We demonstrate an assay to analyze the environmental and genetic cues that influence mating behavior in the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster.
An individual’s sexual drive is influenced by genotype, experience and environmental conditions. How these factors interact to modulate sexual behaviors remains poorly understood. In Drosophila melanogaster, environmental cues, such as food availability, affect mating activity offering a tractable system to investigate the mechanisms modulating sexual behavior. In D. melanogaster, environmental cues are often sensed via the chemosensory gustatory and olfactory systems. Here, we present a method to test the effect of environmental chemical cues on mating behavior. The assay consists of a small mating arena containing food medium and a mating couple. The mating frequency for each couple is continuously monitored for 24 h. Here we present the applicability of this assay to test environmental compounds from an external source through a pressurized air system as well as manipulation of the environmental components directly in the mating arena. The use of a pressurized air system is especially useful to test the effect of very volatile compounds, while manipulating components directly in the mating arena can be of value to ascertain a compound’s presence. This assay can be adapted to answer questions about the influence of genetic and environmental cues on mating behavior and fecundity as well as other male and female reproductive behaviors.
Reproductive behaviors typically have high energy costs, especially for females, who produce larger gametes than males and must carefully chose the conditions to raise their developing offspring. Because of the energy cost, it is not surprising that reproduction is connected to nutritional conditions. This is true in most, if not all, animals including mammals, whose puberty can be delayed by malnutrition, and whose sexual drive can be negatively affected by food-restriction1.
The reproduction of the genetic model organism Drosophila melanogaster is also affected by nutritional conditions. Males court at higher level in the presence of food volatiles2, and females are more sexually receptive in the presence of yeast, a major nutrient for egg production and offspring survival3,4,5. This evolutionary conserved reproductive response to food offers the opportunity to study mechanisms that connect environmental food availability to sexual reproduction in a genetically tractable and time-efficient organism. Indeed, work in D. melanogaster has implicated the insulin pathway as an important regulator of the connection between food and mating behavior6. It has also shown that the act of mating itself changes the food preference of females as well as the associated chemosensory neurons7,8,9.
It is clear that food cues affect reproductive behaviors in D. melanogaster. These effects seem to mainly affect females, specifically those who have already mated5. However, to test these acute effects of environmental conditions the assay classically used for female mating behavior might not be very suitable due to the long interruptions between mating episodes. In the classic remating assay, a virgin female first mates with a male, and is immediately isolated and presented with a new male 24 to 48 h later. This classic assay has been used with great success to identify components of the male ejaculate that modify the female behavior and the female response12,13,14,15,16,17,18. The continuous mating assay demonstrated here, is therefore, an addition to classic mating assays that can be used to study the acute effect of environmental conditions on reproductive behaviors.
Using the continuous assay for mating behavior that is explained here, we previously showed that a pair of flies exposed to yeast will remate several times over a 24 h observation period5,19,20,21, while flies not exposed to food will only remate once5. This finding can be puzzling in the light of a large portion of the D. melanogaster literature indicating that females do not remate for several days after an initial mating (reviewed in references10,11). However, this discrepancy can easily be explained by assay conditions, where a female is isolated for one to several days before a new mating opportunity is provided. If the pair does not mate in this hour-long observation period, the female is characterized as not receptive. Moreover, the high mating frequency should not be surprising given that the data from wild-caught flies show that females contain sperm from 4 to 6 males in their storage organs; thus indicating that females naturally remate several times22,23.
Here, we demonstrate the use of this continuous mating assay to unravel how flies gather and combine information about environmental conditions to modulate mating frequency. This assay allows one to test a relatively large number of mating couples for genetic studies and to test the influence of volatile and non-volatile environmental cues. The assay typically runs for 24 h, but can be extended to 48 h, allowing the testing of cycling environmental cues such as the light-dark (LD) cycle. We demonstrate this assay by testing the influence of volatile cues from a yeast culture within a pressurized air system in combination with the availability of non-volatile yeast nutrient in the food substrate.
The pressurized air system continuously pumps volatile cues into a mating arena that contains a food substrate and a test couple (whose mating behavior is monitored). To further determine the specifics through which yeast influences mating, we test a major volatile compound of yeast, namely acetic acid24, in combination with an amino acid content that corresponds to that of yeast in the food substrate, in the form of peptone (amino acids derived from enzymatic digestion of animal proteins). Together these experiments demonstrate how the effect of environmental cues on the mating behavior of D. melanogaster can be tested with this assay.
