This protocol can be used to perform large-scale ecological surveys of selfing Caenorhabditis nematodes. The primary advantage of this method is the efficient organization and analysis of ecological and molecular data associated with the nematodes collected from nature.
Caenorhabditis elegans is one of the major model organisms in biology, but only recently have researchers focused on its natural ecology. The relative sparsity of information about C. elegans in its natural context comes from the challenges involved in the identification of the small nematode in nature. Despite these challenges, an increasing focus on the ecology of C. elegans has caused a wealth of new information regarding its life outside of the laboratory. The intensified search for C. elegans in nature has contributed to the discovery of many new Caenorhabditis species and revealed that congeneric nematodes frequently cohabitate in the wild, where they feed on microbial blooms associated with rotting plant material. The identification of new species has also revealed that the androdioecious mating system of males and self-fertilizing hermaphrodites has evolved three times independently within Caenorhabditis. The other two selfing species, C. briggsae and C. tropicalis, share the experimental advantages of C. elegans and have enabled comparative studies into the mechanistic basis of important traits, including self-fertilization. Despite these advances, much remains to be learned about the ecology and natural diversity of these important species. For example, we still lack functional information for many of their genes, which might only be attained through an understanding of their natural ecology. To facilitate ecological research of selfing Caenorhabditis nematodes, we developed a highly scalable method to collect nematodes from the wild. Our method makes use of mobile data collection platforms, cloud-based databases, and the R software environment to enhance researchers' ability to collect nematodes from the wild, record associated ecological data, and identify wild nematodes using molecular barcodes.
The last two decades have brought an increased interest in the ecology of Caenorhabditis nematodes. From these studies, we know that the free-living Caenorhabditis species can be isolated from ephemeral micro-habitats in both temperate and tropical regions, where they feed on microbial blooms associated with decomposing plant material, sometimes in sympatry1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8. We have also learned that convergent evolution of self-fertilization has occurred in the genus three times, and selfing is the dominant mode of reproduction for C. briggsae, C. elegans, and C. tropicalis9,10. Among these selfers, C. elegans is one of the most widely studied animals on Earth and has been used by researchers to make critical advances in biology. Importantly, the other selfing Caenorhabditis species share many of C. elegans experimental advantages and are rapidly advancing comparative studies in the genus. However, the cryptic nature of these nematodes in the wild makes it difficult to study their ecology and natural diversity, which is critical for understanding the biological functions of their genes and the ways in which evolution has shaped genetic diversity among the species10,11.
The greatest challenge to studying the ecology of selfing Caenorhabditis nematodes in the wild is their small size; adult nematodes are often 1 mm in length or less. This challenge requires that researchers sample substrates from the wild and attempt to separate nematodes of interest from the substrates in the laboratory without the ability to observe animals in the wild. Because even trained experts find it difficult to discriminate selfing Caenorhabditis nematodes from other free-living nematodes under the microscope, nematodes are typically removed from the substrate, isolated, and left to proliferate before they are identified by sequence identity using established molecular barcodes3,12,13,14. The time and effort required to process each nematode in this way present an organizational challenge, as researchers must be able to trace the identity of each nematode isolated in the laboratory back to the exact substrate and associated ecological data sampled in the field. Here, we describe a step-by-step process to efficiently collect and identify selfing Caenorhabditis nematodes from the field and faithfully link these isolates with their associated spatial and ecological data at a high scale.
This collection method increases the scale and accuracy of ecological surveys by using mobile data collection platforms, cloud-based databases, and the R software environment. Fulcrum is a customizable data-collection platform that works with most mobile devices and allows users to build custom applications to gather and organize location-based data (https://www.fulcrumapp.com). This protocol provides detailed instructions on how to use customized data-collection applications to organize spatially explicit ecological data from the field and accurately link those data with the identity of nematodes isolated in the laboratory. The protocol also explains how to efficiently identify selfing Caenorhabditis nematodes using established molecular barcodes. The data from these methods can be processed simply and reproducibly with the accompanying R software package easyFulcrum15 to explore the ecology and genetic diversity of natural Caenorhabditis populations.
