Here we detail protocols specifically designed to monitor morphogenic defects that occur during early and late phases of embryonic elongation of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. Ultimately, these protocols are designed to identify genes that regulate these phases and to characterize their differential requirements along the antero-posterior axis of the embryo.
Dissecting the signaling pathways that control the alteration of morphogenic processes during embryonic development requires robust and sensitive metrics. Embryonic elongation of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans is a late developmental stage consisting of the elongation of the embryo along its longitudinal axis. This developmental stage is controlled by intercellular communication between hypodermal cells and underlying body-wall muscles. These signaling mechanisms control the morphology of hypodermal cells by remodeling the cytoskeleton and the cell-cell junctions. Measurement of embryonic lethality and developmental arrest at larval stages as well as alteration of cytoskeleton and cell-cell adhesion structures in hypodermal and muscle cells are classical phenotypes that have been used for more than 25 years to dissect these signaling pathways. Recent studies required the development of novel metrics specifically targeting either early or late elongation and characterizing morphogenic defects along the antero-posterior axis of the embryo. Here, we provide detailed protocols enabling the accurate measurement of the length and the width of the elongating embryos as well as the length of synchronized larvae. These methods constitute useful tools to identify genes controlling elongation, to assess whether these genes control both early and late phases of this stage and are required evenly along the antero-posterior axis of the embryo.
For nearly 50 years the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans established itself as a powerful model to study important questions in development, neurobiology, evolution, host-pathogen interactions, etc.1 The strength of this model in the study of development lies in: its short life cycle of 3 days; the ease with which these animals can be genetically altered; its transparency that enables the observation of cell displacement and morphology in living animals and its development that is mostly extra-uterine. The developmental stages of the nematode involve embryogenesis and four larval stages (L1 to L4), followed by adulthood. During embryonic development, epidermal morphogenesis drew considerable attention for its ability to enable a better understanding of how epithelial cells migrate as a group, how they reorganize their junctions and modify their individual morphology as well as their relative positioning within a functional epithelium. Epidermal morphogenesis is divided into four stages: dorsal intercalation consisting in the reorganization of dorsal epidermal cells, referred to as the hypodermis; ventral enclosure, consisting in migration of ventral hypodermal cells towards the ventral midline thus encasing the embryo in an epithelial cell monolayer; early and late elongation transforming the bean-shaped embryo into vermiform larvae. Following morphogenesis, embryo hatch and L1 larvae start feeding using available bacteria in their immediate environment.
Embryonic elongation is therefore a late phase of the embryonic development. It consists of the extension of the embryo along its longitudinal axis and a reduction of its transverse diameter. This involves a dramatic modification of the shape of the hypodermal cells. Elongation is divided into an early and a late phase. The early phase starts at the comma stage and ends when body-wall muscles start contracting at 1.75-fold stage in wild-type (wt) embryos — corresponding to embryos that are 1.75-fold in length compared to non-elongated embryos. Morphogenic processes occurring at that stage are mainly driven by contraction of filamentous actin bundles (FBs) located at the apical pole of hypodermal cells that drive their elongation along the antero-posterior axis of the embryo2. Contraction of FBs is control by phosphorylation of myosin-light chains by three kinases LET-502/ROCK, MRCK-1 and PAK-1 5. The late phase of the elongation, starts when body-wall muscles become functional and start contracting. It involves mechanotransduction signaling from the body-wall muscles to the dorsal and ventral hypodermal cells and ends when animals hatch3.
Elongation defects are generally characterized by the percentage of animals dying as embryos (Embryonic lethality; Emb) and those arresting their development as L1 larvae (Larval arrest phenotype; Lva) and being significantly shorter than wt. Identification of the stage of developmental arrest requires microscopic observation of dead embryos and arrested Larvae3-6.
It was recently shown that several genes, such as the Cdc42/Rac regulator and effector pix-1 and pak-1, control morphogenic processes during both early and late elongation3,7. We also recently showed that morphogenic processes differ along the antero-posterior axis of the embryos during early elongation37. These findings motivated the development of novel metrics specifically targeting early or late elongation stages and other metrics enabling the characterization of the morphology of embryos along their antero-posterior axis during early elongation.
