In this study, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)-like behavior is induced in mice using two sessions of inescapable electric foot shock. PTSD-like and resilient animals are identified using several assays for PTSD-specific behaviors.
Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a debilitating psychiatric condition that precipitates in ~10% of individuals exposed to a traumatic event (TE). Symptoms include recurrent and intrusive thoughts, sleep disturbance, hypervigilance, exaggerated startle, and reckless or destructive behavior. Given the complex and heterogeneous nature of the disease, animal models for PTSD-like symptomatology are of increasing interest to the field of PTSD research. Because resilience to PTSD-like symptomatology is an important epidemiologic aspect of PTSD, animal models that resolve vulnerable and resilient animals are of particular value. Due to the complex nature of the PTSD phenotype and the potential overlaps between PTSD-like behavior and behaviors associated with other stress-induced psychopathologies such as anxiety or depression, animal models that utilize multiple readouts for PTSD-like behavior are also of increasing value. We utilize a paradigm developed by Lebow et al. 2012 for the induction and identification of PTSD-like symptomatology in mice. This paradigm utilizes inescapable electric foot shock, administered in two decontextualized sessions over two consecutive days. Stressed mice perform four behavioral tests – dark/light transfer, marble burying, acoustic startle, and home cage activity – to generate five behavioral readouts of PTSD-like behavior: % risk assessment (%RA), % marbles buried (%MB), % prepulse inhibition (%PPI), latency to peak startle amplitude (LPSA), and % light phase activity (%LPA). PTSD-like symptomatology is characterized by decreased %RA, increased %MB, decreased %PPI, decreased LPSA, and increased %LPA. The 20% of animals displaying the most PTSD-like behavior in each test are awarded a certain number of points depending on the test, and animals scoring sufficient points are designated as PTSD-like, while animals scoring no points are designated PTSD-resilient. This paradigm identifies PTSD-like behavior in ~15% of animals, a rate comparable to that observed in humans. This protocol represents a robust and reproducible paradigm for the induction of PTSD-like behavior in mice.
Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is debilitating psychopathology that can precipitate in individuals who have been exposed to a traumatic event (TE)1. According to the DSM-V, TE exposure may take many forms, including direct or repeated indirect exposure to a real or perceived threat of death, bodily harm, or sexual violence to oneself or to another2. PTSD symptomatology is characterized by intrusive negative thoughts and recollections, hyperarousal, hypervigilance, increased risk-taking behavior, and disrupted sleep cycles3. Lifetime prevalence of TE exposure worldwide is relatively high at approximately 64%-70%3, though lifetime prevalence of PTSD remains comparatively low, at ~1.3%-12%4. This disparity in the prevalence of TE exposure relative to PTSD precipitation suggests a strong gene x environment interaction in vulnerability to PTSD. Given the current absence of a reliable vertebrate model of PTSD-like behavior, the field relies on behavioral paradigms for the induction of PTSD-like symptomatology5.
PTSD is a complex and highly heterogeneous psychiatric disorder, and developing a robust and reliable animal model for PTSD-like symptomatology has been challenging. Commonly used readouts for PTSD-like behavior, such as freezing, are also symptomatic of other trauma-induced psychopathologies, namely, anxiety, and depression6. This is further complicated by the high comorbidity between PTSD and depression2. Recent investigations have shown that rats that have witnessed traumatic events display increased anxiety and depression behaviors7,8,9, further demonstrating the importance of assessing PTSD-specific behaviors when utilizing behavioral models of PTSD in rodents. Additionally, resilience to PTSD-like symptomatology following traumatic event exposure is a significant epidemiologic feature of PTSD, as lifetime incidence of traumatic event exposure worldwide far outstrips lifetime prevalence of PTSD. Historically, behavioral models for induction of PTSD-like behavior, such as those investigating fear memory10,11, did not resolve PTSD-like animals from trauma-exposed controls (PTSD-resilient animals), treating all trauma-exposed animals as PTSD-like, and commonly used few behavior readouts, such as freezing, that are either not specifically symptomatic of PTSD or are symptomatic of other trauma-induced psychopathologies such as anxiety or depression12. While these paradigms are effective in investigating neural circuits of fear memory, the lack of a robust and specific assessment of PTSD-like behavior may impact the translation of these data. The current state of the field, therefore, focuses on paradigms utilizing multiple PTSD-specific behavioral readouts to identify both PTSD-like and resilient animals12.
We utilize a recently developed paradigm for the induction of PTSD-like behavior in mice which identifies both PTSD-like and resilient animals using a series of four behavioral tests to assay five PTSD-like behavioral readouts13,14. PTSD-like behavior is induced using decontextualized electric foot shock across two sessions. Animals are first exposed to a severe Trauma session on the first day, followed by a relatively mild Trigger session the following day (Figure 1). This combination has been shown to significantly increase the precipitation of PTSD-like behavior. This paradigm utilizes an acute stress model for PTSD induction rather than chronic stress (which may induce a more depressive phenotype15) or traumatic brain injury (which may result in a distinct PTSD-like phenotype14). Similarly, the behavioral readouts utilized to identify PTSD-like behavior in this paradigm – reduced risk-taking behavior, increased marble burying, reduced prepulse inhibition, reduced latency to peak startle amplitude, and increased light phase activity (Figure 1) – are specific to PTSD-like behavior, rather than to other trauma-induced psychopathologies such as anxiety or depression. Additionally, the use of multiple behavioral readouts, and the need for animals to display multiple PTSD-like behaviors in order to be designated PTSD-like, increases the likelihood that animals designated PTSD-like are truly displaying a PTSD-like phenotype. Together, these features of the protocol ensure that this paradigm is a robust and reliable means for inducing PTSD-like symptomatology in mice.