1. Collection preparation
2. Field collection
NOTE: Caenorhabditis nematodes are most often isolated from rotting vegetable material, including fruits, nuts, seeds, pods, flowers, stems, vegetal litter, and compost1,5,6,8. The best substrates are rotten and almost unrecognizable as fruits or flowers; avoid substrates that are too dry or wet (Figure 1). Substrates are most efficiently collected from the field by working in pairs. The individual with the non-contact infrared thermometer will select a substrate for collection and collect the sample while their partner uses the Nematode Field Sampling application in Fulcrum to record the collection data. The pair of collectors will repeat this process until the desired number of samples is collected. The list of materials required for fieldwork is found in (Supplemental Table 1).
3. Plating out field collections in the laboratory
NOTE: This section details how to organize the transfer of samples from labeled collection bags to labeled plates. The samples may arrive from an overnight shipment or directly from the field.
4. Isolating nematodes from collections
5. Exporting S-plates from Fulcrum
NOTE: This section details how to export S-labels used in the isolation process from the Fulcrum project database. These S-labels will be used to track proliferating isofemale lines while they are being identified by sequence identity in sections 6-9.
6. Check for proliferation on S-plates
7. Lysis of isofemale lines
NOTE: This step will use the data filter tool in google sheets to help print lysis worksheets for the S-plates in the proliferation boxes. The purpose of the lysis worksheets is to provide personnel with the correct positions for S-labels in lysis strip tubes at the bench.
8. PCR of SSU and ITS2 sequences
NOTE: This section will provide instructions on how to perform two separate PCRs for each lysed S-plate. The first primer set amplifies a 500-bp fragment of the 18S rDNA small subunit gene (SSU); oECA1271 = forward primer TACAATGGAAGGCAGCAGGC, oECA1272 = reverse primer CCTCTGACTTTCGTTCTTGATTAA 12. This PCR is used to check the quality of the template DNA. The PCR amplifies the SSU region for nearly all nematode species. If the SSU PCR fails to amplify, this result suggests that the lysis quality is poor and the lysis must be repeated for this S-plate. The second primer set amplifies a 2,000-bp fragment of the internal transcribed spacer region between the 5.8S and 28S rDNA genes (ITS2); oECA1687 = forward primer CTGCGTTACTTACCACGAATTGCARAC, oECA202 = reverse primer GCGGTATTTGCTACTACCAYYAMGATCTGC3. The ITS2 PCR product is Sanger sequenced and the sequence is used to identify nematodes in the Caenorhabditis genus to the species level by sequence similarity.
9. Identifying nematodes with Sanger sequencing and sequence BLAST
NOTE: This section provides instructions for sequencing the ITS2 amplicons from the S-labels, aligning those sequences to the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) database using the BLAST algorithm, and parsing the BLAST results to identify the nematodes on the S-plates.
10. Processing the collection data with the easyFulcrum package in R
NOTE: This step describes how to link the collection data (C-labels) and the nematode isolation data (S-labels) together using the easyFulcrum R package. The software contains functions that will further join the Fulcrum data with the genotyping data from the genotyping sheet so that S-label species identities and strain names are organized in a single data frame.
This protocol has been used to collect Caenorhabditis nematodes from multiple locations, including Hawaii and California. The isolation success rate for Caenorhabditis nematodes varies with collection location, climate, sampling experience, and substrate types sampled. The protocol has been used to extensively sample the Hawaiian Islands, where nine collection projects have been conducted over multiple years and seasons. The isolation success rates for selfing Caenorhabditis species are nearly identical for C. briggsae (162 of 4,506 samples, 3.6%) and C. elegans (163 of 4,506 samples, 3.6%), and much lower for C. tropicalis (26 of 4,506 samples, 0.58%)8. Each of the selfing species is enriched on rotting fruit and flower substrates relative to the other substrate categories. Sample rotting fruit and flower substrates if the researcher is attempting to maximize the success rate rather than characterize substrate preferences. However, the success rate varies with the quality of the substrate selected. For example, among fruit and flower substrates, those substrates that are too dry, wet, or fresh will likely not yield Caenorhabditis nematodes.