1. Environmentally Controlled Mating Box
2. Fly Rearing and Collection
3. Food Medium Preparation
4. Mating Arena Preparation
5. Yeast Culture for Odor
6. Air Pump Set-up
7. Monitoring of Mating Behavior
Using this continuous assay, mating behavior, and mating frequency in specific, can be determined under experimental environmental conditions. To control environmental conditions, we transformed a stainless-steel kitchen cabinet into a test area, with its own light source and diffusion, which ensures a high abundance of light and a minimum amount of glare from the top of the mating arenas (Figure 1A). The inner test area is completely encased by stainless steel and glass, which allows for cleaning with organic solvents, such as hexane or ethanol. Additionally, the cabinet is equipped with holes that act as inlets for tubing, bringing volatile cues from the pressurized air system (see Figures 1A and 1B). The pressurized air system, adjusted for yeast odors, consists of an airflow guided through a liquid yeast culture before entering the test arenas through 4 pipette splitters with 10 outlets each (Figure 1C). The whole system is airtight and fitted with several particle filters, both before and after entering the yeast culture, to minimize contamination with confounding odors (Figure 1B).
To demonstrate the use of this assay, we tested whether volatile cues from a yeast culture can influence mating behavior. Air was bubbled through a liquid yeast culture for 24 h, and the air outlets were placed in the entrance of each mating arena (see Figure 2A). Half of the mating arenas contained fly food with yeast (Food + yeast), and the other half contained fly food without yeast added (Food – yeast). A wildtype male and female were exposed to the odors coming from the external yeast culture, and their mating frequency was recorded. To determine which variables are necessary to explain the graphed results, we ran mixed-effects models, either including or excluding the independent variables of food medium, yeast air, and an interaction of the two. The data in Figure 2B is best represented by a model including the independent variables of food medium (p = 0.001) and yeast air (p = 0.061), but there is no explaining interaction effect. Even though the yeast air variable is not significant in this full data set, it is necessary to explain the results. Analysis of yeast air separated for food medium shows that a mating couple does not respond to yeast odors when there is no yeast present in the food medium (air: p = 0.992), but they do increase their mating frequency in yeast air when yeast is also added to the food medium (air: p = 0.018). Together, these results demonstrate the applicability of the pressurized air system to test the influence of environmental odors in combination with food medium conditions.
We also illustrate how the pressurized air system can be bypassed by adding environmental chemical cues directly to the test arena. To demonstrate which specific yeast compounds affect mating frequency, we tested the hypothesis that the amino acid content of yeast is necessary for its effect on mating by placing a dose of peptone (hydrolyzed proteins) corresponding to the amino acids supplied by the yeast in the agar substrate lining the mating arena. We also tested the necessity of acetic acid, one of the major volatile fermentation products of yeast, to increase mating frequency. This was done by adding acetic acid directly to the food medium. A wildtype male and female were tested in arenas containing agar or agar with peptone, with or without acetic acid directly in the food medium (Figure 3B). This makes for a very simple food medium and a poor environment; therefore, the average mating frequency is also decreased as compared to Figure 2B. The data in Figure 3B is best represented by a model including the independent variables of food medium (p = 0.002), acetic acid air (p = 0.001), and the interaction of the two (p = 0.022). Female receptivity increases upon the presence of acetic acid, but only in the condition where peptone is present in the medium. This shows that flies need to simultaneously sense amino acids and acetic acid to increase their mating frequency (Figure 3B). This demonstrates that adding odorous compounds directly to the test arena can influence mating behavior and that those influences can be detected in very simple environmental conditions.