All procedures described here are approved by the Mayo Clinic Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC).
1. Animals and housing
2. PTSD-induction
3. Behavioral assessment
We expect to see animals displaying PTSD-like behavior in each behavioral test evenly distributed across all cohorts. A concentration of PTSD-like animals in any one cohort may indicate artifacts introduced either during the PTSD induction or behavioral testing. Animals scoring points in each behavioral readout are equally distributed across all cohorts tested (Figure 2). 7 of the 48 animals (14.6%) exposed to the PTSD-induction paradigm scored 5 or more points and were designated PTSD-like (Figure 3). A significantly higher number of animals were designated resilient. Retrospective assessment of PTSD-like and resilient animals shows that PTSD-like animals displayed significantly more PTSD-like behaviors in Marble Burying, Prepulse Inhibition, Latency to Peak Startle Amplitude, and Home Cage Activity. Additionally, PTSD-like animals displayed a very highly significantly more PTSD-like average behavioral Z (the average Z score across all behavioral tests) relative to resilient controls, indicating a high degree of behavioral synergy, decreasing the likelihood that animals were misidentified due to artifactually more PTSD-like behavior in some tests (Figure 4).
Figure 1: Timeline of behavioral protocols. PTSD-like behavior is induced via two sessions of the inescapable electric foot shock: a Trauma and Trigger session on days 1 and 2, respectively. Behavioral testing for PTSD-like behaviors is performed from days 8-15, with a dark/light transfer (DLT) test performed on day 8, a marble-burying test (MBT) performed on day 10, an acoustic startle response (ASR) test performed on day 12, and a home cage activity (HCA) test performed over days 13-15. Finally, animals are sacrificed on day 22. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Behavioral test results for a 48-animal cohort of mice. Z scores for (A) % Risk Assessment, (C) % Marbles Buried, (E) Latency to Peak Startle Amplitude, (G) % Prepulse Inhibition and (I) % Light Phase Activity for 48 animal cohort, as well as each individual 8 animal cohort (B, D, F, H, and J, respectively). Z values have been scaled such that a more positive Z value indicates more PTSD-like behavior (decreased % risk assessment, increased % marbles buried, decreased latency to peak startle amplitude, decreased % prepulse inhibition, and increased % light phase activity). The 20% most PTSD-like animals in each behavioral test are indicated by red data points. Plotted data represent means and standard deviations (SD). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: PTSD symptom scores for 48 mice. 7 mice (~15%) scoring 5 points or more were designated PTSD-like, while 16 mice (~30%) scored no points and were designated resilient. Plotted data represent means and standard deviations (SD). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: Behavioral test results for PTSD-like (n = 7) and Resilient (n = 16) mice from 48 animal cohort. Z scores for % Risk Assessment (%RA), % Marbles Buried (%MB), % Pre-Pulse Inhibition (%PPI), Latency to Peak Startle Amplitude (LtPSA), % Light Phase Activity (%LPA), as well as the average Z value of all behavioral tests (Avg Z). Plotted data represent means and standard deviations (SD). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Behavioral Test | Points (Top 20%) |
% Risk Assessment | 3 |
Marbles Buried | 1 |
Latency to Peak Startle Amplitude | 3 |
% Pre-Pulse Inhibition | 2 |
% Light Phase Activity | 1 |
Phenotype | Final Score |
PTSD-Like | 5+ |
Resilient | 0 |
Table 1: Scoring and inclusion criteria for identifying PTSD-like and resilient animals. The top 20% most PTSD-like animals for each behavioral readout receive points for that readout. Animals scoring 5 points or more are designated PTSD-like, while animals scoring no points are designated resilient.
Day | Cohort n | Cohort n+1 |
1 | Trauma | |
2 | Trigger | |
3 | ||
4 | ||
5 | ||
6 | ||
7 | ||
8 | LDT | Trauma |
9 | Trigger | |
10 | MBT | |
11 | ||
12 | ASR | |
13 | HCA | |
14 | HCA | |
15 | HCA | LDT |
16 | ||
17 | MBT | |
18 | ||
19 | ASR | |
20 | HCA | |
21 | HCA | |
22 | Sac | HCA |
Table 2: Example timeline of behavioral protocols when assaying multiple cohorts of animals. Experimental timelines for each cohort are staggered by 1 week. Light/dark transfer (LDT), marble-burying test (MBT), acoustic startle response (ASR), home cage activity (HCA), sacrifice (Sac).
