amount of the RNA probe of a lesser molecular weight can be observed. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3. Double Fluorescence in situ Hybridization for Aspa and Mbp in Mouse Brain Sections. Brain sections were scanned with a confocal microscope and images were stitched together to show the distribution of Aspa (red) and Mbp (green) in the brain. Scale bar: 500 µm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4. Expression of Aspa in Oligodendrocytes in the Cortex and the Corpus Callosum. Panels show representative images from ISH for Aspa (red) and Mbp (green) followed by immunostaining of Olig2 (blue) combined with Hoechst staining. Aspa was expressed in some Mbp+/Olig2+ cells in the cortex (A and B) and in the corpus callosum (C and D). Mbp+/Olig2+/Aspa+ cells are indicated with arrows and Mbp+/Olig2+/Aspa– cells are indicated with arrowheads in the enlarged panels (B and D). Scale bars: 100 µm (A and C); 20 µm (B and D). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Supplementary Figure 1. Sequence and Map of Aspa Clone (IRAVp968C0654D). 1.5kb cDNA sequence of Aspa was inserted into pCMV-Sport6 plasmid (A). The map of pCMV-Sport6-Aspa plasmid is shown in (B). Please click here to download this file.
This protocol provides a step-by-step procedure for a double RNA in situ hybridization followed by immunostaining. We have used this protocol to confirm that Aspa is expressed in mature oligodendrocytes in several brain areas.
This multi-step procedure has many potential pitfalls that can affect sensitivity and should be avoided. First, all the solutions and storage buffers for the transcription reaction need to be RNase-free. Second, the choice of cDNA templates is important and we prefer templates approximately 1kb in length. It is necessary to clean up the cDNA templates with phenol/chloroform extraction and re-precipitate them before in vitro transcription. In addition, the transcription of the probe needs to be optimal; if the probe is not produced in sufficient quantity, it will reduce the quality of ISH. The quality of the probe can be checked by examining it on an agarose gel and good quality will be evidenced by the strong brightness of the probe band compared to the template band (Figure 2). For double ISH, two differently labelled probes are used, usually one labelled with DIG and the other with FITC. The FITC-labelled probe is considered to be the least detectable and should be chosen where the target mRNA is expected to be highest in the tissue. This probe is usually developed first and the DIG-labelled probe is developed second.
Another critical step is the tissue preparation. Mice are perfused with DEPC-treated PBS followed by 4% PFA, post-fixed in 4% PFA O/N and then cryoprotected in 20% sucrose solutions that have been DEPC-treated to destroy any residual RNase. Fixation time is quite important; over- or under-fixation can lead to a weaker signal, perhaps due to reduced probe penetration (over-fixation) or degradation of the mRNA (under-fixation). The tissue is then cryosectioned and two probes are hybridized O/N. The formamide used in the hybridization buffer needs to be de-ionized. A very important consideration during the O/N hybridization at 65 ˚C is to avoid evaporation and concentration of the hybridization mixture as it might compromise sensitivity. In the experiment described we performed hybridization at 65 ˚C O/N, but it might be worth trying lower temperatures for different probes if it appears to be difficult to detect the target mRNA.
There is a choice of reagents for detecting the hybridized probes. Fast Red is a sensitive fluorescent reagent but not all batches of Fast Red give the same result. It needs AP for development and gives fluorescence with rhodamine excitation. In our experience, it is important to make it fresh with 0.1 M Tris-HCl pH 8.2 and filter it before use. A non-fluorescent option is colour development with nitro-blue tetrazolium (NBT) and 5-bromo-4-chloro-3'-indolyphosphate (BCIP) which works with the same AP-conjugated antibody. Another option is using fluorescent tyramide for detection. Although fluorescent tyramide systems are not the most sensitive methods, the developing reaction with horseradish peroxidase is very quick and there are at least three fluorescent colours (FITC, Cyanine 3 and Cyanine 5) that can be used. A limitation of this protocol is that some target antigens (or epitopes), especially low abundance proteins, may not be detectable after the ISH process and hence are not suitable for IHC after ISH. In our immunostaining, antibody detection of Olig2 appears unaffected. The user will need to choose the right antibody for immunolabelling following ISH.
IHC and ISH are commonly used techniques for gene expression pattern studies, and both have pros and cons. IHC is a highly sensitive method for detecting the cellular expression of genes in brain sections, but its reliance on the antibody affects its specificity and limits its application. By contrast, ISH has a high specificity and the probe of any gene can easily be synthesised by in vitro transcription using the gene specific cDNA as template. The protocol that we developed takes advantage of both methods, combining double ISH with IHC to achieve triple detection of gene expression with high specificity.