Figure 1: Diagram of the experimental box and pressurized air system with yeast. (A) Schematic illustration of the environmentally controlled mating box described in section 1. Description of the annotated numbers and arrows: 1. light board with alternating white and red lights; 2. small fan; 3. 3 layers of filter paper, each layer consisting of two filter-paper sheets; 4. glass diffusion plate resting on brackets attached to 3 sides of the box; 5. big fan; 6. holes for tubing and cables; 7. experimental area; large arrow, 50 cm to the glass plate; middle arrow, 35 cm height for the cable holes; and small arrow, 7 cm height for the tubing holes. (B) Schematic illustration of the liquid yeast culture with airflow, as described in sections 5, 6.4, and 6.5. Description of the annotated numbers: 1. disposable filter unit; 2. cap with silicone septum and out- and inlets; 3. liquid medium; and 4. glass tube with glass fiber. (C) Schematic illustration of the air outlets as described in section 6.7. Description of the annotated numbers: 1. serological pipette; 2. tubing cut from 1 mL syringe, and 3. 1,000 µL pipette tip. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Yeast odor increases female receptivity in the presence of yeast in the food substrate. (A) Schematic illustration of a mating arena with one male and one female and a pipette tip from the air outlet in Figure 1C entering through the entrance hole. (B) Graphical presentation of the response in mating frequency of a Canton-S mating couple to yeast odor with and without yeast in the fly food medium (Food – yeast: medium air n = 12, yeast air n = 13 and Food + yeast: medium air n = 24, yeast air n = 23). Line graph with SEM error bars and statistical output of mixed-effects models with air as the independent variable and the date as a random variable for each food medium independently. The main statistical model includes food (p = 0.001) and yeast air (p = 0.061). Adapted from reference5. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Acetic acid in fly food substrate increases female receptivity in the presence of peptone. (A) Schematic illustration of a mating arena, with fly food medium containing acetic acid and a plastic paraffin film plug closing the entrance hole. (B) A graphical presentation of the mating frequency of a Canton-S mating couple in response to acetic acid either on agar or peptone medium (agar: -acetic acid n = 52, +acetic acid n = 40 and peptone: -acetic acid n = 28, +acetic acid n = 25). Line graph with SEM error bars and the statistical output of the mixed-effects model with food medium (p = 0.002), acetic acid air (p = 0.001), and food*air (p = 0.022) as independent variables and the date as a random variable. Adapted from reference5. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
This protocol describes an assay to test mating behavior over 24 h while continuously controlling the environmental cues that a mating couple is hypothesized to use to determine mating frequency. It is possible to increase the mating frequency in response to yeast air delivered through a pressurized air system when the medium contains yeast as well (Figure 2B). Additionally, a similar response in mating frequency can be observed with a simplified food medium containing only agar, peptone, and acetic acid odor directly in the medium (Figure 3B)
With the experiments demonstrated here, conclusions can only be drawn on the general mating behavior of the couple, since both sexes are exposed to the same environmental conditions. However, we know from previous research that 47% of the variation in mating frequency is determined by the female, while the male contribution only accounts for 11% of the variation20. Therefore, most of the changes in mating frequency observed are likely a result of female sexual receptivity. Increased males courtship still leaves the female to accept or reject mating, as adult D. melanogaster females can successfully deflect mating attempts29. For firm conclusions and to specifically attribute differences in mating frequency to female sexual receptivity, it is necessary to test additional mating couples where the genotype of the female is varied but that of the male is kept constant.
This protocol has demonstrated two ways to deliver odorous compounds to a mating couple, either with a pressurized air system or directly into the food medium. The pressurized air system has the advantage that any effect can be attributed to the compounds that are delivered through the air, while this cannot be concluded when the compounds are put directly into the food medium. On the other hand, when no effect is found with the pressurized air system, it does not automatically mean that the cue does not affect behavior. It could also mean that the compound is not efficiently delivered through the pressurized air system. The composition of the air at the outlet of the air delivery system can be analyzed by placing a hydrocarbon filter and analyzing the trapped air content with gas chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry. The pressurized air system is a good assay to test compounds that can be easily made airborne over a longer range. Less volatile compounds might have to be put directly into the food medium. Another disadvantage of the pressurized air system is the effect air velocity can have on fly behavior. Flies stop moving when the air velocity is too high (above 0.7-1.6 m/s)30. Additionally, the pressurized air system can render a simple, low-quality environment intolerable by drying out the food medium. In both cases, the flies might not perform equally well, and no conclusions can then be attributed to the specific compounds tested.
Several steps are essential during preparation for the optimal running of these assays. The first step that requires attention is preparation of the medium. It is important that the medium, including odorous volatile compounds such as acetic acid, is prepared on the day of the experiment and not sooner in order to avoid evaporation. Also, the medium needs to harden on a surface with no extra airflow (avoid using fume hoods for this), because airflow can stimulate the evaporation of the odor. The second step that requires special care is the establishment of the pressurized air system. The airflow needs to be high enough to gently bubble the yeast culture without transferring any fluid to the arena.
This protocol demonstrates a behavioral assay with yeast odors in combination with mating behavior. However, this system can be applied to any type of odor, as well as to other types of behaviors. To use this system for other odors, it is necessary to adjust the airflow and odor medium to optimize the transfer of the compounds to the dishes. However, in general, any compound that can be transferred by air can be tested with this system. In addition, any type of behavior, in both males and females, can be tested, either by using the same type of dishes or by adjusting the tubing to reach and connect to bigger or smaller test areas. Additionally, when more detailed behaviors are tested, the frame rates and resolutions of the cameras used need to be reconsidered. In any case, if both experiments with and without the test odor are run at the same time and with the same air source, any response to the environmental cue can be detected, regardless of changes in pressure or concentration from one experiment to the other. Lastly, the assay demonstrated here can be extended for at least another LD cycle (up to 48 h), as long as the food supply does not dry out.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
We thank the Bloomington Drosophila Stock Center for the fly stocks; C. Gahr, J. T. Alkema, and S. van Hasselt for their early attempt at developing the pressurized air assay; Jasper Bosman for the advice on cultivating yeast; and Rezza Azanchi and Joel Levine for originally developing the time-lapse monitoring of Drosophila mating behavior. J.A. Gorter was supported by a Neuroscience Research School BCN/NWO Graduate Program grant. This work was supported in part by the Dutch organization for scientific research (NWO) (reference: 821.02.020) to J.C. Billeter.
