Here, we present a protocol to assess whether various types of silent cerebrovascular lesions are differentially associated with deficits in certain cognitive domains in a cohort of 398 hypertensive elderly Chinese, using a combination of neuropsychological tests and multi-sequence 3T MRI scanning.
Evidence accumulated from the last decade has proven that silent cerebrovascular lesions (SCLs) and their underlying pathogenic processes contribute to cognitive decline in the elderly. However, the distinct effects of each type of the lesions on cognitive performance remain unclear. Moreover, research data from Chinese elderly with SCLs is scarce. In this study, 398 otherwise healthy hypertensive elderly subjects (median age 72 years) were included and assessed. All participates were required to complete a battery of structured neuropsychological assessment, including forward and backward digit span tests, symbol digit modalities test, Stroop test, verbal fluency test and Montreal Cognitive Assessment. These tests were used to assess attention, executive function, information processing speed, language, memory and visuospatial function. A multi-sequence 3T MRI scanning was arranged within one month of the neuropsychological assessment to evaluate the burden of SCLs. SCLs were rated visually. Cerebral microbleeds (CMBs) and silent lacunes (SLs) were identified as strictly lobar CMBs and SLs or deep CMBs and SLs according to their locations, respectively. Similarly, white matter hyperintensities (WMHs) were separated into periventricular WMHs (PVHs) and deep WMHs (DWMHs). A series of linear regression models were used to assess the correlation between each type of SCLs and individual cognitive function domain. The results showed that CMBs tend to impair language-related cognition. Deep SLs affect executive function, but this association disappeared after controlling for other types of SCLs. PVHs, rather than DWMHs, are associated with cognitive decline, especially in executive function and processing speed. It is concluded that different aspects of SCLs have differential impact on cognitive performance in hypertensive elderly Chinese.
Silent lacunes (SLs), cerebral microbleeds (CMBs) and white matter hyperintensities (WMHs) are referred to as silent cerebrovascular lesions (SCLs). Two types of WMHs are recognized: periventricular WMHs (PVHs) and deep WMHs (DWMHs). SCLs were once regarded as benign lesions without clinical significance. After decades of research, SCLs are now confirmed to be linked to varying functional impairment and cognitive deficits1,2. Nevertheless, consistent evidence is still limited in the spectrum and magnitude of cognitive effects of different types of SCLs. Moreover, the underlying mechanisms are elusive.
Most previous studies either recruited hospital patients with severe medical conditions3,4,5 or included participants with advanced cerebral small vessel diseases6,7. The heterogeneity of the participants among different studies has partly contributed to the inconsistent results. To exclude these confounding factors, we conducted the current one-centered study as an attempt to provide a clear picture through assessment of a relatively large, pure cohort recruited from a primary care setting. Furthermore, previous studies have predominantly focused on one or two types of SCLs and did not fully evaluate the independent associations between individual SCLs and specific cognitive functions. Therefore, we assessed various types of SCLs in the current study.
Neuropsychological tests are widely used to assess cognitive function of specific domains. They are useful in differentiation between normal aging and early cognitive impairment. Results of properly conducted neuropsychological assessment are sensitive in discerning behavioral and functional deficits. A battery of structured neuropsychological tests was chosen, including forward and backward digit span tests, symbol digit modalities test (SDMT), Stroop test, verbal fluency test and Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA). Scores from these tests were grouped and combined to represent performance in different cognitive domains8,9. Such a method is widely used and is time efficient. A major drawback is that different neuropsychological tests may partly overlap in their tested domains. A more specific alternative is to use computer-based assessment with well-designed modules constructed using the E-Prime system, which is time-consuming and may not be suitable for screening purposes.
In conclusion, we aimed to assess the associations between the burden of different SCLs and impairment of various cognitive domains. Furthermore, vascular risk factors and other types of SCLs were controlled for to determine the distinct and independent profile of cognitive impairment of each type of SCLs.
The study protocol was approved by the Institutional Review Board of the University of Hong Kong / Hospital Authority Hong Kong West Cluster (HKU/HA HKW IRB) for human research.
1. Participants
2. Neuropsychological assessment
3. MRI acquisition and Visual rating of SCLs on MRI
4. Statistical analysis
The mean age of the 398 participants was 72.0 (from 65 to 99, SD = 5.1) years, and there were 213 men (53. 5%; Table 3). Table 4 summarizes the neuropsychological assessment results. Only 5 participants had all four types of SCLs. One or more types of SCLs were found in 169 (42.5%) participants, and 35 (8.8%) and 17 (4.3%) participants had 2 and 3 types of SCLs, respectively (Table 5).
The degree of PVHs and DWMHs were separately examined for their associations with performance in different cognitive domains. The data confirmed an independent association between the burden of PVHs and worse performance in executive function and information processing speed (Table 6). An increasing load of CMBs was associated with impaired language-related performance. Additional adjustment for vascular risk factors and other types of SCLs did not affect the independent impact of CMBs on language function (Table 6). Although there was a significant association between the presence of SLs and worse performance on executive function, this association was lost following additional correction for other types of SCLs (Table 6).