The scalability of this collection protocol is evident from the number of collections a single pair of researchers can collect from the wild. For example, in October of 2018, a pair of researchers using this collection protocol was able to collect a total of over 1,000 samples in 7 days from multiple locations on two Hawaiian Islands. This field team shipped the samples overnight to the laboratory, where a team of eight researchers isolated over 2,000 nematodes from the samples as they arrived. A key advantage of this protocol is that it minimizes the cost associated with sampling in remote locations by reducing the equipment and personnel required in the field. Using this protocol, a small field team can focus on sampling while the isolation team can process the samples at their home institution using fragile and heavy equipment like dissecting microscopes and agar plates for isolating nematodes. Moreover, the implementation of the mobile data-collection application allows all the field data associated with the samples to be linked directly to the C-label, which enables the isolation team to work independently from the field team while processing samples.
Researchers that use this collection protocol must consider the effort that is required to isolate nematodes prior to a collection project. The isolation and identification steps are rate-limiting, and a small collection team can quickly overwhelm isolators with samples. Moreover, the laboratory space required to process many collections can interfere with ongoing research (Figure 3). Additionally, some isolated nematodes require additional effort to genotype. For example, approximately 2% of isolates fail to amplify with the SSU PCR primer set after the first lysis attempt and must be re-lysed to ensure that the lysis material is suitable for amplification with the ITS2 primer set (Figure 8). Furthermore, approximately 3% of isolates fail to produce quality sequences after an initial round of Sanger sequencing. For these isolates, another round of lysis, ITS2 PCR, and Sanger sequencing is often required, which can increase handing time for the isolation team. Importantly, sequence identity alone is not sufficient evidence to justify a new Caenorhabditis species (Figure 7). To properly justify raising an isolate as a new Caenorhabditis species, additional effort must be made to perform mating experiments and establish a typed specimen13. A formal morphological description of the typed specimen is also preferred but not required3. Together, these considerations suggest that researchers adopting this collection protocol will benefit from trial tests of the isolation and identification steps to ensure resources are properly allocated before a collection project begins. Importantly, even small collection projects can benefit from this protocol because the process is highly reproducible, and the data can easily be audited for quality control purposes across laboratory groups.
Figure 1: Substrate examples. (A) An ideal rotting fruit is shown in the center of the image (1), the fruit is almost unrecognizable. Less rotted fruit is shown nearby; avoid sampling freshly fallen fruits (2). (B) An ideally decomposed flower is shown at the top (3). Avoid sampling freshly fallen flowers (4). (C) The dark leaf litter under the top layer of dry leaves is ideal when sampling for selfing Caenorhabditis nematodes (5). Avoid sampling dry leaf litter (6). Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: The Nematode Field Sampling mobile application. (A) The initial screen after opening the Nematode Field Sampling application on an Apple device in Fulcrum. The red arrow in the lower right points to the + button used to create a new collection record. (B) An example of a new collection record shown on an Apple device. The red arrow points to the 'Project' field at the top of the collection record screen. Be sure to select the correct project when sampling in the field. The project field will default to the last project used when creating subsequent collection records. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Collection bags and collection plates organized prior to plating out samples. This figure shows the samples in C-labeled collection bags on the left. Each collection bag has a matching C-labeled 10 cm plate on top of it. On the right are 10 cm collection plates that contain sample material after it was transferred from the collection bags. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: A collection plate (C-plate) with properly a transferred sample. A 10 cm C-plate with decomposing fruit placed on the edge of the bacterial lawn. The C-label is attached to the plate lid. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 5: The Nematode isolation mobile application. (A) The application selection screen in the Fulcrum mobile application. The red arrow points to the Nematode Isolation application. (B) The initial screen after opening the Nematode Isolation application on an Apple device in Fulcrum. The red arrow in the lower right points to the + button used to create a new isolation record. (C) An example of a new isolation record shown on an Apple device. The red arrow points to the 'Project' field at the top of the isolation record screen. Be sure to select the correct project when isolating. The project field will default to the last project used when creating subsequent isolation records. (D) After tapping the Select field under C-label, users will tap the search button (red arrow) to find the C-label from which they are isolating nematodes. (E) After the C-label is selected, users will photograph the C-plate using the device camera. (F) Users then input whether there are nematodes on the C-plate or not. S-labels are added to the isolation record if there are nematodes to be isolated. