Electrochemotherapy is the local treatment of solid tumors. The main mechanism is electroporation-mediated permeabilization of the tumor cells’ membrane which enables increased internalization of cytostatics like bleomycin and cisplatin. Thus, antitumor effectiveness is potentiated at the site of the application of electric pulses to the tumors.
Electrochemotherapy (ECT) is a local approach which is used for treating solid tumors of different histologies. Its mechanism is based on cell membrane permeabilization by means of "electroporation". To achieve the "electroporation" of the cells, electric pulses are generated by a generator and delivered to the target tissue by the use of electrodes. Electroporation is a physical method which is used to introduce molecules, like cytostatic drugs, into the cells that could not pass the cell membrane on their own. In electrochemotherapy, currently, cisplatin and bleomycin are clinically used. Electrochemotherapy antitumor effectiveness is high, for example up to 100% complete response of canine mast cell tumors smaller than 2 cm3 was achieved. Additionally, electrochemotherapy can be used for the treatment of inoperable tumors. One of the important characteristics of electrochemotherapy is that it can be effective as a one-time treatment only. However, in the case of failure or partial tumor response it can be repeated several times with equal or improved effectiveness. Electrochemotherapy is already a standard treatment for cutaneous and subcutaneous tumors of various histologies in human and veterinary oncology. Furthermore, several clinical studies exploiting electrochemotherapy for deep-seated tumors are on-going.
ECT is a local ablative technique for the treatment of tumors of different histologies. Ablation results from the drug induced cell kill, which is a result of increased drug accumulation in the cells due to changed cell membrane permeability induced by direct delivery of electric pulses on the skin around the tumor after the intratumoral or intravenous injection of the drug. The main mechanism of ECT is to enhance the effectiveness of cytostatic drugs by increased intracellular drug accumulation, by cell membrane electropermeabilization (electroporation)1,2. Electroporation causes an increased drug uptake of two cytostatics: bleomycin and cisplatin, which are hydrophilic drugs with poor membrane permeability. Due to the increased cytotoxicity of bleomycin and cisplatin at the site of application of the electric pulse, low drug doses are needed for good antitumor effectiveness and consequently no or minimal systemic side effects of the drugs are observed3. Another characteristic of ECT is a tumor antivascular effect which results firstly in vascular lock, i.e., decreased blood flow within the tumor, and consequently the retention of cytostatics within it and secondly in a vascular disrupting action, i.e., direct killing of endothelial cells of small blood vessels leading to secondary tumor cell death4-6. The third mechanism of ECT antitumor effectiveness is the activation of the immune system as ECT elicits an immune response by tumor antigen shedding in the tumor surroundings. The involvement of the immune system is crucial for the complete eradication of the tumor7.
ECT has shown great potential in human oncology, where ECT is already used as a standard treatment for cutaneous and subcutaneous tumors as it exhibits up to 80% of objective responses3. Additionally, ECT is used in several clinical studies treating tumor metastases in the brain8, bone9 and liver10. Clinical studies in veterinary oncology have already demonstrated that ECT treatment results in up to 80% long-lasting objective responses when treating cutaneous and subcutaneous tumors in dogs11, 12, cats13 and horses14. The antitumor effectiveness is dependent on tumor size and tumors smaller than 2 cm3 respond better than bigger tumors15.
Also, a study comparing surgery with ECT in treating mast cell tumors in dogs showed that treatment with ECT resulted in 70% of complete responses while surgery resulted in 50% of complete responses11 demonstrating that ECT is an equivalent treatment to surgery. Additionally, ECT represents an alternative method for treating solid tumors to surgical treatment, specifically in those cases when owners do not consent to surgery or if the tumors are difficult to excise with clear margins mostly due to their location (e.g., infiltrating major vessels, tumors of the head or leg, in the anal region etc.). The aim of this paper is to define the operating procedures of ECT giving instructions for the use of cisplatin and bleomycin in combination with the application of electric pulses in order to safely and appropriately treat cutaneous and subcutaneous tumors in dogs and cats.
This protocol was approved by the Ethical Committee of the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Food and follows its guidelines. The protocol was validated on more than 80 dogs and 20 cats.
NOTE: ECT treatment consists of the administration of cisplatin or bleomycin and exposure of tumor nodules to electric pulses.
1. Patient Selection
NOTE: Patient selection allows the practitioner to determine whether the patient is suitable or not to benefit from this treatment.
2. Laboratory Analysis
3. Choice of Treatment Modality
NOTE: For ECT in dogs use cisplatin and bleomycin. For ECT in cats use bleomycin only, as cisplatin is contraindicated in cats.