Figure 1: Test sheets for the neuropsychological assessment. (A) Forward digit span test. (B) Stroop test. (C) Symbol digit modalities test. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: MRI Images of different kinds of silent cerebrovascular lesions. (A) Fazekas grade 2 PVHs and DWMHs on a FLAIR image. (B) A CMB on SWI. (C) A SL on T1-weighted image magnified on both T1-weighted and T2-weighted imaging. CMB, cerebral microbleed; DWMHs, deep white matter hyperintensities; PVHs, periventricular hyperintensities; SL, silent lacune. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Cognitive domains | Neuropsychological tests |
Attention | forward digit span, backward digit span |
Executive function | backward digit span, Stroop interference subtask, verbal fluency |
Information processing speed | Stroop color naming subtask, Stroop neutral color subtask, symbol digit modalities oral test, symbol digit modalities written test |
Language-related function | MoCA naming, MoCA repetition, verbal fluency |
Memory | MoCA verbal learning test |
Visuospatial function | MoCA drawing a clock, MoCA copying a cube |
Table 1: Neuropsychological tests of six different cognitive domains. MoCA, Montreal cognitive assessment. Original source: Reference20.
MRI sequences | Repetition time | Echo time | Inversion time | Slices | Slice thickness | Acquisition matrix size |
Axial three dimensional T1-weighted magnetization prepared rapid gradient echo | 7000 ms | 3.2 ms | / | 155 | 1 mm | 240 x 240 |
Axial proton density/T2 turbo spin echo run twice | 5000 ms | 16/80 ms | / | 50 | 2.5 mm | 480 x 480 |
Fluid attenuated inversion recovery sequence | 11000 ms | 120 ms | 2800 ms | 50 | 1 mm | 768 x 768 |
Susceptibility weighted imaging | 27.9 ms | 23 ms | / | 135 | 2 mm | 704 x 704 |
Table 2: MRI sequences and main parameters.
Demographic characteristics | Number of participants |
Male (%) | 213 (53.5) |
Mean age in years (SD) | 72.0 (5.1) |
Mean SBP in mmHg (% on drugs) | |
<120 | 21 (5.3) |
120-139 | 302 (75.8) |
≥140 | 75 (18.9) |
Mean DBP in mmHg (% on drugs) | |
<80 | 265 (66.6) |
80-89 | 114 (28.7) |
≥90 | 19 (4.7) |
History of smoking status (%) | 84 (20.0) |
History of heavy alcohol consuming (%) | 14 (3.5) |
BMI distribution (%) | |
<25 | 228 (57.3) |
25-29.9 | 146 (36.7) |
≥30 | 24 (6.0) |
Median educational level in years (IQR) | 8 (6) |
Table 3: Demographic characteristics and vascular risk factors of 398 participants. BMI, body mass index; DBP, diastolic blood pressure; IQR, interquartile range; SBP, systolic blood pressure; SD, standard deviation. Original source: Reference20.
Neuropsychological tests | Mean score | Standard deviation |
Backward digit span | 4.6 | 1.6 |
Forward digit span | 8 | 1.5 |
MoCA copying a cube and drawing a clock | 3.4 | 0.9 |
MoCA naming | 2.9 | 0.3 |
MoCA repetition | 2.7 | 0.5 |
MoCA verbal learning test | 12.5 | 2.4 |
Stroop color naming in s | 18.7 | 5.9 |
Stroop neutral color in s | 25.9 | 10.4 |
Stroop interference in s | 43.1 | 17.5 |
Symbol digit modalities oral test | 41.0 | 12.8 |
Symbol digit modalities written test | 32.2 | 11.9 |
Verbal fluency | 14.2 | 3.2 |
Table 4: Neuropsychological assessment results. MoCA, Montreal cognitive assessment. Original source: Reference20.
Types of SCLs | n (%) |
PVHs | |
Fazekas grade 1 | 176 (44.2) |
Fazekas grade 2 | 191 (48.0) |
Fazekas grade 3 | 31 (7.8) |
DWMHs | |
Fazekas grade 1 | 326 (81.9) |
Fazekas grade 2 | 56 (14.1) |
Fazekas grade 3 | 16 (4.0) |
CMBs | |
Strictly lobar | 53 (13.3) |
Deep | 17 (4.3) |
Both | 15 (3.8) |
SLs | |
Strictly lobar | 65 (14.8) |
Deep | 6 (1.50) |
SCLs | |
One type | 112 (28.1) |
Two types | 35 (8.8) |
Three types | 17 (4.3) |
All four types | 5 (1.3) |
Table 5: Prevalence and distribution of different types of SCLs. CMBs, cerebral microbleeds; DWMHs, deep white matter hyperintensities; PVHs, periventricular hyperintensities; SCLs, silent cerebrovascular lesions; SLs, silent lacunes. Original source: Reference20.