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 6: NCBI BLAST results page. (1) The drop-down menu used to view the BLAST results for all sequences. (2) The description of the current sequence selected from the drop-down. In this case the results for S-label S-05554 are shown. (3) The top BLAST hit for S-05554 is shown. The purple text indicates the link to visualize this alignment has been clicked. Please be sure to inspect the alignments by eye to identify possible new Caenorhabditis species, see step 9.8 above. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 7: NCBI BLAST alignment visualization examples. (A) An example of an isolate's ITS2 query sequence aligned to a C. kamaaina subject sequence. (1) The percent identity of the alignment (89%), which is low for a top BLAST hit. (2) A mismatch between the query and subject sequence (G to A). (3) A four base pair gap in the subject sequence made by the alignment algorithm; gaps in the query or subject indicate poor alignment. (4) A generalized region in the center of the alignment with many mismatches and gaps. A region like this one suggests that the query sequence might come from a new Caenorhabditis species. Shown is an actual alignment example of a new species, C. oiwi, that was discovered in 2017. (B) An example of a good alignment between an isolate's ITS2 query sequence and a subject sequence. (5) The percent identity of the alignment (99%), which usually means the query sequence comes from an isolate of the same species as the subject. (6) A central region of the alignment with perfect identity. A region like this one suggests that the query isolate is likely the same species as the subject. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 8: SSU and ITS2 PCR products. The top gel shows PCR products generated with the SSU primer set for 12 representative samples. A DNA ladder is included on the left as a reference. The SSU PCR products for Caenorhabditis nematodes are approximately 500 bp in length. Samples 2-12 amplified with the SSU primer set but sample one did not. The absence of a 500 bp SSU amplicon for sample one suggests that the lysis material was of poor quality and the sample must be re-lysed. The bottom gel shows PCR products generated with the ITS2 primer set for the same 12 Samples shown in the top gel. The ladder and samples are in the same orientation for both gels. Six of the 12 samples did not amplify with the ITS2 primer set. The samples with SSU and ITS2 bands are Sanger sequenced and identified by sequence similarity using the NCBI BLAST algorithm. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Supplemental File 1: C-labels. A PDF file containing 2500 unique C-labels. Please click here to download this File.
Supplemental File 2: S-labels. A PDF file containing 5000 unique S-labels. Please click here to download this File.
Supplemental Table 1: Field Materials. A packing list of materials used in the field to sample nematodes. Please click here to download this Table.
Supplemental Table 2: PCR recipes and thermocycler conditions. A table of PCR recipes and thermocycler conditions for the ITS2 and SSU PCRs. Please click here to download this Table.
Supplemental Table 3: Electrophoresis buffer recipes. A recipe for 0.5 M pH 8.0 Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid solution (EDTA) and the TRIS-acetate-EDTA (TAE) buffer solution. Please click here to download this Table.
This protocol contains critical steps that must be executed with caution. For example, it is important that the field and isolation teams are careful to select the correct collection project in the application prior to collecting samples from the field or isolating nematodes from the samples in the laboratory. In the event that the wrong collection project is selected, the errant data records are best corrected in the Fulcrum database using the record editing tools online. This process can be tedious for many misplaced records. However, the database retains any changes to records so that a complete auditing of collection and isolation records is possible. The other critical steps in this protocol involve the handling of samples from the field and the nematodes isolated from those samples. To ensure Caenorhabditis nematodes survive the sampling and shipment steps, the temperature of samples should be maintained between 4 °C and 25 °C. Temperatures above 25 °C can cause sterility in C. elegans14. Ensure samples are transferred from collection bags to collection plates within five days whenever possible to minimize the loss to nematodes. After nematodes are isolated, it is critical that they are genotyped and cryopreserved before they perish. It is difficult to find living nematodes on S-plates that are more than two to three weeks old because fungal and bacterial contamination can make the S-plates inhospitable.