These novel methods consist in measuring the length of embryos at the beginning and at the end of early elongation as well as the width of their heads and tails.7 Two protocols were also developed to measure the length of newly hatched larvae, synchronized at L1 stage7.
The eggshells of the embryos protect them against alkaline hypochlorite treatment while larvae, adults and bacteria present in the culture media are dissolved by the treatment. This treatment is then used to purify embryos from a non-synchronized population containing a majority of well-fed adults8. Food restriction is used to synchronize newly hatched larvae. Measuring the length of these larvae is then used to detect elongation defects. This measurement is preferred over the measurement of arrested larvae on culture plates because larvae that hatch from non-fully elongated embryos can recover to "normal length" when feeding but will maintain their reduced size when arrested in the absence of food.
Here, we present detailed protocols enabling the measurement of the length of elongating embryos as well as the width of their head and tail using time-lapse DIC microscopy and image analysis (Protocol 1). We also provide detailed protocols to measure the length of synchronized larvae using image analysis (Protocol 2) and Flow-Cytometry (Protocol 3).
1. Characterization of Early Elongation Defects in WT and Mutant Animals
2. Characterization of Late Elongation Defects Using Image Analysis
3. Characterization of Late Elongation Defects Using Flow Cytometry
Head-, Tail- and Head/Tail-width Ratio are Robust Metrics.
The protocols described here have been successfully used to characterize the function of regulators and effectors of Rho GTPases pix-1, pak-1 and let-502 during early elongation7. pix-1 and pak-1 code respectively for a guanine-exchange factor (GEF) and an effector specific for Rac/Cdc42 GTPases and let-502 codes for an effector for RHO-1 7. In this study,pix-1 and pak-1 were shown to control epidermal morphogenesis during early elongation7. This study used head and tail width measurement as metrics demonstrate for the first time, that hypodermal cells located in the anterior embryo follow different morphogenic programs than those located in its posterior 7. To establish the reproducibility and robustness of these metrics, head width was measured independently five times on 12 wild-type (wt) embryos at 1.2-fold stage. Variances among the five different groups of measurement were compared then assessed using the Brown-Forsythe test (using R statistical package) revealing no significant differences amongst the measurements (F-test p-value > 0.5; Figure 4A) suggesting that measurements for a group of embryos are reproducible. Assessment of reproducibility and batch effects associated with these measurements was done through measurement of the head width of wt embryos at 1.2-fold stage from 4D-DIC imaging done on three different days (n = 12 embryos). Across these three measurement groups, the variance was not significantly different and no significant batch effects were found to impact the head-width measurement results (F-test p-value > 0.5; Figure 4B).
Similar results were obtained for tail width measurements and for measurements done at different stages of early elongation (data not shown). These data established head-width, tail-width and head/tail width ratio as robust metrics to characterize early elongation defects.
Measuring Head and Tail Width as well as Length of the Embryos Allows for the Characterization of Genes Controlling Early Elongation along the Antero-posterior Axis of the Embryo.
Measurement of the length of the embryos, as well as the width of their head and tail was done on wt and mutant embryos carrying null or thermosensitive strong loss-of function alleles for genes controlling early elongation: pix-1(gk416); pak-1(ok448) and let-502(sb118ts)7. We measured the head/tail (H/T) width ratio of wt and mutant embryos at the beginning (1.2-fold stage) and at the end of the early elongation at non-permissive temperatures (Figure 4C left and right panel respectively). While at the beginning of early elongation there was no change- or a reduced H/T ratio was observed in pix-1, pak-1 and let-502 mutants when compared to wt animals (1.2-fold stage, Figure 2C, left panel), at the end of early elongation all three mutants showed a significantly higher H/T ratio than wt embryos (t-test p-values < 0.006; Figure 4C; right panel). This demonstrated that pix-1, pak-1 and let-502 mutant embryos display abnormal antero-posterior morphology at the end of early elongation. Further analysis comparing head width and tail width between 1.2-fold stage and the end of early elongation, using the same measurement parameters revealed that the head width is less reduced in pix-1, pak-1 and let-502 mutants while the tail width reduces significantly less in let-502 mutants only 7. This revealed that let-502 controls morphogenic processes similarly along the antero-posterior axis of the embryo, while pix-1 and pak-1 control morphogenic processes occurring mainly at the anterior part of the embryo7. The length difference between the embryos at the end versus the beginning of early elongation (Figure 4D) was also measured. We found that early elongation was significantly reduced in pix-1, pak-1 and let-502 mutants when compared to wt suggesting that alteration of the anterior morphogenesis in pix-1 and pak-1 mutants alone is sufficient to significantly reduce the elongation of the embryo.