In short, the protocol we describe here enables simultaneous staining of two mRNAs and one protein, so it provides a useful tool for illustrating co-localized gene expression. Despite the fact that mRNA expression does not always correlate with protein expression, ISH is a powerful technique that allows us to examine gene expression with high specificity. Our protocol of double fluorescence ISH combined with IHC has proved to be a success in detecting Aspa expression in a subset of oligodendrocytes in brain tissue of adult mice, and it can be easily adapted for a variety of tissues of different origins and developmental stages. In addition, this protocol can also be used for detecting expression of small RNAs such as miRNA.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
Work in the authors’ laboratories was supported by the UK Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BB/J006602/1 and BB/L003236/1), the Wellcome Trust (WT100269MA) and the European Research Council (ERC, “Ideas” Programme 293544). SJ was supported by an EMBO long-term fellowship. The authors thank Stephen Grant for his technical assistance.
QIAprep® Miniprep | Qiagen | 27104 | |
Deionized formamide | Sigma | F9037 | for ISH blocking buffer |
Sodium chloride | Sigma | S3014 | |
Trizma Base | Sigma | T1503 | |
Hydrochloric acid | VWR International | 20252.290 | |
Sodium phosphate monobasic anhydrous | Sigma | S8282 | |
Sodium phosphate dibasic dihydrate | Sigma | 30435 | |
Yeast tRNA | Roche | 10109495001 | |
50x Denhardt's solution | Life Technologies | 750018 | |
Dextran sulfate | Sigma | D8906 | |
Aspa cDNA clone | Source Bioscience | IRAVp968C0654D | |
SalI | New England Biolabs | R0138 | |
Sodium acetate | Sigma | S2889 | |
Equilibrated phenol | Sigma | P4557 | |
Chloroform | Sigma-Aldrich | C2432 | |
Isoamyl alcohol | Aldrich | 496200 | |
Ethanol | VWR International | 20821.321 | |
T7 RNA polymerase | Promega | P4074 | |
Transcription buffer | Promega | P118B | |
100mM DTT | Promega | P117B | |
UTP-DIG NTP mix | Roche | 11277073910 | |
Rnasin | Promega | N251B | |
Paraformaldehyde | Sigma | P6148 | |
Filter paper | Fisher scientific | 005479470 | |
Sucrose | Sigma | 59378 | |
Diethyl pyrocarbonate | Sigma | D5758 | |
Pentobarbitone | Animalcare Ltd | BN43054 | |
Dissecting scissors | World Precision Instruments | 15922 | |
25 gauge needle | Terumo | 300600 | |
Peristaltic pump | Cole-Parmer Instrument Co. Ltd | WZ-07522-30 | |
Iris scissors | Weiss | 103227 | |
No.2 tweezers | World Precision Instruments | 500230 | |
Coronal Brain Matrix | World Precision Instruments | RBMS-200C | |
Razor blade | Personna Medical | PERS60-0138 | |
OCT medium | Tissue tek | 4583 | |
Cryostat/microtome | Bright | ||
Superfrost plus slides | Thermo Scientific | J1800AMNZ | |
Sodium citrate | Sigma | S4641 | for 65°C wash buffer |
Formamide | Sigma-Aldrich | F7503 | |
Tween-20 | Sigma-Aldrich | P1379 | |
Coverslips | VWR International | 631-0146 | |
Coplin Jar | Smith Scientific Ltd | 2959 | |
Blocking reagent | Roche | 11096176001 | |
Heat-inactivated sheep serum | Sigma | S2263 | |
Hydrophobic pen | Cosmo Bio | DAI-PAP-S | 1:500 |
α-FITC POD-conjugated antibody | Roche | 11426346910 | |
TSA™ Plus Fluorescein System | Perkin Elmer | NEL741001KT | 1:1500 |
α-DIG AP-conjugated | Roche | 11093274910 | |
Fast red tablets | Roche | 11496549001 | |
.22µM filter | Millex | SLGP033RS | |
α-Olig2 Rabbit antbody | Millipore | AB9610 | |
Alexa Fluor® 647-conjugated α-rabbit antibody | Life technologies | A-31573 | 1:1000 |
bisBenzimide H 33258 | sigma | B2883 | |
Mounting medium | Dako | S3023 | |
Leica SP2 confocal microscope | Leica |