This protocol can be modified easily to accommodate different types of data that researchers may want to collect while in the field. For example, it is easy to customize the 'Nematode field sampling' application with new data entry fields using Fulcrum's online GUI for application editing. Moreover, the data analysis package, easyFulcrum, can accommodate these edits when processing the new data15. Another modification users may find appealing is to use a different sampling method in the field. Rather than sampling discrete substrates, researchers may desire to sample larger areas containing multiple substrate types. These larger samples are best processed in the laboratory using the Baermann funnel or tray extraction methods13. Importantly, the use of C-labels and S-labels still apply for these techniques and are therefore compatible with mobile applications.
The primary limitations of this protocol relate to the handling time of nematodes prior to isolation in the laboratory. First, the lag time between sample collection and nematode isolation makes it impossible to record the developmental stages of nematodes on a given sample at the time of collection. Second, the frequency of males and outcrossing in nature are key evolutionary questions for selfing Caenorhabditis nematodes10. This method is not well suited to addressing these questions because nematodes are likely to have gone through multiple generations prior to isolation. Delayed isolation means that direct evidence of male frequency in nature is impossible. Furthermore, the multi-generational delay during the genotyping steps means that genomic evidence of outcrossing (heterozygosity) will be eroded before a nematode strain can be sequenced. To identify heterozygosity in nature, the offspring produced by a nematode directly isolated from nature are used for sequencing2. Another potential limitation of this protocol is that it is biased toward the identification of selfing Caenorhabditis. This is because isolated nematodes of selfing species have a greater chance of proliferating than obligate outcrossers, which will only proliferate if a fertilized female is isolated.
This collection method is based on existing collection protocols13,14. The major advancement of this technique is the use of mobile technology and customized software to facilitate the organization of vast quantities of ecological and molecular data associated with large-scale collection projects. The ecological data generated using this collection protocol can be used to address outstanding questions for natural populations of Caenorhabditis species. For example, data generated with this method have been used to discover niche preferences for the species across the Hawaiian Islands. Moreover, by sequencing the genomes of cryopreserved nematodes, researchers can investigate how patterns of genetic variation are correlated with ecological data. Research of this kind can uncover signatures of local adaptation in Caenorhabditis populations and provide important insights into the relevance of genetic variation in natural contexts8. To gain a functional understanding of many genes in Caenorhabditis nematodes, ecological studies are likely required11. Even for C. elegans a large fraction of genes lacks functional annotations, despite it being the first multicellular animal to be sequenced and one of the most thoroughly studied animals on Earth. This collection protocol was developed to help address this knowledge gap by facilitating the collection of wild Caenorhabditis nematodes and the study of their ecology and natural genetic diversity.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This research was supported by start-up funds from Northwestern University and a National Science Foundation CAREER Award (IOS-1751035), both granted to E.C.A.
