Electronic von Frey measurements are an effective and improved alternative to classical von Frey filaments, as they allow rapid and precise measurement of changes in rodent mechanical withdrawal thresholds to continuously applied pressure stimuli before and after an inflammatory event.
Measuring inflammation-induced changes in thresholds of hind paw withdrawal from mechanical pressure is a useful technique to assess changes in pain perception in rodents. Withdrawal thresholds can be measured first at baseline and then following drug, venom, injury, allergen, or otherwise evoked inflammation by applying an accurate force on very specific areas of the skin. An electronic von Frey apparatus allows precise assessment of mouse hind paw withdrawal thresholds that are not limited by the available filament sizes in contrast to classical von Frey measurements. The ease and rapidity of measurements allow for incorporation of assessment of tactile sensitivity outcomes in diverse models of rapid-onset inflammatory and neuropathic pain as multiple measurements can be taken within a short time period. Experimental measurements for individual rodent subjects can be internally controlled against individual baseline responses and exclusion criteria easily established to standardize baseline responses within and across experimental groups. Thus, measurements using an electronic von Frey apparatus represent a useful modification of the well-established classical von Frey filament-based assays for rodent mechanical allodynia that may also be applied to other nonhuman mammalian models.
Chronic noncommunicable diseases are responsible for a disproportionate share of the human burdens of mortality and morbidity1. Chronic pain is increasingly recognized as an important component of the global burden of disease2. This has provided great impetus to innovations in the prevention, management, and treatment of pain. At the same time, there is abundant evidence that the underlying biology of pain is complex3. The mechanisms underlying protective as well as maladaptive and chronic pain point to intricate interplay between the immune and nervous systems3,4. The elucidation of these mechanisms demands rigorous quantitative, reproducible experimental approaches from molecular dissection to behavioral analysis.
Rodent models have been invaluable in the characterization of molecular players of inflammatory and neuropathic pain5. Reduction in time and intensity of previously specified responses to noxious stimuli are used to measure pain states in these animals as rodent subjects are not otherwise able to report a sensation of pain6. Altered responses to temperature and pressure are commonly used as metrics of tissue sensitivity in rodent models of inflammatory nociception that can be caused by infection7,8, chemical exposure6, 9,10, surgical incision11, as well as neuropathic pain caused by nerve ligation12.
Mechanical sensitivity, or response to pressure stimuli, is often measured using classical von Frey filaments (CvF) – a series (e.g. 0.4-15 g13) of weighted tips manually applied to test tissue in serial increments until pain behaviors are induced in controls vs. experimental subjects. There are various methods for using these tips or hairs to assess mechanical sensitivity6,13; the most frequently used method is as follows. A tip with a certain pressure (within the series; e.g. 2 g13) is selected as a starting point and a rat or mouse's 50% withdrawal threshold (the stimulus intensity required to produce a response 50% of the times the tip is applied to the tissue) is determined by moving up and down in tip weight based on the display of previously specified response behaviors13. Absolute 50% withdrawal thresholds for treatment groups are then compared between baseline and post-treatment time points. This manual technique is quite time-consuming. In addition to increased time spent by each subject confined in a von Frey chamber, this also increases the number of times that test tips of various weights are applied to inflamed tissue causing greater discomfort to the rodents in the study. Furthermore, 50% withdrawal thresholds are calculated and compared between groups of rodents; the individual responses of experimental subjects are typically not normalized to their individual untreated baseline responses with, to our knowledge, one exception6. As a consequence, rodent subjects are not usually reported as assigned to treatment groups on the basis of consistent baseline responses within a previously determined range and neither are individual subjects evaluated on the basis of a consistently applied set of exclusion criteria that allow for baseline responses to be standardized for any particular set of studies and assays.
Here, we present an alternative method for measuring mouse hind paw tactile sensitivity following exposure to Bothrops jararaca venom using an electronic von Frey apparatus (EvF). Cunha and colleagues6 have pioneered the use of EvF techniques in rodents and systematically compared CvF and EvF efficacy to demonstrate that EvF provides "a more sensitive, objective and quantitative" measure of tactile sensitivity in rodent models of inflammatory pain. Briefly, in EvF measurements, a nonhygroscopic polypropylene von Frey tip of uniform diameter (0.8 mm) of suitable rigidity for the tissue being tested is attached to an electronic probe and readout that displays the force/weight at which the rodent retracts from the tip. There are several important differences between CvF and EvF measurements. First, the process of measuring both baseline and experimental responses using EvF is greatly streamlined as pressure on the hind paw can be applied with increasing force until there is a response and there is no need to change tips as in CvF; animals spend less time confined in the assay chambers and are therefore less stressed and more comfortable during an experiment. Second, EvF allows for relative ease of implementation of rational exclusion criteria for study subjects in the form of ranges of acceptable baseline thresholds. This allows for standardization of baseline responses within and across treatment groups. Third, a subject's response following an experimental treatment is always compared to its own individual baseline response creating important internal controls for measurements. Fourth, the accuracy of the withdrawal thresholds is recorded at a higher level of resolution as pressure can be applied continuously rather than in increments available in the form of weights of manual filaments. As with well-designed CvF assays, EvF-based experiments are also carried out with the same investigator (blind to treatment) applying the force and recording the response behaviors. It is important to note that this technique requires time and effort on the part of investigators to establish internal consistency of measurements and requires experiments to be planned such that appropriate allowances are made for mice that may have to be excluded due to inconsistent baseline responses.