4. Choice of Operating Modality
5. Follow-up
NOTE: At each visit, tumor nodules are measured with a Vernier caliper and photographed. These visits also serve in order to evaluate the possible local and systemic side effects. Response to the treatment is scored after 4 weeks based on the criteria of "Response evaluation criteria in solid tumors" (RECIST)19 as a complete response (CR) — disappearance of the nodule, partial response (PR) — at least a 30% decrease in the sum of the diameters of the target lesion, taking as a reference the baseline sum diameters, progressive disease (PD) — at least a 20% increase in the sum of the diameters of the target lesions, taking as a reference the smallest sum being studied, stable disease (SD) — neither a sufficient shrinkage to qualify for PR, nor a sufficient increase to qualify for PD, taken as a reference the smallest sum diameters. For all response definitions a minimum 4-week duration is required for qualifying each type of response. Observation time is calculated as the interval between the date of the first treatment and the date of the last examination of the patient. Possible side effects are determined according to the Veterinary Cooperative Oncology Group toxicity scale (VCOG – CTCAE)20 at each follow-up examination.
The case presents a mast cell tumor located on the eyelid of a dog. The patient was treated with intratumorally-injected cisplatin and the application of 8 electric pulses using plate electrodes.
The size of the tumor was 5 mm. Due to the sensitive area of the tumor's location general anesthesia was used. According to the size of the tumor 0.5 ml (0.5 mg) of cisplatin was injected intratumorally. One min after the injection electric pulses were applied using an 8 mm plate electrode. Only one run of electric pulses was applied. After treatment the patient was supervised until it regained sufficient consciousness. The patient was released after two hours. After one week the patient came for a regular check-up. The tumor ulcerated and the area around the tumor was slightly swollen. The tumor was measured by Vernier caliper and photographed. One month after the treatment no further evidence of the tumor was noted. The wound was closed and cicatrix with alopecia was seen at the treatment site. After treatment the dog did not show any signs of pain, the function of the eyelid has been preserved during the entire healing period and the cosmetic effects after treatment are excellent.
Figure 1. Electrochemotherapy treatment. The figure showing the dog before treatment (A), one week (B), one month (C) and three months after treatment (D). (A) Mast cell tumor on the lower eyelid. The 2.5-year old German boxer dog with a tumor size of 5 mm prior to the therapy. (B) After the therapy the tumor started to ulcerate and the tissue surrounding the electroporated area became slightly swollen. Two weeks after the therapy a crust formed at the tumor site and fell off (not shown). (C) One month after electrochemotherapy no evidence of the tumor was noted and cicatrix with alopecia was seen at the tumor site. (D) Three months after electrochemotherapy total re-epithelization occurred at the site of the tumor. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Operating modality (OM) | ||
Number, volume and location of tumor nodules | A | B |
1 – 3 nodules < 1 cm³ skin and oral tumors | √ | |
> 3 nodules, any volume skin and oral tumors head | √ | |
any number, any volume of skin and oral tumors head | √ |
Table 1. Selection of Operating modality is based on the number of tumor nodules and their size. Deep sedation = OM A; General anesthesia = OM B.
Chemotherapeutic drug/size of tumor | Intratumoral application | Intravenous application |
Cisplatin dose (1 mg/ml) < 1 cm3 | 1 ml (1 mg)/cm3 of tumor | |
Cisplatin dose (1 mg/ml) > 1 cm3 | 0.5-1 ml (0.5-1 mg)/cm3 of tumor | |
Bleomycin dose (3,000 IU/ml) < 1 cm3 | 0.5 ml (1,500 IU)/cm3 of tumor | 300 IU/kg |
Bleomycin dose (3,000 IU/ml) > 1 cm3 | 0.5 – 1 ml (1,500-3,000 IU)/cm3 of tumor | 300 IU/kg |
Table 2. The appropriate injection volume of cytostatics according to the administration route and tumor size in dogs.
Chemotherapeutic drug/size of tumor | Intratumoral application | Intravenous application |
Bleomycin dose (3,000 IU/ml) < 1 cm3 | 0.5 ml (1,500 IU)/cm3 of tumor | 300 IU/kg |
Bleomycin dose (3,000 IU/ml) > 1 cm3 | 0.5 – 1 ml (1,500 – 3,000 IU)/cm3 of tumor | 300 IU/kg |
Table 3. The appropriate injection volume of cytostatics according to the tumor size in cats.
Electrochemotherapy has proved to be highly effective against different primary tumors or metastases in dogs and cats. Electrochemotherapy can be used with curative intent for solitary or multiple cutaneous or subcutaneous tumor nodules or as an adjuvant treatment to surgery. The standard treatment of choice for several tumors in dogs, including mast cell tumors, is surgical excision of the tumor. A study comparing surgery as a standard treatment to ECT in treating mast cell tumors in dogs showed that treatment with ECT resulted in 70% of complete responses while surgery resulted in 50% of complete responses11 demonstrating that ECT is an equivalent treatment to surgery.