Adhesive labels | Avery | 61533 | Printing the C-labels and S-labels |
Agarose | Thomas Scientific | C748D75 | agarose gel preparation |
Backpack | A backpack for each team member to hold equipment, samples, food, and water for the day. | ||
Cardboard boxes | Fisher Scientific | AS261 | Storage of S-plates |
Centrifuge | NA | NA | Neamtode lysis, SSU and ITS2 PCR |
Collection bags | Zip-lock | NA | Collection of substrates |
Digital temperature/humidity meter | Preciva | HT-86 | Measurement of ambient temperature and humidity |
Disecting scope | NA | NA | Nematode isolation, lysis |
Disposible reservoirs | USA Scientific | 1306-1010 | Aliquoting PCR master mixes and loading dye |
DNA ladder, 1 KB plus | Thermo Scientific | SM0243 | Visualizing SSU and ITS2 PCR products |
dNTPs | Thomas Scientific | CB4430-2 | PCR master mix component |
easyFulcrum R package | NA | NA | An R package for processing collection data http://andersenlab.org/easyfulcrum/articles/easyFulcrum.html |
EDTA solution (0.5 M pH 8.0) | NA | NA | See supplemental table 3 for recipe |
Ethanol (95%) | NA | NA | Plating out samples, spoon sterilization |
Ethidium bromide solution (10 mg/mL) | VWR | 97064-602 | Visualizing SSU and ITS2 PCR products |
External battery charger for mobile device | NA | NA | External battery charger and charging cable for iPhone or Android |
Flask (500 mL) | Fisher Scientific | FB501500 | agarose gel preparation |
Food | NA | NA | Pack accordingly |
Gel electrophoresis apparatus | Thermo Scientific | B2 | Visualizing SSU and ITS2 PCR products |
Gel electrophoresis power supply | BioRad | 1645050 | Visualizing SSU and ITS2 PCR products |
Gel loading dye, 6x | NEB | B7022S | Visualizing SSU and ITS2 PCR products |
ITS2 primer set | NA | NA | oECA1687 = forward primer CTGCGTTACTTACCACGAATTG CARAC, oECA202 = reverse primer GCGGTATTTGCTACTACCAYYAM GATCTGC |
ITS2 sequencing primer | NA | NA | oECA306 = forward primer CACTTTCAAGCAACCCGAC |
Lysis buffer | NA | NA | Nematode lysis, see protocol for recipe |
Microwave | NA | NA | agarose gel preparation |
Mobile device | NA | NA | Charged phone in airplane mode. The Fulcrum app GPS positions are inaccurate compared to the GPS positions extracted from pictures. This setting ensures that you use less power and get more precise GPS measurements. |
NGMA plates, 10 cm | Fisher Scientific | FB0875713 | C-plates, see Andersen et al. 2014 for NGMA plate protocol. |
NGMA plates, 3.5 cm | Greiner Bio-One | 5662-7102Q | S-plates, see Andersen et al. 2014 for NGMA plate protocol. |
Non-contact infrared thermometer | Etekcity | B00837ZGRY | Measurement of substrate temperature |
Paper towels | NA | NA | Paper towels for absorbing excess moisture in a bagged sample. |
Parafilm | Fisher Scientific | 13-374-12 | Plate sealing |
PCR adhesive foil | VWR | 60941-126 | PCR adhesive foil |
PCR buffer (10x) | Thomas Scientific | CB3702-7 | PCR master mix component |
PCR plates (96-well) | Thomas Scientific | 1149K04 | SSU and ITS2 PCRs |
Pencil | NA | NA | |
Plastic spoons | NA | NA | Plating out samples |
Platinum pick | NA | NA | Nematode isolation, lysis |
Pre-labeled ziplock collection bags | NA | NA | Bundles of zip-lock plastic bags pre-labelled with C-label barcodes. Each bundle should contain 25 barcoded bags wrapped with a rubber band. |
Proteinase K | Sigma | 3115879001 | Nematode lysis, added to lysis buffer just prior to use |
R software | NA | NA | R software: A language and environment for statistical computing https://www.R-project.org/ |
Soft cooler bag and ice pack | NA | NA | Collection coolers and cooler packs to keep samples cool when ambient temperature is above 25 °C. |
Spare batteries | NA | NA | Extra batteries for sampling equipment |
SSU primer set | NA | NA | oECA1271 = forward primer TACAATGGAAGGCAGCAGGC, oECA1272 = reverse primer CCTCTGACTTTCGTTCTTGATTAA |
Strip tube caps (12-well) | Thomas Scientific | 1159V29 | Nematode lysis |
Strip tubes (12-well) | Thomas Scientific | 1159V31 | Nematode lysis |
TAE buffer (1x) | NA | NA | Visualizing SSU and ITS2 PCR products. See supplemental table 3 for recipe |
Taq polymerase | Thomas Scientific | C775Y45 | PCR master mix component |
Thermocycler | NA | NA | Neamtode lysis, SSU and ITS2 PCR |
Water | NA | NA | Pack accordingly |