Cabinet | |||
Stainless steel kitchen cabinet | Horecaworld | 7412.0105 | |
White LEDs | Lucky Light | ll-583wc2c-001 | Cold white, 20 mAmp and 2 V |
Red LEDs | Lucky Ligt | ll-583vc2c-v1-4da | Wavelength between 625 nm, 20 mAmp and 6 V |
Resistor | Royal Ohm | CFR0W4J0561A50 | 560 ohm, 0.25 W, 250 V and 5 % tolerance |
Smartphone light meter app | Patrick Giudicelli | Light/Lux Meter FREE, version 1.1.1 | |
Power timer | Alecto | TS-121 | |
Metal brackets | Sharp angle 5 by 5 mm, 2 x 5450 and 1 x 1100 mm long | ||
Frosted glass plate | 1190 x 545 x 5 mm | ||
Filter paper sheets | LEE filters | 220 | White frost |
Small fan | Nanoxia Deep silence | 4260285292828 | 80 mm Ultra-Quiet PC Fan, 1200 RPM |
Big fan | Nanoxia Deep silence | 4260285292910 | 120 mm Ultra-Quiet PC Fan, 650-1500 RPM |
Webcam camera | Logitech | 950270 | B910 HD WEBCAM OEM, Angle: 78-degree, resolution: 5-million-pixel |
Camera software | DeskShare | Security monitor pro | |
Name | Company | Catalog Number | Comments |
Fly rearing | |||
Fly rearing bottles | Flystuff | 32-130 | 6oz Drosophila stock bottle |
Flypad | Flystuff | 59-114 | |
Wild-type flies | Canton-S | ||
Fly rearing vials | Dominique Dutscher | 789008 | Drosophila tubes narrow 25×95 mm |
Incubator | Sanyo | MIR-154 | |
Magnetic hot plate | Heidolph | 505-20000-00 | MR Hei-Standard |
Agar | Caldic Ingredients B.V. | 010001.26.0 | |
Glucose | Gezond&wel | 1019155 | Dextrose/Druivensuiker |
Sucrose | Van Gilse | Granulated sugar | |
Cornmeal | Flystuff | 62-100 | |
Wheat germ | Gezond&wel | 1017683 | |
Soy flour | Flystuff | 62-115 | |
Molasses | Flystuff | 62-117 | |
Active dry yeast | Red Star | ||
Tegosept | Flystuff | 20-258 | 100% |
Peptone (bacto) | BD | 211677 | |
Acetic Acid | Merck | 1000631000 | Glacial, 100% |
Small petridish | Greiner bio-one | 627102 | 35 x 10 mm with vents |
Paraffin film | Bemis NA | Parafilm | |
Name | Company | Catalog Number | Comments |
Yeast and pressurised air set-up | |||
Big petridish | Gosselin | BP140-01 | 140 x 20.6 mm |
Ultrapure water | Millipore corporation | MiliQ | |
Yeast extract | BD | 212750 | |
Agar (pure) | BD | 214530 | bacto |
Glucose (0(+)-glucose monohydrate) | Merck | 18270000004 | |
Open caps | Schott | 29 240 28 | GL45 |
Silicone septum | VWR | 548-0662 | |
Barbed bulkhead fittings | Nalgene | 6149-0002 | |
Large PVC tubing | diameter: outer 1.2 cm and inner 0.9 cm | ||
Small PVC tubing | diameters: outer 0.8 cm and inner 0.5 cm | ||
15 ml tube | Falcon | ||
Aquarium pump | Sera precision | Sera air 110 plus, AC 220-240 V, 50/60 Hz, 3 W and pressure >100 mbar | |
Activated charcoal | Superfish | A8040400 | Norit activated carbon |
Disposible filter unit | Whatman | 10462100 | |
Serological pipettes | VWR | 612-1600 | |
Syringe | BD Plastipak | 300013 | |
Hot glue | Pattex | ||
Syringe filter | Whatman | FP 30/pore size 0.45 mm CA-S | |
Name | Company | Catalog Number | Comments |
Analysis | |||
Statistics software | R | lme4 package |