An easy to implement, effective, well-controlled assessment of mechanical sensitivity facilitates the addition of behavioral assessment to models of inflammatory events such as envenomation – the example we have used here to illustrate the capacities and power of EvF measurements in the measurement of changes in tactile sensitivity. We found that male ND4 Swiss mice showed an enhanced mechanical sensitivity following injection of venom derived from the South American pit viper Bothrops jararaca in the hind paw. Behavioral responses were accompanied by edema, influx of neutrophils, and mast cell degranulation in the affected tissue.
The measurement of changes in withdrawal responses is an important tool used to assess changes in tactile sensitivity in rodent models of pain and inflammation. Here we demonstrate the utility of an electronic von Frey apparatus to perform this assessment. There are several advantages to this technique: i) we can rapidly assess withdrawal responses to applied pressure for multiple mice at multiple time points that are fairly close together, ii) we can use a single tip to apply continuous and specific pressure to a small area of tissue, iii) we can accurately measure the precise pressure applied to obtain a withdrawal response, and iv) we can easily implement robust baseline cutoffs, exclusion criteria, and internal controls to ensure that behavioral assessments are as precise and objective as possible.
The critical steps to ensure best outcomes for an EvF assay are prior calibration of the instrument and consistent measurement practices. As detailed in the protocol section, the instrument needs to be handled with care and proper calibration ensured before and during use. Before any measurements are taken, the test weight readings must be confirmed to ensure optimal machine function. If the readings fluctuate significantly or if the test weight readings are not accurate, the manufacturer should be promptly contacted to calibrate the apparatus. With this in mind, having a backup electronic von Frey apparatus is advisable, if possible, so as not to compromise time-sensitive experiments due to an unexpected need for calibration of the instrument. Further, a single, well-trained investigator should take all baseline and experimental measurements for a given study or series of experiments while remaining blinded to treatment groups. Mice should be evaluated in a quiet room, held at a constant temperature, acclimated to the EvF chambers for at least 15 min but not restrained in the chamber any longer than necessary (especially if multiple measurements are taken within a single day) so as to minimize stress and discomfort-induced behavioral variations.
EvF measurements offer significant improvements with respect to the existing CvF techniques. Researchers can apply continuous pressure and do not have to switch between tips of various weights as is done in CvF filament experiments6. This leads to fewer pokes on the tissue, which is especially relevant in the case of inflamed or injured tissue. Precise pressure at which withdrawal occurs can be measured vs. using 50% withdrawal measurements that are also limited by available filament weights used in CvF measurements13. Because rational and uniform exclusion criteria can be implemented (as discussed above), mice can be assigned to experimental groups such that all groups have similar average baselines at the beginning of the experiment. EvF measurements assess the changes in behavioral response to a given stimulus, and not the absolute responses themselves. Therefore each mouse's change in nociceptive response is measured as the difference between its individual experimental and baseline withdrawals thus providing internal controls for every measurement taken.
Perhaps the most significant limitation of EvF is that, similar to its manual counterpart, the same researcher must take all measurements for a particular series of baseline and experimental measurements. This makes scaling up of the technique challenging from the standpoints of time, personnel and equipment. We find that ~20 mice at a time (depending on the configuration of assay chambers) can be measured in 30-45 min or less at multiple timepoints provided there are at least 45 min between measurements. A related consideration in this regard is the learning curve of individual experimenters. Internal consistency has to be established before an individual researcher can embark on a full-scale experiment and this requires many hours of dedicated practice involving repeated baseline response measurements until the desired consistency is reached. In addition, using baseline cutoffs implies that not all mice baselined for an experiment can be included; we find that 25-30% of mice baselined per experiment are typically excluded.
In terms of modifications and future applications, EvF behavioral measurements add a powerful dimension to a wide range of models of inflammation to analyze concomitant acute and/or chronic pain that can underlie inflammatory pathologies. In envenomation, we found that pronounced, rapid-onset changes in tactile sensitivity accompanied the expected outcomes of tissue swelling, leukocyte recruitment and mast cell degranulation in the hind paws of ND4 male mice. These findings corroborate previous observations about the contributions of mast cell mediators to thermal sensitivity in rats20 and mechanical sensitivity induced by B. jararaca venom in ND4 Swiss mice measured using CvF21. The EvF protocol can easily be modified for use on tissues other than the hind paw e.g. abdomen7 and ano-genital ridge8 where CvF is currently used. Rodent models of allergies, wound healing, neuropathies and other pathologies can be easily adapted to include measures of mechanical sensitivity in tissues including and beyond the hind paw.
In summary, EvF is a useful and effective technique that updates a classical approach of measurement of nociception in rodents and is an important new tool in probing the complex underlying mechanisms of pain in a wide array of disease models.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
NIH R15 NS067536-01A1 (to DC) and the Macalester College Wallace Research Fund (to DC) supported these studies. Macalester College Library supported the open access publication of this article. In addition, we thank current and former Chatterjea lab members for their support.
Name of Material/ Equipment | Company | Catalog Number | Comments/Description |
ND4 Swiss male mice | Harlan | 0-32 | Mice used here were 8-12 weeks old and were housed and used according to Macaleter College's IACUC guidelines. |
3 ml/100 Insulin syringe with 29 G 1/2 in needle | BD | BD309301 | Dispose after each use into the appropriate container. |
B. jararaca venom | Sigma | V5625 | CAUTION: Toxic substance. Wear eye and skin protection. Dissolve in sterile 0.9% saline. |
Electronic von Frey apparatus; probe = 90 g range | IITC | 2394 | Move gently and ensure it is always horizontal. For zeroing the probe, press "Program" and "Clear". For switching from setup to operation mode, press "Function"(for "MH" readout) or "MAX". |
Mesh stand + PMMA chambers | IITC | 410 | Place on a steady bench top or a cart with four wheels in order to access all sides. |
Electronic von Frey rigid tips only, 90 g range | IITC | 2390 | n/a |