PTSD is a complex and heterogenous psychiatric disease. Unfortunately, there is currently no reliable animal model for PTSD-like behavior, and behavioral paradigms for the induction of PTSD-like behavior are the most reliable means of generating animals displaying a PTSD-like behavioral phenotype. The paradigm described here provides a robust and reliable means of precipitating a PTSD-like behavioral phenotype due to the use of acute trauma to precipitate PTSD-like behavior and multiple PTSD-specific behavioral readouts to identify PTSD-like animals. The PTSD-specific behaviors utilized in this paradigm are highly clinically relevant. Five points are available from the acoustic startle response test (three points for reduced latency to peak startle amplitude and two points for reduced % prepulse inhibition), and hyperarousal is the most significant self-reported symptom associated with reduced quality of life in individuals with PTSD16. Ultimately animals must display PTSD-like behavior in the top 20% of animals in at least two behavioral readouts in order to score sufficient points to be designated PTSD-like, decreasing the likelihood of an animal being incorrectly designated PTSD-like due to artifactually PTSD-like behavior in any one test.
Behavioral testing should be performed during the dark phase, which is the mouse's active phase, and no sooner than 4 h after the beginning of the dark phase to ensure that all animals are in a stable phase of their corticosterone cycle. It is therefore highly recommended that animals be housed on an inverted light/dark cycle, allowing behavioral testing to be performed during normal work hours. If animals are housed on an inverted light/dark cycle, animals should be allowed to acclimate to the inverted light/dark cycle for at least 14 days to ensure that their circadian rhythm has fully adjusted, preventing any artifacts. Because this paradigm involves the differential use of light in both the induction of PTSD-like behavior, as well as in multiple assays utilized to identify PTSD-like behavior, viz. the dark/light transfer and home-cage activity tests, this protocol may not be effective in mouse strains experiencing retinal degeneration (e.g., CD1, FVB).
The trauma and trigger electric foot shock sessions should be performed on consecutive days to maximize the traumatic effect. Conversely, behavioral tests should never be performed on consecutive days in order to prevent undue stress, which may create artifacts. It is recommended to sacrifice animals via live decapitation without anesthetic in order to prevent artifacts in post-mortem analysis. There is sufficient time between the home cage activity test and sacrifice to perform any additional behavioral or functional assays such as a restrained stress test for corticosterone response13.
Whenever possible, it is recommended to remain in the procedure room for the duration of each behavioral test to ensure that the test runs without issue. One exception is the acoustic startle response test. Due to the high noise levels involved with that test it is recommended to remain in the procedure room at least long enough to observe the test is running normally before leaving the procedure room.
This paradigm precipitates PTSD-like behavior in ~10%-15% of exposed animals, which closely matches the rate of PTSD in individuals exposed to a traumatic event4. Unfortunately, this relatively low rate of PTSD induction necessitates a large number of animals in order to generate a sufficient number of PTSD-like animals for post hoc analysis. For example, exposing 48 mice to the PTSD-induction paradigm will result in 5-7 PTSD-like animals identified. The PTSD-induction paradigm and behavioral tests used to diagnose PTSD-like behavior are both time- and equipment-intensive. It is, therefore, not practical to process all animals through the paradigm simultaneously. We, therefore, recommend exposing animals to the paradigm in cohorts of 8-16 animals, depending on the equipment availability, and staggering the experiment schedule of these animals by 1 week (Table 2).
It is important to note that PTSD-like animals are not identified based on absolute behavioral readouts but instead based on their behavior relative to the cohort as a whole. The inability of this paradigm to identify PTSD-like based on absolute behavioral readouts necessitates the use of relatively large cohorts of animals and may limit experimental designs to investigate the effects of therapies or transgenes on PTSD-like behavior.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was made possible by the generosity of the Hayward Foundation and Marriot Family. We would also like to acknowledge the hard work and expertise of the Tulane University and Mayo Clinic IACUC committees and Departments of Comparative Medicine, as well as the Mayo Clinic Rodent Behavioral Research Facility.
Acetic acid, glacial | Sigma Aldrich | AX0073 | |
Benchtop Balance | Fisher Scientific | 01-913-925 | |
Clocklab Data Collection Suite | Actimetrics | – | Home cage activity cages |
Deciblemeter | |||
Ethovision XT14 Software | Noldus | – | Movement tracking software |
Ethyl alcohol | Sigma Aldrich | 443611 | |
Light/Dark Box | Noldus | – | Light/dark transfer box |
Lux Meter | |||
Monochrome GigE Camera | Noldus | – | Requires Ceiling Mounting Hardware Available from Noldus |
NIR Video Fear Conditioning Package for Mouse [Standard, USB] | Med Associates | MED-VFC2-USB-M | Fear conditioning equipment and chamber. Package includes all equipment needed to assay 1 animal at a time. |
Spray Bottle | Thermo Scientific | BirA500 | |
SR LAB Software | San Diego Instruments | – | Startle response software |
SR LAB Startle Response Unit | San Diego Instruments | – | Acoustic startle unit |
Video Fear Coniditioning "Video Freeze " Software | Med Associates | SOF-843 | Fear conditioning software |
White noise machine | Med Associates | ENV-230 |
.