Executive function | Information processing speed | Language-related function | ||||||||||
B | SE | β | p-value | B | SE | β | p-value | B | SE | β | p-value | |
PVHs severity1 | -0.143 | 0.059 | -0.13 | 0.016* | -0.159 | 0.059 | -0.131 | 0.007* | -0.147 | 0.059 | -0.128 | 0.014* |
Strictly lobar CMBs1 | NA | NA | -0.275 | 0.108 | 0.134 | 0.012* | ||||||
Deep SLs1 | -0.235 | 0.012 | -0.121 | 0.021* | NA | NA | ||||||
PVHs severity2 | -0.126 | 0.063 | -0.106 | 0.046* | -0.149 | 0.064 | -0.116 | 0.020* | -0.107 | 0.062 | -0.09 | 0.088 |
Strictly lobar CMBs2 | NA | NA | -0.202 | 0.102 | -0.098 | 0.049* | ||||||
Deep SLs2 | -0.197 | 0.106 | -0.098 | 0.064 | NA | NA |
Table 6: Association between severity of PVHs, presence of deep SLs or strictly lobar CMBs and the Z score of selected cognitive domains. B, unstandardized beta coefficient; β, standardized beta coefficient; CMBs, cerebral microbleeds; NA, not applicable; PVHs, periventricular hyperintensities; SCLs, silent cerebrovascular lesions; SLs, silent lacunes; SE, standard error. 1, single variable linear regression models controlled for age, gender, educational levels and vascular risk factors (body mass index, hyperlipidemia, impaired glucose tolerance, smoking, drinking, systolic blood pressure and diastolic blood pressure); 2, multiple variables linear regression models controlled for age, gender, educational levels and the other two types of SCLs. *, p < 0.05. Original source: Reference20.
In the study, we have combined the results of a battery of neuropsychological assessment and findings of a multi-sequence MRI examination to evaluate the impact of different types of SCLs on various cognitive functions. The major types of SCLs were examined (i.e., CMBs, SLs and WMHs). As previous studies have revealed that SCLs in different locations may represent different pathology and lead to different consequences, we categorized CMBs and SLs into strictly lobar (i.e., lobar only without deep ones) and deep ones (with or without lobar ones), and separated WMHs into PVHs and DWMHs. A battery of structured neuropsychological tests was chosen to provide a comprehensive assessment of cognitive functions covering six domains (i.e., attention, executive function, information processing speed, language, memory and visuospatial function). Compound scores for each domain were constructed for statistical analyses.
PVHs adversely affect executive function and information processing speed. Strictly lobar CMBs are linked to impaired language dysfunction. SLs are associated with impaired executive function. We additionally controlled for the vascular risk factors and other types of SCLs to determine the independent effects of each type of SCLs on cognitive functions. All the above-mentioned associations are independent of the vascular risk factors except that the association between SLs and executive function has disappeared when controlled for PVHs; other associations are not affected by controlling for other types of SCLs. In conclusion, the protocol has successfully confirmed that the type of SCLs could differentially affect the cognitive performance in different domains. In other words, different types of SCLs are associated with distinct profiles of cognitive impairments. As previous studies have observed clinical differences between patients with hypertensive and non-hypertensive ischemic stroke21, the results of the present study are relevant to patients with hypertension.
Other limitations of the current research must be noted. First, the incidence and number of lesions in individual participants are relatively low despite choosing a cohort of hypertensive elderly who should have a higher incidence of SCLs than healthy non-hypertensive elderly. A possible explanation is the exclusion of the participant with significant diseases such as dementia and other overt cardiovascular diseases. Such exclusion criteria have omitted the participant at an advanced stage of SCLs and therefore could have underestimated the burden and impact of the SCLs. Another explanation is that the burden of SCLs may be lower in Asians than Caucasians. In any case, a lower burden of SCLs in the cohort has hindered the opportunity for further exploration of the impact of individual type of SCLs and their strategic locations. The chosen battery of neuropsychological assessment has led to another limitation. Some of these tests have inherent overlaps in their evaluated domains, while others have been used in different protocols to assess different domains. These could have contributed to the inconsistencies between the present and published results. We have adopted neuropsychological tests that were most frequently used in the literature for specific cognitive domains. Modules using computer-based tests or functional neuroimaging studies developed for different individual domains should be used in future studies. Focal cerebral atrophy is a potentially important type of SCLs relevant to both hypertension and cognitive functions22, warranting further studies.
It is crucial to ensure that the participant knows precisely what is required to do when a start signal is given during the neuropsychological assessment. A practice stage is generally available before the formal test, during which the participant's errors are pointed out for corrections. A unified standard should be adopted for different tests in all participants, and this was achieved by having the same person (M. ZHANG) administer all the neuropsychological tests. The standard assessment procedures were reviewed every three months to ensure uniformity.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported by matching and donation funds (Cerebrovascular Research Fund, SHAC Matching Grant, UGC Matching Grant, and Dr. William Mong Research Fund in Neurology awarded to Professor R.T.F. Cheung).