For the pronounced antitumor effectiveness of ECT two conditions have to be fulfilled, which are critical steps within the protocol. The first one is the administration of cytostatics. The presence of the drug in the target tissues determines ECT efficiency as the drug needs to be present inside the cells in order to kill them. When injecting the drug intratumorally, the sign of good tissue retention is tissue whitening. Also, some leakage of solution after administration could occur through the holes produced by the needle in the tumor or in necrotizing tissues during further ECT sessions. Thus, reaching 1 mg/cm3 (cisplatin) or 3,000 UI/cm3 (bleomycin) concentrations could then be purely theoretical in those cases, however, the goal is to try to retain as much solution as possible in the target tissues. In addition, electric pulses should be applied as quickly as possible in order to obtain a vasoconstricting effect which contributes to solution retention.
Two different routes of administration can be used with ECT: intratumoral and intravenous. The antitumor effectiveness of ECT with intratumoral cisplatin or bleomycin or with intravenous bleomycin is comparable21 whereas electrochemotherapy with the intravenous application of cisplatin is less effective22 therefore cisplatin is only used in intratumoral administration. Another important feature of the cisplatin drug is that its use in cats is contraindicated as cisplatin has been shown to be highly toxic in cats23. If the patient has one or only a few nodules, then an intratumoral route is recommended. If the number of nodules exceeds ~5 nodules, then an intravenous route is recommended. Intratumoral injection of cisplatin has some antitumor effectiveness even without the application of electric pulses, while bleomycin, due to its high hydrophilic nature, does not. Therefore, cisplatin is the first drug of choice if intratumoral application is possible in dogs. This is important because of the second condition that must be fulfilled for the effective antitumor action of ECT and that is coverage of the whole tumor with a sufficiently high electric field. To obtain the increase in cell membrane permeabilization, the induced electric field within the tissue must exceed a certain threshold. The distribution of the electric field in the tissue depends on the electrodes, therefore it is important what kind of electrodes are used. Plate or parallel array electrodes can be safely used for small superficial tumors24. If the tumors are thicker and bigger, hexagonal electrodes are more suitable. An important fact is that the application of the electric pulses can be repeated, so that the whole tumor area is covered, including the safety margins. Since electric pulses cause vascular lock, their application should start from the edge of the tumor, towards its center.
Currently, the limitation of the technique is the availability of the electrodes which prevents the treatment of deep-seated tumors. However, the configuration of the electrodes is a technological feature that is fast developing and now different sets of electrodes are used for specific administrations long-needle single electrodes for metastases of colorectal tumors in the liver25, bone metastases7, soft tissue sarcoma26, endoluminal electrodes for colorectal, gastric and esophageal tumors27 and expandable ''umbrella'' type electrodes for brain tumors8.
ECT can be effective as a one-time treatment only, but in the case of failure or partial tumor response it can be repeated several times with improved effectiveness. ECT is a local ablative treatment. Its local effectiveness is up to 80% of local tumor control but without a noticeable effect on distant metastasis7, which is another limitation of the therapy. Therefore, to achieve a systemic response, ECT could be combined with other therapies. Recently, we proposed combining ECT with another biomedical application of electroporation, i.e., gene electrotransfer of the immunomodulatory molecule interleukin-12 (IL-12), which is known for its antitumor activity. Combination of ECT and gene electrotransfer with IL-12 has already been shown to be a safe combined therapy with no side effects and good local tumor with high complete response rate28, which also prevented recurrence of distant metastases.
In conclusion, the advantages of electrochemotherapy are its simplicity, short duration of treatment sessions, low cytostatic doses and insignificant side effects. In addition, it is performed on an outpatient basis, therefore, the patients do not have to stay in the hospital.
Nowadays, the availability of different generators of electric pulses on the market is increasing, leading also to the lowering of the price of the generators with no loss in reliability and thereby making electrochemotherapy even more affordable. These should all lead to the wider use of this therapy in veterinary medicine.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
The authors acknowledge the financial support received from the state budget by the Slovenian Research Agency (program no. P3-0003, project no. J3-6796). The research was conducted in the scope of the EBAM European Associated Laboratory (LEA). This manuscript is the result of the networking efforts of the COST Action TD1104. We wish to thank Alenka Seliskar, Mojca Juvan (Veterinary Faculty, Clinic for Surgery and Small Animals) and Jakob Konda (Institute of Oncology, Ljubljana, Ljubljana, Slovenia) for all of their valuable help.
Cisplatin Kobi | Fresenius Kobi Oncology, Hampshire, Great Britain | citostatic drug | |
Bleomycin PCH | Pharmachemie B.V., Haarlem, Dutch | citostatic drug | |
AquaUltra Basic | Ultragel, Budapest, Hungary | water based gel | |
Electropulsator ELECTROvetS13 | Leroy Betatech, Toulouse, France | square-wave pulse generator |