Protocol 2 and 3 were used to assess the length of arrested larvae in wt and mutant backgrounds. The length of these larvae was assessed using both image analysis (Protocol 2)7 and flow-cytometry (Protocol 3; unpublished data). Measurements of larvae length using image analysis results in absolute measurements of animals' length in micrometers in a robust and highly reproducible manner (Figure 5A). This analysis revealed that synchronized mutant larvae display significantly reduced length when compared to wt (Figure 5A)7. Measurement of these larvae using the flow-cytometry based protocol (Protocol 3) gave comparable results (Figure 5B). However, it should be noted that the large number of larvae measured using the latter approach significantly increased the statistical robustness of genotype comparison (t-test p-values <10-24). Based on these findings, the flow-cytometry approach may be a better choice over image analysis in order to characterize mutant animals displaying very subtle elongation defects.
Figure 1. Preparation of an Agarose Pad. A, Microscope slide placed between two spacer-slides covered by two layers of masking tape. B, The agarose pad is covered with another slide supported by the two spacer-slides. C, The final shape and size of the agarose pad after cutting with a razor blade to fit the coverslip. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2. Measurement of Early and Late Elongation Defects. A – B, Measurement of the length of an embryo at comma stage (A) and at the end of early elongation (B). The red line, used to measure the embryos was drawn using the segmented line tool of ImageJ. C, Head and tail width are measured in embryos at 1.2-fold stage (left) and at the end of early elongation (right). Arrows represent the localization of measured areas (modified from Martin et al., 2014). Scale bar: 20 μm. D, Length of Larvae is measured for synchronized L1-larvae. Right panel is an enlarged view of the captured image (left). The red line was drawn using the segmented line tool of ImageJ. It is used to measure the length of the larva. Scale bar: 100 μm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3. Measurement of the Length of Synchronized Larvae Using Flow-cytometry. A, Gating and sorting window of COPAS Biosort showing Green and Red emission of control particles, bubbles, dead and living animals with respect to their Time-Of-Flight (TOF). B, TOF of control particles at different time points for a representative experiment. The slope of the linear function of TOF versus time is around 10-5, indicating that TOF of control particles is constant over time throughout the experiment. C, Distribution of control particle TOFs expressed as a percentage of maximal value of distributions. Non-normalized and normalized control particle distributions are represented for pak-1(ok448). Other distributions are not normalized. D, distribution of TOFs for living animals expressed as a percentage of the maximal value of the distributions. TOFs are not normalized on control particles except for pak-1(ok448) as indicated. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4. Pix-1, Pak-1 and Let-502 Mutants Present Early Elongation Defects. A – B, Reproducibility and robustness assessment of head width measurements. A, Five independent measurements of the head width for wt embryos at 1.2-fold stage (n = 12 embryos). Means and standard deviations (error bars) are indicated. Non significant (ns) differences between measurements were computed using the Brown-Forsythe test (using R statistical package) (F-test p-value > 0.5). B, Head width measurement for wt embryos at three different days (n = 12 embryos). Means and standard deviations are indicated as well; there was no significant difference in variance across the measurements (ns; Brown-Forsythe F-test p-value > 0.5). C, Distributions of head/tail width ratio at 1.2-fold stage (left panel), at the end of early elongation (right panel) in wt, pix-1(gk416), pak-1(ok448) and let-502(sb118ts) mutants at 23 – 24 °C. Note that mothers of let-502ts embryos used for this study were grown at 25.5 °C. D, Distribution of the elongation in wt, pix-1(gk416), pak-1(ok448) and let-502(sb118ts) mutants between comma stage and the start of late elongation. The box-plots represent the min, max, 25th, 50th (median) and 75th percentiles of the populations. * t-test p-value < 0.05, ** t-test p-value < 0.006 (modified from Martin et al., 2014). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5. Pix-1(gk416), Pak-1(ok448) and Let-502(sb118ts) Larvae Present Length Defects. A, Length of larvae measured in wt, pix-1(gk416), pak-1(ok448) and let-502(sb118ts) animals measured using image analysis (Protocol 2). B, Relative larvae length measured using flow-cytometer (Protocol 3). Numbers in brackets correspond to the number of animals used for the measurements. Means of lengths and standard error of the mean (SEM; error bars) are represented. Student's t-test p-values are indicated (p). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
This protocol describes novel metrics to characterize early and late phases of embryonic elongation.
In section 1, the critical step is the potential presence of bacteria on the pad. The embryos are hermetically enclosed between the pad and the coverslip during image acquisition. Sealing the slide is required to avoid desiccation of the animals during acquisition that lasts more than two hours. To our knowledge, none of the sealers used to mount agarose pads between slide and coverslip are air-permeable. Consequently, when a large amount of bacteria (or embryos) is present on the pad, they may be deprived of oxygen after a few hours leading to their premature death. Having three-fold embryos — corresponding to embryos that are 3-fold in length compared to non-elongated embryos — recorded along with the embryos of interest will be a good indicator of potential hypoxic conditions, since those embryos will stop moving in their eggshells in the absence of oxygen. No morphological measurements should be done on hypoxic conditions or on dead embryos.
Another critical step when using time-lapse imaging is temperature at which development of the embryo occurs. Thermosensitive mutants are currently used in C. elegans. The biological effect of temperature shift may be immediate or delayed depending on the half-life of the protein and the nature of the mutation its carries. Consequently, the temperature at which the embryo is exposed should be constant over time and should be controlled by appropriate ventilation of the microscopy room or a heating-cooling chamber on the microscope stage.
Section 2 is dependent on larvae synchronization using alkaline hypochlorite treatment. Under certain circumstances, this treatment may lead to embryonic lethality (Emb). Emb above 20% in wt population suggests an elevated toxicity during hypochlorite treatment that may negatively impact morphogenesis. Synchronized L1 displaying high Emb in wt background should not be used for further analysis. This restriction also applies to protocol 3.
We do not recommend the use of anesthetic drugs to immobilize larvae. Levamisol in particular, immobilizes the nematode through induction of muscle tetany that tends to shrink the larvae introducing experimental bias. If exposure time is not quick enough as a result of the limitations of the microscope, we recommend reducing the motility of larvae by increasing the concentration of the agarose in the pad and reducing the amount of liquid between the pad and the coverslip. Care should be taken however, not to desiccate the larvae, since desiccation will reduce their size.
In section 3, measurement of the length of larvae used comparison of flow rates between analyzed samples. To do so, the distribution of control particles needs to be compared. If the distributions fully overlay, the TOF (time-of-flight) values obtained for corresponding samples can be compared, if not, these values need to be normalized. Normalization of sample-TOF over control particles-TOF (as detailed in 3.4.5.1) has been used successfully as shown for pak-1(ok448) (Figure 3C and Figure 5B). Relative length of pak-1(ok448) vs wt was found to be similar in at least 3 independent experiments with or without normalization (data not shown). However, we recommend, confirming the results obtained with normalization with those obtained without it, especially when comparing larvae with small size differences. It should be noted that measurement of the larvae length using flow-cytometry provides a length relative to a control sample, in this case, wt larvae rather than an absolute length in micrometer as for image analysis. This implies that measurements from independent experiments cannot be combined unless computing size ratio over wt.
The buffer used for dilution in the sample cup will have an impact on the flow rate. We observed that the sheath buffer recommended by the manufacturer contains detergent that increases the amount of bubbles generated during acquisition. Using M9 buffer, which does not contain detergent, significantly reduced the formation of bubbles but was less efficient in avoiding the plugging of eggs in the tubules of the sorter, which affects the flow rate of samples. Egg plugging is easily detected during the acquisition by a marked decrease of the observable TOF of control particles for a few seconds followed by an elevated TOF- also for a few seconds. Egg plugging may also lead to the obstruction of the channel and the complete arrest of the particle flow (less that 5 objects per second). If this should occur, click on the CLEAN button until flow rate is restored. Any measurements occurring during these events should be excluded from the data analysis. Sheath buffer may be recommended for experiments involving strains characterized by high rates of dead eggs.
The sample and sheath pressure (set at the step 3.2.3), may change (slightly) over time and should be adjusted manually throughout the experiment in order to ensure a very constant flow rate. Reduction or increase of the low rate will be observable when analyzing the results and plotting the TOFs of control particles over time (Figure 3C). Reduction of the flow rate will result in the increase of the average TOFs of particles over time, while an increase of the flow rate will result in the opposite. Alteration of the flow rate will negatively impact the sensitivity of the method in detecting small size differences between populations of larvae.
Methods aiming to identify genes controlling elongation and requiring time-lapse microscopy recording are generally highly time-consuming and tedious when phenotyping several genotypes. The flow-cytometer-based approach, while requiring equipment not available to all laboratories, is less time-consuming and consequently more efficient when several strains need to be characterized. This method is also more statistically robust compared to measurements using image analysis (assessed by the student's t-test comparing mutant and wt TOF distributions; Figure 5A and B). This method may then be highly suitable for strains expressing elongation defects with low expressivity/penetrance.
Several methods using flow-cytometry have been developed in the past to measure fitness of nematodes9-12. These methods use animals dispensed in a 96-well plates and the Reflex module of the worm sorter'. The Reflex module enables direct analysis of nematode population dispensed within 96-well plates. Consequently, these methods are able to characterize hundreds of conditions per day and constitute a robust manner in which to measure the fitness of a non-synchronized population. They are however, not well suited to identify small size differences between synchronized L1. Measurement of small differences between L1 larvae requires the measurement across a large number of animals, which is incompatible with the use of 96-well plates and of the Reflex module that may efficiently characterize 100 objects at the most per well. The method described here is designed for this purpose at the expense of the throughput, which is significantly reduced. It enables the characterization of 3 to 4 conditions per hour once the instrument is calibrated, which is a marked improvement over using image analysis in protocol 2.
Measurement of head and tail width ratio is the first method that was developed to characterize morphogenic processes occurring unevenly along the antero-posterior axis of the embryo7. When applied to genes shown to control early elongation, these methods will clarify the spatial distribution of signaling pathways controlling morphogenesis at that stage. Measurement of the length of arrested larvae using either image analysis or flow cytometry in combination with measurement of the length of the embryos at the end of early elongation will enable the identification of genes controlling either early or late elongation or both with high sensitivity and precision. These procedures may then contribute significantly to future understanding of the spatial and temporal regulation of signaling pathways controlling embryonic elongation in C. elegans. Furthermore, these approaches can also be adapted to study signaling pathways controlling body length such as the insulin and TGF-beta pathways 13,14 and chronic exposure to environmental contaminants 15,16. These measurements can be done at different larval stages or in adults using minor variations of Protocols 2 and 3. Measuring size differences in L1 is more challenging with the worm sorter than larger objects such as L3, L4 larvae or adults. Protocol 3 can then easily be adapted to do these measurements.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported by grants from the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council (NSERC) of Canada and The Canada Foundation for Innovation. Thanks to Dr Paul Mains (University of Calgary, Calgary, Canada) for let-502(sb118ts) strain. Some of the strains were provided by the Caenorhabditis Genetics Center, which is funded by NIH Office of Research Infrastructure Programs (P40 OD010440).
Agar | BioShop | AGR001.500 | |
Agarose | Bioshop | AGA001.500 | |
CaCl2 (calcium chloride) | Bio Basic Inc. | CT1330 | |
Cholesterol | Sigma-aldrich | C8667 | |
cleaning solution | union Biometrica | 300-5072-000 | |
glass coverslips | Fisherbrand | 12-542B | |
glass slides | Fisherbrand | 12-552-3 | |
high fluorescent control particles | union Biometrica | 310-5071-001 | |
K2HPO4 (potassium phosphate, dibasic) | Bio Basic Inc. | PB0447 | |
KH2PO4 (potassium phosphate, monobasic) | Bio Basic Inc. | PB0445 | |
MgSO4 (magnesium sulfate) | Sigma-aldrich | 230391 | |
Na2HPO4( sodium phosphate, dibasic) | Bio Basic Inc. | SDB0487 | |
NaCl (sodium chloride) | Bio Basic Inc. | DB0483 | |
Pebeo Drawing Gum 45ml | pébéo | PDG033000 | any art/craft store |
Peptone | BioShop | PEP403.500 | |
Sheath buffer | union Biometrica | 300-5070-100 | |
COPAS Biosort | union Biometrica |